%PDF-1.3 % %eCopy-1.1 % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000023941>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R ] /Count 1 >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 4 0 R /Contents 5 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 4 0 obj << /XObject << /Im6 6 0 R>> /Font << /F7 7 0 R /F8 8 0 R /F9 9 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 7 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F7 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 8 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F8 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 9 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F9 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 6 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im6 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask false /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /ColorSpace /DeviceGray /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 20546 >> stream l N[< `O^f-c E0 _זB!u|EB{P^C:}Wӽ wzﾷCzMh !oD^ޓ_A>knM{~W}kumտo/ݿ/"c [΁if_W?޾p!35d_>w4: |^[޷}}MD~怣oTu_kk}v f|7@d v_"Z("A.{Ma\2!w$K>xjPЈ xmk`Xe& |"8ddFhdr7 xl7Xa4" Q`%ǃ9ѺKH1'd44w f؀, VN$A!#qB\,d,a] RC" 06ZjicA'dgeɸ5ۢ<5DCAiBI`B`f ;gpc [%7H6%"⤁Je 9o&ÐPf'oi@̢m2 HG}_^O1 '"z֡ 4.{{0"x/\7A;[zzb m'?UKwii% A _B0KUA ?\0U{~_&@Z]-&t{~#TT& w.]6pt R%ݽtM48c ZKJG 7 6U1)/tih4àA[:n]dGp^}$ZjM6]_^7Qm$aI{ 0ޡ[֭$%NGwAl&[jդ6Oö2(I9=ﴛm.ܬRm&xJ;q='h| D! 6 Λv$PED<DvQ>mh0DN j͇0!B}dNæ+;O}f%vU:Y6\@iXJj' 3Sm'M٣DcMζ eݗnO+!֞=wtt[bW)6ݯuI0m|WקOTfj~׾["G).[_߶A M;G!_!үoLq6vYԧn]ҫa.uՆ h v<:zK_%D[K{.h4f|)o_Wﾾ]lm[tE+־wWuVlert믿IY+_ WHiiZW~p!K?~Մ鴟}>6+ءOWZz S_o}d , 4Mu3(tЈZД6LPA;JNGC!%zҸ\ blI4IJ;nb'I䩤ud`S^F0%S T~??i4B:JY/A‚~f aa*tB}$oMj_Uz4!%W*NAH kK䠋 % o# IE$6r3썓W]$$cDآZJ >a h+ ܡ$*;][_I$t|? IAZ_ ]C?TH& t⪒@'+W(% l,֕BtKM#ji9a%K*Hj$$ti>R"KV$^k贡%첹/8ྱ*ٰ%4&($*!I.PD0<"R}ч_AH*cABJP"-= $+D}^`"Ar:vrPDL " ~̚  j5DW |Hy" 4,k 52=>o;H#Z޽hff ǰtcFC$#oɄl ?w h[N'!-[M~_ک|͙yu?q^ZVUwTy~qqiV"H v͍KqFR!^J]HrozJ(_+ҊVGY9xKkmG߉^?N^KOi`B-4 / [ |{kԛ6/^K+zڕĿ̤gdqe1pΕ$C9"!aI+_\0%q\yNƂ Iv !RWK4 Ď[HeX7M-.s aYNBkI+!琰Y1XaJ"Dk$W,uQlJ3FZm5P$9$¶ })qU% $J-$mI=K%m0B{I  %oI V;iHe"ޒ)-XJڠ%Qui,& [a?N蜒a:Ն h+a$"u@%>I&AR&VH"#U$ (JHBnI$ *  ]BAa$8A&BA6E$@ݐ梃 +aVI #–f !sD0gXA(a ACalYŠ \$[\U 3E\ ؝n+hLxhpDEB D<x!KOTCa@FMhiE-=;tR D?M˂+ACl?KO뿰nj_ W_Sz]__׆?׏K>l?u]~ZH}K/_ך#(~};} oֿ=ޯ[[%ou'IW.0koot]+޴Z6pDmU_Xk{^boKI}i .}׵滑vx\C6)HQ|oW_~ -%.""# Ô jZkD~6{~vaץ]2Sf-+}K +vtDf' :x:aE`,05È?ڤC@EBmHq! :xY"3_h]NaTI$PaMLE0 0D6hEr! B).x 8cRpEriH8dB: jtxM>g@P0 "wI7&D C@цKw(9#t A`i7w!"pyЛeĎ5Trl<0Caj Cmz|0" ̆!!C-m74WK8v/ cz3,0PA(׼zl9Bv(CeȖ}eXJªZjQmmAT0 usQ"Oot""]0" ЄK^[NwӠƉf#0CJ)K8߷=]Dy4"?@HO? =OǐpkKvʬvr{B@b=eiu3(Gg r{D0=[Ȱ"5~0 /A"Fe~Iǥ^/_K3/Z_#,o$_nnknB JK4)0]H!jZĈ 3XaDIHr@z}(YrVs!ĥ?Sq9љUǐ@{_ 9룖d?ۖ'ҖBf|:"+3jEHP39i͆$K;eWKݑL6̗27n2wYtm-rG}J6$_a!R(H 丧5T6 rM"΃ b3RQu'nP`x,mDP}?G:h; 64_廖;_:M"_%TWIMӠ(a/OӲGr߯ޖ}oAP^__c}b;I_J|ޯv!w?n=7o ^[~?ֻcC~ޫQwnKD{eRh~#KJg-۷}h>EujM^ q&0zI+rh{kEk_GX~_ 'r\i~'nDտ!G=}c䢚'>u_?n?i?;~kۿi{.K/vtX0BEBJZNu~iudULҿnKzW\I0Hxi-}DHj(j[xm-u-1n$l$) ,Ba[jCbx +D\0[ \N렢Dah$zB$Ze 'rs0D(@Ć @"$3/Ȏ DD}-^d@{ C:ǑuX@{arύkD t<("$&N gO nICHmƹh\"CRtBDDDM3mtFqDN0F$ˊ{/ J\2E>|Jl q)d K.3 i.0c%B@jAĘF KaDHe!!K#x2D>mċ\4f x+f$!q(fh.!D@ /bNYqˆ@,g~"$N2d |e76Fs 3/ADDQf/DG!֢oyw .FQ =cw =1Pw-0J2t: EPd0FN`TEH/B 6x@":P- :DSr!܃q"S;]L~s4.C-Ys^뷦F pL!s@\ii=~lF. * G"Atv'争R{ ̂j5uvڪm'A( j j*/}Iu">Zq?&np"ps;K}ko.￤|;O9jr&?CW-3/݇~/_Ioik~__Ҥ*ջ/݇ߒ*I\_֕7} wu~¼w}?X{1?޿Ð{zq}ko_߰~-N_#ۦ; e>ouZK ݯ8Zkn_}M^T_ޯ_ O P*yt_?W￿ GLt]].0 5VSˮյM)Fa8vb>oPkEapqq~꧑)nAC M5_f*)Zē1]CDZR2"u妕)0iZ[cwAR=D.Pa a$Co"T(1IҴl|aD0L&MxCAAC-2L@! a"%! 6"plsS^"" -@@{8 +T!܀Zk&S(zea8-1p&ܚbJ !`F[D%@G ܂ V[d$pܐiȢ/!0 C0E8nP@2+݄8lM;^ F\3p /z۠&DAd2܅VDs5IE>Z}|NHfHPF-Fj~HI|9&h6C4A!ڀPIߒFd_=ۦA@v{m/Q*Q ekkݢ@ޯ ;Kt4ջkmlB].q_n+үtɟ[LBKk]nh{Ek;qޗqWZE-ۢ $Ԛ/ۯuCw URg'=Q||Wq]}nIUO޿NMO^麒@/v]^޶-0/ήo-5ׯ}  ]] qy %߿vj!cVߥs_È$´"cD6[]zw)ٳP|D{ioUE>"ha~ޖ׭%D 8ViYi8~a@FQR#" DJC:VX=huDR8 C AG =@z0@@zͨԀc :Gn@x]V#@LunU_9$49~pҎYM33<H]qdDEȸdyψ'I1 fcK2wLC~"A#.aD B[1D03l=-) 86)kGeqd"9 S0Dr/ f-B@25  AIØ A,>"$L2rAtS)a h.daJdpڔHC0%L+&iˑDG16.>2|Mq^{ =rЇǐP n>@{(Cr(G|@y Ҏ@xt^rK|K& =9< =nF7%I`l=~+C IW%ξH6np4Sa}_ބ"|߿cO^A"N˲r3O2"Ԧ56533DxF.*Y|(0Z,a;~Dn`[,$E9V?鐡y1z 5-Dua?a p_ϒ"}([ޞϚ D2M3 Yq`A꾫 :/2 \-쓦ڏ^> ]Gu^0# ct~DS}_ᆐl?OmS CwHM®W߶Q(CҼ> 0\B(|ߺt/V}&̈́>.+q"B.EDoô*jUի6 "}`= 0Mh0l4[83N@<8&)?o'ݒN{A$EAIqL$Vwy,+wB",'5.lCҭf\<`!_AJ%'&姶6mxF^ k]"KtYJ"#(ۧm*~0dUN"o]Έku4:xWb|=mXki~^1aWiWVd?,% a /VA ? F"". @m4ieႈ|+ XOHDD3XǓrLk\2^ 0Z ۮKByMJZl9XD,&N!J'|Ch*z jS^ƈY8aԳK鑨.]4W  It5@g5ƒJ.|DI$Mubf6(EÖK]V#GC =WZUo;"I'Q R8dPRIZi UsIDa/*Kҥ[=%y!FdluISz AϐD|50AGZ똿Ӌ 47, p%-pIa ;悑ISa$*Ⴝr<]vg@Z5_ID4xaB"3MX PTBJ',b"AaB`ID4Qº`/d;;t?A'䀟l'D8Yf)/!/B?ߠ{~H/oP_KWz7Huߵ.{ؤ~ /_Kc }uU !h0ZT}3k bQ"-_,\–ҐQ"L8PVm/ &0lD\? ADejAaaq&Em.!)x͘#x.jGid'qVf偁*JA5y=x0;J$J/hb 9t4tK:ZҦa0DB| ,haH3Cڅ(["? YaGA&Vx;rjP鴒_)"8$~9p"3),+IߗN )jiU+2 {_ZwWQ=uMhaM&2g`_SP_Fؘ".KGF8czB% igxP3GRWWWB,-iV,Bb-T)%E]~'jJ8DWT]8d_ %JQ]0ᇄo0K.>p>Yгg!5]-G%/%oֿp𰠨"a5sXBGUZV! .;#/>ioPN@(r #CXd Յ Am+^,p/Z[I%cQA}ZiB7X NtL-VV>hixUHԨ=_ DFP(Z䎵UkBZ ^4%CvhDl:t5 RIV%IuIR/f\D9$./l.GԿ]*KɍauZij!uR+C .u_\*WDN&oEUU^t^I)0/Dvh# yY$q"x%/$k^EWb"8 NiAR7UK^QP,ϋMUD (TqI -WjD0Xp A8ɠB a&X%!!*Zk"0B2*`1L:Y YHا&!fAa?h%@!.^rq,IеA*ߏz&BX# :nH#G5f:xs C#b7wAqV# .z[܉0(frecYHqN2Lƾ :KH~1ʴVN~>@xRnPEq +?T 0 F/drRc; ffK `͕ X( &%7_(xaXunP\6-{' dB7 z$H%lh<wkXPi$d;O=*mF a$>y|A@B/~D1dI hR>O Z%b8ఖ6 I|?+dHZO pS4J3V"_ۺ_T!Y23W/Du~GG3X\ VQȟCЪcj1S ZDWS ٰf"rk !P@ KzItO$Gl*W."!싩0}oJ)|Z JX"?.|*I0PW%]R_dꖐ(Ac*si/\.Z_n,0[`}/mthpupFW%m%DkI 8$!O$}a%ХUU=kگI Ku VKU/W8\1ZcҪzI/UtK ڻV9^=uHN,U*bW!7_5Ii$JH@%JүVmo/Z[u)U(OJ/YRJMiaS_[INֵyUt ҭwTQ¦ 0,zQRH =D$30)K;"<5?'a4|gX>Hi XNi?;8h34H[]ӎKZ %k: DFM iO`›|DDH|$눈LfM :^>@t˓q!MXA0ɸNІC( ܋XRwg &/gjFTi.rJhR "Av<$ iouMA `[$dzq*(y  ?hb-٪7=/'y8~C8C?Na0 }u͊Z'I騄B`Λ/_I00Id^"aXY$ɦ)CJ4 MMXB Xd$e?>^󈸻uʱʳ~9?sL08N8մއƴ?48.CzBA$<__~MPJ?`2T[8 m_=?+E}Qￇ^!{ߥ_~܈( +_[UVA ֩=w]_b ׯM= 67/륿 ~n$a1jw.)vh-܋d aum{f?~"a"XMWZfg\D3z Dm:oV""2NB=A`bu]d~"Cł @ h04v^&/0TRvJ"#3 L L1@QHa_)^"vJ^2n'yIwVa4X T̫D B^C`dD.e4h\vYA Y$~v3;Ib/_ tyXk JDSYR@0] Mg ZW>@uS1Vx@u)xUxYx(տn`BH&B a)3jC@앍 :8^5Y#%z 0D"r1Loסæh4Bc§֚%4a+ _쑭IMD"4MIa4.ޝ===X@'1M'6!km.-ڼ)0Sa^anмŧf :i|{ol2!u6_o&^CT"5o_G^{KVBD{}V.Ž6)>wkGI믓sXO,_S[ uJiRIY("#5\4IWIE߈h PxKY ^ao1C2pLB*8kuX&-5@ABXa&)$ٓ<|LqqIWRFa+@t ,dV8UW[#>ZTn@uaHcI?*~2o\bf!rL,;q%&>9еdU\r9;@uVxuVUj RpϬ% :Eo.Q,U^9UX \>1 4 :ܺ>;+~ ^_ :WEФs : : : endstream endobj 5 0 obj << /Length 1836 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm /Im6 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F7 19.42 Tf 235.44 739.44 TD (ORIGINAL) Tj /F7 19.97 Tf -12.00 -85.68 TD (UND ) Tj /F7 11.81 Tf 48.24 -.72 TD (STATES OF ) Tj /F7 13.74 Tf 64.32 -1.20 TD (AMRICA) Tj /F7 12.11 Tf -142.08 -11.28 TD (BEFORE ) Tj /F7 13.86 Tf 49.44 -.96 TD (FEDERA ) Tj /F7 19.97 Tf 57.36 -1.44 TD (TRE ) Tj /F7 12.64 Tf 42.72 -.48 TD (COMMSSION) Tj /F7 14.03 Tf -85.44 -42.96 TD (Docket No. 9302) Tj /F7 13.68 Tf 29.52 -30.24 TD (PuLIC) Tj /F7 12.11 Tf -20.16 -56.16 TD (In the Matter of) Tj /F7 18.76 Tf -36.72 -28.32 TD (RAUS ) Tj /F7 11.78 Tf 54.72 -.72 TD (INCORPORATED) Tj /F8 13.65 Tf -53.28 -41.76 TD (COMPLA. COUNSEL') Tj /F7 12.22 Tf -4.08 -14.16 TD (REPLY ) Tj /F8 11.65 Tf 41.76 -.72 TD (BRIF ON ) Tj /F7 12.11 Tf 55.92 -1.20 TD (REMEDY) Tj /F7 12.99 Tf -217.20 -67.68 TD (efIey Schmdt) Tj /F7 12.46 Tf -6.00 -14.16 TD (Director) Tj /F9 11.92 Tf 231.36 10.32 TD (Geoffey D. Oliver) Tj /F9 10.98 Tf -.72 -14.40 TD (Richard B. Dagen) Tj /F7 12.00 Tf -.24 -14.16 TD (Robert P. Davis) Tj /F8 9.15 Tf -230.88 -10.08 TD (Danel P. Ducore) Tj /F7 12.09 Tf 0.00 -14.40 TD (Assistant Director) Tj /F7 11.99 Tf 87.12 -1.68 TD (, Compliance Division) Tj /F9 10.92 Tf 143.76 -2.40 TD (Counsel Supporting the Complaint) Tj /F7 11.84 Tf -231.36 -24.48 TD (Rendell A. Davis) Tj /F7 11.57 Tf 82.80 -1.68 TD (, Jr.) Tj /F7 11.87 Tf -84.00 -12.72 TD (Attorney, Compliance Division) Tj /F7 12.00 Tf 0.00 -42.96 TD (Bureau of Competition) Tj /F7 11.90 Tf -.24 -14.40 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F7 13.08 Tf 0.24 -14.64 TD (Washigton) Tj /F7 12.06 Tf 56.88 -.96 TD (, DC 20580) Tj /F7 11.94 Tf -58.32 -56.40 TD (Dated: September 29) Tj /F9 10.44 Tf 101.52 -1.68 TD (, 2006) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 0 10 0000000000 65535 f 0000000078 00000 n 0000000137 00000 n 0000000207 00000 n 0000000368 00000 n 0000021763 00000 n 0000000881 00000 n 0000000506 00000 n 0000000633 00000 n 0000000756 00000 n trailer << /Size 10 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 23664 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000055403>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R ] /Count 2 >> endobj 10 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 11 0 R /Contents 12 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 11 0 obj << /XObject << /Im13 13 0 R>> /Font << /F14 14 0 R /F15 15 0 R /F16 16 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 14 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F14 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 15 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F15 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 16 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F16 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 13 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im13 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 26609 >> stream -rU2^?M)(ZhNc5r@0j 6qB, )h4 JNe3`G !!aN "DDNa`WH6nHm'^@}A:MzäMm?}zO-[uz}_q_j緝k{~_BX־ݎ?a^;1z]]ۭAw܈]no+~﫻w{[~wkտ]}{o[ҿumU_7ֺ[io&ŋ-unnMwiZNoRՀ hRgC $ $U] 4a H*n0pg0gԍ0Ib $C"DDDDDH"y*>Nk """""&|FZ@VaDH6|:r,DDH.nZ\G0b""%d]DxÈEl)Yt. 2܆u`9BshDP@Aˌ3@PljG Kx4Jl bKMmH6L0H |K8}m&7ZAPzA6J=~mL~齾}] _+)W}&PQ\q++~ڏ/}oV޿oC^A޿oE/u߿]-/_nl%Ett^mm[_z܄E ݺݶVh+- ٙ33>ڴڴٹ4ڴڴ##ƙHD >Q'P["R BM6(鯭[[MmmoOM4TMSNM 4a4A A4h4Ma4AA33>ff|ٙ6ffl͚36f٣4#FiD>P"""" š OO[Uz}viwڭkkviiiL ٙ""" a4i M4T54[]]{k߯wjia4T5[NT^T5׵wia4AMSM;MSM=5MmSUOSMSUON5TmV@@D""""""""""""""""""""""B"La Mvj`5ZJ97[QTP(Q%Ee\Y3)+3qVⅢ;!4f6T9nfv@t¦2B8JDG. v 0AYwِf2R="\)5 JxaNB9#h {NvLP0`i'E vbQH=zGOI:=] ecd'i{imN"U_]]} \UIzj#A2Y(D nӯ_P- 303c: Y8H8f HUo^j3¡&5AL(LheL p@D œtviC%KqQt/-SEL*i  ϊB AA `'8`5aaxK$A&&b$4|2}a"蛆TS]TB B ~N"6GHe#aM"Ό$t"TO#E>Y &'>oAb[4z/tMڬ㠪p !31<* 0P`:zK}mM_$`' $> ŗA7蝿TNTjU e忧[aSj7Z Nȣ{h&n%%ME͉cynooI3 `M|l&'o__VﾯOD_U}ui{c?Kc ~}տoa܊Bذ_`DyooO'׿a okoa aS}pVFoY"_m!uϯ>܇o>JߵJ_iuuo?#}{pa/ͧ}m+w_]l1_Vm/C V0\=k{i_kܷJa %Jan(K)o-[[K&Gfam! aaL0J״c㶚 0 .@պJ?}GmWVW_Y{84[ S `5@=!1AApaiڶQ%C0ii=h&l AbQ0L0i/iv1DD0`6 @-0a\&!40@92\0A&!&M4iFhK"""""""&s=anL/ $Ӷ   4aKDH""""$ftya0k˲,ypqªX|0W $ eˆQK%Y0"UѰ.&Y \OMvr6/ }gQ߄m>zϩd43Y0P x&G3"<`pdCͳ/7L&  qaL!E4^4_Uꉎa4UߤgpCH l4 9yIUۤzN>!Su ߴ}֛hw֟]^oB?v+׆Wi Ɍ\?$LEKN?{ .~$o{?_Swaݥk~{[jl04S ޽O>Q *Ri\K0a0 ϙ3fff٤h#H4"|!T8KiIi;LUKvvi 4h0333fff͚36h٤O>5a@6:3#-~zꞶvii44336ڴڴڴٹ33ڌљ34h#Ƒfl͚36iBIb""""'D  < pڦ=u׽tN_??U[[M4M0A%  kݭk;M"""""""" 4AaSmS]=5OSMS]mUSTmuT__^DDDDDDDDDD4 ah4iM4M5M4;M4M;Mm4TӴӴ_[nDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDEAa4Mm5DDDDDG,qW52P)٨3 *><&ư":AJvf}4]h/|'|) UY* %`[?dviwbi2 g[8sY% (}w PxD8Zd4 )9]d4{U'vƃ 2Ӥёd͕4D{_S8otm_^_T?F!8X"C6Fft_4">u3Vz󬿎8 fM 0P0@aD"Z%͑Լc[8tI4ª`?MVa"H!l2!˂j8ΑtHG(kz '5]/:/ooe9!֩OA< `` ~2% > Q!f)Re 5FH"LyէuzMlC|S33M"[.qE^0 &&W?L*g6"~t`?SL` T g *zCCL "[ӤMa<*umG]POM ><'L5S1TD5UMSz`\ ޾I#m[V۽pdqeLglޕ7H 1=&y9|Aؙô^8x+TO>qhJ^T7Ct=6񓍽&ό]&pa`ȣN21aiL|R}j%7WPV:m(O_`}f:?WV!WCJ> j(>_uGTuU#}g+XTLf'(s_?Q_޿D_D#3ߓw+ ҿC,G$m6Aa$~D9Jd7nڽnuǐֿ wJVN֟"];$Fum޾uocl$_i]i/߾_m}۵޽ׄAL4JmB0Io_^Aaaa&)mV $4VUQ_tk~]Y]__xkdKզ!4 0@TP lB d0sE4Iݯm+ }^I_p+(A&q5a5T@5I1Hk{ %[V#i5L?m-J*5$UjtX&A /i4 `!렃< ؠH4tt&QիQQi?&o 0oaBh0M0 mL L  hf M\DDDDDFJ @)aL`ؙ8Lփ0qi a{׆\DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDI)dǖҒA+V`Ȅ9h TU>7θ0#i堨4+/Աʹ,%8<-@OT6PO[*(>߄ץճ忚-$)S‚AȨ!I糾$՚ʐt5u`<Z'͑$F̧5$aHhהi feҢnAZAt(0P * a|a|d3H7ChzHh4^88$3I'nA=>Ǵl禅<>!-{%m^y$8!e9O@b{u۪[UC^ ݽV ?;xInWm![#Czz'ƒג>ǣЋn~,_%*~ނﾟ%<7ݒ0o_I}թx>M=#!}?F_ZzV_.8Vtz][m'[b{nJpm+_UW[imVv_ %1Zfi3Fgƌ͚D;4x(EB;DWJZAx0;!AQH6)6 kJ 04&*m/M4M4AAL ϑ333>ff| Ϛfff͙33fg٣3flљ3fff3f͙3f4f>OvIP ^QM1@)4q޺vi궝ii 0A33fhb$ ht8j A q h6(`_~O]}{ON[ӵM4NШ"""""""" 0P5[[?__""0DG?4M4=SN4]4ӻ[?_[]?]~DDDDDDDDDDD00! 0AM0L& &M4iih4M4[]=4U &iYĚXЯ^\0j?&Acq\ dІ;ALH_AvK*a("!3Zi s 4s44LAhnJlC%$zp;P ` B-}ށ)(zO 57}= L/n I˔NJ_9$Wd34v`+ eRoߺzLR}wM-iRs/_OֿU  xdJ4H!!3B!lB5#ȇ3^&0<*aSa.} 9@O]ZH ڪŃDhjȣ0mPf043O: N0ycM8jj31#"2K%+S >)A/r rwTS L P* A"'M 0@0slPfg4fǓ8SSœ2:Na7% %t]m^ ;;E(40 zL&^Yu ].)SD܅j |=?˂[®Tun%UlAnD44O'*N6kH"x; focEIS8AԆÂk~)kW[OcztF,֒ we'@Mh4=]ݣ3wg{COa-i-XOcI(b[c&wǽu]]%~[M_O_nX ? Zޗ[woOmp`^ġז#q?]}kl UoiԜr^?oЈ.rbn_x}7u{:  F_տ'uۯ~k$_ߥwvZkik#_[W_o__k[kݒ#?/-bU۰Km-][=ч{~vVl!V~c—|0Mui6ݥCkU2ɨӸ(i *b>?bVikkkkZ]&C ": `2P! :ARHTN8jD=n]>bDŽ^J^_(Qnav M4 40Ak D Z߻k !ݱa_\'m/tm/HkDDDDASL&BkPMIdAh6C3 ӦWkT:ZU_*aA/ ʚ &OAiI0L` % 6j0@gP@@ؠA aAaALa3B9PvL/] PI} 4iTM?$ ",Pf_ ?&~SN( 3x͙q`RDDRq+$k`)J2 KKIALU (8BC8@' P"q[\ޢ:O?ZIT fsj<"pZ~(3A"Ym0Mx4884(`ɦl'].__nW=u޸O]~ m }~7}H'{ki}\ ٙ33336fflљHљH'#H'DiZ^amS[NTM4 4 A36f͙4fl'"x'x;$ *qq;c_^[TNT Aiϙ433fٛ4fhh"x4H'2(dB(B$"Q1  kj^Ӵ;;M;NӴ5M4viiL*  aAM0A 3>ff|33>fl͚36i36i3LGP ."&4>Omu]}馶vݧkviki릚ii 33U@aa0i 4;M4ӽ=;[_[Uu]}iziNiDDDDDDDDDDDDDXL M5Aikz}kkkkkiw0DDDDDDDDD0a M4ӴMS[UM5M;T5UOM==;N=?N}5_DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDCC0A!, a4 &a5M5M=4 """"""""""""""@ˆ!fTPAerVv;#``0IrtvFhgiUJ 4,Fa2L74̅!\N[+:Pk 5x< sCBaSL3&ߕ 2^9BW3@P "-tCA4 MA-/h;N'@2( t~vT,]=:zWä8;E+d 8. ^['Iz 0r`y-6O'Jz߷ߊ?>u_)k5)D`R(Gњ6 @ _*a@д,=1DdB `}toֿ}6aUJOGZh0TZk!dfE"@Ι/-"/tHx2tMPDAaB( h'CPb(DPdB dzeD32 r=I?Σ'GF@i~t,Ţn'pptDMo  MIӧ5B 뤷+vI<)eEVxSH ] NƐB4d_4E &/9T]wB7Kv_~=BqiޛZPdqII'd}1Nhfb6$oVM乢WL䬨OI[WޛK_a;%mWMzUw/{߯߯k_տI=C[~ޫ.]WmWS#>ֽuoH%׹H)~A#_WW0m/"Q/-`ץq_cu/uZp6FujVHH /l"NXzuۥ /}N??i-Lkŷ__/7H_K[okȋ__^,6ߺH/ t!:}Lum3? i=%JLwO/m+z} 0KN+Av=jiXKVm.ﯿ{XAl0a*V+I`+I/c6VM&@آ00NGA!Dᔄ$0 0(ii}zM`iin-WlvԿ- *eQ( ,0[Vm+ a&) ӆM6;]vQlTp҈6]{_\DDDDDF"ID ܚ!a `dG@NȎ =0p >ibS]]C [a%"" 0ངկh2+xM5  2 ( a` D0^ A lRDDDDFS 0Eal8]AH0jPh-k"d"""""""8=` qDDFYff) U,j!:u0Pc"ݡrVA2Ct 2(eE-)ͧ`!!@mޣFf!pR.RF Gu `ޚx"qh4j-vwotr P{~uӶ]{DzwFkv@›Atf# .u >>AȾ#qfff٣336fg͙Ff33fff͙Ff٣3f͚F>Q*ڵP!!*)Pb(&US[OOӵM;[[TMSUM4[OOOTNM5M0 | Fi;J4kġh&9\ Ng .dXTAȎ@]__]==;?4[M4~"""""""D2T15"'dK5@a0Pa{Mkk~{=""""""""H@4ijiiw꟧vjz~҈aa 4ih4ii&iivjkb""""""""""""""""""""-M4A0ey|&v8A#;Y4 "w);ADP]AABmg}ƙ6[ʻ%@vG…*v$ ve)|75 T R h MoIRf`Goy ^C`Lȃt-4 ʌO d |?Ez,9D2sBh2\H8OӫZ_18"Xֿگ~}뾿*olH3^q\Q5k@ ` 'd.o#"wz8u_M=0T`T&lTBl1aE!P͔ CCᚋ*# qET]UUU%5N} !`Ȁ|A<Ca!..O3C! f/"럎dOk zH6 Mkg0:: n%q&BUzfL&;A&`< M`0@@la0=DO2m&a0 ]&ό;G'EE2-ETHt8$T  B$8%IyB ;i^ptOI'OO#A (q3Ŵ*DDǤ{ >An~I'+_jc_ ;}k~[WnMxdpWmoX`'>:aۖ0>UݱQ_M~a[oeyb?/ɗ l7>{Ö'ғܲN Ew{{zIFoxo_7L:mHC] R{}1aZGk! M{w}k~ޟ> -ikiZ[wk J[K[]m[Km/z{K/yd j@4 0IߧҵVTҰUُ1{ xa_o[[__m~!bA !0@\8 ` 8@8a-6Iv=եG_e)siz]0_f=J_ r6#FiêL&Pӊ تA t0U5}'VDqI>Km+Xa?bM04mb""" "e*B9M0L' /AT0@*  a ruJi&jXVNo1 : PMxk &P@ DX bSFĄq nM  P"g6eL&MPaW08^4A[_DDDDDDG "&t >famoN."""""""""a0A ."#>f-EM"fD[IṴRd}w+!P!e-gfL4 )ث&ʏ$5(E" dX4;23"2c3DP؜fwqdȤ0P`d3# A2R4o2AO* 5jj GI?%R!`KdZ0`#<w;Ӡl+PYd" w_I/NlJqIko]]_F~:f_[z]o'L`@@L͛A3du(#57OQ4/oS > *`00330p@Bg xg@ c!Ǣ{=u|vWWZH:TIQx=0[L S lT6`pAؤTSjGVgkץ ptrgi?蝴4ND᪦IV$Lv zx@<( ` at@%6 c'%k'3A?($N? ?Űqٙ?& SAM;I0t87š@j84WxO _TgxC `;@D0@ &<&P!C8a_o :}&pmApiI,[Z@'DaKʦ &蝍v5  B  k}nMЫVl'pNf?6ݡҦƅ, .^O?R=Q;Vп}ɞ}u_𒷥o^-_82.t\6I?_Mh7 W￿Bu}}~tI ?lXL& uϊp_ׯ_o|?tպKb>v' a5_kzjo wL6?P!]}aM?A?kib`LX:@`~LuWkaK"Q_l;[/C4?aR ?+!m{'k_/YO!_i車Nߪ'vDa?_7 y ^=FѶ_\Z_"0zզ%Z_b_?vn뵆O_~jgV/kwauIC + l*cn/:M)#-/@= oaiKm.)+m/o _KOav_jz^; @Aa06ӽWKV+^ pakRُ/"~NCI`  m :aHlQ0ᄡ[د.mKٍ}t[KKeM23g&oᄡ]Zh10& 6)87Z^>"{Mn$GwVa[In~k{GF""C*i4 )3MnazH*AyM2 ttd#ޓO m-t!&]{DDDDDDDB"""$`dʀ[ MJPh&mBA# hWe Bb  A_ Д f ah:ѡjAM` B GF"""!" 0FMg6& +]DqCCᄒTR]\3(b-EM'd!sGϳYؘ``Y+#lZ6V`E?9lu?kvju3f)jlgCL43D$੄C4!54$F Rpq< IU4N.:]5Pa aB B cD񠃇/.TS *Dz{}AI&}& .482g'm}CMNd1MHr *_m\XACWVҴDZޕ뮿8e[+ߍquͫGm??_o C$x7kcx|MZ^dG_n}_mڭ7_[޿]W}J.ҴS O(E 4Bؐ)׽_v믴LT 003ffl͙3f4fl'"x4BYd 06)jI;M.ҵUإӿONi 4a4 ϙFffl͚36h٣4#Fi>ϔdfffٛ336fflٛ4fffٙFg3H'"|(DYD&~A (& \%NPM8UA_OM=;Mm=;OMm4MS[M44Ӵ;M4TMa&>fl٣J"""""""~ {<ԛ&3t07iam=4[[^}k߮zwziDqa04M4M4NV׵M5OOO[=u_z_DDDDDDDEAAa4a4M;MSTM4SOMSMSU]uMAuq &i 0A &L Ai 4M4TM=SM4MSה}DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDCX! &i_DDDYۭ~> # .P,#!`tn: wE+䚪k s ksa0#C*0ض[ r3#&AdK a )0p0v; Ɪ;Ji"8AUQ+rxm1A;ZMH^F HXl{]1QH9av%ͦ/[M/ v$oO_k^{laJPGL4y-]u}[uA0B `Ag8(" ?dj"LU=v 'O7֗p0A0&2lid#fd<)&H/`ɨ'OL<L}2%Kl { //'oLMTª`\h`(@ƘC4./~4Cః0D% ( {O%+Agu);GEUL"wO0 v&a\*aBko|&փ]SWM im],MI6 'lؙڤoH7>󋷡Evz"?^tMl'_oһV _]j_7]I~OOM֭?a\'l?w~?&Mo뮝 8?Z31U8hq:,q&#tUI['Moa/~mX7-9c:C__J^=~[AG<;IDokH/w렽+?K{K_o_[WW^2$K$w&i_[_VNt$}objޥ CJҵuw޿ox-mu[(i5|{pҴLmbjym+m/~ުڮ<0@بm&']iC8%E>umkAُ6m'{mt&{ @a *8PiV 6U$^Zkj_xa/_ڧ<0U~MABM5@(a( QV[NI /MA?LV 1LVq'0a0@J rD „V0@T: t :V)4⽊d(v堄"""""2v0B )23 &:ii(4M6 ڪD0\a`a aq#P""@ HuJSXa{(p0 _C"]a& " ˋXB6A fuK/ cu,QUKAX$4 q:1 z*;ɒ8C.7Ԇ^@A3"y8D:.;PC E( pAcOA':(D~,\ h;@1Iw#$vAAEv0vgJڧ}zt2(6 G c]Gn:[P#Ȓ&H ־ߤM M4NoQ{|WzoRC3n4Fֿ( _+V! `!(0M'&C3yVc54"`f &xAD`‚ " ^G &C&TPx8~w OA=3bt[a=?`Nh ߙMqyO ɠ5L)UЯl'^8r+Ktl- n:Na^_/no߿o|7Z[/Ix`7Oۖ3x2thpk__ __?Iƚ) ;p/Ӗ578Ix/,Gm[7#x.H/ma 7zUr#wүo솬_c[_k{z } }E{u-y!4m%NJo_k{wwiZY0R[IްMZmC 0[ X+ %al*{kkP-o$*Q@Dl  % (8@cb .݅/կ{ º" ϙ33 3flٙ33>fl٣3flљ3flљHњF4|瀃]4AiziL4ۈml8t±_kiڦvkijiih4 ϙ4ffDIԁ#{ !Ӧ5 DpT !NILLamiV*_u=?Nӵj@@‚ L="|0Aj"0 OQGP^B> u^J"""""""""S2ঢ়[  0ڪkvDDDDDDDDDDHhD0m4 M4ATM4M4Mm54=oSah4i""",ևY SC#2S̄<}!@`NwpKY ztKY 'D2  /ڤ% 0E"ߤNw%Jh Ɠ}IlJ::-X8i5Mz)ŧTu}{"U: E5f9 hHJ뤰XAM D`gA ^l!xܐtz"^7 MpTLPh<0^ \0L ΀f"] !&:#R\f-$ZEdNhn0T7`4A0 `, B !863$0DbOΣ/#Y.Yy3O2H3&]ٙ)gLԏI:OA7'5A>D;ML(M$S 0T4g3.0L l! ‚P` L WO#M6 ›OH&q)ʟT_BPԐd E}MPgETtu]]:j::O` z w]'D5Sfi=ؚ<7#OnsI}^ҭ_=kO# nmaG?}uZ]U߾u[d]!o?G%]/ۧ_0)`t_!B:okM ] =}}ˮ>+~ 1M0TA_k{Wm_WGi6AO0?&T<.U qQAAثK__IA,+ %iYz‘t𫶝h44h43=b",\ &]h͐ ݭM^'@h `.& [wPkm^!\$xm$8@؏awI޶DDDDDDRNIL_N, @ B0@ `kH2r@eu SlTqG"Xa֥[ gxa0ե@("AdAjMMm=W^! DDD0ABcf¸Кa5,uMS%*kzj?*"""$  Ayi!%"""""0KI}.ZZө | 1QݦDC ? +;c&L2<];4Ч># * $bk I+2+hVa\' CF'vBa2pvJHKD4 AAI@`8L'2&r\ܡQKMPoy:l#1_;X(0I)eQޭ``3i }]-8L"6޽A.P1 #|fgGf0O,/ \XCD88:G:K$ NvaPh40CExD \4Cd G3q:/"SL 0?P' j0 f&h͙\3vOHxtBّa}cED/ ;aD&H=PAz@""t'RF!m0O"`ȶ鴝'I S֩82g/(CDSD?*P=!}Sӿ)m:MOOگ[VCA/a0- DUD裏/{[mx޷KZJM E~xd$0tt L&_=L?N׷m~+ 'o}wn5oxANE'['3OQ",c aWu cҭ ƿM_O}>)7ޕK 90tWap_Hv5p_D\a9:A?W~{7l?D!G蘙0/nEa+l7mmI0]w? UwDDuT _P*a7__1/ddxv _v<ImXK߷}LW^ژAG z _ߙio{m麷zCyRҽJ޾au^È+;[R 6KU01oKYnH#FvÐM8iD % +IXD%v6Z_ &kژ_դi~vM@0 SIEFj6)LvaO"b{iXRNuHflљ33f3f3f͚FљFf#FiDORl%৸a4MK 4ڊjMv#A lPIWWuoi}XTm%",iwvvh4MSM4 3fg33fl'""""""'L7dR ˜pdW.TV֛r#j0@6`,0C -0WLECIvzzivN(""""Qezie l*S"BbؠAmHG I6uOn""4""""$O 7Mr& Zj&v( vk]mk""# &WAP@g. Xa4UMSMm;OMS[UMSNӿA!uKQAaiPץDDDDDDD\a&rZI:MueM DGj[%(c,^?J?YT(Z~?&ҏjCQ:ҏP xbQ8ɲW̅T-j? *aG,J?*?ըB,4]Ya &u寊?~?&*?Q)Q蒎Z@-%~WPz ( A ScJ?@jYVj(@tG@F?V>M(S(Ĵ,KMZrT/M[%9l|zu uX endstream endobj 12 0 obj << /Length 3301 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im13 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F14 12.59 Tf 245.04 733.20 TD (TABLE OF CONTENTS) Tj /F14 12.02 Tf -169.44 -27.12 TD (mTRODUCTION ... ) Tj /F14 10.08 Tf 102.48 85.92 TD (......... ... ... ... ........ "'" .... ) Tj /F14 10.72 Tf 104.88 0.00 TD (......... ............ .... ) Tj /F15 10.04 Tf 75.12 0.00 TD (......................... ... ............... ............. ) Tj /F16 5.36 Tf 167.28 -87.36 TD (... 1) Tj /F14 15.61 Tf -451.20 -261.60 TD (Il.) Tj /F14 11.99 Tf 37.20 235.20 TD (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission) Tj /F15 10.84 Tf -.24 -13.92 TD (Remedial Powers .. ) Tj /F14 10.60 Tf 96.96 127.68 TD (..... ........... ) Tj /F14 13.52 Tf 47.76 0.00 TD (""""""" ) Tj /F14 10.86 Tf 42.00 0.00 TD (............ .... ............ ) Tj /F14 11.17 Tf 84.24 0.00 TD (........................ ..... ) Tj /F14 13.52 Tf 86.64 0.00 TD ("""""""" ) Tj /F14 11.51 Tf 47.52 -128.88 TD (...... 2) Tj /F14 29.46 Tf -405.12 -12.72 TD (A. ) Tj /F14 11.97 Tf 36.00 0.00 TD (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict) Tj /F14 12.18 Tf -.24 -13.92 TD (Royalties To Restore Competition ....................................................................... 2) Tj /F14 11.92 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (Rambus Bears the Burden of Any Uncertainty Resulting from Its Unlawful) Tj /F14 11.98 Tf 0.24 -14.16 TD (Conduct .................................................................................................................. 3) Tj /F14 11.88 Tf -.48 -13.68 TD (A Zero Royalty for JEDEC-) Tj /F14 11.97 Tf 134.64 -.48 TD (Compliant Products and Unlimited Royalties for) Tj /F14 11.92 Tf -134.88 -13.44 TD (Non-) Tj /F15 10.76 Tf 24.96 0.00 TD (JEDEC Uses Is Reasonable ........................................................................... 6) Tj /F14 12.00 Tf -24.72 -13.68 TD (The Commission Should Resist the Temptation To Impose ) Tj /F14 12.96 Tf 285.36 -.72 TD (Puntive Relief ) Tj /F14 11.51 Tf 77.76 -.48 TD (........ 8) Tj /F14 11.92 Tf -399.12 -26.16 TD (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus) Tj /F14 11.95 Tf 174.00 -.72 TD (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-) Tj /F14 11.82 Tf 171.36 -.48 TD (Compliant) Tj /F14 12.12 Tf -345.60 -12.72 TD (Products Is Appropriate..................................................................................................... 9) Tj /F14 29.26 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (A. ) Tj /F14 12.00 Tf 35.76 -.24 TD (Absent Rambus) Tj /F14 11.83 Tf 80.88 -.24 TD (s Deception) Tj /F14 11.98 Tf 56.40 -.48 TD (, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A) Tj /F14 11.76 Tf -136.80 -13.20 TD (Series of JEDEC Standards Free Of Ram ) Tj /F15 10.66 Tf 196.32 -.48 TD (bus Patents ............................................ 9) Tj /F14 12.04 Tf -196.80 -13.20 TD (To Restore Competitive Conditions and Pennit Effective Administration) Tj /F14 12.01 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (The Remedy Must Apply To All Technologies in the JEDEC Standards ........... 14) Tj /F14 11.93 Tf -36.24 -27.60 TD (Rambus) Tj 43.68 -.24 TD (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable ...................................... 16) Tj /F14 9.06 Tf 145.92 -424.56 TD (-1-) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000023990 00000 n 0000024049 00000 n 10 7 0000024126 00000 n 0000024290 00000 n 0000051760 00000 n 0000024818 00000 n 0000024437 00000 n 0000024566 00000 n 0000024693 00000 n trailer << /Size 17 /Prev 23664 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 55127 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000107097>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R ] /Count 3 >> endobj 17 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 18 0 R /Contents 19 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 18 0 obj << /XObject << /Im20 20 0 R>> /Font << /F21 21 0 R /F22 22 0 R /F23 23 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 21 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F21 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 22 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F22 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 23 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F23 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 20 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im20 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 42677 >> stream jE"ʟɲ娀h#3Y6O1D*[.qł =D3 \AH&@ r,I M կkp\s@ȓAy>- . 8DGr@Iy蕌,=oàt5Xwt ԟ;Lv?uҽzamWvoo}鿺ﮕu}o_^oo4+6?տ=_O PT_aR).vۑ,"?GܴRoIT_n}nEv{C?ζ뮗i]~G[WX׵-{_ƿzm}vWKm-믥իm+}ߴ0׆aҖA `!lB `0L& 6T }%H0ia@0 @؃4.*",GNQH&j&a>] IK0X(-|2 RDvZPUHAUi%_]k!RM^x)_ZY4֭.M?TJ~zȍ%ҤZU},V,/KRZKUVKֽo/JzUֵϧI%R-%FUYg ATM4TM4M4M;M4i T!1UTP'A6!*i&l#imt1QI/) %Ua B?m+NO{K$kzjizꚪU bU m{ تjjUS:JkLVPA&K `z3 &0 Ta04 i*a4¨TaU!X }B(V!q 8 `Bkkz|4"""""""""" Q0L ` 0i'axa4@aSOM4[M44M;M5L&ikUЈ20a4LDDDDDDDDDDDDDH*B""#ЈM0ҺWaDUoWGjj[GGeØ@CvZ3">;ECR00 1@f  -AB f-R I>$` %*& m$& :m TOJzt]ҢԾAק&m>kItdw3ѓ=_?5UOT߫M: V$Q/I[5B?_yOЎmRUH:/VOzF޿DTS3K.8GAHlLSd3ZA{c_/kއCa5RW /:o@軃J(DxDR._kI'sI'] $S:oR ҥ KK"]WK^ҥ,&\KKn/J-.JUoKUk$m׆Iү]kJRTW_Z]RTA$Kׇ6ץҪZd]2PO֗_Q wKE?Uz]͵-mzu9*Z K,deҭV/__^5Uit_K^%gׯZ_t1T$z"EMҢs/*ץKR$(}$H[JUtTKItqdgFfB $xљ333љ3f͚36h#Fh#Fi>Od>O"'!"|43H'Fi3Fh٣3f͙Ffflϙ33fٛ336f3f͙HIzZTR*R&XE; EZIXi''AzzvjiiiA 33g0 Mi4M5M4ӻN4M;M4A|b= -1UHq *&)+K vOM=U=?O?[[[ONӽ=O]mt=4 BbT PWJQ^ ޿}}+/0& ~X`L&`h0aPa0 y  kv~kjkkb""""""""""""CDC@eQA;3  SM4U[TM44ӴtOOO[UM444M4MPih4Aiii޸h0DXA""""""""""""""""""""#Di=Rm(SVXiCi^GMG,j?c ?&!i$幐e C&.! sy244AAcصIB"H!AаNqJp-RMAF 2Pga8D_CO4jFd 2 fv8zm]:J'[;(U&AlWZ}$%z'mץT֓ӭ?)6FN~a꒪V i[.*aZWK^#ZׯVf!}M4פ_ҡۺ{us4~i)̌">_> $ apP `T-~-RTW J i.?}kygǢ'm*tK$gAcfm'MZ^zzN}9 /_7t$:Uki/Zkmz6zq-RBK*bk붮Z$/J.uk~K ?mz%]o[m-ثJץ*Km2 U`KWБff|ٙ33flSMnJ!%iEES + ZKAnM+INUMWOM4NNM4TNiiikivvkvy ҂Baتj0I+aaa ޝڮޚzꞟk߯T *}꘠P!1[1ZX2q)k_o{~8>F0@a0&aXaP`jgM=0 K[ӵ[N׿[_5mSOMVMmSUAQ"Da @)l8a4M0h4&iiiv4mSM5;M4M0i4aCD0M4M4i )*MJҤXM ]+ˆX6 5-G*W&*r c!C=Ţ&[%X0h@H4)A[-#ص"(D~̄5j Q bD 0RYƢ &ƣi@aFjO!4a0H(MUz]'I a41h zPk]];4M P^[; $/y}E||U&-.?i4$H6^-'HtΠiLܗK\ޟI_J*}*]}$.:_Z:_hҪ*I~z[o” [ZP!933 3Cg F-$2(de:%5E=I$>#ܳ$<(Mjk A '# 2 Ƚ)2h'ZT^ dۥEp5 *ma0IWogڃ]ٙN2b(0w^q\4`ɺDnWthZ=~ xk]i[ǃT]A8] _?UKIuKiV%M^  -+ MEzK1Z^Z_oJUU^^ ~I%${iuZW֒ڥKI{mm}uoIRIK׭*ZUҮI*}}V KaK %U֕*KU KÇb5z_K-{Ui-WZWת 6 =/dAJI$tDRnk]`tDV$A[?ω}kȚ_JR__UK=R^*ֽ]Uk~KKJP/ jSͺ%UҥzJ_KN&_Iz^\Wr#TRW?ˬa:%L/urB7IR(I" /RuKZKHǤctcvZ]ǗLzю/H"EkZT-UpiVm~uUt_vֺpfzJDIW%|D"FO"x'H'#Fi3Hљ336f3f͚36i3HњFtEEUED**+Ib"RXEI a.KUT&ta~]ze;HSj$-,&>h36fg33333AM0M4M4iii馚iviiCJJMUS *Ҋ$K TTTTTTRiE18a KKI&wvkiizzzݧ}鄠S_UMSTTSUT1 bTTT0 vKI~ﵵ__+MS@a4 & `„F¨M];[TL&U5PQ]B+D@kkkMDDDDDDDDDZDDDB@0B &` a0& )-aPa4*_]}STNUMSM4SM4M4TӴˆ"""jD- c6,Ċ &Ah4AL , ! 䣈4Rl*JlR PMVICxP-,#A!O F9tR"1ۢJ)Bv5", 0 e"dKt1$E8Jnh0d0pp0a (TP Z`auS&fDz#0v8 "3ZA:M*'!O * TH: ߥ$0ng[%$m++OJ*X6>NigSKtM >_Z /mt]V'KUޭ/Ku$ӴWi=UkUQ]%+דBP/cCD=NtGcOZ5 |D<(@f@ H2qgkt҄NZ'ZM MBa? 0IASK40O'6SApdO4DD>!KJƑȷFzT$ٛPdK_Avi.t]}}h.u^u}qڢ/?UE4VA'BqZTIQ in߅R$k֒(i.('7kSnk *TSTת_]%tf]$UUi*KUZ Vץl}kIpXAz}uJD2 ]D I:$_.% _JU_]~+dɧTipU꿥ꖫKkZLfKK꿪]%j֩*YkidGtT*K''ZFy#H}TZ]-tm'KY~Zߥ]'zKU|$+Jl%UKIi/կa+K͚%mKm/I&3|'Qe2x'xњDh#HњF4fOƑAXaL0ZVKJj%IPzjIiaA33L3fgϙ336hٛ4flٛ43ffl͚36fff|aMA &i4M4 4a4A|3>BaM%ED$a&^w턓m+m'ITmSTӴM4ӴmSӴ55OO]=uOOM>Ӵ("pª BbITiAz{ %Ajk_Π&AUBL&ES:(*bb@5/""!0B …&8'g.[zI5M5T_T5M=5Ӵ5ӻNO[M>=%DDFGa3YrL&i a0h5M4 h4M4 iAAABa50 0"."*""""""""""""""""""""""""""#]nS 7UMZm( [J@ fsnDD5 #ȎY8fBvGԷJ;N v"R+Y$&#Hd;ٕFv)gCfPC P3f Bd$N(RDF jeB$؁NC9ظe p phD~¨(M VrmѸB l o H YDsD4PaqA`L0tG8>IzAh.IL $ARp+iit2+<6A䏓XO]+R# pIi' B'%[R" (Niw[_Z&Kt֖^珞C֒IiWKZ9z$~մ޵IuUZ_k]kUƷWKwJ}%ׯRUj[$ZꕥGP2R\SAN9̌y@R:J}c'q&S5H 33$ :O^/lPu:ꑟJII4Ǒ1!iGJhi,0(hiBhOZ K.Um0!@#33p΢>z)pbVp04`CH H6A:aV oJS .wTO[4_CA!a}0T *~za%PO%Z.=$jRa[MEZ k*PA;Dp¤ 'KTN/+WNe>dh _%Jt*%n=~GA>ivBN""0`Үt3jm'FIQ\PKpAkMVwJ6mwJJ .3>4PI]ZIiii$ooҭjTuI*7%P^ҧJKymꞾkR]$Iq QUZ_]K%BVCkgouv{K+KDRIhPK}/?ZQUk~U}U{Ҡ*$]U(A%I/T$޿~U4V6:IR֫J!KI*ס""u*ZQJ}zZ౓w_S~5MU*uK_k1KKJK.RKJk^KZE~Kj_K^juUշҪRU$ȏW2_zTZ5z^u{IlO'ҩWt[7R3]U\T^KT-*RcK_^UUzU]$tҥ=^ר֩v*+]W]utsJȃm<үK^FKct^˭}KK(_KR/zҢu^^>%Ҵtaa$*ҤVZICK]6һޏ^u6?[/JI*LKWR{a-#7Ha $I4((a+ vQ]a$AW --%_%JtaiEiZ]C :Ia$庐cZa1=UUQ +*0|=pBPUTN) Z^a$%UE$!V $ uKM0MtL(M4a0it b4UBa%!$BH5b41 +2\0""tV04ApԐ_&ak{MSM1 kՅ0MPh0OO.""" """F8X!D!(2 iCMrxBV5A˄` &0 F>".#⸈+Ij%Rmi$H%p I(҄H:l$:ZCnqPBaG (g4弲"My!L&VKHfC8A0\0R 3u<% "5]U% \(@J-eAi#j "CK[aD!ZI)hh vBA$ &~ KzON: )Kl$7/:zzJK[H7?0^tncR^}v__@WI~iC+ᤡ2843(^tм '~T(J}zxWUi'A Y'o wm_KjoIa>k\g@}C {etTkNްt^bZm_IEZ[^ޗ]/KDxU?_q5WJ _KJ(u-.DL=/">괸 =?^ u:7Ikh5iy"몢4Od>! /UB@ҺZ&K#Lٙ33ff|ٙ33>ff|ٙ3336h٣3f43f4i3H443flљFhٙ333a|͙&L 33fg33fٛ4jZWj@ ub]&izkiiޚvAiM0M4M;M;TӵM;M4;[];Mm5M4+Ս-NAk&Q_߮ߧzwzݪi&D/ a <LSUk SM4C'Lxa}*5 kkizꫮjڪ(؈0B"2M4M4M4M5MiMSM45M44M4mU;TNM4i &aAh4AM4M4wQ]+i[m+iCQMFEܷ[ v`n4WZ̑c"B,lOC;F k]˙dT(5$Da)0AK"M{57;[Ѣ,Bw B i(@ аP@N 82[) N @ਜ4"PL a4A.8MvvMAp&~'IJ EDHa^fZKqIPth0Di6m*J$L ^FΓLn)6u+KNZ¬zu.*tյWUTe4ҽ}E/_J]RP)Ukk'IջҺҺk!IR۬GKUI}3̫D\9Q~({KZn/IRjL&:ˈ3">3l3Nffx΄b 3H"&>߭/I-UU.=LR7ё{TUj]0I286 L!q Wi.JH68?ޤ>(f A0@ xg @3zxVPD)>SU =AA;z5Da0_eK88)%."&l@ L&p!!JT"*Ť*A8>1t iB`ѡ y Oֽ,Z_{N2"wwzV&%ZpdjfjeI?l-o'U:Fz4}ROL.qU4>R5uJ%nW$gZZz%ч]~֒kJj[RUI}ijKrsuT]&*JO45K%RZ-*E#E/(zXvI!ꪗA*JjUKTIW_^Ju]$%KJ/I%WЅkUAWJ-% &zU֣Kh%kZꒅɿKQZZIRR{^>뤵izUU/[iinב%ִjJIJ%M;UiRBJҥ^/[P^N~V+o_IkY!ޕP T-_l+ֽҪׯZKTIz KҪz5kɌU]+%*YGijB*ץ䀙Oi}֖_TF]W_/}%$4Kayc*a*j#m*/mRFI*R&5m.a&_u*=V1|$iIt$Ja6O}eaj]ZэL-K] [IZ*KV%a*_^\*Zt{kk7S^}-[F>nVbRWK=:ʺiR>!6Kj+IAPD**)bKKNKaUKnTMIUTҥI$K_.)6Ҵ庐:M0a/kI* al$'V im%Lq_8m/IP0,qVЦ'qQHV $KbUTUTKꪘUP0&+@ئPحX a&)*lZUd|TjjA b0Aa0 L&5I_a a6 aU+UIl*5e5L.SMT&az"""""""""" `? &B@ a v; UMB¦i&BE0MSP8!!HR6DtF^"^$*H>$/ZIuai. PHH[J,0it(aHbQxU@DXM G-BiwlbRal2 B R b&"3"RBaIh$p0P5*A0Ai SAt'i"v*~ B vL't66"4BDN#vh:]$?MTNkTAnKTxAg|&i)LǮqm+JNүOoo''}Ai~*X7_껩__]^}*}Z]zU4:_k{wBA.lt>mWMKI^uuRi%DkpSm/-&!Wu_Z1V wK֟LE wӖRk WNZ'uڪmc{KI Y/ObuuxQp[~t vV[zu"I֕._׏ƝCN)~[tt_wVw]+t3ҥDI_m h"KK=UHVϓ2ȦPЊʊ2('"њ4ڴڴ#3ڌٛ4ڑWD'#He! g0[.54Wwwzkkvjڪ"""""؈0B"3 !DCX aa4&M &Ah0ih0 &0L!Јa4!h0Z*N"#B""""""""""""""""""""""4iiCi[JW&tLSڨgfqRl|Qށjv!3gg[ :4&t ITStDSk-i8 (DDs %Nai(AA5U LL:"Y &p8h0*aS*XA=֒$B:H*6m aS ma'K֦:^jMw0!A6t쨠`LMH<PWi4?Jk/V:OTTZ_zw? (_KuKzkINf.jdP5"c"ҡ$3IoAoֿߋA-5PMJ6"L&pSfl4"E8gB.b$v*XU^DU *za 'ev\U hѨA>AHҺNtN5j_uK?z3hKvM4KTX(HۥZRTuKT}zK0ZT ɎƖ*)i%_Ii_U^+ZAit}YNUiz /TPWHt]:T%VպO%ֺ%^TvAl+a},]*U%H-vI-V*K7A1ajK_(JZT - DȃwIRKD/KK*ִzoq־%K ]R-j_FztK_&5WU}U/K_OWZɌ7oK*Iur2K#%TUi-RKHZM/.0++K*H/I*Z=mm*mu0y*0rwF4VzWHUUU$:(65UutJzRwu^I* QQB*FT"*QDQӴ;=;5CiAp% I¦u*RJ!t1 a` *RZa@m~__[ jL&TMIŪa i¯A B W:@5j48XM4 a0L& & Ϋ`Vvڭݦjju8Q:"EE e& aM4M4iM44h4 a4hC0!D+q읠"."*""""""""""""""""""""#+mR$& XA-#EAMn! )D@ȰDed [] ,SN2]<"0S+YE^T"cYlʮU;MzE"xAAX `0Al A @dpttJ-MSi !h<0x^AH((DxSQ*Q*]4N.j&Gj2GRDtIMT:M*ުipF} 3iSi8I_Rm].$]+ i7Mj:RVIz][I.$XX?J0F.?Zk{IuK\K:fc!Tz(mXPUuWI L!0L ff@ 2KIRi+[uJKoI&M$%]%PR\PT"\r BzI{vִlU.K^:_`0KiSm֕-oA%_K/^-o/W۪i6/IWWKKIKKU}km-k[^Khk֩;j܋_VI/}/W_o]/WI<*V{]_j=TFuTKI_},_:ս.3ZT/[#'";ҵK~_Կica#S?K/0tҫ ފs$dT^*yi-m}/V%I.ҴV[d-?a0Ʃi_a--o'J[KK>h23:I'j}^H/144f4fљ33fffg͙A33>fl ͙36ffl q٣UC iEEX%ZLBBZX]kam*T4$p]m5iu0M4ӴM4Nӵmm5M;[NT)=7J[@ڤ) jQ[a$MLA6\%$+TIiDiXl$_vڭ~ujSPTMS LTSP- %a Afca0a+OVմz_K8""PPLL&*4ӵ$> ˜ta0[M2pI Dmh1 b 1]U>OM{Tm5^zb"""""""""""""* 2nHp0T  ‚ycl4h5[ wiiiiiiM4aSM4UDDDDDDED"BRB""""""""""""""""""Q lFii7}'JI]$Bu m$]  BMl-DF嶏˨Y^?g&Y y62UKuxl"B TȠsڑRGv)e,M#;OZDŽ0@L SABAN0p@A*s"%̈2D=r$J0@8:fl"9MpPH(V j0A@UK\-T駐`~ 0a,iiq{uA5&vHt I2?ah=JV{KDI$06mi6þtRӤ<&b($H::ZZ;i NTK^Ion}nm%hҭkIRztXkmI}^>ߤV|.FJ];/: le$3:Q#:#?F&#O2gL9>jk z`B ؁0` 5"b <͗U"YxCZI%Ң ֌BJACߥJ% @-….(O * kJ]#Q \dx4JFmҪ֒UׯK:nJ=ZA* ?tD$~KZ_ڵu^Z / J4޺E R~I[[ZI-L/_֒/RYuݰWa/RIWUI6Aa T Sm=A$jx%Ӥ\ԽJK%&mA6K N)iZN 6v^ z]Zh>II6VNVzIMUiW>(B &+L% ubt!hBi(K,zUMt`T𩮺aST鈄J+z[C(&)0/!GZL0Iv*+XJ]E%apSAL &Mt_0.j+"8,55bTRTUS^DDDTH"$6""4xQ. p4 AP`gLML \uNaU0N0MEևDAC$GQ_KKJ^.,/I%3WI$A*J"*X1Naҥkj6-+CXz G,MeV!)XC#H@"t\x͙-"!v3NA8eb&"#S)0rdR0d`vM[Y7anj`BA  aBRttJOLBn7iADEp8juTւ #…AA4;IA7U;W] <âxU[IH62vm&մHwOV(fmvR&B&zևk&`E 0AB PqB *R_RS_K =EADI<`̻MxD҄J$JtUTT zW_3ч}+Tj i٣LE (1?z$V]-Vt%+WIִud[aAA +}--%KKꚯ_&&S_5_]v RnZ$*k{*Awڷ_~ni!%ޛKj-zUJʠKK U[/_TuبJ.I%Ƶְ8oK/ZUH.KRKݽ}i*yqޗ^}d(]vD4IU6hBץT~I#JTU7kKik_?%~¥o.ri:I}{믭/ֿӺ{z#soO^}.+뤵}%TvHU^Ց$U_+TWj_ԿitLtcJL,/zZ/I+WKפi+%몯=Z[j^m-*ZM'$'Wעb4x4H'|'2|'ZA*0}*J[It봭%AIXAI^izA 4h4A & ͙ ͙6fi-<,TUi1;%QHUGVSa-$&ºZS$L$$ &KCtm;]o_54NHTUBb UX #]Iaa* 0%iA[ ++i6zk} aPaT*jPURzM$E1 b |B0~!40K!alx` &zLSu[WODDHxbLL&>2c A05aI0Ȯ TCP b!&[M{Ӵ4UnDDDDDDDDDDDTA Тna2a0D2A`Rb,(r`` K|Кl DDDDDE &M0iB4"""""""."" &""""""""""#uJ(Im-LXibA"?E_-bEMPgԷX8Sb 3"㵱B,̅`$Dsb8"P!MRi4U#P@)Ea&j fSS(<[ 0IN YFv] ~ l_ԝ5aAT?V3٬ʁDMp.B" pTtim*M IjUal% 6MZ^Kǭtp~J.jmIoT}Gt_JO*n$QjPMq!NIB]5ۘw x `P@ uͩ;a0vjiviiڈЈљ㈈a&raaaaqHDDDDF_m*_%A{kJ0@-ẈG7YPd 2mХ(`(PS !AB 4Tوs3c4ϙktJaS"!rE**ڑ9*@$#F/C,Վ P A&&0PT A vwIPTTƞF`Mv¶UHwIRjG᠁M+k'4ȭ ܧ|ZN(Iau$E֌%-'UAcOM$ B"ޚNuC_W]zKUKoRmҭ%aM``N\Y(_RIRRjKi/ҿIxM,K+EUkK%QB:K>߶^^VTMKvK6 NFZKi}(Ii֖%nפ:?No}~UA%&.tZwKm/z UzXRIv+5u^^zIk_ޒѢKt?K$FK]Iԗ}~IGK뮴KKoֿTqJJZZ_׾[UZUI߮ȅ_Qa/ZQVu$Q~zO/э}u]*N1=mHǓ˥jcA*ޭկTH-=j[U\/9z^])Β{Huz%uzltvQ葓GIb%ai*VcaJҵJKI44FjFu iy #ZL333flњ36hٛ4flљFh٣4flٙ333>fffgϘAA0hL& 33fgٛ33}F.)cQEEEZU'a}a(a$KJ4 .J+vm]&iivivvjkv}bP)ªaEV tlTS %T1_!G C $m$;_[uN  iST *iiL$M 0j_b (AI뮿   a XU7Ʉ-"!ba44[[TuS^ST5T>uM=q:""""%^8 "#eM07ՄM44M44M4M4L&iiaa0CMa4ij؈/KMԛ$iDѪMm,SaҰD M #6[S@jf2#vXEv-.5)"4)SP`9!#" vZF `Eܖz [a I<2[d`%h0I #(&P^۫4`A`4Qg L&0@ )]}!t# rLgC7ϯmZ]U* 8n=u3M| P$c_j)҃-jΌ Z Eܧ?m$^AuJ(DtD7.*]zqGF{imzZNbl&Ntֽ-%kIV'Khժ0 ?[DGy-}/KUWIkҽ/J`{ ۯK Bm~mt ҭ%Z֮]^ -}RI[ҭ$ZIWJXqURj\%ci%KKJ`JI%KuZ/ZviuZI)&-%UZH$z^޺UAztBoI~UƢDҿ_]yJ]*U"7SIUU k RZUUHU-$Kտ/^jI}kTwkIW֫wSׯk^DAW_/zF==IL,KG^ﴺT]4KPR'Kc/{K]# R-%u(_z]TA:3+F6Z®UWG22I%/+H >ia/KZ# ͚3HљFfiƌ͚36iƑ44Fi36h#Ffflњ333f͚33>fff͙3fff͙Ff4t~Ij***)(a(*)!&Z;m.*,qQX[[ EZ * $#mm4oKM4M4M4Ӵ0ii ivviiiT==S?_Tﻵ[m~J4L& hL*iUWT&+¨Fʪb@, -RҴMk  i¦aL(N­P4MS_TO_{]>5N[M5lB10h&y7/@ST4NMS[M4ӵM5M444M4N A M4L&hDDDDEDG:C4Ik}BNJm$IE+t0?5neARTdq;P fBbE&C=q/PC;[J:إ8xfvHԜSyQ1C@#FV'Oڢݡ bA 50d&8d8uJw '29 !aΘL.4Co0-V_ 4I4fH<"vDApl`(DHQ>Eu\PM"pzmU&ҧ8oO-6[ku}$Nt ~kMMmzJU|WZl}}uYi+h5/min_tZ_ZWJ3}ۯF_I{…}%_}ҽU3΄u5lBNHfXoKwkKa a5 tѶtDr3#Hў,sA=|Ҽ4C6Zj߿^%ZIUp.xDxMmm D!lء:IA7 ү|&'U=qM m/ TJ=W]BK8pI0I5Kwʿ53 a'}&>њ ~d O=(~]Ij_myS]%Ii5I7 E oKoȃ.Z[z^t i/kA*Z@}4/o齵`ZJ*IR_ֽtP^վ~~I$oBU%^Vu"$P{[kM]jMKJMRWi o}UtJJ*KIv}oy7U -i`_o_޻l_]$UAR^A=I%$7!"E-ƾ$D묖&҂J#K]I,}-v*LgدT-?K%_n ¤5]]뿫JGՔiz*Ւ*$D}ҺU.*1J^xhƕHף5"KBM^k?ڭ-uZK궩Q;Z jIH_KTKqZZV.iXA_Iگ]UQ%fi\;]6KoޤhCn?Ƒڴڴٹ6ڴڱ4ڱњڑ:N= =!E5zupwUJit / UUKTI%MTR^4F.ޗJzkRU:um{zR$ii,o]/KqK a__A&[ҵU\=W~U #uU !>UR]z]zUJ޴HK__J;NMK뤺Rjޕ/zRT[_UW{_z=~]$B _]/KS{U%uF:1<$cǩ/iB{KJQ{TMzI:zֵoU׮OZEE$&Kz/HijN*J®h+A;H}%dֶ*N>(oʶ#񤰿Ƒ>> $;N8 d HʈvPkD4* 6`ff(6';@-K a=Aq$.a?믿TI_I M9^ԕtQTK}?I%{jKct8r6fݤZ\apP*` \);0y5 !DsQ"!>PΩU$&A0\5U4& < * h0"-' <(U"WW@_&&OLh_ֻWUץZ3-!+R?W.)kСC|*m/D~{U+jKKVb?&3AI}z5IY/8i:I_a=k[]vW?w/J%_NVKK^j-T?KN$Y#/kCnAzB~t/_JkmsiZ^ܝ?Z[MK__ҿM{Kմ{o-.}~OWa~զ__/ֽskⴉ{Uv6 %WUk4]v0>iuE*{Լ_t,[I;Wi8b^KbamuzR>\/UyIB[0A8m;L1MOᄚM5m*㿴T⢢*+M>&m+ UoLM4 &b S0B d# `XL'U]t0UN0ݞDDdq  gf &X׆]6I֘A*THUu)"""""""""""" H-=3EL&U3„L*ޘL&|DDG\"""""""""6""K 6_ 6JM 1m* Hcn+H9e:QH0+L);=Np<,Ap|TJX+eRR8zdȇ7G4A_oUOXJ3_KWO[M}{_htitk fKߪi.MK.Twkޕ/c֖붷5q9$7<$ι}%\={ipl4ABi5 D,ANx?VíSHtQ&;}$ a &TVh82o2R0I[T8h4^Qx%ӬoYm{]t i[KG_}:ȸ]Ii]] 7]=x&Jxa_i.{i?+ỿurP5޾~୦i˯[j=a_ ?]l?[F}RS_I7+ ^~?ֵ[dzIJָKMծ׽:Okxտ_-o ~o50Ն0lљFf#Ff4fl͚D4flљH'"x'H'x'x4f lڧ[ئ))ih4TӴiM0h4i4MiiM;M4ӴNiij u C# f,h p`M:] ݆8O~NӴTm>m=44m==}==;[aSӆBSm:2= `Ll/"E hSYNDmma)&4֨a kkj}j_uqq"0 (& 0iijڦjMSM4M4M4M5L&iO B"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""SC`nm/I(IIp E%m* Y)#a2H3)'-C(()NaA[LDipvK ITd!pLY( c`W p5X7"?Il ӆXTC>l ~I2sAH$ 0Xlq.c?ۤ*';'MI>YLFl'NiڥFW ,8z '5 !'?}A S^GooHRo>=w{of#l~S١:>w>?jAa  Lh`Ђ!. #s|&&2HfK4N(0N߄DN)L4S0T Ђ PLt" B*l'6fJ#@:)0*Dٲ>2΢CxA8 2#xN}/m"v^5UUDI UUBa4y ?< h40&aB & @A (3 ML 0P:M#~ߚ]O7l@ܧ:|aމ9v4pA7xUUDݴHiQ7aWmuDa?DݨTSD3Ʀb O CzM&a0]'IaoPt`&H7M ᠃millLa/ƉB}I& hhh2lMhqh +Vam5mzOBIL'I&a80&ީ[ }vlȑIdosIIIa0͍&l;[˚zuS<',VߦnvkҡŦ`˅kt]鶛?~USi7OWX %+u*zzW^_ uk %]'I,Tt*1V.㎵cX iL0cncЦͥ݅]I*Kҫa,* ahd# L|Zl}۵TmiRjZZq;"hTVR %hKJaV A7VSM40t (0A[ ;LTA4i0Xa(鰕D&***""""! ɂf UdndaM4kB]L*bUQa aɜl 3aS 0L a`088JmjZIimK6CHmJ/ #Qo!'eeyZ̖*AdvxAe[2E^SjJ" 0Yk5aNW9R'mxYppr?cnU {8(D &M&WFKTii=M*fLI{~VªIjubsdrτ,o8<*QT_4B8 p0v]A(E& )Câ_HPh(2CM4B#4A} h_4fN͌!S‚!8qddg. ᬏ%f=HǦak!a0@fA L䡄O( ֚3 BgL&0BȐV|7N6|y.-UV ԼfmQvP33 />&Z-K &$I] S Om&ޗ bq_uv*uNm8284%p?N7z&pIiWںivJK_zolR4Wtt-jx~{i%׷_~ un}gޖIS~Hֿiuk]{8u/mWI}V^bޗ_OORJ*6*8p^%OO۪Zw}ߡTKc_UV]ս$HۦK[1Z~mZG=:$_u7B"1QNM{j *[ wK_R6\6~ߑ3flљ336fflњ333fl٣3333fffff|ϙA͠Ϛ|ٙ33fff٣3fff#KikթJkuuaWI==>MSNOTӻ[[ӴӴ=4ӻ(AUn׹J mZPat 6 a'KXXaӻO￴O^uOUMv˴ )n ݪjUME$S6+ aS!A@ q @K޿ DDDqž &A#Yl a0JS -a&ZTANt5OOUNMS]5O]S[Ӵq hD&AC& . & vL M4h4M0MA &4"Z ! 4 j눈#)֗릗k6+mZM܊`0@?ZiYL d[F>zRF}"YغK`WfCL& I=L+L }BqH.SX. j dxZpp`w'XC !F>ArBQH9 @cDh  ArĂfsh.`+G] Ʃm{uUW_/DF3^} k/?΂ 00DCp&M/ȇ %':0   !آ " 8.lx[D35gvt3Fk"FyAʳ5gL3Yfa C5gNe9D35䈞8ΣHhT]4^Qx;sxMS Ioaz =?GxA//h_Ť߰ӰM&վҽ&ѐbI/l"I$o6ZB&ҳ'gu}ڰ²>M;ѳ<'=xJ._JJMMںZ\}kQǷej-}?֭uZ/][m׽WWpo5;zzzqUWM~^]0{Ŀ^_a$8/z{:?t'?}d0WCo:&?i/aɉnXF-:Za~}o_mM?Fo [_~ې{$oY!V/on}axztwO$a!w~_KjBrE~grEm}FAҿ~zItO^m+L?_^ޛ_a Z^a}koo^_i?ub+I&)?b{0/مk^մm/uv{Imuu _M[I^)?alS lثKVuJ{[uuivJkwuu{ [O  *) qM1P 0{Ij6N'MK+Xm/cb7&)&Ҵw}\5 Z tbA!j*HMTSLP ml0M60itL0~:j-m Ai4B#'"@ )wf-%g 4Mab@0BA 40AA A 4k 0m8 h bL#` 6DtqDDDDDDE""'\0@̠A )3SQ^8ajaEs' LtL _MX  gAܲ d7eXADڸdՑC$gcOB S!,@R*FK]!i2%)r)dFA,ӢP4D/MHn. B0:/rAaBj C@0iE 6 ", iDq^nL*iֺpt 4xBLSa phh4H:;v xBh4.U@ aIh4D[zMk' z$Mz>EUn i6ުޯAA@VSUi",7KVtӤ*HU}+ۭ&IIkZ]]4ݯN.)!UU[~[z_A A ٱAIj޺/KY~>ú&i Tўdd1 \B H:wk?gdr<)""hk$jH/ 馉jgѰOL!V0L!`: h~D)8$ H8 {XDŽteLh=>X('''DN.PPzg (M &ߪAXA^&|E0i}WwIҦ=6F  [`Bpe^9w"xB%m4 d^O8ނ{خ5תKI&II,Tt&ڪz3:JsI}[TW?z_VA%/tO&m뮒ImZtHJ׫Kun{4hWJZU>${MWڧN'b?K҄q]/Hbu'[a[ t} nH%z^T]_~i7__tA%WB /UUK/_NxIaU!U~ 7}iuZ_itM]ux%_^ tK]/uI$_%DI-I~/V^m޴/-Ui+KKoK$[n:Z_K\},WiMtdfI9^z)e _UKB7"u}"Bc/$-/v ~m=%RԽkzYR?z\z\ui$i$_~Z RHShzvRT-zޫK(u]/(m}zJytfҿֽbgl4Z;mxKJҊM-+i_JK{iV]!a-ᥘM&ƨv)M@ VbUZQQQ )֕ l%M֖]] 6IM $QiZ 5L$˜+i.MR %MuHT,< uH0I %YX`m&A,0H6La ؤ جLB4!DDC 0TL(S@ AT& ,1 )[O )b؄x  @45E8QWrDDN*hYTL `VapZ P9P )™qg6C |@f6&IӃPAeN!gRDDA$1K +idNA*ұP,u60Jc?r!"#S;P l82Gnh4]-8j 6 THi6h6Mm뿽ii>=-៵v׏*}u|.ūJɧUŪܳծGӳߥI*밭?UNyү%մБv*}%$u_&KZHi$᯹%Ւ-ZZдnʱ136i3њfffafg3fffg͙Fffl͚36hٜir@;M/VIzݦvk}vzjjjzzvv馚vviڧvvڪkwvziiOiZIZ1I}z޿޷߯z a4(u~i޿kz DƘAM0M4iikkkjzjizziޟzj5M5ON5MUWQaE" L ah0AMaAa4A""""""""",L iiQ63B""""""""""""""""""""4$ID l :daG+;L([L?MD\QK``a(Xl$>? 0eˆA)([hGB@ endstream endobj 19 0 obj << /Length 7457 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im20 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F21 12.71 Tf 232.80 732.96 TD (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES) Tj /F21 12.26 Tf -158.16 -27.60 TD (CASES) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -.96 -27.84 TD (Daubert ) Tj 43.68 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F21 12.24 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals) Tj /F21 11.36 Tf 146.88 -.24 TD (, Inc.) Tj /F21 11.55 Tf 30.72 0.00 TD (509 U.) Tj /F21 12.08 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -264.72 -27.36 TD (FTC ) Tj 25.92 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F22 11.32 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (National Lead) Tj /F21 11.55 Tf 75.60 0.00 TD (352 U.) Tj /F21 12.16 Tf 32.64 -.24 TD (S. 419 \(1957\) ................................................................................ 2) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -144.96 -27.60 TD (FTC ) Tj 25.92 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.80 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (Ruberoid Co.) Tj /F21 12.09 Tf 71.04 -.24 TD (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ................................................................................ 15) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -108.00 -27.60 TD (International Salt Co. ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 108.72 -.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.06 Tf 12.48 0.00 TD (United States) Tj /F21 12.16 Tf 69.36 0.00 TD (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1) Tj /F21 11.36 Tf 259.44 0.00 TD (, 15) Tj /F21 12.04 Tf -450.00 -27.36 TD (In re Dell Computer Corp.) Tj /F22 10.07 Tf 135.84 -.24 TD (121 F.) Tj /F21 11.91 Tf 39.84 -.24 TD (C. 616 \(1996\)........................) Tj /F21 12.10 Tf 139.44 0.00 TD (:.............................................. 7) Tj /F22 10.91 Tf -315.36 -27.12 TD (In re Ekco Products Co.) Tj /F22 10.22 Tf 123.12 -.24 TD (65 F.) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 34.56 -.24 TD (C. 1163 \(1964\), ) Tj 78.72 0.00 TD (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 164.16 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F21 12.56 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (FTC) Tj /F22 10.41 Tf -356.64 -13.68 TD (347 F.) Tj /F21 12.39 Tf 30.24 0.00 TD (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) ) Tj /F21 12.04 Tf 114.24 -.24 TD (...................................................................................... 2) Tj /F21 11.96 Tf -199.44 -27.36 TD (In re Orkin Exterminating Co.) Tj /F22 10.16 Tf 153.12 0.00 TD (108 F.) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 40.32 -.48 TD (C. 263 \(1986\), ) Tj /F21 13.42 Tf 72.72 0.24 TD (affd) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 20.88 -.24 TD (, Orkin Exterminating Co. ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -233.04 -13.20 TD (FTC, ) Tj /F22 10.33 Tf 29.04 -.24 TD (849 F.) Tj /F21 12.12 Tf 30.24 0.24 TD (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) ......................................................................... 2) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -113.28 -27.60 TD (Kumho Tire Co. ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 81.12 -.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F21 12.18 Tf 12.00 0.00 TD (Carmichael) Tj /F21 11.55 Tf 62.40 0.00 TD (526 U.) Tj /F21 12.15 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (S. 137 \(1999\) .......................................................... 12) Tj /F21 11.20 Tf 261.84 0.00 TD (, 13) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -450.24 -27.36 TD (Massachusetts ) Tj 73.44 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.51 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Microsoft Corp.) Tj /F22 10.50 Tf 84.24 -.24 TD (373 F.) Tj /F22 10.79 Tf 30.72 0.00 TD (3d 1199 \(D.) Tj /F22 11.36 Tf 57.36 -.24 TD (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -256.32 -27.36 TD (New York ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 50.64 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.51 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Microsoft Corp.) Tj /F22 10.50 Tf 84.00 -.24 TD (224 F.) Tj /F22 10.70 Tf 30.96 -.24 TD (Supp.2d 76 \(D.) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 84.72 -.24 TD (C. 2002\), ) Tj /F21 12.07 Tf 47.76 0.24 TD (affd sub nom.) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf -254.88 -13.44 TD (Massachusetts ) Tj 73.68 -.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.51 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Microsoft Corp.) Tj /F22 10.78 Tf 84.24 -.24 TD (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.) Tj /F21 12.28 Tf 88.08 -.24 TD (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -309.12 -27.36 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F21 12.18 Tf 11.76 -.24 TD (General Electric) Tj /F22 10.16 Tf 86.64 0.00 TD (115 F.) Tj /F22 10.66 Tf 30.24 -.24 TD (Supp. 835 \(D.) Tj /F22 11.02 Tf 78.24 0.00 TD (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -273.36 -27.36 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj 10.56 0.00 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F22 10.41 Tf 53.52 -.24 TD (253 F.) Tj /F22 10.85 Tf 30.72 0.00 TD (3d 34 \(D.) Tj /F21 12.32 Tf 45.84 -.24 TD (C. Cir. 2001\) ........................................................... 4) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -206.88 -27.36 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.00 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F22 11.36 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (National Lead) Tj /F21 11.64 Tf 75.84 0.00 TD (332 U.) Tj /F21 12.08 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (S. 319 \(1947\) ............................................................. 6) Tj /F21 11.20 Tf 263.28 0.00 TD (, 15) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -449.04 -27.36 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F23 8.37 Tf 11.04 0.00 TD (Singer Mfg. Co.) Tj /F22 10.50 Tf 82.80 0.00 TD (231 F.) Tj /F22 10.44 Tf 31.20 -.24 TD (Supp. 240 \(S.) Tj /F21 12.16 Tf 88.08 0.00 TD (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -279.36 -27.60 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F21 14.20 Tf 12.24 -.24 TD (u.s. ) Tj /F22 10.24 Tf 23.28 0.00 TD (Gypsum Co.) Tj /F22 10.84 Tf 64.56 0.00 TD (340 U.) Tj /F21 12.27 Tf 33.12 -.24 TD (S. 76 \(1950\) ............................................................... 2) Tj /F23 12.80 Tf -200.40 -27.12 TD (OTHER AUTHORITIES) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -.48 -27.84 TD (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, ) Tj /F21 11.85 Tf 185.04 -.24 TD (Antitrust Law \(2005\),) Tj /F21 11.61 Tf -131.04 -13.44 TD (LEXIS) Tj /F21 12.09 Tf 33.84 -.24 TD (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .......................................................................... 3) Tj /F21 10.80 Tf 368.40 -.48 TD (, 5) Tj /F21 11.99 Tf -456.48 -27.12 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F21 11.62 Tf 131.04 640.56 TD (, ") Tj /F21 12.33 Tf 10.80 -640.80 TD (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of ) Tj /F21 11.95 Tf 229.68 -.48 TD (Competition) Tj /F21 11.91 Tf -317.04 -13.20 TD (and Patent Law and Policy) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 127.44 -.48 TD (" \(October 2003\), ) Tj /F23 7.93 Tf 87.84 0.00 TD (available at) Tj /F21 13.93 Tf -215.76 -13.44 TD (http://ww.) Tj /F21 11.03 Tf 58.08 -.24 TD (ftc.) Tj /F23 8.44 Tf 15.36 0.00 TD (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf ) Tj /F22 9.50 Tf 167.04 668.64 TD (........... ...... .... ...... ) Tj /F22 10.59 Tf 81.84 -668.88 TD (..,................ ...... 16) Tj /F21 12.01 Tf -376.56 -27.36 TD (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed Final) Tj /F21 11.98 Tf 54.00 -13.92 TD (Judgment) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf 53.76 -.24 TD (United States ) Tj /F21 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj 10.80 -.24 TD (Microsoft ) Tj /F21 11.03 Tf 50.40 0.00 TD (\(D.) Tj /F21 11.75 Tf 27.12 -.24 TD (C. 2002) Tj /F21 12.00 Tf 38.16 0.00 TD (, Civil Action No. 98-) Tj /F21 11.16 Tf 106.80 0.24 TD (1232) Tj /F22 10.47 Tf -353.52 -13.44 TD (Feb. 27) Tj /F21 12.07 Tf 36.48 0.00 TD (, 2002\) ............................................................................................................. 4) Tj /F21 8.36 Tf 136.32 -50.40 TD (-11-) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000055452 00000 n 0000055511 00000 n 17 7 0000055595 00000 n 0000055759 00000 n 0000099297 00000 n 0000056287 00000 n 0000055906 00000 n 0000056035 00000 n 0000056162 00000 n trailer << /Size 24 /Prev 55127 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 106820 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000141433>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R ] /Count 4 >> endobj 24 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 25 0 R /Contents 26 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 25 0 obj << /XObject << /Im27 27 0 R>> /Font << /F28 28 0 R /F29 29 0 R /F30 30 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 28 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F28 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 29 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F29 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 30 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F30 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 27 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im27 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 29778 >> stream ))?Dlov嘏%UZ"-УZG&J>YCE2rkunT ;~8)prA!S1Ś0$Eqyh o~IZ~K/(F ??l]n(Om` !Pˉl00! 1Vt › $5Q1xyL @{4tEtT,RAh0@" F9!lQ=' Pu;N \hW~`!! ,TB " B#.m5/DGA'nO)D2$ 2BhB}~uN'A{}w>#ޚ}i_}mw[чW0I{osޮ?}qt]w1_޽}붗^+{3wiz>o|wU}]/__Kz_IȑޭAI~7uk"ѯoއtnݿ3>3]K}{Nݿ{9]i_֖4^0~۽i{ٮ[~ߪ[}u[Iջ[nKikziZֿa%PAMP2Щ 4<L0a-0Kpf t  3bA nMh80^ɎTd+́w=Iм0P@ 0  (]2L$=__Yw$dq#qipnP4 AFap> 3}Sx a@b$fY0 %al95) bP@e!p` D 0lka`#[] dJY"pl{"Rȓ%ȔD Gd$A"Dh D`»{mnxz "`lJAkm}o}}ﶻ[H:MMvM}wot_O֖7~[=y߷zmy8o~WW?֖^/~/[ǿ_K_uoRZߍ5޽c^^Tg_x-u+]uzFׯ8\qz_uaI/%^Up_[}mߣ$Hȗc"^Dȱ_ץ^EwAMoo6p_ܳ^ooqo{^f~ݡyCx~}n_޿nbjq],Wz[^Ko_K_kޯKZ_[륮ۯޖ-vo_^uIvյkKzjkz$Ҷ{ooJմKW|B 0]3`U l$V_ a. (H@؃4 hBL@[L0NMNJJ0I7l!`[Vqa6$'Dh Pb<0@Ѕ!&!eo Dc7LACB%1<5!R `k性"""""""""E"(DDDOg2"#u[ؤp.G8B|>7B"""$ Fg# 7%dt$ bw73Dp6ED`ّ_0Hzyޫd+-36*Fx  HPb~Ec*iAh?uIEIϯ5h {t@Azh$ AO(OAXA PhHFiGj2T87H5DjE>ZMB Ɖ'?`k o8FOCW߯[_&2_\"qu_b[Z___[KVc^?(]ucҵqm :0@5σ5H#i4W5A/̞)&Qt )cY|&i) *""""""""""#\qe$_-S%RΔܛdО쁆R$\4;5V5 F uwѠvh A佲\@%ϒ}Fm A7>ޓۆ鴛OvJ  v}:W7~z Ԕ9MMM;]o﾿/5xzO_{kZM'0soKw޷tJKa_q[oWIӾޕb~~ǽ/Kwa޷_Z]o[_$T}x"t?Km|?/^AEA_t%?o}$^ /J%_P9xދJxo!XKpA=o߅K ~ + մ%oV][~U o?u~Mrw7o'fï߯K޻}vovmaN֗ۯnlP{ܴ?ۿkc#޸dA]d|tۯޒWiwt__r#-~\[uimH!bK׭ߥz_IKI봭]J.W֫i^im]Z[w$Hv`m+KaI[[[t4ZlA a aP`5vIM0m3x-FĽV[pa,4:I% aOBp!! Qb 34 _A6cبm+AJ}RV[IXSLi\0:AziRjv BQMeH!"-Evz)s* r,ئA@8֢""""""J. l0aQngĤ4""4"L2ҨK¼$o(Y}k^'L 3mgX3Lu>`3BL 0 >(i¡MwAItO2Z'n4'N}-+ G&G2%uаkt =Sx뾵JЯ[{O $I$ ~]ޕյJT;G0izd{1o^ئ]^iؤ4Mo0A8 l 0h0  5YgKQDDDLX,_|~o_[^n`܎!2qFDDDDH#]x"МPPh3DDD 4s$f"9 Z~ |1n? ɲYTFY=bt@'-qnY0hY9&Ba9A r%faǔȚ&BA j?aa@38scR L tPg&CABAF30qf bd+B!> : 0` 0Z!\a0@ C4Մ6Q??^ &h6մI@ ml$K;]DHl!8pD`( )4p@n 0:M::L:ڠH>|% v&6DԉLJ L͑) ߥ:L6?'I{ݷvot}:Kto_}}]&omW O{u}~_}ÿ;O?z K_tx }i?~cMm]z__g]aֿVIkn=/^-{Kw_/oa (-XK: nt{~-q\|B֕nD~ҵ اK=>E"A""Eu"DK7}߾";m.u>(A}}YU|7Xoo}~~o߿s5AW_}o?iP[xuV+]}/R_N뿾ڶuoM뿮귯OVVm~omiv$ /o¶a/څKoUۭ]z B0&B:MgJU.Iz]iL a@0  Pbhf(8a &hRm;`th3S@Ф"2). %$ؠ@( @ܧ7 FF̜CA@qK1LGђ:Y4d.2N΃́#3dGh4aiBBD fC-R&]aU%`Cf5 :0M445L ͈`P0 AEs#2<pΤ]p΂dV!B ђH4e9"6 tTG^Dt~ɠQ;ht"PpC5LzDo„%OU!COia5.T (LZapDfO\'FzPj8K44a5 i40T'K9A_ToS%9_UU8ҭ*)K$t]R֕VT/T%נUSS"qOUUU꾫XZ0@@ٟ3C030@ϳ8) ѝOPA0\j3p\kfU$) 4͈MK 4"aBjl@0C !:Cќ2\2A TٚEVjC( 331nɠQ+x*Ţqe#p(DiTN} ꆺa0'@C! PAA!؁0L!dHMBa/h-'3=L6h&Ŗx2g:js3MY: 2to ;˼aDA04M;Ez'Hw4N&֗&MT x3gTKўi"ǠI N-PM'ߤsƉ(A8A84̝uO(PO+KKBz'--QI%Z--. i'I3.+/KҫJcTcJ~5I*KI5_U|R귷%*URIV~ VkVk׶׶)jHRTJ!HRҭ-kltnUֺ\%I%T҂ KZJAA%U_մ&X-WIUuAmRKI%Tu].Jު\k$TKnBMmZZT-tK T kպ7V(.]ib$׭._^$I/$ҶnP_"D&V=Dm}%JI]WIuKU~i_JN"UZH]"*K%WK^].W?kUZJVM?oJKIiRC^)1UNa%U^5OnT;Z]tOO/){F?Կk}RYGU*UTiW~Y#~B֩uMKTUt}jX]#IKF;}K'F5/˭# 1cԿdGIeR0aiE$=(=}5K֪Fv6N]i*KRJKK'VKTؤU1UŠX*\IqXJIZQZIMl%^:K]#*ItXK.iqI[IRUHVL$)a1 &!E5LS TUBXҴ(qq\TBom-I%KLUTWQ;ê*j꺪i&L }EUE%MES ) ҦL0T j !`SAaB  &T H  MUB ]SL ¦ڮX(#Se`&`!i!&  B-XA!  { """""""#)DDDDDG -uA)ijKZ-Ϩ;\0?٢0epA"q B]x9Sio_U(֊͡]z]eY*]%"'ΑRTf̐#%-k &|@0L(*h0D? vfg >^PEH) 3읚/[DDtUSP] ؁B`jGAPO/&Dh4N-"N!׫ў,, h2jZN .ִ^g.tIJҪ}ZTJҤZIzT*Z5ǭiK֖5/k'jIRTn*IKK%ꖗчkT_Z꒺ZOiVtUҷA/Ti-Wi7_z꫶^j_mV.$!ztZKKzn=*UZIkҺ_U_I%U]mZtuJZ]6zHniukZzZK~.iKF5/j]lW3}KaQ_ \F]/Z]WJN$/_u="h*GUzKZU ӤpUTN⺴Bq,TTTUECC XE**?_LWT5UHT*j`ST]0 TBUL&HT.""""#TʰM0Aa0L&SPL aSUADDDDDDDDDDDDDA3GZB FT FȂs+O j JAذ`9ڱ1 Qy ̮/L~ # N=} 0DJb(Ԋj)U J""C` ph"9AF:%piDa0 BgA3&N}V 香P0`@vª'mRI,R ]Ѳ)M$MIؼHI?i6K]-+DgSHk'EKM*4_T*a_ҭq&Hhj+K%IW^^I|}\]R*]*JIUWު?^]j+ kΩ{ ]_^2p6f6!t#Pg:MHc4>]V*/~AB;3& ЉpP2p ]P) {tVWYǨ2h'z]Q;%[H(DtDkJUL!ކ zU&ƪ9Sz f:2N:VSF;6 N슂qDI{`֒ץ]%ItR]"^Mu:3NBAӂB$d'I$]$ǤIy㥯OҪm-uA]תZ[}z_ÿjR_KKHcZ[TZJ=%jRoUK_RRKU]WJ*I$AZ $KWI$]BT/uZTj%^>K ַkJTүKK+ t%_Tk ץzҤIm&ꕽH%K%I}/BUUuZԈߪ Z%%AzVUեKBJWB~I:֔(K\}~Tiz_]R"]J *]%ץK]*%^D-td믭%ɨuIuVZ_֬굥5o$0].FT0ZS_t_{Gk^ީ$-iUiRKֽzEkU/ڗ]ƥ-i1zz_1JcҪH_%VK^utT®FgD示]zI]._KKKEE1 .8E!Va8*FIZ] Fv$ڭUyK8;Rs6dA $gStUZªaUUQML4KM(q Z (i!M\H$4_P]auMUSUHSSU4CKK0KL%I^I|ZUa000L&` `j APPL8MBŠmIA1  ҈00ZaL*L&0p 瀩^"""""""""."  !^qI4qJ$K :Vz V"6ڎZWYTȝGdބd8 i;+A2VĜ!kx ‚e-dʶW3Wth 0h:9BqP]0]4J);FCiBkկB i WVIZl|1h}qQq֪ɲ]%i%!__mA<9pC?0Gh) $$G j#Qqn$EՔt":210dOO'SDPPUM *aˊ>(Mf0P`a- 0@D9"x"l "0Lh  h2ްcCؙ9gt_88/D.' N]I 8jDc8l iQ7{L`N ¯` E3&  ,\A҂[>0ȹE82.Rm a@ 4P A; h y = z8Pca9'I[k]?]u]t/_]=t*>®__F[I}_oۯknt&o/u⭮mvxk˯_AWv_vEa _خ=w.2?d i_$w$ ߿A 7ôN N?k_݊K uKK^ 7ׄ/$mK_KnAC+^aS^oukZ_UzY ?/k[]{Usooifח1_k^]m׽Kv‘m&iYzͥorꨐկwO%qm->"Kب~״#{ *m]V"߯=NYx` P @ؠM4SNᄖ (ilV^KuW^[K ka X WMm/m-;-ӼæM+IH0"A A j*(< lP `@%AQӾlik 55[Xi- I=i! !a2OȳyPa?L*0 l0MB R$դiDt0@hx 0b td q!EE2 `h a ☠@H!5H8)`" )p0E9aOL*hLؤL*M{#[ M, iPuJ^a&4k"#":0a`Bf` ΦPFʚexRn00SD4hU:LC+""""""K֘KIW %Rld $ ia(i,J¨)h( ba&1484|G@I-GɲҬ1~M3c%y؄K>[B쒴22VdYd6lPP3! x&fQ-LaqAT(P K?.^$ @FwYHI;#Z{ WЃMN!C60"6GQr@τ0xِq9^t3As4ka3Z]T"UN0ptN:hOUL*aaSMx]t vti  A D[`0 cBq&A(D.A.lgA 1O6(DJ|AjD y7\1:I9 6W 4^4uNe.4N:&D݆iTOh4 & iTaL&~0P 5Sb~ 6patm'Aa ٙzxKqrkXvaa!haAp8'HMə$rC\Q7i2 Mڨ44'C/D0dTLwKzwuBMt): Pܸ#Oio|gI{t;:N;ۦA;A|ðAgruD>__u]?'&oJoy6+w6n AtpaqM&s"Ҿkxo^ߦJ./miu}?M!/|v?USzVww`IDk=_nxm.=?X~ #,FZuLX> ຯWT{IW׸D=_ki8+w[ j\N9Al&^_ߠ~?wKKTDZGaևև7,$K'}am/CXoC}.]z]W߮s _ !dld4 u ^߯{R_e޽}Hߐ~"߶\o߇{߯oc^[v?mn/ vկ u+~v݄+Jw߅#צ{ cm|^ K hW}{گmwK[Io8҉a-`6+>;KJj¯iꮶWc0vcoͯm&¤m06[[-6aA6B: 50A|aA46MᄡGVtZ=[JՍӏ>ؤ{ 0"|P AAh4u6 0m4A@Ȱ8 ݮҶKV7UiE}RSKZL4 -0B" #g0Dfa58>aGjZI Zi6Du@X mTU!5t8@ӂh7h aLTT`VA """"""""""""" &~L 0fM4c L*jLp­aS^…[ACAL%N4DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDh['\D0M0&aO{(x` a ܃ Md2 7 alDDDGDDDD\DDGI% xW P@#S#n-=6l[E15=I>n4://ihghHh4^8}'mSD'Jv̺X$Mii> Ni0TݠD.DT¯駦P+IjM#ME&| ZA4f)A?I xjA˾xA;i:N }OnUVM׵7mRoxOiS`nGj'I_?Fzn?]k^_zOBm~Mtk=Hx_QvUyi͵ֿ9/o6>`^ߥ?;Gt#Kiw_a_)`?_Dm/|B?o_WTWXJ-?rl6oz֌$?_nH_+ߺ ['DoWٍ?# HG Y#%[AA~oz{~t7_ ?}տGC%K{Kx[o~ӿz6w_k_iӭ߽}ZmJ c/mW}JnoiowiiZU _0a'1-a[ tk/wa_ZVuI~H  aahqIIrw %QJbJ>>}կU޶T0KIX0W ]ڗ M4-a h A SA6bMl%Uum4Ն iV=X==v nulUCV@;Jb.@3el3 lStʀ“l)~qi0¦I@05@pA4 @@!P ` T°ӱnQ 6""""""""""""""'3*h \[AL/ ml/mSKiNa 0dG[Q@ S":0A"8LU4QDDDDDJ3 !$ 0 3  &28&An00#r)"""""""""*""""""#YKuӥ]:8ܢ?tL [N„ɘuy(˪ t vRaP`T)Xge1\fdڑu0ڨTApP)S 'vKѮ6w;Kek2WwwEi* 88DtwA ؝k_hUvOlrHgbݷ;޿^:=Y%~ BxAh36gQxd1CY舒]}*^0PA= af0B0"C" (B$\"ЊA A y636FdCt6ȁFu<4as٬%6IFtFkǪjD:u馘M AA xa4@A(A 0h\0AAƁ % > *͑')h9qD`HSa!D nSO{.v7 I~ZӫmX287r-ZNf) 8{qiA7EI;E-:NA;;'{o_JIֺ~vոM$pWodN B NT:M"հa[]WګU?_o鶟/ou]y( a?_ZU7_ZTu?]v*o}^6 N+_?WGM{a_X5vX|h߿-w}w\Wc$<+a1__aۿ~o_,G6 |# {0]݆ yuGݠ_6:wDJ>Dam*8|HKa-/ מdf$xK_d%^i/l7﾿ئ>߿GڳӠdھ;#Ӥ_.ҍ'ҳ٘%ς%i=Iސ԰:Oك`ȗ73߰]]7~'{JU˧ŧl7o Zwm] __0_y}d?adA~A-oW]{ w[_3ՆKHd?쑶?G~ik_zMuߥ}H^}ro/WOԺ놓kk}koդi}{M@6+!z[ukGmUXkw{M5_[O/׿_8b+vҴtj0CҽInJ׵c—I<}kf6xk^_޾6.ڰ;Ph0dGLP b0b 8)4kI8kiU]W҉Mk6*᧥a=Xbڱi^klv_ _iڂװ Ui0ba#0A*0hmEE 6) M1m[m1w Xpx04b?b8ӈ0BHR+!Mɟ0͓ð4 injڨVla  ih`h )A0 U 0AAqDDDDDDDDDDDԈFԜTdß*h0 n0%SńȰ_MK -wA; l8 km'm4&L&j"""""""""""""*Cb"""% 0@hLB *i (hڄ!! &a4IDDDDDDDTDDDDDDDDDDDIKK„zJ&$X PCCMDX(qʟMQ["A0g=3HBh]YaLͦW vFB7B  4 0xý"yAH:/2}L/K]]'T'j$4j,&qa0GtF_I>mȶwl BH>Nk6::}{SOai=SnJ?I; IմXc_];M.9պ[II[Һտ^ _zot"<~qzVG봯_۾0_9i/(~ֿ_z}~#XDY-)uB ,_wh_߯a߾#B`ֺ୥,K^]zK݆ K}~7;/MKA^?o'{Km~FK5T$~j +}~n7~_W_r2u%~C~!W~CLUנ__ߪt]7}mV>cҍw\tp$wg_V_/-./޽zb.+dWaK&ַյVܘҥK}~KF@IB 0V;V)#61Vn='iZM ~i}S4׺od ! 4UӸOJ'LWUu 1IJ$¶|WW;k_k{ $kK4L&B C ))0v A pa*M5a$0 ZL-hTa/ba`Vu md.&0s": 4˭ MS)Ta4` ؠ@@ڊ((:SA@h iiZwbM/L6KV:i0B"",`L&WW~@ ) Aal)qv C Oj0A:04@@h0AG[@ ئȎ"""""""""""шa`J"evn &h חvhATA7OP0 )݆[ Ftb"""#KzI%K_a ZEy*E`[ !B0-@PXL(`cE-pVW dKr`)O;H!y t ap~: djA6[6PX|qs) _믯KAh(q:/0ADC. ̉BD"1G:a2%}"pU5M+ Nu00i0a&4C38H!pqDd BsA)BZI  &'NiMIs9Dh]p=<$MӠnOn 84 ⾚鿾鿧KInmŧodoW/k_^UJuOzU꽿ޟ5߷߭_+:nUqT?l>H~Xr0:_no! /X>O__U,Gh/޾m/a_ _kKÆߠt_ M_C$C__Uv߯L9owHorE_]n7ccZj6S{WU}F]v/i5k4ڵ{w &iZ[uKf= { `a,4ֿIxa-3:lRwmaGqVVTT{Q^ڷ]]-hb"B 5E jB:: INDa&XiRM+ $i & 06 M A5@@b`) +2@? `TL'pº .VQHDDDDDDDDDr7eW #E.+0K Z`D 6@D MG QWf$, endstream endobj 26 0 obj << /Length 2990 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im27 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F28 10.33 Tf 505.20 707.52 TD (PUBLIC) Tj /F28 12.63 Tf -285.12 -42.48 TD (UNITED STATES OF AMERICA) Tj /F28 12.81 Tf -30.72 -14.16 TD (BEFORE ) Tj /F29 14.67 Tf 52.32 0.00 TD (FEDERA TRAE ) Tj /F28 12.62 Tf 105.60 -.48 TD (COMMISSION) Tj /F29 7.31 Tf -272.88 -60.48 TD (il the ) Tj /F29 8.53 Tf 30.72 0.00 TD (Matter of) Tj /F29 14.28 Tf -30.96 -28.80 TD (RAUS INCORPORATED) Tj /F28 11.97 Tf 279.12 0.00 TD (Docket No. 9302) Tj /F28 11.76 Tf -245.52 -27.84 TD (a corporation.) Tj /F29 12.84 Tf 47.28 -61.44 TD (COMPLAINT COUNSEL') Tj /F28 12.60 Tf 139.92 -.24 TD (S REPLY BRIEF ON REMEDY) Tj /F28 12.71 Tf -35.28 -42.48 TD (INTRODUCTION) Tj /F30 10.92 Tf -114.48 -42.24 TD (A public interest served by such civil suits is that they effectively pry open) Tj /F28 12.00 Tf 0.72 -14.40 TD (to competition a market that has been closed by defendants) Tj /F30 12.22 Tf 286.08 -.24 TD (\) ilegal) Tj /F28 12.50 Tf -286.32 -13.92 TD (restraints. If this decree ) Tj /F28 12.11 Tf 120.48 -.24 TD (accomplishes less than that) Tj /F28 11.98 Tf 131.28 -.24 TD (, the Government has) Tj /F28 12.06 Tf -251.76 -13.68 TD (won a lawsuit and lost a cause.) Tj /F29 7.87 Tf -.96 -28.32 TD (International Salt Co. v. United States) Tj /F28 5.00 Tf 188.64 -.48 TD (332 ) Tj 23.52 -.24 TD (Us. ) Tj /F28 11.68 Tf 22.80 0.24 TD (392) Tj /F30 10.82 Tf 24.00 -.24 TD (401 \(1947\)) Tj /F28 11.95 Tf -294.00 -42.00 TD (Starting from an incorrect position of law) Tj /F28 12.13 Tf 198.72 -.24 TD (, and relying on false assumptions offact) Tj /F28 12.10 Tf -235.68 -27.84 TD (Rambus has rendered its brief irrelevant. The law provides that) Tj /F30 10.77 Tf 305.52 -.72 TD (, to the extent possible) Tj /F30 10.24 Tf 108.24 0.00 TD (, the) Tj /F28 11.99 Tf -413.52 -28.08 TD (Commission must restore competitive conditions that likely would have prevailed absent) Tj /F28 12.08 Tf -.48 -28.32 TD (Rambus) Tj /F28 12.14 Tf 44.16 0.00 TD (s conduct. The facts overwhelmingly confinn that) Tj /F28 11.96 Tf 241.44 -.48 TD (, absent Rambus) Tj /F30 10.22 Tf 79.92 0.00 TD (' s deception) Tj /F28 11.81 Tf -365.52 -28.08 TD (JEDEC') Tj /F28 11.74 Tf 40.80 0.00 TD (s standards today would be free of Ram bus) Tj /F28 12.17 Tf 210.00 -.24 TD (s patent claims. The unsupported and) Tj /F30 11.55 Tf -251.04 -28.08 TD (uneliable opinions of ) Tj /F29 9.20 Tf 108.48 -.24 TD (Ram bus) Tj /F28 11.95 Tf 43.44 -.24 TD (s experts should be disregarded) Tj /F28 11.93 Tf 150.48 -.24 TD (, but even they demonstrate that) Tj /F28 11.98 Tf -302.64 -27.84 TD (had JEDEC used Rambus technologies) Tj /F28 11.97 Tf 187.68 -.48 TD (, JEDEC members likely would have negotiated) Tj /F28 12.08 Tf -187.68 -27.84 TD (Rambus) Tj /F28 11.86 Tf 43.92 0.00 TD (s royalties effectively down to zero.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000107146 00000 n 0000107205 00000 n 24 7 0000107296 00000 n 0000107460 00000 n 0000138099 00000 n 0000107988 00000 n 0000107607 00000 n 0000107736 00000 n 0000107861 00000 n trailer << /Size 31 /Prev 106820 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 141155 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000189456>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R ] /Count 5 >> endobj 31 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 32 0 R /Contents 33 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 32 0 obj << /XObject << /Im34 34 0 R>> /Font << /F35 35 0 R /F36 36 0 R /F37 37 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 35 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F35 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 36 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F36 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 37 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F37 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 34 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im34 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 40838 >> stream nDJER WvQj?-ґ2Fv2W D2`0Awhd 2|vW jgds;$k G%` wagjD v2 2&VD-  ~Zd;m?XoPI("!0dS|=IxOHuvO']dNuZIZIޝ?Wuh$oWQQJZӽ~%QtC8ѝc3TL~PA 4ABL˄6!'lg|!5 " N \$(HOG nq)Bd 5u[kC u{ uOAxX 8AA B ޕ }K"EV#mRgW!]rK}%$}w o}֕֗uvӬuҷM7 oM֓wKtޯi/kK'k{__WV﫪~xccƖ %"; #uWm[B|6{~mucȵ ۽oyWn_#1m߿xtb޾[jK{:'k u{w{ya~FbSm{>]gwx]/|x}4_;__*o?_9{}_JWzմi6m-/uu}^qWOm/V)x _kXkJ׿nkV<6)4&B´V* =ibKm&+ wK0a'{[a>6jL MvAa4&iIAbca'uiml6v5ž -o{`0WAj0 +MB!!4Ȑd0`@M6)Bh4h0 ؠ8al&Dtr$ " -EY t'˜s9gx@TK &BN+ tᦦ|DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE4}2R`29&0B"""""""5DDDDDDDDDh>}l%ؤAGȜ(0 0ё0;fsN31/ ; 7l&6&4'vV{#oVi~ izȩ?Ԏ_["ڼ;ݦ^]_b^ )dN1^Apj u?ax2dDٔI)Pg}"#24C;@BH̠ H7.AC ʶwñ3 qO fn4Ӑ#RN@d"0`h6`l7DguruzwdKK{ 2-Ht#w޷?5[_nzkuKڵIG_CK]V`W(!3#2#ffyNf3B1!(~j3\m.@wha4, hqhbuA ×`fq$q2AB!rSS!52H##4#l.E9 dr@^D<08hџŢcL:Ƙu 0~UA~1aTX! =AD<0a=D@@BCA&5 Aha;M ﴃi"V؋ctO(";l~'~ݰM"C=]\ ݋TtibzMwMZ_"E+չwX~Gt^IilxDv "VÇ"QtN-.+n;aDȎ}ޝ]]+_z۫-+nҫoY^ ȴȠ WMG;JHt)lz7[E6}}64y^|'My/aXMa:^ȑ~B:}^ۦ[JnZ28_bR]!J7}oa`}Ur,zkȯ_[7޿l?FjEDj#HB{"$T|_1#" ^~"/&Jߎw{F J A3/FK߿W_77__ۿW{4zƿ쇿JWKz֪4l;/o3ojok]cn޵u뿳m6KUoޯ/vuvi_1M[i_OvU]}MWJa.¯olWWڪ~Ltvж44*( ؄A rm&II0_IoXllRv [N֛i^V~EY"k0 ЈL: N1[ B 'IB>46)$ ](&KE4h6""""Eb:*P`&yM20 ,0ziT5&M4H[J ! 6WjakVQfVrTgU&0 s )pWo8j `恄 DD4 a*paDGlO~ZPٙ͢BH&[AD~<&L`0o| jpȘDC c2B]ωAOzU[Ai_߃ o]]Z_㎽K1gh.άڬHws^:I…AƆxDCȀ PBɜ'!3#HLC#Q{5g2DF2#,Q @t{vBhDx P d `QBD #N٤`3dfd1HD?N~P3yL'Y ue:= SvhAsNɏ2f COir?L"CP`iS ,44AЄ&` `! :! A:AAbh&( m PPA6(&hGIt93E~j.umxM&ZOpM6{_+I.͞_#m'/nIҿMޝ(ֽkk麽]zl':OBOOVk14Wk^[mZͥZ m}5m+]X>xDñb+_x ^` Z"c%0~]~o~a}6 RY1Qa_}r#rk7l  ]zznHEW?#_!"CXo~W뽮}ݑ} :OQd?ms{GKoK[tW1Kz~޿{6}i7ڷ_~W_<. ]i6i=5m-o_Z_Ҩا@ئ6+'f?`&no0` %_ /Ul.cl^_ӊj:VLA -m4I_^v][K[-V{kkiz~Ǫ A4@ h0vb`$a RiLKmVJ UPkN88cxᄚ5jզ +jI &v#Ta2+B]h*ji b 0A8c@魠b Ai A 0@ 'bDDDDDDDDe̊.!YSL a 6)yqsan ]aBWTi44‚L4֭ji [A0 qdI(*0L ‚ &~LeڛT ` ՃfPRADDDDDDDDDDR%2VB^-G; T3L "-q5PT"@ɊA1 J= MGb[`OA @𾪨f@A@P@h3"N5DgbD_ SK 9+vErxDa !! dL3"aPÄ`PK Y0Id&0`@%DjApA TDQu߫תI8AOE k4Nm Ɖ[ D/h89_tuIjH&*MM )I:Z'ȵRTmiWr&鹼$wWRO]:4_j5KI%WooI }/޺XUKK^o})ngvCfrSα5o(#KI.R_꾗^ 8;0 "Xhj%"%5%&u%m(_K~{hoDF"_ y> EDh0T!çḾ(/` 6CA㠦#YFQgFo>ʈOPZzi^h@ L0#!G4'uokWVIi/UҮ_t 5Wb4 ߒOZI*^ cW[c]R$^,z,w0I_UJJ%zU%}n)a߱_ 5ׂ 3n|M_%_MtI פ)R^DTtK׶M߯(D$dT z{U?zM/ /NɫV*ץꞿO_qmu$ZZ{ZkK]/i/]K.kKFlrn~"?5_&mr_SԿ}vO|V_:I/^_]w_)V߫iY'KKiZJ~]w裺,_ut~u'm- FKAvZZ0\$kDMsR_I-zNz]f-UBb[ %>iTW w VҰpҶV{J%I M [4"&TapM0P+BDtTT*U[ $6/ . K1A@!0@""ш00AL(AU4b Ul&)bba- ڭ=N"""" U4  da0e AML00 Aa?)v&MA4""5B"""." 15B8!7"""""5I%h~WJH-%t[!GEZI&%  M -6L.5bBeqڌWj- Vۅ=2y2.)/8ћ8: j)A -" wq\g`\vT]`dhd(C r H$j>A 6!dBa3PL'#HA$"#wm_\vf{%6Һ A@<&hB]$*I$A@}N{rDO)z|9C3m\>bɱɱոٞ%?mӯ:ш޿S }ߪKAfhy4#H"GB035š4k+7 *NG.AA 4 ` 2bA9A.lbCA.lqcfDᙙ f)4:"DlB.bk0D8&ffxeB.o9ދ4O(z'}(;lK^u^DxMVOLث 0~!0(L P00TA͊(\M0U0A:t2b/UIqXp輊'tJ/UM3=vMIT¦UP`40AvqSML̾'v{+ONK %pdKDXoI: MRq q4 [82P\/AȰ! UTSLB t  ta6BiqIAULS]P  tLp`DDDDDDD[`\Q*i'M~A_MvjդIIi 10 aa 4:L-IZiADEDDDDDDDDA Š) &T 3EMP xh0 }0P &?&D韓?)ωAL ½"""""""#vK\=v[r^?6UQAU %R2(-5 3 Qd[dRD\d$}|.  …;I;%G &s[Md. gtА\jI,7!݄HBIX0ѭH ÆfMZM2 4emdgi]RH2,2v_4&"eAZ余ibBam~0ѻtҭmvf]6z_d["꯯zM>[ 3B$F63e\mЋy5t6FHlG'fC&0P@σ$. |cIn4^4^UQxEh5TNV5A `xPIP(O &‚ B !(O kakl˴'EqԘ˃"A= L&aҽN K鴛>0OI&Dg-' /bo^qݿoOU]>}ZO_i%==j7OCu`Va7w&\=>cWzꫧZح鵺ZtU_ ^_O]߂K/XP։i\ a/=C[I,N2t ! sD~X?}}{7_rc{z|l$Ko_ Gm=gkڡ"??KF믷kw{}_{mUi#=-b[u{0{K߿Kaz]~H<Eg}u}a_wmx7^]궿t_]_k{}뮗{z -_8j_0JoՆcua[KoJI#Jm/ ]a?`/aU/c@/$}nm/ocK%zUؤI Vv]㍴{ZQVq @ݮ¶=*ҺM[\%j@ & ۑ! b `Ѱj@ AA 2:@ؤM6&VۉkZZ]!CbnK@X`0Kl) ᦰ8K ײ,M4 mE4Ȏ a 0@:DG ( iR>X+a6)E b!%DDDE#DA I@ez &n. igy i{jNja4mA[A6BP!!4ApASjVaiWDDDDDDDDDDDDDDqpavT*ivL0xaO &L LpaAv0Lgʚ g)?z_qDDqqץim}U/_ibKn_"b zR- XaA` *VQa!m,"bS=٩<6=B1†V"W 0LPg[.5-邅3;)2 n; 4STDL7B'8x"2:.P6 PeT,'‚ „N,TwD\H/"0B#C *Xq_psC+2M';@s #"##B B (uƿCڄ˙?i>.މҥNzNEVA|A$w ֓ZT;~8qҥzI%]}~Wu-WIҹ;!fCᚋ!f@*3!XK}Z#U% aAAB p A8P xDL!pA[2&zy euZJSP%OMy TxOp8*x(La0a ij"TE!jBZAX.~/Y|NN/Dp4N D`<-D 0A 5SAN!yDXzSjIpRq]:6 | ނ TL/EEAЫzOM&RuumAih-*LXATh-&h E}r;}{^KK&L,xI%KL%:OZI<a' <0?>7ը?I$.A_V:֩uTߥ;v6K$"l 7uZ@}o].?uOࠤ$jW_J~uZ߽akI*7":tڞ?/붗 ]~uﲏ(G-kViDIV^R00ְ4S \ipմ$k]aB UldZ뾽u^%ҿ;6*))bPi1ڱW4֬%i6jF3NKIWHI?jzK%5Gs2}\a4Ӥi7i %;Ki@NҴa$ah<-6чZH4AvO#N+L& B0AAmEv(@GA: V**BT%m%(TijQJZi0] =nGAUL& N*mBVAB@6 \Ӛ/(4B: vP"T= lTN\DDDDDDD5TI[k ,,mXA Sa(Pb!ᡈ2MAT~@\ GGG 36r;2*pi)K8>A &v0Rf!,kGv̄gi] P&~"D3vPf(#C*HYej id5e-"Dїa D0ۮ;<"$ua0R\3tHg BP d2͆PCBTVҥh2S@A#O(T=Ph--Fl$) zAI<%F}T% *l274dM`&i#QZUӭz §I;kTHhzZ3CAJaЃP4O%nޒKtD})JI'VE^_KKvJڤZU6m8ihE$mӝV i4E>?]tU/Z0/U[I+tj._uK_[RZ$|kki/K|RK^uo~I-QfÂLKSIDd5iCZj*6m#Mv/ .e8 g  h"Y6k*4~ȡOZXD'3H!ڳIAfmRK-R]FtoOpݴ]i>}-J+I*$$(-%Ji^AK֛ ^_jb^R]\W3UoWk]^_WwI-*U^үZ^u.}W?hHzzUuw׷]zޗ~^*_Z^uJվ]*_K#~K_^WU/JZ^J BDO֫/*_ꖾ*KK&ֺI_K/_I/W_kT_۽-tvد]%~ׯRZUUUZG^ץ_zK-kKJ[TaꖮuIkii{ZW* DtZ֕}'^K1U`~ֻiZ?E[_^T+TUނkU륤r]=/1ҥ/+[ZZ1х֥I{UU8⢴R'm}+Jai:(:#䖶Di,4N"t|($[JUiUa.) aQNIXa'JuaIuSkO=[KPMi*t'%IkU^30B !iy2إ$ET5a]Zj 'Ma p]J O`IkQ8㊊*Ш| l&SUUAj}$0bAI⾓P= 0Ҋ@0aUULWLL:,H|DD0 BaB )ov p0uV iX.M@ؠA@3k6!V MBj5"""""""""" 2Ј a KL0% MxaM=s 'Ј""ޒ"" ؚRZ؍b6 iS*tHbTJABM$ 6JCMP )҅jHb!G,YCQAep-́!"9 eb%ȆUcZ D^:v eH .;4geta^( jC"C)) 6 Ed;'d&OWi8M$M"1TIBMAP\(PpXd]=2 vBx'l$ K 4 p\. 𠾤zjI- wA 8A]g}:]6H'2̄P (y9$:F[Mڨ".xvi*[IZҋ]n]k]-}-'_8?_xW]_K֪ _c:Pu_^Ct0!b*[4 &`S“c<2C( h͐!dT3c>Gxec.G((]ec3) "Fjy u3Z6R4mQgF#c<2peqτХJn*jxPg ء L&4 !a ,X(L a{@ ".2 ay$0}L<4<0Q;NJ 4t{' U5TUS Put]SAMBn<'SAS ࠐM®OI:NpNUfRH;;މ΋ZaâyL;hQ;"Ps|ot ~7!БSȏ Rc}ApWKm4LY~!-%^Dn~ax'm I/W}~  "Q$K_DK{׭ -_Ņ$:ծKK{}p/A}KCZ$E4:D?_]s=gl#_Kmw?=e Az֓U*']"HͤCzJ?o]i}VV85PCNOM$izE_W_j_m5kk}\,TN⢫IJ}+ $Vi=0G߭0Y/=K_k %cYnMUUR` zaN E~0 +x@b{Cմ+6 ?bjaPb31X fR&(0A 'aM4(KcI~ծj $IYxT`L&a4O"&PPL)&&L* 08L u 0A `QM2#6 9 :(6B `h` 6B=(0A6"""#B"U!6",`L &l˵0dǵ; -ڗ4Ba׵M}0a-=a뵵״"8eZx ! & AiaT?0ʚ qD 0U[DDiS$Hmo«I0I! N",?aIx7[Q.6$aL@IBdV w>s2Hi*Aِ Q].,_2 AE;!E#s;TEc;N#)fJrMIK3T]]6b&*"(e8e KpP0! Ӥ"FD[m`HEA BM(6@k}D1}za0t 4O %П*x37D|+vWZOi& A%TiIQQ]Kt_epz!;ե t߭REZM:O!upO%ҭGT*K_K{ֽ%JKKF=uDo5# T H I?0/}_--ַ8P>`pN(!B'~,0d6l%f-ִa]u7t{׍sbj0U= mBԫ" gQbC$fn;KIqt>r(dtOgL_{(q"NrN^C5S ( 0A2⦟FԸrLDt;8!|)p@"u3ጋ„(AۯnfzNbD&͉މ$¤Ht;H' /KY`EMhgRuۂ§C.={IwZ[0Pt i:m/DqƉcփt0CD"NuD0h:U>>*MO^R]~?z] 3^~sƩ8AdB6fj KZba'ޖz_nֿJ_I* \$ ׫Za?Ux0at뎗_KRWF[KRIu KuZz[i_/KK't(tפ i_i'/I_o-%>6%_bZWJi$5hP֒Uki,wa|/jZ0uiV^I$_T J7AA%^IZZIVz^$mZ_m]+&oz*!~ z]WI%.KIB Z~w$RO KKҮҭ$ ^Z_t_$b}+"_Ro$oU__Kė/?ޫRwKRI/Koo@K)몯K_}j-kJw_+okQG뵒?It#=*I"W^GKگWy}k/u]EVy+L,IVL-u֒$a"G?KK>յ밡riv]%֫'iRZv_mH-9%oKϾvaCIkm+Ma8Я%/IUu~iiitiJG𝥧kjtxH&pDu#@pA 8 !TlBM~ᄢUi6^!5JJ)-icl$턽&JN!@Xhi]]t6Mv^մI04UHSv6!kQ JJK $I% vJ&iCK E=m Ѕ\DD0OE7 a5.01sa TװO8M+*bZIe8b\TW!a_0qR"""'DDc@14`& v ˜t A505/“U2+No!B!0X0D2p4CDF ,\D\DD086#U^$Pt4p H bLn1J4ړ{[aiVv*̋9ngL)RZFv2A5FQ2*" B (N3"vTvhfJQGL&aI,(P]x@J? -vxm$ WEOSL Sm60x9o_"݅hi6礴;NfCMM4AAH;izB) ";C;(ud[" ~'zݯ뮺}U_4Nh3PfxeD-8$"ZUv !݂jx aB <lgA>)籝33<>ΙGLVAF&dE 0U< ЋAAha0PA(L `L8!0AA:CEPB!C4fP"NdTjE EI!HD(".^ A!˲0ȇ. l)E8|9h=Q8oiI4;pSM aM+O.(LD U: 4*  0;:0&6*i}&3>w?8A_cIn-Qyb8}4N2DvyD]Z 0W UO4*HB$UoMRKK>lioIޕd\i7)MfMnqI}EiƉ0d QMXaIA a0Ml SB h0L&gUqHDDDDDGHN1KO&*[KTL= -ɮ*M a. $dl:B5Qkh6`$N QZD?@geH;uCLfv4+2* &O0!; Dš3#4vZ0!Q]H;[v CB>^4y٨R&;PD ]x(AN$JeIganLwE݋#6/Կ'3494i&aIHv]o_}!"Ft'_s, auwԷZN͐)3!# Dd@Vk`S!"sa=Hӑfky /5_w0R„TU0T *߿/ EIYbw_v wI7_/LJX>K/J` kKDEm7/T$]ORݪ Xo/ׯ ?Al?J_ק*$y#~`C]7х-_lo~H ڮ_/%ikՑo~oF~8{i{kkݯWT{uj:‘K]V_ C 7~_u%Aߥ}vu4Ҵ؎6 A)C}vh?M߯awմKͫC : B=Nnq-M_M=cl$V~N i1][i]]-}j 5 mSL4ѨTNMSaiD5c`I5.8{IvaҰL)7 NO`* 4&kj0 " a4dH WU m1Ad#GPpA lTTz T{!E ` m!*)38"8㈈D3:_BA44*Vk[Na0MVD5tNj=P j'qfAjL&T+*pa0Oɟ) &AMD" #0)""""""""""?R]&/|O0@60,k5""""#R喼˨SF #PdRe\A8)@[a [2;"2(2̴3>`MAAB[MB h㪂࿂!VT`dE[Zn)OI!2>4EuU_UkֿUWY-օ$F٠ћ#:Q }H|3>H#O$~T-4wUU CBi(M5 fD |)!D`$ .'I Bd|H5ENts$4+~0upª'd+Ä 6Q8O.,hXP854BiCP(@`A.la]!.AvH R62`:(0gxلA&E(f9vH2& : Cf<اCD)MƓN/`ɗ&qi82a+xT'wT (tiI**`0 ੄„L4 &<5< a0& h4A apdQn li82.=y3ԡH8An4_4_h3 DM4N'%JhM$=USOL*aT'ICM(aBjhTN!ÄBt:^/O]`o'?I&ȁNA Cb$=&2 4vlC!6 -&O  pAt[>0~8z]~ia?OM{^N7 Wᥭп8׮zt鮛קսun!_ ɄWKk~: S/྿`;Rc/Ic?c+$m_"o^hG:ׂ,?"p_'eA~ D "q _w`__#O.i__D߭߄H~W?K _- /i~CG}>A~7^I/~0^/m{}FzXu$?)/CK_/,/IG_ﮫmo޿.w_wd_IS_1%1]auL-턯Kmz_Kw/56+6?Cw!;ۯ[^K6.˫au6aaڽېӥOVV=xQT|{a i_[iM{Nnk-—W5!K{_ҽ$ Aa0@iȐ": `6\6B:@i0:c؅jK[aثV"b;_^ڴV_iGKH#[J*5@8ӣ][L&Pkph4h6 AM40@ lP uAG i PH6*)Ӵ+N& ݦ0 B=")XDD4tك=&ia cڒӆdn Ҩa_JL m5 S0ڊj@*h0$ "B i4M0 &ȃ&Ј2L&~LPEAMyod&:'h0P 00aBF _:S̏ XD9ϡA&t0D%UIүJ%I}~[` 0$A BBDla^k!B(dfb"IzBPMÅM}&@wM<4iiX! %L F=0 Y:_M (L-O/}ޯ}-uJ*J-/KIU.K]t]x&I] ^?1Ǫƺⴞ*UkKJUޕ$z&׍Cx^Xe@.մSүQTUvI5K]%I*T [tUFrs1U$?[jKim^+تU:[izCUuO"O"OчiCU֯_JK%URZ uZmK A[uk$V [%~ҧ_7+齿oU֒mZx%_JR>ӯu/Gѷn@֪./-*ªdz尭-LʰǤ3?S_&꺮ܮ_Qշg֖ųՑ'տ<*#Ҫimk~^_Jj}z-/}*tZu_ َ/َK1jj{yHIpuFZZ]}K^QSI4+]*WP m=X_b)Mu+keR=UA<*ߥUZikZZEHF:K_z^^״ҭ7KIu3δK13MV %lqME/QkkگZ0TWI-WZ^-tJ *t+%.M26Tk` &T"M4L 'AB6BZҊK▖-kX hTTRiC EZIJXI&KBa+J%Ji-W (-hTTa0 6mxTAZ&.0KJ*IU &*aaIEm 0UL Il%\iLADDDDDDDDA&LR49ǰki iih1 *btA!QUMT*TW **!m1LWC5$B5L B04¡eOaBgp 'i (T0T„XATNT-"8TDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDG`q""$(. b#J-*A$i%R"F 4XZ+ZKIRMUq `b#-/oW(Vd`ʞcns(e8!SP"A*r%NyYd$K~;l &TFEc&LЪ AiH( B l`Na5;gb?vSA0""M_AAl( …IT4)A 򋷆ZABVEDiAMVj;@(^+FDZMrI=ݴ- Mn..d*ekhfhd*pi,Ӥ6OONk T~~j=tOǯWIut>/^U_w%ћ'MtG:U®%btj  acl#f)SR(D8A:d\"5B0=D>սuf5:|{x.&LssZ1¿/_W1a~I_J|DW_`6޵&0?l~iij{ƿo_KKzY TZ_}__ 6 w-.G0o\%9Gd$}_> _<7KGH'W_HYz^ԼZ"?թ? -%I%[KN^Ҿ.VJڶIa HUE}^C$=y_k7ki_koI$$I^JI6ho^_]{iiZ[kki7_}K׆AIq a^ZVZݭTJئ $j~c0V[ W?c0Ic1qPAh!Kҹ(؅ˊa°M~NVQi+WKTWqQćPҏN#cئMkjե_ABuZ1 0~0Q@ Dt `@i:4V!GGj)MI[M5%FUEAFA.U! IaA E&ADpA0N ްB:0ibB `RA jA*DDDEDGDEtl&W`0 5 Ұ0 &Mxh0_ a0N@ x""""""#0B"""""""""#ƓkMIK-HaH$0AY""?dGE5NYL&e݄i@,vK "aP0DDȅl`vJFy2.UpPP*zS0uA!]ķ)NHMoꋆXA P`5zbe'}7t#_<_^rFMB;1e^A/ ?[ }vj 8zh¦;qLPt g4@AB`4 '@s,XB &!i BB] tNhs8ȚfA /NpbkŤwl4Mtš g a*pwA[A15L<&g  yqTa Co?OM s84WN'͛AE6LƂxN||D2L㗌3As/(l:'mSO蝹vM >AhptI2@ZVڮ+aZZMr; /w#`uet'E$# pzH6-?NrMkƂ H6wt*囹mkwKިU+ $W']/~}鴜a085|_oI&? j׺\^z}?jW~+m4:WNz_E T?zV֙#OWM{I]{kyb?WZ}jcbMo_ _w%LMa +; _zb;pazuoZ_z_n{0xA0anCT{А+ׯ]} Ku~ClY#KޚNkuqMGk0ӯt$W?K$VQ_"ܗVD*zWsun=҆~o/0_}/Z~Io[__+K0J_bU t0lƻ %uvi^^6]{~^6Jﵨ*j6AVktj/6LVv^* c1jawi7KMͯ6VY &#?4p0AAA  llu $E_O4 l4m$ؤ>;Vobb>bVa66[ 0ZH0vjiZL4&! @ mU6AInq34a%V+vJbKqÃj<0a&ҊKX0e ! 2eQL)ɒA&8^aUZnȃ &h: )jSfQLt tLP 86M1A5[ n"8""" &W# –<0­0jUl ժpM+Wa-DpL)h  qB"HEtBDd 040ɝ8P@#^&``""#Z\`0+0A?/AR,,bL-j?@Tn `G#{ 4 01RdGb$Q&'_2V);%w v C#B[dU+FZ }XOP 9C$("iP $` Lb%.d 2A0AhDX; A A0@ mBN 2^֌Q'i4$CL IA6:V m ܟA&@>iDa$ORMTI  i*M&A.\I'l AAZSI.MINOZ[о6Qִ[-$]uRU]:W]RT]qK]*n$35-.=RJm$%N0L'D/8fld3ўz'Ι!l  '[ҢKҾW(8GP͌ aM"ιHv @a\EXRaS3b0* &|S &2$H=v*iUB3B xTg `AbDAp[pE UH*j7XPT'WyqRK#_փ j¦)K =US^:-gAAPM9NǦDCI({TCDDŽMLg/qm-%K֒m}iZ3E'Ѣў:3&k #ƚr-]&&aIdx%:Tb%}VTIi2c=?e HD xAa=WI$/}$(i/JUTL(I}/Ү.{mm^׵uIRꛪJzJ1+Kҽ/Po>_ +TZV%UIzTwlL0Tg{߫ lJXֵ *]WIKIؠÇÖBUIUUW_MkFll~zҫW-KTRտߴom]F޿Hzu[KI.'IaoUWU]up&uUZOu__i-/үURz߭߬䅪+^UV -ȍ/m~ȏao_ =hNqu^(j.V"F]۫I"i~cU/W7]Vc\jL//k^I}Uuפ__JV>+*U}T*ZiW_F=i4Rm+H'u~KOmTѫ}I_u7IQQƩ6a%V**.,R %ҡTh֒+;tISm$>A-'Wt 7_}*MB$]U-ULBU)iXl0[/m$Ji64A6mKk va01 T Uu UU]H 28خ|=Xa() 1MaLPMAa %hB" !a40iC840jjR 1MzlSIxb l fb4*؄A 0uA@*"""""""""""""""!  ` 35/-SNA_A'{6seԸ1,xa{Tq paH{+i7I.Ma$6ni7 PMYJ$Ҿ((հ0ڔ峦;I̱ӪB@Β'}vfD47㷺ѳ<#?_TwJΆk yBU DF:"!*@(@Ph0(A"YفB#ЊA:d4r3#ԔyBU %Y:q~U p0P $L 03Aaj  P9xKB7b䁐™qH!h,HDmG d1E%c:$QdyȠ=S$Gb6f&D4_Q<`vxE5M UM7LPaT`0 (*L!TsMCw AB `0@ sBhNa&0L38NIM"*Si6 Mz&5A|2g/'e-//(v;h'M$<*$:i0J)I»a~ $;M?M= *oiպ鶜][a6&Ӄ#x2-doIl)6j:A Om&txA80H8Nhp2tZ7/Ţv݂E( d-ƪE [WOO_U-= =i=?ӥOOZM`N#zMO^K2.{#oGj/A$r<0b{m֫z鮾'akj>ﾓХrEv鴟y,I7'uI&[n5Wƞct;I{u뮿_I_x_mU=Z]ov:_dsO. odvoOw^6_ԱAuЬ<co#;#Z?iRXr?_c C߽uBO!}$u.X:`庖_Cx"Ov?!ලx"Cko_5 a/o ?Ւ?nmo71/]u#Y!zCx솿!} F_KҺ{[ջTS|_Gm+_l+߯i=}~kZkJ$K1^SWW߭/i}zOiZw[ow_׿8Zv ~.ua+ f;m-B)X_k[ %J~^ʈO_KOl0{ $0L8?ڻbKب`{`z[l[j %~0Z}aA -6~ ] T6(0@ qMP ` I6)騥aM4UK6ե~@cX6 ?0XBӽ?k#י0L,00aaAzl$NALu! U1 APad(j7N)6JiE5p`IGi8+0B"""""""",3KtL 0i L(A=! :i aj!5u0@ ؠA d#AӠ Dt0AA8""""""""&Dez 0L:>"ra SA;aPaJ  - 0j -iZ4AeLk_}?Uӵ<[(qXh 2x4t]dNB*W]T& pCCˈ0D6U Stiun[dp ƚE7΢%i6 noyN-'҃jywҢ iQ0}%ՊIO^O p_KIO*{KƺA8:3.7K,Pjah`4&m0?a{׏C.O]}_]%ҪK!%Z3FU3toߏuZWkz]RIzxZZ_I*Z %X.ʭ/NXOaTt=_4+D4PQZk/9N@{ މ~Ui}}i*UEUUh}zu'l/gxD߰"OdU^JK*UTZZ*vil_^_=zu\0X ZZU__ꩽY~uA/^\I]%]**uPI._Kմ$D?ޓH^}iW[Rc\z]RUִ)i>)אK꾒Ұ՟*몪ձ֯JK֛%ⷡkꫥZ&3ճm/ۯoo֒ںҴ%IՕuܴܳ<* /aWiZWVmuZJu[>Uukk#&1m)ڰ_aK z鴛Z_W0/cJ$ߘ장 0K*0&Ү*/^qI %5a,iXW]XJwGMҪmR]WZ^/RzkZVE ZAh0@ݐ S& +V$$Z_a cl#Z[Fi**JƖVTV :IҪCV5L*MCMBh , A 4 $0A 0A0Kh0a%WWm) bEC␮*-EE,T +Ij2&qE4 0Lń׆+NM8Q& (0A"B 5KUUl0JALB^C`X d;!!lV`DI*hrn RA-a0aBPb…<*kjb4H""""""""$H:]$ S%U^$BbjTEF#0(¦`ho- oZKr+!Ld$A$. (L2:iX iZD; P<(AC 2<)SBԸhTMڦݡ="QY8i-(]-)Tm>mwVa'TA:NO]үM/Tg|uH '?ikeKJT ~yk pU[$MݠIO^:^0% ՠүMwÿuýKu4EFo_mCzD˵AӺ:K_փjJH/D5?F%I%_AKdJ_A^}4aa(a-KTJeP]XMNMa$dAڅ6! : LSyi & h dƂypa{a5\DDDDDlDD0D( `wDE!KյG[\SD@ޞ/KUJRHRZXK #0b)>?f)hTCXdgT)UUX endstream endobj 33 0 obj << /Length 5610 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im34 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F35 12.70 Tf 111.60 679.68 TD (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission) Tj /F35 12.40 Tf 339.60 -.24 TD (s Remedial) Tj /F35 12.39 Tf -339.36 -13.92 TD (Powers) Tj /F35 12.79 Tf 35.76 -28.56 TD (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict) Tj /F35 12.64 Tf -.24 -14.40 TD (Royalties To Restore Competition) Tj /F35 12.07 Tf -36.00 -28.08 TD (Well-settled precedent confinns the Commission) Tj /F35 11.93 Tf 239.52 -.48 TD (s authority to ") Tj /F36 7.43 Tf 71.04 0.00 TD (cure the il effects of the) Tj /F36 5.00 Tf -347.04 -27.84 TD (ilegal conduct." ) Tj 86.40 -.24 TD (United States ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 66.00 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F37 10.86 Tf 12.48 -.24 TD (u.s. Gypsum Co.) Tj /F35 11.64 Tf 88.32 0.00 TD (340 U.) Tj /F37 10.17 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (S. 76) Tj /F35 11.99 Tf 24.48 0.24 TD (, 88 \(1950\); Complaint) Tj /F35 11.77 Tf -310.32 -28.08 TD (Counsel') Tj /F35 11.85 Tf 43.68 0.24 TD (s Brief \(") Tj /F35 11.95 Tf 44.16 -.24 TD (CCB") Tj /F35 11.53 Tf 29.04 0.00 TD (\) 3-) Tj /F35 12.62 Tf 16.80 0.00 TD (4. Rambus) Tj /F35 12.01 Tf 58.56 0.00 TD (s contention that the Commission) Tj /F35 11.87 Tf 165.12 -.24 TD (s power is limited to) Tj /F35 11.99 Tf -357.60 -27.84 TD (ordering a respondent to reftain from repeating unlawful conduct) Tj /F37 10.58 Tf 312.24 -.48 TD (, Respondent') Tj /F35 12.72 Tf 66.72 0.00 TD (s Brief\(") Tj /F35 12.12 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (RB") Tj /F35 11.53 Tf 21.12 0.00 TD (\) 4-) Tj /F36 5.00 Tf -437.76 -27.84 TD (, flies in the face of relevant precedent. ) Tj /F35 11.28 Tf 192.00 -.48 TD (See, e.) Tj /F37 10.73 Tf 39.84 0.00 TD (, Ekco Prods. Co.) Tj /F37 10.32 Tf 91.20 0.00 TD (65 F.) Tj /F36 8.86 Tf 35.04 0.00 TD (C. 1163) Tj /F35 11.52 Tf 38.40 0.24 TD (, 1216) Tj /F35 11.93 Tf -402.72 -30.48 TD (\(1964\), aff') Tj /F36 5.00 Tf 54.96 2.40 TD (d sub nom. Ecko Prods. Co. ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 136.32 -.48 TD (v. ) Tj /F35 12.69 Tf 11.04 0.24 TD (FTC) Tj /F37 10.41 Tf 29.04 -.24 TD (347 F.) Tj /F36 5.00 Tf 30.24 0.00 TD (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\); ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 113.76 0.00 TD (FTC ) Tj 25.68 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F35 12.27 Tf 10.80 -.24 TD (National) Tj /F35 12.73 Tf -412.80 -27.84 TD (Lead) Tj /F35 11.64 Tf 31.20 0.00 TD (352 U.) Tj 32.88 -.24 TD (S. 419) Tj /F35 11.98 Tf 30.48 0.24 TD (, 430 \(1957\) \(Commission must assure that a violator ) Tj /F37 15.21 Tf 258.24 -.48 TD (wil ") Tj /F35 11.93 Tf 27.36 0.24 TD (relinquish the) Tj /F36 7.48 Tf -379.44 -28.08 TD (frits of his violation.) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 109.44 396.00 TD (\); ) Tj /F36 5.00 Tf 9.84 -396.24 TD (see also New York ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 91.92 -.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F35 11.99 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (Microsoft Corp.) Tj /F37 10.50 Tf 84.00 0.00 TD (224 F.) Tj /F35 11.55 Tf 30.96 -.24 TD (Supp.) Tj /F35 11.84 Tf 27.60 0.24 TD (2d 76) Tj /F37 10.70 Tf 27.60 0.00 TD (, 148 \(D.) Tj /F35 12.13 Tf -392.40 -28.08 TD (2002\) \(") Tj /F35 11.95 Tf 40.80 0.00 TD (equitable relief beyond a mere injunction against repetition ) Tj /F35 12.78 Tf 285.36 -.48 TD (ofthe act is ) Tj /F35 11.81 Tf 59.28 0.00 TD (generally) Tj /F37 11.21 Tf -385.44 -28.08 TD (appropriate. \(quoting Areeda & ) Tj /F35 11.93 Tf 156.48 -.24 TD (HovenkampJ . . . \(TJhe ) Tj /F37 11.81 Tf 114.00 -.24 TD (Cour finds ) Tj /F36 8.40 Tf 57.12 0.00 TD (unpersuasive Microsoft') Tj /F35 14.85 Tf -327.84 -27.84 TD (arguent ) Tj /F35 12.00 Tf 48.24 0.00 TD (that Plaintiffs are entitled to no more than a simple proscription against the) Tj /F35 11.68 Tf 362.64 -.48 TD (conduct) Tj /F35 12.04 Tf -411.12 -27.84 TD (found to violate the ) Tj /F36 7.86 Tf 96.96 -.24 TD (antitrst laws.) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 72.00 510.00 TD (\), ) Tj /F35 11.81 Tf 10.08 -510.00 TD (aff') Tj /F36 5.00 Tf 16.80 -.24 TD (d sub nom Massachusetts ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 125.52 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F36 8.59 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Microsoft Corp.) Tj /F35 11.68 Tf 84.96 0.00 TD (373 F.3d) Tj /F35 11.40 Tf -416.16 -27.84 TD (1199) Tj /F37 10.82 Tf 23.52 0.00 TD (, 1232 \(D.) Tj /F35 12.09 Tf 48.72 -.24 TD (C. Cir. 2004\). Applicable precedent requires that the Commission restore) Tj /F35 12.00 Tf -73.20 -28.32 TD (competition and deprive the wrongdoer of the ) Tj /F36 7.14 Tf 222.96 -.24 TD (frits of its ) Tj /F37 11.10 Tf 55.68 -.24 TD (anti competitive conduct. ) Tj /F35 11.67 Tf 125.28 0.00 TD (CCB 3-) Tj /F35 11.91 Tf -332.16 -84.00 TD (See also Orkin Exterminating Co.) Tj /F37 9.99 Tf 169.68 -.24 TD (108 F.) Tj /F35 11.61 Tf 39.84 -.24 TD (C. 263) Tj /F35 11.98 Tf 32.40 0.24 TD (, 368 \(1986\) \(Commission) Tj /F35 11.99 Tf -313.92 -13.92 TD (Section 5 consumer protection cease and desist order ") Tj /F36 6.76 Tf 262.08 -.24 TD (resu1t\( edJ in a roll ) Tj /F37 11.73 Tf 89.28 -.24 TD (back. . . of ) Tj /F35 13.39 Tf 57.36 0.24 TD (the anual) Tj /F35 12.01 Tf -409.44 -13.92 TD (renewal fees on all of Orkin) Tj /F35 11.63 Tf 136.80 -.24 TD (s pre-) Tj /F37 10.50 Tf 27.60 0.00 TD (1975 contracts.) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 77.76 679.68 TD (\), ) Tj /F35 11.64 Tf 9.84 -679.68 TD (aff') Tj /F36 5.00 Tf 22.32 -.24 TD (, Orkin Exterminating Co. ) Tj /F35 5.00 Tf 129.84 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F36 9.45 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (FTC, 849) Tj /F37 10.43 Tf -405.36 -13.68 TD (2d 1354 \(11 ) Tj /F35 11.13 Tf 58.56 4.80 TD (th Cir. 1988\).) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000141482 00000 n 0000141541 00000 n 31 7 0000141639 00000 n 0000141803 00000 n 0000183502 00000 n 0000142331 00000 n 0000141950 00000 n 0000142079 00000 n 0000142204 00000 n trailer << /Size 38 /Prev 141155 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 189178 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000239534>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R ] /Count 6 >> endobj 38 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 39 0 R /Contents 40 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 39 0 obj << /XObject << /Im41 41 0 R>> /Font << /F42 42 0 R /F43 43 0 R /F44 44 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 42 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F42 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 43 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F43 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 44 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F44 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 41 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im41 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 44260 >> stream M61ǔɥ(onU?-xXS`?X6_ɨh2wXzDtMO cfd ljB*o E2#$ޢT36z0dk7X0̍@pa4-4AFN.8,&I&6D,3IB8V(j\D 蛷o 0@;+% P" a:[߷w ׮ /KֻV'ᅫK߆ W_C);6f##yAdRFO=V8 XC 300AD1p@byžl3!AG 3ϢF2$P_4GVsԊcR^!c$zDM)uvפm&h=wa=h0U8} ` AB̄$hC.ȩ56\"% 4`"` D1c}hZ ˃ \'ENI8}pMu4ML M47}_ &nzxN}nB ?Ƕ Kx6 $gl[M{&J8bkN'wG}ƻH h8+M=7A-o}Nȑ]dG^AڷW2,29owdt [/GD~ 0꿾+n [k/!+W;i|'KWzKi/ȗ]Lqïo޵!i^߄odHKuOD?"9 Oz߷_D*o"=wAh]mk/ #}/uJ _ۻ_~~!dGq߈]]ӄM1Ʈ:_k^oo~o]WoM?ucz^KKi?K_خ_mRKݳM_}7޿7W}K޴}~o_Kkn +[iG0i_^iy[vw{mЅޓIXbAki.IN5?m꿺 / uc$ L',qRpTȑ 4m! 6m+Oa~)X⟶)=[*LR~CEi]ZwM4 jpB"8a6D{A b  =IM'Rj)rӆbL ΀4Aȑ;N""""0`E@F* &n%p’rBm]i ia4Mm8@l*dWiBAi $4څ,0DDDDDDDDDDDDDDG"AS@ ) 6f1ʸaT)gy?W4܁yg2``DPCOHaQr}-:-MQdzi0 T0 "?-L1HC@-!ɞ0I}}'6I;h30Aٰ:m% }P:&܄AVScj&^{_}j_kkw4հa'Iv!1P $-\" 5- 0"0DDDDDG;K吭GYT)334 ;ԎdY'vY5 fӼ BiR[B;S3,vd\Ƀ!„ (TT K2+  p05H893!3C ;@d}oָ9佃ű2sDxh޾W{]uq-j-u_{ΙN—A!!'63(fxe ("f AvFCS3duu"0 FAE)B_ k_>(L&xPL50(L200 4@SC6*"X&$3Fly!p2.d Afy3IGGB/D1Fu#8aN,2= ɑ]ԌyA<Eԋd\""zyRuEjj' UM88I4N/ AH'G8*(L м!Ba`0P00S a熆pi`{i>l3Cg=bhdnh hhh4ppuk34N޸Od D ?AL&t$48ANSPT;`A'vE8U *`N; &[M_#Ɠ'3Ioe<+A<$_O_ Ɯ[Ex}BOOA 6'NTt56~jj:M`TO;xJKM\'E\8R,wII&#N >(tkW3=ϞGt}_U׊~ON'_ ZNo/WmkzISWۧ}__ aWG_h^O]8iƻl6} }-A,1ZCCW}#l_bXkLr,)1vu߭_Zm?lO#%0?]ma^!D7޷῿/ aoa>^#P-]}w/Kou}_>}Z#`H._u{7[~6>="0KujW_kV]o{~I_K}_/ +K{/ެ-a.V¶1 jޭ[ ~z_n 0[Xi' -m~D-C+bnX+1t1݅/6X05aZ>Kݭ` .טKd. 6`@ ⢂ 1H4HGm[LjݤSMUwp>[MlSiG;#ba5Rmai@6 nMmP hP m4 `&i4a (a&=Zn2tz)7VKX!02eMJA2?&~Ft&~@g?e0POJ5ᅴԼ]i)0A 6Dp ؄TSAQTaA `  6Mm ttADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDq(ńu@FC@i0 a54›0% )n /a5ɏ EL aPRǙaaDDDDDDDDDG!ʚ"#0Y?B UQhdk ̑"T„BO ePȑۢ@\ /;0SWq2/qgcaB~\.2骅0A9v`GekPUM^az$1'1$rT AAQ?`*'*op؎Jx;/,3M}]TֿmUk_/׿Ynh* )8fsk,r3#^pdOF#>Py)Pȓ5Ju]`(M000ia\!RCc8\d \ٝ,s9?#+5(#:?_Ȋ,ԳNOTL*h0T{$A8Lt p O<(Af<p (Ba ٲ>V`'gb62h͌2`!@ .PXE-dž DL$^40dN' DǪ&= C HMvLL<*u__6H T &0PPN q=i7c &qd'סmu}n?tE=ntWVt㴁JՂWVo_}mw߿__ֵ^zߡi߽?]ii oS~zkW7]ֽWW81׽k_턗֢{oiK0 ߯u^_~ OzN1_aw^/|&_)uw8?_^l'J(?a_iuЋj^ouxKw&'K{KE_Y"0 oSG޽(BmK߯tVگ7ik dkCuw.֭]tU/_WZ}VZM}{i_֭n[ͫi_f=L+_V/}K_W]ZMEvR=k=(0fk%vկYb!j i)Sb(a+{Xa/iXi5kvZZub].Z~`{_;հkkh&L  ڊ P vLSQTȎ 8AAa$}M5VKNՆJt8avv&RoqN )nk4V M4i5L  6&M k h46 aGA4@mEDDDDDDGe5&0LhlɽAڂh0uL ψhXO a65i!j0""""""""""""""""O3-D7C ]厡4ԱAph Na&5{Yg;t0U` "CB#Ј@"""=+ZI//֒UYdT[KtnJ6p ]BaDDEq|q^?ɸVfFK|fAl#gPBAFvFyNGܼvb&w((.v@l N`31xX0 i0 tљё8фGDgb' (RXS  wC-Ym[UO;\eGm}N֫tW["2#akL"΁L!2vld1 8Q#jydjG!e9Άc!gy/%Ba͊N xP F Bh0j(Aj  ͇8)ADԈAt.B΂#fy3aֿ5#FtFvJʼ(2n"C:| y&Gϥr᠃Jh꨼iL&'h*: 0]փ D3g8(AA@ j8` p1á`   Ph\ qH 6 $L'Ec1h Z`Ƌ憋Ƌ'o D/'NڪoDM=06*t&LQ'j WkRm`GpsAVX+b6io@ȸ&Mzt{6?;AeƱyTEM8;pAH $Nh'E^QxGNcDZzhk뭡i&O^It}&?ff0V |r,;b{w~M `i:M$'{i8ɛO]VkJW nO KJO#5 o}'.JIJ׿O׷Iz *_Uu[Nݥ[^t:.}תۯ_qv=H_ ޻u֟/I.NFɎE/o}Hx~Xcc׮KƲӬ>`bJ"1m:B_iJ?װz  l9MX7a??//׿I'pawOo|+  a/W- v'0E?E /܇׷C]ڥ$oAa_ul7~wH-K6_A{k֖_FZ^覆uZ?_A]6Cuҏ$QZzY9~W.{uuцMO#'U9Wi O0VkWi6տ^kcUVGUz0[a}[K߷^ڵu/U!=:_;J;I⯴b;Y MmRkz $K·K[P[ .i#a/1Y\ m6GqA06M:c{MY0iUa&Kwa#b?cۈJ vIwwmua;6b;mpMv^dtȃD']8aAT"1(U q(.Da< 8*T)Ba j`af03@p5L! B`0< SA&5AaC_3:zn i:^' t Ct rPx;z'mǦۋ]Q;huMT'TNޚ *aS T|2TQ7j'i/ozK~t "]I#AzoA6 T&:x Ɠlı'4V ]D|1kWn/կ5Z鯿oW]뮵i_HZuzڮ߷:_kｰn_i/]z_kڿ\("a޾c a// _ku_c׆vWka[K_m+ %}%}Xa_0k_շ׵u]ژY v}N) > $cm(6Vj>=z Ca+ K[KaaKR+JbV^ۯ{mZ0:iS!  040AQM>A !_!GuM[LUްqlAQ0)_8var0PpK80Zj¦ 0Lm5 i Dt6 a!PAAb!S#AAX lPA!5A@0ڈ #rpT炾L$<A0L* % &Pֺl0m 4  M2, a4hCPMl M4i4 0""""""jB"H@` a5.0!c’aBj Ta04.!L)o6&~0L :)恘 lڗdn _-u@ u\ xǓd eqe v &_PTPLY^mls$hfEY] !2 SCBB*a; dj`|0a7u * a(. 6JoOA6 2=:G-\,Iuo ?;Hk@짇@/ԉ!cё!FK9)$/iu׮67}ү_(*JB~y[<:_F"#%^tJ]aB0CՄ" dPZ ΂8)S C!3z5QJX*zn@ !H 0P0A `sK$eN)d΂dHf/險/tDwEh_L0L]NUL4*k!`"x0@(ABB0PL hZiP L * 4C !^4h&tUm4'MSESR%…OÇM6A DႦwP¦' i*aPa#xV*Wdpt0&ޒl:]"ؚ3>!I/D[J)ɺx =q`cDMhbg||CDwH8zo⢖I pJN|}y c tԏ=r-wD>dvp34ڧ+Id[lȐ ӟ*AzOwOOj*{jN{ { x@ҷuuuv֓ء$:8{_OU'JJOOݽW=Zݿ'^TZkZ߯xJ-koW CIV{tw'_K 1 UZI_n?lXb;{W ~/$/i,G_R/vN]u_Pk~-ݵ_=opեm/, niwAVa꿿;K7a$K ?o_ZQ_ݠ몭%[z_Amoa_쑶Qz^]Wh/7[{oz[V+Z*_7^/}[do+VuU1үs1|ڮj齴'߮KmLjAzZ ~o_1G_F?KKm~i{E{ $7QC {u]#VҪRҷmt{oo~ռ޹VcҴzSJӨn+Ӷb6&qJ_]hץiv/x[ۯ_۵/Z߱^]CpwUۮz1 @":D1A *!M;":AM8}QŮP[i_a.)6$<4$_ba~LAtڭFMkjVlk{ p  ˚h0[j@ l`S! 6zbQLB#a&)4kM6M=iqRuA %a&*+Qt ` a0A/ OBXײ+a$[PACh H$C0@ئ 0t[IQQ @_DDEekb&x0Jp- *z ꝪSL^L N Lؙ0)7Ak """""""""""""""Cb"8㈈׆/ү_Ia"e%^@췭+Uv«N40Ua (S2AםL;UPsDOvTԣGo|(I4.‚&M9d4~$  S wvK({OAvT*Ċw9I'":;'(y ^ o]u;I[2gdKa_d]_]|_k_UW_~uU gL':#LFyhkTa0hZ g<l#A ɱUs1o$D8fuS!&awPj$uA4 PP0)Bz` aA. (A l8DO |TA&B+. IN P!P%͑e!) vt"6FRIt DG$Fp)D=H!\,ȧ. I <" Ќ78BmҺDŃH5D2t'm%Y7$8Nx+TA &a σ BiPPA *aA1T !&V bk؆'k;3v&2e̠4O2} D &n7hi9!h4N(=0q0*48jT &a"nеTLv$I[a0K _=?/JˊpC Ah ۠h'O/ńO 辚EAjj"qhnA 4O(q_UӻU _o+ {} $ڻM-6M6pg ]+E{"؟`ȣmmo827@ޓ #tz~O~~ML'Ii/z:^Zt*n+Khi}5_i}]ZU߷zZ;b+_ ߏnV .=Ct o/ !K|W=i}/}m| e^&9')׽z] | W_?8a{? B#?,&Xo~^ﾩzЏc;h/%/F>"Om /_/K7 A~.D/T= & .ʢf0 j œt(Ј"""""8k-B^*/_Ӵ0A|Dynu;:(M3LRj4ige;3T A;di3$W*2}I%`-0^w𠾘PZI 6O꾋Gps!]2 =:OMȂ{s,2[dxF]]/V߯+usAr #ld<""|(Φu C#Vz g djyKz  A$A0C d`@@lS@RBBle Ft"͡*͙Ni0kgTf mDJBtDS L(*S=BAf4Baj `=00A 0(D&t0fbqat5HENa)Њ]Cd" # F]A.lgA0D^# 9pN 7,Ex< Q; OEM蝷 0 *zh7fOag P3  (A 40 h30Ǧ`gOzN|R9882%pzm|ȗIsA6ŢvDŢ'im *UTN(tPU JA$ UL&y4SDl{I $Gka=;m6Ar|g '&/" 7NEE4_4YEDg'-&3Z mt5dnQTz[u];O__Nk&ޚuut:u.{^}};ކ_׭z%x%__~:kC/ڋWk(Rb=྿D _W]~{}z_˯,GM)i>9&9:[1Ɏh*rT/"Q"QD/"?/_/a/FzIJ>$~CUy  |6/A}_5/]rGd솽~_ K廿گ釯UOobd܇#Fi#HG_>iu__]~{W]~Kkk^_+KtkKK/մ/.ǦGս6Zky[L%ҵ]mZ{K~o~_W&Vh8KKbCam/Ս,a(4ͮ Zˬ/_װj]{m´Z]`]V; 1I=i6?0`V;OMԏ-^b b+*lzv Dta `i σGL|r ba4m=[O_U[QZk-~ե{Kv}G * & +aBiC [L(MASUl&Ma b]4 `A tAlB4ؤL (4461 60AG hU`HHA `&@-Ak x0 v^iJih&m 60A0dX&M0m-L$ 5^"Ÿ?"Sr &&|0 h0a0n0 aK͐a3?erPj""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""# T~YdUG-Q)743[\Vzg%@-i 2 erYAT _ 6 5 o%͒Ie?]j{AD$FۖG|E24+mz__^_uD3\9 :Ksd"XT~ (ZD,xD^"8싄dBE)(2*Y=e|'Q-saa΄R"F{! zOkF@0a0Iꖡ0TzwULaB * 00P.@&`S`3D9|] ^KB)Ǜ|S[4fȨ:CRlgQs"] > " Bld1b!H3T4Op"ǥTtN8M5x8:v **h0P< AS L&  <4ABag.:& A(L ¦z੄ < ͊3aa]?MIk)&xý<B(xU;ꝂTDrn;n5C pa4 &0M0TN4;T$Hvv&i'  {zO% X% ܏?0@gO:Nw6fb$&M U M]c4x.;DŢŢBoqAlKhENWRo&Mpg۰N|g#0-"NȖ&`ȣ"H6 M"  N{&uA{MtW׿Z~5i6~=a^^;L'\0VKK߾'e8k+|v]>{VUC]u7]]?_O_}{J(xIW []]~_OO=v[j _a}Qtz__Q p8m~}}߶&00}wzZ[Lg &:+?]m/U_ackinPhۯ$?:$=]7]d?l ּ76_A?~8 öHi~HK_K_+Xoo붯71J_iW?үVQnC@߯_t+-v?K90[Jvީok__oKKS]=1Z{zZKk /Ko/} *]n߭Sw~l/4m/S aL/kiV筄iiФaZ4Aڵ XNد]pX{)׿¯ޜWv_aaqC OM./& !C@؅": `G5^kJҸOҽuU_kiZ]/MkTGjZM *pDIpPUk@5LEp8 `h8A S60@* & Z}A H1H6A  t aAAMA +"""#B" "$0#246" w Ԙaյi:jA!&a"x `h 5< i,$kM i"Š EWDDDdId04i--]0彚&ٚh_gaBeaa5Pi""""#""""#B"""""""""""""""  ZZLERz`4l0Aj,~]DDDDɨ@v?^WUgsD ({P.[2,L](*`(NA0ru\P`B\_[wPI0AA*L&}}O84Bf6vTek!wWў.ȑ՟3?>"_W a0A H `SO % HO'p)pSͅ>2SALf826fE"?DDIg]ku8P M :a?O# $ ` d 3Y saO@(fu,"&2Fpɂ!癨r5GC0H<|:!s1fYu H"'B0ȡGI"{hNޚETM J' 0A \0DBMB` L SO*`a a 0AA,4D'4 ;. `wT Aa<;6鴛'5vP{\M 'YIxCD˺%mUQ7j*hDMZiL"n-4N\j & R=`<$4F;`M=:]6 ό?6_Nie&=7;@, xxI7 xcHv'~,8x[Z]?~_OON] k}W_|RiO_e]^ݯuo޿]ሯ߫ 7k~ߴQ[_ A 0^HA}/^!m_ _K?$ч!0#1W֌A}_@A~@8D@w~ﶩqaJ7(ս;.KK<K -XoO_.)cKS6_~I#$~ +#G#K}?_wza[xIm6Haca-?k`FO\?\uUnNYI_oKoҾ_oikMk[OV6/}߹9kW7_}InPuƶlWA1PO鴺N—~ // Za2=%wM\xPG_xD9i 0@0i`u B< a>Bd(;NXaki/lG8*+19&*T Ci=m a;[Ix`K0 aVJ Vk* j mE2 ` a R M67TێC [d#զ)=Biڊ`]iu!0FM0BAl0L&~[r0P55MRNڄ "@@0jn  mm@  `e MSTL @ȎDDqDMH8ez0Lr 5a0 xa{W PO{ ﰠa{"hR 5P ڠº금")G" OZZ `.q꾪\$K^K%I5ׄ(% -YN(0Tp;LS 0:Uϝ &"%JͅZqu" dBj Ӱ\;ׂP_  wFAblZ ʬѝ2܌;  (U  ظT((((.  .*X9-_ץWӿ⣺O;:ߧ믾Ir #(Ȗ%ja$mK^z}\h4p!dxdpg\8j](0aJ$"]%_믰_=U 0PAB@`A haD `!t8d.lQ ?<%U]~iM4AWL~O!MxPAB ,HCD ` ๲!@AB "'<3A_E)EHE &\?$Y 1B "#P!4ޮ O~E|' 48A-HƋO6'Z' C`TlDMh,D8*iB  zhS H60$* a={L'>upa:MoI[i'AA:'|y0d_4u 0_/_~czqZao ?O千1ȰX?kD_(J>NL?cc(1/޿}CKA/տ ?n/=}{a /o^/_?k n ?v_uVum0_nt}Ҵտ/]/_KlUoO/KkR1~C-{]/mKKޮ_!ka_ku߯if=(koiZ]i0jK siam/{_i bc[x]mk %{մmuLW]i^m[ߘ/:Z0iiҸ l @b l`Lt@@d A lP aC 1I'l0Ջ]pjQi]1QMwVqKai[ mZWG ׫M]MBMiai7`b0UQL{SƴSR m1I0tLmE ݪM[`KՈ3!aUa22Og )7Z &ih5M [L*i@ݪAh&h qAiB NAA 3#FDJ? a"`La4i*a;MM4- *Lpaa0A-K UDDDDDD"U#KUM _ /"l]A_~ bl* q (ffj<ҏC"Lf&dP;̋Qejࠠ& +i8G`C22 ą4ِBࠡT*…0 &*(/馘-JT$HH^hh FhfE&;@I=% E_qpr*X9V&UQ'p׆uVUjtuׯ_WW+6GAB "G8Y~`ȤND;3@ \e!d&Leal*꺪xLL25t0A  аxA|"!싐PApbA4!#ʸ'"Dp FC)1P]Bҕ漈ٴRv-N2NTCD& $;\&EM > 0L B &43aO a0At*(f" ņEЈvKk#ЉDD&DdxC>h! " ,NġӴ(q3i(L& zAЋB- h82%M两s6i0R.z+xM"I[);C=& hcMƁ &ҧg' i6P^'uL̈!ڦTK:P Hv~'hd]J -4'WҸO ouvjݽ<&Y|&4A6 bkWnbhm'9|šݢlLD[CP9  Ilc|__uZNM-'dL'޷'ÆzI:^| >֓gxad[>$_I׽雮ޯպi_i7ӥ_OT6~zեWW#]ƽ_#\޻ .W_ӭt]O ɹ~!a^?|Gouq_\dž[*Ј ',GPV {uK_ƛI\xc?"CFIJ~Z?Dܷ;_N :'B _h*Al;ۯ$?K`DB_^ m/aoAa Oa[{_KWk~'uo ?~gks Si]}Wz_א!EXoI._G{߹(~HG" >w~ZCN~ ki/k߯~~{~ $|5.n޴i8R=k*cW1Ktokxi~ڷv__iu6j6;Gkt'i{iaH_X0ի_]aͯ6 i`w'^\0JBtMS ! *4VkqƼ{@ߺ~ئӴ۫/aKW_iSLV鴻OL(M47 `R40": ln wAmUi& -ޭ8ҏV?izڼ{Uj -լj d}Sa0qka5WնMa4 a m `@` )* ݐ (aS A4xQLg aDDDDDDDDDYZ a0j  Ȯ]J-mD&ta4jajOh4j06DDDDDDDDDG"H*eW `  g)i—'’tAɾ[wD 0šALL0AH2暛, ֖"""""""""""""""""#%4ka"(/X\ a]A 5qn tGڏk,$ɺ!3"X;"PaA4”`-ӢvM+\ bcEdɯUPP aB(.qJV]0:98!ٰ}m}{}%Fp}ôRK>OU\_UtUuL3Vz)Jeޟ(  DShf"a\"I*x"̇<;h0TAB 5'A0ABM i œlCћ e #8G) #Hᚇd/ˢ[$2"# QFn$3Yy3YcgX5Nf1"x>C:#Q' :' %4M&ᤦdGDBPS8*M k&3aBaa 8>g pfA56!4E,3B(AA B -&#(fA6 q4Rwt\Z6cB8_BTC4SDS 0* O_‚0T *i4 >*i 'nGzzlO pd\$&ؘ{)ċ&zNlh Ɖhhdoy jADJDP8hꜻj'l*hxi4Na ;DҺm^{_'|mԘ pg8Id,4oId[~ ]Mf @Mô&CH; H_~/V{K_ Ұh:?_$pt6xaվAҶd= }ok]'BZIzo^N׽7}mM::]6{{_Wc_:~WZWj:_[UMZ]wJ^_LrZ/W:c}j_߯[{}4t?a]b/ L=tWV_a_u?8_ZKmP_,O"Cm~0^׷_1Z]DDҿ?$zސo$T zH/7~׽7]Wׯ\m_I_zk}߫%uW)v+Or'iz_i~_v?cKm{{F[%}_zK}oottkUǥi@;+? /װ0i~z/i~~~ӵki{q0+[Z^;X4m6k_.1_zi~OPE;Ja&WK.醻i}MS `QTaBil&ӻjһav'C߰V6;:VVҮ+X4ײ+a5IjT&M `4P `h`6a4MbXa&6K⪖'pwn4L=m. &Ja0Ҽkp`DLA #X haAa4dW, ݑaAhQM 8 Q8 l@;X GMHW0@h0 0@ب!S[AiADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOR`ݗX= z / )1 }4 {j M0ڗȎ 4A48HDDDG(ALb!.PB8`W"u3B)bD!h  QDDGZUׯ]}~Jz+uO\VzM06|%ha8A8? gDDDPQF[;ꚦک{;JYƳ$2O_P=}haAUpPK`4Dh#1NqA߮FДb&f _n]t*UUK[٠a {/͡)=rB'Q ZrsdI}S&!$KYnI\& 5 *` ` `4A2%-|& ћD̈́/hF,Y YhC2n'sXTZ Ia0$ *h< fSM3bCQ(@д `0D9Ÿ0͌΂ٲ:Ctp!b:`Sš2l" G2 dPTPB" '2*@©;48#7_4_Av&\h4N'ơSElAq-^4N'm &8qqDҨM5M0D'¨Z L"v5Dt$=}4[Im`tKpa:`>nH6|C%%͉xIN _pd&yyEEJE_4:?ꆚLִCWMkMo.$%r8^M4 64޷Iw7` iZN2+}I6ZMVTVm*'hwpOOZp/K %zzj:='m/֫omo^}/{-믥CH}׷T|v1',G3 ?_>+ KEa_ LE,P+ / pL8[aakڂV1<rKo_/aD`?m!ouY u]uCw__[K {m2zӿGd$y#!ݿՐA_z _w__KuԾےn#n$KyK쑮C!鴮ڿݾӿTǯk\R[~g7/mLnb ݯ6[]҆iեo^no]دӽKn&[1jKm}MJ{K{JKjլRQvKQZ~զ+K߆ ^W[]uK[oT_UAVMv%Q\kM*U^{Pi7^W Xjnoi0^s_ .{ث Gدm UE 1M1@ qMP m@ӂ tmTVa& %k]_w{i}tJFGiqױLG &b=xiZ:t^MKp &ckkZ֛IV&(`@X a 'qӲzqۦ :ih ڎ( h"""8*DDD g [:pja k݅jh6AL*a5 @ iA!MTiH=`E`鑘=>& l˄Rn0UA‚vT{T )qpaB' L&gAHsbgs ZDGEDDq~֗GGƈhaeB13~[@I DDDDDDE +A2ld`iRnYSSf 6"! ""?i,*& I2X;PgS+yYeCl;Nd!px..?-ljnIZ`!cLJ1Ru[C2DlΙgGx)3`A7N Mbkt&AA}'nТh4<`Д5[DD$+AP`&+N+ ;6x=>i0@6 b| 8NEOqǾڭntJ݄֭ ?#ud[i6EǮ˻}wۦ^_Ptiu_ߡ{^֗ڽ_W}/k[_I!v_匿R:~5׼Rca>XZrľ .ϦxDWXooN=W}_ N >+M/_:䍊WKWwῴ"/W]~/u/۵ׯ_߿__a-}ªۯnn6ͯW.K*lKJմMҾb./~ /^0uua$ڏaj0T5]ש?mkCثOJҿ~5A"B a P"QLB hU(8 |P ڴ/|Tm~ǭZL:O /MBa* M0ګ 6m Ȏ@q86*0;"""""HJ9;A$aTsag_ K{LjMPjma """"""zgL0M*h  2Ma}&DDDDG]uU_خA +ӃDGZBwW,**(=_ O42;U{ `qvdL&D"$l\‚@ B`>%t'FźB*aW 9aAdvkB{] t8]쌷#3"23Ί@!Յ34 AMe£ C3FCD #5T ~`?0PL „"@ȜA8ȡda dE"Nc5c:83 yЎO"tHF6)- .X~|A^8 &HN0pN ^=0dSttL$n0 4‹DŢv3bix:Mr e^ϊlWoZI6 O{ߠ ::HhR ~0A^Mt׿ut*Rm4Ta5 K0 7G aqb""" !`XIGF""""""""""!!%^roPXaiJ ZaDGdZ#gaBoHjy]N2) (.(LdL젎L( 4ՙ;. 5a;OTL/[$kC^AcCI&wiRW`nQ8⢘ĭKa;er-[_ת-ґ#:"_򪴺T*[(A&`PCd|B@lSe8aO)!3dHbq33YsNfz"5OPZ Ba0 )PhZ 0A0A"8K"D`41ٲiAc1a̧LQњ#WY\ԏIy!S!愙 LלgS0H0eHVI#%'aSDa։ ) D ^B'mT*N!SM3¦`0xi ClH `A B  0@0AӰL a0 *4C(A.!h_FH2N C#8aM&>8v&UD^c_h7' *niGTT a8tD4 T3&\& /g A2%b{':OONm'}37]n]ujtۮKWIt$~. tIIGotIEjW^[}.m}ޝ/ն~*b+{u_7oݿ{]__}_U[Kcco߷_m]۫ ߷W@_o$ ~_*5__8D=%`$ %_Ol Շ  +r~[ h+/7${%߶D_Z_R_Wwa/KoAz_=v)_߶{A : a_uuW#H}޿AmvHm^/]]фtom|'KKҴԾ.׷_jm{ڷ)Ұ&C'!#}tojV׿{Z^_յMVcwaW (VOdW8oխzߩv_xNԏ_iWVvb0HGA@@;X Qa8MU -amGuq"l lS}I]O=;]!ڰtXamX &iL/D0ML ab `b AL{i*&MC C[aK~إXa*5aaiZTtpa(2p (M*"Dl$ y\dYdLR8d'(wmƋ˼ZƵ`ɜ͓_44¦f`ɠh;‚h&tӦlTԎ*a3š a 00>0_]?Z?K__ސKm?[W\u_z_a/-?~KccU:cjOaI_XOLr+/'tN?m:O,GaBA 7_A/AwD;/:~'__ }_~ ޿&?ׯ0~_ ~jJ7^m/ֿ_oiֿWLy#oio]_H!{qo_Z:/Gk k^/1?z_oKJZ_﮿_a-եWl%k}/ُ7 ՘iSVm~ݵַ^K^}acc[Nj] j_a.mz_UKKa޺һ[!M)4Ai1M1mEU-Ic;N*C:إ*M~ӿ -ep{׊א6V^] %A0AAuP li;M `5LTtd(B=Siw;5m(=ҏ/U Qװ *aPa A0@ Dt0ATA@AM8B=4n&)+ЪA $6 = vGAmCI6"""""""""""""""2j aa`Ÿ 0]Zl%ipa:jp@ 46jVSA4b„ZimAڊ """8E1:0^56#A;‚zX5 a8aAԓAe0 ˻='ɺetC Ma3eR* /"""#B""""""")b8#_wI&|2Ă |'h>U0C qaB N""?[U@׏&FK o;twL ¢ !I 'E>vP̕YGa#WA܃(N,. fE ɲ9$g `#A)SU(-;#!v頩Fv0C H a;mBm56@ZW@WAMRAIn ޿;+> &@MM7'Ĺu^8`"x鴭'w2FNIna$.I~kOKO׮WI*oo?URq.tYnJ)3d!dzIdKR.-"64 .)<}uO ~ja(A OaH9ä2-ۯ_Ii=l/xM"t@ *k?ZV4J qDw &mר]]tNO$ui:N tzI.,Mx[(z'< `ІH u^'?:: d͖tۦnۯյ4I' M9F@NzvRߑmE9=~@O]?MM#ώ+[ۯu_unzz'ޒNO `:mմ?_Mo-Eé;;ndrK/KZUFs:*wMW>k7_DxZJ#0Bpۚo ~ڎw~/Y:*MjW!]-R~yQ~u1xbu -Ա p^.ZǪǥKƃ_9iɹ ;?U8_C]&ZݾK_?ai0mK%TZ]/KoBw_ҥOKj޺aÿMuMHޗd5 ZW %]t-V\k_<>CI_u(Z]1W_^y>z_U?Ymo+u"V_Kޛ~zuK_+o_׺K[KW0j]]aQuHO1G_֒kui_J G /im*1Ma /vPZRjZIu%iuGW|0 6  ba+ 1IivLEI{u_VZJ֖Tjit6 al+j i @4j)A0B jB:b#تuƫvEEE,Rl"TiE a+Im&ҊU6b $q!{LL9?e[df&k@K}0"&!g ;@h6Dp ςu]uH!LWװU1UT )EE4Q&DDDDDDDE lDDDDDqDDMHA 2 _ɎTQ  !0M0l5 jamB A׭!2xZeh0 c xhA &0A0iyg 00@ PA{TGDDF{. Zy:һm.-a*ۮp A1K\6@vDDDcA/ɰv8;NpeD(U =5 S q4,& 0x!pE-$63:Hf!Hfu60(!A2@0L&| (A0̈́>(@!Bi*a00 ੯A & !L&Ipa?籠'+3'>2悿oI ;E^0j^A蝶0hTM $ &釪Ў- K8~"PZ[}?dKpoK-A}uK\_CIῬ1Z^k@ozZ$Z;Ϡ𴾢ׯ/?zk'uIuƗׯתׯku}jNCW_}WR=^{ $] %a/RL4KҴ^{^_j޵E=qMlTziD=x`iڷV^] za& -?u]~t\4醶B:0!Gӂ 1H0cd#ڤ+TIt8i1]VOAp{[aۭ[[JӰvDZKUi^VNҊ 4զ$MlpMA4AH Al OLVa6%ӅIU4C^Oim\Ej6*ի{Ӧ$"5]@j‚?&~L 3\05 0)͊l 7sS &(!Q0L Qt%0^:@DDDDDDDDDDqQ}uWuUrH pZB 0UeMQQ&ƹSAvV2qVhePxLPYeC-)/M<(\N3,dvX)gelo'¦VD"꾩 (TP酻H@" ]S (PX8i?I4`vt Ɇ8&UbQI"K!pt$A!?K__O}㎐K_]WU]/KG* 2š+"%Lu~{zcE9>! z !  A8aA'B0 63Ey.>D?}~M0UAi?.(*h90ϏL ., ‚& 2k%Qn![g#0H>je; 5arb*o3)ٯ8g20d}:/gX= j<"vHv?h sQNfMAB S L PN-B σ 4A8BA2ld1 qN Û(6&@PP4D*B `ht( d΂pbk3:A:OHp ۽/7E O:n7aU0TlIL&a?4 4 6u}4*p{= մ&oem'^V OnmbahZ/ Zih@N2t.蝶g' 8>h0L㐖蜲;>ԋƉ|<*'UM^6~oV:0-> I77M &lM ባ,&Ab|7ZM )WAu_׫*zUuo}ItN ozuzRtaUBtvhWM.Z_u]=uJ7OMc.ڵT\_]z^_K~ﯭzҾ-:a+/c=>_}Wy1uWV./W+iW~߶Dt#&LDr,囫 i_w/_+7~_XD+_'jߒ/d$HRK7z^WK3pW{tkQd![}od[i_{vzol;(_Q}G_$IU_m//_֚׮_}}v7_n+ew0s~my_i>uTvkOVث[M?x_cm mj_j =4aKKU{I_ImiWO6L4;ZOx0e1 80_k[ jt^^xV#p`0AM1LQ!xAm M4 ◍XҨZb6*)튰&G[}) !u[bwA\0IL&5zM0AM6AA kNij*Ij'S-ibgULUi|wDDDDD0P3BOA, FC &WMjMc5 6 ih {" 6( a"Bz$Ai@jA!>`A6""""#@"""""""" 2 &~ڗ \L)7A +P &KUaKa B^L&*a"""""""GL!(qL#VHAX!DDDDDIEtx(@*ZV""""""">R_ᄌijK vaVW B> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im41 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F42 12.76 Tf 147.36 708.24 TD (Rambus Bears the Burden of Any Uncertainty Resulting from Its Unlawful) Tj /F42 12.75 Tf 0.24 -14.40 TD (Conduct) Tj /F42 11.99 Tf -36.72 -28.08 TD (The Commission found the requisite link between Rambus) Tj /F43 10.45 Tf 283.44 -.48 TD (' s deception and its ) Tj /F42 11.87 Tf 95.28 0.00 TD (acquisition) Tj /F42 12.11 Tf -414.96 -28.08 TD (of monopoly power to establish liability. Decision 74) Tj /F43 10.61 Tf 258.96 -.48 TD (, 118-) Tj /F44 8.83 Tf 28.56 0.00 TD (119. Any remaining doubts) Tj /F42 12.09 Tf -288.00 -28.08 TD (regarding remedy must be resolved against Rambus. CCB 9-) Tj /F42 12.41 Tf 295.20 -.48 TD (11. Rambus) Tj /F42 11.87 Tf 60.00 0.00 TD (, however) Tj /F42 11.82 Tf 47.04 0.24 TD (, asserts that) Tj /F42 12.03 Tf -402.24 -28.08 TD (this case is akin to those which require ") Tj /F42 11.96 Tf 194.40 -.24 TD (a clearer indication of causal connection) Tj 193.20 -.24 TD (" at the remedy) Tj /F44 9.11 Tf -387.84 -27.84 TD (phase. RB 7. Areeda & ) Tj /F44 5.00 Tf 120.24 -.24 TD (Hovenkamp and ) Tj /F42 5.00 Tf 81.36 -.24 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F42 11.96 Tf 53.52 0.00 TD (upon which Rambus relies) Tj /F42 11.75 Tf 127.92 0.00 TD (, say the opposite.) Tj /F42 12.02 Tf -346.80 -27.84 TD (Rambus maintains that ") Tj /F42 11.89 Tf 118.56 -.24 TD (affirmatively to reduce the defendant') Tj /F42 11.99 Tf 181.44 -.24 TD (s market power) Tj /F42 11.97 Tf 73.92 0.00 TD (" requires a) Tj /F42 11.98 Tf -404.64 -27.84 TD (clearer indication of causal connection between the creation or maintenance of the market) Tj /F42 11.88 Tf -6.00 -28.32 TD (power.) Tj /F44 10.16 Tf 33.60 0.00 TD (" RB ) Tj /F44 9.09 Tf 30.48 -.24 TD (7. Rambus misuses ) Tj /F42 11.95 Tf 98.16 0.00 TD (a principle important ) Tj /F44 5.00 Tf 103.20 -.24 TD (primarly in monopoly ) Tj /F42 11.97 Tf 111.36 0.00 TD (maintenance) Tj /F42 11.49 Tf 63.84 0.00 TD (cases.) Tj /F42 11.96 Tf -440.40 -27.84 TD (A company that lawfully acquires a monopoly, and then engages in unlawful conduct reasonably) Tj /F42 11.98 Tf 0.24 -28.56 TD (likely to maintain that monopoly, should not be subject to ) Tj /F44 8.22 Tf 279.84 -.48 TD (divestitue or complete deprivation of) Tj /F42 11.92 Tf -280.56 -28.08 TD (patent rights absent a showing that the remedy is linked to the anti competitive effects ) Tj /F42 13.20 Tf 412.80 -.48 TD (ofthe) Tj /F43 11.14 Tf -412.56 -28.08 TD (conduct. Absent such a link) Tj /F42 11.96 Tf 136.08 0.00 TD (, depriving a monopolist of lawfully-acquired monopoly power can) Tj /F44 5.00 Tf -136.56 -28.32 TD (restrict pro-competitive incentives. Conversely, monopoly ) Tj /F42 11.98 Tf 285.60 -.48 TD (acquisition) Tj /F42 11.86 Tf 55.92 0.00 TD (cases are less likely to) Tj /F42 11.97 Tf -341.28 -27.84 TD (deprive a monopolist of its legitimate market position.) Tj /F42 11.98 Tf 35.76 -28.32 TD (The Areeda & Hovenkamp section relied on by Rambus is straightforward: where a) Tj /F42 11.95 Tf -36.00 -28.56 TD (company lawfully gains a monopoly through ") Tj /F42 11.96 Tf 222.96 -.24 TD (a succession of brilliant innovations) Tj /F42 11.97 Tf 175.68 0.00 TD (" a subsequent) Tj /F42 13.70 Tf -399.12 -28.08 TD (unconsumated ) Tj /F42 11.95 Tf 82.56 0.00 TD (attempt to acquire a new entrant is insufficient to justify breaking up the pre-) Tj /F42 12.37 Tf -82.32 -28.56 TD (existing monopoly. ) Tj /F44 8.60 Tf 98.64 0.00 TD (il Areeda ) Tj /F44 5.00 Tf 51.60 -.24 TD (& Hovenkamp, ) Tj /F42 11.86 Tf 76.08 -.24 TD (Antitrust ) Tj /F42 5.00 Tf 45.12 0.00 TD (Law' ) Tj /F44 8.83 Tf 35.76 0.00 TD (653b \(2005\). The subsequent) Tj /F42 11.99 Tf -307.68 -28.08 TD (unlawful conduct is unrelated to the pre-existing lawful monopoly, and the remedy should be) Tj /F42 11.85 Tf 0.24 -28.32 TD (limited to offsetting the likely anti competitive effects ) Tj /F44 8.64 Tf 258.72 -.72 TD (ofthe unlawful conduct) Tj /F42 11.89 Tf 114.48 666.96 TD (, ") Tj /F42 11.90 Tf 11.28 -666.72 TD (leav\(ing\) the) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000189505 00000 n 0000189564 00000 n 38 7 0000189669 00000 n 0000189833 00000 n 0000234954 00000 n 0000190361 00000 n 0000189980 00000 n 0000190109 00000 n 0000190236 00000 n trailer << /Size 45 /Prev 189178 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 239256 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000292100>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R ] /Count 7 >> endobj 45 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 46 0 R /Contents 47 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 46 0 obj << /XObject << /Im48 48 0 R>> /Font << /F49 49 0 R /F50 50 0 R /F51 51 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 49 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F49 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 50 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F50 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 51 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F51 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 48 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im48 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 45569 >> stream 唅娑G z9hj?-A{q)^?j!GMZ8d~?Uc娨ڏ .VA|T2K'*b3>v[2̆3. X*igdwy3X?W'0­/LJ!x^;UV_I%_6tJ|(IU% lg!$3c! lgA3ka@H!pdP8ɳ5: d H4 dx&G5#q#)ٯ<#>}0 >(M00 š !0<`0hX&  f B 0@B a0D]A8N/\"Њ%zh'*UE"v'o ED AD = &5phAM4(TS<./a4 eY@AN&MŤ 4T//hŢ2}I|;hzaB A`HL&T)qa4XtGo"%vdsIRi>N`ș [>)Ilaڜ};7,z/`Tw-[kIIۿޭ{ ]'i; K'EAl˳g/M==?omҽ+ֺWOMMMп_u}۵k.k޾_%W ޾5]zPX@&_} wX?z&K L5&;ſч{?ߡG[ޝ$ޯҽ_ޖ${E<bUikuIg0~¿7$$_]^_6hOO]~MkviZկ~J}߽VK﫯[_Kt_aHbd~?K aonCK7붿f/tiZl4&JV;wMm[iG @KV*⿊~?Na6( E1AG}S!GQL0&&uUV] $OO֜jWT4t Mj  h0SA m(0A 0@⪁h=A⫳(@&qHa8]ӰM A00„U]a_ &A k """8GF"""#'B_ &T )qc ;MIL&JI/򕮗T*.1 4 `QLdɃ2; :!nYZJ \*aBeyl[_dk/sIVmuEFVmLFAz+ZCbV__)//U㏪IzSa꾺0@чD4SġP)<)RDP͐!dE$Fȑ,C9dt"' aI̠D!)ި"SXt0\AB ϊa  ,&0 h\ htrLFȈ!NDvGr 9BC0G$!$3c<2vln).B((L <`4]K %M '' v$=Q1J0EgjS \U xT * 'L*a0TM3aBxANSLD݂|uzM"VzKx 1:6߯I.:A?IuﾭOOzpIGjuקE 7OM }ŨZN )=:M 6>}'4_J&JWjګ]_Bj'K]^OMФZL.zۤM.R({k_?[z^]1ZtC6=!m_]~7}]yb.v]~}Q_l^WkJOmT?cu'9`0 &Z`i]k?"O}?_.-_kqaWI{uK m/ ;wl%}쑥NU# _5 %d5zm]p E6CG#EoȌ?K[F۷_{??kWm$U׷޿/_Vҷz*^'kK0um^Umm|_~+놓kk]M}+k֛VcA￑`sYl.7›-.Ja/. i=} 醖c&_zP l$\Sa)m-V#4 VUV qL0u$vߧ( :5lTIciAH4퐣ᄡxTnibV4MXb)u .Joa-=Wk0aE!tȎ4AaB60mA":A5q@A!L`bLP qAMݪ @dG@DDH1@)`0 0.&cf0ofIL>gᦰM5t jTڦ =6jNa&/a0ЈqG6"""" |&SL@:`ɢ &?BeM anLI&T3DDDDDGT"#""""""""""""""#RzzUZ_JV+XaB^ҖeH/  ^B0xUX: ! @aXB">1,6Ngb [zgfC%qޱE*Y\W-Bـ@aBI$r9G eE `Z^ I@(.!EUU FR;)ӃD3iE*|pprrDєіB v;09ةޝ1O_Oگ׻Wu믯VaUu]WaȾiBnWG2f SjwK!teShzZ`A(Aa߄A\P!3$CBDtc: I0̼T e93q)#$#Ndj%%f)ޮLYB?ugLgs YDz9pιND0i͢4|U:.S S 8AA<4AA@BaA g"O"d%"!haL x&D`„( `B-B310P3 |CЄpчtOq{H4^/(rdNa'DႦD'JhSE0M*`m:8"ak&fL.0$PAӘ=0§ªt֩Nf)YtM Ši;3 ='Ep ^Qx4^44O&gꓢL$N.ڨTNZ/ɞ'oU3hq/; =4_c0wD4=>'[V^oIϊli7_ oF շ =&i'zAbk[I.4POpd~JClv`ȣ\hi]Knmӫ.-Io Nޯ?/M'mN|mAxC] &Vtׯ龵]]I~]~St$omccWŷozu}}{]_%;iUU^u _I}ݺ~Un=ַ/>Bxnj.?_`Z~,w[k W/^ƻ'_~֘uXK>X`N#,F [vu_z}oa{_]/86;0o/w/I xo幖E~H$o[]A!/1A kA};U=. oG_"gv1EUoKuۯI}osFx^_ҿ{_cuww_^R 5[_;}wԿ}?~w׆w_a}K}z_Xk=[ %m-|5ضǶVM^U1Pݫj _~o_~oiwٍ턬W'Q3ՃA&հ҆iۦҦ_OV mUj]1]=WN꯵bh6b⣰ipڻ]z5 P a0@`h6) b)kh6) AN4lVLXa*W[n!^ַݤbja %O Z\,4@L& m2#jMLI`dAqLBh6DtA 6*a! mPAN@i@MC,&qAh6?A*0 RnaN57) R3]! Iam0Mm]4Mm "`i0 Xa8a`h04DDDDDDDDDDDDq`YZ6K H0A &QQ2\3"DDDDDDDDqsצR[ !\ob,0jeqPaH7، DD@Y-V?x@FwLUFdN2B ((PM42 ̮&ѕʑRD]* /vv)P%ِ0F&Lh`T\UT/A„&aB cBhn„$[Bt\x:+'gjF%˶ҽJ I> u8zo?}Wk]}0}Ww>S6)|dld<2fI2"h?#RetF&5罴 3 L dwH0X!a|" ` 0@χD^&AD Pf!)@D2N#Q8g 1Af 6ˣ̏ 'du1vCdFA\"xAR 82C pt^ `M4 3b&j ]ϊfL& 3 0hZ"t aBAZ>.,! L&~;Thnhbaha'Ni4^&'lz}NQ7  MN7pUTLwv4$U'4Hv|0H}u"P߫.dx'H;"Sd m I>l>(|'e4As 5I;dz /4DàZO/ P@]Iam _>64vm&IőItosOO"IzIҧߧ30d\ߤ^Nm?_k뮛^K]oۿoMjޓ_|/tZ_N׶+?=O6O[ҿ]Uu._᏿_ok߿ ޽|_}|vB_۴aZ=تKட___=_녇]WC\-)$Fv_a_/>.jm/m/úDT~/tN}_WAw}lUk_Kn?,6}}Koޯֿ 3@]_z_?,7Y#$_تدF_Mcb*1A_F.]}~_zozMm/zNwij]]__/߾|I/۬,էL,ߺUZmW_uͭ{,AljiD[Jۯv %a-Tڗ[?m~Կ &%~+V* %LU9 :M ILvݱV %M_ $mc+ICҰpwCm-Wc mr ]B t H0ACiM0AS `!6+lP Z>@QI %҉ڱWLI6Jö;L:k$=atˋ y|[ML0 *jVִ{ 0„јbd#j@ 1@0A4h u 0A@; &<5HDDFV a2.LC96 *0v P^Յ0k { Z ~l00?\0Ј0DDDHDDDDF";%I.jK%(P`0 LV0L(0Q}GDBC2*2$d؋aBaAW>MGbQ\!\PPS$&E:aA;# 2 (P~S-4%  @AB ,$&zi:td (O 4UU LS0wJҤdM<*i|E 7XxA;bTN$NvJek*#Ft4 n7MAJ*O?UF.WC>:NA?L)R CFGuKB=WB!aB 4A1 / 9'^#Pk#A27 \)OHA^_pOkȺ„ORD0xA{GQ d1c44Bq 2 e- pB KFHOS aAyh0M2>!kD4Nj/2}Oh5P't]A "pª~ Atz A A΃TP<(L'*`h0ᦃtD=M:@! #A@E =$֕a*% xDn*h"xxu$88PvPZh33.\4Nܻv<džDM EƆ;t:O % \XL`aIόi6 uA64`ɔ/Q @Aq3^6X410YCi:OAS-";9n@h'&nM­ХIzIN= ]_^Mt[ŒO8}d\` jȮu}i??T}߭--#/Bt Jo]nW]7hi_]ziuTbޗ[k}U֗};__t.]m4KZ%@_ b/J6k}եk[뎾?^܊ZD0:R_P}REՆ C?^Q uZ֗uk~߅$m&?}WndsH"o/- t% W/ %]j$I$?D7IAKҮ?H/K~_-| A(W$_.$!Eu֓i ][Ao/PK _it^ZSb7$_/$j]/_/Gy߯׿S_TU~^N_Y:_7ku׻_iWGK__4k}}m}_v45t~c+ZZ1ViRVA7zJiuVե7i7vJ]{bAJ~iI%:~Rmj "um~m,ߘˬڶ{ڗԿ /[kK^j>=K{ZX/I4%Th50g +N®BT4pa&[ [_Sm>*!}ڈb Mh1@SM lP@: Amo!GI=:b`+I!% ^$84&I*@qGGVWCJVj#ZiC &J҆aMdG }@c bS\B Su@Ub%nA j A  b":b!(7c0xDd!`tCLQ ܙ5l'AnU,0i80il."&jVa4pMB 4ia4B ^@KB 4-Aˆ"""""""""""""""""""uDDDDqq  (& qfe( 7)o (L( a0f͈0a30BQ"""9,0L&~@aA~DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDkDDDG*ZJZH%,_FJu Na*U_ T-4aN- ד|DD/M$v3;3e)^v0L"vf2Y32& 233ASCP݂j;:.^;)A}']]wgDR`c{FfTTGD}^taxXVD;FYE]Wu^W]%U]Ut\B"3"kWU&ÈP"BR`y@ 3f|g:L ID1#Ct"8a23Q&]vq"F Lׅ֔a+9 6jGAM:A Ћ!0  `G4DƋƋ/2jhZ/i7CK'=IAZ]7𞩺~ApzVkAuVApd\~982.:rsA9Hzuo 'GڰI:O8I?i[Ꞽ% WWhzoZ'_zwV^oo[zm߽=կ_oknn.ڈkW[=,W ?*_ﾯ[د 4/oP[/_Ap_ɎEl"O"qނ&_ vЎiKڄۥ "O]'}?//W I]k/_A_ׯP/Q%db!k _ZW__oK KA%/KOb#dK{zoa __u{oEF/گowu_[0ta_U|e֕__߯_֭^iX*V>ۥ®#D)~j{au/~o}ֹuW}_Ym5y ҈ +V{Ď *!i/{ji?aKȮQ={ /M/J>­ ǶCثLE2t1F`0Ah 0I8iW{AaՆ)E~Hu⭆5WM,G|;VIc;jiL&I4Tim$(l p@dH@LP ` ` h lP ( `AQ馝4i i6*(1ICAA0A DNGmC `&0L0͖Ltalκy(S400PT^AS6A0AȰ0 lx"paAM*h&ȰM4ۄm{ROj"8HNB""!3 D2&WZ \fU =e8AM300ǰM3Z.(ȑ *A # N""""""""""""""")""""""qj*ᄡ{KHPᄩAM+\ a0ˆ0S0kYr:(Gb*M"3"eYE}"'B pAd)(AaH!GɆ$b;IT!+1QqPaL_NF B"$ Hg )6" BÐaAD0& "}=7 Ai0a !馘V,OI+]4JD #Iv[*gd}.ΉC]Rm&Jm mڷڑQLOE%DH2pd;A:Mi6__IuW}#MںN~:mKJITivz~jI{UkчmNtɱ_]*KӬ~_]'m~z0]e63:62lgA3aOT=Tx?k׿*qt…:7=`>(P AN2D RSbA$ f4,:#=f3…YGQ%Oq<`@0aM: N X"'A'NSD9(P.; &;L&ڄ&h`֒G3bB0@ïP aBO aT'";ıķiؙ Z޽%$"wh*P5 &'z^D᪢wOL&:8oDDAlAl7fjh`@NM xy)],Dx.%-N_u/)6ot7'A{,3oaBWھZZ3PZT%Z^Z]*ZN; 5uIKwIV E뫭+JKZJR]?NtUzp``%޽z}]~T/UoK[&IH7zjii7?NoM{Bn%Ҩ^,HL V{_m]-uꗪ .פMkR5[bap`^ <1ac1?_T_IiR׭%_IwKtKV0_#k ]7KM}.mZ[E~߂a_6wKJZҥz֒ z& "OwH-}it /K$-_~ްma]ZN$}uVXl687K^}u޻U_%iainHs>H}uZ}[JbIR1˅DvD~g0ٌ?j|/]uTafK Z?J[$HFLOںuv߯^][_(n.^=#U/i_חI%֕ߪ^KZoii;J-kꖫ^ϪJ/Ҥl4s_4:Jۤ}^Cin_<մascWwVi_mHTS iiXE+J ҥZ[IWItJH5nf &T ztw݅#%VڷNcAb`}UEEUQLUZzqQ] 6k a& wIv[a+ai7Np҇QJ &ParuMC ڄ1 jjL$!UkQD=D(-- &a@AQQt E4QQLW-wgŸ M?% iA…4&U0S ' *apL+z 8PNf`b1@6bTh j0ASUU b@""""""82!Z5g'F$&T@4 7!Aկ (Fe@L&LՃAH2PHvDDk:B(AHz]cb*%Wm OVUu M4kTQPkHa6k "#luTG&Qs$Pu[;[,gkH+~̊LdO2T|vH@ (L(P@xA$*jtI`$V`6Id~ΒZN;̫2{p!?#3Hx?kDWIIu(fmk^)b-U0uWM+qԎo0iWu$~['f*35(3[0fb/ј3?ۍ^m4y B 1/'x,&r/138mI'/zn]x]? M?At O/>0#zMoX2(;0)͚LW,*n]'uu{kuR]%J~{t?M?]:V׊M֓뎪5~bKֿ}뮿wuz޿_{ iBRR/JmkQC_pZY:tZZb]wƿ1W?IVR߂ t ѩ_XkXת&o / 8 ӗ6 [I%.-/?"o$?x_aPI*kK _lHVAi}5}~oo ҥRKZ_Z_HV}dԁQ_#z}--%Kak%޿K^{ziZo__0_$a/I}yu +k掌tyS1я/>_}/߾[{I!iҰb*\/`'[iZ]U^uªy6Im"~կm{ %wk %a[ﰶ+\ALq0WJ㸮;JUI B W簇R{6)4ǘ\'{m+ LlV   mHw a`ai6*6)6!q3q *8҈8iTz0 (Vi ujMi0ȮM [PIp: a@ڦ"RL$ SaG Mia;M6)!F@QLS!m4PaSAeMSe0(&[!3#,0pJ[P iL& i4dXA6Dm`T000&S Ba5% AQDDDDENDDDDDD!jш&L&~˄aB L-qiFaaA0g & DD 280k눤DDDDDEDDqHDDDDDDDDDDDDG%*O$Ui~*Yx0H%i*J)*2,MCHj(LiqPXUMp`MPj" L `"?(^>Mev eL\mAT&VcHS3vdVu*! aJbgs0dE8q䘥8,2yP ]߰C %(aB@ `T ]oA|6ڜo==5 OM5gbUH45dӤʀ؞44O sa~]v[JNIlqH4~?_F(rC"O/3AtMzz_#6i:0zM7 I.ߺJސi%Һt:J_["L'=/j|_kǂd| (AQ;."q"0<)0fFɲ:gXFHN٠E$Z%M%Zp8G2h0TT ͊M§ 0ᮞ6P@PhXAj AAl2f!Sžd8_0 dGAk_ ;NS3DgiI=0 SL*wT ˊfc ,: h2Hc/3 .L (~;l'%tTZI:着og[7W_%.K$Ft]iuWKz_W~(FQZ]E4zZw%u,G_JR_Hq!E,GZXlr?:I$c_Io}$@Do3r?vmzҵ}u0zTt'A/I'Zoo~AUW"_0?!!$y _X7]R*M_TR߫_+_% W[UTIb/_a_+=6^TUi~$]N߭_k{%^VQ$HA/6_ᄬ}mki}i}uWi'-ނIU5uK_+OcBݯ_ZXN+k}u~y㮬il*MAp]n68`ݤ4kmﴭ&鴢 X.iW~Kk6Ӥ撝 t0ӰXhht-22A mQ2h;}&1PTN)*iki[ +V .\UTAz 8IM'jiSXa&A0 E BMn(6)(lR Nt-$LWWa6BTV+"@VU!!2B `23  P.3d5 xh0 5 ªL5Iմ [Jii DDDDDDDDDDDqDFDDDDDYpva  0S\ 0A &'d)Dm 2/Y"!db^c_I﮿}Lijեji~w[uz[a4?[a,uotҶm/oK.K!֢biS0Has{K6S 6޿k{kK .oapi;Zzkz~mBklmqҺJuki ${oԿ1~VV[b@ 4 ta֚ ڦOcM/a%lN}}jǶ +>#88oҍ@㆖i.J{VNէa0MXAT[@6Dt0Ȏ bb (@Mبإ=kM8a*=N R C 4: 6 nL;Rψ0.a<a4[ Erگ &Er ¬0TMl D aȎdHM4 4h40A L5IiADDDDDDDDDJ!DDDDDDDNV$œr0a=xjP0#sM4atcaFA0 )7& ~@«""""""""""""""""""8"""""#I$ɷTi$0 * ЈA&0@yYKtWXiDX#-,u  ܤey⭄ArP P-FIdXd@rH00A2 RJ2 " B  aeQL_5E#.7P "Iw晴óC$R ȧhx<ii&dMR־7H>NuInK 8O?UZ^J:oIKꩨI:UzǥzUZZgL4833" ΙFg Τt}L* ֎aHh);%٪:]WZWAka 0P(A@„, hX@0 A 0DIC%F" B!r sc!I3YlЂd=̍3MYA!tD&uFʁˤd|gtHfLT֨0\T& { t ੄gNkP0T&AB3O`: "Q B5} mW кv.- &'tO1qixN&3$"y# w  Z%a x((TMū0T~Fc ؠ ! 8 j_AO]KEI7 M@Ȑ' ۤi>13,vJNr8PnG JRmO_ nGl ȣ'yApjCNv|PA&q-^_TJ'O& `?zZ!-vWVZ)m^m }:V}/ '7AgWФj'M-' ?zmv_}Zt}޿KtI}/zÂxO?_~O_{}u]7_Z:IJ-.A⽤cZWUӥU)wœkDɍ_/ u֕j^kOa?ɌQ_B[c_m*u{Aw}L?%m}-p$}W }[}wVj*K--"Q@AA*w^G_HEY-AGCWo ^_Wm_?dҭkү/ o~Uw[UUK_77kimmK[a~oRDk~[IW0as~ck]i_i~hvOSjcIirJ3]W VئV*K/iY{ئ.z;m?]}$/Sƕa=RcOgaUzvJڈ8jio icaդv]Aq{XkJ.$+Ga#BKSmlmO P h0@"@ alP  h0@ئ)LU[]լo߭,T0I]+[KNa᭧5'CL t2#0aXk PAME4":0@>) LBب+*% B:iX*@ jg!## `?C OaI 9`“4L. &8AnBh0pN i&Wn Pi\DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDFK I" 5A֙;xh00LJvQ@0`?b"""qQT""""""/׭k֩RZKDQAR`V v+-IB 4P͓)UB[?d"]:&2dI)4vetDܛ2Bp0SXDgbg@<& p(M$U%‚TK軤vE?L(CE-`9 E:`88O]A..RM$|f@hO['?jt\S,\u~ZHu]-W/KB!p)5hঃ$F 6E3#P d<'"|# +g:q&\"/t/3Ɩt&h*aB (M0N,` ,pa xPD@0D\0d#%:v Qxt3ѬXSy&]gȾOhEҶjfȑ#KA (*a0$!*aaAAS tb>j͟ AtljtGC7i &0 " 08fh^ q`af(L Nb}|a"\Zh8d˄4"BƋʪzH &t N.  - L&pPTASA3'~ * -{#M$ۤ`ȣr%ό"_tIȑ`S҂#$ " AHU j'SUM㐘Lی: ETN8ha= \o @MTN 14 f!3S,)~ i!Mktjn/wTX$t'X%I+]6~Z=G5*A?I$]R\/jS?:Mº_ևֽi%֒V_Ou_~KU_UUOU1,mmkXZu 'IkI%__}//KZI[X_,G`oj^mzPUֶx'!^~KJUuJ?}_Ck_د_ָ.j@I_o+I׿OZo"뤵JH ץ~C_k' a_ւK쑶D+%J ߤ/jp_맥߯kZ]/}ү(+(-WKjK-&cᄵvI~6 T%MZ}.+]kAi4Ǫ166;@[KتURKJm kze1 yᄛIײa2=ڵj}KJÉJ])zQV *чkv׿YCV> ZLA񶺷kkQw`am 0B 0@@"B k ` 660v :ئ)(b[ XV*a4(iL&i8^S0ږa-'a jQ@ 0 `m  m1LST0TSR$ GXDDDDDA"( &(F @3?|AL&04a4 N tݦiAL(& =rc&8AjpR""""""""""""#+ ex@)!ÃB `0B B!qZZIiIV Z}.$+_(bK +X0 Kt^0qA"?(r?S +?寊3MC& -FD IS,r%l|-Ǚ\)iL )\HJfJ,& q ~ɷܬ#fWĶP(H7\E#-M4`i5Wh37ZuI/в@ 8s8! ## e gR@8ffk#c/:}2蜈qhDa:24UK|א_4g0P2`0A0PB 4;L hX aBa d@ ɣ60DT񬖤_!s g<3m"0qI4) 2N 6d<ᚅ:FD<ȧ%!H/:AvFTzB$;Dݪ$=S U0hAQ7x*hw]AUrjT 5p< S* S>B ! `4tZ…L&|P tA7AOK/ oM/!ED CAD&rv'O2C*m& 4zA邪`ªnય¢ 􉻓xT8ji9I 6 fD l!I7 toA:O #E<a!蝸;q8:2/EAB 4eO)OO^)uZ^MO8 'Wdp*Jp~˰WJCM8 Yt*d,d&Wo KǵvG.n~__Jݡƿ=7N_ }Ѝ|06c_zzWY*]J#vM|pt_ xS~G}';R? -]^b2u__/_Ӈ:?a]b=I^XB۬L?WL 0Dh'ou}'?Il?oV^_ CCkX7C@ޗ+!}7_7\O9LҾEC[$WC߿^g>v׿z3?vmx?7iv__i~ :}¶猊D%jZ5&;,Vb]Xi~__a-A _) 1~izI=5~Hl%_\pLRwI]ֻM>*-CVduM^b?1z zdtl#lRjUkMN( Nm&tƛIFLL;ڍ"؊;ئ;J->!lAwViqU Jմ4m.AIa m4l  m2$(M2#@iiZ5JحjBMa(Vpa$*o ᄓAfhMa+ U (M44L4ia@ 0C-0@6Dt6T`5 *)@dGAAt݅PӠb&|LfM8BW&g`}V"t[̨P ^B;U* T4e{Y[ԅ=jd/9 p\ TCFaM@S[>f)<"$*9 uhNˆ}p5d6H & A \LRs$hm:9L0pv$r":a$D+iDnⓙeqsl vKKUl%IL#h m>I6dOps8D0 Ӥ؈=oo ~tNaw_ki8om'K^:O:NV'j~jY$#"hE-(Ou]A.0@?.*"x& 2lgt 'B 4:Qxfy@5̑Dd.?'?4AOA&  Bg  iف0D! 0D@s"L3c$ 8) jApE=.(B p@-h~%~'D5MUSDj$:DǢNYCil&J_M0&DziBwEm ߰'A6q,qlE;6 ŋCǢkE4N*h5 q ?'cT P 77gM0Mt[i\aPja2#L i6) bPTN D6 Ap_0LaIAk0 A;c0 j c4ˈa3E&a:eq#.D&!ZDDhDDDDDDDB")aqDGbK^^ xa/^p׶0@nJ'5eGM2oZ+RmvDvRȈ2QK]d \Wq.e;3ڌFRȐ ffvF`" a\2ĈJ"!T 3[S ﶂia4= i CAuP\-s4s6"\H42[UnKA: <'鴝}] ??C}Ҥ]n}w8?z{_K]uts;~lqND "]ǡ|<َ_~UDfHˊO :?V!SAN ihEԊpNzIT}2x=ft3uD 2y8-ƫM2ߟ80nWս$ou]GǰO?ɳݴܰ:W?/볾zZ뮿~յ׾=ޮ-ސ٤jt}28"k߯4iù%4ǿᑾ< i:_,gKKWXx_ ƕI{\떜dï,Þ{i}-/oK׿!oc}'K/%_(_"w]z%$~IuK__i1_uK$Y"-EGAWՒ=~K"HI*HK }/i}T_ut#Wfц0ݮmSj}}Jq43jѤ.~վ n}ZmI4(uM I4;IOa+Kϻ_&޻JͯTk ^a&[+K^$ 6"9уMz@.0׆1} )~plPA n`b bMiiv $K魴I;#X)G @^6>GTqM|w~ V4i0i8 H4IgPLVj1K6b#mUQi5n}1VN(@0@ `aAUdL@ ؃ J|MBAaS &SIAP=!1AdG@; @ a  4t `jM5&i&&눈!"P$DD acA {AL ; ^Lsa0 &+?Wd6M5hDDDDENDDDDDDDBGF""""""""""""""""")*KJ7*UA$T-%PA(iARTE&kL!h0p0 DLC嶫ҏ--bcKe׏&٪'d;w6E% "ӴXɤD#27sPP`R& ;P&Q+LŪnk`0P[ aTkG|,]p. Y X9\PY '&F>Һo])7#i 4Gan&DN>ӫN㽊M{{_߬}]_"' ) "Dm tS: l\:vjY :fr=|5yΙx:X^$%a0a a 0A<00UиPPA `0hA] |Cr8.z0g4^!k2:5ȡ!3qAg3<|3!:0~d!pf) )f(DnATTDSS$=0I0T64],0UMSCA 0g 0T h\X ,(L! PPA: E.4_4-/(4_} h\aI'P8ABCMH`{ߺ &M5TޓT0Th0HTg亓`ȰG!-Nt2(CIv )2n]l &@e338za"yDyT4]^P;aD):D8Zj Z/ɲ uv\ttuph;% \{K.G H?~X%Of 짠xN4)6]'Irպnm]ޮzhUҿImvK$ۤM앮;i^OopM#uonvVu&~cG[CK^4o\7ta^/}o^1KoKkۦ^;_dž?caO`sXe|]Q ]S!k V]_󀀿˯m/NWx[v';"CPz#?턾7H/_P"Qoƴ@ἇ>?o[֗/׽oo a;k{͠oK KֺAaz}^ww{O%_ ]0i--[[{V___i~kOҿ[{ /ۯoo׊մbMX>0]-KU} ^ͫt&ի@ثA^='i_/}"kk[ %~jQ^ZzA cLiiVUXivհ҆IV#aLD\Sa* Ua X*봿 o /UA )AA <Q0@0 &|06bhP" [kӉ;ûv>SaM d(b )nR V#XatN1PXM(A#rPȎ m4L: @a5 m"""""""4""")DD!5dD 9L&SMkj 8,0 OAID!Q5RQZCږr>]F#/)au$"""""""!2 Ŋ `P^T(:Me [k*2UGɰ.jG"$!ED;+pLLU>v lS"hʃ+ v~(K !v"A3"SX8Hd@P8()Ai: ]i- B" 000j IՂKLʖhTE x:%6 TM4M _~ׯۏT(x*i|A289̆|Rk:yNNضK}/Mvվida@:ON[ut IoV믯U?O_kU]*Q}nt_c#]GB!B! &G^>2 fṡ3ΣSGˢ Tÿgh:H <jC>.- L9p( B a`AahXA4,4/0A` x@"`]ҥu 'UOdqfGQӆjA.pE4o¦ aS4SM<&APvSˊSFzJhgQ m BiiiD/E {JB aAAaNEIs(-L$N/qhhdN'dN.;a;D'8h_~p@A&B 0@CO&WBh0[wO0h7pU IƓ`ȹM2%4Az I @'|< !VE%Dc Ӥ}N'l0%aÙ/12t'Q̜{[K uMoV'zPpAD2ʺNT/ҰdK$.Ro0i:OtZOjիuMkֺRmtO uV·Z~,==~CV_Woz%AT'N=ӥjXbߍ>Dٱ!h)@p%͌ DѱB(D`0Ph"] FEaêD<&<2gj 'l-pSfN,PdC _r!ip rf00›?a*i `DDN3=5TDDDDDDDDDR""""*DDDDDDDDDDE!DG^>UTIky]bI$_&l%nXaJ]jJ) uU mSM5P0P DDD dV䠃 "#,P@n'ɷĐ&d4]4Ș:GbCPCP Pi׵22TDԷ[YU4MYjdQ5/M։H: KUtC]$OZ tyB!rpq@PGAH(Iy"Dq ZxA0A !aHt_UL"wTh/Yq|EE زyWItxA5TOӯ:߯nK_m+Mdp~*o5 PKV*+H/LxXr3X/do$U$:ah,7֡I/T7KҪIwޟIn$6i.."H%_^=-I$DuaaKa$M‘i5E1kiE\GOkR|o\Ri$a4¨MP 궚h5S5 >yM0Ni&."""""""""""3c7&)dMdW(SƢ-&HO+>vqASPRB "L!UFaBqhX[ $0IQ;u…T]SV='#Dt^V>^zrt#gs=;( *>N+W__]~;~a߯#C/sdt"@Σ1H"aa =eАgh2}9d8/$ ;a  * T GP` lA GK΃'g9y3B:a&R u3YיCfgP tHfƙ}3qCj08>8tVSEDF0h5T &vB a3„   2 MIx OH aB :;>(L &N aJE||N bn4&4 BxȾv8hv⍅}6A0`4$SOL CTzaâCӓv}m'Ei?N όI\=N ; 4DPƋ ɜ,0ZH  42s؉cyNDfz}:_pik]=-&$7t^~l*bkۋEzAgA6ȃkE6dX:ZM v0Ӽm&{=_Oӿ_=7ޕZZ_*nO >37OOoJ0A?o~zuz^tzQ ڧ]+WCB1" =]ַKꞮ{_ ޚ߻l?[!___t|}i5_Cc}1i|l>aO#ow ?J۩8bWaMDXD[TLf q/ A߾}Az o_DN 2"Ca޿ a_0oKDh/{%V >C_C_^i_,v_?_ᱷ}%oOZU׽jHGj~~iGA}+wocW׫l_"$Wz^{?zK~['[+_w_'I׽ui_i?'%jX0K#/HIom/ouvv1ćQ1C=c{ C)׷Vc %~[[⛮qWQU!GW5V0=a`8nC_ҍX@'M& &KU]W[ 'L$A uȎ@ E 6( `M1tRia*[J u /aZw ) >6A"  zi"56@A[PAړ&[PR a0rsL(MpD1¶C@ 8A4j*p6Dt0ASM&L&  B:k""8GF#"0`Aaja80Za]/aS[AEp@­L/ji >Y2&nSvhLѝ mM?`A "DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA\"}I~Bb\PaR|PJ l p`N'eY^Dhc_6iqn/ $jȁyn&AL!YC- (h+ABg' \@dE88 I;3C!fv0Z#TJ'BA`;i݄AAm= Azd 7 SMv踮 A|(U[ڦɣd&ia Z/Y|;i:EIMO!I6vZ ;Vm:M~L AtH4"Rɓ3tt'_xOO__~zKk[l Z>_%Z;uO*&]c޿ Ć3$C%`AYiLȌ[vW&&")251Nyf20xD9"#&2Fm*L *L „p!L0@A&B(Y;4fxdh͌0$ȃ%͊]`DBPAA džxaMJ2`UKUD꞉A*.&aAi0~fBa0*SOj'h xe 1::1faƋΐm4N' v~5U# *'m E / $b8_8ia,t A?^oI'IdOtt A@.i{h 1=2%mJNjRpdQ6Pj XBzMt880KvNl'IaV'mҾ?U^^鴵꯯ZMtӵi>_$)D#CR _C~륾ߦ_[׏Vmq xxzz^tz21__P%mz D?C u:&_/,oĿ#O-}_= A~_~}}H''Y0J_U-onAi]__a/_o#! W~I%$?~jc}?//GC~}m\%ﴈzNz^o8kkz8Ɨ¶YwI/_KW[[}?K kgԿM6L5^_[ҵuu{tPP IPa+ |RVpW\?ac}U.msj_t]mZiH`+1W*+^)P0iv׵_/:iQK]6*w^ڦè8NBaRP0 Du@ Ma+LAA5zlkIvAZL4iӦ*T ]0.M'Om 4m6ih`0@ :ڠ @`LS{"AAM`h BD!dɂܙT\vA\4iik0P_Mm  DDlDDDDDDEBaL22Օ4 & $}Э{""*""#m\DDDDDDDDDDDEtz+im]Um7ieh,0[ fO L(&0Q+L} Eb2RgtE[l(L*a2;3f@FB8VTԄL@m|-ރ ݨPPvKEuZWr 7י(26I/tʨIz3d]Z}UT吩;i%zT>!RN hr3'̈@`4"q!NE"TCDpFGa>T52@K3 tA?8)p kP>4nC6*a O A34A0Pp " /4"IE(bF٠QD_ !D<] dL3:q t""D"lRN P L * C*Ó'tNQ8jAD"EEDpQn`Ҧ=4alPtAa 2p˄fc4B &h4A0L A` B$ة5ACA:Mw4l6 h& &78g@'Oqqhgi޸I0`t*a ASAlTl҃$a4'aa .B?>]d}үҗ.hn&}.0_X_.XoA~/FD}?Via~6޿ ׿}C$`adF$d5? . 1S _mOH܇LW#Kkkd$z_=/}zH[^n}_+[_׼ʴ.mI׺oz{6ڵݮi]}zKm[ Z_K[]߯mozݿS lm U XRЈi{[ \ a-L )ɵtfJB4Pa22T8/ y\L!>f*:ӻM6.l84'c1(H^ _I~v\[)ͷ^v_ץ]$Z-$ tx$G "9dzG4 Haɲ:R6Ffu6 &G:*%t4i * hf ƃ>A? (L N@м"2 BC6GQJ#l`'#'U tH3%/I'N!5  ASD5H'JPB 4$TO*a (L P@͠BB!C&lgPB6CEgiRM{__wN}}u{ۡ:MkioӰ][_OO^~7k1}$?:k׮&9kWcucc`סx/,D/釥>'?_X6#~׿A|߭OIMaAw/ՆA}}.#Kk_i~uonw߯O1A]߯A#4{_K`6v~]jS]}V޷/iKR~ҺtsRi~VXa_ x_WG\:ۭX&Gŭ)}_ lB0Ah9 =0 $E H0L&A4d(;jI[JTEE Bz]jkwUWdW4a0 a0j! AAA0 {   dP@بa&d(;MKk %0ω>f>)x kS]. NLؚ ›>YpKSFlAM2Cov_ C (4l(M UE4@qDDDDDDDDDDqĆ)p0R0a{Sq&a/l*I8GF"C]K^a"*i:UD.Űa(b2*U֔G H()lNaҪ]*.J" `TUDq ?0?o endstream endobj 47 0 obj << /Length 5408 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im48 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F49 11.94 Tf 75.60 708.24 TD (monopoly as it was before) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf 126.48 0.00 TD (" resting on competitive merit. ) Tj /F49 11.52 Tf 152.16 -.24 TD (Id.) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf -242.64 -28.08 TD (The ) Tj 21.12 -.24 TD (Microsoft ) Tj /F49 11.96 Tf 50.40 0.00 TD (decision) Tj /F49 11.90 Tf 40.08 0.00 TD (, applying the treatise) Tj 102.96 -.24 TD (, presents a more complex) Tj /F49 11.93 Tf 125.28 0.24 TD (, yet similar) Tj /F49 12.14 Tf -375.60 -28.32 TD (situation. Microsoft developed the Windows operating ) Tj /F49 11.93 Tf 268.08 -.48 TD (system and the Internet Explorer browser) Tj /F49 12.05 Tf -268.08 -28.08 TD (lawfully, through its own innovation. Microsoft was found liable of excluding effective) Tj /F49 11.96 Tf -.24 -28.56 TD (competition from middleware) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 148.32 0.00 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F51 10.70 Tf 53.76 0.00 TD (373 F.3d at 1228-) Tj /F49 11.92 Tf 97.20 -.24 TD (, conduct that reasonably appeared) Tj /F49 12.06 Tf -299.28 -28.08 TD (capable of making a significant contrbution to maintaining Microsoft') Tj /F49 11.94 Tf 338.88 -.24 TD (s operating ) Tj /F49 15.00 Tf 55.68 0.00 TD (softare) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf -395.04 -28.08 TD (monopoly. ) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf 58.56 -.24 TD (United States ) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 66.24 0.24 TD (v. ) Tj 10.80 0.00 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F51 10.50 Tf 53.28 0.00 TD (253 F.) Tj /F49 11.84 Tf 30.72 -.24 TD (3d 34) Tj /F51 10.76 Tf 27.36 0.00 TD (, 79 \(D.) Tj /F49 12.17 Tf 36.48 -.24 TD (C. Cir. 2001\). Massachusetts sought) Tj /F49 11.95 Tf -283.20 -27.84 TD (an order requiring Microsoft) Tj /F51 11.56 Tf 142.56 0.00 TD (inter alia) Tj /F49 12.20 Tf 50.16 -.24 TD (to ") Tj /F50 7.55 Tf 17.76 -2.40 TD (grant a royalty-) Tj /F51 11.63 Tf 73.20 2.40 TD (free. . . right" to ) Tj /F49 12.00 Tf 82.32 0.00 TD (use the source code) Tj /F49 11.94 Tf -366.00 -28.08 TD (for Internet Explorer \(the ") Tj /F50 5.00 Tf 128.64 0.00 TD (open-source IE" provision\). ) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 138.48 -.24 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F51 10.73 Tf 53.28 0.00 TD (373 F.3d at 1227-) Tj /F50 9.43 Tf 85.20 0.24 TD (28. The) Tj /F49 14.23 Tf -405.84 -28.32 TD (governent) Tj /F49 11.93 Tf 57.36 0.00 TD (, however) Tj /F49 11.98 Tf 47.28 0.00 TD (, had failed to prove that Microsoft had attempted to monopolize the) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf -105.12 -28.56 TD (browser market or tied the browser to the operating system. ) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 290.64 -.24 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F49 12.70 Tf 53.52 0.00 TD (253 F.3d at 46. Thus) Tj /F49 11.90 Tf -343.92 -28.08 TD (the ) Tj /F50 9.65 Tf 17.52 0.00 TD (governent argued) Tj /F49 11.99 Tf 92.88 0.00 TD (, in light of ") Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 61.44 -.24 TD (the ) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf 17.52 0.00 TD (viable claims ) Tj /F49 12.32 Tf 66.48 0.00 TD (remaining after the Cour ) Tj /F49 11.95 Tf 124.56 0.00 TD (of Appeals) Tj /F49 11.89 Tf -380.40 -28.32 TD (decision) Tj /F50 8.29 Tf 39.84 0.00 TD (, ... remedial ) Tj /F49 11.93 Tf 74.64 0.00 TD (measures targeted at Internet Explorer are unsupportable.) Tj /F50 9.23 Tf 274.32 -.24 TD (" Response of) Tj /F51 10.62 Tf -389.28 -28.32 TD (the U.) Tj /F49 12.02 Tf 29.52 0.00 TD (S. to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed Final Judgment 12,- 22 \(D.) Tj /F49 11.90 Tf 390.24 -.24 TD (, Civil) Tj /F49 11.95 Tf -420.00 -28.08 TD (Action No. 98-) Tj /F49 11.16 Tf 73.68 0.00 TD (1232) Tj /F51 10.34 Tf 23.28 0.00 TD (, Feb. 27) Tj /F49 12.57 Tf 41.52 0.00 TD (, 2002\). The cour agreed) Tj /F51 11.72 Tf 124.08 -.24 TD (, affrming the distrct court finding ) Tj /F49 12.00 Tf 173.28 0.00 TD (that) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf -435.84 -28.08 TD (the proposed relief - depriving Microsoft of ) Tj /F49 11.72 Tf 214.08 -.24 TD (lawfully-) Tj /F51 11.13 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (acquired royalties for IE - was not) Tj /F50 5.00 Tf -257.52 -28.08 TD (suffciently connected to the violation. ) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 189.60 -.24 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F51 10.73 Tf 53.52 -.24 TD (373 F.3d at 1228-) Tj /F50 7.81 Tf 85.44 0.00 TD (30. In a nutshell) Tj /F51 11.26 Tf 80.16 0.24 TD (, the cours) Tj /F49 11.88 Tf -408.72 -28.08 TD (found that the proposed remedy of royalty-) Tj /F49 11.93 Tf 205.20 -.24 TD (free licensing of IE ") Tj /F50 7.67 Tf 99.84 -.24 TD (ignores the theory ofliability in) Tj /F49 11.72 Tf -305.52 -28.08 TD (this case.) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf 54.48 0.00 TD (Id. ) Tj /F51 10.42 Tf 17.04 0.00 TD (at 1229.) Tj /F49 11.97 Tf -36.00 -28.56 TD (A subsequent paragraph of Areeda & Hovenkamp ) Tj /F49 12.21 Tf 242.88 -.24 TD (- not cited by Rambus ) Tj /F50 8.13 Tf 110.88 0.00 TD (- confirms that) Tj /F49 5.00 Tf -317.52 -41.52 TD (See ) Tj /F51 10.41 Tf 19.92 0.00 TD (373 F.) Tj /F49 11.98 Tf 30.48 0.24 TD (3d at 1230 \(relief designed to ") Tj /F49 12.01 Tf 149.04 -.48 TD (eliminate the monopoly altogether) Tj /F49 12.00 Tf -271.68 -13.68 TD (requires a stronger ") Tj /F49 11.90 Tf 97.68 -.24 TD (causal connection between Microsoft') Tj /F49 12.00 Tf 182.64 -.24 TD (s anticompetitive conduct and its) Tj /F49 12.15 Tf -280.08 -13.92 TD (dominant position in the. . . market \(for operating ) Tj /F49 11.81 Tf 243.60 -.24 TD (systems\)"\).) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000239583 00000 n 0000239642 00000 n 45 7 0000239754 00000 n 0000239918 00000 n 0000286348 00000 n 0000240446 00000 n 0000240065 00000 n 0000240194 00000 n 0000240319 00000 n trailer << /Size 52 /Prev 239256 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 291822 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000343378>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R ] /Count 8 >> endobj 52 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 53 0 R /Contents 54 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 53 0 obj << /XObject << /Im55 55 0 R>> /Font << /F56 56 0 R /F57 57 0 R /F58 58 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 56 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F56 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 57 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F57 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 58 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F58 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 55 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im55 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 44879 >> stream SIKǖ倿 m-# *f-1)ԛ\;-,dv)fJHF3 gd24|/ … ^ Bk]hJHY94Jv ?UqDbgdNiZ\0>?Wɶ"΋דa<ࠁ A6D#03u#Α5 3B5 ̎لCY Ȥ GZIur9i(8f %z&,(E{#L'ͣPft0r#(A  S Ba |ZdL AB 0L B a, a!#1p9B !(]S™TF\Rdx";(bǐ sc!0Sp@B-  `Ah `CbN`"wRPAh$eh0in 4 6Lة}k<3PkCL9qix)B{Zh9A$Plщhı/Qj&rıO'^4m_4^cM;` d]&C4P&I<.8:$_ jhN&'UO`x 0xx%Z'nw_Nf6!s1Iϊli7F-"87Ei6OON b|'A6 159z@4773y>9A 'A f)t "-kpպպm_Ҧ}i-oovZMZIR6%`Ȯ+pzr0I|&ڸZ^zP+tm&Om'WOVtM~_־TM >ﷺZtBnk:[^^nUk^}n-ۺ]̉K_ｺ~_Pclwиإ߯]Kx:C7c?V}%_=Kc K߽W,GX,9b~X5&6nLpD}_ X"鬴Y7M"C|?aVB#?}xV|Wpza't_/K/{wKko,wݲD??CAa聺7ῠao솿~kWi~^s ژHܑ#d??X7H=?kڿWju'o^?YQ_zk'_[m%I{~oKwaiuu׶{o;}{Ko[[m[_ұN/^ZR~c ZRLXk#Wil4 $ol/ޮKa?kk"?҃ f7ᄡ .KVZMlWkLU;ثJ[)+mX+ kkkkkM1LWU@ `0iI &)]m:MSPl{TT0Pa-wJիᥱ8i_kw $NPӆiam 6@@"B0@A `a2#@  h:h` @Ӥӏ)h6SA` ! biݦ `h0@ڃ0!i?)weŸ2 '–A t„a0Aª 0 A iB 4x0:ڂ2ဃh2(પڵPh0 5^"5!0XC)\0P aB$iN6 `L`DDDDDDDDDD"""""""=$*("]R @ P@Pj"7\%+"l*)^IN  jInbM0$ E s U$ +ID30*m0r4`UΈrO%&J$;_k-}ׯꫭ&e9cyQdt;믬 `CD["D82vlgAD>M! #:CftJ8h LCR@k2pB$hs5gyyFuKq&F"6=g\Q2>NFA3L #l3l#lyS&U͊iqa 0Tܐ)S 4A !a0P `0 0 7 W60!!!ؠSaP@B е> fA* nREEESE=4IڨMv8aSD<0I$$T"CPAMv L& &`|&P 50(M3oD݂ip …D :$;Ai9 't&OQ<4786H6}ؚ 4nEx;qx¦qLQ;hQ'hzh''3HB~]?/_,X=?༴j𾠽?_"OoaH?X}&D [ô ?77(Ko^Dulo}]ou/A_䏯;X{$`_Ka}"z?ս/}޿K Kwk?kimiXog7mo׻_uWWKwu^^_Kҽ{K__i_ݧkkf?.juW[Wk۶߯WU__/[MWO1k_ ج)bۯzպkVԿa(kتvo‘A,iA* ;N@OjVG}Z{ Kui}iՆ :{a}/8@${[kEo`ki 7jiaA0L b0i >)ի[b XI} (h+N҉kǼlRm'!lR{1vk#ΥS a 0  Յzi@i`0A$ A 6b0B0d 0@a 4im&ao@a 6DMDDDF0AL&W>)|ؙqؙ )7 &{T͉؁h0ADGA׆]Rc8MiӄԻkL& \a> - aAN80aUST¨"#""""""4"Sa0eFla" atlDDDDDDDDEDKKuVY ]AN0AE? ԣEx? OӤ7NO+WVtn6 ʇt~'o\io[) z.QA8:-EI1NuonoKTzKWWWi: ?=l__Njz~W^WKҩ,ut^6=q]K~k^nUkWKuuW?k PcKXaihRҪ*]B?~x-0{&'Hu⸧_펪 re\ ]-Ukuף=/YݤnZ~z_ ?DJ7J*MUmz^K_jۤzGH}/׿i HKZ{?_9?^zk_ҪVVwm׿t߿K~ouozW~TZUֺ幔A];w;KU]N?z~+}Ji /fթu[־ڿZkiP/tES~ZkO+^ [J׫NҰiVM8R= ԿAsz -uTWKUVתa$kՉkƶ (bIl4kamSv!a bSU%֖^J$ E_}@B:S"LUaX@ aHGTm5QAOMciv=oJ)3DΪTB atN4iSM|MRM{A{"M40 &jwMS0AGU!5X ZBMWPBA4j"8"%(GV =`vŸ@ 0@a20TMK5ʀ p LTװM4 a0U0UxaA"eDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!$!"#_q_!Ck馾"/,aUeeqjTg|RfBQ# S;DR;2w .&OiApPP\ J(n\-Wh`JEq;xEl'>w<\U u_]}}WU幠Ab!d|: HFyHFqǝ&GE\z'f:ǢȃB!RjJH""7}d8D5rMh0>(L& AhX& 0x"00 aA0 aB# ! !"qdCŸ03S A# jl&Da63xfcFA9C"qC g< ɱD6NDI&;I4$' * .T3b*`iiM?pT@BL0T.\i'Pa? `L/zA6XLwAL` M5OENEBE㋗mSQ;&\I2tw E e&>Ca44Hv;`N(N4 ʪwLy33"vӤ`ȹzEƓ&!6 Ob|[i6kC`ȹI{: o'2QI.ttmxQ({(q4:~EC--uzkim]ӟ? xL-&Id\t=?M}:M"G'wmAK'JHz~5}uNm[iuVAI^ZIoIm_+էiCUVn?]?_}]Uu7]}/Cb^鵿oڵ ~׻7uOlU}_ +~1qU~ kKV Wk 8_+-Z`7ׇU+0:i>Ɂ𸅄M"Cۯ `HX~o/, A:;D%~ۯo"Oo?_h%K/ޗo/aߠ^HEׯd4 k7_^}A iנ/ZsO?\>??_HUHG7_qky7wkug3Ɨ꿞ߪ39?zomn[I/m/_]{zooIkiZNV޿ڞ_moҿ&^Ra&[/TݩA?a[uU{k_U}+OK_Tk醰J06mkb8ik_Ja^4uK[al'aKjm/w _ [c{ _]=2=iM4'~m-ƪ[mZ  &aGCb;Ո>㆓uC}ڦ1]1VoIb5Պ#b*ȐAadX@ mh! 0]@ 6(0@ؤ6( `Lt!!) ZiSxӾ :)h8AqT`T -jaj…Pӵ^PMa4j AAU h`A,:dG@ 6& p $IIBiDDDDqE"`DeDDDDI"]gN 0L „a3ZA:{*ژp a0 & S IјLח0L&L+܃a IGHDR hDhDDDDDDDDDDDDG޵JuZ]$;5 iietjXKB dX1\+J8A&+U]8AaiܹqL&iqO+dG&2S3; ̋B;d'P[ dS1S2Մɰ|((\(&4‚֡iBKEc ([A$dXčgd9.`,:NKpeh20)>"K8_ֵ°a4<"7>.PP0(H P)͑\$ P͓"k'21̐S4S2jQg }A2I7ߦIտ]]&].WMm'wuM iZN*M ~qO_ӻBwI&ҿn7_}%kWL&n&/ۦo{[^|6:j6KK߭ I[KWZU|[. q}c_VcпCQ`D8#t ɎhL='ej__ K?aD /HDX>Ў,K]jШHɌ& K囩^'a{aGaw- <0]_"Qm 7Fww%ߴ m_Jn#'$Ia x>$^ߐC_`vH^CH/O~ Cz>~vS%림V_#FHS;ߥk﴿~wWuFwߊ޿mkmov_6_Ӥ_w߷_i~ޫ}ᄛIiu}iZ5ҵ}a-]JlTqXR=vߘޮՊ鮴צ K0Vҳ0ORv[ &­0PJV0X^0\5{Ki* "@aiG %a };J)SbcZ!5늊IV?݊;bi Xa 0@iiALmE6lt?b!pµzm'[lkצc D*C8a&AL&l&BPI# 'T BpAm A5@[!A lP m4A  `jB:BA i@cXDF]F `L"r jkAShcfɡ4L NA_ al)7ZMAVaBa 0#AQDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDN`IP^hLց({+AlFfkelpB"""""""#up4„2nXʶd/yi^ˤ̔0 Gq2)v}? P`"lL0PR aS T z,v[( (~U5Do*Qqƅ:!=8Ѹֿ][]uE,_%aZ`ȣn>)m-&ϊpS NoI:ZAdK:AdKhh 6ƋzOMAg/h4m(Kq4P@(q=qit Im^p-{^ӫ§j6zmuzt&ϊpl333Y? [>2:0&ń6xg{޿^~o鮞*VMոV OB6֯^?W:u~л켚>?ӽui{Wuu]:_Vaߨi!+{\_>G}{cp_Ru?⿯?^ ,@z?ܱ۩`k-9:ԟ࿓߯?a_B?A__z_z -{7K4}?G#k}i_k~[7b_$_y{kkkuۯoivun_Km/m}Kooц~_~iioiZW_kv_mo}i{ [u#c~c LUZ?K jxK0a{ /]1V#-Toi}m .Z☨u>m-nՊmSnA?jl0Wm$X[K!GQQ@QAlLU lRmSa&=7ja%;ciw tM1vHX+VKl5iiIiZj+ BL'M4Mm4A0@) LP@ t @OH44Mx"lPA0h`0AQLP aM1PaK&W“p! (MA8Aa^A[ ඕ YdAa0Aam L0iSkN p Ӧ08"8"""" D0ŕX&=@‚ aӆcXa3] Lf +?T0B!A'0!DDDDDDDDDDG~~KBVVwQ\0@1a'8t\DAYTZd@lHKL1S;ID$Kay\YFwVK ٨SAat (PRei&j4pE AAN. ടvWT]7T]0)1;[vIrO.z$ }Rk]Tw-r\ģC̅Bw7IM?fW_׽/Uתֺ!*ȶqk//02H R _3"3#A ^,35:H3q(yaNdzRc#5\*7!y茥`&gAa݄ B@A‚<d`8(* &gD CO"Yr@``4 Ehdxd<#ʈ("2/͌FƂLV!<8L >Dߦa0ZTHxUM@oCag  &AL xABatBJUO[N=|㗍Ã& 203EO(`м&qrB5ND Ip}&6S T"N„h08$?MAS' L'Nܜpd4NxN$ i=:A'naA3.![i7646'tq/h_| 0/A 擠HAM:M_[]va:}$ߪ\Or.{"XM#tz:M"ppd[6:_&?_ i>au om~e{w.^[޿굽_  B>ŭ {zm~{w_և}*>տڨcX?/b1 uBK|VCK}XX 0arX`ܴ11 _ /X|q\"qoaH{ 0$? BɍQ2_`+Z ۽ }l"C$a"QaXoa KA/XKh'_o, ` o t<6sb ح/O_+K%<6?lׇH,_+ԍA|z^z^_i}VݫuuzkOk~i}pWui{as>"Y _)_K_j]f-vTkv]]ct )َ08j҉m/vOV.:i }b޾_j_b&G[Vob׍v*Y  `b lT~&E<I :N[Ob}.UWQ[KǶݮ %J8ᄺjUqm'a&3  dGQTS"B !1Ah@ o!taSZimPAH0A6h `=D#me0j)LR LO0œp0g&5@ kT״Ծljm&, Ah IN iZUij"""""""""""""""""""""""""B"!. 2#^( ``&W ԻL 5_M5&“ΏL#P`D ?DDDDqi|{!|?tfB\^#QW1KAPp[;R4gxg̒"ˬT$ vn#FK P.wڙI.%xPK kye^hekvvHA `) ;X_|w_' ]IbWJ;QY+].AT(t}^ꫮ*:ץ_]}R]WH]uYDa2cW]RIV}oUA&`:"D %]ЊAG6FNh)V D>(DsY=dDj#y{0"AERFufI$gJ٬ԫ"8r5yЈ՞a3^-nCxL&|PA (A0L | yafCB„,K`T0 ΘRPKC 3A1D80Ag0 p)B ;hh 0d&M0p¦OUMT !k* SK3p`#fpAe'TIS<(* 4pPa0P~vPiDqq\Z'Ƌpe'Ah`-4_4^2ADQ8I*x.GT!꿑źOаdM|SDvPcD&f'dp &gpS ."'E}72. ߶fh'l@RŪ/wi"(r-DIa N-: g6TxRmWtim&R}]i7 }"sUs! AInMzk~mO__K֩=k;VRw_vu]K~_uu|un_\OWkkJkQKKE.JZ ~ثq]t_۩b=? _?_JM*B? +k_nQ7+Uw?&G"O/[=%I[/.KJG/t(? د}- _ѩKZmU}./ _w/ad/m/\G^H*꒷_iCW/Fp__w*ҭ!ԺZe^Da}vH-O_{uWa_=muwuKKK]v.I~_mm&f;.4m&KJ6aiyY/э%FE_ZZi:\! xylVb8/PGkuWҤI5]KZ%.ty}KVXi_4UiSy`qڍE}vumDqGi+LpKǶ$445!iiE1KlUi>B:CѵM1Iv7a&*2uM ӦMm*%a%Ճ -|RRul"I*aXi4{M1 Xqi^MAqL0A&6i&a063 2#! Abg֪ATخiBe ltTSNp@h4 頚 LhQaaa<[UOa`aBi 5[M[PW iC]4WUA&U{ m* ii5"*"""8"$0L&pP0 jgL*a5׆0A/84HL RrvrBuB$i1h@a8}="""""""""#"""""""8;ZU]X0K;/]+KGPZ@IRcgrDDDeZlWR2;]>[k;-*bvW]uUZ^sRB9" \0@ 2N,* dzNA(FA 2aWx*Bi 82tOCN:]5L oiIht_Q|DhhhIdo'EƓzM^)մޓ^zq}]Q{dA}&7 ?D?]kxo/ܑ/aԼ K_i74Jc[x|R}cbWڵM`@d#8M6* Zm5M'M@h5Ui&s00L&$> j""""""""""#w5 ~?Ra6[GbZId0$2Ha2 Ɂ #d N4ӹd#Ph)DF'ɺwRG__b^뫻ݥ]}־kX_W_WֹȌ1UyLe\^K.` 𤀦a @4!auHf<*a !٘f2p! @ɳ5 `C3XΤO>qˢe$DO:dDffI!՘34D6PGQQrZ\fa " FepMM={hk 顮zz'Aa0B0B haJ00C'4.3  `!! a|]P'lZP#pdž(a$;! ?7v-4MSOL* 0za47T SCh:mII &IDH6ơhmA# UPvD6I;D.N("V7; hI'l"NشJ%n8hvtcHHӥ}[]Fr#ߐt(wmm oX2-i-?Zunvi#$O:r}wȐҹ^VȷJJ[O׮u} ߭}^KZ_"Bۯ_WCh/민Wo_v}PkIWK1^G~F+H_5cGKڵTto?džvo//'}Fr=Ԋ#o_o%8uQ}Gvׯ}m}׷s]6gOf<vtA/Mgfwk柾ifwO֗V~cK{{3m]u텿oJn[Vߪ߶빽vҵ[KWknc1X[`b7~*5ئ+?j %k04.bkmmtҦRiE1W5i5!I5kI݄m$߽X?V+I=66+ئ*ՊMتbVA :n)N! 4a8 6 ! 0itNb~45Mpj*R1_‘\ 0kkkuxa&l&6J„h[M.LȃjMM5I0""""#2R@ E D &5G .w [ L0&aSA3fR"""""""""8/aW?_BAΓ Eb?Ze2'B2/\v喡 aB233$E(]L) B+iWWQ7mdvZկw+Xk}'r \!8񰄁I6F p%D'1Ooy}I"r 'pa*qh$ƋƋZ'֩x{z{7>:M6i{zzDðtA >I6nE `ȹK wm޽kWOuO^rҷy08JVo_iK}}|7޿_KIuI~~)_>~]-zBNoOƱ#% UBǏua/kx˙I?^/tտOI_|k.޲(}/&3Z,@,%o׿7'DDz/(G_\^auu_D?Mo߯~(% *7iu_|?sH`}5~C?$]=\߿8Wڗ޿u;5vkٜWfܝWIzi%~]k)z_=?Z$}iomUio_iaXikz_[RcͯJwтvUkuk M /]bku@z~lmNmtwҶK0SV+&+nOخAnaz5 %qQ]EZQl_DZW.iZ]ԁxki4]?ڶ 0 4( (=!Y dGU@ A!GմݧR}+J\4 ZTQL0LPA` tua{[[;]aL:k|M5V 0dG#a4 h&hq@Q @ Pb 'l'OeH(GX,&&lA`a ha0V.D0La6)Mv|A"."""""""%""""""""2p:B""8i%KU`_WI/u_A 뤑]D$$0CBP_$qa/UV4A &XL&a0QRӹP;YU@♡uPn:k/}]ZW;Uv___K_PDg"1)"dcL fUR9QjJ|.[Ddje%"1" {NG࠘@ C4f0= @`h\a@B 2 !0f` *d#(#੅ &a *gPT6*`P(CTxPC0004a 0 &h0A (Mv/&5Dv'J *; Z$-xI]L=N:i4ljDp0 i<"8~ƉD(aS MNghm'@~&vm EE_LE6[&vI%nCwDN+mWDnI%m'I`h #v ]7a=tٙ ՂI. )6xScIo34p}wI][dYմm]>ȑIoGw`ȹҿau Un_m7]=_kONu|zkuWo5ֽ}:z 鿯װt?z=[Qޮ^+W5_ڴi>zXaLG0qa_Qa/_v/G~B5 WoqyzaytwȰV/Z7#mz[7HB1'}B K ~$(E#$ZE//__zz Zi~~z._K]_=/^tuh4_vho?ҽ뭺׳5ٜ{_~{?}6a,lk[V k7{J}Uv=yK]s'i x_bڠ=XI[(دvҵ4oxacaR={w6aƶ|WmZVJ붭PiFjzQdu1SaX)t?bب?az0ALP `;h `a2Um6F4Atb)bv];Wcj6)6M v8IM[i 5TBMl BM06DxMDdHIAiBNH[MSA:BjM2$ 22L`.F=\f aSڟ?“p )70^ ¦siM6h0pLG 04p aa4jAfʢ"""""")aDDqDDDDDDDDDIA@0A445@N t  DA2^DDDDDDDDDDqֿRi%H%*Na /8yQRTeo-3%FTT…3*NLfBYwb))2!:x*!wPf IaMjo `%c;$tiùW\TEk^_Wd6E h2R#dr2 P]ԏR2d]Ht5 As0d ]dtiL՟y&G\FY&ʄBA Y#^u!D#1٬dn1QAyqD8$x.`9M:Az`aaL P`(Laa#A;0@B 0 aAa 0 3O!<30 3a2( fLd1b \^~&apT axMPL$h4N'tN(UZ Mq<*z` ?COV-7}-45xL-ƂZ ƉE'IҾ-d/ A'='mS &z%(v0(Q7~F%tJ ,l`$ސ:NtzMv`R'EƖub$%xv@ 2%''MaHKOȐGtȾy+~"]&ҽ'ot] CMZڿ'ߒ`l'inzzVmnB=/}{Mk]]7M_ZOu{O}{Jݿm'?w\_F7]=|~?x=Do~?_cֶ=]z_ _}uÇ_J?ת&1b<-_X% _޿{t!__/m"hDR$ut ?"Q~}B= B?A׿׬%WlH%#oxߧ~߿\///_o w.od޽/]?suNZozKK]/׭0ٟnӵ߽~5ݯ+I_UXkU^߯ھ~׵vmS|%0|0V+ Dѩ1M0K7zeyuko8V/m'OimmZ!,Tq^ױNq%?zQi^ ;uڭjk7ZZa>zڎv$6*bcj4 HQm&N)i4+i/㽫IaLA11MҥjհiiaA6MSl aTQMP lP@`Gⓐn)4V\0APj)QLBAz&`h27,4 & M/XaB 5%ݪȃԓtMH9n( L:i]BdXȮH0LƱDDDDF]D"g"Q a?0 O;aaLi4A<<g OD)ɠfRDYFlqM_DDDE,DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD}kUiiW-LK $+®6 j $@ɺa\DG0GYIl'S;Wt+&d}W_ibx_YdYdN!C@"\E"lgQ &l!胦a L'L&AI# Za64tN蕾B(%mGn,{y wIV820hd#B9'"Klmn ӫziտ &ŠI{ }﯏ֿB_7[okڅoo)/__K{ooc?uK^^__b_޿Ka4WA>QQZa(LW!C"BSM!L ؤ!TAWa5l&æPB ]0tD[a0@0A$buN%>#@0"""8h=.6ABґ6!G6vN&TT"#$&ٝ2ӌΖqx΂* h3&[̂ѝfFdwTE$K$4^.+eH!(. al-a0p-t 7t*pPP] (,"-eLSYtMުP~;Ga`ӽHm,Co w4e3}icm +25B-nw}iz^WF{O__^o;j);63(p΃:|(|Y @GtD<ȧ9Ϥ5pٞ4z]>ȷ3='<7z[]~}&/ץi;^O#O7SN:77n߿_Ckoo}^[Z^U_ {_ئ㍊uD;.\_x?2MtUoI_+z4#Xb_X|/-?rj ɕ :ɎD|=_//&:%O$=Rma//Џ)cy1ῂ^ר/.v%{׽}%{hV?$?I=~ koP kk/ᇯRAk7d4}Az ?֖Sw?KۻorEd }:__@?v߿[7w#;^_SԿ׫ۯiڤ߿IO7kz{^N鴩_߫KoJKֽt)=_qߩ~an#ֽ  *Ma67MjKi ~1Rҫa?׸ l0Mu۶qI]>4m8j $KwaHvkkCi$p±QUT4[X`-[Kqݯ}@87iq8^ZPAqA" A2$& 5YvdHA @A@AdGA0@ 4ⓦXjՍiP lW6`i&nMe8\&2+ "%k a cڤӸIV   ApA r$ @aHidG¤&PUa"""""" qpFЈ` Pe&~GF&wL|~Xaxk~PG A &5GSe&A` ʨ&0ʚ$=»>"""#"#TKU}*, kޕ%aP-; %Ch1 "?GJ?(QMI0Tϙ+ԣ"ffE#X2p$w *PmN#*P S܏ep0?@ q'vӾ.Zqwpse^ R*X8;D`*]go&JUZ/-̞C2Hdm$'깐E _W!ADK"|p&`B M|#pS@: 3AD.A.lSlgA#':W#?_>zZֽ5]tM{&ZW[~;OB[_^=kzKۦ_o|ZR/~B+Wnnկi;B>#A? /i_פ } ta0^XXdaN7D "O_}v?` o/A{?aD~j:]h/ynu;//nZ]z~Ch7d?n:__?m/L nߵ_?0 a~]_kO_kk_]{^[uki]kk_i6im^_ۮ]'Kt{ﵵ_[k]Gݴ zuaW=}\->vko}cۯ>~_ukm~ az &&\5&b87c؃pҏa i6ZM}]Zl0iҰ{{Zwb dG1R4:i :  b0AM6)i1Va0KvP aiD04֬$ &ڮȎY&@MAU &M4BiM'ma0A  uE lP ݊d#MdGQTHGmE  0@KP`0s a0A|a0A`d&3Bey4l .![Rc1 &j0ApUip h0 ,0")b&C !5rNž (&.aOP@`a0B'^]""."""""""""""8_ޗ_땰z/[jP@l4]l'Y&ho?ڏeL;"̍2UUHa0a0S"#*--"42EL˲djLaT ‚ࠠBa0a<((]B^t…T Ap e]BRW_Z띚ٮW!VH <㲳]tCC g!~iAƆV 0q"F8꾗uK﮾믵 z/4P)͑g\2D &r-APz/zmmſ}k҄VWV: a: s2(䜋k6ȱ'IEp _yz_֓i_ׄ>ޮNMt<-vP7nn_i>~mǾQM{6CM~t}~Oƽ? /kk?#[}zW_bO⫥^_}`oD$N|  [_nW.3D=H'u7w_-/aoA?_p׷I~C_HG _/__ּ~j޿E$`ޗHlu__JZzKќ+_mݴW!ݭoO5҆SkkZkV1sp.vżSV % ${j+00_^߯?a֥S{_N4bxڧK1M}kbv޻v`C_cMR]zzii[i=i^[Uwm_Uq_jp֓%)Bm 0@0a `! S ` A魐0AaIm8ڊi0i mF!AA  AA `$9>p0_0Oa{^L ի"9gPL&P6DAh&la a bA6" jNiݴa{ _mq'DDDDDDDDDDDH C0L0A0L is0aBAL&fcq &(PL2(3:uL#aW8DDDDDDDDDDDE'i*XJ&+QXQXU * (l~3Em^Y&+ eّC+;;BM&(.  ]NB… U\(U`B26'#pDCR!<)aK8.`Rav6(A48!m &~L4*a0V0]3XP00CB$Z#L `P` jzBalTƕ6a"yD탃ř'xxtO/i9Ex;hCM"vдN& &(N;IPPz0Tv,"OM0T MS +TIaw #:6}$EwH'I`>2%1 G&` 2-m''A@ð|: N 'pdNh0p9vtv|Evbg3Aa<+}nA+I7O; }t<0z޽+5I$ߪMkff!A;Ԏ&4 t$ Mm֛wz`O]oxMZB}MZM OCMN'ߺ},Ul&'KzJn+Hm~IWi2_K_z=uZWZKo}~;Wko~KixJ/צ~ޕo_|n/^!uE}_zKKkaS_!,o,g:AtLo,`?J^9!ak֮c瞟_&ȵx"NHW?DW_~ LG4^AJ?Vta_{h AWa ]wނ~[ o۝^k4FخHk/A_iV_a3pH$foJIlRU6nC__܇HeI/FOGa{KaMcWZ~ڿm_$/׿ҿѓ_kGO{Kkoi;ko[_oޯizKk{i2?{ᄤM%/털i}{a&^~\ip55a-|v\GhQlT @{@ڰCحnl)~E#f<_K]^LVm1ZoW lFL\0La* &wJI1nPm/i}q#}q[k xak^mUMB lAAi&) D  h0A66LP :azkՊT᱆+=A6| nLa00`dW,0R M #]_aEr I5nd 2$'dGA@pAah a =4 .""""'HDEDDDԄR:1 0B#Yikl&L/ 'k /ᒀAa@gZeM ڷ;__]'Iq~z~^KR_קW^ڷ`R>Ʋ RZ˙ $#Uy쑚ȍ,FWfHD20ȾPGLN&t"4gS0DH^pCBaax. 3  ax)p ( aa `hZ a 3DNA2ld 2.] gad#IEEyG\@'A14 Ԋ&b l p}A&MƉq&rv8z'tN`м'AZ_, $WI tM^r8_{| A~IpOCoA)A ٙӤ]82%Iن`$"I WSt uuiύG 'Kޝ'a:NqZDutW֙oU~ڮzOCW^WOM__]}|bz~꽽2:/~]kz!?]WÆ!}_qVW/#?ｯL~־ XJ ,o˯&0 .~ Xkֿ_ñG__4/H+ ߏ_1~X> _-:l'ǡd0>D㶿A{ $co_Wa_oAN_G_d5C`{zXl7_߷So$_/_m6m,w/!!kG_"wC/$5~]~ac/{w?r##O_kw^V_~֓u]kOii~o]/__Um[K֭/o]]m+K՗l4j_` _{JI|Z)} -+׵/^3J/:׆YcX85+i1^E1VՄ;X!vNحWC0[K. L\/kKa'T[ a$V'eXa(RB=MZ[Uզӵ % E+2 *P&K[lV'}kkL4 C $JD[kjcA60j@H@ A  6B:)@ dHuARQUAj 6B(&NI]paXa(iGZv0A ρA ɀzCzkY&@ ­aBi74*$i= aA 66&)B:A 1H KV0ҵaj"""""""""""!DDDքDTN250`\P0L aI1Mի XAiKAL9ԾLރ 0 (B"""""""""""#B"" DDDDDAR"""=R֒K8+HhiZT4<%ij #r!G- ?eQ`ggg3HEde*L' # FB? (]Bjȱ3rHeulӾ0P_PTC>ÄMB_N]0v# v'ʄQ!אTvh4ު6#:DY?gt7讬vģ !'k_ߝ!w__ҤJT8fftGx^D\fD6jAN$/ ^ aB 0L` eD #PxS6lgADtfLا!Aٱ(DA t#ԍJ9d8N0Fe{GE"#  aAxM01tCBx)I͊pdL8(f)$.؀D``4aL(,X(ADi'N*j!p'pd p8hAu34NC!4M(r$ a$ o BuSc3„gW4ϊCwA邦D݄8PZA:2. "X&gA;&y@ۻEMl4 CA&w‹Ab˝DvдQ8N5 UOL"vБDݢ5P8tN2`'2xAwYy]ON¯Iޓ~ 'W68>1#W6gpslAߤ{bgӴ$ O t-34ψ`B߫iRnBz}KI ztt&ti6,'Ka:OZO_}ֿZWIuO~'ۡu[ZzJ[]]omzqj5_5OMt_z_K}zJ׆jڍ\4b= _X]g)_c V+۪Wx|a`95/_`U/mKWt:]𾗿_a?{0ۯD׆wwD;aa8~_[V_6a/ Am"; !? ג+$KWւ6?cV)]? ἇHEz/K7"0_tKoݭ/RwK~tK﴿i6}nm|0a+V1 }޶ͭmo_Voյ[]W_Uzz~lS}ƿLvSv^v Z߷eMif;LiR4[ ^ca&V4%LC lU'\L8=WTWÈm6&a+_V8a2:b!#c>׏m/A@0@8AA RqA@W6 h4)ipoi5 +Vb8a%aL0q0㦣OcO>B>Ճ Z uIza0ȃi<5[P[KM]UA 0dG@0A h&AGa0AQb0B8A@jMo:6b8aDDJDu +7a)͈0&D`&AkJ 3(*hg??CL& /݄PMCI 6va'AdW–M^Ȯ a3PAqXj"""""""""""""""83udIS0Ũ"2)57) X0(`!ADDDDDqDDDqK}:X@M,XLj(e\@fJri徙n-( %LqHA`ʜt)[ 2AZg~ad -=BL(A"0 I@ߪPPTF; WPZNɜ1  ,o軭epEگ޴*vZi& 6RRdAӐ#eE'J]1,~_oKuIW_W]Yn<E:g 3r# *>#Ym3s젍ftij%i}X@΃L&APŸL@g   ` =*d|S5#eD 3TkG$e5(3YfD<4S>! !͌" UM4(M0T{N MS B`u~ `"aܐ  C "3ĘAL*a_2c|ECEM*h &y|x:دLDjL"N @ '8(M .ZM0h0Doh3C m'3Id[i7Dôm$5 sN`ȹҿkwHhd-Ƌ 2}mqצA44nqixAh [IWvJ׫mWz~E m[&$>)YIq& N =&]\Mj^鴭j޾}&o]6?O N5{Ӥ_~i^0v~]%_~^6k]-맫_n[(PUU?l/_v'_\?cE_鿿?ҿ{\!~a߿w" oe豨_`b2j ?I$?a_aDi~ۯނaNImuk$xoIٜ^o __v,7_^b}4t?K _cM"MuIjt{޶ߵ&[å_w߮^uSMCtuҵuZ[V0m?o? okjk[IWIvҺJbb_mSKk6ب`a;[={K_]0#&m1 +0`6lTS:bS@4q@ha^ 10@Ƞ` G[IOÆI40j mB0AMC ~X–8AwkjCB[8a^Mi*0@i"!4a g@p AaA L0""""#dBCMxjZSrf pv0 U/aBiZ^i ir?AX"""""""CDDDXF0fb:1눈_KrIkVR&(NQPaL6 "Wrܒ4;A$ w!1JkڞH%n%0֩Q-2V۰-/I~u}-IdRKK_֕-*뤒B eGgȝE/PF0L<>VM r. l(AX& zGQG d21f8Dݢg8}7tSPHMt0" ! @H: x9<`ɜh~ż(_dzEh^8_CvϚ'tE34NhCn (- A*iS 7vh*톃 ۋNveKҪ|gI'4S# pd\Hu2.PN`ȹKm8);E&xN>hz/Z' /CHޢ H&DAqN];qoҥߤm' i{zT\-m[I߫_'IKItE7DppdxsNѬgO#m+&WO7^ץ?S_oV׽'0[[7[v /_O֙ҧK#Q?m]z_鵾&n~zwGZo?[jG_W¥+J{0]E~\klMUW >{"i|Lr1 KWn,oɹu"o;_ַ# }u%"OoWv?wֿ/ :_w/솽~{CC_u_N[X$ZIr{(?Kد]~}/'?>~^V׿^׽WzTIK_Vzz[_izT4?10Yj `.ujWuz׮iAf ~miomӵK[I^?Iئ=XIn#Vv_aثR5muǶWi{ut+V-_bjvAQl^ƬI鴚 Maja+V"wlTTG'+6_/+JV[M]qSjԲ`eDL A@؄a A !ݦLP [! qN!DZ;V Zl0liث 1AQA@ t0AuR6028^aW 0=<APak0 iT"L0R$_A@bb @ K ׵a^§jMa0i4L&3o al(%au 0 ›'xDLpa! a =QDDDDDDDDDGDDDD~/Э/ޣ0AOav~B#CJaydvJr+2E$Lgbh2 ­¦PC22O  邂fIb(O2rh.vZF$Apzr_zAzm_Rr,{ El;9 _w}u[#_^Kw %A2`d0@A HcA '|Rb'͊pR@ b( u`)h\'f цNGA$ gSya~’\"_5BDKг~0Ph0л< xC2 gBa0^ `a@`:$ ك4! A&}#CͳA3D-d~Fh<(PBаZ(TNgin!&Sp0tN `踤4N4´8`uALD*ipSON5AAB ϒaa L0bAwDA'AؙO'vX4Ev&y9 4PMh DA6;Eԝ^8hH'AS]4 t8ji*h} At^:M-'IӻW`otii7N6'IdoFm'I "[Iނ zIh~M Mplb6nӥz7z}]t4)?{בIMo nf0m}_OM+u>uO]tޓt*O |&뫪tCޚCon돤7ҦoպW?ר?1__kۨ'o㿯ޚB?"u0~\G ï~QJlq_jw;}G_1o@u k׿tMhֿ$=ז x/ᷧ 'w۠z~_/׿nAPm]~t/YGwCJ$zH쑇_%{_ޗ_tC[{zm=|60_^C!n_I޿m-mm^K0]_}]mo[_+I/{7مݭz]m[K᭄װ[z]I봿[SVb4/m,aK}I) aAҾԿKҭumxdk:_ߪ_j_I6K}1M0lTqi7_AMCWtCi};]ۮdV~#WՅ|0ؠD:0AAlmmTbaCl6*&mh0AiV)n6Zj#*#(?KkElLVa4 M L MhIA^L4 Am2$(!&!@bB: uղz 00 P @6D0$ @\&V0 ؃ a0 &2w͖l4„ *i0@M2OMM]f.!…84jT@ B l+VU *gPRXa0p•;MlL ( g?`AhDDDDDDDF"#؈""""#,TUho[WH]_ &<( ::S 97%\GGk尠)zY e+J5_DV:x{ؐn޿-D %!j UQzhiGʵW endstream endobj 54 0 obj << /Length 4803 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im55 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F56 11.92 Tf 75.36 708.00 TD (even in monopoly maintenance cases) Tj /F56 11.97 Tf 178.08 0.00 TD (, more extensive relief is justified as the link between the) Tj /F56 12.14 Tf -178.08 -28.32 TD (conduct and the monopoly increases. ") Tj /F56 12.04 Tf 188.16 -.48 TD (When a monopolist has ) Tj /F57 11.68 Tf 116.40 0.00 TD (consumated an exclusionar act) Tj /F57 10.23 Tf -304.32 -28.08 TD (. . . \(w Je must also ) Tj /F58 8.00 Tf 90.96 -2.64 TD (tr to ) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf 28.80 2.40 TD (undo the varous effects of that act." ) Tj 179.28 -.24 TD (Antitrust Law ) Tj /F57 11.39 Tf 77.52 0.24 TD (653c. In the) Tj /F57 10.74 Tf -377.04 -28.32 TD (accompanying example) Tj /F56 12.06 Tf 113.28 0.00 TD (, the monopolist actually buys its only rival. The treatise explains that a) Tj /F56 11.85 Tf -113.28 -28.56 TD (simple cease-and-) Tj /F56 11.94 Tf 85.92 0.00 TD (desist order would be ineffective) Tj /F56 11.96 Tf 156.96 -.24 TD (, and more extensive measures would be) Tj /F56 12.10 Tf -243.12 -28.08 TD (appropriate to restore competitive conditions. Indeed) Tj /F56 12.15 Tf 256.56 226.32 TD (, ") Tj /F56 11.93 Tf 11.28 -226.56 TD (one might force the monopolist to) Tj /F56 11.95 Tf -267.84 -28.08 TD (fashion out of its assets a viable firm that would bear the ') Tj /F56 11.79 Tf 278.64 -.24 TD (same relationship) Tj /F56 11.93 Tf 84.00 0.00 TD (' to itself as \(the) Tj /F56 11.88 Tf -363.12 -28.08 TD (target companyJ bore at the time of acquisition.) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf 237.60 -.24 TD (Antitrust Law ) Tj /F57 11.17 Tf 78.72 0.00 TD (653c1. In that specific context) Tj /F56 11.83 Tf -316.32 -28.08 TD (the treatise notes:) Tj /F56 12.91 Tf 35.76 -28.56 TD (the monopolist bears the risk of the uncertain ) Tj /F56 12.57 Tf 236.64 -.24 TD (consequences created by its) Tj /F56 5.00 Tf -236.40 -13.92 TD (exclusionary ) Tj /F57 10.67 Tf 67.92 -.24 TD (acts. Thus) Tj /F56 11.81 Tf 49.92 0.00 TD (, at the least) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf 62.88 0.00 TD (equitable relief ) Tj /F56 11.93 Tf 79.92 0.00 TD (properly goes beyond merely) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf -255.84 -14.40 TD (undoing the act; the proper relief is ) Tj /F56 12.65 Tf 171.36 0.00 TD (to eradicate all the consequences of the act and) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf -176.88 -14.40 TD (provide deterrence against repetition; and any ) Tj /F56 12.73 Tf 222.24 -.24 TD (plausible doubts should be resolved) Tj /F57 11.41 Tf -221.52 -14.16 TD (against the monopolist.) Tj /F56 5.00 Tf -36.96 -28.56 TD (Id. ) Tj /F56 12.09 Tf 17.04 0.00 TD (\(emphasis added\). Notably, in this example) Tj /F56 12.01 Tf 210.24 -.24 TD (, extensive relief is mandated despite ") Tj /F56 12.03 Tf 185.28 0.00 TD (plausible) Tj /F56 11.79 Tf -412.08 -28.32 TD (doubts) Tj /F56 12.18 Tf 31.92 0.00 TD (" about the causal link to the monopoly position. ) Tj /F56 11.90 Tf 239.76 -2.64 TD (\(No such doubts are present here\).) Tj /F56 11.84 Tf -236.16 -25.68 TD (In short) Tj /F56 11.98 Tf 36.96 0.00 TD (, if the link between the conduct and the ) Tj /F56 18.39 Tf 194.88 -.24 TD (har ) Tj /F56 11.89 Tf 28.08 0.00 TD (is established ) Tj /F57 11.96 Tf 66.72 0.00 TD (durng the liability) Tj /F56 11.91 Tf -362.88 -28.08 TD (phase) Tj /F56 11.92 Tf 27.84 0.00 TD (, any doubts regarding the remedy are resolved against the wrongdoer) Tj /F56 11.90 Tf 332.88 -.24 TD (, even where) Tj /F57 11.31 Tf -360.24 -28.08 TD (structual relief may be necessar ) Tj /F56 12.12 Tf 162.72 0.00 TD (to assure that complete relief is obtained. CCB 9-) Tj /F56 12.55 Tf 240.96 -.24 TD (11. Here) Tj /F57 10.24 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (, the) Tj /F56 11.99 Tf -447.60 -28.32 TD (Commission found the requisite link between Rambus) Tj /F57 11.35 Tf 264.96 -.24 TD (s exclusionar conduct ) Tj /F56 12.01 Tf 112.32 0.24 TD (and its acquisition) Tj /F57 11.27 Tf -377.28 -28.32 TD (of monopoly power. Decision 74) Tj /F57 10.61 Tf 161.04 0.00 TD (, 118-) Tj /F57 11.12 Tf 28.56 0.00 TD (119. Thus) Tj /F56 11.96 Tf 50.16 -.24 TD (, the causation finding here was not) Tj /F56 11.75 Tf -234.48 -28.32 TD (edentulous) Tj /F58 5.00 Tf 51.36 0.00 TD (" as in ) Tj /F56 11.73 Tf 33.12 0.00 TD (Microsoft.) Tj /F56 12.00 Tf -54.48 -28.56 TD (In addition to the link between conduct and the acquisition of monopoly power) Tj /F57 10.48 Tf 379.20 -.24 TD (, the nature) Tj /F56 12.22 Tf -414.96 -28.32 TD (ofthe conduct also influences ) Tj /F56 11.94 Tf 145.92 0.00 TD (whether ") Tj /F56 12.37 Tf 46.56 0.00 TD (reasonable royalties. . . ) Tj /F56 11.83 Tf 117.12 -.24 TD (\(areJ but nominal in value.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000292149 00000 n 0000292208 00000 n 52 7 0000292327 00000 n 0000292491 00000 n 0000338231 00000 n 0000293019 00000 n 0000292638 00000 n 0000292767 00000 n 0000292894 00000 n trailer << /Size 59 /Prev 291822 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 343100 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000397297>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R ] /Count 9 >> endobj 59 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 60 0 R /Contents 61 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 60 0 obj << /XObject << /Im62 62 0 R>> /Font << /F63 63 0 R /F64 64 0 R /F65 65 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 63 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F63 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 64 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F64 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 65 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F65 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 62 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im62 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 47250 >> stream aN?s(J;;ggغ?M"}ʳ|ՙT@vK !B!2HsN)R 0h4Ȱ8-"H)" x…L[FtN &!„AA5( X(*-_ӂM 0D)0`iB hBaQ8 'nA᪶`OVwSAA AP@߆Kտ_ٿǹ^ϭ*Uޖ=ҳW^5ܴ:5b9q*ڤydz(ٰ%#ղ۶ٲy*ZgM00UNxP NLxPa`' "wmwGH4M"zI&8S@MU|4N`)z MmiZOh+E9h7LShꖻzUjش֒餰Oo zZ8Iml=^G &Rtm^]zK*uKTkim**K--,?R&/xU/_UIjפJ-j]޽zTt޿N7BjuU7\RRdSXxl*ּlSKGUJTtk_IuIV:^ocm-4B+ע!_KTVoK*]*JIinwKu.K娅~Yo|~X%R!]$Aު~ZA-jw2P2P__ _mҬWI -ꖵ]U/քЪ&%'KTROIjWT2W_Un_:=WRjۥƫ~.AނU##G}/]/5zJ!K^֖}>Hõ~s %ZuuS]QIׯi1K/ y=kFֹ(IVJiR=t"D^_wM_/KEMW]%]"z__~֥߭ʒI-|KI-+_]Ko[tJчkUP%Jtu kDuH?Ip¤ݩ )*Կ/`40K￑aj*8 QQV8&_I]-zXXI ZmqVk$5B%L &SZ մ[C]!^E'_# $T5H4)A^*) Ba.NbwW % JJ 0 KL%vVMJ %QKJ4n֜a4wb(MUESUPMBbA]Wb A*] v(6  `( m`[!A @ 0t p L)& )*j*i *a04L,4:i Mf+:mmj X+^T­4^99Oekw64DDDDhDDԄDE*U`D0C@0XY82E@nP=s*G!DTDDDDDDDDE#"1DDDGqW[$tzI6k -4kiR >!HTABm-[ 0Lj AM DYGSk(8ޜ&v2&e}2g*D"ز;!Fk";d & PL'vaUY AAp0L.Mc_PTAp jqF0+M~7:NIFG`d LKsS%̖4v@v43H;M!_W}MU__?yZG:3h:j) aDP&l9L٣63SllRDm >t" _3Τt03΄_(F'"|=3ʲΌd!h)tCGDFs7 O3QjCc: "' 28y8864CgeE<|?y HA8$a0+YN   Bo 0A` B `a дD!@@N8 `$`*CA4C<?0xL BA-xA;aS 0U*aSL"vªM߄av$TD I ~kHpM~0UO02}~'rtiʶCC辱ŭ<{ H7Z'm d''E4_Q;z'mǮMEvyL  piOhX2t/_ &{C$>ސo@ Y+~ &]"27I>I&q׶AIM r{ԊIwI-ތSdϊpN s1ޓzz][jCM]nm:Om޷VoP׾w _zo6z ]?ӵ_錄^~Cmڷ>{]W_]tP+%t֭}}K+_U~~~G~=h(a"O#7x몽^;kݻ o^=mZrt5/ }Q_u{X1T/O/ b _VFw-'bn[T o''!a~! '_ %A?AmM'Az3N? k[ ^[/_z o(F>?!_넿m~$$$ia_ z_פHK/߯]g0_=/ۮa5bu~F^zkz}M?:߯~V]u~K~mL/JvZֽi_;Wu[ͯ lW.m|)0[1^m+Rc/N -niKaԾt_vZK0K_ G?KV=~iZKF!ZXC8b(ac®QV4=b-kiiY( `M@ؤ6BUiXa$i05ՉݫJE_ڵ &6OMjvjmCI9 =4" QUӵMA a 4": a 2# dXQAT6@j)b a`b 6 j:{ma0B Yr)MMUi\4 PL*pj_YPi|Ah0iWxj[dK0̻LذaDq$ ` fPPB """"""""""?GZVi/ij$]ZXA`N"3,KqKPǔ_ҿʏZd$Až#73\8pPBa0@fAFv!L(L(PPPPPT BAAAABPQqPPPTVwx89 hfDZȾhd*C "-#$[fJׯ7O[/WU]Z^4S㩗͢c=E;:f#/ӽ}W_]s#!!`4E' 0P ` p\/"žRLSMg3YE9#1"c!tD2fsu,GdaˠR3a<ᚈB29 S \"D6:F)DaCBG!',I@>@8) SM0[0 axPN !5΁Mh&a`M DC< M&B`{M7-= NzoI_k7KiW5կO֯Z_׿׷־6tڷ[k]WCt#!G׽W]hj_צG}kmPP{GCi_v?\륿m5_W~LuU}/!/`u[囨}PWuuXP_b{etLgm]R]/}I"O pG~ u@d _A[H?J޲4C$CY u#Kd!֓}m"ik,w~vE[kquqW]ﺧW_m/_J_tk~[i?]Sjڤޯ[{_]ui.߯խmJ+iZ޺kYG^Kt )—_lV7N Gb YoO.^Vs` +o11i1?`f6 0VҲGKmtX]cIVJ&kWMi~Wi1QQX@҈84!`0@ث[!USqmtTIMZb6:idG&4IÆii 2iR;in:iUi+%b%H:kv*@0aKaaTl L,4a ijHAm6MMSմ0@  0@h0@ 4&Dp( mE RȃTڦP"hDD" aAMPL˄UA_&: 0#sN &X0a+-5M.a0ՅAa4H [A  (A3r"""CDDDDDDDDDDDhDE!Iz/K]_I}xH$"`SV;*i41 *GaS/M¢+rivX!3wHn;r10+I~K6=8dn:t t.fM M9uI ::MӃ;M '$7եɳw}zv7^O_Z~nW۷պj՗5˟}7WK{un]7m/#o:W?z~ݿ4|]>hG uZǯhxc {K[޷Z_w0-c& _1<kߺ_[x*2]W;  L5a]a"NADcz0=o߿%a moᇠXa?C܇?!׿moKu@?_d<7ֿHwG쑃#\XoXw$Aҽ^bGa_K!ou<=÷L7yx=|z\Z뤿zmWJ/./knҿ_ێ{ц{kI鴟K_T_mW~kվ[I  `°a$%m|5>zk /6KKK-nk/ k)_a(k՘KKV_Li^JUb&G;_b_㺏aK; 㾫zl0d~i;) aN!LUWVW4Ӫ _I؏{ >kKjե#b؎ߏ☎իIm+q{ %%a+V4 a @ m1  i(M@ QAj)t4MWIM :j( ta0mBdH@ԄuM!M**!4p Aᅭ*  L p[PA4pAM MA"XMUl  4T&Wi7M ij0iRci9ni0B!uB l&W^ɛ,A[A8aA3a0Asj~-3b # :amPa5;N;]`6M<>g) )v8R5 0a B }8K̯Q""""""""8"""""""""""""""""*#"5/ztڥ _m8m& h0Y Gbe"""#-%*y(l$Y s*2Ȥ0a"Lq$;3&v)!+gbqAAA[  p3aPxP@@C@ jX*q"Bp(L*Ǿީ hT"9τ#L.U rd` I.`+Z:;'Fpuom]PN{lA|߷@;x?cӎ?K/WWK{_֩:_`Ȳ_KBH`8BȨg'#6Fld|{(|ND3Y7+gG4IT| "X4}>nNI<'!M9kz]q4 ":A,OtA*~%LaizB$[u# -'mWW_IGXAI'O?iV_]^]$Ckju }v/[%MuVNi_}iWuխj{W]W/ۦOOۭw^\?x?q_](WVC^&ƿƟ-0 i__]vץåޗ/ ¥,F\_׃V ?_oDx"O jama%"QU|7Dam_{_zZW+ݿIծ/ k[GHi%_# uoAy!_#V0Z_{z_mkirGZ@B dG_u4}v_w{]t i}+i[kkv]߯ S u"qmO +)B#{tjwilҴX8`Q $I0JOM5xA 6B0[!HS& S]ݴJSvImU5p҆ NZ,}j` Є5A vp[ U R S#@@ ` T  4 tB0A a05QQ@ 0@h`Ti!! Zkoa0ʲ7L a3b<0GRq * ,0dW."+A0½{aI\0&k0k 6Bvhɏj\dDDDDDDDDDDqqHDDDG5dFCШ*p"B " . kDOC"֒IRJiH@BH%J+Hj(TiDDA -G@q:l/ZRl7Ȣ%Aa2,TEz+c;4HFvZupːo CBaB;qK̎E9G2 !(PPP30`'7PHЉ  AAAAB}X# #"h=WP`C6q]U]?rC`D6l8s!4 yI1DRI> E+>>: Jpw|pwߤO|_~+ߪ[_'___朗!B]{I%KVi9#u6Fe3Y ̋r(f5hy5I# eS.{5_( \#$#!H33͙ *D1H# "l'6]z `0 `0P aDؠZA xP lP `    huDP']ԍ ك4hSByȴ  0D"d0L&ZB T(Az]4aUt`aASA¦xT{A 'H5!53C Ӎ4M znEASD`֯׍4_8<#ⴗ}o[~?U]$}r*k /-ǔCdfd1HNSΑ gk3 Ț9gFD^kE'/G{~IgT&HrMp\kjf_:p: <4A A࠘A!6g 8!8?~C!N NP%͌*fA B lPD  .!8P   hZ §M.= *j  &0P}P? ~ xPL&gM<BxMuMD0`#蝽'E-=8:'|)Ɖ'z&w/1h:„N`DwSDoKI鑇0ppdrC^8ȹƉ۠pOu8`&! )! A66N}zAh4_Q|_2]h6tA&q4P@KZNТ$RnAд)6R â<lZٕlN$#$@#hi0!{z pt12T0r ҡZcAzv6Wu_I~~_U}oU⻯H$J! #ا("h'B-O"D?B09FjH/*3A a򠎙鞲f!TS5]Cdmz)٭(AED`AIHR3AMI1k0Y`?^pP< hX @„ &<( ͌9!3C1lgA p&` A& a0Ha AA 00MB'pp=SM8~ &`I*a0T$TA&ACA aP PL0 M>邏o;jS#,0Vńӎ,'߸ZVQ?qV릾q_iKVWW.+z&ino]}SzNoګZH#]M_?]{Of__k"8cNL{K'c]mD/\WEa_.>@yH/Udc; r`,@P_Z}(___W ޅ* ]{ P??ѝD߷㫋/t _W__aH_kkKE?AAK|R_5V=H/_ׯ}w#;K}//9+~Zo_vﴬ?J{KKzS;m/VUmF~AK_tWگ֗Z_ga.{۫[mSp %jڽ/^w넴]ڗ0}KK{KaۦԿ1AV}8;J=بu}ZAam.>hф;}]&i1ITWkiaXV6U( B=bIa.) Ca6+IzcXa+Qa&Zav0zjllSQi4pjA! @ڊ5@,@M5!EEi0{GA4 Pb@ؠ@0 6B a m@ a  & WXaBKPJ[ AEMB,pa0Z 5 6Bi -~^ / ,286DDDDDI؊B""" a HFUX`A &a3 ;0 `2 *YB *iA@G!3DDDDDDGX8^W҄XO A/h+ EAf@2吱eZJM4 쬏\],y ̫3\2^.! N*jv  vd!"AqH0 vDk0AZ `7:~jB &`Pi𺤞DE8qOAxTh!l[L`.JGj`iU҃$z*vnvjgcP6.nL*V;'[}Q|}V8 uz 3O'`t싽k_֕*ӠZO>OVn֖UQzkֻ_ץBPC-%_ kik>u΢A*M t, C"sIכe d5#"~t#q4A#D&QΨFJCIU*0I.NO!"$tdU͑g\0h h3Pa (AaA46S !'0PA%(. 0L `IE'26lxzYFkC3To: a_  (BB3M9LjUSDLE3b'N A0UU0UO7ua()SM=ˊ3&V^A<0L !@ҥ**VƋ,43yDl3MF a"wCQ8&rvD`U08a'l!Ҡ}t0T.iĉL*.^b;q"3hEƓji6|Sӥ{M vAwzҫ{Վ)/0_F^֫K n_~}?}~uWIom,ڽkkkmֻ(-#zA%t %i)/0`ᄚjԿ~cԾZYKAYҬ }a zئO8Wخ!!i6vtT?Kl%IT'_I4Z /4qXKISu0ML &S{\jI4kp҉JJab zqMJ0I(0Ix0Ib5Ba-4ӊA`[\ aa !h6L "B n[@*01  0AMTTP  blP@^QI*)U\WK80!abIӆ0LʀA 5 0["*h00Ӱ:aaS[TZ\+2#]4UO"-z 0GY A@E4 i06& ZerU, eUXa0T (h"*ІA"""""""N WI$UJYH%=0IiBI4mE1Qh"vS-́p`B4Wز*JbeDM?;4 A0aJࡂ`6(5cX0 /"h]WԮ)7> "l#@D"+'S*T CA?SS;-;-2|Dwxtߪo ]{}toj뾫_UU|{/K꿪H[yBe ћyO#!pbCd4(L ϊpT 3Xa?:B /q}2Tj h?AԷZ>4cH82t$O(keoLdDݢ .tN' "v l "Vz{u827I6RtoxӤ=_B'i^]RInon/m?iոMnФu] OW]7}m׿Z]W_ݾO)W_ݿ CkVow_ /ޢCu\?/' BDZ]%c׊Bc_ r._1}//|RcNH V ֿW OZZ(_5$>al% K A}{ mtuWost/A} kZZk"_KմL@HWGx?^?LW Gzdd?ц҆i}wR^mVI붿$Z׿zߥ:U_um~/o_kMT9)}[v_f?6ao[ n_ͯMgzژ]5u -~m + ifc]RZW[@X8l!V;Kc{MXӵI(Ҵ!MSM5_vݧW[1Vmn.XVҧiimZ'+Mm(|5iRW|AL0[ Xi_W4calGjIjqZZMlTl0HS0aA  l .dG@ lS  AChabBA(a i!G@h u6 ڊh5(H!XbW[kڦkMBta&dAaհ[*j5l MadGI4u}aT kDDDDhb"""""" 0L`^a3i0A4 !CDBe<0L 8.6AjOa2OUS)0Xa0vS0LMOUkAt)7 00a0UqDDDDDDIWZU_jUl$HHUڅIvi80qrJMZfBqڒ%.d4v$dFB+l1*l+^L-i„¨@Bi!Aj ¤ …P]0V& \.*݅ &;PPڴH?{ Aȗ.)"ari89-0pܨ3C+$z`hy-0~;W>԰ݵ-ֿ,s5L§pTTT zv|x ~&4@   ` L`aDL a PA/ GaoAA*?ODڦ?DUT!'pppi%i._Dm0J0CM0TM0T<0TSA *iAT1+&+ņA6 MkN.)ID ݦ/T 22%h 2%AsH6 qdnlN Ӹ=;M2('KzհzI>NO& 'a7}&(JNZu}zNt?kWzIKҦ.WoRo+޿[KkojۿCߥ+Gt~_߿dž?^p_o հ}_ 1 |?]{}P^XWD0zFI0l%=__AW{ "P݇ᇯL?/ Kuo n}~HTK!}}7!K!vH7چK3{ySV{sJ}La>Q_+_}]~_'M߷~~W^kkj_i_.1w߭m?~_&J/ۭҿ_mooچ*6?[ 0JƺzKŽKԺߘn]?{/ZMvT4K";Ka ب]ثXxNҪ_iz1iuwlVåbC tKiU(0A(0@Q@)jOM:դՊvM8iWLRi4l4`JZQMCᅹ =4*B:6*)iv-I5U T `":@U  m$0@h0A@B: P@t 1A4@ AڠSPBi<0 ¨a%9&AW0?2PPASnL/ '}hKA馘[ |4Z_ j_aj [&A(\DGDDDDDq)1DDDG 0B&l0LAfU" ϵ"BQ㈈qꫯꖒ_nZP/ rUzTն+* 6 @@jը0Db?T6p<Ѥܛz,X\$@^E#A2R)(AU pR[TM_ Ept͠[e(}>BDvu#Y_\D1M8,9cդ=Pz괫믭o!z몤_Z__J:DdF&,xLB&QHfu3¨!!!YyA282" #: NkfD(A%x `! s 'ZC"80xPA&0PCAH5ԸUcP< f%8ORPZ';D U 'vPZht.@:TDx:$PhZ$;D:UN+ȷA?D,f mށҸzN- Ln8>i8_:+,],z >MZ ϝ8=6 '_pa~iZAoG]%8.ZFVZJJ{>?;MuIRK?wֿ]Z^*B'oՅ^n]|^_KiVKxc~+&&IRl}/zO_aA~{Jz aÿ9m$ׯaH꿧?k A~:$%I ,7A~~ISuH /!^H޺{{=i~}r׷/մWIeRK/_k޶zlK}/tҵۯV1ݘU׶4>-*+/V)յ _KV#}`^XA$ViTTHKKivW[QEEwLU 6" +bMPA)N*6=hA9*0pmzҰ aPap4t(A"BA im&*i4ڑ!PA`DDX@.+ @‚ a3\l! a> 3bi,)1AɩuA 5DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDFK*],xVY"LW(g~r\L"av\)S٨G @S=#hHB"R5 CX7;V8@xM`r`@!ih*hFZkr[/P"i$ pa) ݧ~@HI : Ș2$섶O$fL Ql^i8^i;Atm o$}ti^}]Wꮝ%޻KI_ZQ^_0 릒_o?N"ׯZ M}iMdhٔdOh._.@NNP2ٚ$<"_)","c*Q?Shfy29K@a͈fr!$ C_L}< "#PP~  a> a\(L0A脂!@脀"Bа?Phi 0 ~ AOTRb ka A=Pta&?t'07M aa:#^j蝶?ê#tMۢP- 1IDW%|2$蝺vPuiSq}+oȿ_IBCvTj4"u(!G?EWu0ڭQ޵}_uA"A zD~u#]4Iu+vW餻_]^HG]ovuwM}ޒ߭ȖZ_CB۴ۭ*}Z꿿oǫ~/"?G__WW(QMw{ uzմ7{V #b_{aH/-Oqi9~"c~"cl"cG"oߦj? a/K%_J[dR޽KOzȲ}tKl*]w#֫מkWo~:15nkӵ{-4;iu[}k^Zu]wm&ͮ׶[_}|^i6[\mjK[JXtkuVMi/|wjKV,[㰞Q [Kb-=A*+$bP z״!up%tiN }ƭCI;Um 1@bDtjb ()bM8d Si}RRi 4m4ح!AA  & -ai텰 &&BGPΘiR#H\ M4#M i[ ) CK,a&PhAa2 B (()Xc8 ¦RCLʴA< jy4 )?;ih0R`"""8Ј""""""""""""""""""""""#B#ZO$we3ZUuzV*5֨ mC4Zj wVHdj"h@:9!6jC19hrB!# `A6 a!. 3B8"!0d`BAl(h<;DȜ=S}: ~'?a>{z?etgC10fYtdDs΋!v?A !`Y DDN0a^cwJ(98'D% 1POwӫi>Mj&'-vȗ{uw!#o^c?n߿ $[_z_oۮu]c_ȷD;m,? joGxmo }_܎"`_8|unž"Oo^[ %~| voƺ;gD,~}^aM6>ir__koVҽ_IatIa&n;۶apaImv t⠈},Ri@ab8X.id#i&],4 AT'UM! ڳeLC re L xE=fX0MO X  """""""""""""""""""""?c.K;!fY",Re d42}Y;SvPa /̃22\R>lf|20k0l/PP_2./#E@p\9yp|+mmoFC#8 d@ZohcqNx@p&^뫯뾡ꫯkk^]뮒xӯXE!#f: F0ly""2#(P@!X S0CAA D 2 eN,2!.@/"!˲=P0D:FxAT]  L&az(0]0TjA j\\ a|PC<*&|P\'BgL(AB4֡p4^0xyED'SDaED qx;hi-l2} Dݢ1$SD2 Bm 6ZA?ejA mzkAؚ0Р~khi?uNwGp}'fgn&vJMai6MﭲW_Wӟ.ޓmZsIa:OǤ4=828knW޿hk&+z+_nտ i$ߤ㧤;_{_׭}Zݪ/.ztuz{xר~>p~:k~L?^ /{ kzzïIT{߿bⴼ1_-?.ir&K`<!Oa?ү_ i޿k?ao7?"qa7w]v7o{ox|ނw_ #$'La?_O!#5Ȅkyom~=}M?]:xm_ñK[m+u_/׭mmki~ڿmm{k_߿վjKKۯa/Uuu +aoںa+/MPa,. 6mvOWi]YuiZl4BUb*쎫մ*1M~P&OiW\XV; 4i*LX0Q[PLlI:a+N+QUӱVkbK2%\* +E.|CtզP@a E1 6@ l&@*6b0@h:A@A@{jhF 2L`Aj+|` m~Rc5- (L Ȯ]l0ZdGXaSA B`ZUmniYpA:M8L&P&L$D {"(O_5GRa 2A0@ݛM4paMw*4 &9"l& BL!Ј""""""""""""""""""""""/K]iqЬ(@cT'eMO0OM*2fDDdLEr;VYvd52XBal ia0X`8zpPP_(h^EP`l:GDrBe$6Kdh x8m$"qRq'˱23CjzO_ TT~[/ k׎5rLȇgfgH&G."|jL =?O(Ȍ𦨌MY]Wj\Far `AhX(( h3 pJNPHDЈIGYdh4` I 0D" 63dA33pbk Mkr vAt6Aw4 @: nq&=82}E4_8eоŢx'Oq3_8&zbh}Ӡti݅ ߧմ_Һ|M;륫ذAq` ӯM"lx?Y`ȸr}/Nf7Id\kD ӤOz鿈[pZuozoMM~jMm=;Z}^Ӵ: njJ꺿_Kn~[ [5kк+WIk~J:.'lB\|lE/?_~)}Oca#_z^߰M? ({$H'D{j { }w/_?7]_~ ~__~ #Q?GֿiuoKK޼|%מAܑZ'm/_O_~s=]~oaZ_noK֓konzҺ_&t/~~X1ُ-oMl0426~ͯ_L.:JPҼ4q0!!uatڷQW^ V){ߪk'ԏk^߄nl%Jz{ 5h4MUaKka(vXM0^n[&8Ai um."b5U/ Bl0I*S@00@! @օS tU 0@ 0A[LP@U q{Ab AX4E AlU2{AbL (  P hf 2 Ey1 .ia0M0 va4~AȮL" %w a& ڠL a066iiSA/ DDDIaa0@2O a0 ]OAKAa `e?p0L| PRlqR!]I: * * K )XB3!AF"C5 """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#~үa!aub6{vSIS&Fv2d ~Gzv&dܣ4eȇ-€<MB/! (\}ҝT­ `e@ (PYn>ݲϱ-߰յ%ښI9873@ԉOR;>Ѱɲĭ𾱳ܯR7I۽?[^^³ǴЎ3<ٚ"B)ٌ$t2&xFxSZ5T ?/S5o9  ȴ C (&`TA&D<"k#A2pbC. ЏB+E9\k#P"$_"DrӔј#1N3!D::6($:32$F(3d S" Ԅr"LdI '!(MU7ե4S ء5.(A0aS4; 0SL"L A!GA a `0$R0fka a<0H'݅AMA8:'qtN'a&rPQ7 *$:DPDpANAjxP`UMxL*a0UL<*$*x8:cMAyDv,Myv t 78hւzMq|v&zA/D!||/ |IA(P=>1-i' *-( ;: ]zn* CqWf8D⤐q+`&}vi}Q⢻;W]ukiTUJs HΨ1"HY'~nah$*{fLji0g 4 0T˃`iAH6"C L B eA { x@0Ph^apPd "p;zUMÇ Nh=00Y"\*hn 4UA8gOjh"CTפ!zfx8zAIb{i>K36297BZ/au+G! [o$"q?"Coooa0uoWM W_NtatgJ7_[z]TV ނ7Iulv+KnI55>׭TݮO?ҽ<u{߷4mz7o_׶ko_kW~[׿14/i]kKGoHiyۯW}/k۞01C M1KW/kxJmaۯ_`KyV%K1^҉QKlAz (m&#Vҿ؃ڻn%I5봴׸ba?m#b5DpGA#ARa:*H>B=k:+N))>WM:黵aA~a5Kl92M4M4Ȑ 6  iL u  6 66dH #A  @=0) @s   ? aЦM R0PR8_"  cN ^׆VTdp`xka0MBlDDDDDDDDDDDDDD~?JI * Bb,+Σ 2ͪ; Rɠ쥙 KfFM4Ԥ-f_+♒A p(8AA0PPRJj `\{ PY <.-AƖvv vcIZ ҃idp2 69"Ѡ%\/+I*__kum/KuIu}U/.#H:&Gk$%TY Dt_4u2#?ֳ4vDtS|gG' 0lO&4< Vs(jjKULE a` (A2\` `N f ! lb3d|y>)I‘AbpS6` BFCS™ID-  !I0 0=BaNl fb0y< ϊp@4Hz & 0TSA0Pa|PA&¦o .A@TABa8~O/Nx֑n4i*&>UNTiAyD/:'m 8hA$8jaHM=0ptIpÃ"qy Dpz' `ɛ0Ff3ZOn94; 8St~07#ۥӤO6ڰʥͶ麪ٌ:-.чk_o鷰<&uh}JmҦ뮾IzQ.+zMRzMWi-~IV>:W]?Q zz/ozµ߆b?]- KB$>:Uƣ}_i^Ӯ޺+}^I*}uz;8!xoX}~ҥ /.\ZuuT/:`YcE -:ҥKS-}uT~[;{OI}UTIRꕂ ߶8{"Vo߯*ס~}[%HCIzT $u}/]%sU/O?__x>H/K$VHcK}_KU_{xZ_Z^uF~vi^+KkFTcԾFcoakozZIֿ{{ & jR뤪a[Kz 7kukMk_ %k/㊍xZ/Az;j5KKlTW -v+uB?JwI aWNZ&6*!{ha0iMUҧ:l$tRLBci%l0իLC;I&a (0b⡥zm1jNJ MA u\-ʥ VM4P  ahai$lV  `d#!o0AM@dG@Aj 6DuRnZ0ᅫ RP~A0 Յi$ )6uA4 &m4TXi](MF؈3)"#&3  \ dFL)3 (" 0A`(&|S0L@FNGDDGqƒU^ ru/Z( `0Dc铳FwHMՎ a4gjd{2)ddڦTdZv,*`5Co0 SJ 2( T\WDn07P"1ƈC~  0AS#L A? XBd# tt8d PIҸIMc a :A?}RtmSQe J.ҺO[Iꖽ_~QI}UKޯO__l省^U%-̹fXDrك3.O: 3F@AC0fj3Fj |'2vk3)"6Df)6d8c9[I-Ҫ}'L t|a0BA0@ͣY0B040P0@AL(LjaB Babt3[%=4=I S8gAF",);<΢Ƞ]SE DTMDzF;L*iIXT0PPTMQ8`I4$¡qA xpS|P@VL&0a5f a5 d#<  _bX_n-'}-Qx>5EE'Bи|иM^6a0D4_ZG 8i(DJYmndnҼ'I`8{M$6 b|i> |i7A l`ȐόV" 98;hQ*tֿJXRhA%1ZT1^ (j@llZ?`"#Sn !s#;7 /9'Ј1SA_tTI^""? 45 #$)d#e F[8dW2,BH24d@b… &%H!kנPPPPPIUnl,2_TI~is@<d\#G,, 2`h343FlaD>M D2 c:  * aAC!D% `CM>)8RN h) 9 {悝:F(dJC" B/.pL"͡>d \#B`IY* 7` MPL'a T& A AT&lPaxAa4* 8(PA" =A0KNL'q񪠃!. 0d T;hM h4A'aE0§&<&;rn $8m;yAv Q(zqdKjǿCK&44q0cH7;At'"Abk m'zwmA:'<{c/h l5I7E@ۿA7簟$݄po:X0lh::M#\*t~otM>ܰ`$W9t^Suʽ豹Բ7·ɱճ*M[Z=7װWmJWmǰN__ѳ?U߭?W~Zj5ƄXvհ.Pݶٱ赶_pK[k<EH/j(_uD߯{onwk$oF/_ô+دnzAۯҥ$AV?%c$_/Fp_zب➿boC }~}o&/iukiZz0;0i]zVI¯U_ik_i_= /C :aHlV7WLvXݦ4l.q]aKcimwVlL8?M؊5Ka C m_u jb Xam/X#MD|kVzWrL2!`Aa!AP lTSh6 ݊b#cv)4jb6j))@6?l(WmKiҦ JaB X&"% ZaD-4 aA t":AL :04? "BH $&T8v+Aa4L)8&ȌJqrLm ,28:@SML<` M &kAu60CB$F"q"""""#""""8"""""#]oTVtuIi]kT00Qd.*+5i a pYAt ""#o\wAcC; 3Dc;ђhfFQy^"q⥝p@ (P0AB;C02v\Y P_AQ  i fC0PH4ꋇV?AjAUU^괟$)pTePPDI^%9+8@ظ9٤hN!Ehm2~n..v ww_t_֓C:碋9՟DE=}W֩,)@‚ng6)|0@vHS H AO#sR 0D̈́$2:1 #|y>)I!6FIB!pD@αNqNΙ uΆjĺ9G3΄u3YqA d8<ٙpeR!:0c!!NDD?A3bOA<= )]  ໂpa .h0TAO0@0P ( 0!aLhZ 0 aP``0AZO4'I4аtNhE &$Q7}&: 8MDpy'zn¦SSU0UL M4 *.ƚgTD݅M=0Q7A aQp/D5G{Atm@ТsF M_PAMt gh }g;D/ZhZz/蝸aƋ/I-nUCH7H:^^a<&W:_2>?^\ x릡I›NxO3ৌ8`TE˾t?"H6fzIg8)b>BtKoH7b]?6N߯_?A}S~Z6{&oVj޵~nGa$KW uoI_KK'ުzPWojⷦ*_<|&=[^[Q{k[ }?O&0S#0PGC I)7FjHtxa0 -jy0&C"Cu`kfQDDDDtDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDibiU.JVD;- F@HOl-3M6[ÁbM4ԙHiطj ([ T(U Wp((PB@(((PPURUMWZ\V%aDHIуy96Ӡq]?V=~~u__U/K}WU庠SE@O0d]u?E3΅ s)2[e$쌎'C#MY sJU0%8M2UA0SF!(T<0 &hA4a 0A 0@hf<0%$ PP@3B0P BA(ASb DfS͌͑&.i31 FŸH.UHfCL0 Mw.(rCAL'hxL4 Al[pD੅L*iM CLxApiC ϊAoav WEPhaAƉTyD'Jhq tqvv4^A$wDꨜ4^04։EvD탃#eɜq t^II2%h&I|>`ȸMp'Ig6I? OǠMAh&tm@$ߟr+j~tkI~i7#O ^'[6:G ut&6M ~o[CM~I]:ӽ=k{_MMOCI#N_uWMuN~MVӿᏯޫ1>u*5_o_ _Շ/T_z=__/{b?,?/~ZJ\?Kց$?V൷XK+^L"Q[ oFKIIDߠvH-6A~z 7^CK!K{ؤ}_-°_kHN$rGK/$~WH/F$rGޗzo_dz{_wzuuz+m*m%VҿKomzi.o[W߭dyi^\Wᅾ҆R=—~tMwڶ5KJ^,֪ +IZ{`iZR FKMqzKՎ‘Mm[KaMa>.յm/ A/ WAn7O^/rG^$yk_p.g?}l?i}/~'H~+.z_hm-ۯj_[oKm/._P҆~`h.  v^J§e+-G[uꂺ d(ӻ DφM6 %jzmW cQMja-8M\ %K堻  0<(@ @ AP@  ڎ)ANLq@@KnR,~L()/ / 4wnB0VUԆu5p¾QR"HHA!p! `D""$HhDeQ"#"#KRka-&0AbQQ ZJ 0BABT"o5ƕuKD\xMK뺶P&j#"8Z8eƣ-#5зe%(-”~X^ 4g (@ endstream endobj 61 0 obj << /Length 5066 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im62 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F63 11.96 Tf 75.60 707.76 TD (United States v. National Lead) Tj /F63 11.55 Tf 152.88 0.00 TD (332 U.) Tj /F64 10.38 Tf 32.64 0.00 TD (S. 319) Tj /F63 12.20 Tf 30.96 0.00 TD (, 349 \(1947\). For example) Tj /F63 11.65 Tf 127.92 0.00 TD (, royalty-) Tj /F63 11.92 Tf 43.20 0.24 TD (free licensing in) Tj /F63 11.74 Tf -388.56 -28.56 TD (a price-) Tj /F63 12.03 Tf 36.24 0.00 TD (fixing or market allocation case would clearly bestow a windfall on the plaintiffs. No) Tj /F63 11.96 Tf -36.48 -28.56 TD (consumer could have expected) Tj /F63 11.91 Tf 147.84 0.00 TD (, but for the conduct) Tj /F63 11.92 Tf 96.72 0.00 TD (, that the intellectual property would have) Tj /F64 10.88 Tf -245.04 -28.56 TD (been free. On the other hand) Tj /F63 11.95 Tf 140.16 0.00 TD (, under the present facts \(as with cases involving equitable estoppel) Tj /F63 11.93 Tf -139.68 -28.32 TD (and laches\), a zero-royalty remedy flows directly from Rambus) Tj /F63 12.16 Tf 306.96 -.24 TD (s misconduct. CCB 12) Tj /F63 11.61 Tf 110.40 0.24 TD (, n. 11.) Tj /F63 11.89 Tf -417.60 -28.56 TD (JEDEC members reasonably expected that JEDEC standards would be free of Ram bus) Tj /F63 11.91 Tf 419.76 0.24 TD (s patent) Tj /F64 11.46 Tf -419.76 -28.32 TD (claims. Amicus Curae Brief of JEDEC 4-) Tj /F63 12.36 Tf 205.20 -.24 TD (9. Because the facts ) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf 101.28 0.00 TD (demonstrate that ") Tj /F65 7.66 Tf 87.36 0.24 TD (but for) Tj /F63 12.00 Tf 32.40 0.00 TD (" the) Tj /F63 11.91 Tf -426.48 -28.32 TD (conduct) Tj /F63 12.11 Tf 38.16 0.00 TD (, royalties for JEDEC-related applications would be zero or ") Tj /F63 11.94 Tf 295.44 -.24 TD (nominal) Tj /F63 11.92 Tf 42.72 0.24 TD (" the relief does) Tj /F65 8.00 Tf -376.80 -28.32 TD (not ") Tj /F63 11.84 Tf 24.24 0.00 TD (confiscate) Tj /F63 11.94 Tf 48.24 0.00 TD (" any rewards to Rambus) Tj /F65 5.00 Tf 125.04 -.24 TD (s innovation. ) Tj 68.64 0.00 TD (Cf Microsoft, ) Tj /F63 12.23 Tf 69.60 0.00 TD (373 F.3d at 1230. In short) Tj /F63 11.99 Tf -335.28 -28.08 TD (finding that Rambus is entitled to zero or) Tj /F63 11.94 Tf 197.04 -.24 TD (, at most) Tj 41.28 0.00 TD (, nominal royalties with respect to JEDEC-) Tj /F63 12.12 Tf -238.56 -28.32 TD (compliant products \(while stil allowing full compensation for other ) Tj /F63 11.99 Tf 328.80 0.00 TD (uses\) is fully supported by) Tj /F63 5.00 Tf -329.04 -28.56 TD (the ) Tj 17.28 0.24 TD (Microsoft ) Tj /F63 11.96 Tf 50.16 -.24 TD (decisions and the Antitrust Treatise.) Tj /F64 12.03 Tf 4.32 -28.56 TD (A Zero Royalty for JEDEC-) Tj /F64 11.87 Tf 144.48 -.24 TD (Compliant Products and Unlimited Royalties for) Tj /F63 12.38 Tf -144.48 -14.16 TD (Non-) Tj /F63 5.00 Tf 25.68 0.00 TD (JEDEC ) Tj /F65 5.00 Tf 42.48 0.00 TD (Uses Is ) Tj /F63 12.76 Tf 38.16 0.00 TD (Reasonable) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf -142.32 -28.08 TD (The proposed remedy restores competitive conditions to JEDEC standards) Tj /F63 11.73 Tf 357.36 0.00 TD (, while) Tj /F63 12.01 Tf -393.84 -28.32 TD (permitting Rambus to collect unlimited compensation for its innovation on all non-) Tj /F63 11.86 Tf 399.60 -.24 TD (JEDEC uses.) Tj /F63 11.93 Tf -399.60 -28.08 TD (Rambus) Tj /F63 11.90 Tf 43.68 -.24 TD (s contention that requiring royalty-) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf 166.32 0.00 TD (free licensing for JEDEC-compliant uses would be) Tj /F63 11.99 Tf -210.24 -28.08 TD (punitive and amount to a forfeiture) Tj /F63 11.68 Tf 168.24 -.24 TD (, RB 5-) Tj /F63 11.93 Tf 40.80 0.00 TD (, is wrong on the law and the facts.) Tj /F65 5.00 Tf -172.32 -28.56 TD (Since the ) Tj /F63 12.46 Tf 46.56 0.24 TD (Hartford-) Tj /F63 5.00 Tf 47.04 0.00 TD (Empire ) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf 38.40 0.00 TD (decision relied upon by Rambus) Tj /F64 10.94 Tf 155.04 -.24 TD (, cours have explained that) Tj /F63 11.68 Tf -323.76 -28.32 TD (royalty-) Tj /F65 5.00 Tf 37.68 0.00 TD (free licensing is sometimes appropriate. ) Tj /F63 11.63 Tf 196.32 -.24 TD (See) Tj /F65 5.50 Tf 16.56 0.00 TD (, e.) Tj /F63 5.00 Tf 14.16 610.08 TD (g, ) Tj /F63 11.78 Tf 12.96 -610.08 TD (CCB 11-) Tj /F63 5.00 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (12; ) Tj /F64 10.73 Tf 18.48 0.00 TD (United States v. General) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf -267.84 -41.28 TD (In arguing that the proposed remedy would ") Tj /F63 11.84 Tf 215.28 -.24 TD (confiscate) Tj /F63 11.97 Tf 48.48 0.00 TD (" royalties to which) Tj /F63 12.02 Tf -336.00 -13.92 TD (Rambus believes itself entitled) Tj /F63 12.01 Tf 148.32 -.24 TD (, Rambus hopes the Commission ) Tj /F63 12.39 Tf 160.80 0.00 TD (wil ignore Rambus) Tj /F63 11.90 Tf 98.88 0.00 TD (s wholesale) Tj /F63 11.98 Tf -407.52 -14.16 TD (spoliation of evidence and other litigation misconduct \(which already led one court to bar) Tj /F63 12.12 Tf -.72 -14.16 TD (Rambus from enforcing its patents\). Decision 19.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000343427 00000 n 0000343486 00000 n 59 7 0000343612 00000 n 0000343776 00000 n 0000391887 00000 n 0000344304 00000 n 0000343923 00000 n 0000344052 00000 n 0000344179 00000 n trailer << /Size 66 /Prev 343100 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 397019 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000449438>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R ] /Count 10 >> endobj 66 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 67 0 R /Contents 68 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 67 0 obj << /XObject << /Im69 69 0 R>> /Font << /F70 70 0 R /F71 71 0 R /F72 72 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 70 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F70 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 71 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F71 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 72 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F72 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 69 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im69 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 45607 >> stream e*U-@l *~2`m!K`i ,xQdf3QWv6-Ks0.E"#k#"›/Q)ƙH̄נP,!:FHh):5SS̐Vjvʈ Kc3;;*Hj@`(]#xA(;*0l%PU pX`)\w?…=DIpld B'mS (\x(^j8z:$=R;n zl4WwlV:+Fʊ0nTmDB'kAZMSRm ,_KHk JM't}7+!}vҧm~o㤖i}~R!%n @y>uFu@ќj=o48)M#dHïֿJ_IB dq~cPTH5=ALf8))O ll$q@_A?Ť蝴O(Q;h36zh:Ty39vD5M'l0TZ:_n6zwA#t#Ewa:O:N^Nilŭ82% q3Ay-b ')7_ZX4}JޛV'2< dna?gp4C׷'N#}x^M_m7MM^?Z] 7M{uI$5>E_ۯl+fooi/Njx*Iiiƾ;?_|׽}VWH6o'_W?J!uZ["3߭o(>cyb> ǂKJ"[U.U~ZJzIDK_c// Kڮ!W _u YEjaWIU}$_//3AvHK%kя_K]zKKk_o_ ]$wkgi*^G>y${ikߺ__kUl J)m+A Z}ZwWIiOA$;;Ka&_@J*!WiRAZi&a.K렡NiWL0a> ij]fc;a /ﭾSL&*k tB|0`TV+M0R %k01ՄKK׊uX*V.RA aj >!TTBi ѰG@Ũ!_!^iXv"ډ v**{ %G|pxk؍U""""Bg]0 M“p` 4[m;A0Ii[H A m*m4@!T0 6(d# 6 A m `/B""$GDD\DhC0Zaa7=?&: AaErA\M5mZL(L [j&I ! 6Ո"""""uA"Xe,e``303ɟA"fؗN""#"""""""""0^KMZol$ zP@m&R+ҭlA4Qerj|IDDDgTDG[3%Eʓ8fGd!s2(b]#ݽqjȧam3!(TN4E 0#V+.p ڦ+ &_LokIE_. 굥k20bEga2.(r|9=LC2׭_L/;-㮫IUzK]_UKJfTuז&G e˱2AL͢"'GvCM"ChGHF FG^>.` аP&0@υ>)D;F^Of:AH3"x5 dCPKB= 9F6CFR D| 2>BVPCp`.t8_l*C=*A5 00 oA0L  (P   A `E0(&`SQlꑡ<Є &A;֘DNޮ %_cEx<` ACDifl&M0MBQ; 5OipUNS a]%^}va4yM`ȣNnNfb4A6Wg:/"x4^V-`Z dƓ ƉE;ċ/ 6nwߪZMOI~~T/Wnu &JҷN27I6x:Z d\S@ȸ*tN--&uYNlSdOIRҭ%ۭ--*TgVW}}jN);ut)i7:{_OtIսuwU+RJ7KBY֬ׯWvv鯮_~T%cWU_zUi|q4v_n'4ִKzUBMOUT[_^z#|C];5]* %"H+տ^ S/]׫t{m/D쓪t+ U!zzG^AV=/ pFXYb<_ ` iV]mQ]BIﴂ'a"C"CpU:*K# Az_WO,0%uUO+1^ׄ_i }Vֳ^_c_uaz_H;$~ K,k$vh£c=V/$k-Viukڷ@-ai#索]KF;R~+ {iKH{фO޾߭G֪jׅwRh]װ +_ҴIK__m/&U[vE!L0Whõ҆Um_V ¶bom49am&0Afq AZ֚QTA {\S U`{־) } @}ZauSyث ua{/AIKM4UL& !U R!M4MXjI؏cՊbAbiFziX@ؤ;\ωv a0F (AU8A m h5@abB: )^Z Zv:j*+[;i4zMDDDDDDZDDN0B0keMᅆ 0hM 8A 6A@dG S h4 @h&": ` 0AhDQ}-""(0^ d |0_;VjaiSAaw( I8"")GF"""""""CDDDDDDDDDI0A\|DF_.z]PFAzV[IRJ $$2h Xa!0I+b (AiAa "#XmGibQoj)3(e(((\&)4"P ZJʳDMN:kR鋐LHwYGx`_ o_Utu_֖숈H_U_A.0d ""HS !r9sq.d8fkGDST)U BzpO8h^a`D yd c$'5ԉk%aY-I<#mfǒg2#,.dM'oiH'N*Axa* qŅ< a0 `BP&M Dkj& OA7Ajcdˠph33 L0dMəAS(UN(PlDhwz~i8$>Ad1zx Z6Ld'bN; >|hDdϭ=m 7o_zvG K" 2>6Hx"[Az޿n޵o_a7WwE݄ZOt:jn7Z+{Kkuմ_,ya@_8i|/M15խ_'߂$? j'_/ "O? /AK_"w?/!CT__K K^/_uߥ{]_oOZ_Ku/Km? V^Zu~֛/UJ=~j_msyjaZMI7j;+״J#}:K‘V *w[_vP`t:ox=)Rv4cmbnװCm= cNja ;" :dXMU6(0@ lT0A{-KLAƞq+*rղ L'L&]M6MEL&:dH@ AP@ `  (""""""""""""%al ` ASy0̷L(^Ȯea|+ reM6UR`?&~A4"""""#W|/Х@/V 3f#3U0Gf(gd qY udiV⥝2d]pP (M4 2WH̃2g| ^0arW(/0I#,6љb~z뷯nE#C 0{Mn@C"&A NıWk___~O־@$Ȉ!`A8ΙгTjGS0jDgA t4-0L taB DA-K"`D)DM" FUΣ:GB5f=2הdԨNv (O)/&4M$=:i& 5 yBk Mb;aF 00 _ȩB le rB7`'fPAt.= nm,Q8@h'Aj0ά:AM0; pL &|T& C8*3OSPO?MOHnEF z~EwC|8Aa08aSUMQ7j'O'tN=z' SN&U%DZoP<~c#BAd;@[)tmtMgh ֿz~Ɵ0mޓ"XN`}pa6ZN &ppa7㾷Z޾^OzOm=R_7 Ǵkߵ>I_[&7_ /{kK㯺??߯Z_bM_/ DR>GngI / K7/l?CM~i__h/~mLaX9zb!6_l}נ]*d߿"ivi ]iy_Ә^g56K^/_W[JjuMJ _{_~m/}V׫]~ޭd1Oeد2]ُ.[_ͯͯa  ڦu[Mm(aqv&GnO WM6aSO a@Q qM ab# V Z4JG0a(j֬pzA )&M5_ թvj 50ha  adG[ mlTP aA@ HQ0AAL ( at 0M&VCPH5/0im&A"!SH4ڠ4 ᨈ@%8 ^|͊nFd*fˈiL)hD2t͖8wf̼q!8-Z^]c yr('HUڊK-S"<eKzԲ'g Hdf\ZaH0.d6G3'촊W;FEHdIݕ[V[H  i(, d;ǶA P\BJ3qᄘ82=ԕUu/w^YR< bK-Jk)W/\tk_/^KIkZIWH2Z38.H==4{5F}`@ٱ_HԂje/ҳύ<'I8{M"&\܏ ȸ 'iJRo'.(WJ&VOJ$޵zZ]iu{Z m[jn߅O }]% ])k↫Ү*Ҥ޴뮟oZ^_ZKUTIUzI ^]i.*XQkoI۵ߧ#]R.Pz֩/֩VDZ_?׮Q]PA߮K /\0/wu_I%Zu"OKIW_JT^_蘛,o&%Z$?K }R]jtEa=JI$9]*X$?-kz [i{iw>^]}IZ_TֶAzz_>Kz]izҤu_K ^FF%d܇>\7_HT0KҤ^j]k]]R0Gw>mk^5ҭKяT~kZ1֖aiek{0]k%%u.HzK/i.Lvk}5V,q\U:^8zT*K?nUUU^"4[_nkRpRZQJ(X⢐%QVc)BMaE** j{خUU_w9 .ڱY0j *CtA@ tUS %8MG ZGq -=ح@}wVlRa5Tv$H0M&TUFijd#A&iMSثMMNB)퐏MVcDDDQpAa23 & L&0 0PL aB! A@M ڪ 0  a0jSuA 00RDDDDDDDDDDDDDDAh:a00PMK$<L. / ;ڂaO›h^DDDDDDDDDDDGHDDDDt+I*([K,Р*b Z5X4fFAٙEwI2KZgbSH((\.vBi^…p1I2TĤ舡]_W9-p<D)]-qk_KUU]U//}Im]B?H> h"{B,(&.q0@f<2C4fH!C62RDlO1r.- lB  zvSUMNUDzƺPh0UASM;0 a BаT M DICa0< a 0CAM RopjB30O8zxMf<+yԊ Ir n`:6poOM[t)ZOU#W a~Vv_Z}~uk_*WN }}.o[cK᪎>봷iOҾbZ ߿z u^F=1덮Z?[ @LK /_/}/I#U.1˯__׵A__ïm?"O°~uӿᰐAWIo^"wa"wFoo/|k7 _ Ko=>, ?C,܆ BKр[jso Zu_t^_-{J޿Kޘ___JJ}0S _wm{[_k/_}a& ?WOD vekkf?`V &]]}iZZ_ /VI HWjqq[F@☭> GA |[R kupa|C5@$ 3 lt`A d(AQoMp׮؎=v*#A"/ p=&*iv6hiXAa}'vT݅A0"B6E4iMTbX Pj;Jҽ.b %,DDDI 0L)MMѓHl&ז…[[ _"h4k6EA L) @.)!4GHTP iA 6h4: TDDDDDDDDR:!:T0Aιo{ a0PE0 K4a0K/ 2#281m5W1e7;!e~#Tka/}i0iKDG,TiX쥒2I#Z…L&vRa"&_2oApT   ܤRa%(&F^꺢o(H0T -NY@]6.PP\8W ~Wirej+I=PrZ:N."'Vtv*,6zAs5Nl A>R-'kiE Xt.[KI}҄I[Zl'_ ]=_'_c\]W֓uk:tz\.u}J]}}qҾ?~oY#rz/OWƺao/Ћ,'^&,GK6/Wzu?KK T_pOma;{]kޚ^ 760ׯ}"Q$CGds_Oo__쑮mدk[ itտ۫~+G149zM}mjZW?hkxPk+_~ҵҾm^/߿h}v+튽;¶ %K]~/u][Ki-m%vk %i55J1Q8 إwKȣ--.au/}5ec8644خib 㴪M ;?{{C_Ol!Mm*aa M4f a 4vGA6)=aڴKXݧ[i{T*I8"8&–ǃ0AEpAjȎ Vw0A"ʁi o[UX@ 0Aa 0#DDDDDDDDDDDDDYCAA Laxaz4vȮY–a/鰚kXGF""%:B"%b"$Z }DDDz_Ta!!SbQaGE^(endeEt).Z;Nep,J6U!菛G|"'NÏo_$28ZM্IsA82%CMt¬Ml'oT5MmRi~ t!uɎDu__B?n_0?$zCSaW_om/{_ uO_Vb%caM1Y}ׄU(i[Lv׵ `QmSӤ؄Zi6AAS6 `DDD0-Ap """ Lӄ;+GnPaIxEneV-yn L !q#&2Rqtŕ^dR0 2P& jk Cr9r-$ȧpʜfԮ%aƆ2'fK,:i)%M?A8;Ba ŕBh0ڧt,t^4RDKrPd D0+t0ztNڤܐU*vJA hU-$kkKA8ڼ ګhoI6֓gc짔%vPw;.niU]vwi+~B QcuҾi}{~?=Iџ70^_[zKKJ-$g߮ǯ'd>H_kW~(dN``tޛ/Koקg`*aL*U-/awjK;02.l# 2__?bA6Nt>앤G I.a: 5pdplX>0&dK~ 9oi.륥V֛joV^W-+Wa?¿I ?}/K]Co[_WWO}}:O_^lV_ ~ki}?CaG\k+7*}%x}?Bk]1?D"@5 #?*XrbV&3x~ƽ״_oO_e /_$ml}.~}v_%A~M/D&BC}[7{/!i]$H"LA1tgtۡd$y"dE5UzH-wuowi1K}tߟ]oB4'~i/V"w=6׺_~}@Wݥ. I4?SII߯(i}k5OiR0ᄙҴ{JM0]tm/1aH_ 0L0i~[Rxzߛ]Z Outk0KBoAX_xiwi\wt^1_ǬTRzjT4߶i?ASaAURi}`>CA BOah4%]vV4\V׫L_QVz[LiDG<(BphEU<PM{h&aMlt6 6 n@ @MG@ `b < =㈉""", ,&g)6X0[N - CiP]X[_Ȏ^Z¦h] ""4"""""""hDhDC QpDDS4eMfN!  z 5&Bk07T"""""C[^_NKUMI*ZڄƂF](&l&I*CAa* 1m :CT)ˆ1@Tӏc2*Lj\mBWX M32DUPE*4[B\([ 3wrgjo֒Ap*a>,$6I%N'n0⢕`d&NNP*M%Oy/ g(yZ_Xk(foi"+=[]W޺du! Cž! e\%1hA/~0Mj0X&`Hb: P).f7B('#y5O=@BIaLL0AAڴPg A{0A p@\;#y|BHTIGL4<4D $ADuafz)E.-O'O 'uM'hdǢAt7Pi#Ea> 40PAD\"Z@ aA  `@ ا ؑaiol' '@hG 9z _+]&_Is p+IHJ'KKd\A,Mpt81=o{OUouO'I +r<; ZM~E~Pv֫k?[M7MW^_T? i"C= KO/'^N0]CƇI롆偖Ƀnw(_!W^?aI׿ᇿ_ z h/K/m?d$i/#7h/o __dtZh0M;*j7:h n0@iA D'&ba8uJ. % %ڬ5i[b-Q' aCaBh0)cKW0Ҧj3  dH@0@ئDu 4)(0AT"""""}b""'""" `? 3rf`@kmvL.5¦35dO'DB ` 0""""""#^,0aŕ5Qe,geٌStL4 M2Jv ((/0\IsLȻ+EG,U*`S엳*.* 7!At;&m<' $U}3O6K;kqpW0}޽}___!d9E 0xCb ”@)88)m 2>AL gt3S%^Pڄ  „&A- ,0@03*L#ph3pdj$9{_ 'I MmN d08ߧD5t%O ޾nWo, %i+mt&vJM -'5:a0O#)7N kr;z {wzZznۭ|kjiit]>(b. &}Wx*o߮}+`XakDWQ\nۆ1[|/0&0/ _ጔ1_᎐1?aJ;a_ 2r>M^ ]p_붒^ ?P?]/ꂰ6,Aᴗ a {#u۷o"O 6GCåi_z7M-렿kao_SoHKwCW {zὰ/_oKK.oGh7_os}!}}^a^Kz}-7}>ޥ׭o\_ik{k'ݥn#҆鰫ZM0_~cJԿvcmW ol%T $ÃVVjQVi{ا0IᄿaZPm_IZ)uZ[ ea"8@ lUqLtS0m2SM*UQդ +*=?mbn t wK;Ҿ݄i i(L*02,&AiAA:iA a+bE;mv1mZUڪ aǯ (G XijXUx‚:6 \#10A;A&T] A4Q@ E0 @MqM0@6zd#02#i0A mDDDDDDDDDDDDDD"Rl0L&aԱaKp 0T ֿ 7aI |MS 4mDDDDDDGDDDDDDE"" e,#'H0D )3 &00""""""""""?WY ,0@ IŔlG,ť%guY2Έ}B ;Te(RieNwE -*) azb%a|`q2VBL,ŴywQ< ,Wڠ[IW_-/kuE:F̊#dj"8d1&a樧_O]Uǂ fc0TACB60GAq)" )rk%9c:"3a|td5#Rz4ª`UBt\@<(M‚M04"<&0A"44fR u͐D?(dnxeL( k2ygD~#lC2UD8~Hʴz:Ae9EF{x~մKV޿ݴ+Ib;]/]_6+0JzG?[KKKJҴu1H4L%I0F0Wqگlq0CvҴZOJڂ8Vcn· /߯i0_]{}aaqAAGM p@v0NM?զB>5Vq_vlmkZQ_uiXM6)[ kiiXCӰ aU(i|06 6 l&dGACTS@ t'uuviZMk [ DVV)W"#W^a{S[ ¬4i&X[ ZBa  S[A *)@)dGm4k @بE20ADDDDDDDDDDDDDDF]@Rp00kڨM4kAM*p ; L*jiDqHDDDDDDJa)8͟V` ;&৚Na ?&|L"""""""#B"8^?S*`A0@#DGQ咝RES"eqX-`ȑlvd^NʑVgu2^ɽB )ހL&h/U (, O}\p-߿Hmfefd`_6d9E-2JUHkݷ_z0R addtf5JD:2n(#qF3{ C:!~&h i>? P ` 0!D$ `! |y: Q31 pf'2ʂ%+η_TP0(~ 0] AL(*L xAT w@By=S@l8)s4'f>2CPSH"6F3dC h(DCY% )0e<쐓=";r[e97L4^P8aSDqDyUD$;DkT¦4nީO8(M=pi80`a`0 0 L `? &C.T-#ƐnA`cIIAؚw^8y 4D8aajU8*zJL+8*i*& &U i]$I^OKӥfId\i>'ia0wRpdQMzH6UlEۺ'xd^PNEP^8O)O蝸 y39w*OJZ^ЯP/imjI&]_nd\"Go E&0}&t`Ȗ'q82%ptg6XIAXޗZ;W*?M 馝I] M/unr8_ Kޫmm!QhT^z޿.R4 W~鿿߯K_v}&_׽iWÖc?'?/IW_}!ů֫[z?-X&%T}_Ua*IVүa_#`Wuꩽw%a7_!QI$A/_FR"$o#}_]߯ $*^{cV+~kG?: /u/~۫-/9_>o9"s$,y%ixP:L@&i(CEiBȓ0@8( yE: P ঑! ONKACh^>H6LY yYxL-}]z~}ji{K_T>>j:pJE o44Aqa޺I륽k;[u]nOZMZ_OOiu[^ڂmk1zIQ[~WMwQ1_au^^?{]7JօAqw_s_Lg_&%__D[Uտ\?E~#P?n۠__K ib?&Xzd_ 4z_۫KKߣ?{]𿿰~Gڥ# . "Oݰ?%ob܇6 4:W~ނ {}cXK$~?$wiz w_)}XKO$oHE#K(<$nQ-;nڶ{UokZVk__]}{ G?iU_Vmե_J4튵ka/YV=0Z_v0Ҵm{K]om~ﴽ[N00ҊV)6? _1VzfS KK%u[i]}^TȐAnA m h7b> %]6؆֓TAQE61Vz~XMo*va 80e۽*ᅰa0{ZjM0N 45X `d 馢i4+: 4J+VZZLU.PHDDD׻X*h0a^4L)}dA-a40A$&!b6OP xA *( ilP aA$8i5DDDDDDDDDDDZ `0&T+a0aa0j  M L&MCMURi մL$ᆚiDDDDDDDDDDDDDCՑL!&tHs0^ aKR>&AL&7)1aAq&U)6&M1e%mIfb] i.)a{Qge 0L0PQoP]`*QV`m z~}u%ٴB~TA8YSBq/ʱ՞w, *xO `3b" A;6a5 L/p;47}yD$a7{:A$N[?Z:V/kkto۝_ fIkwH_}wtKOK^Һ8_ i¶YG^M׶Zڧ D0@: Qm0VE8K֪(a>9PA t5]E &Y3 *v &dA5i"""""""""" 0L & """?-)唡\QK%p0!# C;NaAT'ZdDE, *B^T.P9萁VWne$K%vXe@I_\/w3qYUV}(@ 4 AQ31 xR@c#6GAAAB^?ra\ϥ___^U 7pAxA5a40A!.0=)8)0);0fbA0'ŐD B=I<2r(y>=KqΦ_*՞IL+eeO_I6z'uM$Cp==f [͍3apTS !Ƙ@д,   ~A\ Z" %9@SP\d' '#LسI'>) An4t_Q<-'3h $^8a0UTHv Pz Tm8D SO~ ثjfL&F ~|v0_PGWdWJ>tAI'ٻh<(<`ɜ4Oa07'N'tNB;~ND郃C'hy44Nڪ&ᰚDIޚxM?֭~l&}Mc|eNܝIDWttA4 37<xAպm>cAT2sM"x}~7֭]~t] 7֯%zzxW| `tJc#lzIbk|0[J}[Wm/յ}_*UZn툯ت|o㮷ꝯ}zҺKzWi`}-*4}}+5حqmx_]k}l0 ` (sۡ Wb:U]n_"Oۯ'_B,?NXM82X"ށ__i_xml?__ֿ@a/:aK/_] %' J5n$H"O___Kدx7!6oI_vAk__m.^ژ#$~C_o. ᴴa?LG7 ZVH{I/z_i_N}koR_z/KObvZkKY=kZ_KKv״&_mC}XRW_ja~V_eimژ_ Ȏ ؅\S!H6!QWTKA5b>x+k~bC[k (_a4MP dGUA 6 iݍ0U' X0Ҋ կ[ %u'`A tjCSht 00UiM&mSM  QA lt0@ئ @B:Ch6(6)B"""ш<"""uDL?@I,{Aj (L-Zk\$ UTڶ ޚA|DDDDDDDDDDDDhDDA0@C=2a ! C ` L )^L)nXaDDDDDDDDDGDE!IU/IV $$Yl*Eq Hd%5 $¡j5(,~?l6du 26jC/@x*eq  uElWy0PBLH(DC2KS)j[ f7D(P(U  0d6jRH_ pq+x89~H/ְot|C'I&PW.w%y,Elɚ}~_Cv}~G` ~CIz޾ܤhGU0f<(Lx)"8ApNr IQ'Øg? DDy'kֺS0T &a a C0Ai%u}?앪v,XM_ 6 Ni7O0Is3pd[ oEOy/iS^^{z֓x~.i7zB8cW}ki=^^]uO=u ~m/a/Q_WO֓_/Xcu?0/+cj??Dv}m,G/ɗp\rG W!A{ ߄N;kD{/^X`~}rdYd5wޗ뺿'[i%"Oa?|/>6Ȍuxw/0:_A^/"wZV>n)x7UC!C /m%/~דZ}wKK/+tm'I{WvoK⿿mf^~x:_뤗}-+Jֻ}կ]6>NkVLSiikaH}o`~յVjawjK_i%_H!!! $ %uE|lHWktZV5azQ]C+2?[a.7Tan_i(&)(0@Aza:⚃L;IcXa%X#bxa/ A ;[[O_UPaKԏL a 6Ai B @LS@B:@ 6ptoITj[P6'WҵJ5؇iDiƬTH\}P`DB ɸ)3CUa4L(-\jӠAA6Dth6Dt0 m6G@u[@@ B` 8Bt =7M""""""""""" P@2*h0A?3 &H~L&XaakVmVi& ZP[MdGi4Mi@dG x DDDDDDDTDDDDDDDDA""!!C ʚ 0؃ llAtL&~L h)KL&4ZpaA; iIDT8؈Bʚ /uIuoxa+H%ӊ $mEBjLP q&WBwt)n!0&R̷&QHɲ0RQ W)JTW ̍2;TJ,qd0BXnApT”[2$:pdAUZM_R0]<=;z]tZVA̒bEpppsNuUW֕W'#3!Ι "c4pIu_xfdL0C )3αt" d L7CgTyhU *i f0&h aa 0\1}T) dxR.2m0YQ$R%O!HJ$Oi꞉bM5L*xLBS8(AaHA0T  @p)ͅ>(Sff)B A!xŜK'4"EVD GRDmk8!YS2?pd\8:AbxAx| L!;qyDƪҩN8j$;Pzyq}?@0A O 4@  C 4Azj оtiޝ]v{6 Ml'A68;% T"xtO(ƋƋ9'Qhz'?07xa4!$T̈h4(WyM4N'l!hi8* ݪګ[+Wa~ m=;#~t . M 64 HCސA 6 ,wBq`6xxO:/JwLޯkޮ'][WKKootK(U$eN]d'KE2()?ML ;[]_S]}uKKUk} WuCMt;k WOņ? qW~7KWO]?uSauҥX oҏ㦐z/ r}o1BH%Upt!uQooIحl0}_?@9jL &^tVҖ_K&sK0: Nm}j ub/&_36{PU݄J?_u''_DuD1| /KA}~^Mwo^!Y4$ia/K Z_L07Wvsj#${ivHKbKج]5mu}m*KwKz=xk]¿cH 㴛޿{Jt],S KM~]~?]zoi6WW_ _ªZ߻MjMio{jaaWLT4b-mbu`HR _V  YvK~ҵh `& qQ@@)); {L4.L $SOqlSu.j+ 1Z'1鬃zd{)^bVק1C0Ja 8 :b m4N 0A `u Bk銵b֘*89=1|7Ҵ%$5 (*0OSa{AdW,m MU4Ȏ5$ @h6A@vni6 aI@* T܃˙ia0aNa^inKaM tȰȎAA h ݠxu""" C "1+?a3f]4a#qN 2c I ?`)1a0""#B""""""""b""""""#Б-'Ij]$%K"ܕkjiPD'QQI\im0Tv0a'g*(s&d 2_DA,}΃ e!EN.@ge̝ ̫2FTt;4vӈ1d2 <^0M3:D6 <. ampT)6R[᳹#t#"xW􋾒-ܭnm2hi8=SIlH5Z=nNϕ|D+"V>w~jJ:K/I/_W䇒"V!-WXC 0&`S|SHEfj3[N$^0Ta0lSTK/6DEgAgAs gL3ѭѫp9vEU\&QT`" a< ` (A S1"Ysα" 3dcD-RgrM = MO-Qi?A/t/<& i "xEUpdPrc t_OwWնJN0^a=6~f~MsKII 2.4Ppi "C@|t_ۭw]~hB޽'Iz /V$OMVN;64;V_}u7Ux6Z^Xz8z_>L[bկ쏑~ۮ ` xn_k_ŴWDZ\1{Oo%aoa྽# څa]^ mO$?\/K'Nk'u/km/Ỻ}oaXD>'!?mvV__67_%} oX~_yȌ7_"ۿ=_uZ _,7om}4_!~ !`iu={aW_m~z Zڥ۽K]S O_}oJ_t߿_ci-ComRm!kXJl%Gן~jKۯ.*)ǭQkjWdtX0xVOZel/{ /ۯK_t_ou=}VӴk 0r a8a) 4ab.'cb`|T0C_ƻ +#^_~bmU -W_zȎ Aڅ!4)(`5YTb)Tӆ ;KmZ^R}iqjC.;_mCpOPmqPgX!$l0 @L&j2+kN0@0A0@ucAh` Aӂ B bmUC 548`VRj ZDDDDDDDBa0P@h4Du/[8iW / w{Zl* 0 @i!ESO@!D&:p@UtaaDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD! ]. f6  0 5aPa|&M[JDDG!Hae' *hPʟ(m*[{T3%0fAi*㲄vH~ (PN} ;ƲFvnTpNą…P02wIi_UAApPPPPU*@)EsfAT^ӕsS%J28 =_u<ƌD8f[/}kպuk_}U:G ᙙ$PΨz_B  &` C͒8Rq>pkdhfjdc"%}zҴªL*xTЋAڞL!H^` 0P@ p%sc: O31B "#Xx\ٝ_CЌ3asyy"2+(ɔz~E5)I'hh : n4_eyN_~#vH{/;DZo]_'uK_}z0KX-mn{]mm~Ҧuҷmz!R/=m$TW4ްm&]ͯaifkֽiZj~kK(0IM4U8a`]I;q}v6+ VjZLU=Hԏ}~TJ[NjjK_ 0B@qQ@(`:*B=S tJՋniJ{J$,R;wLTlr ikz _Zv*CA+ |aIg&j ah0i m5MP  m40iBB> %KVҺj jJ kqqiPmCITw-ҌDDDDDDML)5&a5i0bS": x l ` 0M bMNiRt c4" `AAe8L) w a{T„ZXh44…T , m@M4a6h4 `&$DJ!0%H0SMNA$=nL&AɺfH#pDDDDDDDDDDDDDDEADDDkIjb#I%ihH5M-,S %]E1QZj a(6M}ynZ`$Kv]3:l!SL -LN,5 PU -̅ĐRqD&\2X® 3#G…4$t ̰zU D-O Ċ+.T\X5]9.%hA̴@p{/_[6v8oo_֕{ BlgM'tTNjj߮B 0,`̄ dO sKy2=OF/άO-}"wUMTIAMJqMB &(Aa? D`Ba<2Ԑ!m9.E"?E~R^$輠"wLO* APaUw` 84alPuS xL Pa0X@a0B̛Bj D&'xA\Ba6N/CD3L2LfCk<Ccc^|aMOM vؙHq,x2}EB &2h/TNh=Atf_Dމ=:M0M0ML fC L&xxT 4AAA?!Ca/O:N '&sI:ps1 6qz6Mhq46tOhq/a4/TxDO(7i' 4!蓿N(UT"x&E:j ־}6+WRolba:X0HC޹48)MNx]i827N 0"q A'Mh8MO2b!H4]_ot~~tL'VI+^ tdpVվ˵opa:h&ׯwZ+b=?^_V7Z^uC__Ot6 뾬5WO[TvG5znoǿ޽߶ yi!_=$=п} Bڶ_/a`# ,G ۯ},~|1?o/AM_~XX/Ap~ᰂ/{m|/߭,_i}ivH.ֿJ?uMaD?i?z@mK^oa]=$N,>kz_uHGH!ւ۫Ip޷0a_[}]mد{XW$^Ho\6 y"Kk}_J]~ד~Au_Q@ _JPGv__+[K/}tp{JKąvحXca_׵RvKKoujOok{plth4JB**@^>j!4bKX0KOa. wZJ_M/|mL& BiL5M1A05i$6O^:Պ㴭&?bMm*C6={DV#?o: k^X )w a4dAM4M b 6Dp1@  m am!QM'n ;vJ4`Q*&ҵNӈ>6*6l)Ј0L lL ­0;a&mꩠA `LU0A#6)1F`2tB hTPAmG ('LDF\?eze}jkvVV02/5(L%"8&ᦚ ӠA=T 2#82vMHA%Ө`f ?&`&~U&L~Hl΃aOqDDNDDDDDDDTDDDDCTB#KY&K]'(a-z4iph ,{Xj?9njw44Mɚ+jX* a2 Ī؈*;*Y% !̯2AB"D:L"3i습Z ^5aA PH$4 zפڪY֖ʊNtH%/ܑ|]U_I,t{II$HREuK*I*VJJq Dal$O6Dx^'3s k$N}5M6 Tjua N "  Y*'6V^G'Q=JR!0kZⓥIQ p *Dp*͊t*`Ayvl!Nh ? Y@˲2RQVmiX)E9;z&L8vPPt4M8*) 5.* &-iB:ǣHd)ZT:: 'tlAwZqh`ɧ/'m^QyC Tvª.XMW3g0H!3c0>׺OO vv~Go|$2.4h'Iul Gze' &:'͉> UBk<&aBaBGR8\ZA`ҷCp~[մoJvlM:M 0iT!ɠe:K=(!~^k^XKUҾx>ǥE>Gm%_kKޟҤ뻯[z$--fO>?A7mQ?1l_Ij5U}RZAVЪzKLG#{{K]+J+RҨ[KM-]yca&2i$UT]tA&Kw0_K%TUPiiRZ_{_o$ ~kUD _J֔Kb]!6CAtۯAzUKTֱ ߿.H=L l _#Jd/.GZZKK-Vn~ׯJJ]./_zYүkK_i}[VozIdeפJ$GFWzXk—`_ m[[mJ: KKIQ%UI?QVFLWjk^f?l$P_}ٵi_}ߙ%Ri}-t{KKn뤊-"E0@ا0 t]ݤziLlUi`X1H-Um-%z&ZTgjh]jI'&ii @:M HWT[V=VixZlG%a(MZXIURki.foC[nBi)pKJa5?&~Rqa4jiئM 6 5!0A0A 6( Ӑ&!U0VU%Sa&;[^ mK $DDDDDDDDDDDI PL'^a(L(_tvi;A0a0<B!}EUU+ @z(&+l$A+X:Z5#2+2L 3Lחh0]ڐ!XUL ªa L(AT-NA+bHDEDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA`0@ 5Lş:h& 000j4"#B.""""""""jb" iuKJM-PI* $K׊ZQa#-Cqn#RC)5 g|!y:ABh0Vh)N)N$fg`WI*AQ;a$ A 5^v4R&2QéH7Mp(iNH"-P[ իjIA ߪI/P5VIM+E㧤qqN]KFZ&m+TQq;&KWVI[I{q_M~kJ֫W}=6w4tըי?J^&œChSlgȑ#CG#sd<-&TfDDEOa4BfcL&|a0(B( B `5΁ \"v  0D!A8S0dл%aK:EMYFR͊aρ0UTB 0PT 6A 00B!*f "'  31 8("% Z͑CQ;Z: G{ n&v-//5;`zNꉽxDP؊zt 0H*i 頃]U&հ`ȸ!zs &I 1=n[Ix ATN'',: ڪAL&C'BvTvAD0 km-. ot46Ӥ%k}*ta?ONNM悇Y9nEIfff)X14 ӟH'H6l]VVTW]uЭui&={& a0y-*o%pjtldvl{zz^I]/otxMoUCMm0!J (cht(oWum!Z }8ե^6u?Çx^_}6KJ$"@˿l?Xiz| .e!.XI{ӷ_%mTRm/x_x"/m~.n{mDA 7//I'Ii n%k(}>MioKRW߯ uֿ 6 ~ KK/ZIzU^f0#IՊҤK鼆zKU[/F_oF}}tg6c//_wڱY#I>zE;zI+JN^K>6~UIZzҤ@Km+W]m/߷m/Һ_/nV][*l$HGv0[i6~x^H7z5pD1KU a%M+K6? y;%M1L.a/W]BLBbbLh04Aa(0I6 $*j6|p*kj GJҎ!!*ӵa^YpA13&AN&a4,&*(  m0SMSA!0>ؠQTAib-x7c(iWKi5qDDDDK` nfl05ƙN &&Pp4aA0A{Ai0 m 6Dt m5W\DDDDDDDDDDDDD!G M0T+90vfOGCh0 az?a0 '4J *XB""""""""""""8g0R`][W} ؊WI'TRiUPJ׺i`I{_2I:[`^^m !ר a!Q,& "U!e "#҅&(孢R=}%~)zYʿ~KU Q廨\G_IY endstream endobj 68 0 obj << /Length 4921 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im69 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F70 12.43 Tf 73.92 708.72 TD (Electric) Tj /F70 11.80 Tf 45.60 0.00 TD (115 F. Supp. 835 \(D.) Tj /F70 12.07 Tf 111.60 -.48 TD (J. 1953\) \(requiring public dedication of patents\). In the remand) Tj /F70 5.00 Tf -156.72 -28.08 TD (in ) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf 13.44 0.00 TD (United States ) Tj /F70 5.00 Tf 66.48 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F70 12.14 Tf 11.04 -.48 TD (Singer) Tj /F70 11.87 Tf 37.44 0.24 TD (while rejecting royalty-) Tj /F70 11.90 Tf 112.08 -.24 TD (free licensing in that case) Tj /F70 12.33 Tf 121.44 0.00 TD (, the cour examined) Tj /F70 11.95 Tf -362.16 -28.08 TD (the relevant authority to that point and explained that:) Tj /F72 11.27 Tf 36.24 -28.56 TD (The test. . . which ) Tj /F71 8.83 Tf 91.44 -.24 TD (rus through ) Tj /F70 12.00 Tf 63.60 0.00 TD (the majority opinions and dissents in the) Tj /F70 12.46 Tf -155.76 -13.92 TD (Hartford-) Tj /F70 5.00 Tf 46.80 0.00 TD (Empire ) Tj 39.36 -.24 TD (and ) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf 19.20 0.00 TD (National Lead ) Tj /F70 11.91 Tf 72.72 -.24 TD (cases and the only one which must guide the) Tj /F70 12.25 Tf -177.36 -13.92 TD (Cour in framing an anti-) Tj /F71 7.71 Tf 119.52 0.00 TD (trst decree is ) Tj /F70 11.94 Tf 69.36 -.24 TD (what measure must be applied in order to) Tj /F70 12.03 Tf -189.12 -13.68 TD (dispel the evil effect ofthe defendant') Tj /F70 12.11 Tf 180.48 -.48 TD (s wrongful conduct -- which means what) Tj /F71 8.13 Tf -180.72 -13.68 TD (wil restore competition.) Tj /F70 12.00 Tf -36.24 -28.32 TD (231 F. Supp. 240) Tj /F70 11.75 Tf 82.80 -.24 TD (, 244 \(S.) Tj /F70 12.34 Tf 63.84 0.00 TD (Y. 1964\). In short) Tj /F70 11.62 Tf 88.56 -.24 TD (, a royalty-) Tj /F72 10.84 Tf 51.12 0.00 TD (free licence is remedial) Tj /F70 12.51 Tf 111.60 0.00 TD (, not puntive) Tj /F70 12.05 Tf -398.40 -27.84 TD (because it is ) Tj /F71 9.08 Tf 61.92 -.24 TD (necessar ") Tj /F70 12.18 Tf 54.72 0.00 TD (to dispel the evil effect" ofRambus) Tj /F70 11.83 Tf 174.48 -.48 TD (s misconduct.) Tj /F70 11.96 Tf -254.88 -27.60 TD (Rambus also obscures a critical fact ) Tj /F70 12.13 Tf 174.72 -.48 TD (- the proposed remedy pennits Rambus reasonable) Tj /F70 11.98 Tf -210.72 -27.84 TD (compensation for its intellectual ) Tj /F72 12.90 Tf 156.96 -.48 TD (propert. In ) Tj /F70 11.95 Tf 62.40 0.00 TD (contrast to the open-source IE proposal in) Tj /F70 5.00 Tf -220.08 -28.08 TD (Microsoft, ) Tj /F70 11.97 Tf 53.28 0.00 TD (the proposed remedy here would allow Rambus unlimited compensation for its) Tj /F70 12.08 Tf -52.80 -28.32 TD (innovation in all uses unaffected by its unlawful conduct. It would prohibit only collection of) Tj /F70 11.98 Tf -.48 -28.56 TD (royalties \(which it otherwise would have been unable to collect\) for the applications affected by) Tj /F70 11.92 Tf 0.00 -28.56 TD (its unlawful conduct.) Tj /F70 12.02 Tf 35.76 -28.32 TD (Rambus argues that) Tj /F70 11.83 Tf 95.04 -.24 TD (, even with ) Tj /F70 12.25 Tf 55.20 -.24 TD (unestricted royalties on all other uses) Tj /F70 11.76 Tf 182.64 -.24 TD (, a zero royalty on) Tj /F70 12.01 Tf -369.12 -27.84 TD (JEDEC-compliant uses would be harsh given that ") Tj /F72 10.94 Tf 246.72 -.24 TD (relevant legal authorities) Tj /F70 12.28 Tf 119.28 -.24 TD (, and in paricular the) Tj /F70 12.01 Tf -365.76 -27.84 TD (Commission) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf 65.28 0.00 TD (s consent order in the ) Tj /F70 5.00 Tf 104.16 -.24 TD (Dell ) Tj /F70 11.72 Tf 24.48 0.00 TD (case) Tj /F70 11.87 Tf 20.88 0.00 TD (, are of relatively recent vintage and largely post-) Tj /F70 11.97 Tf -215.04 -28.08 TD (date Rambus) Tj /F72 11.49 Tf 66.72 0.00 TD (s conduct." RB 8. This call for leniency fails for ) Tj /F70 12.24 Tf 239.04 -.48 TD (at least two reasons. First) Tj /F72 10.24 Tf 124.56 -.24 TD (, the) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf -430.32 -27.84 TD (Commission found the conduct here to be substantially more egregious than that alleged in ) Tj /F70 11.81 Tf 437.76 -.48 TD (Dell.) Tj /F70 11.96 Tf -438.24 -27.84 TD (Rambus acted intentionally to implement its scheme over a period of years; Dell') Tj /F70 11.83 Tf 389.76 -.72 TD (s single act was) Tj /F70 12.03 Tf -384.72 -27.84 TD (not inadvertent) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf 75.84 -.24 TD (" but not necessarly intentional. ) Tj /F70 12.04 Tf 160.32 -.24 TD (Dell Computer Corp.) Tj /F72 10.16 Tf 110.40 -.24 TD (121 F.) Tj /F70 11.61 Tf 40.32 0.00 TD (C. 616) Tj /F72 10.61 Tf 31.68 0.00 TD (, 625-) Tj /F71 5.00 Tf -423.60 -27.60 TD (\(1996\); also ) Tj /F70 11.53 Tf 61.68 -.24 TD (628-) Tj /F70 11.99 Tf 21.60 0.00 TD (29 \(Commissioner Azcuenaga) Tj /F70 11.93 Tf 145.44 -.48 TD (, dissenting: ") Tj 66.00 0.00 TD (obtain\(ingJ market power by) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000397346 00000 n 0000397405 00000 n 66 7 0000397541 00000 n 0000397705 00000 n 0000444173 00000 n 0000398233 00000 n 0000397852 00000 n 0000397981 00000 n 0000398106 00000 n trailer << /Size 73 /Prev 397019 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 449160 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000498290>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R ] /Count 11 >> endobj 73 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 74 0 R /Contents 75 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 74 0 obj << /XObject << /Im76 76 0 R>> /Font << /F77 77 0 R /F78 78 0 R /F79 79 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 77 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F77 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 78 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F78 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 79 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F79 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 76 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im76 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 42971 >> stream 唯TzzZl5-CU9n&Q؛;T;Ge̍Go. (U +)qڣ2[gxɸ7z ࠸Pd\4 #k[pwa$CV'i {vLN0vY"I__;Dh*W_]zYȻExpC'F1j+UT}zAq`B a F CO " B2 d%fLQιOkꗿPiN Dτࠡ*A `A&NDAy4f!&!V2<2(fUyAQ̑dT$ -a0OHS e=0U0*g\&C8)B "' !`0a`u9ȜA jdz@4)add?2.S "8d8 2@F٠8h'ICH4NǣBqe4- _b/)2.0}%ul \NNOX2(g K}/WoV_R}xO!;t*p}oiw__Z_={OW֮I[_t4Aq}>*+/{׺t>ܰ<1+?Ccb=~Ko_?Aa࿰dK~C [/j o_?"qa_hAomB_Yb#0_Y.Aj_D{D?Dߥ+___h/a Am-Anl ~1_ cO뤿ߒ4 (7 WP^د~}/K >HbJFᴿuU޻ '޿aȌ;KK__w[m_~w׿U4g#Ju۫װ)v1A_^/ -Amw~{{}u׿{]/5KM;bK`U`eKԿ____V/m_X hC i mLP P{KXڽV[LG "wQzC;[⬼{^BpHR<ׅ/^K]%c 1Ho`/> A@@dH@ `QPA@|tQpҴLG[V4 C1H&lEXOL,0jAdGM7dX L(@Ԅt6}4 lRw!GӴ:ؤI:Ө(bDDDDDDDDDDqB4 ()͙va Mxdnj U4h `a@ia=!46AqAj(4`jhmR A m}$DDDDDDT8"$›?&]D0t0©1TBj.< &S^* (X0 zN""""""6"""""""#UUWIa"JJBuS ~!TS5M{UQPPªa2!]\B-4( AwQM2͛M;H m{rl[FwN}TW}I]BI'b#q )C%*gyS] B Uv¨2| 4WbXE`DwDI` w鴞/TWZ V꿰'? _J,?7,7}/BA(oE}7o}|k]~3\)__Nij{ %;Wqja !G+⩦*IMNm*#aB7AqjMaOB& PUQDhu]R(AkQ $*NNYA1ڸ롏!qNgjvHD@)#ݴiv^2O2#+$8P<…APfAv q؝AЫP]pPi;S6KPP]?NbI&_VT`ohh?׷]t\;Uuz׮-W_25觺_]Uu_װ ` ( a ٱ`g8)8TIx8FfCOtLHkFW]u__i*j8(M:O<0A<(A  aK6D djD(MSABaAii:i>a0Gt96 "Ƌ b'ah;p'hHf;h0p}Ml0p'0M7_ oL'u[uyIs3؇ MM IAA8)& qju[ڮ_NOVذ_Iń $k~z}uIҾấ(c?תOOZ5^ݹi`l?/ⸯ a/`/{WVY5ODa__`~k Keۻ ;'߿/|G_]~ _E?$K7 K_o[ݾa#i^d.i^MV?(մ/mm3o_~ ׷+S +[u_1^ua/ُYl.Mi7JaX=}b'ikam%ڧNc] at6m]/m6fͦn^۬]raqAA G!0"!ziڭF4X;b)v)[N;m; jmO?l74AY{L%M6)*  Dt@ؠA aGMr*m:qV0ZQWiDÃV Xj_Q>b"" &R &+?) C/1aSJ6M40A@0@b46@ݦ!5A lmDqD0GLC eD0L& 4]kVD&i&Ȏ T0MZa8j""""""$RtH0aDd *aW  ‚g?` i4 넵J\,$U 1# Q qMɲ"]0fEsd*i&V22C;B 'SAJqّࠩ!d; ّ_&śM}WҪ~ 'JTKYL4Hx.> ^q(p:i}}W]"h4Q^;TɑE20Vh}W__zE'_KQ_J2#y!C:DFAJu La( `N tt"A#9adyN_U}Lة  p55  PBS 3!(E ] ZKLe ΤjkauU]}~,?p!h33D݄N黎kMpSB ((M`>A(L8AA fό!64C"ʆ2΄CRȦH"PF:LB5O&u3YњqHDSfSl:NH N 4q Ţv]ɺ 4^YCA 'axUAS SP4L((@ IAa a(@гa`?< r `L 31s1=Hאg H>Arm3ߎıbZ/'2r/v8wM$:O 4C& PL*p;PP=4E4gL!k~n_d{V6 &`G2%A6 Lgq)s@um'I&O"m n4K|{ߠ'zmii{pa7M]7 G }v Gtl$+b_/z}v}zڽ]z~Wzw'hk_/.^!?T(u}_o~{0_^ /ÎZ˂U}p]?}GC_~;uQ4X~X?5W_K w_VybOctN_A}_~ZWG_;J|>0patNu $_C쐵U%]m߹#H~ڃvHWozM_o{Kj?o?~O"/_ƛkuV߿_V[KߥVno~k kz;Mnǹn[_kkovVwc(4-)ym %U֗k_._h8 :c?O ?F0z1JwVel0;[n]#O _=Xa-zfB]i &l@( ppDA6Au}Rl4UX҆qIڧv];@Վ8@_⢛KmSU:! c.0 &jTdAɧm&h a0mA @@h`At'T:bMC ZƜS &iJaX""""""""Q0L@f0cװ ,4ժaM `QL mE`4AAd#4@" """"""""*Cb"""$N)3`e_P Aja{[TXa4A\턭V~""""k DDAD 0J5qQ]k0VB:D6+AEvU` j(:˴1%du $J++qY2"fVD4mpU dfI̟*"lYܷZ \K`(-0(PD!$D[;,@  }ʬ0d꺪-Ğx oϕx8Qu_}KU%]-W|0f:A.pD@!?__z0A~a'"q5@Bll8)Aʁ3͢BLU _PO}B uL zA0CD\"N$3RN D>MaB ~#eH0Makˋzd`4-  !˃ tf)B LR63Pal@1l tlS()R@BL Bh2&ϊlC.a:NT Ň ""x;jd]O! `ɸZi2$=tIM2NSPtU0 U6.xA &4?3L&a48. <&մ'%|g8R;OZA(Om'w&C/mh4ECD-v 24*iiTDj_uOu_T߫]WIHwH6 BzAeC=|/ED|X_4~gNx2s/Ӵ⫪zoKMIld~'Id[j>--&ό=:NV &tt]7uoڷ?ڿ-'h:MoҺ:MOJ!CW.zo}tn]ޯrc4a1cڤcjv{_~]!#<7j뿿}o1R{?u똻 Zf?oJI}om+4)j݅/0մ/a& ﯤioiZ_i;bM6Va(pqPMEZwkwW_uhaX:k]wiԿ4m[WK[[[ }J_ ikx@6Bh4a) 0I%k ,N? ⿎vcm+_Kb/cXۯa?R4֛m4  ؄QM1@STM5X x@uipl%lqViCJ[Ku1^=_DDDDD!$` : 1Ӄ /8A +XMAmt&mRȰS!LS!M ڃ 1QAM1@8d( aM!LPAQDDDDDDDDDI0B `4 5tԫ U^I M5'EIS &M & [HH0i 금 0@ (L&Z )nF 0L ,| a )cHx`ta5 """"""""#K/}@ɾeS@3g" }O;2;)PZaA(Sl4(L*;XB2* T5 I/. 5 B`҄LL,VfbI$Ev OOw} RmBiU;$E6L_M*-Շ]ҙI%Xm >o 'Ii~};I8:Ma~ZvxF? ]׏mk4꪿TܷGB5 3Q{6¯I]___a`д,4/iK(GuU `~-4R!YcȆld1: Ix#ltT5"B&/W 4^ ptN2`+  Bh0aSL „0 ` `Sb#PS`IjSœ! e &Me>EyQG I?3fjNDyM$i6|S_zKQD'phAS 0TSLz *a0A&h=S*`fࠠrP<0PL `4AW'O &_4t.4^4/ECUUTO6zaU0pM4®‚IƆ &;ia0T:[?Ӄ6k"CEmDMP'ME//AOyyE0eZ/N|Y t_8 "dȖMpN ;?{j\~Ir{׷ºn }'J'KtNt*M>"K׷MJ+.{DW8w v}ouoKoa_G^z!+oj[QZe:zw8`!+ w",0_-:|_yAk4MZ8_`rc,[u&3Ա _׭+Fh/_J?}?"-Oỿ[[MHq5=??$wW m7WW}^'Wղ2$m}[/l %#C1Y d5mrIm--{_M/{_ OMY&JZuZMi_~ף {_ۿ6 6*ӻ %z^a-[J0k [_om/a..5ՊbK/z0ۮIK%kkkGLP `Xj υ@!CZ~hBB %k0Pi[t`KҰIZ`Z߯|P0K0NAdWԴ&1IL oh 2؅Ȏ uLpamx;W.66);6c+m.׻@j/j h0p?mRL*M 0h4Š 59  m TR|tRiqLRkjwIt !ݐa0a33A Kp8imh x@ȐiTj aF` `8a@ m 6؈#/a+?)#aa &a0p0 xa~׵P؈C1 $ ~CTd*ҷBoX0 n*BBXpLPJ*aԶ kFCaTDDFy6E|嫪DJʛ@PlC2ADAAT* "ܭ"t0 W; NӲ^^Eۃ (Pﺃ's̭nW 30X0vI/ zpw_[9KrD᷼E?/]Ѭyk3) 0C>):6)M#'a2?3ےy觲<ߥ﮿L*h4 & hм  g" 2.fN BC" OQ.C6ffa#W Tv<' aNpPT'cL&ӻ gkA < ȓ!\)|fc(s!1Hy3<ᙌ_%ld _$"8a2a2>ggNgB/S$#^7H>ނ ӻM$Ɠ&qhzL#C'MNv OAK`5 *h P 3w~O]un~оw =?OM"IID>97AB< Nl=nNoH&aA-? /tkS /7_a zMovU7%- [t5:۰CQ_" տސ{~VBt*i7c/,_kP }p__sO3zt/կ'%/N؅,1mRz߰Lj#B#}?;u=Tҿ䡈_BP+I{J_t[ ڤK_laԱ0oχ5 !K%>O<"O$?$?}k!d5 /kh/ a^~ỿտ &~)}?F4m/6 ]>u+ֻz_7~oT y6D }5{# ?Y =~__T lqLW<au1ZV/8a+o{_m*o}{_}Wo~޿lUU;V6N/ |cgꖿ_}i~WӆՅj*6Aw00W^+i{OoRVz[aNJo庠.S4M8oiKq (oҿy/7]ݩ~ ձN[Gf/bI1 )1a04 ஙpU  l @L mC Bd#M4d}uOaøiC 5wQ6#_8jilU|lFtqB:a0LXa0A?}W=5ᯭO Hu`"@A ALVŧaa$ڊi5z4o"""""""ш9XL a? …N?MAB& M Ȑ! `bo6ALj mzWDDD!lL& .w "j0AR,0 }MmI Vꖸ"""""""#BFB"ZZGJBKp6I $[]@bBBL*Kٹ0P ´<<- PPp 2;+ȣ&(IoPaA5 Gayh4- O=A.XTක6<H` "2;|ڧpHzAsz`} G80D29Qģ0y8 xJmob+;I|}h}R{Yju}}W)I¤C B )8fA2ajY"$]uz$v&pPz,  a , "ȘEW"pq9' e\q՟ȶuGUKz 2'T8:M]xM75 aAO    @ NH t.lo( #G!D? d"̇~A<,WPE -.h>-^eptNDpÃ/(hCªmi ASB, Ƙ&asP4 j`z ti6 'h NyywŖ32t/Z'mUwSM (P'L*zޗQ_UoznVJpd\ԋm ٬Sd`@Ĝ}Ƌ2tL ',94͢ 5ivJ 鮟zz_]/R}ޮ:]=;NհdoKIҹ>;!ګk _N׾ T n l=_Rt"?[J}t6ߺm$!h[~p_0T*> |5? _ ul"OA==eǰ _W/~#;OdW/ݴ_D}BD#ot6jG5___{]/_0F>쑆|mH/mҾ[HC}?Iti}im_ޗZZ"?{z_맿_zzk^_>?M"BqðZV[ f;IoK_mWKouIO %vVpҊnzZ{m}=|^4]|}%a/<KH%bdH@ eL`80@ئB>4))UL4iDwVױKc{JӦuaH^mo hpڅ7TA Tt7 &t %kvҵXi-k-̱0_g-œ0 / 0MA(dWmBj    m 1@jW1IEC U4o KJ"""""""""""" p0A 0t& %Kai¶L1@ t6)!4@if&DDDDDDDDDDDD1tHʚg:0L Ip mBT"""""""""""8",z1S"A}z]Xɰ蕸T̫ npB@]T+ 2*d%#S Q_H^ (\(LlDTG|361:0PPU  ad!쪢\#;S>t;,H2Fk]T;akBFJfXPq%̃̊M=_հPH&^ t_8`m"xK$H$wJBl馒IK?8?lނw0nQ~M[{m/M ]'O_[Wצv_ҵ^C#tD< H+[{wA0PL `A 0  %R'"`f(ŝ|23U$ޓt4`Ok xP0 DK@@/ঌ" JL$ "z ZrÐhIv׃ ־8׍D "<8j0 &0L!*a a aB <&leDDd1Iٱ*K4uN/䀆Lj"fڝlMӃ"[AwA9|EDvÃcDn;dQ'}=4 *h<3A*a8P񴿆A4I Pa0p@֓l'KI)8:O 6 ╱z/// ɜL!huM zaSLFbNDV#MSMRz~zZ޺֕$ںMf~8zM>xA tm }cMk~ؤ0/i/(*S {ozKҺnK}[<3GH7"Id\}v/oI7!ޓ=&j1_~ޛ._봟n龛Kޗ گl5zMVۯb+HGq}qOUo /_}7}ïҧLFX_˭uMpջI}ፏMa]Xcyec=q 꾽?pեw7ڰ\27ZM}Rf{H솿iAoE½ _?~HKtl"Ql>߾S($H$`}izIVoWm??u?Z_CWa{kZ푒O_I{to7>iCi]Im\%}Vi7}zUOMspպ aE;0iu_i%zK'WM[cXabZJ@hSDž¯Qߘ߿߯ ϛjzD~i{0AL @%L NaIؐ#c}zZ[KzPWV6^T)KaokڥM&A a 4A4!! Bꢶ*Ҵ;]4aZa(a&J#^kkuqWg¢DaBaA8aaa5a\a4}KM40jaEE4q@LP@00Ah Jv 1 ) p[[ 0@i )&RcL%h4H0?bia4ȐX)@bj؈"""""""8`('2 é780@AP HpP +86DDDDEDZf([;I_I+}I&ӈAj  ͗qWp:Mwㅰ+rMWq_7+q,YE<& ȸ5SaIY%v%6ʢ*YڧH6M@ӻ Mw0B@!8P9  !Sv{⮓@Les|oia=aB`U~aj;Јl&mt{DA0[!$E`cD7ik+;mvAq(ovL 館l<$Eι,A*{|&{<ͶIIZwn^5M{n-zOi$SIfdьRvҦA<-_}wWmmtIWtt ᚆug㡝L]-?[oCt3vﶺDŽA*`, JY@d6!uk3z(H$%*Ik[M0T03Ha31 &| `@A (&D(B(e$THUovuT }-ɜhh8X=ܳ:аza0:&!"çoC,!2Ub螳G%*Ѱi7Z'<դ} CE AޫTGq]~]]x=uW .Il&-umaW} H{ɟ"[}GC_.Zk֓o/7Kt$u"^$ZO׺J7 _kڶc%_[I3 7uM0גM֓_"9}RV uuuVפ~#UT T0RTSi^C]?]56;~鵰C^_TI;Hw^M+NmijuLWzvkWJ~mzߛD״L-~"""""""""4C`>dQ*0AI,FDDDFKK]jI%_JA(A-  i*[I! # ?-3[4ʃ"6wTiD5©Ad7=JQ>#!;v"2]մǧ⿭wI0< |8gو R]uW_׺\TT* 6 Ђ DX@u\9O(3 d*Tu# H2(g=,aYZ u]_[b:aU` P 0ML0P `![fh )2<r= k&_gDSZgVaJH*q_Zy"v .AMh&Bj`B``D!‚a `a B (AA¦(!`LD A c62@1BvlR!!p8aKdnNȶ 2%I ۠A0d'O2ED'p:'mUh 4t…A5O5PAS d`(N׷ H828Ni:M2%AvPncIED !h$MUAtr.;`:D0 SDhQ; e9!֜ӽ^㾗+Nb%27I882.iI& <[( z= Z ݭJgi;MV41fm~Wz~_׽N^ &'IE?;=i>v<ձ&W]-%==7W>ֿZ ߅?n#5=:MW}~_??PQ ^+k-Zi9capZ3xc+7"C{/Azmd. 7OKX5_K]+7qB$? -?7,7a%A}muG$F~ȏ@ HPo!CY z )K __l?h//O7)6gp䊒Fkp/vݧnWo/޿p_L`~o_E_}#G_ֽV_Fz/XR}c_/[mZ_VUڪm_am.J{J\+ %a2?j^P//o\5Rm?հZVi[n 0AC iZ /MJ68뵊bC]*A~aSCk۫­=(aKͦ\mx"i?0ͯ!iVAC  |SN@ij $4qmzxIثv mZabu^_Rod 50¦"TSM 6(t܅70;j:`V_«JҸ;V8av 4nb"#3țiaMAM5;TM{LՆI jbTS@Q@0d < kd#Ai0AQwqDDDDDDDDJt""" H0Hai4Ijjqh5&8P MM6 8M&MmRh0ȃ A mPA}DDDDEHlDD Na"n MK͈0i &zԱt 'a0Ia0M>58"""8!I/a_XIR_KJ t1^z\(`A0 ]D a&1qecnK; v&)e/A PTI;i،)UETCFȭ32ę4;-7H? ࠡ0BPHɰgT((P[OM[{;EKM봋M1;NfVLh`bʒ___k_<3YNSW__ @τ.ظ@ CP|#Q#5?Yty_$ |& 0 0  aMpR@: H Adfy3QD&HFh&jH-<'l4ah0}ii54? &0Aȳ fDdJM" ņE %l!Ȃ! GLF2>ʹ󷒴0ue9'Ұ5IF#>ٳb봡tƋE;> tpdKo"ImC6xAAAh2sU~zZB밟xW-䱤8$][i֝+WI8<{zm/t_ii ~Qu𿮛T?%ptow۫]-?ս; B~z_^7}jK`{ɎVJ">}}muq ?T<0om!.߶_2+W굨Uc;״a Rx.&2|5Ó7I?Jo_߾H5wn'�oq O( !ݶ_}wzw7kn;K0y?uyA~9#nO/[[]0kWZ?GVHE?y#iUp·kiZ_]lvU~ڿnثY)lƶm'a&յm/m&K޿_^kk_Za'HTpҾ\'|5Կ]c0v__mkpAb6bukM658kئ}i6;b_‘`ۆom7 $I{P Im}8& @  ⚐i4j*aL>K6"v)~Ұhi}vbb-}bJX.ʚZ0v - ] 54ai΁l b m4ؠZk &*鋆{L[QMS & I""""8F 0BQ`0 ) ðj_wM A": 7p@ qRt hM1@6QT>1A"""80P: AkaPa>azAkU 2# .DpM4PZ MIaA:_ "%"CDN)7 0 ()D J""""""#t j+ WkH%\ ?-嶓~Mgcƌ]iT(PaNg3\!W%[)FiaB3+2Gh:~. C `&4JMek/]As(PpR;UaB Q;@i5v$?NW)x{2s`CfhfF U|6_>uFul# +BU_]RACDK" t4a3c: r0d' ^HfQ/M 4Sa5h `'3!3}$3cH'͙0!

T C<$f9n0F 3Vp y Fp— vPd pdK +I&&r&qaǢpUU+$L%#M)S0M0!a0=0&C@B & hX `3΢2l'_&I~GOn%1,q3_tO1Ϡʹ֔Z'uTxDA4n§'`h L< ASH'7A\dҺMդ_ խ[ҵo NO"0ېGbaI7qaHNA㋄aiDiz'T4N/0a"vAKI-?M½A& J_'I܋upz} 6R;C $hCC_u]{NvuIvO7 XJNiό>IG&W~?z]_o__U=_ktºoߧIa1x'&zIzڧmw{]Z?__ q .iqzk۫'k_ b ^}l?aD __V}#k/a/oo zpDcx_[Oׯ_"KحP {AרaDw"qmQ8}Ku־Hۿo/߫l%n ~_ҿцF_b+m/ A[tK/u⪾nvkz 7>^_m/o߿ђ}_W68ab;#֟wYᄛI{{U]/_ .ű0mT0zimj_uomտ_{ @j@i( iLVl$WJa_KuavޥO,)~/XI.wVM~0^ȮY–iȃa۴A )AA 8a8N+^*avF bjB"ZDD!@a0L& 4Z &ai= Na@6D 0@0p0c0m8:TӴ(=iJ׆vb)n.""""""" a2jsf0Јc;Pa~צah66 alBjDt `B:A(b q@#A 6dG[!1LTL;k"""""""""""""""IK?&W&] 7NK[^ 0 27/ /+ML&DSTA("""""""J|Dd`P0L AUQDDE!׎J-+I.!PD@\ѭW UZj uXD Zf-3d)B࠙.̀DAl(- 2WJ^*ࠡW W ?T(. 88!=]Ap_9 ̊Lur .$OW6GQ ћ \G Be&3gDFftZ 0S*`0P> """ղх>0%eٳ"8Nڣ#ٚ)_ƭ=3C#<5A|hx|9hj' vz$; i?j  C a0 `2Pn31$yIAMA 'AxDi Q;YC8t$UNSL!50?T7N sbϝi>r.a6 Cdt&vcC'2 /h44]N$;>eM'}7W׷_ozo^Gjim]3ۤH6}A?_y?ݧ_nOWBM=u]>l*pd|(IZAzN=~xMkﴫVWnaҺ- }+C/_iޟN/X?~;ׯ^{vum?=װDvcyb?-:UPKu__]釅-e.La/~{}Hb!_ /[__7v[~_oVV+ V u}a]m*_ fحBU Z\p`[Yv%0_cj^KoM 'i& ZJخ?V;@[zz‘~ %Z0~ {>v(4 `hm;68 M6[.>;Kb*ᄵoX0AL>?kdW,jt `h6 m5 `d Aa:KLCM""*tb"""2pL3 a39CՅ0 \5MRmB6D qQAi i""""4""""  WW0L4 U 4Ȏ 608MWDDDDDDDDq'0 a9׭$q^K{ W ]+$Up`uUaUD0/-/Q&ek _fd`٩P2gz {+咀5 ;v 2o\Loo%I'yO9p__ڷ_ۮ:n_~v׶ݙfwf}z;mm&º_Z__~}ٟ[~+uKߴOmbK^1^v~זL 6[uM~{⮻[ _޾+պmW_=K~r+a a a qASb7ڵۨb)?QƛizK?].bN CM )MtmESM&h m&4lilRiqL0Sq\DDDDDDE`La2thf,CAR\50si 6L h Adgh4 : U0" ! &{0l$ """"""""""""q As )iXa;#pS -kvM""""""#"""""->"10pSgfcUl 4GbrPu ;4; zaBdU`.k(T+ >DsAhh }&tYlI~JFKZp$O&);ӫ?tDSUUM!fxerHq0P\AD\"{ py!LCѱ4Sc:H"碝hKM*KUL*jta੄@ K a0'f  \"sBɑ{,tSa:Yseѡ<<2/3q3fC&db4F/H78LD"vÇUDôNASAMiM`S vh`afdA&~aaB `(A9ȝ0PB C` 2% L6|aqs1Nwe'xA&<|(}vZ/: xQ8a$1ڪ$<Z & ~ M3.&L*iPiL VR-[O WߋONz@ȸշI& '{h h n8Am4/A4CM,:4*aSD#a i'dFǟ2$;B_[v^N}MfN O σ>|Sa M:N "[L;h }(i: ڜrz( w]ӯ_W𴮃i]܎Ҵ? <&} [տdpM% Z_My-{jkzKhtmZ._Ю: ]=T_z}t^wL_~^#a-_?u_X_.Z|cOT~  }W`ZxDv`b#? [_a@nJK&a°I|Al=/mm$#+"?/$[`!7zXo7o_OkiwEz O~CߥY#/bK 'o;V&'Y)otג:m+Km-mwmv봚?K?צ׿I밤yWmk] /mK/ۯ?l+iX@Պa^Ү0P`cհ /~Z믬5m?UK  ` Iv `Ni4U{i;J61~;[ aKGG_euyُs00[N!'"B01LST0A46B4h6+ظmFի\4#>@ qvPkj] Obb@3?)7 & j mI0M 0 mE4l{!QIN0i5x0gV^8aXX"""" `0@ԷSpi"ga׆&H7iA m : 0bi3d# ah |DDDDDDDDDE"ud fH& N7L&\gva{U )1“ aB*izN#C1p`D,D0eOP"""""#j/BBᄾ8w_ICl @ F~Lو Sª7Gd v"QJDL̍ؑ„2H OW@|iL3R]e=(6hh- d:*;HhQg'ktAA}Ӆ UA)4dr)d`R R\e'IS%)tIRv]u/Ah{~WO$ꙸΙ蝔짟azA a! x[3lu<;W)i.wL0kN.!^` g'53c>0 BсN ig@Q$#LDw;hij  ;M?$ `0\UAS0AXL:hFY gQ#ld_?C:癬8gF%KMb|'B@66;a/).8&aBkoA5.*a0O A 4"а@!f ! ! l!p6l`HeC03"#[ :ii^Ac& ŖgiyImx'j 'DF6O& *M:„DZn/VZZ"7 fi6^|֐oH:A,M;Š haH'0[B)aD@H4&m_8'a FذdN$U\Z]~It&vtҧ]_t1>3Ɠ`ȷISX"M"ߧ >.Io׮nat]ii70'],Ut>lߓu_T=..ou*^굺ot^zl7#?[K__׻ t/֘]{K?u[W /"c0=B^ ߭{:p6sD_Kז^ ./_o X/_z֋_!CX7_4KmB%+O']6_A~So/m.o~\u o%G<%_h/]ivk0Nb^/I#oz_֗[C/ui7__oTmoFUqV}:եV?K+ %޿j_~V]}_It=Wjma+I_ڱbTDPasec0_7V҆﴿K[_mt`2 :AӆᅻV7鍴KTa^Պ.ͯm.R}Kkl%⢃A00& !`iڞccUNiǧ El&׶6  i{ 9{պ>簧 rAj0M6`a l `[4m] %L4biZmkiq4B%"Ul aOg_ u¦DpMA mG@!E1T0id 6@i lT0zu{ [HDDBBg!Pʵ=0Xj}B  waF#8AҦaMU &L&  A@@EP qDDDDE#8aj  0@ L&gɺ )naW¹d0.WDDDDDDDDDDDqQƗIRסgUZ $; /K $*• NHvVi4* a  +j"?ykڧ娗?Q)R v )۲hR$ j d#4eC;Xi2Xd"'2;|(PBPrV?ABAv;d ޯk_8vUeEnT__"4GFj#r>E*g\Dzܴ*#`@„E A.lgA# R("m"&&UP6(L!^3M3` `( PpNzxDRf5gԝEqA8V_HqrTNҨ8邧`am0U0 „0@0)Lb" ņEH(!pDCͲr)3h= (ySW3QfIFk.RwAi'bkh'xcEA6Nf"xDp(&CL&ŔS0UL ϊCB aA 0A!q`&ixA(A >SC$"2-uVZ:tF'^lh&&rqƉD᪄NښUM7wL& MPN޿uCMB7I69˺m'X Vm H?Z/h,E4L$]p/hqx<a'E"v98`Ѫ&~M] 7#<:MOX>`ߑ'E$۷'2.4I;n2%Ai[=6ůS }պn.n鴛hjI[x m=6o:>ޯ=7Q PW:C /z]n߅ﮓ_ZOl/<_~;]ien_o뫷_,gbYcOtcGo~~֯_}+.D~E/_w֭_^?A{aި/a_ği烰c}c\K/7?Z]zdB7WZڽ_s=-mV}{!H"ko__??#_i/r{UJ~K[MC~vK _A_]kvZ %imm_^u7Q_x~_ ;C+k J]{I{I_׽߯۽mo굶E\0^[izQV^sii}ki{qk]JۧoZiq 7LVa.@m+m-m~ײiwta0Mծ0u~U7f?au7jȎ L8M  h mES6݊Xa+il0ڧ[N@h@J]ث[Kb" PMO~AdM0 ,A SAL*j(0@ؠ@btlPM8iiLL;V8i4L[ '1L4կ l KL0 Lu᭠]$M:Ak؄ @ S@TU q@b ڪ"" WaA20t L7GUi ^A\an(dWib""""""""CDDDA !y (UlA0+aU/n } --V XZVAˆLeiD'8M3(fFT;:DW.dS HeXO vhLgf GtGp6Uy%@i&JHg a20P "$fF#!&R,Ű/ ޽X0\BTAB Hc5OUtY 0zMPaRvy/`2=h'\"QDv;n"'TK[hJ0krhfD'AAI.kZ_MZTutꥒue Lfz_鮖 & аP55*"BC5%_ۢCL SPg z 4 8)0FbA(E&l'2>#9fA ӇB:"_i__ hhPd;qzD?3~lU< „pa31z  yঁHϑ! zfD{8gAs&GjC&`k2O=c:dEK{t&M=/O42eߢ|EM$8` U0P?SP@ 0#p3@Ă\ @ lPA ф  BL[Ufd]zpa&M&AP [K'4E$TNPhGD'TOWA&*ilTiU[ lWXS36:R?^2;I^pdH~|m<*pbkۿIؙxayxËD> hzaQxM DƋ.[((NJ4?»KT<N & y ->?#ơyM@M؟2 l'H6Nl6hB#xұ _"Oa,WX0c_U'a"C%1HUX1~X҇_!$/o- ?~'7KI/_ _נ6oKZ0XoU-o_snk?i}؅o솫! 0ҿ0Ay+i: CXat~yT;\Ik5~{Z}oyS]X_Kp'1Iiֿ_~~ޛطj$[ $;#Jan.`gQ<.}_y-RlON Ae&MSlh'ͦ/T4v33 MSI D:"OiᶖTwa*n^6{ pdnItn}'@''EٺyA8 00 M pdnm&m^K>3 4F lCՠ麦GZ/zk^m7B>W[k=aOYI__v+Ock{=SKo׽oMzީ,WX'j0Я-]$#K^Xl?Zou 9b*ྖ ^ֿ}ubc[סw aɌ'L4_]|6⿽ 0oaC_0=T l7୥ܛ /mҿKw om'[|vHy#o}/I{_aTK4Nڇkk)a& oK6B /.MA/_{_L?ia=c_ߒ7!TKbziSׯVM_jcc%_߷K$\cm'[ݾ_$-j#Va_a_Nj~ҷ_WTq08ئuKhխOl&G[`-u׽޶L5?HylY9tm6yJ{ajt;C^jڶ uVmi?j˘MKװ/zu]}~VWtzu`__v1E_K֯_ץ_!_I?߫WV}I_އ,r|7U}/  /~X`IA}/8A }k__~K V8uT} _?׿___Z^=/j_xv"oد]_0%m}]La#د%}_׿i__VhZVv]+K1Qf;ik_okz9[QwZ)K[K[K_=ijPN6B Nb[ڵJҽm5bnޘ1m/^^f Y 8H8L&TS m4A6B:iPMՃJT l4mdkiAգI; 0) 280E{ RpڊbSc h#TI;b '҉8㈈),j|L&l)njL 'a8M5`jbK!Ap@L'US!`HMh&2La/S XL% $a֡;T_HDD&L@ 9kR49X L&~_]'P`DDDDDDDK_J@ C |h6)6QgL(Վ?T(-A%(;XQXA>u~[a^FylTMn^i-/붣ұP0,%~? "? endstream endobj 75 0 obj << /Length 4261 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im76 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F77 11.97 Tf 74.40 708.48 TD (knowingly or intentionally misleading a standards-setting organization) Tj /F77 12.03 Tf 338.64 -.72 TD (" presents a ") Tj /F77 11.78 Tf 63.84 0.00 TD (routine) Tj /F78 8.03 Tf -402.24 -27.84 TD (antitrst case) Tj /F77 11.74 Tf 36.48 -28.80 TD (Second) Tj /F79 10.43 Tf 35.04 0.00 TD (, Rambus) Tj /F77 11.89 Tf 49.44 0.00 TD (s implication that) Tj /F77 12.01 Tf 83.04 -.24 TD (, at the time of its conduct) Tj /F77 11.88 Tf 125.52 -.24 TD (, it could not have) Tj /F77 11.97 Tf -329.52 -27.84 TD (anticipated that it risked forfeiting the enforcement of its patents) Tj /F77 11.81 Tf 308.88 -.48 TD (, is contradicted by the record.) Tj /F77 11.97 Tf -309.36 -27.84 TD (From the outset) Tj /F77 11.96 Tf 75.60 -.24 TD (, Rambus consulted with its lawyers about the possible consequences of its) Tj /F79 11.50 Tf -75.60 -28.08 TD (conduct. CX1941 \(") Tj /F77 12.23 Tf 99.60 -.48 TD (JEDEC - said need ) Tj /F77 14.18 Tf 95.76 0.00 TD (preplanng ) Tj /F77 12.22 Tf 60.24 -.24 TD (before accuse others of infrngement") Tj /F77 12.16 Tf -256.08 -27.60 TD (Repeatedly durng the next four years) Tj /F79 10.38 Tf 180.72 -.48 TD (, Rambus) Tj /F77 11.93 Tf 48.96 -.24 TD (s lawyers told Rambus representatives point-) Tj /F78 9.97 Tf -229.92 -27.84 TD (blan - Rambus) Tj /F77 12.08 Tf 82.32 0.00 TD (s conduct could result in the non-enforceability of its patents. CX1942) Tj /F78 8.04 Tf -81.84 -28.08 TD (\(Vincent: ") Tj /F77 11.97 Tf 53.28 -.24 TD (I said there could be equitable estoppel problem) Tj /F77 12.06 Tf 234.96 -.72 TD (\); CX1958 at 12 \(") Tj /F77 11.87 Tf 90.48 0.24 TD (Two possible) Tj /F77 12.42 Tf -379.20 -27.60 TD (theories for non-enforcement: 1\) Estoppel? 2\) Antitrst?") Tj /F77 11.96 Tf 279.12 -.96 TD (\); CX3126 at 552-) Tj /F77 11.71 Tf 88.08 0.24 TD (54; CX0837 at 1) Tj /F77 12.02 Tf -366.96 -28.08 TD (\(Crisp: ") Tj /F77 11.83 Tf 41.76 0.24 TD (Tony) Tj /F77 12.16 Tf 28.80 -.24 TD (s worst case scenaro regarding estoppel") Tj /F78 7.95 Tf 197.28 -.48 TD (\). Despite that advice) Tj /F77 11.85 Tf 105.60 0.00 TD (, and with full) Tj /F77 12.21 Tf -373.92 -27.84 TD (knowledge ofthe consequences) Tj /F77 12.01 Tf 152.64 -.24 TD (, Rambus intentionally embarked on the deceptive course of) Tj -152.64 -28.08 TD (conduct leading to the Commission) Tj /F77 12.05 Tf 174.48 -.48 TD (s liability finding. Rambus can hardly complain today about) Tj /F77 11.92 Tf -174.96 -28.08 TD (being held to precisely the remedy that its lawyers predicted.) Tj /F77 12.67 Tf 72.00 -28.80 TD (The Commission Should Resist the Temptation To Impose Punitive Relief) Tj /F77 11.97 Tf -35.76 -28.08 TD (Complaint Counsel acknowledge the persuasive ) Tj /F79 12.58 Tf 233.04 -.48 TD (arguents in ) Tj /F77 11.97 Tf 65.76 0.00 TD (support of a stricter) Tj /F77 5.00 Tf -335.52 -27.60 TD (remedy. ) Tj 44.64 -.24 TD (See ) Tj /F79 11.88 Tf 19.44 0.00 TD (Brief of Amici Curae) Tj /F77 11.91 Tf 106.08 -.48 TD (, Gesmer Updegrove LLP and Andrew Updegrove at 2-) Tj /F77 11.94 Tf -169.68 -28.08 TD (SSO members may recognize that) Tj /F77 12.05 Tf 162.96 -.24 TD (, ifby deceiving an SSO they can collect monopoly rents for) Tj /F77 11.72 Tf -163.68 -27.84 TD (years) Tj /F77 11.93 Tf 25.44 -.24 TD (, and thereafter be restored to prior conditions) Tj /F77 11.99 Tf 219.36 -.48 TD (, there would be no down-side to the) Tj /F77 5.00 Tf -244.80 -27.84 TD (deception. ) Tj 55.20 -.24 TD (Id. ) Tj /F79 11.14 Tf 16.56 0.00 TD (at 5. Failure to punish Rambus might ") Tj /F77 12.16 Tf 189.60 -.48 TD (shake the faith of the members ofSSOs in) Tj /F77 13.15 Tf -261.60 -27.84 TD (the voluntar ) Tj /F77 11.92 Tf 66.48 -.24 TD (consensus standards development process.) Tj /F77 5.00 Tf 214.32 -.48 TD (Id. ) Tj /F77 12.23 Tf 17.04 0.00 TD (at 12. Many SSOs may ) Tj /F78 5.00 Tf -297.84 -27.84 TD (disappointed that the proposed relief does not go far enough. ) Tj /F77 5.00 Tf 296.16 -.72 TD (Id. ) Tj /F78 7.13 Tf 17.28 0.00 TD (at 14.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000449487 00000 n 0000449546 00000 n 73 7 0000449689 00000 n 0000449853 00000 n 0000493685 00000 n 0000450381 00000 n 0000450000 00000 n 0000450129 00000 n 0000450254 00000 n trailer << /Size 80 /Prev 449160 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 498012 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000547291>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R ] /Count 12 >> endobj 80 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 81 0 R /Contents 82 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 81 0 obj << /XObject << /Im83 83 0 R>> /Font << /F84 84 0 R /F85 85 0 R /F86 86 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 84 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F84 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 85 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F85 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 86 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F86 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 83 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im83 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 43007 >> stream VPiS,|feQr }ڏTN)׏@s%QH-Z~Zr eN@1OGbL&wHʑesVTdgiiӖBa-SL(S=L/ hP\j ((  *VU+Z6v6nEC%}X4h% >*%qb E+q(MuRZk'UW[W׭u]}zAѝ$(FzCI2 \5L(몑RѨ(3FugC5@Ba (&0%VlؠT%ٱ"aY `!gQMf"&D: P36FfH:e/|: 0!!6AAA? qB(F a0D`L&  !6b75a A]͊D&x &`40 aBA4(AAja (A(D~ `L-$^8§xSHeY8pQ8a/HNx]^eUvFtI4¦.B`=4N'pٙwOEOzpwiƉ2%Cg]6ӃA4A}H?@uQ|XyEDŌ 敠 ?& b|&~l& ޿  oi7i+lI&麽&ό Il:OMd/>a0OO׽n] _ }^mOZ ~mom}7]w־ou[zZW?oC鮿k_j?+_ӊ_ ^+wa/aH . 9[ p^u "? kv k(/]'Dq7߆/Awz_C] k_ W"7"~H͠B#Z _/lr2=8Ml-ow~{Kw[oHu]_}Ino{_^׫Ҵm'{޺~jaM *am.W6MZkvֹڂ)K_ }u iҺ1JIV_i:|Mҷ_f6—W\){_m_a׍m` ]mxb 0LL8;W{UWmo % bqm&;J8k4(؊cW/kS0@  0VaB kh: nQQMa m0f&iqV*b!1*+Rt@#00 6Dt; ` mSP-Z j]L+a4[]aUPIA0iM@a@h ai2 T¦5Lڵii\t!0@BeMMP"2`B"" 5*i0 @ “&?1* /a `Aa0 Be}5"""&pqH8V"""""""""""#Kxa-.pc6 D+VX2Qn6KeqW!lV;Da3g|!idXh3p2'gQa<*|(([ AB0~B1„0P/…(PTLx*=H=<*40uKu`8?M(ᆉ$gbhdX4wW9smuppq W%׸i_}~kWuUO{658AO6L.&NB0NdT LD'q29~Ff }tN1 -we8':-oT8׿N z[%g'#3ZBL'VKսnTK7=7-m'G}IőunWa7%Im/w5t/_W_^o_ﶫNMߥЫOnoOW__~z[H]zdpEۯ_GKBۮv{uޟvG1oJ"?^?:;k8O6-׆_|crv ֵp_Xc1_pW ]u7eO']IM8k;`z/4"OaHhÿצ׭0_6a'߯_o}~w]GzW m$~kA޿_i6~^wm/atm /ýJ!Ղ) %=ծC!znؤ_ޯ1ݟu?_Ӑ!}/GdB }_cֿ{kqڦ n?I~۾k{Vkk{uOo[{?k~-{]K}J'^]]WOHe }a[m.]2_4m450|ڴ\-;߶K*m2?ݮ;{!ئ1^}6LWkxJ*c۰CҴ b?<pմ QaAAGRMZV֚jn*vjVZJ kiqT=xi18 V^i&hTrzް0 m Mh` @Ȏ   ` `Gh8 `41OS 656B:A\Tn0aAl 4C`݅LR0 ! k>Ll-p֩ ײ+@_jdAS puH&!&k*j &(UJ0|3M}2&G@P_DDDDDDDDDDDE!DDDDDDDDDDDD~. &jYPGRp Lj`A0G\!Ј"8""""""")jzZ_UzU饬2 R{WզdH aD|J"?\Idd0Fv-L3! `O `vgj [ Fw;qOiRP[ *aKĀ3X PAZ  nCC0vdz"YD5v.̃ĜğIߨA@ +yƿ'e8NoNWKERzo~kumuN@.J ف!BB̼!l 2?# A#6ԓ!pDU3#ƖpΖN!!|aY 3P<ˢr!200FDdtG!UV.z5fH⁑@q Bl!"#$F O#2!Hfs#c00M`0@B !(A !0\ <u3@pP0P0TB`@ 0A9pP@Ñ lRCD(APa   A$ύ0PTL `w-DTN.]ih& vU &L.]0OL&`3P(\{H ¦T *D TQ!੅C q \bgIzIoi:wÛB "qGdGtbxzZi}_)Jj{[vJ[Kio}}m|0Vwzկmڶڶ_*&V֓/ݭ?nPa-_K %Mtlpm&׿—ZQUGD~tVi'L}1WtS{iZi{JNm.᭥kjՠ B:0L&Q +pNbn 5|VP~I+ZaaviAT4wvW5 Bj0*kh6A 6UA јb!M4 `@ڊ0ABb a!(`!0@B6:0A aȰj?`A !a02R& vG00ppiC 0ҭVt$NaÄUAq*:pAɎU>i"""""""#B"""""4#'C>0B,)5?S aBfDD """""""""4"""")~DDDDDDDDDDq-)iZZ\.d gfA}u:ijt XI XQ+ЈDU*l`uve3dv*"%nq4eC2Q­[ ((M44 } \ _[mW_ z+Ttۿ[۾vq q;ldC+ynWI#h> 駽/vJu^_W]ֺUoUWdyc)yGѨQ7wꪺw5dc J<` * Sbf(f΂A3dj) 0 63JIE 9=B3#Y͡M0#]h4];4M Dz$?MvwDsMSM] 4 aSA- 0MxI„TQ;hhQ;`' US ^tzI MgZ;z&xAwOh lYg/hr /^44¦L$N蝴O1|EE'bxAJA6nqф3hq'znwmW'p~80Ni?ۤ<&oyUdWI:O&u ؇ AZM"e'sO2>ȐƛnRla6 tE%Zn]]_i] ҽ&o}mҴN 'IWW:]uЫUӴ;9TW4Oz֗/7[u]tTӤoW5uZB5=ڎ+o鵷J/;}1*O@zҿװmW[Xb1_}#ǿ"L}ߏkC${Doa}ao_-O Za)5^K/ׯ i87%/!d ?F y d5^CWK$vQnH\7#ۮ*Nލm}/_TmLa;$E0y>}i_Z^w߷uO{ڴҧuv^v]V_[Vz[KME;jڷa*-v_4*o'^_ͨia,m[_aبx…I^‘xV¯MVywV -/}anWKn+ nO $]5[IKb+զ@;Ia{axIZm%b1LSh/V#@m41V҈==E[O@6Ȏh; rz 4B0V!H0Lx ⪘j= L0MW4Տ(ӎ bi qLq VMnڦm4aaB pA4j pAMM16 P@8A tM 6h6:ia(ڦi:imD "!e0D M2&xa a0Tʂf|@ ()L0AaPa3L k&8M5mxaaxdW7Z vTU&)1—a3 @ɟ̈́Mv[0FFDDDqHDDDDDDDDDDDDDDp0DH"""""""""8~z_lPtޗЦMK[M Cˈv$P6 3OP q z~*fUQSXFh͑\)6`)3B0W BƃP'oAI' DJ|Mjg{}ߥU_'WxCdN!̈́6fq5糙ǝ2A(335s8ԾH!GduZ~NH2U?p7D1䆟pqa g h0AAA/ h< —jO(sb3`h H"Ѓ2 Ba0lZ[tGmشGض0=ip j[bú'8"NHvtNZF; ZOTFNp'^6D"GG &I!aD-ױr$?ÂXIin "dY;I~pdP.\r܄O^ l}_x}]liקW,zo_JIO!=/l]-(Jz/tW%K~ WIKzJV޷{5դۍVW]{^߽z#_"?V?7_U_]__C?*z#M*_-`nK_Ȏ/"ÈIȂ^?ۭ ?_Bui7K[oi#NL}mh-~P"C?a*w"q%7~Wد}mK/~ t]~;$Z_4,רX~yȌ:__}6Ϧ/lܧz_/i_}m/}vGzmuzik[g_kͧ}U_tXtm'V_K_뮿iZK鶗wiM*mOҴ%Z~J^0Mwխᄖii~_~XVL0jͅ[ w޲ t &={ccا`*cTh3t?J=$+#L(` &9n(Ї&Aj Ѕi a: B0D馜BMյRꞻ4Hi` Cbi Ӡl&kR᯴.V 5 $-UйnA&T#B$*h!mR` tiP* a^:6"# IA˦sʢ a2UEQ( !g!0L*j<DΦu l&L,5 S8^ ϙ&q` *L&y """?YNxDDZOiv)aI+4vf0ac&3FUn(Zi&5E- =>_i}LRﯯ˄6FG؄1QcLtl #P) a "hAa0  5]Sb4طWONnGi:auDH:iZAW'yj"[Eo!7MGItK S iuj*߇^> ?ҷDA_a.ZMGi޽/K.m_=OׯE__?iMvzm_m,ߥn+[_?c &/i' $8m( a6)DpME uAPL&Ȑ Km504a܍‘G[ FjAa0B0D ,$e9 `؈M4h?Sbj?gK d3)`@"Aؠ̋GbR3y>o'g$Apv@NAF`ރ s;46[ 7a} }]B;a87\"fzXD& ><6=^4Ziߤ:?դIn鵧oi'J+W_U^=RqIqw_T }.3f!Dg$Nefy'.ȽDc젍C:8ȃ$d!yT!Fz6Iu: 7(?aO6)HS.C4 XL 0 h4A܄$N3@<)" G!09 ! 0@r/CӠB?~a;AصL1{a8uH/6-t4z| 7 a!C !L&)k44AiSuLRilPM8v*BA. 2$-Xe4B@aL8Akva0SMnIA& pIi 5mӆ0A``D2F0!0@aeN [W}ﷺOQo[_{{n?^8f$ eh?J&BY-ID)>Hd瓙Z5ă57!2CRC1vB `j?6xL! ~A &򀦁 qM (D10xbj&,1T0N/Aml4Jo' # ;+;mڢwv;ŧnHJ; z%ë&6` ;lH;M߃ ޖȴM2/א7Ow~H!"$ȑM}ۥ_!._T}^ z<~|B֫b7]-_چv^`5 a {"%Ȇ?r+oa{!o x#7$>z^"co~C?Un~ DxK路_K]_t_/}{^Izz_~m/>AՙK}|{3M_/M7ںO]zm/~{ikk^+-tm+[_+WK[kv;Պ6ׯ]-Ca(iZCVӿi0M׷ZǬ0~ m$I3!IPbupKvLmUA f!*!4Ȑ(m4mAW L%˜t°X$ { VEr:*M\ҦAA0@iB带Dw@a4 jThLD0Do$2i `BH eQ/kAL'’ &n%0""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#^?AJ?3"ȊE+4䌛\dkq/K a ).!NᕖR &&aAB6 ;.#Y؄0AࠠUՃ\/B/7̃GkI<,L4wjN A 0G$w"FSRgj/`U3l5RA0%9ݘ89.߱}'_ߥozuֿO~֗__wufdn(e;)ٯ8Iu+ɄSI(0)٭J-|U E$3"_"^ރ  `TB|!`63‚!ND rRp@ BvlaD!H93ᓅ GB:2Fp!k#*@P']0h0C,S|Cb`&*LP0(M0*kŴ0P3AjC00A =! *jUVA]4 /(N:j;T8'Dfa* D ;qoMSe"vªzaQTHza4$(LuPdH&#jƼGiCJ="aktu%` 0Vlwp^؇i5, m4 A ltP@d >!F 'H8==6Icbڦ$&B!fR0ARxb#v)᭠ dA2 VTUT&iAM .":0@ PME8 m ;4 iA L2 iMBMj" gD &0 `^2 5? At ႠaJ4&„ȮY4 ݪZ &Ta0nvPAžhBHb0A3 &` """"""""""""""""""""Q!#HDMhe["""""""""""""Z34,<N8g A&``  x"^%IEYX0EQhpj jz „ AS(A 7?;rDsG9oEd|(". 7eOAU6gj"%6 vHC%8LE J!b!h9ܐù6I'I=;i+jTIqQWx6z};z>-׷]/}I'Inul^Zto޿[:IWIFzI?u[UJ""6ZU74uү-Rf!U" 䀤6Fb8Z!GFB* E"P)':ZKR"]|du__EB:gw#5|"Da_%xb'6 KB(2a2GiAzpPz l'HaP`M&A 08KH:kkOO鿮u`4E$000 (PBO &0 Ţ4Hv!4⠩N& nBKK_0UONB`0BL"wO: r,mAsI-l:v hK.O*q`tNwt^QaT%I"tЬ^ ac׻n⿐``B4pR|Tv*{[Wȃ aV[ ZI]UVn҉IWjHm^w ׍V8!mi5v$A؄UE2# Ȏ0ALPbb)>$@A*ا A a@@ l*hmA  luYtAU$v‚pRc„kam5߰0R VAIMmR2nMABka0Lkka{TDDDDDDDDDH!'B 0A  O 2 gA&r-`a4˜׆ tL ` lDC vЈDDU_I+KRSalC 6"#ɰ"Jʪ 2%nguetq7pTF]B ¨&wTi5[ F`GD!(..(AW$hElԆV[\(*x(A{n@!$`"wEү !#<(!"#**]gdI٤لRz^ɝCh vhU={}?/_Kozk}__]Iתꫪ2D6ml鞂0te;ו=x&` Lht0 "˂=H5'22tDtc: Q3A3d|$G "dR&{1q&@ʌ) D{)MFC02/S2<2A)"P!!3@w>f ྃ iPTg4$' e8A`4`hX@E* &aADa4A8z`Aڄ, y8g8*a5k'NX2}MM/!ڦTj$=APi.44ªaSL §?h<PTxA<.M05 NꪚA:82$w h LX4_Al?x3E: c_>4ND2t'0 DfhV;`8dN1hh</(u& zWËVOV|+[tls+EO:Nf32(882.RlzM"(&s] dt.pdK Aooi >C=/W]^ޞ[5t>7Ot p+mIko^ثVsIӮuֽWUt _|]?Z5uZטk__M_wJ^_ծ3Nሯ~G_toN\t-c&#WaB_7+/^,G ,O&3ς&,G{ˮ 9`=a__{*p_aD~~AD{p~?-{߶_A[7/7OϠHFߒ?G_>HJ_ vH#5w=?Z%/>~H3A$]gksu\9[J_/?nL>۪x{__VumjkV{kK-'K ~c [[0W_ik_~[O }~Jҿ—~^c;Ol%`=KuR[VuijaYKjꒆl.oaߘRUa*qvll4K'QV]Ǧq}`Ctl&WzLqQul|GI@L qM @)ؤA`Ik6(&AH:AI&ҧuj,N;j -cb)[MTp`iH6a`ЅaUզdG A4)8L A`m 4am@ m tȎiM1F`j8 : *)鐎M"TcPA-,g?fN@ )nInaS&aPa{ k5Va{ kZ Aia0 L((M>aS |{ Du BtQDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD0B"`B &0AeQh0' N0lB"""6""""""4 0\DDDDDDqt/޾K턠iTo 8LYGi:M ]2;$ڔvtR6eFdR BpBvWGfase8PBਃ}*0Af ^$1S뮬5E nƩ:aCqs7 L ׃#}zĞ%9ߛR\%6&6@7ݿk] 6о;$R۷i__Vy3Yffk"Datj#hy:?=D}NWԲaW}kG9a\A SZ`!8B!@@O03Aq)!ԂPȑ#Ԇ2Y΄_k*CAO0ا8R|v >)A yn"i*i5iv L& A4jXAL.aύxAC%A\U=P`%ƨӋECE4M" h/H0h5uD򒧦BՔ:ZL'Pz bS^^ 6ATDX8:'DeB@82%"H6 $M }>q4 Ǽ ˡyLZ/Ɠ//:$_0U;8a0+[n t`ȶpz#>`ȮI\MA&GҰ_ &IҼ% +j ۴itAKV:ޭ'WVl'~;ToZK!}}77BU~zN_(%Km]z{W}NQmooዪO⮕V+v5#r?A}bCa1&#X?c|/`}aá=& p_p$p?_l"Oo}޿o^a A{koo}ۯ~ l0E5o-/~Wa[Vt|>~H/7~ ^CAK5#pH<_olSWz_߶3zelSz_Fivi߿0~nׯ}-kڶMkU%m~!ݥ_޿ՆR -//aZ~k4/ݴUw=moi;8{~a_ҊJ‘}{Pm-;/_ث u ^޾U{v_S_iaiD> iIaaA FW -ջ [ui'`էqAJP@0@4pp5@6B:*BC`=`2@' Nzi4MJըa%hBVIiuC ! ab"B?k pa4+" vTJpILBPP &j @C@bQNL 6Nkj4 (`*Z `! JAp`Aa3aA3M Wp ("2mNa?(TUVOdO'װL&R0a0D3#EDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE")a8uI-P`*T6G\'5*㲧vCDV(S?نwHg`q>ddBI2!ӂ&.Fppi%!* )4T* <!Qo.n#}v̍|Sب 8;HD!2 NffSb;8 ubA|O=RowﮫU]/^]oIzEn[ Pblg);6AM|3K#g\ ȽIwEMN b|"XEA\Ƃ (Omr4_A~-o EbPAwZȷ\Rm'DO}iZO_/IMwtOtز7I6$C"Gm')G4Ұpd\i;ili827]{u#ui&ӥdq7pi__ M~+WIm&m_ס΀={x}ݽ=v{ӥVVҿ^?[_s_{ccUU'6*?u# /#i{Wb_+OzccЯ_ }{~>]_X/n8>2/aa~_nl= { _[a6?}_~(__~o 6z o]/b!7a{t_}CI]gS/$wWlG??wir/Ñ{3_?o_[Niw]V/{I\[Vm]]__Kｧk޾‘Az0]y)~y0WiZKm[z_4MҦM $Ob6 86Vw}Mh6i5ҴowVvt_ma#m [w! oA0UI $-PJȃ^Dþ6aح}AëKj6"vwOa+M U=6BjL tAHM4aih0A` 8@ؠP `@ݠ@b  $Gƅiq%cp@ 0E 2#A &tCSa4¦00a}.R0dA¶M0H(Tj aANI : akMa0`DDDDDDDJ1a0BIBa2L):›2< ˜ &L/a0AHu& a C@DDDDDD*TDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDqh jU]*0X$ւa+ #% cXk M3PBhQc"JԷT ;l9aL#fDi7 a …涞d*0kl3VWO[PiU "xҭE;j;M5 !Wm/779BIttAA_zZN:O_Z^΃! 0("b8ˣ%$yDAC%AM}5pt? (A `DZ <ԍ0AfDB cȺX I%(רCH2W 3P΄_$C3D_* utD'*D\0T/0a@,!~xв6hjƬi޴Ia4A$!i]!ڄzJ퐯l?Iqh^O@ұPoT1ނ I-^ph;z'm'~pao}Ԙ dqH;z#z :AWjނzz|W @T+w[tTC @~OOOnj}o~]Z:_2t]=ݿY8?ޅRtIV/'pp^Li:V(w Ro`z?X4LXlpa(O''Kwop:C 'U "w ߆aAuoKTuZ%_{i*__~HTKzy y `?{ZU_*ú~|9_^D_m/I"D4toMG)I/WIknvO1mw}Myzeכ,mMIRPFZU wvm+ vVЍ8io[jՅM[VzqWp4 $q [a+Aո+J }[v).)-mWSKIC##cX[ꁈ6B:bh fjnbB:AM7MVKxiVa(anaBEM/M4QR4 *!2#j**"2˗esB80L!a) &T%fa4 'h0TxAh0O 0TXaB!E! !DFDDADDDDDDDDUR-%TxH{;iIA)\zIhhi%MSUI%h zQM6T!93`YKcɰW;2Eq\*fEQ٩,B &;V L&W a3%7邂XL,=VX@ꋆK=AT4/2C;=s+Ts;9hi4LWwkQ)}߿wuz%_t3($uE:|-A  x g8)zCP fb͛D'f" (2" s"#0 *:FNH2`QPȾz$gDy) S6GLNѦQF_%cu3ACS8s C'#u"6A#&pPSyBh06(ABgL 00fcA `'CȞ 0cB!!~0 Y(@`T b a0<0D`E'mUHhSHt5T' SS 'TI] aPx(LA3b&v 4¨MYC(Drpꨝ;jiM7ҥ@ Nı-; /7/ܼE$E.Ŧ 2}DhN,/: /'Ap \i ]ix} B`vr-t[>3ޓNpdH^== ㉢n ObkAM"I'ޞId\z]biwۡNOY.b}%07t;ZMN5?1W_+zx^ ^گ~m5{QۡkuUW_ wлxDB a Eqء\7ڦ?K鰿l/'0&/Xru_!v,?W0_ץ`av{9b/LgG}D}0?"O ]a/@?h*/mK 4ۻN;xD{ho7 }pݠxm/K/ K_- EaCIX6__6W!7_Aת^{qy y;/}/iZ0۷Wncޗi;o�uo_m-/UտP[k[oL}K_ͯ k}׷+/ͯk ?N Zv aHSjPE?[K1'"%c]XOl)~+콩 iD (iDUbqv8iD}ZQ *l vGQPծ_} (WPҏ! q_L0dG@ lS\RQuaA= A&iXi10UcVKpTqK4+M ڊh0hdG 66B`7 U}k0L;6 h0jL @dGQQUa*4+& ! lBj6 jSi:N4Nl 6 !PY0a2NC3 &~֊ Ÿ0Be@&%K0MBRPջ }8a`e@M3E: >PL؉aA0LOaq"8!hDDDJD6"""""""""""""""""#\GI饦 % b[ MfAM1 UcJ? 2?ɾgkFvLIqT3єd2Ȅ> ̽AJWPd!jT…   BUࠠT\BL|.,id;uɱYA̍=$N D{m12#_M)J!TuIҤUUU]H)52B?#JMuWX B 0L0D)]*K BLB6`gA ك4" B* SP \"DE:0$#H @!@d4iGS:8gB#;4l)I lSAL8.Hy!}*a3xAခ x* &*a 3@t,S( a &`SNhauM# t`8лԋzmbhސAM'Nir +&ީyoӫn-'+Jy+I:m}-'2,R'=RtiRI}]ON?t}zWIպnzt]I_Kk>/_~#SI7__]گߥ]GeW!׬W_Gڮz?_xc /Ɏa-}K._*[N/-x/׶N_Џ"чD_h;wA??G}0oo.!  ~tK!#ܑ^HGtz_!=]vY}/p]}wi_eH_s vkkWHunWkii}kڽ}mtiw{i7_vmfl4Vm.YW[]t];} ipMULY\&G6¶Kaf0J~mu % &o_ul{ZaK0vǭL4i]# ?j*CݍD-K~kQ?+LqA (1@0@頃 0h 馁S! AMtM0W}kM4JՎ6*)4Ӄb@ UXTԓO VMZa46a@iȰ @bp|`#! @06 A ah ꩦl 6DnA a>8 / &͈ a k@pa@h0MU0ErՅ kOKIa0JdW/V_0ફ *pa0dU0"""ЋaʝnRn0A4ʁ `A"""""""*"""""""?DDDDDG_\% 'mIpAG@c*gf}dX" Lr)h3GaK L)wmgvi3,4 [W&&vLPPUDz*t(_P}j4pwpa2gbKY3SP 8i4঑:H<9q 4A:H X((AM0pTªm4tHv;JZiJ: S i.* aSB ?I0PA, (A  A0 SL*yqP`0E4M O8t82.RmA! tm&n&:M"[.h;wEv,6RaM6$L&A":b4aiDP(4ME`b%08a!E2;b+A!GQQR qTbP@m *a052P [g(t a wAaa{P j /a0M05 AhAa4M5T}kjK-"ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA*N"9ѯ &^0Bj6Ta ^(AAaa L \e"iDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDGA e3"#[h-fBlHO-Q&ԌQds2ȴSa=0,zSu'0[pTXP8ph[`. cݨ6@ȃd2i޽U; 3$CA咳v ø֗uI{^IkmF__[]]ROUѝJ8:y!EhH Ԃ~Kdc#LGuvH"l:E8)l/ঌSj.h8(A !}'3CcK8gAe3d1H6pϙЌ2A) RL˥Hf5"((/ g.A `05 C_AODPH&BkMV& UCC ^iV0AlM>( f0@ p& iPpSDhÅ`AvDA;ƺ.V֕DD5B'h"P'/ T$MpPPm0 P qhhz/;,vIp xҿI,azֵz]~JT/UUUCK֩RRӯҿT[KkPUKTүI*__ I-~kJU-~J zUZK{K/JqZKt&6U}1Kt?_jkk:-/^i--zKTu/ֵIKUԾ_Y=ta%хF5/-)uTa)zkkiwVVjյ5n­,RU}}zTVWKUUiBZKҪtq $ {k %` \/V:q;^(JҊXa8 |UX(`X_z+AU!XKI}XlW]HxLq! $D6JBbk銮!-TU1T&*pU8J֒) Z`Uz۴v'ȏM@)N鵶UPbjB]US  ,0AC/_]kQ j6iA@ 0ڄ aDDD0B,0Až2uiaBh0L iM aB0&T V0&AP‚{0L- " a ArHDDDDDF""""""""?N?-RqX4̂"Iu 0ب.e;.̊*=ѱ>_VҦҲԞ;K/}۱ǵ$'0m/Үџ^_ǰ³٫Kmɪް'ɴ(4 j „ _]:KKT*^j-;Hah4ca"p;zaU0SLt]/⽴/ކ.֗W'=ӃT:A} R.zA}%}EEb#,0J^{_ﯺ~xAN7[VpOE5`ȹ_vim?P˹=Uk% z.K*v'¿\_p}РJ)/U޿]D6i#ygL+2duЌ`&>Mœ4#H!fhf UMN 0 @ r= A# jɺ:C' f)sc .fEAȡ ZhÅA &a0 @S31 `0Ba0 aM"p4^4N(A5 M؁0 B ! <-m`4tP 4NL`SaAU5T^4]! . 0mU;(q4W31N8J(B';Aař N' $D$SDɽimj2`8na݅/L;IMA_cA5MtbzuLA4315A9TulTH N]NH h E&6 Ais33 >˝մIAf!V_{z-RJ%=Rgi:M >#V &7c.tt+m+kT\8\'/WO]Nij7~޵t)=i_CMzMvT?нZ3!W֒~W{սoz}*_+$-.ޭߨzݯc^ғÃ꾕z׵6Ɵn|BV괵IRaku__}l?^%U6-kku^ څ׋} l7V,Bw["Q"w~wKa:ZI.A^?K7W _5oحv)jI:KKwN}+ނؤ7#+^aaT¥}~d$aKz_W]~^}W׮fqh)Dp3l36y: 2>&3pG3ճ'ٳWD >i=SȰzyGovBeD :PM oKGo Tߧ^[]+k}i_ mbv+h}nj6㯭ˢO^_/^}nۯ_ b# k_mGdr_o}2?k^ҷV__JWLj?l%_ۡ ז'3}r_& _`cw/-G!AXaN?<"CVIxD }~A~_{xAr_,7d4_70 _/$>뮿 {}/ CItHw/ޖ푗 M%үi>կ_ﶷ_o/_/uKak}o }{'o߿}Km%k_7 $ھK0.J/i6kZ}5__n.jᄾҽ*ԿJ~huGu !aak!a&p`VcԿK +m-o6b5U&iXI5❎ՋaL0iqa+ 1ZwlpiBn4ڽEh`@m0( j4Ȑ a1LB 0AG@ 6HGAUa0d#❤*h0 $ $ l6@%bZ LxaJ%-’&L*0_rcz ‚T44NDA` ALD(j(-M4V$5 +c@K„̃ƥe ("0 4P _ZMTK 6f ٹD!!lDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDeB"8KJҖE[ͅZ;^&A62/ceze5 ,ЊY@AnaÂ\)=g|3 8c+lh)aEJ#C2NPۃ(PPX  q*A?Dv5B "-`lN*hL-x;L"q"SH2<& T$t889YA:O@ګAUI]'Z!}7i}''}[JUta׍Uu.-[ч_V/~[r(gLSg fte;)́.5e/Ι/^K]z庬P aB0P0AL0!H 2ptA20 sd1pDCda4" !dfdexB3z52\d o58e;h#ĹB: 2R>Hu*` xPTM*i r06(MQ3AO0PPi@"> 0l,`0P@аQǪH18p2r1„д^5Mt^8 v|xNHgANڪ' ajp…NBAAA੄aZ!邦DރT6"q?|LA8bhiYIM" 6c\OzIA$i 3X2b(aд^Qx4Oav)KpPAjn UL&"u" p$M0BDXT!eů~8"""""""" DDDDXTt,]'QEMPX@D,[CDDX( X l% IM}uZ]wwcYET 1zT*Tl-eTҏJ?̲KW@ endstream endobj 82 0 obj << /Length 4367 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im83 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F84 11.98 Tf 111.60 707.52 TD (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditional) Tj /F84 11.81 Tf 363.60 0.24 TD (, limited) Tj /F84 13.95 Tf -399.84 -28.56 TD (antitrst ) Tj /F84 11.91 Tf 42.24 0.00 TD (remedy clearly within its well-) Tj /F84 12.18 Tf 146.88 0.00 TD (defined powers. Despite Rambus) Tj /F84 11.85 Tf 165.60 -.24 TD (s windfall gains during) Tj /F84 11.99 Tf -355.20 -28.32 TD (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs) Tj /F84 11.88 Tf 324.00 0.00 TD (, the Commission) Tj /F84 13.65 Tf 87.84 0.00 TD (s primar) Tj /F84 11.98 Tf -411.60 -28.56 TD (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive conditions and protect consumers) Tj /F85 11.02 Tf 0.00 -28.32 TD (going forward.) Tj /F84 13.10 Tf -.48 -56.88 TD (II.) Tj /F84 12.82 Tf 36.24 0.00 TD (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus) Tj /F84 12.73 Tf 186.72 -.24 TD (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-) Tj /F84 12.79 Tf 182.40 0.00 TD (Compliant) Tj /F84 13.09 Tf -369.12 -13.92 TD (Products Is Appropriate) Tj /F85 11.47 Tf 35.52 -28.32 TD (Absent Rambus) Tj /F84 12.50 Tf 86.40 -.24 TD (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A) Tj /F85 11.43 Tf -85.92 -14.16 TD (Series of JEDEC Standards Free ) Tj /F84 12.90 Tf 170.88 0.00 TD (Of Rambus Patents) Tj /F84 11.99 Tf -207.12 -27.84 TD (The record demonstrates that) Tj /F84 11.81 Tf 139.92 -.24 TD (, absent Rambus) Tj /F84 11.93 Tf 82.56 -.24 TD (s deception) Tj /F84 11.91 Tf 54.48 0.00 TD (, JEDEC standards would be) Tj /F84 11.51 Tf -312.96 -28.08 TD (ftee of Ram bus) Tj /F84 12.27 Tf 77.76 -.24 TD (s patent claims. CCB 4-) Tj /F84 11.61 Tf 117.60 0.00 TD (6; CCFF 2101) Tj /F84 11.83 Tf 73.92 0.00 TD (2435-) Tj /F84 12.79 Tf 28.08 0.00 TD (40. Rambus ) Tj /F84 11.88 Tf 64.32 0.00 TD (errs in asserting that it) Tj /F84 11.98 Tf -361.92 -28.32 TD (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents because \(it claims\) JEDEC) Tj /F84 12.10 Tf -.48 -28.32 TD (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-) Tj /F86 8.87 Tf 308.64 -.24 TD (12. Likewise) Tj /F85 10.38 Tf 64.32 0.00 TD (, Rambus) Tj /F84 14.70 Tf -372.72 -28.32 TD (arguent ) Tj /F84 11.99 Tf 47.76 0.00 TD (that the Commission should credit Rambus) Tj /F84 12.01 Tf 211.44 -.24 TD (s retained experts) Tj /F84 11.80 Tf 84.48 0.00 TD (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr.) Tj /F84 11.90 Tf -344.40 -28.08 TD (Rapp, to justify a 2.) Tj /F84 11.84 Tf 95.04 -.24 TD (5% royalty rate) Tj /F84 5.00 Tf 79.44 0.00 TD (id. ) Tj /F84 11.71 Tf 14.88 0.00 TD (23-) Tj /F84 11.70 Tf 28.32 0.00 TD (, is baseless.) Tj /F84 11.93 Tf -181.68 -28.08 TD (Rambus) Tj /F84 13.57 Tf 43.68 -.24 TD (s arguents are ) Tj /F84 12.17 Tf 78.00 0.00 TD (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the ) Tj /F84 13.13 Tf 237.84 0.00 TD (fudamental) Tj /F86 7.75 Tf -395.28 -28.32 TD (staring point - the concrete factual record of ) Tj /F84 11.97 Tf 218.64 -.24 TD (what competitive conditions likely would have) Tj -219.12 -28.08 TD (prevailed in the absence of its deception.) Tj /F84 12.04 Tf 195.84 4.80 TD (4 Rambus) Tj /F84 11.95 Tf 53.04 -5.04 TD (s unfounded assumptions include:) Tj /F86 5.00 Tf -211.68 -28.08 TD (1. Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. ) Tj /F85 10.81 Tf 253.68 -.48 TD (The evidence is unequivocal:) Tj /F84 11.98 Tf -290.88 -28.32 TD (Rambus refused to give a ) Tj /F84 22.99 Tf 124.80 0.00 TD (RA ) Tj /F85 11.23 Tf 37.68 0.00 TD (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223-) Tj /F86 5.00 Tf -90.72 -41.28 TD (Even assuming ) Tj /F84 5.00 Tf 76.56 -.24 TD (arguendo ) Tj /F84 11.97 Tf 48.96 0.00 TD (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer ) Tj /F84 13.28 Tf 232.32 0.00 TD (durng) Tj /F84 12.00 Tf -429.84 -14.16 TD (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate relief by a) Tj -.24 -14.16 TD (preponderance of the evidence) Tj /F84 12.09 Tf 147.36 -.24 TD (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-) Tj /F84 5.00 Tf 248.64 0.00 TD (9; ) Tj /F86 7.60 Tf 12.48 0.24 TD (infra 10-) Tj /F84 10.56 Tf 42.72 -.24 TD (14.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000498339 00000 n 0000498398 00000 n 80 7 0000498548 00000 n 0000498712 00000 n 0000542580 00000 n 0000499240 00000 n 0000498859 00000 n 0000498988 00000 n 0000499115 00000 n trailer << /Size 87 /Prev 498012 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 547013 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000599814>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R ] /Count 13 >> endobj 87 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 88 0 R /Contents 89 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 88 0 obj << /XObject << /Im90 90 0 R>> /Font << /F91 91 0 R /F92 92 0 R /F93 93 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 91 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F91 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 92 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F92 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 93 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F93 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 90 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im90 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 45902 >> stream 8M?r*k_M5ZPfMrZ,Ql(3mb~@@ڏ(e?;$Z(lDp,Je(VwTvLG 5`LAvc24g`&."a@ x.*x)UH֡&࠾H=WMR;fv ۗhiݧ$"J!ӆ[n)gwK ߫_uJZkc믮ѐQ#͑"6FPι6H28<•\H2db*̇:z L3^s%k\#9L!@C$ xSCЊy ))aa.%ٱB  S0A炷-BT )" \".t!)0A|)A 0P4A `<()8s\);0g#O" Gy'2Af pPA`=~L ISb Av4Mڮ =`:aMBjC*a3bM7*(Dz H4 &`< 434Lr/&48xLENDݢ 'qS3TMUH  "x^MQy  'uMEƋA^uD&z4N Ҧ;nQ''Bv0uAU4`  Ɖ''ի{ ޭmIv>0Wa=:X28Ti88t[WIҺַOU~jBO}]]^CL'Z]6Я'_kWz}uMڽ}-mvݯz۴zkk_{]{bWu~kQ^cw~]K`X~c8_} -༺W#=4X?Y|?,eu~X 0\/ }߿,?Im{_KX`??Ww3C^ߥN?;H"Qa A?owނ_w k7]zAz_w/?G޺A`_^v+}oA^X:]4}?կݫur?]rG /$x}/[ƕkׯO{}~mm׿>a|Wں[uKޟ{ݤ}{׶H}﴿tI t_׾ۣ?޿}~-z{z?{uK+҆oAwkaxa+V_J6L>"K4{a'H[{_ ^oN[Wj׶RM[}1Ӵ_cAy Pa 88 zMiqKTjIpIM-ݥ[kki1M\0õbiZ4p~@8jwaqzm2uNbAA4`6 1@M:*@ȏB0P  @bBA P ` : UHQ6( ;2#M  Ȯ !'Iaא a )p)!츆az§PXM^4XkjZM8MA{"4PL2 'vޛMSPpL ' <˄0A & \ #Y3 &~@K٫"""""4""""""%aH1 3oD0PS`7&L镡fp"""""""""""8R""""""""""""""")>?JֺIw]ua+ %҃ C j ahBmaa,DK*Y&#d $1QrqnTP&yFܷX] HDܖ;¨(\ҠSPgTBjCI7`P\<,*(H`6ntuX͊/严eЉaߴdJ`@ەr(Er 0 6d;(/`݂kXN`/1Pao` ka-Aw/cuZ_ -0K }iZӶ+ 18ګVդ|vvZ\T"ZjADwMC[C'}i1U+]=uE ( qU a EiLTRPMtƛ 4n5 lJ֭iamƫQ0 i5ޝ %!&ahP ` vA j a  dXMMEl6i/`l2#0@  1D`b `0AAjiL%i& 4,t6l M“0ca{MS^SXaO D:zy a48A m 5Ծ ^h0PDg? `L!q,"uDDDDDDDDDR:1hDDDDDDE!:l0D!5㈈]RK Y 5a$+ .MDGRWqL)r%nM#!lNȫ֑6,EX w7eTϙM:f kU exL&WN(LȔS0࿅Ta]0L "0`e  pۄE haA4*>݂rC?ɛ۠@$TdxQOs0ntX; ۤI6k/J@=U,94:dQawqJGĭ0'm-` үiwpqvW]:߿?'R-Wu_[t￤ݺuURJ_kkcQ#~!KzZ[Mh. xA}'t'oJ}? ;$i}}֖/$vH$~Hp$n2IuK.~l^sØG~ՏI7Z{0_}O{>.H轵m-/-޿-'KK+_3kviZ]}[]mu[ kWIJY ռ)IӿVKLYԿ!57Vc`%ItWVA{^Iא\=i{ZvA4i6(0Ib;J %)68NҎ##QQQWZK]ZAXVVG4VVb8!q ;!iNߧOTح )mt}T*) ZiZa@`0@߈LP ᄸh5֛A 1TPeh5"@AAM2,&!a A` 0v6,(!XbS"Bh4`k4M*´0XZea&P`LSe )TA FD0a5- aS[KaAPjLpi1rSd@3e|^QpDGq! """"."""""""uu_I]W}Uw4J4 |iW]G(VخCi!I 8H(p`td.b3tDF#-˯J?Qvd,MSDǏOء#gffv*FZ [L(@8 0 "V…PaoBP!ˑCay2> l(.!a4@.."Bh",x.  ƋI$..E:DH۷@IJ3CŔ=i'aAG#B; 0hdnmhZTNR\Gqڪ@i#Fd|Oٛn^%Kotگ[Uz֗^_uo_}$+ڥ^vR#aMz)w#h(z3Ϣ4eB5fl|'RHSXԐ.Y_pi. a0@D`ٱA+挐!Rl.e0y/& HS” ?\() )#!ˑt"]4d"h!\""p@>""{AAB j '6cQa 3bapP lPT)M'XM=P00L aB &f5n^(TIBN(I2S@L`=A5! a@pم )p!MAR;s"h A /$w_dk#Wi|h A$f0lf`Oj_ԉ#IvAK̻4)*0a4R^'@>h³ɰ糢ԒMдcNǺ#ܳ*鵦տ$N[ʁ߶ʿ}/=հ´Kڱ_I;(ѯ&Șk)Љ58t'ptʶوK̡y|0DDDDDo׷~oҿa+*]ڶ; Yf;?DF#&fvM@\sBGc;

8xIL$¦xL& pj Br 蟴K'_4 &aL$m Mɝ;|C3nm^5Y;jTNZBNHoZnh&tOH;p|nϮZi l'gz Iۤjީi?i]untU};ޓNT?߫[j?MujUt*-]i;V_ϿVm-K[m$J_f0KJ}ۧҥITlqf)P0d]H#֒7դ?U[if3VyeviӺUm}uBN%!$k<)CfC04046 M!u @%!5 ( AA=u!8Mtt: N͌":t.i(A~ zi `(j L&-i%L DwJ}v8Paf iumH7_E TN4A EK i}t[[vCoVuKeчiz@2x.MopdoIAt"O~_Fwz@IA=6.hijx"N}vu^߭D"7Eد[/]AnK76 /״P/ooInt]Koey#h7N+دII$wW_nP[_t"V$/[Ҥw_rEduV_z_/}T-﷧M[KXU^R ҽ׿_M[I~ioi't""G_!TK_ꓤHI}+%oo~Y}T/K?UuIZI7ׄ .0~i-GU`6KM A|.EtyBƅ TCMA}\ ȸnm`m' n{u}z]606|m0u鴛I[yWnm-'H6 }'I.ńy?z}^]?dpjӴ zaVm+׫դ ҽҶ[O _/u{o%k!ou׿7U_^u+~^]B5J[\gTMuk1 [,>]TUt^IտaRC'{_.[ ~˂^`uO'_~XG¿u{uH~'D]=~tƿ]чN^vZ_tWoM]-%U׭[_O$ަz}K]K{Kv"{m. m5Rk[cA{i-KUvz*aOKXAK ,4A5a&al&;Tu?Kح~BXE[aEK} bԣ|7#u}hX/޿iZI&Vi7ۿID"|28_ }t#/޺9k;' 3b{Dd.n[_u}&o "%iOu(+MjI^[ջ%kA}TI_ֺMOwTK/Jޫ/׿޿W޶\*}{ײ#V'm/I￤\I?u_7돥׾?ib+~I?Rw H4+M&ޒgI?^+VJu+~Z_Mi{&$^Όzu]D?J[!/* 6tu v]+zIn^ސAGtmKV"tAH=--WlWm V %ƫ~:P]6%  6HoVvAkڠT$kvjki}݆ abQ@uWiVبI8m &J8iIAjV 60AE ,&L4*:0]IR6D `01UGYL1@LS!4L+ 1LS $P- b)DĢ`#m0i5\&8A{ ׯh4iZMPT&MAi && 00vSFHO&10E)I  {_;@>lL3BH6PJ l!Ñt9^#4f)On} wM\&']&pdyl&:IGo:_;i]80]i:MKzat︰]_^(^+j?7tuk _ӥpIb]?M}z~BF9O}=_Mw]֕O_KCC4~[_Ƈcƾrc1 l1/*װU]W_y7;GaB?Ã^]yc.zn-Ddܾ_r=#ïaWn_+cWl"C߄ImX$|V 0 Aw0 _ *AK-Ao_uno$,^Az_iK=/~o t{Da$}5NDf7_z_,"^_TF]/=oi{m^k_ko߇ciI_=o{{KWiii?o][__^o᭥kyt[Zo{K/:^kY_ͦ󎷭oLazmXa& ]f>-[[j_O.L0L0ޥV§i}CVݥj8+48+WTۭSZpKJ#;vÇk[iXNO]1LWE6v aiDS֬oƿpQT`AtXi13⡄iJ4!!`lojKiD5;V"{Zk] -8uiL|TqR~4!A0M80L1TNlA5\SQT0@(2H *`!ANB:6r~@86b` A lBiUL&L$im4L `5 0gM~ &T Lpa/u*AMEpL)7EpP 0ȃڪii4аh07] PL&03]a3aBee8U5_$10D0Dna`C:0ʡ 7&q0 aaLB f4""""""""""""""""""?K/ 8AAA5 q5?FTv2 vv.eV; ȐId!J.` ND2 !ؐ2!ނF c/4Ƀ?^݃ !qa:# ̈3c2hD3",2;`6Ι9N4` @%ᦻMOoIׯTn7;~uIZӯXmFv..j%UT__WlUkz%XzT_I!ƾUZUKJa߶^3/꒥RZBKǣHdUF.zK-'ͱ#յwҳ*hֿܰT>*i>ץ֖Β-?<>./I^KIBtJ*Һ}i-'$i,VtWK5u^I+.蟥JKƽ%T$zJU-R]%HWHRQZ'UWZI}zjR]jI%U^%%ZhRUw0ҥH%UK$-.5*Jz_Um/]֒tK-]t׮I-tZkIm RZIz]$Z*A$]+ %%_t?ZKJתkU~ ޺Uu( ,/zm*ֿRK7֫RU__uWTn$5X%HBKB UI-*U҈^Tz$KJ%^ҪZXIUj޼k"kZ}/YǂoKIU]+zKT/%]RK^K֩%RIk&1.&2WZZIM=^J_Tz׭/_U^[KUHEZZVFJ}tHޝ.%J겟W=KZQZUJzIUVUִ)*k^WY!V.H]UVQu*׭u.ZUTItTaU]-hí)k]-&/QkM-=*F_KꑅZtF5/1>%KtiR=.I)/*z/at/%z]e$I.U-]+ UҥJ.ZJ{~tk}muҥzZRm$R[T500TDA4 8 '\<`Pa  * 4fCPTzh%\&0LSa:'JiUUM T0U0TPT>; i!ڪh8DyDŢpÃ@kķ@Dl\ԼDS;_y?ج7ڷKKobҦz0_V8tMe/Z+iv{}/[_M__խiZ_6ma]kmoj=kikj{kk0_1ﰶ_צ+x)6NLoZk_)b_ᄫ$0V{ -H0K_bئ;=&Ұ3" Z}Mpjڵ m.U_YakWNqV5b؏aK1qIB@e0dqB hhA`8IO!GSv0L0U[QK!GH40i m4GLS!XV)SL*lBp;l @a5T A a0B@Aam15@ [@GA@MB":0 SiCLa5.ԋgP3)j[ kˋMNUAA / >4Tv0¦& a0eŚ0eQ2 td aA"""$8N0q 8!DDDDDDDDDF"""*""8KkKZ "v^a0`V*6&RͅD 'j?"r2 nȮ*fZK2X`0aB„a0AAA`* ABP\}(06+DgaG%̍tA佃4[p}u_Ko=)|dˣC0ѬԆ~R1g ;蘍hg#4ȣ1* $ Q32: HԸP@B ^a/63 " l6lgHN͌L>" p2B@d1l# RH9qN H8EX1!C/Afj) C98L !Bˇ6(@д/ha0P (A8*i0U=Bh3S g PSS0P0TB Va0PAAAޚ tzaU4MUXT;`ɜjНDZJ&USMSx''8:ƩO)CT'uL*jUDHBth#4N N8} xдI 15,4zOAؘwǢo^&{li:'7q辢:'x^uAN,8tNh4O;t6Lw:Alœ5yn3Kak'xށ6 p`z`IEqԘEə>܋Jב^AXh'K_~i6J֗L']zozjl&wxO65pu{KKv'>?I?5ﺿz?i뺧[Zo)zkޝ-}߾ޭ׿Ҫ~?}_k뮾;v'۲8'j}ᮽ_ڏC1kt" Rr}οA=+N'YPɌ/?8U,@l?la.ODW/%a_{M6/[!wD__ۯ m om?W7߷__wa//6/77d5_$]/޴dK_l(,/?#FCct/{oIK]z_ÓK9V7U_v_5_}o7_K^i^{{ߥ߿~~/6KimZiZp[>i]j l֪]`‘`k5+ۮ#߭R= %?0I);]Xa+wz_OXatV?mm+]mXiZmlCZEkkD_Dzi]AE!CzM1QAV^vIlm_}^)h Q@@lP@ 0Az 9 {!M5!a06ba8aZAu!ҧQVÊUi100 &  Ah` C 5 jZ# RiL'L 6M4Ai4q a 0uI@ȐdG@ lUTV4dGM xk "&EpA7{", B"#<Г("`nL;aMS$ <ɏ (@ L|ca3hu&4ve8[8mT%v‚a80L&0 a0M`&DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDTDDDq!""""""""Q!"=$QUWʫ])Ш0 !bUaUAA1aZNʹVM.M dV; ȓ@BP*(W̕,9>R;B|SuwJ-̌GAh2xfGu"Dn3O=?=qNf"6vt!SJ0@Iqiv`XPAp   `$3^( P@ Qp4L*頟A-XM L&lU5 4BjX4O2Z'l0D'N'j9yLwL'SDƉD'DFTN(4N5Iy2( uoE 44ke&7AA?)<v&'AႤ{vI;zM8[+a6,&G 'Ҵ0]&qCݥ_C7NӥӤw_էIkJc_v=jwom~~!aЅ+_?1WxcV_]6'&3r? x*xl5(_(N?w{޿ڠ =mxoAޒ5{ ܑ_ z#Kw@6?daޕz_++Ҿ{o{_jm#iz^c0՘Iz_a/I58v*!t c!zaҵMtبbQC TVVzհL4jJAP 0Ȏ@ڊ": @#06@⚏ qM5+iU m&M U j-Ј"!5! 0B+eT ,L`u1eM&W3aXAWRuZ,_"L()dgȪ;L#k53v!H&DĄ cQH*wDmp".k"Eċ 2]'#HrDŽ89D ;^w=Au֞V$A=.}9FvQ[KK]/"K\IRkI.i'uM?zR꣨jWWK^T5t)~j$ D")*3~2F{4Fn Q2|~c8٨ffk8ϑ2: u3:0Dt2%jBe3If3R#:%@1I5=Dٚh382%Z(JH\W_-% تV!Ak*ZRiꖲu%JީjFKKNnU a}U.֗I*Ү/zI|ZWoZKHת\ZZ0L-$XF=W\֯WF_R$0^ZFVOoHѭkN j¯UN_Խ~1֮ZEԿҢcjc0z1WI.tcƟ%*IWTOIBJհIRIz:Uii*ZkեW][KU_T]-uN]u[WJuJ6k_[ZU z %zXU-L0iX%Uh$*) +U6vPvчGaRp-+_%Rl%iu:WQM*qU0a+KU(!!!L%K E*a*ZgU*PlL8**aGEDB0Mk`l$I%IIizj*xN$ RIST1 Q]1 m5I0mH=@MUtªTU4QQQT1 !5]!LV…B®MUPjM0!: ]0 TT0aUaU h aBT¦ L&0   S:`hX`A a x " [Ea` a 0M0L aT'%""""""#Pt u>'Z[IS%7VPZb ⡄N dK6& ""?(Yɸ4S]Berv&"L);.gcDu3#S;W+؇JrL3 &* ;p0p4( (\PAB~MrPѪJU@n\v hzMB*i"0LL}&3;2`{sU~}}]//z믿_UߎD8ᙞlA雍OdaLdu3! !uyT3Vz 1Y֍hՔ p^yD#jDlg0FJ#lsCN SAC/Aa @9ȇ^0A," |PA { 0% `&r! " 8ȼA&E 5ԏRO*<اk0aN!@%͌ &*a 5 *a=D0T'b%tM0? /Oph3¡AL >3 !B &xha? /TiM=4ªM&ﯤP4 tp9wDtNމ D`RD푇D!ߙ}:' B'h*a0P2Sf~ƨ8-4_\;A>I,6r,7xOYt-VNt 7{M[&EA"= ϡtOh;  ̾KzDqE6ipM~M%&p%&II+Rv~ij28 I}\~6(r$4`ȣ~ ^#0iC궛׷nu'Һo{ޅ[NM'۫mz֯~۽[o]ZO7i%5h[JkmohƕmGOaKX{Xb K1G_تWu۷ߨ6K6 A+Z~J2_~]|`׫___~X&"K7? /,di/F%Ko'wo?/D^h/m/~Xo?}/AC_᾿_X6WY ,77aKoӯ _diUL Y$^Sk#~H$wCRj'Fv?[V޿_0F{~޾JJ޽/V}j{V{j_vN~ׯ;_9z[zzo{JmouUo[K2K_鴻n2?2?-m[I" %a _uվI?yͯԿӪU-m/*;w]vװ?+0C=;l![Kbn}m.ث_v^d{Պabzvhza,$$^M-U (64Xi13ᄘaxa(ii_ %j{QV Zm/LTE}+vqWGq 0Im&a8a&qA- 6Dt`bDtuM![Ȏx(mLP A@LP aj)3QA] kmAIQ[A6BH3 e1 a6 & Bh' 0k&ޘL.g aT 00 {40֡&iaaii4:a0bUL@ ,oA2+m""""""(#Z:\!'`&A9CD 0@0&nLփa4ka28OɎ e@N~AЈDDDDDDDDDIj㈈B""""""""""""""""4"""CDDDDFaH ` $*V*ua ,0L A,*?_fg2iWVYMwM3KC;dC!!B Bg`jBpPP(/0SDuc]A`Ȓ%h&4V7kAE,*i4rZJb_Q$"?_]$Hq뺯K_WUU괾Na3d6A 523ʌSLErST1@Ԯ]h&uasY<0X#- FRGW 4-  hQp@0@Cx0'I !Ü& !K"!6`PDJMSCdd ̉"E͡a$ D |R 4f4A.`#E*a30 6=<0?Bj *a0TBu3L&h4 0L B AS0AA!SPrpT& $]N'DyMw>h0dD ʃD'Jh4MڦMj PM :h,&fh0d-D|8s6'4:H6z[H:O^ւ mޢh&(7 baR'Zqqx_9x/rr]e9)9x|j/Wx4 -AdQH6nZVMS &a684N :A|27IItEƓ@M IqI:N a7|+~]_uw]Z^?t6n5~>>[[7:V~I;][J߯IoWvKޞ[0B[?ץm}vji7w޾!tBU q_QIuvǯЏqco_/8a62;b?Ka҂&'Yg (}~.i/MFN6J=0wW}_KKV/ /$,$/_ݿkiiv'MW#A/+!HG?솲d/q&ok;woo/6i/k~__խZo_ZK_׻ijkWoivjlJuL4u_s|0jmj_&1=f_i6KKco~&T;o=>;niim~Uƿ & lT01L-'kWlqtՎj5iޱQM1h0QQŰXLUZU4QLR0 &59 >(VƜ`#dG@T6Bd kik m1T0@)A aC 4MӃ Z=Ztԅ0 !P@  4M0M4A[MAl&a2#L& pAaPaZMBj)6h0w aha4\+O]*aBN\DDDC(*0 ! #S !aJ M?&q0A51–<Xaa`_k0 ͈LCjDDDDDHlF""""8"""#B"4"#i~/*j%KBJ𑐠T]T(T*Aki&s!n?Dw;R-_\xdvd3[P@„*I B;p6 At$1tCF0\/!}jS@P|A#PdvWaaEjqjYML;%0䈄7mbPx`tr o;_[[?oWou[߽*kY?h:3)"5>DyE>VGaL"/띫uE9&Gt"'(= 0 ,2 $'f!D:D1 ÝBBv`0!Ia0<ȇ. 0("'N.^"̊A 8#6G dx3r'3D3:#Ғ E9) SP!܋THb xS aC IznKA44@ ةL'3bIԸ <4A4-40@a0,`@ C2 0`<  & M?P;ǪŇD(AAv'x]4M7h$O 'Y7OD:Dꨝdc OH*zaè$*a MC8naDPvAHvxA&MhAv $n4kxA} q;JސW];hff BtNoEzO b{m "~7Kv Һ; zM=6N N A+ n|g8R#> Ȗr0Snm+IWWio?Ututڷ{-N NA+ I֯zO]7Z__uo Itk׿W^:~N ޟmk[ o}o^[7K? ?W? m.Wּ۽ߎ?okwkA/ֿM8o/~LG}1Ȯ98b* poOc~ 6ô_Ea,`9b>x/]tI"q{I'{aֿD$[_Vi^A~/-ՇKo /} zt_SsZ ?d$_D CKFVo-G^#zGv_X^!{__7P}B/rx?We? X}_]&׷wߥ뺣[zߺ__Z_o&_K_uo]6FZKjuf -]tu ߭ڰaf޿Z5v? }0J % G륤Uij@piwR QRw[z_b5n#X[-_)~[/:R4v|lqF]& C% [n+҉J)҇kMpQ0(8IzkilU{i[QGoCڦZ4) `"B0A MqQ40B 6:z))@ڠA lt t h6IaZ[a+M ]4ԅ{!H60@ P dGUhf 2تmIj_ 0PiPkjӶ,dGA0 j)@@6(dHMSPkDrм0M{ 4Tf00BC#^ L ` # )H0‚:fgh57&{R0Aka20kamS گ - j0R1 SA!`DDD0D0""""""""):vuW^KvA,CN,?ɸHhdE\̍YF[Օ L(OLɞO&Q$3ȓ lc .;0([ V\ٟ˲˃`\*!stt\T."" Bwj6 0m҆\/rl+.d>"١p !a"F͢ 3]Auù߿_$?o'֯o )~Faaq%rdSP!"D,C1 xD>M'G ED:B u0f 82q#leDp# d|4ׯ]}uKu_۽ֿ ~hW?nbc{&ɟ߯ _ }u!an׿_o?]ReXY;/¯paM;_aW&l=Fw }[K(ù[WaoK.A~ _Xo7x/ #K7d#:/!wmo9V)}~}kiA Qk޳_w_aQm}~kK-6]1^~?/^ݴm}Wpmk~kkJ׵_^hKKIoK'{~_Ұ}LT^1jaA YyPUhAL ~L ()SS]3Hhxja4*p   ¦aUkLRH% Ȯ a>g>)PGVDfDF1DDDDDDDDDDDI؈"&"&De}^>9 T"""""""""""""5DDDTDDDuTM֒A-(BYn%/ $B$E!,ҥh?70!"&fEح C.8B8q b H xaA0`KiBdK#6Sq( oO~}u}?vuog>V#9#ճܹen8VRr /U{I_HW_~u}_K+K𖿽M*Φt2w2B5}#Dd:Oٌ.}/m>Qk5!8eȧё2" sdtP%5,^PA&f:,p@aB `%PBo1#eS RDt#!JNAI<5 "R d|A(EԌz "(@G~a axaD݂n*j;6"a5*koE4g i( aaC0Ph3Na PaT 'bˊ\)Lv;lA0]$UXpAT^A=4Ng(DAMڄS tDM&At7h;h4OƓӔD m &L hV|Sb9Ӥ6I?[Iֿؚ6lThz'3:qd_6&v}\lI`\)xg%5?(O <OM$2QFޓ{lp`I´m{KҺon[n_- N:^4jpu뮞tz_}{k7]?W_Mk׿ !V3ߓ?C˘_C_G]u'lB}utx,}zֿd6 `p`b<0:/ ༃N އk> / ~G_#?_l?D}wAwm7/ ,[o/t}zTa_K_~_)I?dklvH<}sUHGH$y y z^]d?$$}_Š~G_a>_det~}HonJuFU^Okkڿ}_[_6]u~vm|)6KKIZKai] [ iR5V*—ӧ *]Ep}=SմbՏ _~e]ٍ1LW~H1Տ㯎6>հL8ᅆq +qHXP`Lڊccmb@i[V %lT= M*$ 0l0A kBS@@ qT0AM8e0d A kij0ST00@؄64L&&EM:ava5/ kM @M6 &aS":iAABVj婲0& a{Q'D!LDDC4,RBjn@ AaF a4c `HODDDDq"""8/_ӥv6ҋ%^*&LL.b#D!-rAyغ+7L+LՓLa2˳f"pBfI6"#i+M3C""4  M0XÐy4!V }@ԬZTTBTk08= \ ~ DfAppuzpvKŠL0LHaL.R* d~C}|. L 4P!` 2v`\CD\"л# CL5O 0 ܅D辄ND<ҫ{iM5T>hLkX&* aS͊| &;t!I"h '7 M4i:Zu^zM q< &({4:TQ' 0a4:fhHa;|P7_פot[%i&I*z8aX0 |Am'+R\g t3؇/zw&AME:'WaVu}:t)ZO$nzP%;lwX_[ih/qWo_!zz]WZUwO}T~[iU׺__ǫFtm ׿꾿TKKw/N?M_>N{ /cbomJM֖ˆXiI&#aKI$Zå+nLߦ]n۵l6z%BGN$DIoޕ }Wۿҿ0oomekmHBu_KKkAx? W$_HtdIzu*_m_wҟÚw~iH[}#1zzzOa_kuKRK].m+WҴ/H]e^uݯWB/[vKkoԺWmnٙV"H +].`^ ptKخ;Njݾmmc_/'mZ o_a}iZiMi|64bd Uuim1=!&)zR_ TBIݥV_/ⴶ-8uaAAi@أ0@D NȎAp  a0A<  q$4 X`w+b@@جVς ma60ZdW,i[CAwi;Vi a%*(` ^0@mhS tk -ӆg?Cgڠ! ϼ*iʚe(8ezgexSg0LL 3|!s#t?;9caK醥S@AR|4 `!gti 0Q0DDDp-#HDDDDh!8\Rץj~%ᄓXH ' i%Cmb IQNa (A"F|F?ZUfJN-E dUfDN0< w;ر"+geH aeP:f A8dG쌃-Q ,X,Z x&I)̾CP5mz *himnK(.H!k\0#A0<*|$#A $@̀0\d1uh4X6SP84L- ƾ}$"g800vKL7LOM6Qx MݪAA++Xȑ#ރ{ Z쨠g0m~8OjZ'/{_M ?֗WҿKm!鹇na0U}zM?o^0~i;] kKҥ/h\pq4 VD'#l1Hy:r. 8fu— y{5" i>vTAF Ү @w_1 *aa PCL0T hhE(A0B< ‚  @l!@R"0fb2@AB #ԓʁHc#t #Wۿ9pp84R~]Zb*  &82o0=v H0SOAMW48(Aha„ zOUb4^0d/^׆㛚/(M1e|wty.hh<'v\4uEESE'hdHqE4Hx*jheۯ =ե5]tKuh"DxIzkI'E&ό`ȹEƓI=\Mpbk ;nqmA E0@]~otF&ua;nAo}I*^t~uIM+~ n28izM]82-PwO[Czw}Uk{Z}jӫzMBZOM[o}VW!Giou?o5t?N\B_nLB 뮲tcqt/i <~㾣B67_lAv97uok_ د/Lr#wZ/ab? ܺecSvGGgm]_n}ЌB;q~o@a߯ i{_z_W^ {_ }0u^ o_EuIN~"_f07u}_VHܑU'ܑ#5d4D{+۫CN 7z3o0n={֮WWDc>ߴn뿭^ҰޛzտkӾ$o_-iݭk~;6J3za/0{ӥo׵տL\۰«i6رUbmhCJkM7B $Nue0 &>m%ah {)jU `hlB0@ a!   @!AQAkiv66$pv$B!Q`\1 v0M z! * d1;Xk'#p^ nᑸ& a XVW ZL&d 2 U n'Ap DC"" & 8hm2-K'>WfgO#>ȶ.zA#3A7NF:A> /ktOOڿO6xMޭ6%i&JuMk֯un~_צwWb*_b˯˯~0_ ?~i{NW$_[}[d#[֖g鿿~}/ֽ[.߿_ӷ]~J޾[^^_Wucam~@J놫 $YVP_)]@ث+b؅K 0v'uaX4J_i[ %}C [NQTlS `h0A"ST(aM! l6Va{_;/ 0XaM BM "/.!HMX`j4ӈ"#Cum%ii[9JlBmETDGrHRaS&I[~z-M^l%6+4#孯&qZEj?{B-e endstream endobj 89 0 obj << /Length 4987 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im90 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F91 12.04 Tf 74.88 707.52 TD (\(Diepenbrock\). This was not mere oversight or misunderstanding; it was a calculated ) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf 412.32 0.00 TD (position.) Tj /F92 10.52 Tf -412.56 -28.56 TD (Rambus representatives regarded ) Tj /F91 22.69 Tf 162.00 -.24 TD (RA ) Tj /F92 11.12 Tf 37.20 0.24 TD (as contrar to Rambus) Tj /F92 10.34 Tf 107.52 0.00 TD (' s entire business model.) Tj /F91 11.95 Tf -306.48 -28.56 TD (CX0873 \(") Tj /F91 11.99 Tf 52.32 0.00 TD (Rambus Inc. ) Tj /F91 13.22 Tf 63.60 0.00 TD (canot agree ) Tj /F92 11.05 Tf 63.84 0.00 TD (to the terms ofthe JEDEC patent \(licensing\) ) Tj /F91 11.87 Tf 215.52 0.24 TD (policy"\);) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf -395.28 -28.80 TD (CX0874 \(") Tj /F91 12.00 Tf 52.32 0.24 TD (the patent \(licensing\) policy of JEDEC does not comport with our business model") Tj /F91 11.82 Tf -52.56 -28.56 TD (Tr. 6228-) Tj /F91 12.00 Tf 45.12 0.00 TD (29 \(Diepenbrock: ") Tj /F91 22.69 Tf 92.40 -.24 TD (RA ) Tj /F91 11.98 Tf 37.20 0.24 TD (terms \(were\) inconsistent with Rambus) Tj /F91 11.76 Tf 188.88 0.00 TD (' existing business) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf -364.08 -28.32 TD (practices) Tj /F91 11.95 Tf 48.00 -.24 TD (\); CX2112 at 213 \(Mooring\); CX3129 at 488-) Tj /F91 11.90 Tf 220.56 0.00 TD (89 \(Vincent\); CX2083 at 98 \(Davidow\).) Tj /F91 11.93 Tf -268.56 -28.08 TD (And absent a ) Tj /F91 14.66 Tf 65.28 -.24 TD (RA commitment) Tj /F91 11.96 Tf 98.64 0.00 TD (, JEDEC could not have adopted Rambus) Tj /F91 11.71 Tf 203.04 0.24 TD (s technologies.) Tj /F91 11.97 Tf -366.72 -28.56 TD (CX0203A at 11; JX0054 at 9; CX0208 at 19; Tr. 1868-) Tj /F92 10.71 Tf 277.68 0.00 TD (, 1884-) Tj 46.32 0.24 TD (, 1895-) Tj /F92 10.56 Tf 46.08 0.00 TD (, 1907-) Tj /F91 11.65 Tf 33.60 0.00 TD (08 \(Kelly\).) Tj /F91 11.92 Tf -403.92 -28.32 TD (Absent Rambus) Tj /F91 11.93 Tf 80.40 0.00 TD (s deception) Tj /F91 12.13 Tf 54.48 -.24 TD (, JEDEC standards would have been ftee ofRambus) Tj /F91 11.78 Tf 255.36 0.24 TD (s patent claims.) Tj /F91 12.23 Tf -354.24 -28.32 TD (2. JEDEC members would ) Tj /F91 11.68 Tf 133.44 -.24 TD (have been satisfied with a RAND commitment from Rambus.) Tj /F91 12.04 Tf -169.44 -28.56 TD (JEDEC members were focused on minimizing cost. They were particularly concerned about) Tj /F91 12.13 Tf -.48 -28.32 TD (patents held by non-manufacturng companies) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf 221.76 0.00 TD (, such as Rambus) Tj /F91 11.94 Tf 83.28 0.00 TD (, because they would demand) Tj /F91 11.92 Tf -304.80 -28.56 TD (cash royalties rather than cross-) Tj /F91 11.74 Tf 151.44 0.24 TD (licenses.) Tj /F91 12.16 Tf -115.44 -28.56 TD (3. JEDEC members would have engaged ) Tj /F92 10.92 Tf 202.32 -.24 TD (in a detailed cost comparison of alternatives.) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf -238.80 -28.08 TD (Rambus argues) Tj /F91 11.95 Tf 73.68 -.24 TD (, based solely on the theories of its retained experts) Tj /F91 11.99 Tf 245.04 0.00 TD (, that JEDEC members would) Tj /F92 10.67 Tf -318.96 -28.08 TD (have calculated static) Tj /F91 11.79 Tf 102.72 -.24 TD (, down-) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf 36.24 0.00 TD (to-) Tj 13.68 0.00 TD (the-) Tj /F91 11.87 Tf 18.48 0.00 TD (penny cost projections) Tj /F91 11.93 Tf 107.76 0.00 TD (, fifteen years into the future) Tj /F91 12.78 Tf 136.32 0.24 TD (, of) Tj /F91 11.93 Tf -415.20 -28.56 TD (Rambus) Tj /F92 10.74 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (s technologies versus alternatives. Rambus presents no factual evidence that JEDEC) Tj /F93 7.38 Tf -43.20 -28.32 TD (actually did this. In fact) Tj /F91 12.10 Tf 115.68 0.00 TD (, there were multiple reasons why JEDEC did not. Rambus) Tj /F91 11.79 Tf 290.16 0.00 TD (s own) Tj /F91 11.90 Tf -405.84 -28.56 TD (experiences with its ) Tj /F91 15.77 Tf 97.44 0.00 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F91 11.66 Tf 47.76 0.00 TD (show:) Tj /F93 15.55 Tf -109.68 -50.88 TD (5 Rambus) Tj /F91 11.99 Tf 79.20 -5.04 TD (s claims that JEDEC never rejected a patented technology ) Tj /F93 7.78 Tf 280.56 0.24 TD (ifthe patent-) Tj /F91 11.90 Tf -396.00 -14.40 TD (holder offered a ) Tj /F91 14.70 Tf 78.96 0.00 TD (RA commitment) Tj /F91 11.76 Tf 98.88 0.00 TD (, RB 12 n. 9) Tj /F93 5.00 Tf 57.60 0.00 TD (, is simply untrue. ) Tj /F91 5.00 Tf 91.92 -.24 TD (See ) Tj /F91 11.82 Tf 19.92 0.24 TD (Tr. 5046-) Tj /F92 11.15 Tf 45.12 0.24 TD (49 \(Kellogg:) Tj /F91 11.56 Tf -392.40 -14.40 TD (IBM) Tj /F91 11.67 Tf 22.56 -.24 TD (, Cypress) Tj /F91 11.96 Tf 44.16 0.24 TD (, Kentron and ) Tj /F91 13.83 Tf 68.40 0.00 TD (Hyudai ) Tj /F92 10.67 Tf 44.16 0.00 TD (technologies rejected despite ) Tj /F91 22.99 Tf 141.12 -.24 TD (RA ) Tj /F91 11.89 Tf 37.68 0.24 TD (offer\); CX3135 at 104-) Tj /F91 11.93 Tf -357.84 -14.16 TD (06 \(Chen: Mitsubishi technologies rejected\).) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000547340 00000 n 0000547399 00000 n 87 7 0000547556 00000 n 0000547720 00000 n 0000594483 00000 n 0000548248 00000 n 0000547867 00000 n 0000547996 00000 n 0000548123 00000 n trailer << /Size 94 /Prev 547013 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 599536 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000657793>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R ] /Count 14 >> endobj 94 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 95 0 R /Contents 96 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 95 0 obj << /XObject << /Im97 97 0 R>> /Font << /F98 98 0 R /F99 99 0 R /F100 100 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 98 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F98 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 99 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F99 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 100 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F100 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 97 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im97 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 50777 >> stream dg尖?j?ѢMTyj(U R(YFוgvdܗ%g)Gi%EBiB [gclx3(k mx([AP&-Ҷ,aB,v RVttHJ%tɴB;`B\}-k`T&EGW[ijU_UöWuOz(2>0HAg#yBZ Ѝϩph0xFrD 9S3‡'lͲs!x4 A(@B*a4440T 06 0 pJ  C%Ø๲ H DaO" B!vpP@B|PL w30 _IvMU0&UA0 (L'  8*hR`4<*}xAӄ* aâv=4&(U eUH vZqqhA_8_A|EF B_ MQ;xa0yRr/D탃g//'ppxE0dh4l0HM!##bǏ|]z^ ^! K__]u!ȴ0:x?n4Zֵ]Lfa&0z0z޽V~&o >{u_I.ao\7֯޿zo}won6 #Gm:/!CIHkJ!o<7Gy7yNge_x7RoڽokOI__*F]w{ֻWO[i/]kk_ko~nۮMKK_i_6 /ͯ >z6 %_j `& V콰a.im_M=L-~mm'6w]adZ}RWuUaVmLqp)Xxbm2:>k{a=-aVi~M1W[iDw{V+8$ a0IMiثX`4(cm$aHWh6Md(CibT 5 AU4@M m 0A7h3i B: *BBkb 0A1[@ m4p6 M5M\Y \,t,AӃ_;aa -_atȮ_ &MB M @L&a'MS }u&)oeI&A8_HDGDDDDDDDDDDDEDDDDDDDYS@0F ,Ճ $ DE#"""""""""#oDDDGR_뮗n^zZKdѪFZial-HQ6= 4*bAjSWi0A#- qC,LV)K"kL(PئK\KEq((.aN#A]uM;NI1+ eD-:488ZQuV_ikk]W֫rFGdxG\Pfe; 3͢fΨP݅53z)3C;_~q 0(>0@0A,S PBHy 0%f]EP! jD3͊pRp 3Kc>2C4f4oA *ψiq<*kNfM4&lP8 T„L0ABw|uCEz/h ]xx$a3v'N'p8 T(M5 & Ii'I'HptA]I6 OH6i6-6pCfDSN  ދ/Un[z[aol[M+u-'M]bsC3*t 7i~Tդ] = M}zK~_U__K1QmR~ *>[+J?-?eD~D%T4`*[w?U xm{o]_~s_7K|܇o[|=.E#op?z_n;V{w9O[}__uooҾ]봯]}VkU/]v -ǶO .a{'o2BҴmLvv[]~XOX|'=$l$ -Z4j=j5Ji10aCaVAүXbaE5bh lB q["30@ت6)8a dH1AAi!&UAMIaaiCKp4j—t" DPN*  &`@lROԲ#"""& (,(G]4L` pL (# Bf{&z )TLSQDDDDDDDDDDDEXC$A G(%dI4WR#T);+llk&V"MuDI#(PBڅLLCy9E=D#;e:Pai0aBHP\!`@g iH7 r712s9.y>m8y5MЎ525*?IʕHF5|'AiP P A0 `aPa0( `O!B# xPD$^"̈rdB")1zKA+_覆0@ )kj#4SD~֠`DU0TAAS 0mbŴɴ/4_4O ˡy#a:蝴 '7<7Wd|&M27X80L'A6^֫>a ouյ+W߿iSЭkC[MW Zii~ )[߫w׫O?W_4{__ ` ]]^]tKߋ_Wu[h%I.ҥ^>>_K_kQ_nm/IR.p݇}Zu /֞n=a=OmRH%Zڂ}nk߰/KGN;VwAahB~_?{~A}_BB/״Xomߥ_~_('I߭! ";xoo״/EHדJK]o^ Mwץׯ_NEY^[kjw[j[k{WM!z>ޖ﷿Zm׿][Wu]{Zmt(%׵oҺuwz{KRu0io0ƭL-xa{UH߮6I..i [~|JC㴣}-Mwkj6!Mu4J/aa&KCiMw R[بuiZ Pa  TJWv/`PҴ-X[b8)alwzm'0 L4LV .q 0ޛL0bi"B t lTBlq !46#b4: u EE aItbfb 1` 4'ea㦦&1Pj0PA\p]RnӶa4~MA M!Ab 5h4߬4„rb"",X2'" a0a +*jh&~L)Kyqa55 惏 0A .DDDDMp0WHG|DDDDDDTDDDDDDDDAeK}_n_V`\쭥,J?BUִݴ xa&aa8O,0DDDJYFLّv*gu + av&20FGu\kfK Dv"™, a0PA;dჁ@711@`ò=}t7hxM<&"4n.$S$x^Aƒ# w 4N.h52+2vT*6iZDƉ;I }Nڦ m4m&ޛ{KZm].Z]_/+KU'oVյH?յtaZ_W}^-~յIO꺿} 2AyYdFD ! d) d,Cpª&iO M~ ة$S>)SD܅jBKޕB/8(L 0L ۽ {imfUM4: a"xAm(kWjJSiA.&m/R 1L: ]ַjv5㶘iZa)Dt 6ӄBTTP af@@0@ LUuHBaIi&a$IUaK qR@BT6#[8 u*avM6 Om im&M1[0@<80!Jb68b :j4i SQe0l  \geM 9U=*$"v5er§!O,3h%&g:0DPȜA8dh!F |d`9 Z$ tUh(͙O335 d/ԎeմzKjm/~}{Kum{{_m*o[m.%_WulUktخI^vUa_}}KjULqv0[;b%m/CB=j[MPM d(Xt{1*NaV^a4Mh l*0=A d L&A T0#0Lty8^`0M2L˴|{ o jOdn00XiZdPtDG$!p DDDhLi _QDDGK#H 4ESUv "Q?O"tw8t(L&A"DFE!,t`…;  k. IDNHGE] I6 StOT8>n% J5hRWWzI;i?ZZ_]k3)|G\Pf)5F5#ue=d /&k*y葝s٬L a B„ *` L jBa0C:D.qfŸd3ᔂ!c>DE$G C1C R= L3=H6dUd,9@ R! PD^0৅BCЉ2pFlkpT>* <3¦,it 4iƚ 0 0PB a a a [L ‚A s4gL& `Ӡ`x;']8vN' >pDAO(hh4$; 55MU0 D4aU0nSiDݨUPMMaSETL$N3ZL;H6mnqȑA;2A޴@cDh4_8 45''-Pn,4ւ/oU K=/դo_c_Ҷ]ǿz /I^~t}/ۯBX?nQ:_ r~Km_n D;$?'W__kߠuA? ?/z ۧU}_ O/ޯD'͠$_@ۤ;$[#KGo X7]^^mnK_z}//{ы_:}}֕~]O[ki_ۮMmmߪӭ[v.ҿ(z턛 7_Z0il0uk1VmWMm?i[~m/N&G0MߥWAAs*6^iz_ %L0 % .Ҹk1 +G1lAm?j6LSuu\EZ_][ҏ]إbP alP `lq6666(&a6vd(צ+bNƚ m  0@0@ Q;M = PAհDE8 [H0 4(L ⚄`4h S"8ADuAM 0 %>2vP,a "h a  ZgN)%/ r1–0q~Ma5a0 n e8RANϓ aʚ$!@@3&W)!EDDDDDDDDDDqDGDDTq~Z^/_Wi%I~uI[kWqqC5F:KIcuGbW}zB \ ¦p@3AD NS`!r< f 1 /ٲ:tf$ Igr=H>:#14HM΃!d|SI\2!r&C i*xL!]05L੄C?qPO ia A=[a^g=}A00:.'yvL'm *'tMyDp0;D&h0p`^iO'hN 'NT:A  ivAAt44 9Šh ;|ٺwV|A7/= nt <]i6}&] uq{`=Im'qMI;Ipd\I}*pC ﮒ2%Ȱm' ] 6}u{:WC]_ ~o./|$7@կzz]W_[_ߦmoun]7[㱏?k/Cn 7O k]_Qz?W,ucߤK_1W3ܺ kZܱ(/, ?poq^;b }~_bg@M}al= 'џxak8_|^"C~?ow{m',"w׷{{j_B o_/د|6պ/pt%37e#W_/Ã?rGC{j٫ }~_v.$}~mmF6cku;N=%׷s_x}K/[ۿ]o$%K+K]&dv}5ik_i^K_tuk1I/{ .]zpnna_۞%K/}wtISץ~Ua + m:Vuas0~Z $3f1?v}uKt+9;56 ״iZMlSiw{aXka$%aPZ>J Km+IiXI!Ph0@ڧ ݠ@8 b$lTTP a v*B> j,Tlvai 2%LSAmaL%0iBXL 4&!M5 Aa@GTfa, 0A*Pa05mT.""""C 8`#g `GRpE;: &kMA4@zp[aPa&Z p` @A! `xa90TDDDDDDDR"#H8=|muUȞ % 6+ 6P ae!<9^j\DqR nRdu_6[i,`iޭ|W߿_UW}_{޻dgZ^?%[#:t}~w_Kׯ~u_֕~IS ޷}Km[ͯIu__[CXM~׶Ko6Jۧ\~E7H?sO $/ݰ҆ˠl5ߊa %MG"/i/ޕ:$ҴO@Ȏ6!E9;@< `wb`ˌ8a&K@ӻT4pbJ0_UvXA] Ӡؤئ*6E  a3 a5*"J/yd/ 0ASrifԍ7GM2p0 &kiZi.4¤i-*8DFDE"!\d feձt=%JTJiC[ BZJJ!1I[H4J Yl(j(lb,fJLE`bVvdgcN̕##^3#) ua@x8 i< Lȥ¦0@j^ ' iS J0.蛽]h UH'MNߤq'0}+FD݅veMhW $'CDV'q"\vO??㏾_OKK_]W_^HGLe<2|>[0A;L )Cc<)O$悤CBH$xSA8B 2U]SdHιz8ffJ2:2>gENgLuG:6F3n)?r@F/Ay=AIك3#AJbF|dj͈ ݥ aJ=>SL(L1Pa3 (L aBB  a ́  0 0C)rဃMlP  00TD6Qr-Lv8wLQ!w`>Ң&<8P  M4SM`T¦ PP z`0A'SUAMS . bk{k oxNhhtO7xv@,|y9jAϚvд]Bm'5P%D 0yA/ı'_9}J-iXPI^+_& ^ M E>:Ӯdȗ'ڡ:Mֿ7xS7~;߭_:|~޿^)c;|ڧ؏W,ʳ V_b0x.OZM[k[i}iKմJijݷZ{ %aMV'zK;a+`I? Յ#߶6I2kC 1QDTvK᭄׶Kޜ:#c&)}=J) Յb;^ eAvtG60AȎNHnQAAQؠ@d~B4MT*Mk׆[XjLi @ `i :A ؤaSgt<0A ZV0T $TaA6 C.  aM2$&4!0 0&a  Ka& m ۈb$m0?WT)a0R Kta0aL=XaArvq¦0k B c Bh28RLןau`L)c|@5""""t@Μ)p3B"""""""""""""""(##iK~ (KA …l( 6L+$dCVZQ6WiyD,4w讟PjԄ=75=@[0NApS%P2èeYTJSLAI 3ޜ#<B#'mCM$Fq#x8Q5$Cl~_MI$>O^w ӤHQ|֜_IڭIO__ҧ_}'Iҿ/ﶗKs1"_E#q]C:|dDF#5IlUfK#VB Cu쌄DA A`Z`3CMx)8r "c<(L @<ȇ |SS4f0fbd8!M"kI‘! e8DC"ft2FfQҪʱ Slt.D"P<00DIB"{ICMi:j 4§)P< L;A0C`/? ha (O`?h?<3"pdAJ'va0;r;DMAS݃$rniPND $:eI Mp_8D 08jIaaRINސ&;l&n@O>ީ%hEEyBEDv;wD]4(mbx|(6]ҺONӮ p}>f3 ˺oIۥuo{#T>m'A7A:AP?ڥ:N IT4Et޿M7t4+oo?pazt&GΪ^SJߎ]&_inKߡn_KWׯKo~|v-Ҷa!wMu|?&WJo/uEzQ _}&+ hwQWoc11lcaI/A~b:OɌ/d˺aCXc~{.eYb<~=zHɌuj"Q Ҷg($woa/6^wow?_v~CAzK _ ?߯{>RU*/4Hy"/ d4xI/ld?ح,m}v?buȈiflc I?UWo߶L=7_/__[Kmwo5}]$H$~ikVU/R=i]?}ktas|4^^V/f<:_mzJߐBJm6K :#;갈QiqV}~lW[mo%i_0K`?M'mm/6oJIt&C 00Ҿ+iki8Ij$`iZ[ &)*V 6%t m|muwvՑ!᠃ US!E;0@6@0kd(A1MCBlXI 5P p+IR퍊m4A0A ai a0ڦ5 ڨAµ . m4Š P*QQ*h0h0Xi4 """""""tŠ0D 0^O5& 0Ll3  3& Z ))1ph5  &M ¦ tc9 &""""""8DA#N0B8DD_}vvW%t+otۂ adCG嚡GMړ`6C2V͚2(PslaK!6VY^8gBdP"s n, p6 AmBg>`…^@ !ݶ-R$K 9s!v`b "EDT"r&["6I=i8AVu}62Mh$DU7ZN ZSZjڥZz뤯jz=N^Vs,8<ᚆ\(Le; Fq!VR"iDBʟ$o\$)V I$ na4*h^$YN P"!2)p<9>p9!r$Ba. B9 YPk.T~B=\BN~F̜G/#$I6f׭% ! )aV&^U0Tתi&0(L'*} A0T !a`0iT / *a a!qժhO hOp4Ih0 $$DݢwI$;DMZiUiaSL&Iit§޸\k]%TӶ"IE4PMIAALAޒ $6z6/!Hi/'0 %mɜO(A1ЇMm_8<}o\ tҿձ`I^'J8I=`ȯIdQOM'A>A=:W{]Gzt'EƓҧwKJ/nwҭ¶ꝡJq}$I?kiW_ޖtևӭzӿ^oz o?_޿{K?]Q_ozQ|hvz/]I?Kwai#K'biGɣ'/a]*/c?,g`Kc`Ќ8ֿ} _&iwk@0mHͯ,FL  '_?KU]h~hZVڄI0=?=_AmA~ݣ=/џz'Go]o?!~ ׶ m�moz ɻ-Hm/\K# HlHiY#drk~H5k7cK9oo>ucs}/[">o}j߷~ե~ύWZ[_WKK[M/ݶ/뿵m*~}--/Iv^> % u1Mkޭ 7yߩ} /TҵvaFZM]{}UE}qث[]"wV;;[OJOllujۆ 7zjZi6{ڴtm]Zm 7TnJtH[|-h0| :.ܸmip0_hd;D ֚jQ8jv:Q|&06gM>B¦ 'UDH)7oZMGI66Pxw_ (A~10_>4.xjE=)yXBDۋDyTO'~_;j[gi4a[JZ):Wi7o=9 Nf29m"_zIIo=7AdHN82(z '$AFZZ%o]}~~_8Z["WKIM7WB]Tڶ}~^ֿ WӴN_]~__kƿǻɟ\?[_uoWMv5]uuZJm4L1k {dž??_c?X!|Bpb?:zۯm?߯_,G.C?]~߰|~_kn_VߪaۿɎ/_oDAI{{}~Kkثom%n/o /h/ 7دms*>YE)$~% o 7l/_<}iW"?o_K}.?(a7}B_ZV}CizZm_0ֿӾڷ^Aޖ/oiu{iwﶗiگ0Æ}O-'K;!եqUג[Ӻbh9)B+[ mmkzHzO *jݩKJM}'wOL\6-oD%I{045"b;^[ i;w|n@vI=UJi?0P M6bb,H BOa xKBiZPMCJեI4&06at aO&Ep[Mi/T$IȎpM&Al dG@^@ y1!EEF6kb ~0AM4M6$p0@2? ir)$0)+@fy4CL^^/a5qԆ+(Aի aK冾}I tC [~Ed")28."D 0L BPAX8'~*j0ꪸ0'#  X vث Z¦OaK![@ D|F#屢ML4d"M90B 0`Z`ϙأ 㵸왙䌒^;PT U M00!aAB= PHd.(MB@AaפՠQpuERE9՝]FfBwsS;I$coNcfv[N'W^ӾNm~KGׯwִפ넒% pPDdCR"6G8)8G6fF##OC]d.!pCifiHDњϢQXfft3Yn'"lEdj~ ૧MCN4* *A0P0 O0v" a:XBN &y@8"9K#3: Cf RgQ pRu8 g pP@"`0C*`}i*0aUt 0PTLkM#LGPS 0T 8A00vjH5 MASL5L4^ L446n^A9x' д^4] X882jDAË;wUAUOMU0'8~ z.h0H'JZ'vD' a9xO7N mّ];I=;5ۥN W]^;8G]ݑ{K]N'[lU>Qq_z]EhZQU_1ȰAl=m/{J ~wX>`{/_մ_5M/ &3,Xu^__koׄI;?nT-}_/lC_5~ {{KKK܆yO^]~Hl#Z[iFOOVﷷ{oMO勵q_m/߿oJק{KImni[K_m/ai{kkkޗ}w W](0uf;K`?`asmmvxskkKm-^_akv]w %` 5 ~@cm&ҺbKV5jO >덊m,-/Cմc6;m; a4 r~QH;bg|4 &*^jQ0=IV@#+ڶV8ixꩋش[4BL5A0A`MT0 t@@1 h@ l{m:in iM<:ݧd#@h67h6 )'RC AKxa2/j a5aj0MA4VB  A0A m42$ Orb^Ȯ il2+I DDDDDDDDDDDDDA`D"%0@L@f :`anTAiaU&`D:!a:‚"""""""""""$6"""""""#-.VwPO_A&uQeM G0axYѝ2%H2Fv+y; y_d#&~™l … `q+P (((.& v ;r gc(l5P T TALBIY,O_֎ |%OM`4K`s)٬Bv`i6K{smdTrAuuÃ>=>'޷ZރʯU~շGհױ_j9=/oȰȴ뱹u0ҽڳo`[9F(((PPPPPڀsj`D\HMUU .TM4\hPOe~aﮋƚ@ACh,qqŠr23ddb{AjTDc8t{0UU[S6|70iVOv_[/֌=w_}I뾒Z-utc'qSt_3Fs0A-rg/_^B$$! a "4,ؠ@ !৅>!PL! DdMǐ5N͌!;3ySu3 1h1ctH2n3F<۝"5gTjFGK!#W>ASLOkvA~ i !<3b`a0@„Z<a`A  'B`TPKƉM a ]}M0 vDz$">yDcM5TNߴ' 0L<"N#  4]}gPP*Nt<&5;$Ig p@ށA6iR>qa$h4O n/D7&rvM 0D"NN:KB׭kW&oo''I/I]X$zpdotBGKciA{2Bo@&CN (q4Ur\Sd_Oi%jTߤߺO]ZM^i7܎iGtJq}lXOSth޽jO5NOWIu_U_Q\u_Ms_~/nH?+MV^qIq %#k/]{i~a .&sB,r#ܪ/bpO!Q <1I*^}tDz]hG._ &/LB_ғ[_~vO0="N?~"W/վz^~]ꂮO((z㪏_߆_ KA~|%A]+(yG?!.ޕ?_C_C_~㍊~)*_^^?K$Z#zur#U}0{_k_w_ߥ޿*a}oK{]K(k}kkWkuUe7_R뵽i6 [MjKvu]_fUttiXOm;*m1_ ZlUjG6+i6ҏ\ǩӃ a2?I~ pi6ۣpK ++Q0a^"1; q^WGlGilT0W.j)<$Ew[u_i a+I+ ҡ `7b l4SANcd(鶁m!GH4M5a'^օm\5[ 턢D`j "$ՄaM2pM4Il* j*R t ` AY0hqA P `0@A+-؈-0PFL?&~L(TE!؃0APL$dC 5Lj A&:iM0 [iMA Z^v daGDDDDDDDDDDDDE qejza: (h `I3"Ј0B""$A^DDDDDDDDE}VVFZFACH![~'MWtA@ cEx?!&ތZ;YE ;a2exd+r\dPkN((((* RPnT(PB ąm&`乃"ݔ<}'afF[;mvWKUU,H4͑DlgQCN3q٬C#BC" B"3霊 ՞5|~qkf%L\ʌΈgFgL(L*`xA  AX  `0@00@8!Ar"xc>)I‘: r2 dEЋ]4ƲA`dR Zy͑N f8( `$a 0@>!@Z$<*iTD i'L4M5Oa0o B 4(TA` 0 *aPa  TO& ƅƂwV4O'Dh=h0p;yDvÃODݢCN<&:¦U0*Q8 :$ptM'tN CTOP $N|(r$Ann&w"Mh&X:AAt wm@sIn xаd˒T;hq7Ɓ5 N !ѯw^JńMzV` _I'm'!pl$Eƭst+WGovCI>`lr%pdK"Cdom'IdnMI~]z]}*n&m'_}'I pa&ҸNt8 \Zۧk%Tߡ>߭M5n̲ԅtղԫղԕڰ::߱ů4?W7]=ܽ}??<%B֗}-֗ W_WסG_V+),1˯^+X5IU[X k/. |pa[ ?^X&3`_ D(_'aM? N?~Lwrc_ol${׽mAoaHz CWW4m/6K὿{!K _rG__/D_KCZCY6G_H޾ҮZ]o}7_K;_a'Syx=oo޿oK}o_I?l%k%{kkim}~ZZ^o_W]ե~mmzcm~ _Mۿmt/0ԿIۼJt/oV8j^c ~ /@JҴ &Ҵ![lWi1][i]60CIb&GVv/8NRc`_m~Ճ kڗҴ \;_]XlUc)4nVViC 1[iS &KMokiDqiiLD.Xض)bmb0ŠiA*B: @ ah0(E2#@jB:3: #&8a) >*kWIpZi,d#hȎ=dpn-dna X  a|,4aSM` 04I*4ALP h40A) 6Bj'PAȎYtҴZi8(Xgԝ "`` `(GF 0M4k&?gah&MiR\Ÿ*@D[Tëj'K n mk".SI]'tnm.I*zI~ڶӤM{IS]uzI{O^~O_[kiRmm/^qM"'fxA?]MZld &"TQ̝IZqw@庘B&ahX `|PC(  " 2! ȡ0M NAvG<`[sf6'ιI8aa)Ƌ82eΘa0yEJd񮉻B$"N$;Dݪ 'uCDT®F~w NbUI}CTNTԎ&\ZN-[ Ow U t6M| q3!+`D뤫)n F/!PIACMzvPh::lsN"[r,0'IҮuImC=ic#~ ^[C & u+Okޞo[ޡ]'_Z{i~m}{zҵը\+~R{>*߮b%%"m,d/{_c zJe]o{_ ^_݇}$Ip}"q~Б~2q=/KKl>$EK__U m_֖J+Q}?(I%^6 I5_YGUcد7??m/A [I}ߵJۧ޾][7%JZz׿n$H"D"m+_ۦ_鰹J}i[դ}u<^H/k}DZ$ڶ/(??-մ q*ڶ_c`& V߫ߩ }Ndqp4a(mNH4Dý 8T*Ҵbi*ݬ}VҵNm}(aޚ IWXU[I% ap  {OQ@ih1QM4 aGA8(a0O I5+04n>i*M>JJ)xa5,&Da4M*Ȏ h4&&&:p 1 u)86Dt bIafa@ &l&p!B L aO@05a0LL& 20gʼ׷3T.MUS AIo00"""""#@"""";@S5 $s) 0(@e"""#KZqDDE]iVteXB $A]$I+I+ 0iL- !l$-0tm(t2~?HbוrldXu#,"007goLב@ƬB;5,wDv;x땖[Q l d XT"…."Hp@fP@ H MBPN@A@N 2n4ϙL"aD`Π@P ax05D "D0$ PPxPixPVBPh5H †A:a@ Ɓ$h6 T*Hm 2)Um`mRaBv= G80@Mƒ%nUIA *x(ADcZ$ 7@I& pa0Yx5I 8xJ| - IK"H4YFa$j))Ң괺oKmIewIHu%kI(U$V]GK%:0t_tY t 3 M $IZm[֩*%O_Ӷ6:4$ұ%dz]%ҳս+^J_ܷ_եڱ%zRI&K>P\i?atai}&bno oO[޺}֋v۴o}?{I Km/m;MY[}߯_} .LpM/Zi~`wo8ɗI&ot[}/l"C^ޛJ_Di6wzJ_6_?קJ7(1OiZ_[i~ZWUNWodn~ddIw]'m/IZzm߅ ltnoIƉ zKy/[_R.I$"Gi%Mz t'm_(iZJ|Sm#F4zC% Wa -GAbDf#Rh(w'iʡT0 @r7DDDDDDDɸҏJ-AV"m̅:ر̪_LdQvy2G 0 &0Oijpך]0P\l@^7IݥF͉;ib轠ph}ګK^*9Fv%FͷHa{\K]uuKjyh zJzI\%N!>0D)3:t hȆ" ņFA ^tdA"rȺ6)Jqa.!Kx48ffLsLYNX_Td!2I\* *AA33ǂSX8A0AT !A A0 !L4A:Dؠ)@&#uB "O ASDզ$8dap8vvN?74_oNoI6Z4Wm M"KI|67nElKw-sA龅 M4@h&{"[IdIC:Vu}Kޛa:VڧIs u6ܻ IIM7׫{z^[ޞuNO]_t7C_ߥOp~ݺ^wҽU߫׻z_zv}Pa1׬{K޾J=z" l>M?}}t*KWak?&/7&ܲyub;%DA~[*aߥz m_"qD[i> 6  _]__oEH!?]^}} }%؅# N~Ѹ6coR~[#K$]<}V/a뾓V[vw]{}k__[Wn^Wݫ^Ko ׯWW~ͭ[n yǟU1W`եcKkif- մTPJ-׿_m/k}:OjұݤP҇{VIR 8m%%iw m/t{#˘_ƭ1YyISJ@V i!(1Q:A QlR !Eh6 H4i&ŰV[iw .5ڈ#ޣ?[aj+5jj&AACM4aPM A@ 40"Ba1QT6(` Q%&i NAC j[0M(l奸 t&\A k #a80j 2P0 p 1a~Fa'l+h  p mUh4I݆S &SQDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDpe)L&k˄ aKh0.,&R4Ah&W&P !f""4?ҤݤK(%L4Z SQeDb?" L.뛕ƋARܩ1J㰹h"n-Sg̙;0PQ6VB Hn-Ġ%auMJQ wLPq…0.kikT[YCȫ %I=8 H>Dpa{ꁷ]!qŻAS dTm|kJuk غu]u'}ݥj_w=wõz~SƗ[=k'}=΂%)3"0๱%8)4yĆD:gFud ΨjA2Vb",.z5'f:t31OB} ~ gƝ /"@`35IY r.H0@ K L ƚ/Hvv XM z&uAޮi&૤`0ThgA0*iMU[azAg@jTMmA|v;j_0CϘpt^Umd4_8|QW[_$-BIn)Lsa"Yd/fFDcr3t3j#QPD>#uD:#kDp8dCG#K:5/Y!3YFhr#ǣR E aMA^&f0PB0A_o 0PO0`z< C0žA E$E#gX,yFRFHN!/< aB a434MiqVa"Ca0*8'ߪ a ziAAa h0Pa d!L ~ |abgƘAA MpUDkEzAؚ4ސ O!F/'YƐl34}N-4^g0a4DDL. PD*h`aUp'h9wEexh0Qh /4`m'}&Kۤ \̓"&khd\e&pOE jYgAAAA:MO'ظox4 tHom&S{MA7MG 76%i_WI&W`4fb0d\ pd\k dpuu6 {Mk:W׺W_ն$j_-'iMӫﾓZ=.=t6ҧZg]|}5[߫~:j==S_wot׽;u}}tOoc_7ﵿ.ۯ ү_ -CXRcm!U/kCw<1/^U{mhF]_rXz^?.&06?/ D?m>u~ _[kPwz0D[^XAz\ua=/$_"Ca}N_7M_A'_.m/6 7z~C]4K {٭~kW? ?Uv-aZa׿gIi.NKTIzIV{HD'إ9?Rw_꽧o1 {~o/6cJ}K龯Iߺ~F{_+]iwa~OiߪWZVo;_$1_P`&[ _V7}ҵ]~i6}0__Kq}u-vv*8JXVIi1]LUݩ~ -Ko@XIn%nk;]' J4mi7CB Ӷմ$ /aL0m1]mVLSI5IX &iA 8A#`i9QX D0b a@@ئ O lSTLm= a$S㻵av0@؅X d#*T  Q6!fM\FYE")B)N;AAS7„((%I.‚઺H!V d4聲Q=k*NBAt1"s@pDǭw^ÑBImZk]W%ٴPAKy HL#i%TA\v+a;>VHE;5#;tfWuA  p@@0PB8S"!A!!"4B\"0(" dT A馉Hi{&rv'mTO/D/'j'7޿uwAZI=:]?zqaBoOװ28_` 0xIi^ O{m lMhH'm&ft>6)[K[պimuI>iҽ\L&G I&zzzo7Wzn֛鮟JS]m^1kƭ?ݼk_OӭU]a/ ׯC5z+1I=/Q U[hh4Lc!KZ ~J]zgx~`h{ ?KoM~'_N !_ᰂo_ a_ᆂzꁿ؅mK_,w/im/(r4;_d$~4U~C^CWdG_Fsk}/w{|77d~ޟïUKV׿~=o_/ۺ޽W_oB-m+mk/zow[~__wߦa VK/i/j_k] ~ok-a>ت-쳾WO`)1%0P)C6D0xS@{NFG )̇d} q^W\:Ƶ yV3α32pΣ:fdxYt3R4„`<4h48*aa) A Bha amS 0A0( f " <ѐǒ:A1O# P Zy@!r7"q ! a | &aM мjv8iB;i*ha4¦THxptHS 3b` 0;PA(L!0Tt$`*h0gM|Kq4Plո mEI/'DxE%KMviƨSi: SL&B'pp蓰dN3Ƌ/蝴_8д4^QvD-Ll& /izMW#82.4'Id\6pnǃ( 1=AtƋ0e]42g/'t_8 N:Mc<)DX2(Nl'v+WJ/{Ol'զ]0n*uptM27i6j2.i餛ozպl!utzzׯzպ[ZKkW~z:ץ믺WM=7kzCQk}G?ο][{I~Zz??M?Mw_Cסz_߂I_rK_KQWz_ArvtX=}Wb -?U_G$u?z WL5 ?a߄J A}K ~7}נҿ uHG4?bG"  6 4]7{ ߯"?܇Ӑ$~$Z0_մ`7O]ּW~o/n[Kuc--/w߾om/+}JwkڿC__6h?W]+_VZ^^yvIn Za/בL0_}-pm%ՆI]n~뫽m-0VXRi_}u&KVSPՎ#=o `^ֵNa+abbwef6հka6V^cb_[N& 0S6#aa4ҦM;iM8㐏B(l0JӺ\5@m&6?bKqQRi݄  *0&A0L0 ME am 領 5WH1a0 ` h8( qA0bӆ))4#d#@L  Ȏ LP `͉+?)80A? a20L ԸL\Υ @— y 2| NԴp̒r7Mk 2+PȃAIL ii dW 'pM{0DDDGHADDDDDDDHl[2""" 30)Lݗ0 a I,t &0DDDDDDDq4"""""""8I}5K4%!!QeS (RN0 4F^#";.u(XI72HdPP̕eh* /PNٕQ-a0\UE‚ -&oA *ps5hb E9cn99Rɦhgj-w?__}몥U_W]}u]UuZ<#C͑&eA)) s3G[ 2aԋΦFC!RG Vr)YΫ ^88 a=0C4A'D<0L0@ ͇8(@0L! hX)0|T.)L `>.lMD8٨GF_3Y3.f XyI3n͌0(4^pd^83Pa"xy# /ᦍN-lAv !D a04Mߦ-AaB` &4! 2S'xnn{i7 tzAVIw"[V=$:N Ot& =E@ 1aÃ&h'3=QxDLN/i6ƋƁBڦH7I_lZ:M\-]ҫd#M-'l z ts4'Il꼏uoWZW&[XMtG &Joztv~ޙ_KZw]i۷_~[}:v龸>ujiխ7}־+x=}zoKz_CaWj1P_#Kbto4A]lu ~K-&3Xֿb/~D$xDV&?'A~/ 7aA?? A$iy#m ۯ %){(_E~CaOm/쑺Y"*/$m<_Hzmu_w7Wx7#D"_^_u߿_龿]k~KK[Ko^Z_wWz_~]p# Aچ~ -cm/%~c ]}l[Izm+i[}q>cU6+]j)b4>Կf?nalǘIRKV+\DŽBí[L444q\S ~#jIX^)m◪iZJ !W{ۯC#b%{h40AT! 0@頁E4@ 0M m;A i2^Zbij{P\u:A h0l&PJaBi<5Ak SP 4 aAiؠ@!C `&aD&iC """"""""""""DZah0t& &¦a4XaEra2aaIA 2 #"%Љ1KkuTj)4RBBC 8"I) 0`d FG"ȂAA L `ZIama?'ĿIAs*ƒTY 0]6I%RVUGM)nOd쇞ȡCDk"26+"J[B"aaBg`  N͌> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im97 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F98 11.90 Tf 111.36 693.36 TD (\(A\) Cost projections were extremely difficult and subject only to very rough estimates.) Tj /F99 10.88 Tf -.24 -14.40 TD (Cost projections were often rounded plus-or-minus 10%.) Tj /F100 8.38 Tf 0.00 -28.32 TD (\(B\) Costs tyically ) Tj /F100 5.00 Tf 95.52 -.24 TD (dropped dramatically over time. ) Tj /F98 5.00 Tf 159.12 -.24 TD (See ) Tj /F98 11.96 Tf 19.92 0.00 TD (CX2747 at 68 ) Tj /F98 15.21 Tf 70.08 0.48 TD (\(RDRA ) Tj /F98 11.62 Tf 51.12 0.00 TD (cost) Tj /F98 11.89 Tf -395.76 -14.16 TD (disadvantage dropping from 80% to 30-) Tj /F99 10.69 Tf 190.56 -.24 TD (40% from 1H99 to 2HOO\).) Tj /F98 12.03 Tf 126.96 4.80 TD (6 As a result) Tj /F98 11.82 Tf 60.96 -4.80 TD (, cost) Tj /F98 11.94 Tf -379.20 -14.16 TD (projections rarely extended over more than 1-) Tj /F100 7.50 Tf 218.64 0.00 TD (2 years.) Tj /F98 12.10 Tf -218.16 -28.56 TD (\(C\) Cost projections vared widely from company to ) Tj /F99 10.76 Tf 253.44 0.00 TD (company; a single company often) Tj /F98 12.10 Tf -253.92 -13.92 TD (presented a wide range of possible outcomes. RX-) Tj /F98 11.84 Tf 245.04 -.24 TD (1525 at 19 \(Rambus Q400 cost gap) Tj /F98 12.74 Tf -244.56 -14.16 TD (scenaros ) Tj /F98 14.44 Tf 47.04 0.00 TD (\(RDRA to ) Tj /F99 10.81 Tf 63.36 0.00 TD (PClOO\) ranging from $8.) Tj /F98 11.68 Tf 120.72 -.24 TD (74 to $19.) Tj /F98 11.37 Tf 48.00 0.00 TD (71\).) Tj /F98 11.78 Tf -315.36 -27.84 TD (In sum) Tj /F98 11.75 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (, Mr. Geilhufe) Tj /F98 12.31 Tf 71.76 0.00 TD (s calculations of unform) Tj /F99 10.72 Tf 119.76 0.00 TD (, static) Tj /F99 10.94 Tf 31.68 0.00 TD (, pennes-) Tj /F98 11.95 Tf 45.84 -.24 TD (per-chip cost differences among) Tj /F98 11.90 Tf -301.92 -27.84 TD (alternatives was completely ) Tj /F99 11.57 Tf 135.12 -.24 TD (irelevant to JEDEC') Tj /F98 12.30 Tf 101.52 0.00 TD (s processes. Tr. 9622 \(") Tj /F98 11.87 Tf 115.92 0.00 TD (I don) Tj /F98 12.03 Tf 28.32 0.00 TD (t even know) Tj /F98 11.97 Tf -381.36 -28.08 TD (whether the questions I was asked to answer were ever asked at JEDEC") Tj /F98 12.03 Tf 348.00 -.24 TD (\); 9674 \(") Tj /F98 11.80 Tf 46.56 0.00 TD (I have no) Tj /F98 11.94 Tf -394.56 -28.08 TD (knowledge of how JEDEC folks did their analysis) Tj /F98 12.54 Tf 244.80 -.24 TD (\). Dr. Rapp) Tj /F98 11.87 Tf 61.20 -.24 TD (s conclusions) Tj /F98 11.72 Tf 64.32 0.24 TD (, relying on Mr.) Tj /F98 11.80 Tf -370.08 -28.56 TD (Geilhufe) Tj /F98 12.00 Tf 45.60 0.24 TD (s numbers to opine on the ") Tj /F98 11.92 Tf 131.52 -.24 TD (but-) Tj /F98 11.73 Tf 19.68 0.00 TD (for) Tj /F98 12.04 Tf 13.68 0.00 TD (" world) Tj /F98 11.91 Tf 36.48 0.00 TD (, are therefore equally flawed and rendered) Tj /F100 7.72 Tf -247.20 -28.32 TD (irrelevant. The factual record establishes that) Tj /F98 11.92 Tf 218.16 -.24 TD (, absent Rambus) Tj /F98 11.93 Tf 83.04 0.00 TD (s deception) Tj /F98 11.91 Tf 54.48 0.00 TD (, JEDEC members) Tj /F98 12.04 Tf -355.68 -28.32 TD (simply would have selected a generally acceptable alternative. ) Tj /F98 11.98 Tf 303.12 -.24 TD (Decision 74 n. 403 \(JEDEC) Tj /F99 10.73 Tf -303.36 -28.08 TD (dropped loop-) Tj /F98 11.89 Tf 66.48 0.00 TD (back clock proposal because of Ram bus patent concerns and pursued alternatives) Tj /F98 11.93 Tf -66.96 -28.32 TD (without any detailed cost comparison\); Tr. 1416-) Tj /F98 11.86 Tf 235.20 -.24 TD (17 \(Sussman\); Tr. 9022-) Tj /F98 11.92 Tf 116.16 0.00 TD (23 \(Prince\); Tr. 6635-) Tj /F98 11.52 Tf -333.12 -28.32 TD (6717) Tj /F98 11.88 Tf 29.76 0.00 TD (6686 \(Lee\); Tr. 5136) Tj /F98 11.64 Tf 106.32 0.00 TD (5146) Tj /F98 11.40 Tf 30.24 0.00 TD (5170) Tj /F98 11.96 Tf 29.52 0.00 TD (5187 \(Kellogg\); CX2107 at 137 \(Oh\); CX2058 at) Tj /F98 11.66 Tf -213.84 -28.32 TD (371-) Tj /F98 11.53 Tf 39.36 0.24 TD (440-) Tj /F99 10.94 Tf 21.60 -.24 TD (41 \(Meyer\).) Tj /F98 5.00 Tf 10.56 -43.68 TD (Cf ) Tj /F98 12.14 Tf 16.56 0.24 TD (Decision 95 \(") Tj /F98 11.82 Tf 70.56 0.00 TD (Rapp) Tj /F98 11.79 Tf 29.76 -.24 TD (s calculations) Tj /F98 11.90 Tf 64.56 0.00 TD (, like Geilhufe) Tj /F98 11.89 Tf 72.96 -.24 TD (s estimates) Tj /F98 11.80 Tf 52.56 0.24 TD (, wholly ignore) Tj /F98 11.95 Tf -378.72 -14.16 TD (several possibilities for cost reductions from adoption of the alternative technologies.) Tj /F98 12.00 Tf 71.04 -26.40 TD (Dr. McAfee \(who unlike Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. Rapp studied the record) Tj /F98 11.97 Tf -71.04 -14.16 TD (extensively\) explained that JEDEC members followed a decision-making process known as) Tj /F98 11.56 Tf 5.28 -14.40 TD (satisficing.) Tj /F100 8.55 Tf 51.36 0.00 TD (" Because of ) Tj /F98 11.98 Tf 66.72 0.00 TD (the many uncertainties involved) Tj /F98 11.67 Tf 153.84 -.24 TD (, time-) Tj /F98 11.98 Tf 30.96 0.00 TD (to-market concerns and the) Tj /F98 11.93 Tf -308.64 -13.92 TD (importance of reaching consensus) Tj /F99 10.93 Tf 162.72 -.24 TD (, JEDEC members did not try to conduct detailed comparsons) Tj /F98 11.91 Tf -162.72 -13.92 TD (of each set of alternatives to identify the very best) Tj /F98 11.95 Tf 238.32 -.24 TD (, but rather settled on an acceptable) Tj /F98 12.15 Tf -238.32 -14.16 TD (compromise and moved on. Tr. 7255-) Tj /F98 10.95 Tf 184.56 0.00 TD (56.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000599863 00000 n 0000599922 00000 n 94 7 0000600086 00000 n 0000600250 00000 n 0000651892 00000 n 0000600782 00000 n 0000600399 00000 n 0000600528 00000 n 0000600655 00000 n trailer << /Size 101 /Prev 599536 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 657514 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000718817>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R ] /Count 15 >> endobj 101 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 102 0 R /Contents 103 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 102 0 obj << /XObject << /Im104 104 0 R>> /Font << /F105 105 0 R /F106 106 0 R /F107 107 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 105 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F105 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 106 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F106 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 107 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F107 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 104 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im104 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 52789 >> stream ? << 5kXR1 :MvSG,赕Sd10"n S(k!̭ʳX쑐q\% vf!\TSN5vvA}U.@4v̠f ;#pU]SImNI?U0iW[JZZ֒}jX--%UUWZ {Ҫ_ `dk3Vz'y̌TAR*4 0A P&xPvxf^$ Hge#)A5!SF#D1c̣33U>x JⷓIe+*h J5b8HD7gyNgL"N8DˋA j40 jAjA0A 0@L0@vuт Hњ2@2@G`?0(& 3b=A00 !.I|Yyt.'oT]/N*.N&*$;BDxLBPBBCPCCP&U\&/Jۣ=x-h]ANf֜]&NpoINA\PdT@ɊJ>Pٷ6.$FthwZWOOIz]OKZ^/ҽ]j-*}'JI -*uKKI}Titk]WI)kJ] _K괴$nj_K]Rm]z_Ijw J+%ZKX]_R*}.IWBiJ c U^htW%D|RoI[*KR[FUzK]/XҥuZ]URUuTIizI%T]Uz64$B--Um*ziiku%ƕ.֒U7-^ҥUZTm-/*Uti]$^G+KoI}*mz_MT꾾Wu_KA*j֪k_~o-*ZXA.%Ҥ]RU|A%KU^UȐZVU*^ߪ}j:RbUIUUm/]`ZW-u:^W?7tIjOgk/KWKZī*MW[}*ZUTGI/H^}UkTUֵIzSүS|[7]*tF?Կie0* J+(z]tчj>޲KzZZuo6m$W]%]R*ZZI*MuԽ+^Z/K˯R_{]L/Z/c/ZoэR/aҰm/TҭoTҴaki_UUK^RxHZ]#J-KUIk֩RM0&JQL0JҪ&'uiiqZ]6TTSiETUX⩰AZUa.KJ=t;IU-zmt j0]-JчՅU>ZBH/bTSV U/a*a*K**Zm**)j*) wQ8␨b-EEqHU EEa(qVRj ERiZ aL0_HBa0I1 M5 ꪘHWLWW JjꐪbTIR %U1 DDDDe!`0Va SUL&L& a gU0T&jMBaUBaT 0.AjB""""""""""""""""""!,`A`Z JB `A """ DDDDDDFDDDDDDZ֗IWA*JUramGc4\b!%(X&DwW`CT)nb2&L3-;)g`i"d+ma([ /a>][;̇Bࠡ}U}&vT+]r3el>Ksgt`v ~K^]ZmkXK^ҪjFԍdD~5YȄkfR   2qHa #AI);8ΤPf3B0(>{# Fm3arM ^t#pr%Fa$HyFuL3gCF2\y Y:#pΙ : IINv"y{'I&76Nz AI6pe`ȸ&ItA:A- ޒ .id\ܸ"|ߧpjAVGM}n!wU֯ [ҿo}zat%D_MаVJr0z~5X'Wuz_{1J:BSWuCj(/,vEu/' Bcc??| ,N>]1_:o _]oD㶿z,FXҖ%_ |JXN/a_]aaD=?^z^/ omoJ/O ,7~/^Zk/8/׭my!y d?k!k솲GY-#i}zi/?߾~_[jctq?Wu/1_ߥ_u^_wHuo}߽_o`_|0\jai:O[}_J{Kn+W]/j]0@*մ! *Yz)YV.ަM|5޶׵׵um~ս/Ҽo:0j3ըi18׈mCҰaXCVElWݥ~c |0L\RKf65&GxO4S@!A;dHZmU-ÏL88kJ[iAI~V66)bb*iZ{L}5k~0>Hi@Mr$*h0@5 ` j!6(6)QIժӭ6Avڿ!$& TC 0„^a}R&A4a*h0@biبs 4A ! l:h 6Dh<`>"""|DՑ! WpTaa@a0K®M{UPԘSO w 8atƺ^0I08iXLT4Դ'&KAni6$2+ (ØBB3# -˨CPPT z&LQL3x=PaaV[ M/a5pA A!A"bk!GL50 š 馁ZXTA" (U-P(foQT-t(-EQ̀erd/'t$DR2:l0 nf3- 6-D ?;;LNBA>ӣhDeXD&U8X¦@酖ER:" $j`  ppl@& H5DHa0 "vwM&% Mh*I$__1X:M'%m/I$I s I /I$UN]ku-d["~ZtjM@g)Ϣ#qүo D"+"q d~]ԊrZt"5EЋdc"k5BAȜΈFY:PiWtpk„ 0P S00XC0 MI &!!(e8rLʱ #IC26lyO/֖mflgAt_=&;&rvy"-&5$$; L*i&2E0T„͊g0TN <(A'_H#n?੄=MH OR,PAl=!hv4_||ؙh4_4_$^R3'm 'm ptMDhL*@j:]mSD㎟Ii6ة6 ˺V .i^:VxH6pdKi: twt&MA3Eڒut0W [^KznIy]-MӲ8_z OM"&ό> .:5>|>t$C괿m~]u^Wt;ֽ7[z÷֒M ЏJ=C:j/ߦI/^io&֛8XK+FQXc Z:Iu]_?avvz'_XjMG7,?'^__cKuHu[B?.avXX?kt8KpB:A?w$?e(oD A{k+xGH_  ץ-nw#rF<;$y#å kzSIzW?/{uox9:_?!o]/ZKm7_kjmaKI.$M_mJJ_u_"F>"zWaAK-ݘMIm{/}unI%Um-'տoW[lSh;_bxa&+ᄘ[)WaՆV=It I7_,vk[.)= v}^WWVEuu{hUX‘ﴺmP %i+il4ktm" p h8  j}Ma(pm_Jiji,PII 0ٻ'aS #TӄNIAMj!M `i@ lt`bAyP"bVa L(2na3r0͐a,{&aa2&S…]ErKL)h ըA; BMPҦAL5A' ("""""""""""""80B"U0SL0O)n?lLw?g =?–408a L :fdtDDDDDDDqmᾖ}]6PVp,QZU3x0(PeTkB2̮I2'(P}h# ݒTD2ELj.2qHrHpP„A,U2 O;,S˄LUMS|*&SP,#1L(DBӕ BoD {i6h`M|7VΒ}QWE/\޾p{k޺]a_u}O xC1N i<Ƌ'M UqMBRiI,i7 )Bjt0PgN[27~D2$Rttm[Γ/℅wDpARU?鴵N'lЍ˨2c5]v]l&Poi:N|OȸwApdKpAmbgr;ItBh}m.$N\'%_֮ӤݤP0=6tߧ0 eè(O$ֿz!+{kum[׭KR_^} ,1j_oG%z<޷%o׺!a!}.=_u?G\G\B7m->W¤m%° я_ot+c"}V1XЋ]ybjc<ɐ`o`LkSy_N]}_VdI7/lAV%67 vz_IzMm?^{mUt.AA !TpC ( PA t6:6inҫVa4+X=c ›itװ7jȃ && A 0h0@ mS!Q@ &0AlVxL :p@ a4"""""!`# hLNfd~(Sh1 xa^ VjiI0&M4MuAa!DF  H6g8-Աʌ >L)7Za0M3T0LeQ0R25=_"""""""8k~YTJ 4 jB`+LRUa0 1l(S@("?pMLx[ඃ R3dY)p8D ȊLu!* aa 3X! & !B-5( ʪ%7 a p h0A!؃rYd42[{xEE󤂤 DEDJMUX4[ 2)ITI¤&AO*MDA ?t{H]zRW6M=-%Wn`I3T*NmB63+Ѩy⓫]>چ{JMIj?Vƿ^/]U$[5ۿ}^! $PM9:|(3)IG8=on5a P!U@4ik]G`P֚'PgCT D{Ӧ=*^m/ A 830`M!Rl$ %!Hf! 3!Qx!IlS"sc!#c: ='3|v'#ED-;_OIm'ϊN`1@A70SA& &fOfS 7M!7M!i=]Sio &97h0'oDizUM4Na a(2T֓lJ+H/H_EwWLVAr >q>r 鸺EE^QCeF)6GQV)B62l(DdMR!88 aA6p 4fCtXp愐m x4^Ԏ-6]maPa0IAS6(L &h0T31A(MMa =0TN Qd g]k&].mqI'Tk^V=_ޗkkz'_?%vz5b%T{Woo zO׊_lI?{ץqoKm %}_Xൽ/[TRF;d|/^ $_B!?T!i=tO7AKK)M_.~KTKI%W[ҵ[_߽I?эp{[_ as~yIUnmI$]]ZT߶k׷_WU"bب {IBKƖ餒QN *M %4m{ -wL0 zw!G5ǭK+I[I&҆ K{t1Kڱ{T6i}!a_6TL&jA Aj 0IV0A0PA  I*[զ8޾m/8U E\k+I*;4Y'׵ 4—oտ5$*b <fb5IbhS@ AruUA7i ( qTi3d#`t= ` 0PB"HH8 g@„an(,4h5 4aM5M0bIpAM:XMpAjMڰZ":B""""",ب@qrn0L0L 0]?@4C ee3&D0 a  qgltiz؈"""""""""""""""""""""""*"""* I'/mIR~,$J$am,RH&*Xa UQVBݍ0: (c (,E*8(P $L);gfxʙ)FJ#AAB(* B @PB 0z Pjd '3"K KshR TEV]]QnV郪(0y#{d$;pIpps.2I &hfE̬Kommqv{j_u/޿꾷͌)C A<_}k\&A uG3?3q!J4uM pH5 a5om,  ! 4E- )MCL#A5Sg:Y )B3 Ds3^0T͢IaDhTǽ*&t~450T ;Ќ <B lUL੄z M$^Hm.4_twV*yDp-v;!UTNڦv'=ÅTHv4<&;S [{_׵j%U}}5;~K[$=]^j.J'__~ ˯Y_1'r] .1c_?\|B-W'/n-pɍvZ/ _`_c??_(XDk>z_~/__^~r_$"q;4^-n vB넿 w%x}-G-#K+_A O_g߯{{OK$^yy#$_"GE{zo_7]kkߥM~ߤ~ҰRMP\uߥi}ik_v}մmb66!Z{Mim +kvHiX^a 7_alavվ /_if8A G\Tm1E[ . p]zVMA2!5iE6LvW_*a{qZ|U{Kh6ӇUkj 2#M4Q60A 4MxiC 4 DՎj'5i8ᠯ؊5؜pvh(Ҷ %mEXI.? a4L M4"$4&ID ń "dGLBijiich1A@(A%6A q@ S$Z""""""""tDBH0Ax80`<$ C8a4 B P[" j*iM&j 64RQiMXZ[2+u-0"""""""""""" A#%`GF ‚h03^\ j]k| L Ÿ0 !da`!k"""*4,ҖT=tja(a(D-*W? ,gD Z̦eN;S;,! <* ƈL")/iq8Bd%i[(.vCf2 Bd%f2]fEXT®E2:A `h\}E `hO!FB'Ý %?\E_L^2grAˍ+ѐx0DAQG)ޝ!m'ɜ<lk]7m'֟~O߯|wǯIGAT)dkxLeO)K>ܐoUo_xA .0CDa\x)O@ pd` >?%lfHd|eΙ̉U䅾QHΙћDXY:(=0Mt*h=PzpTI&00C, " a glR0Bl>/~F3b"% >"`` !a ! 20)A(\_ȦԫD擮DD4]4Na4$; iC *` 0*A ASL Pi4͈P8"jྜྷiA7I6|MH6 Zv'bX^4N'l"xд_eU0d]Fp0ANꡠjqPŢp㓌ǴL%Ja&Rk?%n6׃E MIr6` 8}bg^3q-ѴlA8I}j&7,& OUr8_OJq]&paۥAYG4l%wߦ_uzҭKzm[z{oz~aVi|m~Nm wG&koۭku뤺(/+kx1okד?#.x(Yde_,N4,CT^ZZi {M/߫_Y:D[e rX>2f _//^M+}G{Du!_߽ K//qoK'}wH{$_E?k} [uzb^r"O9${.K_j$_NvlTY#U%_Z_}]ozFUX_mo{_ܗtJ[V_.ק_+/lRHpa'[1[ %[a^2nuKoEikukyɺ][^C@)ӊ JXVئMׯ0\4j?]%Vҿa0 }k . m6Z;_%a&I^)u&Kk k-Lk"B0@ PbAS!aj4 B 20I:iWjWJLGz @̈́-4aK,VՓRnqᅰxi\iZm{P]H I1 m4 aA :h<6y2@eA0@ a4V 8 xA |DDDDDDDAjJj^ a4&3]&2,ArAAA+׵! $0a\,5Zj uD0@ 0M4a3nLpR3 a3g܃+) 0BHgH"І24 :B#"""""T!DDDGꐫZZerI*ZE$dW%hVtߡaՅ=D0Dd2#;;2Ŕa0i&vL̅Ȭ;x)٨[0dETeXquᇯ aBI̒n[tHvtJ.'u80{FC!2I>vV$$Oe *'{-.*PP:VZ 6gz_ҫuW_^ۂ)I0rȥȼBYzl.4Φj3UT[UQ  І &!" p)O2pP=͌!&<)DlC53aXdz mYtgĂ5F; M4=;A}xVVz|a&ύۤx2+I_>3Ża6{Ӥ%dx~JpJ-߿I+IzNOkB=tz^+{z\mU{u_W[M{_^ }6>-IvرսгܴѳҖ#rгڳ鮟K'&[a_ֻ}/y}11J>_Nm!W[v~ku?%]}ȏ&WݥW֕mSzjA՗JԺ]-&0>Һm-6=+.\%X⡂QIjB C 0jժ^AmPi,!S0 Apa&p L&RiA0A!4uDDC 0La2>pA' >N5Dٶٶٱ6""""""*KKU][__Үd Pzd R90)Dzt#3P3F"5Ufc :2!zϘw0PT`h4=x@0`4A 3C ΂cq\얤T du"D`ȣ8yԎqQ$GS5gHEu~"wU A$&> Mp03bB  AA0@¦p B  L 200 (Aނ On оh w;ag.'J' 2@"NSM5VSDPE UA (LcMpE 7IzI[h O H6AA'A&"[_%Neh'Dh8 g'l$ cDŧ~i'KWI_~όம tyA88;(r": !@OBD:PAd$ I~zm-.ҿmZ7u}8vJ&odpL' m-mk[v?_]>:OC5_]?Bt ~^: 4kmX_uu`/T}}¦ydGu|Zb>_~t""_җ_bpUZӰsW_/WJ8kG 蘏㷠E$__/ۯ^H|۲  GWd͠el|WT]W?_wmV_uo["iZݤߥ}i{_ث f6q /pkk +uuf{ծ _[k6@j W6+v)6)NӴ KڷY/ 7_齫@@s 4[j-JI6IpkmQ^JP"a h`hl頁AbA t6N-׆a+]aM:NYj a2P3릚 2+^[MdWaBiiRp-S N2, Aa4 a `"  `@@" 2$ b"""""""""""!$b ̜&"^#0 ‚d]4ʀi\a5}}SVZuDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDYA (0ex@ +(DDDDDDr)QC@qc"qnY…+M2nW T[(\H6$"Α2"0H- ń*8A [ #&A$Y\r2TȖԟ'l '"X$;Lph'@IXM-}߭մz%ebS]/]WM</ZK]].m/D.z_몮tC6GȆ)!#Hc5 &]3r(gL'ȖRꯨ[]iW$0  дE' `DA 2Jd|A8A&D0EԋxCA9̇9=Ð} Ihjm š#5'l*qOw0*i0O=Pa`85a` hH@ Af`m$#.ا 0d0p$! `!bgNŻMvַ_}?MNSw 1QWCHZk uaLg__/ 1I Uki1'`':a8uu ྿bI˯Ö/A?_J?ᑿ}&<.?_a w8ޭzX= D?a A&/A0ἑ]<>^7UW﷥ỿ/{/W_]} oE_}$y#m}z_k_aյ|믥ik%_{uma0WUj]x"ֽ~M~V"=l +c5SzzP6 kڗ?$4/06aoͭ+ᄡVjaAQ{LTL;Z$լ4>"llqqqU l!ƭKjm$6ZLS m.' jATT uA:@ < b(香m10KpN uSLAMi;ZPkfrǰaj W5 JA6 iPB8M4!P @ؠ Ȩ8 A0@aAbi0i*)h1QOg0F:a3,)7A.-aB 5AAamaBk %{MF!& wڄm4ȃjAaBj"""""""""""""""""!aa`t'ͩ5eA NaOx`&a304j&DDDDDDDDY[Tn{xO+]&[P0e!e,ϙuCȖU&[SOM0Ji T0DaLHda/ETLw݂` `:̊ROxPaAL Htݯwx$䀉Ai {BBa0vmISJu>jI$RT]WrtI$0tk[~%U%*UJJ$ ?Dh鞂K*XCAаP2@PDz9 Ƃs"hk%dȪ \E- Lfk"mcAu3FtF:磮uf$-WCxA4 X4i(N xA*ah00 ` " A.lgAO>)8C Љh2#:!ٛ^}U%!)'"DaA;hÇUMoLߪaU4NI7p OL& L*ixTˆ; *a i!`M0O=?T&\aPth+w'= q5r\qjqӋENI'mTx58Ń#N9!iIL*i!ރt踹qTKqu Lji g8["[|ّa8(- pC  L;Ei ^>^8:' ~!q\hH4=kuWMЭ:[ td+zM¬a6#I8: oI_^Ȏ|D"þE"M kTV}S]7] O/M[O7imޓr8KtI?'ҽx&߂mu^ug==]?W[m =_ ߻kMt۪Jַ/aVGTVmokzakN~kOMqk?\Bm_1W#]_/V`-~?_Xo&0=/_z{}kuww3@ do_2Lg u xD_Kk/\K%H 9E|Ky ____/ќKOk$a>o_^C?ou/).)/ү]/!/KXikkޓPKSk[ۯ_au_K_iz[iU:vַioD% W~Puڶa~ͯwxk_ޒaZ]LL8^_mlSua5*[Oخ$`/—tMMivV1MTA : mElRilLxi4KjJDz +6+Mv*حma1w !Zi6i:Ait\27,aKφj l0@ 6)@أ@v a m!\S!Z;[[W1{ 4 aTڦ#E0+gh#s<0v{PXkiXMWMaH&(A]8 m =S"B 6Dt\#(b mmDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDJ|Dd 0iƂԙ ˜^ / kiZ§ $0An0 'DDDDDqDNDDDDDD .=-.I$]&HP"A'$Pm DEj;E)…tWZT @f@d4i2KUB 0Pnt "zȳd%I9]"[vi';(NZmagjo[{{juׯU=uK咫u׿sTCB ## 03(TDI=^a} C0303’b_3 Dr.hk.d 4L ud|"Al&f=f5tNq&rn;h==4`!a0a: B σ (LgBH͏h' AN  7^jwUv!2N a5pW3O3„ۯOizM܋?&M47'A_4_$N'2c([);qv'_&}ޱa0a?O"IGi7O@b1IÉMm' M*o^O\E~ׅO/hRn}IJ„lOz藍KޛW_]N}&k🧡믊I_W~o[i,8iWK*5p޿k ÿ_쏗^`&9:8__/B;݃~,7&?{%]m'J/%}m!^/ ޿֗_^H5m^m_.|7i7__]׷JE;a~mZO]w_~SkZ.齮+SmZ}տcj6)AZLv~_(_a5`Zn+l%jf?0kn> h6)ǧ aI 88WbizC_BM68TLU2#@ 2@$$^  aGTY駐tqM1HtjjKM. (ler ‚  ~ 4ڄTT‚0j0  @0@頃b&(t"ezeM4H< APh0M/k]Za*-ˡF"" 0^ɕe:""""") zRRj;eB;D#)d,   juHLaE#;+ (PBilȥ PcE(PPPe]}p~.$`3;,DV͔>_'p{ FhfEeO_ZO_"0y.͌)H$g)| yǝ)O8fDty%jKxL&k&`a O A=CB 30ǒ !$ t)H3pDDFhyў2DC:gY3lyV3PDj"Fp!E OR=HɑP]: jFn 蝽Q?b@vAUVkwW u-`` /iR0KK1_V<&GEBs6Dt ؤMXᄭna&-[JQ /bӴAUC11$nQxkN2+M6A 0D# 6 `bb SmX jBlR 6Vӻkb mZQliD0Aa3er,{# K*ZidW,l M6m\8h9 lph5L`MB0@ mDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDB 0HRvaʄA©7A,t_akaBVL)nj0a5ӆ|DE 8>(B""$4#t?kJ:*KҪj-5a+ Y j&lBXAԵ 0I "M6!,Upg5k2$S2KfHdC`\*es L 'C+;d$vҜ0a 桖d *" B j aB),"ƺ0IT v$B7Ap2Hz'l"4;ID|a_׆kNGN&UH l0Y]N;!Yǭl%//I*Mѓȡڹ{k[t$:]$m*zo&/_~k$:WUw~2LjC eH3pfCͳ30:gOd(vuϬƘ[];_^XC*  *a L `3œ`A&\XCJx4{_$d 3W6Rt0|ԋhsq!Ϣ1/_tN)Pi5 I(M0S0NbLsi~DO! 5d$E.0R@``_"a 0BA{Hnh{Ҡx<4]8vL"yTDLO#%4U~#xOPUT0TնS L'[렛ԗ-8Kq4wb[ׂmy}iRމa 0 M2N;'pH0;p;h4N!PQ(sa%IWNlW\XN  o~'>22(||Z_oH;Na)>vwIA7A&'3kow޵zkݧuߒ7UMץ:Of]+~6pGKw׽O_zM{{ -ֿo^hR&/? kVmoIo׆_ Eq>-6_O[_v__^mXb }z[_wۯ__/,EG~6^K/X0}Ԙ𿭴YmN:I}/_oҮ/ ovahDv*ob! w ~_OA/~^]_HoS}$K=ׇj Նa~__߯A?_k_^!$^S݇v_׭_oI߽{uW~%N*DZ %ߦ]k^kws!-ki_}-_Uk olmK!a>¦ZVt4=r/مkMNot_{ .a~mK'@;`cj $J>;;؊bmWi_UWM}]6+vwLiXAi[N[qMP@ mȎ  lC \Bi@@aU\0Zn ;S|Cx4{ 0`þb88d]5" ͢p{ ԓkl&MMUBDTS$bP#]u ru oAlV0@TMr{DDDDDDDE#  TаB0&yaaOS5nmiL&DpIDjXB#iA6*+jMeNM a4aA2` `"&p0 aHZK 5]ҨMa"&a(M% &0l&8D0ZjD>?Ey٦I((TdUQdڬl(S%A2bܲ$Z -P(. [RaL3 "&drBJo,v !,* &Ae8;D4>0<hE`K+r;͔?s$P)L &5u{TZ `d2h ȑ"G_ޟu֕_'߫k}-z%͌)V!"6GA__ױZ axi„- Bq ."AFC pg$dA!|τ"#IgQ3Gl u i^L+'FO' M4NT'i_L'3=p_ v aN`5Bа`J" Cf)V D4K{0 L3:F@in{/_߯/_Z׿A?a(0$|/> A.'KpG'Շ?]H/_z[/A{/zw?Vk֒X7H/v/ [~޾9_m#<>}Kz_Ozok|wkZ k-տmvZv#R/ͭ[kV7_??m-l!zm7Va2?}Se浍Rڗ1ﴽIֺ_i [3=7Z@d(i:0IC݃Gi1_QPI`ֽ^m^<*}ZU 0AȐ qT0A#h1U[!EamS 4+VXa( .ڈP0Ioa-nՈ;b nQL0V &^U㄰[MAD 骦0Uh`G@P@0@:6( m4թ8ebTɀAA6+cb"""""#B"PDEPA? a4&8Sei- OZVj8A E*ȎDpIi\FDDDDDDDDDE,DDDDDT <D= HAO-a0L&'A30&ʝW 023 ( *_Ј1IutY h dPKQ68\&TiEհ" (Z<2PLʌ Hȣ*vQg\`* ih>pPOM[bv6*vjYj 4?ᶾ;.fB72fnӥN;jI^ȁIffȑ ]"O =]mA>K$/nxo //~yj뿿O_—iiZamyNvK8w9k~­L'Twjޱ0V]A0 na !GlthU Ia{ L&uTDDEtb$'T & {lI02j7gpij""""8=-RZTTdU -%KP`T)-1 -5TTJ"L(Q Q5[Ej?;ePl앲[2"E "&erl d&wSlZ%'¦ <.Bgi ia4 /ݨ.kP (-?'t}  PoNbIQN^;_AuE7raPr ;ehEq?wzkj8_ᚌ3DD5k !af!`1 "DP㇝u34366%-OqdC_͊M03@ g 0A( `0 "T0A<)C00' : Y"8f T .C("͡D]AvKB%z/Et]pꨐ"nރ¨P0T5 I0TLN u5 |0aB !3AiA&f L B ]-  h AE'(O:9]O;h.4NńNv` 7I*kU ID$T4NU &iz[dpIڑ3j`6!H6|St7V 'Aq3rO=7/j% D} oE4^Q;i;qh0dˋE_ӫ};\…7Zpw%putMM82.R[O oI1M:M0N|g&Gt۫}}4O=:OT]; tjoIN={_8c_߯I鯯I߯_zZ~jФ:]Z[W省}]JRK_vݴl0ZW_k{zWkTWW_}ZTMbKm//>a{~mi7;_K]wK_5aXi10ҿNӈ/b)tҎ+m6?Կߧ{ + _ᅴ __{ .keIC j)UoQLQ" 4h4cAbMuaVV.j0;Վ#ئ #XuՊb+a|04ԝ55`A`A A ȐmAȎA x :0@ikV4⚤ڐӪM0 = ATDD eMRǾ(pL~]>a5 p a5l94+M0il0`AMB"Bh A44„ L43 Ba aKtɿ &Gi ; Xa>ʀ P7ˈa4 ˆ!P,(YɰvΈe eK2%d0Ca!DPH;́D B  RH((- B>Dz'o ۠^S i˙9MZ U pvPymȏ-%s`\FH2\չQofzo֓uIKUk}}WJF9HfjfRB9i~T `Z E ]2E2. "Kj^گwZzxW4&nKӤO'< MV*c}}{Mߵk]>=?t?C= >]=x꿰˄4|K][]We_پ.iKu}m{(G^+}_@ dW_ɎEuץ!5 ƗkHG#%a ~_"O}k!Ju"Q7 ?!5d߿*o/ o[/Kld4?!$,7u[J/K_O/|;Zy>Im.}*Ҵ+u{RJյ o>~CץK_KKK.h-oiZKԆi +a&Uj 5[__K׵_WM0[cpu tB nVa=;ObB0_l("5v]zL^^Ka@@a+NO RqOjL4aݱإO@|Wi6wQ|AF055mI0d a0SA @Ajb < m mL a'NVn5'wm5ôN6*ᄙ =d#iIJ"""i @ >l' aKdW/; ZUA h` 0!4P A00A lS@' +jړ a0i au “}aL(,5 & |AEDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDFDDDDDDD~)BDn\X,H튓 왦F&ʙ;;i;Xe|I^‚L ;/dMVgQS H6v (PzPڀ_C Ip ~x^p-'hlM$A I>BFIP8;Dm4I2`!%Gwiӯu]!C5=ȉk_oh0 );6AO#gX$1g<Ιг8d@^t3Y)I2# Zi0<*a0PA0A `8fA@ `Dd!  ;4f$3r63tD?B= 0z)'?E9A<)D;$D1K*tf)H3l!"A7?^2/v;jh5M5W] Mj'MTapPTАP BPO@@@ `pPa 04%B)iψ`! E,t7IsE4j-Q;qŢwDvDy4N &U4N Ox(AL L"OAMMAվI0G&`ȹ􃙃R(PPR'D(S! 3xT̖نW W((*@pٙSḏTT C'"8d8)C8 ٲ: QgZ'JNJSM M4N#' ph0t*a=4; AACa`B`n@ gk @g3M"A ᎛LtŤhxED&D&ႦapATa4"(0MQ8[T HxTT'uNa\L 7:MvI4Id\t3A6A@Z//q֋iŠ;_7ibaq}IzMtVZ p}zKWnh'Euwtm>3Ɩ`T$0lޫ_^'N6i}]644ۤ^_^tޭuk?~]^w~t_cGоJy}oIWm+C:ki|3zOHG=k?/Ӗ#.蛑\*\- nvw9U~8Ma޺0tX= U aD> ҭ zm/$ d5 Wm}$oax7Qi;Gn!؅doޛ_wOZ)/J(pҮ}^߫[I^鴻^X+ѓݶ6iuJ^ҿ~յZ׽K[_UZW{‘ %ua(if m\Kk׾ vV#OV?m& ئMm+0I V UaK~Uu! ? `j6L 0ƘOaᄢgKi*caڱQISn Rvj4P & * 2 &)8bj 4i[^'l\ O V[A0h ?!GD0L p sd v&S a@[Ai BM p@ڪdH@ A0 aqRH & )74 -^N(OA)5G:!f.!6XMKqDDDDDDDDDDqQHDDDDDG/I*_[6&FCJI) ա[6Aʈ f[GtPv"*m0P+2ge(ʙEZx.d(av&Rh3 'i 馚jP {DKEP WÊETq+xa$ɮ6 O.(o)fFD'Yƍ'L|E}Kc~_פu_庠C:D0鞍fS{ ^aa а `pd ћ"L\6!r<32:G%Ⱥ!:<$vHc FS^z'HQI _^;L&`v L&>ྙN aFd CP,!`4A2|(A 0PA  3œ N G fc5)՚%h"Vts5(GQd3QqNY[ In; Zlu.o]/Iz M 'A7 {[30dK`ddyIpCH6,SYo}6_[/W[TPzpz~d&鴛dt_A'j8k=?V}Үh}j}}{}u7]5W<+]G_}]mnIo߅b> z_5aj:V?}ֵ]0N:b/%ݤA}N;_'H"oD//I^$CI.o;ۯ-/(t>I/!m K]Aouzmcc/%ݯ/G~Co+H^uҿׯb]mu/!Oi|4J[//m}Uz}Gj 0msVa+m*t_մK￿qQWQC_ _a^Կ0?jz/-׆imMU5i5[ziElz]a}2?]"cᥘ  ~#e j*0@jh 0AZ ڧn=Si %lL85:Uڪcح;_iL a5^ 'Ӥ4dXB 6` @S@h ` H  ` 0@0Q鴛LlJ+i׾S[*iU᠓m%"""""!tQ20L&aM5) ڴ ^?aA,[T„6p":jA T ` `@0A m @ȎA6(DD`hC a0Na ]'vȎ { Xa>a QDDDDDŎP!DDDDDDDhӨ_Ir/%k qBŠ?Z * ,D+236eHZv*SQ /a11M)hhyؾJ !^E0P!P)0fD73R+9Idi)""0pWM %4*NL B ,a20i a_,!>'B:MCH!APT]4n&A\*u]%A;PA-.*6 m& (A*KN/U4RWKItn1%iRV u;:-ޗsa w{tRhU}\tBޓb$BZVWk%]uYnSTit_U%ݤD!Ba N."-r@d.a2=MŒҡ&^u0Ti0CAA(@AIEm(Q)Hǧ@_)Dc;aMvv H*L*jDaMSnu3œdQf ˳Fq#͔Z<Τb:}ABsD?B ub{h h n:A/EU] za<@Bj  L&5N1u/&pE.(*h OM@ȶs"[>)Š^Sh(D񥴨"VPނV%oT]"pT aW_8yEkPOO FC=~yOT?F44JItA7)Kmzצu_ҠI}tg>])ij|?׿\}V \}=rcZIkמKn%3KKUKJiBoy'k0Tzq֗QCJUkKKoZ/ɨOT/-/ꫭJy?֝ao~%_tVB*JimS cD_UZZKJ$JT{mwiw߿M/_`뮪_AW[~#J ˸2poߧ-kK-V_J_Z%k_9$U}R^jj&"iz-&6.*I:T~WRI_VnRZ]VGM-/=?ioe{R}[_ޑKUikTT~K[$/VyޒF? ,VOi|WkхYEI$Q7]]bJ$!!W{yM굪֮Q6Կ]kKTc1꩞zKVNjUzin +_n5%JMm-UiUUmWJ­A$)>zYӦJi'f5;! mqMLUIlBMu^*%`]l0bqkE6Zh)a%tCKM5A\KKA$0| l(Ij(aaA &ꖘ1JDu28I}TRP*)&Ұkv %~a&PI[`A\L Md5XkڪZ0&؄®am5L(\%bX $a A0""8a `0Aa0a00 * ! aSp k*viDDDDDDDDDDDD0SXM30j N 0PRb2VVDDDDIxDDDEIDEC$nUI&nҧIa(A & |XMl(6W"#ɾ[-FBYnbE(츇##c;E d kTڲPr@b@丆qkhDqh9nJgAWO֨0[d\3JÂ"TD!"aI 3XuK2\Š82=Hh P`+ꚠjj Amת ڤA6i*vO'mntvkOUO$餂mh*M$=WϤ/tdI_Wm 鿥N1Zvۥ.z{kt^RJ]/ ;чO*[iu^ׯ麿.;S5 tYЈyiGW둽/_t ~AikmUA5T ؠqB 5!xRx8gAf8ԌGA4d fqd27f/j$AzwOCU'K)qiAMKhi!i&w1O_MVyDZZ/)҃/%x(DVB.'tJ!F{pmtz<%A6jI]$&t,5Ih+Z@ Y {֗N3^w0KzJxFZJgK%*Fz AEIԊֿ]!-.$ZMRBҭWZZU]t$Zoz _]$QJzZIE )$mkCZKZZJ+Uץk]7~u__I*]*Z^AZKZ---R֓ZRM7[WoI﮶՝J%UIz/ҭz ~ Z=./~}MaI~+f% %ZUZ_ZIVuKJ%'D1MJZz_UKI.,_~֩.7dl0F]z@zTkijWnR/I^4Sƅ+%KIפu4IVU`Uzվ3w-k]WI%T\WZPפkLe*JVi/I~葉utuתK_۪_zKKҥүi]eQ 5I.K]_YJKU֒I&Er~J-U,*ZzMnǥVteQfaVQ[Sҥ,KJTN}vW ZUZKKE)]iuzZEH/ ZKI$$M[a$Q(A:^KkVU_K]?up 4I-"s͑I$HzI%(l$%b,RUB*,q]hU[a(**Vc*MV+ wijuޚ -$sA$A_$I-'T¦!0< m.ª5ZbUj*TUUSU&^) vᄨ%v * $IHVaa0L&5= WTaUU0(LQ8WA,PA%` ! """"""""""M57!a0L a4   a`jw_T[H&pu!0L"AaBk( *>XCK[$n$E H&J, H h$D`) pSp5ŕ&}~nK.^KKHK Ъk /Q[ '[(]G endstream endobj 103 0 obj << /Length 6563 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im104 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F105 8.30 Tf 110.64 708.24 TD (4. Cost ) Tj /F106 12.02 Tf 39.84 -.24 TD (comparisons would have shown that) Tj /F106 12.18 Tf 174.48 -.48 TD (, on a value-adjusted basis) Tj /F107 10.27 Tf 128.40 0.24 TD (, Rambus) Tj /F105 5.00 Tf -378.72 -28.08 TD (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. ) Tj /F106 11.89 Tf 250.08 -.48 TD (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr.) Tj /F106 12.00 Tf -250.08 -28.32 TD (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective than alternatives. Mr.) Tj /F106 11.80 Tf 0.00 -28.56 TD (Geilhufe) Tj /F106 11.87 Tf 45.60 0.24 TD (s conclusions) Tj 64.32 -.24 TD (, however) Tj /F107 11.14 Tf 47.04 0.00 TD (, are fatally flawed and uneliable.) Tj /F105 8.18 Tf -121.92 -42.48 TD (- He lacked the experience ) Tj /F107 10.97 Tf 132.48 -.24 TD (necessar to render such ) Tj /F106 11.91 Tf 120.72 -.24 TD (an opinion. Tr. 9625-) Tj /F106 11.80 Tf 102.24 0.00 TD (9626 \(") Tj /F107 12.10 Tf 35.76 -2.16 TD (Q. And) Tj /F106 11.91 Tf -390.96 -11.52 TD (your last hands-on ) Tj /F106 16.57 Tf 90.96 -.24 TD (DRA ) Tj /F106 12.31 Tf 39.12 0.00 TD (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? ) Tj /F105 9.71 Tf 222.48 -.24 TD (A. 1978) Tj /F106 13.68 Tf 41.76 0.00 TD (, 1-) Tj /F106 11.96 Tf -394.32 -13.68 TD (that is correct.") Tj /F106 11.88 Tf 73.20 -.24 TD (\); 9550-) Tj /F107 10.81 Tf 38.64 0.00 TD (9551 \(1988-) Tj /F106 11.04 Tf 60.00 0.00 TD (1998) Tj /F106 11.86 Tf 23.28 -.24 TD (, worked for lSD) Tj /F106 11.87 Tf 80.40 0.00 TD (, a fabless company with no) Tj /F105 8.94 Tf -275.76 -13.68 TD (manufacturng\); 9628-) Tj /F107 10.81 Tf 108.24 -.24 TD (9631 \(1999-) Tj /F106 11.95 Tf 58.80 0.00 TD (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing) Tj /F107 10.78 Tf -167.04 -13.92 TD (how outdated 14-) Tj /F106 11.79 Tf 83.76 -.24 TD (year-old ) Tj /F106 16.87 Tf 42.24 0.00 TD (DRA ) Tj /F106 11.90 Tf 39.84 0.00 TD (fabs could be used to ) Tj /F107 11.23 Tf 103.44 -.24 TD (manufactue other ) Tj /F106 11.74 Tf 90.48 0.24 TD (products\).) Tj /F106 12.10 Tf -360.24 -28.08 TD (- He failed to review any JEDEC records) Tj /F106 11.91 Tf 199.20 -.24 TD (, interview any JEDEC members) Tj /F106 11.79 Tf 157.20 -.24 TD (, or \(with very) Tj /F106 11.96 Tf -355.68 -13.68 TD (few exceptions\) review the deposition or ) Tj /F105 7.93 Tf 198.00 -.24 TD (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr.) Tj /F106 11.53 Tf 199.20 -.24 TD (9619-) Tj /F106 11.80 Tf -397.20 -13.68 TD (9623 \(") Tj /F106 12.20 Tf 36.00 -2.40 TD (Q. You never reviewed any ) Tj /F106 12.52 Tf 137.52 1.92 TD (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. ) Tj /F105 7.79 Tf 147.84 0.00 TD (I did not. ... ) Tj /F106 11.81 Tf 70.08 0.00 TD (I never) Tj /F106 11.87 Tf -391.44 -13.68 TD (spoke to a JEDEC member.) Tj /F106 12.08 Tf -.72 -28.56 TD (- He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from ) Tj /F106 16.83 Tf 330.96 -.24 TD (DRA) Tj /F106 12.08 Tf -330.96 -13.92 TD (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-) Tj /F106 12.04 Tf 282.48 -.72 TD (9618 \(") Tj /F106 11.96 Tf 36.24 0.24 TD (wanted to see cost) Tj /F107 10.92 Tf -318.48 -13.68 TD (documents from a number of companes) Tj /F106 11.89 Tf 196.56 -.48 TD (" but they weren) Tj /F106 11.98 Tf 82.32 0.00 TD (t available\); 9666-) Tj /F107 10.66 Tf 88.56 0.00 TD (9667 \(never) Tj /F106 11.92 Tf -367.44 -13.92 TD (asked to obtain ) Tj /F106 13.31 Tf 75.12 0.00 TD (DRA manufacturers) Tj /F106 11.71 Tf 108.72 -.24 TD (' cost information\).) Tj /F106 12.03 Tf -184.56 -28.08 TD (- He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptance among) Tj /F106 16.57 Tf 0.00 -14.40 TD (DRA ) Tj /F106 12.17 Tf 39.12 0.00 TD (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(") Tj /F106 11.75 Tf 199.68 -2.64 TD (Q. Now) Tj /F106 11.94 Tf 37.68 2.16 TD (, what did you do to ensure that) Tj -276.48 -13.68 TD (the analysis that you did was the ) Tj /F107 13.48 Tf 158.16 -2.64 TD (tye of ) Tj /F106 11.68 Tf 36.72 2.40 TD (analysis that') Tj /F106 12.72 Tf 63.12 -.24 TD (s done at JEDEC? A. ) Tj /F106 11.75 Tf 110.88 0.00 TD (I did not do) Tj /F106 12.29 Tf -368.64 -13.68 TD (anything. I did my analysis. . .) Tj /F105 8.66 Tf -.72 -28.32 TD (- The sources ) Tj /F106 12.05 Tf 72.72 -.24 TD (of his information ) Tj /F107 11.68 Tf 90.00 0.00 TD (canot be identified) Tj /F106 12.01 Tf 95.28 -.24 TD (, and his calculations ) Tj /F105 9.50 Tf 103.68 0.00 TD (canot be) Tj /F105 8.56 Tf -361.44 -13.68 TD (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-) Tj /F106 11.84 Tf 118.80 -.48 TD (9715 \(he couldn') Tj /F106 11.88 Tf 81.84 0.00 TD (t remember the ) Tj /F107 11.55 Tf 74.88 0.00 TD (manufactuers or par ) Tj /F106 11.78 Tf 106.56 0.00 TD (numbers) Tj /F106 11.98 Tf -382.08 -13.68 TD (of components for which he collected cost information; ") Tj /F106 11.89 Tf 274.08 -.48 TD (I believe I specified one or two) Tj /F106 12.67 Tf -274.08 -13.68 TD (companes) Tj /F106 11.82 Tf 51.36 -.24 TD (, and the others I didn') Tj /F106 11.76 Tf 108.00 -.24 TD (t recall.) Tj /F106 12.26 Tf -124.08 -98.40 TD (Whether a method "') Tj /F106 11.98 Tf 103.92 0.00 TD (has been subjected to peer review) Tj /F106 12.03 Tf 162.24 -.24 TD ('" and ") Tj /F107 10.76 Tf 37.68 0.00 TD (enjoys ') Tj /F106 11.66 Tf 37.68 0.00 TD (general) Tj /F106 11.77 Tf -413.04 -13.68 TD (acceptance) Tj /F107 11.59 Tf 52.80 0.00 TD (' within a ') Tj /F106 12.02 Tf 51.84 -.24 TD (relevant scientific community) Tj /F106 11.98 Tf 144.24 -.24 TD ('" are factors in determining the reliability of) Tj /F105 5.00 Tf -249.12 -13.92 TD (an expert opinion. ) Tj 92.16 0.00 TD (Kumho Tire Co. ) Tj /F106 5.00 Tf 81.36 -.24 TD (v. ) Tj /F106 12.23 Tf 12.00 0.00 TD (Carmichael) Tj /F105 8.63 Tf 62.64 0.00 TD (526 U.S. 137) Tj /F107 10.70 Tf 62.88 -.24 TD (, 149-) Tj /F106 11.84 Tf 29.04 0.00 TD (150 \(1999\) \(citing) Tj /F106 5.00 Tf -341.04 -13.68 TD (Daubert ) Tj 43.68 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F106 12.26 Tf 10.56 0.00 TD (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals) Tj /F106 11.36 Tf 147.12 -.24 TD (, Inc.) Tj /F106 11.55 Tf 30.96 0.00 TD (509 U.) Tj /F107 10.29 Tf 32.64 -.24 TD (S. 579) Tj /F107 10.61 Tf 30.48 0.00 TD (, 592-) Tj /F107 10.93 Tf 27.84 0.00 TD (594 \(1993\)\).) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000657842 00000 n 0000657901 00000 n 101 7 0000658073 00000 n 0000658240 00000 n 0000711907 00000 n 0000658783 00000 n 0000658396 00000 n 0000658523 00000 n 0000658654 00000 n trailer << /Size 108 /Prev 657514 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 718537 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000778265>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R ] /Count 16 >> endobj 108 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 109 0 R /Contents 110 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 109 0 obj << /XObject << /Im111 111 0 R>> /Font << /F112 112 0 R /F113 113 0 R /F114 114 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 112 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F112 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 113 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F113 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 114 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F114 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 111 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im111 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 51944 >> stream 6?Q-,J 4@Tk/E%[ $dT@B*38i͑Hhg~.(P72NKC"G7VpAAAl ~㌓"0b&U"~2* :;R a% J2FAFp$0$9XfDT&O|K&  ok8Aմ l (6INMUIWI*%H^}KN]uK[RC6lA9*'l.} UuT$Ka 4,`4A20@ L % pS♄>(D9%'=Ɇk"Z&$PB=4M'4& h? 0h e f!<`<#><8RBll62C .SzJA:_F h7CiSaZ K// Ʉ/a $N<Q7n¦vɾ_R8G|ILAĐ{L'צ~k&780N{i=$M!HM AA.q'&z>wհ:i;¤ھ#ͱ6BNg61羱ұѤ27D.C|&6&7MקW[/Z~nkN _OW~ۥMݰ ai࿢/[- _bI_ [kkԱYb>]l}߿s#ȭ~/8~wiI`Ћ(/ _ƷK/WzKm/ oVp~^E?j  ߯oگ_Nu[Z?m,kת߽T_ky7Z7a+[{ۯnǦGY +w~_m&ַ}Iպ~Qaئ;_l&ZRL1ߘ}k /WOm2tŦM:#c븍[mFQ_jJWtw'm& mVad 0i@dGTa@ 0b銦i]4ik5h&m(a&m+Q39Y & 0L0Ai0Ҧ2#kiib `p@a0 A   LS@b*"""""""""""""B NA^+iL%h0 Bh5J]PME&XaXN&@i$ 0""""""""#9" L~<C p3z nSteR B""""""""""""""""""?zI-~Z_CWiAŅh]_, k243.S="[;WFw@6d)z ([ ew&j+0N  ZPvvݒd5nN=p[ v-hF#fZo'O+pP+nخRHKX8EjziW~q~0uOz6lg)"8G8.CAOD79 huΌ$۪׫oqS0<0 hHD aB  &h!l)NDP99R%AD2'DkG2)4KQy՚R5>}YIלaJ3'd B52H"=ߤM4NڦD pU V* W„ B  xB p  d@BM)@'2@@@Ca< „?~&\KNt^0d聨xmcTN} $DlA0mAjmS AXLC84\P<(OABx*h]4NU\&?"3:l1<7Q9 /(a;hN80 8TE?˷h0T@}/E*O%jdS\'IO m&T>n,M Vt`>)pz&jGt ~kKzumXMtVt'd~l'zzJӺ_N?_MU}k:]_ХK>_Z'}zn_!Տ_zN_M׫_^ׯY4Fу#־ /o_lwQo?Z__Vv"ۈ J到{_&9?K먯&"Cm.,-__=m{_/$?a]{K/J Dߢq >_G5]AWVk_~Pn$u^_ 7owL?f(ܑ_d֬;V}M}z^_._.֗kWk𕷷R=GkKWK6/ߵ kK_moջ|BV"؃V*]ki]7Z`ُԿ߮4Iv[^_yԿa, kh B8LM9iۧ m;T(iG0CIlSWq!i{a bئ: a ڄ`5U@V0A  |0H1M4tRV $Ïzan1[ $4ccW4㲂Lg6e݄׵7L i6X\'4E5AA@ȐVM1F`@ 8 ڐ0 <4@":h m4 0@"""""""""""""""H& `SLeimR &AW} [W kiȮ &LQqZ `BP!!f$K""""""""#HFnyZWVR@; 1MxeE5-ş2S**SAS.WvFd/MKA`0ؼDR|v$0r3 E߬٩ mqO6AIW0@=FKtA I 9Fv'Ge<3b4G/A]$U닝Ţ0uդ-׷OI%U7$oJz^,!ȇ t d#3oB^;w0a & g`?TN"(D9\-A8姄ӴdzoʳҾ99< 6 ˰szA:A`&On/Axxn( :MAx4Lx&&tm 6o߮&ޕJ? E`bt}&z9I o`4a6#%_{t}Ыn[ Oua$_ =«ӯ~i!zOOUk?.u^{__~5]GQW[^k~?}nT !_Z={?;ZB>mjX?XȣW k -ߥ8UIz-?`z _7{Kk8u7m/__wxA_˿ aɏ[H%,sMA /}:avI7CWKZXHE>X7߫ڷ_G޵&_Wjn)}%{_kߵ=yKV/Zu~ۯ_omo]^M&뮾[0׆]i?Wioum/մIdl%ba; mo%ky_^Nͫ^] &i+N=? 6jGW[+y*N‚8۽dD{+m[ _&T<'0A  *!1 3aց!Gm5 m4iIm6 Bq`AUi T[^ iM6 00A @h6`P@4M==h4iÐ! "'0A l[":60B""",a+gaI 5ov0 wUժk 0M0A PhC0@؆ 5jji 'DEDDDDDDDDDDDDDELLˀ^ɚ.!j\Z A`D6fnhLך EC DF6_d3a5?g& DA0L^""81Pqީ?zI/oI4xJP@T p *RAļM3|(PU5EA2(gguh˙Te̋((]0Td-m}uKZńD@ !!>)cA(F : _ {8ι ʳ5gOd?_zi{tA&;0TOR (!Sb B02@\z/(3C2Ig$e:)6E FN2_E?[z~ׯt)ׯo_~ 렮[Z~m޾~ޗޗ޴a[ӽZ޽CI봚.zt+KJi.OaH'Kmu# ~al5oՄaڱpiOQ4:մۯ봵մ+uK $ %twߩ~D +jb mn4-T&Iw}L I$T KaXALmBm5/Mi["z m3`F0A a+L404M*jVI;MVb8ӊjmSDDDL&W@zaBIh50wa:b1LSRf`<pA 1@,0DpaM6iDDDTDM2%)2OA ʀ [JW ZOaViÑGaF"""""""4Cb",DDDJDDDDDDDDRЈ_inIto6ȬtIau Im h!l5l(hcB^*#%6HEkRș4„ʨD3Cd(6PTdRt]A^%Bi A3X!8N2,AAN2/qDD 8R8d`B%. .k E^xT ' L j0(MBBh5 4A j;34DT]O(Pa8aAQ7aBaBn„I(TNAAQvD TN?2i6H7M l‚A…IABh P&uIjut^7Mkڤ/hۯVյnbki6*, ʎ*5sŕIeD4I"D6}o'[,tqձ^GKz~:z[ikuۿZ0e/^IX߯{?K@ pPL" scكQ$ y<3хgS ufVfU-A__u}׭z🥞< |'qgC0f2@BC62f0z_W?M_pa +괉}7}1T$8*`5΃OO_//({v< @ŇNhhxªDh ?/m'~ goӤ[({(q=z ߯z]&]t_k@ n\ \ZwJMNZ!kۯn뾮zWam{S_]{{_&_m?iB{o}~ںkZKﶿW?G_ol+ +ڿޗkKߝFJht*67n~5vF]6p$Dt]fat_a˿JO !o7%KbQ+EC@oIF %Η^JLuiVMa,WK/G_}ouU?:^DSYi{_{o%ZDt$oUtد{ /S7I$/*~q^kZ0IiZ_ծED] P_/g.?+ t`B><0g:vWm+_Oa}A 4zOt+ޭ+?$n-vvB ! A=FE  q]iAE*vjIVWvIij0W[kez Jֆi @!_| Xi;lQ8Z X `@' P ` `Bb@c؅"DDDDH e萉|“ A0a0VZLMmDGe(> TA=mDL&le(#\'XDJ`I""""""""""8%I~%KA%I$TL*PA"#vG@, RdV4eL0 HB!+ ͑Z¦d+FTFJLeb+3PI=4-9  L l9 5 (T^5M#1*mip 0 OONZNHPm zy;@ <DgzOqqzmiwTq'3絕DŽ_I&7чZkOm.q{zv֪0az3o QNz__T( ʰv_,'AN&/u0FtJoi`hEੂfc0xha.@D$Ew5I#<<:! !GpRxᙙ6Amdh!A]F!C02C4f'dles3uz'mm^0iMEizp^ };SPhw``40M0 4  pTS>(Mu!_!tKX5 As^8|IyI'/ a(2tiZ 0ޘ' ઘJ$; TNU&*joC0-&I Vϊpptn?Avx{k憋NZbnq,vhoC@MwqB%}n_^ Mt}ג=#uӃ-.ϊpS  6|g]s2.0s1:V 'ڦN^~u׶: ҵ_S>]j?[uҺZ_t^nZ~}/鮯Һ޵zo-%k^1a?YN*m[^o_K_J_YiKU/jņ?ǷK"m~a_҆!6i_L__a튤/"Nۯ`aa Km3&ïaI? /~}_ᴩ_Aamὸ/$?|6خknuào A~}kï Hxm,6 >d̓"E_u#}jFa=1tr_y7 꿥yK_k_.ҽׯ~{Io7P0o.[Jk_{](k}Xئ߄I ]Һ__KSǾփ T]M5ikWmװ n#Dh~鷱0_d~Y)V״tVhg˪ QpD/O&lRiSM1wa־CV#^5m/b?l mi~4[ XJ][ 0iA A6@66j6 `A#Ө >*)NӰ&&llT0A 6(0Ib""""$8 a27Rp[G < dXvH[Ah&C6`5MUST0@)h`0 l&M iSЦ b""""""""""шD )2I~g.Lar &SaN57k5Aᰘ\J`AS B d' C׃'l"4hǨT[L+ #5! ~OI I$`ڢoP R 'IL+@d@{VA"hUIsFv.ٝ2S tKoo~$>Ko Al/Gwu{tI']]j=J_IzKZ&dPf'3y TI%!y>3ŝM$3Q3̇f lF-W]Sz / t0S8}%@L8 m9P@B 0`S3,)0a8f$k tb'dtC,2fc 2/ Iۯ}hgA3|S SGt. Ѝ%{c~ aLE4Lv 05 ACf40 hDb h%A   U0P  |0ƉH/T^0d˓*h4Oh*֚h MHp"CompTDL8}M0UpI'K_##^-t`ȸϊlxnPhn0d4^8N ޒڷ^ZN%O[MФܐtUݫ^?VuXomVO]i}_鯷V~}:i/}; wz0׍^WcذhKc!iU|+ԜwUŽ_= =&н i;H}`__/K῰]ׄ'w_NAZ A6^_h_֏__K솒G_ ᴽ/+/]?$/M(3ARu]Խ^Cno_oUz~m/Aӷ__oҾmo_ڬUKtK=/cژ[_+]m/]Ê&WxIK{_1MZta5[K~KORMKRVԿᅲkxU b1LU6M6B=6[c=حlv|mk;[xKoxb6*8װUM] SA06aA`USR 6i&w0Px4[ 'iզA:j#i? *p=auMa5Ia5 i86@ i m1QUȐ$"$"!  6DA @M5@?AII"^ &g'`0i M40!¯aAl& ]5lDq޷ҷՇWJ=D;S@3Dّ%,l`M'SCA &wN3Ɔ%߮V TN4DuY7'Ex4;TCvSx8: 8kߺ$őIs1KiI_"[imI7o%A4Kz?FABgI}'V'+n/3z|'pa0t,'J?l%[޻ֿvai7Vi^K'}|1[nU_t^>:_z|7 ?I_>Zu7lWcߺz.zye~Q`]%y>_u+?` $?a%o?W/ @AnPG?k+T K7n_[#$vC9xDT"yQ;a'mU4Hv)N z'tN2h' <`'opj^Ф6iIdnlðtEƠȷ&hi:$KM@M &>cQ,vNA;(r:APK[][k0պ;dx67@tnI7I'/KIY( ¯tXMPn^VmzMuO֓t;MCuu5c[[iz0鮾j+[z_m_`5n}^}]0޷[_Շzwu׆">Cڰ /@/ `} /,m֯ޛW}^a~  _C^ZF];aD8^D'D+z # Aw- Aoy?{T#G^in 0ᴻ K-_o$F6okC^Qm;޽/wi]^znq(å_[K_RKjk v^a͖[kl${_][ 10b_T׵a/N^~K/{u]kY s{ -af>0Va@nC 5KݥKlV_v4Cc4TN¯ukƶ*qVMG_Mo۫!YMA&W jh0@g@ `h0 >BZMLRi 㴗kl@a+m-86QW .#ij"8Ն^?A4e|0X0.A{Ӷ!&l @GQ@ ڊd#At6BVB< a AA:kv 6Dt@ؠ DDDDDDDDFA6tlt )=ySɏ 0 - Luzl*jM6DpLBMjjJl5Ia4aD4ҴZ!3͈!a(#QLjLaB\0Sl0 wh0RP7`0a22u@0A$U` lL_8b"4kDDDDE qX-$J֥T"Ij  XH$MVBsJA$;C CQaVX *DDd;D;(Pa3dew ;8%K+gfYn pW B{jx89133:Uqֿ%0ױv R _>`Ԑ.Of2Da&G $fykg\Ht0p0T6  (A!5D ]E"\Bhk$Adzv_33d )o}0h"qO D>*gTBa D*N  AB 0Dru/|SS4: 62` : dfF#f|BSM~63N |L[A|-L v!&P'p LةT&SD3h84σ M0Pe8a0TAT SbփȷzIyM#.'A n~%'DƋCDĊ了\4O!UO DTNU0 i@CMz ݪ&P 28`ȶz`s1{L (r)6 4f!I H6Mq3C4_8鸖;A}A7}-V*mWiwIbM%kO$T=E9 ˳f#zD 82+I6 &stn?]z}U_.m}a>7CUm NM7Zoۥ~ҽ}u׶{u5TK]vIպ-x^b(,~XK/uWҽW/~[kA~Lfk&_ [_RJ_^nao `daWkiw^Di_D7d~?[m 'iuK7 دA/{~u⿿7A~A/ܑ5G]_yG*(wk~]oK k߯ތ[ѝZK/ۤҵH$K}]G!~kj_iaOq[+uխ.uպ켩jmm+0(a~ᅱM1piTi[ + 0҆m$NH1?c¯qQI7}LU A)A#h7 b ؠ@`0u)Ui5iSm.#t4-[Բ$ ,t a4a4 iV&mt(  am m0h 0A ؄B:4@@ؠMh  tDDDDDDy80)7 #Yg˺2!˴ʀu- uiT5Ȏ :M;L4 A0!i6MaXKWDDDE qш! r ضw*?)4R39O 23=a3:s[L*v\EC"""""=}*-&Ay*KR^W, תa/Hy}WiLI [Ti{\0@ \E0WaP giDDDNIDe__koi}OSKI[վ2$F.C3!F2 ^H5ѝer7L 04!IWCgAifyX2N&ªzh:l(A K@!<@6-EH>̞0dSM4T4LNWI.`I]K^_Dx"vᏦ&Ixn {A 3WO{m6n6*Oӯrt_*I{ -/ɣg]^GUտ.u W]VKx_ /_!oV7~ɫ0i'uvD_H;Xd7ݰ=_$_y ahK__~뵅_{ׯD~K^K_фoFVDvF[E_mozKm/I_ojk~Ni~NiWjV) ~R;b#Mi{ ҫi[iAut% *L4m$K˥0]P'=4@ )6*QVI |Rih$[AT,&6` B:j(2r@eN0IA% $סKma$QWa&'ɺFAi@aSN*)B: GbUDDDDDR:B"",! '[- …xk,,DH^Fr &""?{_ +a 8G6xq8+@nA0A[4GaFB2/io I2\@4 S2]62;ʓ)Qٙ v H2$ ?B¨]B附*A PB#rj(+(.5OA}ޤ z]WEڢ&7A89ww;TM$P?wp\;V8ֽ_C^ߵt.5_'FjDy1au]Wֿ(AD!΂Af) RRN$ N"h }`T*a0 B@@Sc>2vlgHd™6l:S3ʷmC538) 몝G:3qZ'7hz&;UMA5𩨄S >(P|P\&w 0B0 atN͒ 3|&l!B 63JH!`qt'd|E ! S‚m,(A ا/ `;ow.qq.á:`~:*]wU?^$/k| _70`D_D.?~V6}t u#,>_Z _7Xo7 Xa"OuK쑃X7?__?^sGAzoۯ^so|?H}]?~t}uׯ_kW_ k/iy/m{K8m'W_K=ц~KKI!zU[#֭ڧf? __im~]_mj qݶ}]i/]}X]aNڶm|0 ~oj{ -Ua`1@ `b l -ƜUa+J+]QR t!w}Vuk_ZڱZ[ mm&PMDuA@[@A`AaM6)V8VDZ WVՏ_aj %v~Z[ e ,~L0‘aNP jkTIA6AM@ݠ@h @0@i00@ؠAm `B<C 3KT?W 6Y^hgSe MC* Ȯaڄ^L4&TimZt|m4PJ"""""""""""""""""",1 8`eM0Li*h&~T5a 7&Wv )2` )U2@&Pez Z"""""""""8-*%UJ•I U%aSPTQAuO@hkeVWfvMA %Ȗ%fHDdAd ٲ 1`A2h25ڤ@!qfh ]am0C‚\(B„>E#8ʆ<3PtB9,i}(6DX꨸mࠠ  ʁ  vt ;``7n.ސq3=eiIYN3"NЊ D8wr ՂL T! p'qw{_[}wIڊ_+ZotrJ"y9y_]~m}J ‚ ! @@3υ.๲:IyA; XH~i? n{J{}']+N?W.G &'u|&~~x^zM9/tzuT?}+O^?V!?ބkƖ8ǿo]o~17}z\1?kkk3kCl/kZ/: ÿlWzD'{ׯde/-~׿i~ | +A?DA[R% (_}]ѝJ?t^WK?Aa _~K{ׯ^H~׿/]_ׯs e_k~ڱW>Yt_~~K]-le׶߂)i]~jkz׺ _mC+vد(;/xik_EMT߯VXv{^v  k›+~cRiVialq 6`\<d#6*-[ 5b Z}.*i{iڪxBUa'j x`LU'uU{I ` m `tu!_i+Ww q}C8!C#aawl^nDDDD0Cԛ&k05L_~A6 JȐ ! `@d# ΀0M #' `a)@B:#8!ye!2 >f5`00tm4[ j{" Ց S4jȮ ڬ55!0D &S*ia2T(hLRv0M2T-,A*T0_mDDD\DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDt7S_t~I}*iJ`p_dBq@^j?0y -GMbl쵐HhB&wH4ŸPL(U y]O;33!a| 290dp!  hE&dabX. 7ę9N dh@d}DsRܰ̊r[&;(GI>{ۻ±˳٦Fl& +Jl&MNk  lAAI|AM TiǢ}>_ۮu=>;Ӥ]tiu?zw׊?/?mm{u]}ujWK]z_cB.o~_ߺkߺoϮH/]pCߖ%_\s;pX8":_uaT1D'7W׈V}yb:/xR?{@]pr&]_/[ ?~(G#/}~_K"qa-F"oPuJo_q~U[]0ߠmG7G ZvWKmn_߂1s=Y#$_䊲F?5_K._߿zҴm/9?}ijGᄛ.aZޗm_]ou~wWZvӊ—f6Vtk_{a/֖TӮF^i?cba+XbR>GqQZ~]ԂZaA~VW_ ^Z{j]W uۜ< f6{Ӯ/m+!M1QUNA@ Oki[m-Vp֬ m|l5nZC Z~]}N+Mm/ﰶV"9d(M"&J AAM4!6(6* ⢤()6)4LR4i0[I8k`銈=mcCXmXiZ %G@˄1C + fԜ ` a&T a}Ӧ iMA0i0A0@b0A!;!0A0[ ޚpA ab:bMX!EQDDDDDDDDDDDDI(`H6~@:0'a28^ ._ &dݦiTM0 h mWI *ja+JqIDDDDDDDB!5@a0{> a0 d0@aA3=$>L{n§ &L)23gY`3aL08+0N"8QHhzKZ,-ia$*6aTK!QpˆMp"eq\: 0 [ +yضd:;t솪 ‚;8id ".B @M<(P@$s!C!0h]PBBN;dX+Bv'zئBC+VL'A7zkim~kIBK6W_n:N͌(qk<.mDkO[iKuAalPz S (@ لSb lfq5 g㡐j#YyȠA&HF40? iMQ!*L O;=0`P0Aa0Ac " B s: )tl΢GAHc5DEc:f=\lq~ZhqZ'9yAB<DG@ `ix(*h` 0=B4  4 䂜`ȖD"ȣϊl~E7n} D'-'n4NމMH6xA iOA}, U==[C vO ץIKA?Ll'EM7u3ҦYNDQ>/oz//tLE (`Z֣ k`0__ PDVLg/_|WZb%?$V_W͇__o2(DP t߄_{K?GK봿}U8zDwI0_Q%#K$id~C_z^wA{,wւGھ-FkH/gr^d=K!Uo/[}_">֗~"$_Vڤޕik߯%K׾_tww[ ,ǭa[uOKUoK./VKmi]+A`ki4ҽ)?X0J]/ٍ?[[{I$utZL&0\0^;V.5^7 ؊V+دV+0"c+m/ݥڭ^IڷZpA m lBh8 60:j =6aZVX⿆J?n+`[i1[zi%\'i5 4 Tm&h0A0 mA `nM6b C uiUÿMbST \DDDDDI0   &PL,0Lp5aimM@ME1 !44 @ؠ h  >|1!A !( ` 5 a)H* :lg䌋A 8h5&8@TZazv2oaw/*z؈ADDDFb$4" 13a `Df`$:DDDFDiu jK |xizl ٱꂦqy&[ge˝gNynJ!> lG^Dо?i~Αs5#^)/ܜ! Rp0D@˲BgSb%;'$;UU6 Ƚkmi/I{\?:azK"}oK$yJ^_o*ϥi:]i!taO|$1_[i'cMU]~N M4AAՆ '*@ lF6 咱eb=ɈGjFdح /N@2!#; fE\MwI "Kr `ad,!بdG0@0@tό2Y@ U<6|h+gc EGyIVxd$SKtkַ]|8/K;\E5}v]i.ҔM$vYᯤ-:H{%KKCJZKK]WIT5C9YȌ23FWx\jY#.. L&f apPL dH #3ѐȨƲ:.aJ3r k~ԖYגXx)L4fB;~*J4XCOOPA 3P0 a0(A d T!<3|hG6d2x2A>΢ I<)<}3 d.N͘" W*e8ȜE P5[iQ;DCQ8$a MU B`hz&0q ¨AAHv RZR4QoKgHDyJ5t%K2%A8;xOPD :EMR*ե'KҵүKZI%Z4$htg9tZK]-&zF%sMoҿQZHRX/ZI*UZZ_PZTxI^ T-.'tOK]R[k]*IU*ץZxI/$IVLp+JƻJ--֢R%Z/]$UKJTjH%Z뮗IRZAҥ}m]K֕n\RI*Kn%WA$*Fk_k U~KJ~bףJ$di%B[zZ]V]WUPIt ZH$]%kzUUJ߯J.C=$UסI?ZKZJ*]nr8X '*u^VRiW֖*#WH~-` ^W֩6ZTHB}RIjJ JҺ%D*d_KZֽz_H-a]/J*V{zKUui}zPҭ/m=Wԣn=-U%I.z]*bW+֗ɫjZTZHŮkGK]--$ VRү ֵR=kO[ZRv;_UI%m/YK QT/ю-~)2*._KW_T~ tzJZ]/auZ/KTWHT^ҤF:t/Pң0Qj_W֒˥J_ߥ,£FUGuKZ$Xa*X J^Sii~NҶj֮^WatޕU}SUNtIX_H%4 !!Ki1 wQVXEJ%]kUIaVJVZi}WJ-%VI6M1LR 1ZPkL0IaiRUlB)5iGJN㥊QTvƅE!MWQQViGK1z^ L&C@Hmm1 LS 5 !W 鄈:RMU4^*X`LBUUaZUZI0 X iAiDDD-  SM aBA&P'm5&Q[Tªj*1UI4,4P q:h` & L` xs a0x Tih0S څA8h0B g=| """""""""""""""4'KAm"l%l*$PdˆoZxiS T,?YHǎYM+*xN{L&W 8( װ@Ԃ1٩GG7T?Bª (N-fB&AĻ2L;C>xT0p (PPPArHNi ֖AC`aN@BI"dIR4eK :軠Ҵʔhj2l&c" u뎗տni5I$R{kU_K#e#fDᙙ(#Ψy J}K 31L(L „," aA50ࠁf(DTDO#jk2Y&HGC5#LէOMU0TU 7 AKB (A L0P/TJ L#H0w#*ÐqhF56 sED8(y qFgA#qA*T8_= N-='NUiiMpA'M3L&5 0aDA 0P@|S!:0B f  !!MGRl0d['bhm;HDѝqF}YG^wޗ{_p޿AW~R]?߲  z䏯l^{^zXKo_5imu~N}֗q_7z_1]u5-ۯ׻ݦ{Im + .:ۯb)B "(`$`)L3 _m LhlKL;|#Dfa4[NL*jAD &B{A `<& A 0`~ H;=?L&lU;l&@2<"c"]gނؖ8hq˴/p %!G@( mT2DDDDDDDDDDDDD !30L5 ,uATӰȎ0dA2,+h4L h ݅ Bj a0i+`8B @ P@—ALa0a39NKa0n ‚a3Q &jLaOZ  lA\DDDDDq:B"""""""""""#KZ+JXJ+ l( R2 #vUAB #f;%FD0T(P2[+Q-2<ѓIUpPBT&v:&=&TBd` ,_hLّ4* v\Z?o"0q2 s^WTa_z.8I^z~kѨm'dG4- P:4fx!0g#c>GQNEYdCЏCC3[GJ]}ka:p*a3bZfcL0A,!A <  y C 83A(E&A.p΢52q#fD:<)5%MAT'jj8q $;0< aB  (@д3' !!@RCM=ǚ2xE c'2;>2$D>ёԱax鰪%<y:0% jI .mED3]aJ'#P&nA ? `PA api< a:[`ȷIIdn\pONNnj,3: DŢx N'oDd&hHp&wPH0UPi4NZaSM=4I6t:BZMZMoi#.RvBD2%ޒtIAކ&}I'}|vE_0(_Qy>y@W?T֯zM.t&۪oPt}m-'m\)0TI6ȷII:ȣMޓi?vI^K.M.ޕ}>uiu &=o mF}le6~M=kZ_#.߿н{[v~z[Z^TڷUu7Bq-z]l|!ǽmm|q__ּ__]vK/ U:}N/޿_/Zr X0Uɺni/&:kynD."QFOX_/:ߖ^&Qת x(}/pDoizVQuddKO-/vւj?#4oa.>V_EGv_?$_$md.FvHEJz]m_ng]7ǭ~߶Ծ0Wmi_kymom$KtF|S[޿}][:J+]=66 1_a'vխ{{Mi$Vk_]ڴmhhFC@mnkiY{ح(0U/IoJj_m*:jkk@dGM5 gؠA&QU0@ilSiE}ZMwXCج'mvՏ۵Apz0[Z &kUzLlIUk Piv4AM4"B 6دObjIZv=ؘpbե4bia#WIJݴB 3'2 )4&k#j"8 T6h& @`2#@ڬ6BA@Um4 M+4A!M $U1q$ `D6PAN9v0L/ Kp &a5OaNVMi a4mMTMBL4qL& 0"""""""80~C`^a3gf`™>& go & lR:7h00 0O57A(DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDRqDDDFDDGV-okgiExNPBb)eSDgZl?-dSWT vRȲ+M8 ‚y&ђQJf)q'f@WF.(p‚gfH@`0aSA  @cL'WIőnڡ T Be:6vir59qVB ovLozh}㷯$vQvD2Xʼ'_zo몪&UWG]kz  dC8G6G8AȈٚ)|ΙS5-ua8"h4gA>,!0A, `DQ a3:!'Y#6!jaN뙢3U~DH4ÇP[M`A44Ax |D\"a8D0a\5 5 hl9.!Qf"@gǜfN# d|"iȸGCY" "h-}|3Qw(h C&&L`лwT'vPMi` )Th5h44v S&v =aBav `wW\%ȸy;!g0ZNqd42a?Ǣ.آqDݞ3 L&;/G C]<*$==\ 8pTSLkM?]i7&p0\'>0?#Ͼ֓`}AOgxDyWxZ/'Tq/Z'N/$aƋ\Z/HX2tV>nJuN?ZN-0&noI`)Eo34E܋n}EdH>)t_?~i:uM zuumvKwuM[Mۄ? ?']}a\}Ud߭om.^zno'? ?cB?o?j޾a~{c>%B W1b+_ a o{o8 /_Ybk^}x:u|0ᰉ?ja_V7O߄_ak$ K6_߿n_~OD}a/m?:_CAᰂTk~ߧ?Hm,KNC, _C^[zi_}FMQޗkY|ׇ]' 7z_޿i߿߷Hn}W^_V6_}+/m$6_{_z_KU}._֫u +N؍;(#[?wR=e;0 ]k_j[}zo 3! #ad#%Z ,~kSo[ v_kիu" Ի0q;[]ot1>Zn aȎAHvG@ 'M'U֣톓 i0iDwKVl4BJ҇\q՟Ј0@ʢ Af̸Ljip Aa;PM a4ts@6 a6;Q 6 lS[SH6N 'PҤ)bb{IDDDD:04~J54` aAaI]ȎiCMNL4adHLPAȐ tP@A 0DDDDDDDDDA 1eT0Srezj&]:;5L& 0u &S‚IL^^DDDDDDDDD$8_UJ6(i!_ bKy80Mw-Uhd) DH-jiRAC9(s]AjXntv>_#G QVTr2Ez[@L43 47='@q04j- ǃ&dNWqhoMƂm*קozZni[a6a7K=t2- `JG.Rpp}'ȶmWE?zm*xߧz[oznz_~uJ_zmZ^/_{KK_e_|z;ЭwҾV?!_EJ蘏^_? ^!a//$ m4bE+"QN4_\"o׻'_nP ?N_=}/7Z/P{_w޺mQ^ 䏻$ud5CF.' ^I.+ӿQ_/~sK%ot{__ tkOtKM{קk~K[8l!]`uu~0ow_a}}z ⡄bJ?cV&5J!׺nX %_V/]/h&h0A$&(0@v6BM6i5{XjLFa Jal4jbՊ6*#kaw!Kk_H AI *(pA lB  #B: 4h66);6NM6M;I `D0 &nS 70 Xz[ZADpAa6 NAA a2, Aئa  `dXQQDDDDDqDHhDD a2` 0 —yo  nXa5L&.2 L/dp a}DDqDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD\DDDDDiz_Kuۡ_:Z>w[z0a  ~K;Qp̹#>f]A[ Ӳ(CQ HH0§v2(0h C/RMu &5Aa< Sl.v8#mHA%D~P&;I4 H t7piRZIכI?m /WVTU+C׎~t%K]WBA$UZ^?lgQNc%#sZvIh,qA*zCPA8MV $ _Q.0D݅[#ADRH3C83|q;8 $Ċ(6A؞ɜd_4k$W 8"~a kxn`I}iZU$뿆w]?T*KZ_᰿[ K-(A:]lULwoZIkJ+KpGBV<<솾R^I% 3 }wk67nI~%O/~O_W^/ZVoGzKUU_VIz5mojZI$auKHuu[J6+qW8a+L5o]k_HiiSIoZmZk7b@K]c^U21#ki,]"&`MG!KTVXA\4m+u$ h=S@Ml$U8.ALܙ$ N4LR|&JI1LSqDDFDDDDD0B4-T[L&L8I5` 0LT-*TPJ,!,ѥƫk(a, a0fwlu~̩L? ȜU2mU H #8͝ee8Z;YeeaTB(AM0B;vN;V/ T} ]4zzT\4}=]p,wtH#Iޯo+iAEgan`D>pw_ړ4fohqIWKpw5_ތ/KU_}I%꾫Ӵ &p)l42hĹ Ҽ^ʦiT & OA<'M 0`A8L&0  & ! L  B0TM0@ &Dj[<>whaQhqahxO>4^Lv5CMhma 4W 'T'q`$wZxL>*} aH7 `)7Ȗ~un@An"@q045 .nzEO DPD|8x|&9/iǧJUoV#cnm6zN ˲727@ O۩NF 'A6 i7B I"nl2e?^ Sn4u}7CB¯[Kt~vK}mtonvJJЫ}wOޓ}tmW Iڭ_7~\W_J*GBQ~zzi_||[!uwBnww? ?ܱ/߅Dp_0oo'^>޻ 7O__Au}~߄N+/_-_o_+F[_ג/^Gu#$Wo__Ho)__]Y?J_zmZk/]\WZkZ]o]}wտK/ڿr uvif41_a+Kl%5_4z]{iviZlUO)±,W~zP`m+z2@ a aA֚NҴuՈ:aooiVv* ׶>/i G}ƚ akpAq) m 0A4AؤiU &Ո{LlW 'ZON)\Ek(SށUX5 0I 0dGN40A mHGTM1@:u@ @ 1A oF`0DDDDDDsDXB ez 0RQ )wOI44kAMa{M L%N""""""""""""#0DD0BЈDІJ6~TDDqK+,–U+]!VNY MK1Ј ,Ea2US\uGp2ϣl8)%e2Nf))#QLH)'dgi"\XAQq0aABaPa4[q*&K~gI F<.!AQc\: ijh a *O FG>AZ_T?HoAD=;U]u'6'=A}24A-%~.~ 'I$|R/n_K0~[1lc$FB'QڜP[/K]-y޴@㰡`  (A N.RJ)ޟ%nсSL$Bg8(LiD2x8f|IEQK3v$3: kFgTECE, oU8 S*fM5 $ xf̜%}A `3¢/@Pf 0G53f|@zU-D\"л$yc:f!q"eGB(9$2pt!"'v OlbhhR֚% M:ˋ4^6PU O&6*|UPMPd`B~\a0੩N 0<&|Pim: Ӻ0UiP ^! +X.m.>^?2Hc.= v$;TI'O*AUD⪚&ҦvwMx?FOеH'"M=Yt4m=Y| ;&LObxJ:}]ZTiZO5]+Y4K?]4#Y(28"'l'o 'I|4`m+IGM_蛱U)i%Kѝ$Mwt<]6?i7CBд? [^'^[֒U_P=w[ү_^o^|#_UZZZR?^kZ5}_Wo׆WJZ[~=uC +;on/ ab:༘s\W[%_]V?Б/B#/a>CJ_붗o"O~a?;{J}}iWIi}_VmUT/JZ/]!7A{o|jm~T]tE]}dAHooὤª]i/H?owyo{&`f;o]]hT_m.jtuzu~%^^ߺM?v)n+K$~W;3tWk޿~݄NiXK]8izkhTURUwaK^ /{ % J )@݊ `b0R$)bi64#M{{@+K)[ N{׺Ɏ0Pa դ_\&( VMi0`ᄮB']µ}L;ZZmkvҪi~}FDF]?)اa0`0+h yLv6 aT\ 6B+a0A &x  i02$q`Aik 0MhiA5M4p@ B 4A4.ЉIЈ0M&>m'Z/2g/'tOqhdNމOA& W}vD8*h0UDq a MRmzt'WDM6 Wl`5Or )44A綠I,8lMvϷo][oۄ[Ui޾4ӫt/ү_>;5i~`Mo^M]W׫zo ֔?|G_K__W_kZ~auu%}[Ib=ayb?'u,p^]_zz 1%ah_/ _Xayc/'{TooKH! _A_{Ӷ!]@ Au__ Ho%CUiuW_ 6]ޘ^?]w_,7]$I_tX:^5C_o״W/os{azY=_zFnbVi7o^m;۫Wᄰl4|a~]i7궗=4؏㴢cX_յpW~a/zl0x]O^m{aWV*(` a qMHQL0OHXv1_aخK;XAy&Mo_L/Jza->—/kR_  5ix4ӥb`JW }8zG `-0Caa );#ڏ鴵ږ!!0AŸ24 A4Ȏ 0(h dG@0@ؠ@ȎA 0l ajF am&ijN7B=6*BMiOO"""""""" 0fѡI0L k xa{Pj'{U N,!aȎ A0@MA` Ј0B"!5bhSL) gLL(6a"y:G6^a4ɺ׆TMP &4ݤqz_KU^$0EV=J+@iQL0 D7'w)̓gbQ4di zxޡ4;EyYwt\=gaL!PAEnA_qpM;6B"TCXDOjJ^'V+):֖?鵴LSi;{w~?H{o}R~ֵ-Y5 tf͖C"Ld|2|0uP5P] !"gB+")L'f 3#Fy=Q#qغ?F[IcM蛥xMSwPL /t* ‚A BC BldB4Dlh2@$F"s!|6KBpRUwoՐrdY"'_AA|8x(aM"n¡,*.J(A|S|a|i<0iT(L 4cXAI#63CP͌?MD6aL`AB->!9$DdB2%{Ӄ6|h 4;2tRƨ;aS\&4ӓDh ]5L*mI@A;}# gMBa4A-,)UAB'u~}?{VIlwn%"3:tq`4[H6A5\L4nqƋ/`ˠAdAyE"xNNjwPp}' .MEV)j O?N"pa8tt80i827-"It &ҧ&44e&9 wA8:N A: IMiu/ޛa{M텯B j; zV -X0OX_G [dSLNھl}cJ_+kտU >6+zzW_u;]k~\?oS[}T_*kl7X5`wYc?>m׊iDv)___cǡao/{~Lr1ʟ҇߅avKpmU}J^GXr|/K@{Xu _D?n=A6<m/{UOJ[N^'mݝp#j# WA}xnAk/WoioV_??=_?FK܇/z^цz{Kk_ݗy+-GeN{/$Y#[{]V_nn~{~}. VՆa_v}}[u_autUaب]Vk}^kں] 1QQH6Jچ`Q;vA-5 _V}uLJ%}Kj -^_akKl,5l0(5TaQLST (=&鄛 Z]XZJZLW`U]V~݅#a-; }qP-cmr `c:؃ )0Ei7pL0@l0A06(`2t 6*tJG"BO#pkQ0,5bj@9sga3Z 4Ih 6AMA@ @(0C`0A  akA,tU @kic""""#؈!a2L 6C'g Me: /h0Sar*i„Z֡00M4p[TqDDDDDDDDDDHz)6~0A? x20@ `Xa0^DDDDDDDDDDhDDGK@Z0J1 4*K4d> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im111 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F112 12.04 Tf 110.64 708.00 TD (- He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his ) Tj /F112 12.34 Tf 257.04 -.48 TD (opinions. Tr. 9665-) Tj /F112 11.42 Tf 96.00 0.00 TD (9666.) Tj /F113 16.96 Tf -353.28 -28.08 TD (- DRA ) Tj /F113 11.25 Tf 50.88 0.00 TD (manufactuers \(his only potential ) Tj /F112 11.88 Tf 162.00 -.24 TD (source of verification\) contradicted his) Tj /F112 12.09 Tf -212.40 -13.92 TD (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented) Tj /F112 11.90 Tf 255.60 -.48 TD (, asking a ) Tj /F112 16.47 Tf 48.24 0.00 TD (DRA ) Tj /F112 11.93 Tf 38.88 0.00 TD (manufacturer) Tj /F112 11.92 Tf -342.96 -13.68 TD (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-) Tj /F112 12.10 Tf 230.40 -.72 TD (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed) Tj /F112 11.92 Tf -230.40 -13.44 TD (with Mr. Geilhufe) Tj /F112 11.95 Tf 90.72 -.48 TD (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-) Tj /F112 11.24 Tf 111.84 0.00 TD (11009) Tj /F113 10.60 Tf 29.04 -.24 TD (, 11012-) Tj /F112 11.43 Tf 40.32 0.00 TD (11019) Tj /F113 10.73 Tf 29.52 0.00 TD (, 11024-) Tj /F112 11.14 Tf 40.80 0.00 TD (11038) Tj /F113 10.53 Tf 29.04 0.24 TD (, 11040-) Tj /F112 11.87 Tf -370.08 -13.92 TD (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe) Tj /F114 5.00 Tf 267.60 -.48 TD (s assumptions and opinions\); ) Tj /F112 12.03 Tf 140.88 0.00 TD (see) Tj /F112 5.00 Tf -409.68 -13.68 TD (also ) Tj /F112 11.91 Tf 23.04 0.00 TD (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ") Tj /F112 11.97 Tf 97.92 -.24 TD (cannot speak for the actual costs at a ) Tj /F112 13.93 Tf 178.08 -.24 TD (DRA manufactuer) Tj /F112 12.08 Tf -299.52 -28.08 TD (- His opinions require finding that IBM) Tj /F112 11.52 Tf 191.28 -.24 TD (, Intel) Tj /F112 13.15 Tf 27.60 -.24 TD (, Texas Instruents) Tj /F112 11.86 Tf 93.84 0.00 TD (, Samsung, Mitsubishi) Tj /F112 11.78 Tf -312.00 -13.68 TD (Sun Microsystems) Tj /F112 11.85 Tf 88.08 -.24 TD (, Micron) Tj /F112 11.93 Tf 41.28 -.24 TD (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others) Tj /F112 11.40 Tf 203.52 0.00 TD (, acted ilTatiolially) Tj /F112 11.93 Tf -333.84 -13.68 TD (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expensive) Tj /F112 12.28 Tf 0.24 -14.16 TD (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-) Tj /F112 11.14 Tf 220.32 -.48 TD (95.) Tj /F112 12.29 Tf -257.04 -27.84 TD (For all ofthese reasons) Tj /F112 11.93 Tf 111.60 -.24 TD (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe) Tj /F113 11.03 Tf -111.12 -27.84 TD (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable) Tj /F112 11.96 Tf 270.24 -.72 TD (, and find that JEDEC would have) Tj -270.48 -27.84 TD (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents) Tj /F112 11.85 Tf 342.72 -.48 TD (, the testimony of JEDEC) Tj /F112 12.05 Tf -343.20 -27.84 TD (members) Tj /F112 11.91 Tf 44.88 0.00 TD (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-) Tj /F112 11.99 Tf 224.16 -.72 TD (back clock in March-) Tj /F114 8.22 Tf 102.48 0.24 TD (April 1997.) Tj /F112 11.92 Tf -371.52 -28.08 TD (Decision 74.) Tj /F112 12.12 Tf 36.72 -28.56 TD (5. JEDEC members would ) Tj /F114 5.00 Tf 132.24 -.24 TD (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. ) Tj /F112 12.35 Tf 255.36 -.24 TD (Even if) Tj /F112 12.02 Tf -424.80 -27.84 TD (the Commission were to find ) Tj /F112 12.99 Tf 142.56 -.24 TD (\(contrar to the ) Tj /F112 11.94 Tf 76.80 -.24 TD (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a) Tj /F112 14.63 Tf -219.60 -28.08 TD (RA commitment) Tj /F112 11.96 Tf 98.40 -.24 TD (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives) Tj /F112 11.88 Tf 265.20 -.24 TD (, but rather would) Tj /F112 11.98 Tf -363.84 -27.60 TD (have performed detailed) Tj /F112 11.63 Tf 116.88 -.48 TD (, down-) Tj /F112 11.67 Tf 36.00 0.00 TD (to-) Tj /F112 11.73 Tf 13.44 0.00 TD (the-) Tj /F112 11.95 Tf 18.48 0.00 TD (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected) Tj /F112 11.64 Tf -184.56 -28.08 TD (life of Ram bus patents) Tj /F112 11.94 Tf 108.48 -.24 TD (, and that Mr. Geilhufe) Tj 114.00 -.24 TD (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the) Tj /F112 11.95 Tf -150.48 -57.36 TD (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "') Tj /F112 11.78 Tf 312.48 -.48 TD (can be \(and has) Tj /F113 10.59 Tf -385.20 -13.68 TD (been\) tested') Tj /F113 11.19 Tf 75.84 0.00 TD (Kumho Tire) Tj /F112 11.55 Tf 64.32 -.24 TD (526 U.) Tj /F113 10.37 Tf 32.64 -.24 TD (S. at 149.) Tj /F113 19.18 Tf -135.36 -21.12 TD (10 A ") Tj /F113 11.35 Tf 51.84 -5.04 TD (high ') Tj /F113 10.95 Tf 27.84 0.00 TD (known or potential rate of elTor) Tj /F112 11.99 Tf 151.68 -.24 TD ('" may be indicative ) Tj /F114 8.14 Tf 100.08 0.00 TD (ofuneliability of an) Tj /F114 5.00 Tf -368.64 -13.68 TD (expert opinion. ) Tj /F113 11.14 Tf 78.48 -.24 TD (Kumho Tire) Tj /F113 11.27 Tf 64.08 -.24 TD (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe) Tj /F112 13.14 Tf 150.48 -.24 TD (s elTor rate is unown) Tj /F112 11.72 Tf 111.12 0.00 TD (, since his) Tj /F112 12.09 Tf -404.40 -13.68 TD (opinions can) Tj /F113 10.94 Tf 65.28 0.00 TD (t be tested. His potential elTor ) Tj /F112 11.91 Tf 148.32 -.24 TD (rate is high, as ) Tj /F112 16.57 Tf 71.76 -.24 TD (DRA ) Tj /F112 11.99 Tf 39.12 0.00 TD (manufacturers are the only) Tj /F112 12.11 Tf -324.96 -13.68 TD (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of ) Tj /F112 16.57 Tf 305.76 -.48 TD (DRA ) Tj /F112 11.96 Tf 39.12 -.24 TD (manufacturers rejected) Tj /F113 11.05 Tf -344.88 -13.44 TD (his opinions.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000718866 00000 n 0000718925 00000 n 108 7 0000719105 00000 n 0000719272 00000 n 0000772094 00000 n 0000719815 00000 n 0000719428 00000 n 0000719559 00000 n 0000719688 00000 n trailer << /Size 115 /Prev 718537 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 777985 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000825337>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R ] /Count 17 >> endobj 115 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 116 0 R /Contents 117 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 116 0 obj << /XObject << /Im118 118 0 R>> /Font << /F119 119 0 R /F120 120 0 R /F121 121 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 119 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F119 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 120 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F120 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 121 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F121 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 118 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im118 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 41632 >> stream Y=ڏ/xQ@aZ&SQnB (򛚏֫Y1:MSYGV*Beu$e 0`v&Z s‚dR22Z &W+Q*z  ABa0D 2!v8N ^v.*"*-݂@l(PPqs "A~ntpB?r q34 h"G_oTfK,@A 2N5]{WNׯ/0[_Z]ZNP3Tl6Fftc43>ut5^ik f ό&0 C0::#D9"I"xٚ(3NeĐ!d"ѽUװٰ(ֱՆ'¢4w($'ʱʘD`<:X g— pSl1 d1O p\06678ԊwdYIL4fc 8f@88fft '3kI1!ό 4ރƂ <  t4|h'A:'еL/bׂA?B !8)B45B!0PL aBd #nu]0zz#MAm' S"VO_[(~/! T$p}0T$Lv]Vi ¦PU '=WouЮ K]_O]{k#<|&zwj oEIO/::/8{"Cv_}ܗco߿XKZߵu_^K: y"!z_[oK}]{n{_[}Lwڱ]/k .~?K~zﾾ/[ _l AN[턿K[v}}ut0Jb_ ֿ״׿_ҿ].ߴ~ &iAI6i?@OcI鷱W {a+.߿~鴛S@00 hTP 0@ 1ᮛVV$/XJ馽® O/y[ԿkW 7ُ>ۨa-. jVIaBA`h0 Π|=i!^C z{|G_uC밙ZZL4ը 4/M?+/Zɶ DDDDDDDJʜW~S ‚>(7W / Ph ax jB:M ګa8a[bxqXTl Rw0[ -cm("""")B:g2&kW(,04V& MB6E ؠA,&h4- !40Aa qQ@A:b$㈈YD4 a2q & 0w j#RԿ dW10AA85 """"""""""."#2"""""" AaRUIR"poXA=V M dU`AEKئ&D~@pV#6+#XLvV̩'PT‚)\;6%E(*en;v.d)N‚AAM>*#CIjǶ(* p qv̈ʦB;꨸UK׏~* p+f>VF]o!Sgs3qqޫ}~ mRn6f$ BA2l@f.d ČuޫL Ћ aFHpH!0Fcy RᙑSqGeўmST$ү Dꋆ;>ed NCB |xCL a0PhX*aDd"r scD :E!qk~AGhx;E%&x4CEDNEDTA*C&L a4A  <͊pR@ " du1I3<ٚ A(EЉIc: 5CdIHA#'3C.KWNuZ];ב AN xEDyƁ6 #TN2ns¦0' Q;!4AA=0 B`i 'pPA "E 2W][ttzWJG+E?RlWxM<4%E44 &;SD$'xMSD.'Bji`5vR~:N ~`.pb{kWsYƍϪx РMbhzA~nha"?kVu}[k^G /iҧII%pM?Itm)9zt$[at?5?ӫu_=տ-P߭'յuoTd*ϧEɎ ߊ]$? J^}C.r,/LևO{w_Z_!tLo++?CL1ݽނN?߅ɍw]3D_i&9Amנ8H׸_W'_BJXCKW7/+ H"Q_I5]/__~C__xmI}~?$~-X i7km~[Jx_׶_]>AGW0o /aٵ_kiv4k]aO$y$_b*K[OV KcԿ5__RWupw[vnkK ث[ aV* /[iǛ ͯk__i6Z\  iM?KS $4aBiXTX c?/_aki-~mZK_k 4m4a "04TA@M1ADZkpa% LUGF/|])ئs0] ]zX[M VH`;ޚat) Io l&M55ip L2 ੑ  1@ lh0d#kqW׈> Kӊ۰AGLW %m(=i0""""""""""""" a`[a|[ VT  @"B A!@!b}&0Nd#⩧MlSil0DDFDDDDNb"! a+` Rc Wiڂi@` {i0A L!ii 6XP@RcU0S0Aɛ3\090 NN""""""""""""""""""""""*tb""K#e]%qJzҤIVLJS!GZ 1 !Aɻ;#QQvT(P4(((-ꢜgj0@DZD\=%%k V89ۙ>7NMH6M*J~сLֲW}[鴡<( ` y1J0s _ԕ?L  @S@œ ԄrBC@Ph'B)%_O0 Ϣx'aL 0jkN0gAؒ:ZV_9i94Ɖ4a"v\j4r ,`L5D~I$Оv8DxD}~"Ciͳ[ _%AP Aw J_Aat!!_ح-/z /Έ=H,6o _i\6C*߿o~_ƖrV(VDvD._i[~W׺~/.Կ]v_i_eml(V=-l&G7 ^Vjg~Nޖ#Mb*j"⓾!2?u\V'al+i6 4GA6B Zk[b߆Gj=IMa(a% 7I'i iLM0AȐ{ )A]aC %ja0UXL a3aVawUUaME0ALQ0 AqqD0D8f>)w & i‚ b5h0B ȪA&)\ͦ§ُ_t~oI+KK^_ߖB E*iPaUKp^ 18@"I F0p8c⛭WڴK0=PGկ[ .魆  qQ@A(0@تA8iluvլw~Ii*CKO[خ[!@دkV_nLg a…j 6DpL$ @m`jB0 6=6a.i18I4J&jC mK#aDDDDDDCPLP@)c:3Sń"`iTAaa{fta# 6*@ڊdGQMDB 40A#(6#a68tb"" !`ИRnpa~]IPUMii6M5 ;Kta(iA4 """""""`JPGFF&UI `0lD`D a55/DDDDDDDDF^_!an ت*«D@xL*aLY3;T. d2 Lf+Gj3 TTA0 %dy9<qH.MBa3ws_:AJUP\(/[=~ڮBwt̃ʖI}/2,MF1;42[륯-nzq׭YnF ` xS#dFY_M 28< `E)DJO<)Y dFjÃHAD a4TTPA4< мa$'3 H\Ao!!G_1'!LgL՜3FʱG!D3<):OO#Al EA<' p QxEQȺ K (D96 rx4gS0yN pXOM 7g/_zZ%G'T"QDL"wM *o:< .I hT&`p1tAa<  !{%xM:V N I0_҄=NƓH@ɜO(h0MI8>;*=±ʱ4IOႅM5ϡճ맧ղ:|ǰƱդ>m'ݧA-̗3ĵ/'ٱ;8ԕ7< +h Ad''5z!82.t331 pWxj/o)B߭[xNVA{L'Sפޗ da?}d$zoo7_W./l\_~[KkzoL yuOU\k}a%0]t뿿>8 #Gk_Ol7_/_+}פ?% 8~!?}wӶ'^?y:Ɂ~m/\pނa^w_m!m/="0߹"rG?  GG ~o{Ovl }h/wU~o}}]ka=Kz$C%_/H_&_u^KIo_J68;_I F/]/9݅/i]6Xi~mw^xo}oiFvF}U#҈;m8Lvٍv OZمaz_߫i}ki{_a馝!GLUZLW +; `JӰ}YҾԾ5kk_[Z_ۯ-v"@@ 5QQNU M>B CX5@>khK 1]L0vk*Aizm_pa5/&DrЃ5MXh A@0aES!H0!GQi1z6a!q[ m,% ` փ-ӻ^„ M„6yꪘ &ڦ +VjQ0J[ SINWv $ a(""""~("l&LѓPL&287iȮ\¯j 0NM1F`=G`***!2$&0A@#@0@⩊a! x2  i% 5' ԿPMSN_AtE!(I4!2$L#"UmaAuDDDDDq 3X $]aGp_,ɥ8a'yg[QɱW&JiNê T3uwߥ_vilz "#ɰҪDҾOYmICOp?jҟDs#\DJlr $.CJ[2CAC; w gz 2RdYD%L +xD< .[N̒5Ȑe a34&;|Q*!0oxL'w}'_t;@'eKU)z}}I]Ȗ$RW]_R:0V~kuT}{ᦕZN?:36:ij__x!4lq 8G4S萈ׯ뜟zJn5ta0A- ! YpaL ϭ"7JH4*ầL1ŦA<&.i H%$xN `dDȖCQF `Sžl "/LrJHܾuoUmC"6ƉC-J0 w#pAAvP0[ MP] Rwn#I ;7I;hE{;a;VפHv i_AL$X0蓽OtؿJ$W߯nD?CGh46]xa % 2#iJ(DwcÃ"hȓVBWzto^D޿! wڵT[Cޓ~"A dH~֕G\ ոKv:v]=J^tuu ?]!/A[oȏCzߍo-__^U_ _zּ?Gۑ#ua_}?ƣ }O#0}{}D9R-_߄_"?A]Nݝ7~_??_?iStwIdK~814 'AyviV bkߤO񮇵ZWU{|/k%{aս'a?; pj?MoKty,M$E}mm{i|v_U*vou鮞z~,_\9C]~K-aTڿ_v_M{O~~Z~<pKiz޿ھ |a'l?Z k' B s/aWtL6 X?X~:ml8:d׾߿%D'}w zo$vd"W} Dql"QXm=~ ޗH`KAo-Awl7~?00|75O7m/ڵk{~?_KtKm3@;[&CNwz'?.OS{O?VMޖaZMlNI&'G &ޝ&RWA@Ș{_^޾U?utס^['^XohօƕO?.ҿ[]$H|BǾu%t[H/ Ow߷R|"o/#\_߿j}_}'J>; W_T7O(g %/%]߄IFmZ=  wkii}k~_HC_ikjUQ/_v}--VHV{ $Piym+KIw~_kQccz$Jԍ4RH_P¿=+I/KNoJժױMU\K0m/ w $J$;‘o[ _ _a^־z{_o]bl$A)5B[ *KM1QCث_bXa+u_ͯmuͫXapE=K[a/# Bj]؄@x@A<( R!A6J$itI~K]^Յ¶al!n0@ B ?WYǃ0^aaN&&(4#(6DNIi.Ƕq (:kꩆqDDDGM%YO &ϖ0 L*a0 CL% a0 6#  o  d#vA@@(=ЈЈ‹ 3 efrˎn_M+ WkDjM'm2+^iIDDDDDDG Lgp<|ց‚h0  q&0T U I|DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDGKA+/6AB`˺q~?K (7*N2 aT)*hAp\([+-oŀnE w3% L(PBA> $(PBpo޿_|r&T`9`{}VklC:c>fc =5U}W0 *4;B0 N)22q š]}--u4SoTOL3„AB݄B a (A If""P!'_|g\Og-U蝴N^4 .'.-Q'hU5D PTOL<' & `GL"ЇC AH2q dff##<:By2O6ȇf#Qg"fHpC4E;6|S6BH6iy2A:M|<ЅxA7j2pNS ` JL!v 0 h @%*a|0A4.;B@ZM6 Kذ'n,]AlLQv;ٰDO1=5WuWn.^aDa/]__( l"Q"qn/6.~Z{7Ukz}~ mKJ? !_ޛuڣ?H_ C/ 7 _ O_[J?ڰ__}6c{d7l6 _/^^_k>_^K?{CK!]}kow d_AK.[ۢ#m-/ /7 WW_mmKz_;k-Vb}}2?Zij]L/[kmi{`II41 mXi8a}4[jޥ뮽]i?No( aP@0zh a  h8Cc[b()b[!ao/%v/<ƽ1a|0 } 7iX[iC0pAv & S"::iӴ⻆iDk'ZŶCb;@ڇIMmcGa0L$A^&q3 \4Ah&ȎL u A!w!GiUuk[Z{L|zlTL;V.j8:80&0Leza0[ &iSL0dXAmA@0@AȎ@ A m4a6㈈`EaB$ hkگjM{Xj0 ]ᦥ\0tb"""""" ab -B"""  f7DDqMBSAVA6*;U` Y(heMFMBa2d)ge T-#Qu` .+##\^JCf aB-`&TCI귰aT(. dfC9 8d?EWUPaE;i;w @'߫%JmZwpۆ_{?{i7U};'%"r0d>#;:!7ŭWkPʘL<i20E/ I r4"d!sHAasq<Ιгך j &q鵪xM2SMpA ?!P͌f)Jf32.$e;)_uDo&rYg': D9'Zh{(z 4֙ A& '0D! dÂ)N ŸN)Sf826jAC:)6F# pf$F_SuuIظ|VC,,4MGwDj05T# ``0T `0 O ; `=zM ,-$Is}HnE;8wƂ 8:'mv;DcCH484‚L*ixa98 [ҧ[ ޸WAGwtE: ߦN ƉD8xDBEvH֯6[UA}Bzoi:MJMff` plA"CH7"CV&-/}~}[_MW޿Si<&t^zouJ+ g_>} _ uQM{^o+U]]ZծBwXxi1_v6 !RnkIW}ꞛGa/Xl1qcڎG_kNqõJ=Fpc^_K޷N4'c/ol"q୰]]:Il5d5/Dݾ ~ņiMhl2w6{$xok Aa߶ _uOaa߯kֿ_i7եݯ7g0sV$`.>޾W6]^/޿mo17㊿wv wVS ݴ߿u_tu qkƛiZvKa/L/[Iz_Iu_WjUJi 6*kav;K}&;q~4__n,oK0A &M0E8;0@ 0@64MVGiD!@☦?‘P i~Wi6lz{j/.A  ,4ԼڧPMPA ` ! 0 2I %iDöiZWlS0h}װҺm-IkOJ""""""""" AF&?&~ _kPL(b aȐUpA4Ӧ-{b6*I@LWwl80B,\aMeAp & U'H&vDdGAM @a)N@ """"""""""Q& aD1a0N0ڂ4Ȯ]aSA&8AK& AXQDqDDI،{_}u^]v B[ ZZXZ 663ue?@]ZyrMTC;(-Ң\xP:v Q7h֫ 8{9 fwkƩ: _@ !$3cP|"gQ2.مLP<*t4A.„_E8p4C0{W"M^Sq3|œc >#kҎ|_FZ,0.֥ HQ\A}'viA@'A6e3r(d2;)__][E2ou+_ڷIn 3C5y0 yFTXM0@B е‚xP@eAIH" /jR7:G߿TTDd AEA3 ^a4A ! B St,<,/aQx _M4Nߢn;'pRaJA 0AaccS|@@΂3f<'RN8f( Ό&tdeSSTjdhwl2z5II$NN OhtCAn^Rn,̓'A B;h7j "nwDI\*h4@ 43<0Da/BB !` A! S`0r%f\9CD9#tӤ붽N2/V[j m iIwW./2NꩢwU @OA0&pT h;j 0(M{0*a4Av?:ZN>62%l?4i:O xAd`ɜNˀA>}4N h0&ҭWdwk}{Okkv~BIO "ߠx~n OxA m'eAp Nl LGO׷Xaoz^ 1R7 ֮+Wdn{nwXb+~\xj>4O±}Խ[.:#bʳ<0W~K/u0_&il7+ D uT> c8.^lH?[h/'$?m_cy:~Ɍ }_ ׷a p#~"O_/.%ioMOwH/׶}WY=d<ץxb_o޿U߱Vd!ޗد: o?]ߠ [$K_{~׫_9GZa`+]:oS kkZZi?ގ3}[_5Vmi5!B c—mXkխm_{{WֻmVmGڮvp҈c!*)b;R>W *z[^Ҵޝ{_ui_Ѱ6U a  ;LuQR6i8a[ 0|ca+0 kjH={ᄾxif #[_U5T„`i 4N {ia&IjE[ k'A1^ivZV 66){[ ~e興""" a22`Dja L&"d&iv!ȰA!!LP m6A60 4r݄al0jNiDj58 0 `0 S:aXiLDpIm mP l @jh0B lP ئj60@*Di6` 0H W„1P[\+ &M}5{P 0dWխ5'EDDDT8tb"""2{@ϳ$pHHDA3`A2 3v5|DEC]/KM-R CKb`XUPh6%aDYW$#ȳDBd+n(PM3fFJ  \aKqH;DW5pwP w# s_&.vSPVhD2E^}CFILJV?W_U-#R?ќ_593ё믪u@ L ``Bl!I03ؙ ~ldRej21\]A:T`M0 a2^6)IP3D8SܺDME"vh^C0ALD MPa:A0P>&a'fؠ 83*#h2k#Q jdIU2-JtK!Xej Lk. @6oHnOxyEE2nvN*xALL"/SA0TA M$'&E]j_~{KR޿/ХӃ6~jذIOt&Ղռ kG^WZ۷]viMM6'jս[ip_iji.*ڡu}WZzuߧ]kX__^MWƞ5^>5kJ/j3B?k,GB_}q$]Rb]{7/&:ta_Cuzw/uK_onB&"Ov?!C_=:_ kz!ئ/[OOߥW_Wj_vWd~H$]K {ia}zwi_kk_ '7ދ߰M4ZZޠ[ 멅Vviֿ~OH!z/WV[iDaba 0`_^mk}i^]_! h0 SXAPi4k;q֓~lRﶞu kͦҴAmy6j놿 2+i$AMAȐiTJ[NJjbn%Kج'm-#M;MUb aЈ8L &)( S" [P 1  `? mMXI6IK^)aҶ8v#B""""""""  0Ah00A4A*j bM4 0@ؠ@ئBAA,GDDW&T7a~L-h0aC 5~Jt4TiMtH8"" a"* ?Ta +, !A gu.U_|DhDDDDDDDDT:2ZZgfAT%j iZF'LV !Q 鄝E%:i\aTY\"ܨ ""?_Qhѕ-UL(R\2A (_ Y\-U BdXŸnH(^*gpWv| #AvG#ԌyH"䈜dSR =#Ni;uo< ;(q4 (mqxidN.v"C 00t 6*M0XˊpPD (L B AS< ύ2S ! PqB[MJM& {loނX_8IO2`TvUPdO/ ɺL4CL&I&;C¦Bi*'AxAU]'nWt?6|apd\fMiq4 L/Z/F.,i= {8ދv>&rFDn/~鶘Z´d\ir8 p'0a.`ȐҰdW. g] &!IuH7h oi6_zWZMA%OM_Z:=;CAK5ZZӭ_~R-:_[/,mwn׫__k_,S#// ꟯:#+uַak<+ u___)jwC//3n[㖎cc{߶{zD_"?_CVCuDD+ccboG%[K __r_tUߠM[/K}O$ HUd!i_i64Vk_0~mb_-{]& _0$ivi}i}§V֪~ (MV*Mյuͦ_٥IijU_P! h0@id Z m֚ujVn? _1L0YͯaskԺͧ[Kק~i b@ `i6);݊cn8K]b)5mX;_A ?cbIװi_R<&+|Y\R"0$ nL0 @GM1@H4mWiWQ6+m&aqOuEDDG HDDJ!0Aa5PiBma! h6A@ @ u@ᄩ1@ `0@LRuKI'T!0lf`RL(_ ium5M'j /v6Dh:h1Uz] !BiʚF" &kRna55M4&{?ws u? h0Pa}0""""")DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDECRlZ$K#5Ju^ KL.0x P+!6(0 ˄ ""?U%J+ggBBXRx2uPPPBadK,Ɔd>U{(* . s9~K[P_;vU@*0tW^7ȣ*Pl pmX}kuT}q^RP8) RLB6AK3ʈᚌ=`SS)zU]WqAϊkA h\\Z 62s03 SX_H.RJ%eAM60 "85# sc SCЊa9F a(_/@LY: E4^0j2`Av;qt&DݢIAAi D! f!Nl h'O "h&A .F%Q$9'='!eFQdf:N~HD)ޟtaEM" u W"qAmZi'Jp'a)VT $A00SA  A8E@a0,!H((AA ( &@MnKa6zM.t&6g/X2`8_0d˓=Q;aSDinTNVNaSM]A!*iT`0n _[W[u_zts\+A7c0]Wm^Tm6q{Wk_eVV6V_kizio`}(&Am*]vMҴc;1Ǜ^ k }uM߭~C_qMB 4a`AaNAC6(&C}6LVR/`jkZ-v^bm/x0] 6'ںe8A )oB 4 CTAtէTii=5Lm1\T>bW]Q] 1hP0 ~{i6XM60A#AQM0IA1 [P(MA '=> $jP#eLhM [ PI4A#htSTM5 ` aCha0@]!gVM"&W7 &4wM510 +S0a"#˳Y^!REC_`$:UzXL/PaRDAMQ8DK?咣2vݝͧ-}/I8 U(P&1bvk ߛ(-m4҅cZC.v vgg _u__MQU)ћ")9vFAaPCA&EHF硃#ZFue<@ό&* & <(AC3PP@"P#A*.z9*l,NOBǝu_^&UB'UQ8hNMMBv#O ͊P4A{0 a0LaN!K#$p4y|q"gzx@M{qu8AfꠘQ;hzQDݢv'cM0L `0 L g@ fb$ $3KE aHxd1sj8 "AA e$':u6 όձ>ޭ|Oȹ3I  ALhhƨPdN D`JNh37wC0(M2'x `bi !*`X@to}&x_դ&nd lM< Aqp0M,:h08`^Q!&`:TDmiaÄN5 CMBm^7ЫtOON N n-"]}A'AH&v|xwX4Q|EEPe_];__v4VZ_i[ ~M w[-+Ia>Nfc8^|\o邑roEn WQ#?]=?uֿoT֕z_ׅum_>a>G6ױ՛߱ҿܴ^z?#(G׵N?Ǿ?;'8³o۱ʉ#_XóoX:(õᇄm/a<7دۥ_mK5a_QY#AlB!$kAmaAmWKцk9WA^H3A}?úiua7o}.ҵa]okh_}^X7dikw4_VTx[iwՆ‘s (iL5__t0 /LFiZ إb)DJ /{ /m}ۧzu[_^aT QTE&õ]iq G☭v+[[TՏ[R=6]Xkk}0OaaSMPA0@ 8NMثJiDoR{am&vӃ1ujV1Hj%{ ʚ$)pa4n;!t@g-a&HNm4 ` jkㆽ6L:? ą m& v;Ҹ""""""") ѡ0Ogk[jTaE2$'0A ت4A4l{Zi) >jHGtVA8B  , pP5B}a A4Ph a&!PdHPAfGPS &0.5Lí>00SPP LRHDDDDDDDG+KI/K"b% a$M( a).*47P`D !E6 ?MȚ&Ԣ[Lg`fhY :PD=B-㧑+geE#vvfI%hɧh@^ KP0&B⛤*ׂ9dwQMgҮF?-$Je<@Zr 0q*P=?]_]~_-TzyњQ.CZk~\| (D"=.y" fA G k޿5 5\B 0<0L!h` aAA&D N]6*l'82ICF0UW^SCwDD⩦PTBi& &<0 (N0>2@6`dy d#">z5R:^Jb#Ϋu庑e <'I81΋.[HhZ pSLP>40 BZD aM 2.i(dj"9`,dC#d:tpSFȑf$FEI_Ia"42%`ȑL6輠Ū/`ɗ'TN'OA0A p@ B tA(La T&owWa:O &IE?4˭mNtN x&dIM0@5:ipiA׿zպҺk] 0oIh&t>!Ij-4_CP~,Y: ͿBE|o}߯uUUu֭S[KIIdnnX82.yRvȐGIYMl1o\uus_[o&oxN7?WMaI40Նޓzmx-uۭ?}:?k8?X`u~+_cb׆}oXx⿿Jo_/_ oki {o}' Џe#%8vpo ?PDaἈ1H܇woo/_{ڿu륹#7oO~FVo}}ѯ +E#OW }#kO]o9_kWJi7kW׺_O_[zW_bJm/_OKإ { %cP6_M߿}iW-!qLAOa(a%aW4aSbޯO{\ao/>$kmv] Zk~ж &B 8@ؠ@0D?6:a@;Oav}1Z6+bS‘iK`sZ (&RpH#[50a4dW&:u8a %M6a 0 `i@bqZ{@WQ08҈5qm$ݥVzkv_Q!a+@3\0[/iji4m5LA@ ) vA4i 2KwQ0&lə5im0Bi0\L2 MUL4qAdGAMAP@@ ڈЈ`&~S >& h5Ɏ0_00tPRc DDDDDDDDDDDDq""" &LFe9V1~ޟWk[~_VRn~yc=K6:ؿV}==o[}6{ax/?LaukT%$?p _} _m _KO2u m%z//kA_GH/6h/ۭ!ȍm0_u;l _i}j/oMZ_g6}ׇ_K߯Kֽ}z^K_w}#$lR_m[[_1}/c^=[ݷ___0]_m&l |waV+O11o_?Wi#WaJQEVF l/M]w}}֮j]}%kb D=R!m `h&}ZqU 6îal}1ca6ץͮ/$A jM0vAM6D a ؠ04N % *QA_}k믬UmuWy{Ar?bX DDB! `^^ϙj ֭(4a 0A*!8B:dGa6)40 (6VI~RX0S59ve@S4h q6)@0 ɧ*$0@ ' @0N""""""""""%\ a3N[vMwa2#i (&jwTIk!DDDDDDDR!e' 0 0&~@gw? `03xF!6CωSц|DDDDqH8؈;u%J0X\S!ZMK)a*W@n.?MN[8U\/-JK/V+`_IU_>{Q j(@a,ɢ,Ql(\Zxj2 endstream endobj 117 0 obj << /Length 3752 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im118 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F119 12.06 Tf 74.64 708.24 TD (Commission) Tj /F119 11.79 Tf 65.28 0.00 TD (s remedy findings) Tj /F119 11.91 Tf 85.20 -.24 TD (, Mr. Geilhufe) Tj 72.72 0.00 TD (s own calculations \(adjusted by the Commission to) Tj /F119 11.97 Tf -223.68 -28.08 TD (reflect the factual record\) demonstrate that the marginal value of the Rambus technologies over) Tj /F120 5.00 Tf 0.48 -28.56 TD (available alternatives was zero. ) Tj /F119 5.00 Tf 155.04 -.48 TD (See ) Tj /F119 11.83 Tf 20.16 0.00 TD (CCB 6-) Tj /F119 11.95 Tf -139.20 -28.08 TD (The Commission should disregard the testimony of Rambus) Tj /F119 12.33 Tf 291.60 -.72 TD (s experts as uneliable and) Tj /F120 7.78 Tf -328.08 -27.60 TD (irrelevant. The factual ) Tj /F119 11.99 Tf 112.08 -.24 TD (evidence \(as opposed to theories and assumptions\) establishes that) Tj /F119 11.71 Tf 318.48 -.48 TD (, absent) Tj /F119 12.15 Tf -431.04 -27.60 TD (Rambus) Tj /F119 11.77 Tf 44.40 -.24 TD (s deception) Tj /F119 12.08 Tf 53.76 0.00 TD (, the JEDEC standards today would be free ofRambus) Tj /F119 12.19 Tf 265.44 -.72 TD (s patent claims. CCB) Tj /F119 12.73 Tf -291.36 -56.16 TD (To Restore Competitive Conditions and Permit Effective Administration,) Tj /F119 12.61 Tf 0.00 -14.16 TD (The Remedy Must Apply To All Technologies in the JEDEC ) Tj /F119 13.15 Tf 311.76 -.48 TD (Standards) Tj /F120 5.00 Tf -348.00 -27.36 TD (An effective remedy must address all ) Tj /F119 11.99 Tf 180.96 -.48 TD (nine) Tj /F119 11.95 Tf 23.52 -.24 TD (markets potentially impacted by Rambus) Tj /F121 7.44 Tf 197.04 -.24 TD (' s) Tj /F119 12.04 Tf -437.76 -27.60 TD (deception) Tj /F119 11.76 Tf 47.28 0.00 TD (, CCFF 3113-) Tj 65.76 -.24 TD (3182) Tj /F119 12.04 Tf 24.00 0.00 TD (, and be capable of implementation without detailed review of) Tj /F119 12.28 Tf -137.04 -28.08 TD (complex techncal issues and patent claims. Rambus) Tj /F121 11.94 Tf 258.72 -.72 TD (s arguent that ) Tj /F119 11.97 Tf 76.32 -.24 TD (the remedy should be) Tj /F119 11.98 Tf -335.04 -27.60 TD (limited to the four markets in which Rambus has successfully acquired monopoly power) Tj /F119 11.60 Tf 423.84 -.72 TD (, RB 9-) Tj /F119 11.85 Tf -411.84 -27.60 TD (, fails on both counts.) Tj /F119 11.96 Tf 23.52 -28.56 TD (Rambus would ensure that the greater the deception against an SSO) Tj /F119 11.87 Tf 324.96 -.72 TD (, the weaker the) Tj /F119 12.26 Tf -361.68 -27.60 TD (remedy. A malfeasant that ) Tj /F119 11.96 Tf 132.48 -.48 TD (deceived an SSO regarding multiple technologies could ensure that) Tj /F119 11.91 Tf -132.00 -28.08 TD (any remedy would be inadequate by enforcing with respect to only one technology at a time.) Tj /F119 11.94 Tf -.48 -28.32 TD (Any remedy would be limited only to that one market) Tj /F119 11.91 Tf 257.52 -.72 TD (, permitting the perpetrator immediately to) Tj /F119 12.06 Tf -257.28 -27.60 TD (sue on the next technology. To the extent that the perpetrator were successful in compelling) Tj /F119 12.15 Tf -.24 -28.56 TD (companes to sign license agreements) Tj /F119 12.04 Tf 180.24 -.48 TD (, the payments would continue throughout a series of) Tj /F119 14.22 Tf -180.48 -28.08 TD (fritless ) Tj /F119 12.08 Tf 42.24 0.00 TD (Commission enforcement actions. No situation could better explain the Supreme) Tj /F119 12.96 Tf -42.24 -28.56 TD (Cour') Tj /F119 11.96 Tf 31.68 0.24 TD (s statement that the Commission) Tj /F119 11.89 Tf 159.84 -.72 TD (s authority ") Tj /F119 12.24 Tf 58.56 0.00 TD (is not limited to prohibiting the ilegal) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000778314 00000 n 0000778373 00000 n 115 7 0000778561 00000 n 0000778728 00000 n 0000821238 00000 n 0000779271 00000 n 0000778884 00000 n 0000779015 00000 n 0000779142 00000 n trailer << /Size 122 /Prev 777985 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 825057 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000873709>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R 122 0 R ] /Count 18 >> endobj 122 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 123 0 R /Contents 124 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 123 0 obj << /XObject << /Im125 125 0 R>> /Font << /F126 126 0 R /F127 127 0 R /F128 128 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 126 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F126 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 127 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F127 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 128 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F128 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 125 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im125 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 42337 >> stream M8bxRj -̚4ZX i[Fj>ZʟuL%(7(Q-EZ&FvKfA i3#y2,T&O d(C#"Ani ྃ LRd̓#)pn \. (Pn_*X=$T}p[¨ZН1 f%59CӦ$k%Jhgi{,x9+?Dh_ZK%t|CN,2.d΃e|f$9}tWUuPgƘA 50 ` '3lgU) l\ \p" #sH(HS맪IjTª'2P &BpU pE La4ȁO^ 'pT3X` hdO`0zM SO RLgvpf@#ԓ'D>MeFpΣ:$fG["=ǓP! \# '.4ƋF 'mwD7D=% TA -B0\(\&  a4^ 0 OA(A !P4 La< kE{y9Ӥ6f3lL<'A9.AbDMhOQ3^8~ ̼/8:2g'M &jIMVtpz @7j'tN DhÆt?_?ZX0Vz%0N > f MMOIg"yL ? -ܼ&-0dbxwiZ>= 믥t5MoTu{I}&H'Ӓf)xnC]'wlt}&]W׫_MwMokO] nҭ.մf}7N*\&}_Oǡ~mk[om_K/_bicO[FOoRzf~ߧ ^,k9bv6l+QD^'):_׈,?G#5Ɍa_ , i,nk _~7DG_7KCק7-/_m",7>~[};~}_o5d7 #rD/77_]\U3O=/{~m.%okiuߺ}7ﶿ^{{߿{ _aX0Jk uVim}N}}iZzkvKحV6>ҍմl%7a) =@`bv*)DMHJgVQO]O֚f-s\0w 0dG,L$jH4 p40  5BMBiAȃUP`DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDa?)L,0 aJ~aKpL)0a0B *g0LL a# A0""""""""""""#B"""""""""""#? B =*a(͐vQ 0ɽ68.\-b-Ku v؞vWdk;+g`T(PP<  ad"A$B qQu]WWoX9Q&v~_`fĞ%vctޫ}dxE1_}-VsA E 0PN y4:G 2>B E_<ffȌ#2]#2]_UL SA43c(A, &ahh]" ! ! "d-A&DP\)d|DVAFK *}2!hh!hvªDh*$=S 'j nfSA]P0AB#4"4 :A$F Lll" B=ʁMBDȘRL A8(@' DP: pAOZ/hńAj,"v4]'mm'QhHEhT&a =4Ii30\ G L'B 8>b"G$ߙ:M"zr0Sb?z]`H6h : 7j@Ƌ/(&rN0`Pzkƒ&v;E8H0dM x2s'tNhn=_ סiiޛakuIo#MސotntVtA lh n&(m'P&Nnh@:At^M߿?NZZ uO#M7 f dpA3IzIoӤ-Mwni_u}+hRKߧ^ouսm{_[ipǫ iuڶҺk˵Wo[zuտɌ!a*݊+׿t____Ӷ`]wD.`k-c1_xc{L0D0a(-l=/2^k4^[ "OaWa.K mKmzp?~I8}G~ :Xo}i{$Om}wobms?d$vQY#0fm-m/4_AwaoK6׿޽7KMu[ns ~ "$o^_>k]ڷWj.WK_tUjմ-/ߴm/n=/~.k]_l/Ҵj]z[[uҍmKa}_umZ^1WXRZ %{ %[6m._ڵo[0uS ~}i v) @bRlRk 2|0T5Pҵm&+au0~X)Zz]zVvONmWkt݅Ji8Vh j@Ȏh`Q2b6*$k (l4mhI{XQ $A+ 6a*h1ʚOa;&1t[ʀM3a$AL *j}0A ( `LtE44h6a lH&1VHQAA":h: """""""""""9ʄ3F@&~aMVMBdASMRaPMXbtdG MiӦ+L ȎYO""""""p`m54f)p \C͙] k5: `Kd 2?`!`a0PDDDDDDqHDDLꖿ봴MaWQ\&Iz A J((hb6 Gdp`[eGfT(L& ihL'DGG@#;R24ery\/;\/hE v8.E;/ʶtf̝ȃAVT F29RDF S'dR$'@C544,!y8g5", PTJFh ԕAd2,g`aΞ(pL ]tNa ۠l)xT/zZA4!A7 6Th'_A:/*ߪkUmt^uK_[^OZ|']eWȤ2MVu%_UUOjmat.T׿I%KKFM~kmԷ2ϢDj"?^U K]qFz;z0( <u`gA3dfȈ!3|S##l2?dQ#r%Ht¤"K_c]~k[ iӔ MtA 5C0CB¡x&  „ >` 5YI RMk. xhCDņASD᪦ńp_Lت*{pIEE4zNDa3fZۮLЍFku{]'zD|h ݵ H6/h ݅8-0A봒 A ؁0AiIu|1KKW& 84&4ȁM'] ~E82%&a$tMQ1Kҭ^Nuq¦T;L/I~ ҦWޛIaS}NwKR+O26P$OI]/8EoA:'JD=B'k^k}M|};$A: I+I OAIJvI:u_U]:ZHuJM,uX^~Wa1/A ZK^I=֟ZZT3/ZJ5QBJYTr_aZD@Ҥ-x?`6_tZI/ҥa ^6\Tk_D޶}-U--Kt 7=Ji* m+/o*^~U$}u꒭I}}o_ooI+{Kn$&T$M/Ik$'$U+a$~nHAuWת^UK9?_:֖^iuwu[:܈KT/ֽZZKۮzokKmWZK#-,5YDtz_e\Յ׵oZ+aхUe륯kKIQ#S(_ZU==b 㿦%~ :(:J5KUKZңK_~t''=% kU4&(Ն64Wm*AkZFq99}_ 4jZUN0@d# lSLBj %VUӴcVT7RMKZ0pe9i'W2K­$-F] h1UPi AqL0@X d ;*Ӻ L0-l%^PMV&Sa&I'qIDE&PL aX.MaBe8E#pNZp@4T&+j+⸦ bB麨HZ0 p@@P !a a :@ 6y482H9ި /&TH6 'x; *C'Ӥ?\Bmh5L(*h4NDD*ap?HϤ-V:N4ւi?_"M@hh/):7L d4_LɜZ'SO/, E;hcDyyLN2`4JTQֺWi?g@ï݄> 'ItI G7EȷI.$ނ ӃI:VO82.POht.)KK-RꕴN7^V~t/K MV}'+O my.i7IqkrV3Xl=K}ڵm/~үWV龽ޟ~%tt_MKKU׷5__U?K.AU-/_ZUi{bK*?kB:m~֩R֫WU/ MLs9Ca/]U?$-*}kUȍ^ H%ZP",80]\D//߂?M'_ -UzJ^}/p}nal"C/_}//#_R}*ӥ h-o"Q%"Q҅KZR7A{W zTWפKOA_$vQ<6_R!aeפRQ!kHڗÛij^#E?a~!ƒzQHj^_Ra%jz_kҴmSUҥt=$N￮[K_ %XE+KK\*~]%H%#7IH=Km&Yi]Zi}_vVQQ J*)☝$Q;BA0Mޱ~^Z 1WVjak_xaxaoPf?/6%[~RT0 ja&J8/ %׶v] $jmZC+;5*SװLV6ݥ`;J?bN[T aU5 ⪚a4B❑!5LSa6+0TTTvvlwlU[LZi1L\SNi;I0B   [K jx 0Zl$'m4AzDP !5! : l*.G b$&Ȏh0AUDDDDEDH M 2 &qœt/kj4*aXi\AdW/a^a0]Er ¤"6""""""""""!`A!HC0B PIZ-b҆vDULc幔J e{2&YJs\b‚  e93dib (((([Ǹ;>OGi!7*$ Fh"+}&a-BDBz`Cat2yLfB=kvlb|`̈́ &Akvs `B yziwN$_K~KA<tSzOn+T=7W_W]TkZ']umTqS>.D #Јr2(fZxL 0! לjIs~ zI___ P`gƃqxL аl)QAlS1 \3c$͑R\)d|3Q RҬiwCN&-Hpª'l*q7nOi&`a4ϊ=aa 0C dK-[RiAN-IʎA3 h;Š: L; W 4jqhaM"pU=4T!. dx2"7.sAb8e e lA'# ex)E3t kEX!}&'>)`N mSe.EAAq4P@Kw7|x^4_Qx aC G B !ڡL!<p L!AaRI/O7]~OWO ҽVό6|nr;i6餛Ih"yQ;TDnDNJ&$NTNxyU'nnzoz:NJh'AjA  tM- Z4cs3T-$iaV~h{t]k]i]=]7o--~]IiminutAiRM kpگQ_եitIkڥJo~-$^iDp __>1KK늭i$JKB$$-, j/x/%N_܍_T}~*/uMү%]Pl:&Diw9i*KUIUT$zupA?=+ IjTA*jA7RҭiRKA*T/7%z}ADmKSz֒Z_?!_u (^JkM_K*/Z_~#>~CT}0T*U.\'XJN UR~V޻Ѹ7'Y`_nK$o֩R&}UmZW^ZI-Ukѭ?U뮕j^UKͭt^^].m/O_u^?I_Wפ 鶕kaKk/7_޼0VRawJ[}OjkTaeҗ'%\¥k(\£ J00Q~$[KJ@8h/ݏꛯXa $ރcwJUZ§'j_裯R&.MzJp "(A4(5cӶwU}oa%m.j+m-b@JZ:^JKIU]/NkjJta)34һQA6@M ӆ!0A 6TA@Pa&6*)IQ8␥IiTTR Ua8`M*_c)X,BTU\% $g@3r "L 3> ,~ SMjS *a&@jkM5U % % -SLBbҊbaUl0UIUM|TPJ"""8B" S}~@f5 ' &q Ȯ]tPQTSQUݪLWL*iXMT*URC0AaO0L&TL&L&L5L* a0L` L*`_%"""4 B"""""""#Q-%u) nJZ aaGmQxɰLvآ+z;ɦhd2Rܐ0h5;.!BV2()Pd1 LtP0 Kb%hLv5l"CM< §@+" -erT0hfD &!fj'i*^wPP`(-IwIOäm { AQo]W]4Zus#SȒIޓi.,! D'I-'"jEԍdxE9h,z3# NrAu,a$AO#S` 6.le .laK#IdƒVKm*UM(aU<*x(T}tL!PaB A400A0TA3還aTv)h&E_33D_Q;aΉN' DU4M੄Iۄ$Q!!4Hv0CL ²i Ρ`B28I7@˴oDONnKqAtA;E Z d^8;hZ:6 ,9HqD^bXYt/k M-XOC_CO_t]'IJ=`:MӲ~ .K>)I d[$ȯmAn7ȶmۦ.mտIk_.uwK$pa97+߽] N zM-{okK_;ӭu6 KF\WmuסOvצG_tt_Z~oo?.FճU_^a*_zNG7kB#I~~j42q\Y,*/,DB؅b!1]: "o?_^X/,G;nDD[ чKS_뻭]A ('o_nۥB;mn?k$u_Wz  ׫u\{#K߯OE~^?.솿_#I~޻i~fS+ϵI&[]~~_z_/$uiJFkKzKkk5ovK׿v]Ah$MhKnҰz xMuVMki~V% :**)]il4;֭}JlmSخ‘Xal' m?/80KR1`v~bBMBPMPn(02tƃi;w06"#b >*;J#㺈l vGVwWi/j *L*iAO ӂ  h`  ` @iuT:iݎziS{.^~MAaAIԛXŠdVՖ C 3aJa kidXL୦4  v6B: mE2M u=4-Aaj""#B"6"""""""""""  eM 0P  0 0^ȮXc„a{L* -BX}""""""#""""""""""""5?{ ޽ q'-%7&hEB庢iW;BdX M2eA+p0[<&dw񡝚pT\W `p}&֕zHɶV̭tTѡ׊9W8;OMqo]WTU幑dQ3du,d8ˢ(A>ht6pg 'JG~Wo-үIo뿆u?:B;C^z}_|A~~<m$?Qn,GK?&5.j_ڮ1~q]|/V~;8} D>r/?| oPҿo_$_#G-{M}/#s^ k4Kia&andAdGL  (6 6A5iq BBaeM?` p2㆛[R/ *IA"""""""""""""""""fPr0͙aU5ƗK҄-GF@PUxYHQ@kz=GYJPDS읙B\(^AS,2̨D";=eqxٯ P& L `V۵2(@tXPPPAݦ .( 􃪨PDž w9 &)t F>U4F;0t9Z[Zj*Ru_]/=6DC, FqY~q2aO{}}Sk0 0L`!|0@3 v` !|%B" "!2r!癡}u]f(AL&S0S… L8(A0L 0l)I lS1 8.C/6FD1O2pdK' ͡E-Ɖ (qxTN/! a"CN6M¦a!੦ ª4(UB$:Ӥ &FI'D A8:M"X:NR;4^4>Nd;af A 2g/tay34_bOO'nuW:T[ umL'J߶'ItuȖ'f)34IEoI*tD_ֺz_MkҬRKou߷oa5~[%i&}UN'_m_՗u}_ީW?[u_}KQ_}?⿏>]hWMӥ\[T/t qɎw4.~u[}wn_O]_σ]ז#uuoKz/PGB$8ïn` l>Lf?m~X<ʮ,7 }1_}_/ {t_Q_OWA~~U/۲F#rG>kO_ __Kʈ7{u#/"En/۽w[6)}z߮i{]{lj_=Ka{mWk5_7__[m K!]?q֓0 / ݺվVrC5Nul0mGkiSlRShU4m&*}iZ1Zj{w}{1 m4 1@B: ol `G 86*M4{I{i1=*m]V8҈@}>?v@ab;+A]_[L%'jUA\6 0a;TTzlpv=;+ӪbN+i; aLm N:Ө" S`LSSSš  pA[ᅰVru|4A0D AAB:h0Aa t! Aa2, @b""""""""#a0J5JaEp_L&A/ڪ2P00dn XЈeK:I-VrEI%Ф= * j!QI:mӂam3쯌 Nv' !vF| *xTq4PBࠠ(,X2Zb't &K:OP~t Em?O}ZUs2VanC ?v*]__/]_5 D1O8)8GQqF\~u3~'+ȗjO>0& ~PA  SB`: N͌E(D9r-Dseќt#qDSxT  D=S6*i7 ͊B,&f4a0PL PiAaA 4B`!S ! 98Bʱ#dR PsNr<2Q33)"!#u0-A.ld16` pS#&Gh~ '5\`ɗ'oNT398Avnh0`iੂi500PTAA4, A A B afAxAA' 'uELuI&MplM AD'd˓D'Na $Nܛ(h8 nSD0T…P(* iSiNTMVӯ |&80doIl8H& p&y9D$ i:'- >;z' OB;q2t>辆ILتv+ڮ7^t5§ߤMG}t&/\N oSa .fb4g8i:M`ޓ7`ȶv_uOZݥOt; l_^ xZMk}oڏuڏ}_-+ɏBNKzekkۯB{`?%"Oa.AO~C/د^Ak~| G _oX^߿@ݒ?_ܑ?ޝ$߄ A{/_R}~%/m/7u-cK<,7dKdK!/$~Hi}ڿ_knvn~__m~VK[K//jo/SK W1aKLڗ]+_am+_k{׾ߺikOiwE?㰇 K $~kK-}Axa/OaկMכ_a{Kmk:M;6ثMwҶ6b6*>aHSj]XRc/6)״b>+—10 aA"8NȎaB: `b NmPAi46JӪLGt6#i>8#-Zm+ծj#aLA|^i/aWi(Mja&  AȐi P ݐ*BcbZSZt׮iI1Iӄ Ah """""Ոa2`Se~^ š '0a5A½MSL&6DuȐh0A"B 0@A 4`  iBah&Ȑ6""""""""""""""""gAr a>jMj Vkj -3L֘NM'""""""""""""""""""""#kᄋs5+Wap`+GYTM$Qe 2o5̅Y.̲ fvNJ (-!4"\rVd&.kjA]0OPBU `EI:#P(/S*X:;Mm?qqa2 \O*9m9ǯۏUWI[F΂o8Py$s}$7fSZ3?d< PA A! \"&`PA!]AD.A.l#|q33P29+e?UU MMTL4Sg8(O54`0 *!` ` =4ftH!!H|'6Gȇg#d#2:3Y"ufdyj,H %\/# d#d 쳗t/(^0p}' S UL4HvrN&8zaSL*iPTS4ੂ FL0PPC3B 0AhCAx@ABa`A40@P 3₄[ G$N'A:N L|M KOq.N*'m]‚T4SAO M'UMBI¾*oޝ_mϊl^7:M6|S d\34pt`ȗ۠-tX2t'͢yyL: <7AEL"㗏[ZK[^W +nzI paJLGDM a4m ,MopdK:M6peف ]~]~}}[k~^7oJph6Z^&']-'5T:^G*]uޗOӴ5Ы}?Ot5__K޾چu]_drOC ܘA?Koa>C=I__l?^Bu/o?aVXԱ/l LAl?"On }6?쐟AoAacK"Q%k Aa __ %޾ݭ_Dw}6^o+yBt#Hoa߿޿޺zz__} i7__i6WI~A^mul/uc/4o/׺to/KKGj7VlUޗaSWSi6?ow[K+_{_Zv4PTqڱ ]EvJ?vMím!1f;7 1;5m/Rj_ՊlW Ȑ0i ad 0A )0wJUaӃ㍴>6+ب*+׾#]߯_aSTa5Er [Nh4L AM`0AAE= 6Ӫb:jᄖ:Z66iio`0@, "& ??a000[ nд AMA@8@idH@@ `i  a0j"""80DDD5HO0͊k,ro4/k,4KJpȮ `i\DFDDDDDTOKa26p0B"""""""""""?KDDzK__IWC tLW Z0 AHu?u…Zplb)QLwVV2, wgLGaVw`&WB#BPw dS;H2q0j-  P…^0P]0P_=fvhӏ W"E_``r*wo <ϊpRp!j,Ԑ0|GzW]j6*~`0< аA4A. "ܔǒ'f ᚈY蝐jdk 5:q糪)N'Pf0&a aA hq  vHؘwA(7q['x;g2t' wMSM?M4`< p35A BWOL6(L)!SCLj\P Pa6 y<WzH;t! 'EO'mM=v 0i< M4Q;aRi=M5vN4ID$S ߧI.hp xOwj'Il˵pdQЏ"6 { e'--/(4O2NĊNޓKv ^&]^*KtInl&I$#MpҴӤ`H'#AO{6 |[OuM]:Uҷzt_M? a6Эv{ kK_{IZ^}^&3p؂W޿wb=}Raa /.`7#pկu_^\{zW~VIzL'PpULd/~_J??_B?->X0__ 7 _?d_O}޿z~m_Aw/u߫i~|WwHGd!l6//^{_z+><`{E#/_om]_zKK .oi}Z.kի~߯t_i[i$߽Mݯ?ndm;ڗ0m{ .akjWiViij*֗n#uhmCcma=8KazVZoڶ]mkczY pA)7M4ᄤ(4ctثc-[WLSi_ެRMy/|}P(o§KyV+V+[ _i0 T4mȐAA)T`d#hrM= m1@駻U+i~:alz1MZVm1\E]vGZS!' xpk0PSL a(a[ 4Ȏ CAdA4 m4 `A4 tP t6i)}!A a4P n!NlRw LLA &at‚ *k}aZ[VM4Mi h'M&k *ih 9Sz )Lk T gpL 43^kLU pL& GDDDDDDDDTDDDDDDDDDG_;JM'Z_uWMaq6f& 5n@:#l:… 0fBDK,  6d^! b>\\(P x89o+҅‚pksi?ֵ\Dee(88a}Qt___[D4x(E:%庘B"YCV0( d΢pSl:L)6q:E4gS1lfQZ$".i{zi OBa hY03a A0@ <0L΂!r@ᙙyfr)ٯ%38G=,)'G:jǟG\SdAGa"vZ/h4N.`4MT;C SOD`T&4 OA& pPDaBa0PA 80CB! (@ Lx ay`PPA B }'mAэK!';z>' j'=0j*P `3X0ޠS0MIב']&ό0͊:ZMM"Mfff) NtnPhۋg|MEE-4^=0dNh4N(N᪪i@J7DdaN'zapc4NIN7B'uqa4<9҂I&"X(''OuCbhGT '4ii2_OuO^_׫]5o__6iպjG&lXN &82-'m'tnJM/_nU7ݯUu} m[? oKOuVҤv~mv_?,`u_*ׯH{^᭯I8mtׂZ?+ kcyau,XX9iIJui?WDK{_7WK}N!ׯՇzc$Y#! m~鴕ߧk|H HZ~h+[4 V $^H 7iJҴK]oۯцK}T+]m[]^-{mj}/w_tAm2:bKյ]K /R_il0nk}zQ0.iaI?a i[`t6_. Rpu¯AMp8a&- ꘦m1M4 HGAlRm+v %P״o +b[+ ua}{Վ=uY=P~MAl M44h6Bi6 ":0A 8@0 ۤ]ZcAG *b />>ڍJJL/0!$0@ >YK AI 0`aaAIm 6:b":iؠ@0 U4B lP lS`"""""""""""&p0@2+q< ݭZa 2 Jm,,4h0VxiDDDDDDDDDD$'l&` `˴iAO6d)L ܥg A0DDDDDDDDDDDDGb WAkbhQS[,r[&*?Y k (G\p3H #ف:DDDDDDX1eь68m(r| ,Ċ-V=2$ɚv_fB afG )7&0N$&<*K@!HMa.5OL Bkpdv5$NTv /Wh\-6ߢᅻJ&M tjJGm6Kּt0U&մ9/>@;6)"NdDM>2 Rp|g2@q蝐:ĩ~?5Z }AS 0`0- A x `!'gfgP2?iZcamFU~ [M\v*I.j4ҬTD*h&W2a.4@wɎjL ؄US@LV=)A\ EVp@@b(DuM |DDDDDE!Pe3Rj4)jo0;MKM40 [PZ axh0 .\DDDDDDDDDDDD0&Q8a0!Ab :ZDF tDRDDqk4d-WT],$MZ.ŠI/A1L.AЈ J˅ID0L݈Mez٢2hwP`8)vGe8!mLN2;h'$] Ci d$AE1ٝƘN`â-.'… aB;Egi"0"Z+%BApq+p9[Ei8@jւ4N¯7A0pw ouH8vS7K]u_k}W>- 20YFz53i?(=FdbI~ `PD'\"! N͍M RDlad4rC _? At[_4[#AϊaS <4 L a DT sܜBpgȑ32:EGiL՞ΩX)"tםQFj3NtFgѵe; agȃ0310 &3XC  \"\<( hL0`4&`PA 0@  &  0@ZT Mntv&q3Jg-8)UJ` OwutaE"i?uOADӋOEi N8>Κ'p $M2h./(ƉUTM ‹D'AńJ/kv?np޺}5Mpa1?ApMz} ސAx[v$A&=ޤX|m'z[({!`M___^_O꾿 }+ >_xMӾ6`&ińMm/IJO. 0oG~޺7I+.Ojz5 ={iS~+=w_}WU|?eZaOwH^oŽ=}o_ t__`W/ouz\W8J?ZDaׯc2c?,M~XI__mai[:_-/]oDþN?0oUl/B߮ /zt s /˾_T.a޿ z_H--[IM\{H$^H~Qu}k"[][ mqS_ԿaK?]V+I״j׼յtKo_ 0t[]%,+a&;—Vf>I_o/V_av0]G M0#^;Kah0$بa&Tv\K6~\چ }/ m]~! 00$S0A$At$cpa+mi6:_p ; lUktױQƱn0T7a4ڊij b044ޭ( n>aj)Z}Si҆Q- 8B 3n5ٝ Է \)d.AM4! b8b#h AM44T ` `VA@ @  aaqDDDDGa+00( a{& 8I0ABMP^k Zk@ت"""E`L?)0MP`@ P&0*i4.0B ΔR!`ɟak^YX XWu @2m"?M: 3&q\apȉx-I=ogcGե_C]/^M#R"C) y \)hv&M\bHfu&_#DAM3:f?^`ZMaPh UB *a `04M"vy `ɞ禉D=v0DxS2#`! ww'wE( o4j]WTSti;T&E827'lE[jf3Ƭ ma'w>)t{Voii_J,P}ZWNWOi:_m.o]_|Z/c!v_]O/c>ޗ`kwk{Hwz^/_@߂xtwM!R|+]}ޱi~ߺADij#k$vC_0AH/[nvQ_ؤl$W=߄~NCKb#7k[פ7տY[. /n~It׿}vc0KI~ vAT~_Zxim6 cibﯿ z_v_muiի~Mj҂A6A i %ii^w e뿨 G뮬0Viڷ]Bah a@M40@8 oXi10 DS i_S^qiDlS (i8idchC–9C2dž-i0AKkJ$6!UQ$v4MiQL*l7L&2PRLS!6݊""""F!Bʚ4)5٭#aViUPi=0Aփ@ Dp jE4a4j )6Bj"""")80@ (&a0Lk *݅ Ѳk &Aa M3aA0#tb"""8"""#]/IZ,uJvqK $\U@ڶ4  @! p`ĥ(4dE &]>A((-+̄dM(\  `k, ȣ2W?S  A!h'.… _;Y0r*X9"IU&M=PDTֳC;-ɦE U[?U]z]~WXD>Ny3d|.EC'g=eRa,^aA (L P 4D%A"LY͏!tFGdi!뮫AuDݛ0PTSwaB 4E-K`>! Ț2D=eDl͗G | y"L D+0SO^u_a|lhG_c_+ID,o-B#;ԱKCh/__+0ek}]CO!_!!KuTgvKz8{~u߿T޿}>u=Kcl$k[{I~J+jzZLAGPki6ئ1a7kMIrE߿ ~봽CJB [jQjCm{uay{دƽv+aI7as{iz a)@`!U4b#v=ibXp+حuaKat6iw p iPa2piAȎ* P tm&N ZmED⡫>M:h ('"""20@`LS( ׆ &5I`h PAP mm ha 5 nA@""80B  Ljh[.Xia5Ԙ52#O0I8"""Q"""""""5}]^/ o\S_K ׅ4qiœ؈Y 2/ I;wS… .Y%ࠠ*D;[C"ђV֫PN…;M%d,/qS#[k%pL4yY&fLMrAh]R_ɫѫ"萊FD)"h'޿P&\pPL0( `AVu".HSPzs!"s:dDNDdAHwAM[MAPa|a4 a"&3>)B ȈeA.lR6G|SbaNf@CLN P0D- S@a A8281='A5=}EESDh$M2CHpC $AkA4{USMkk 0(*u-~ ]]}\O r;dAp h L YƋƉ͡`Ѭ4N*0p|.Mv'o[ETy Z{Kk d% Ӥޓ<6!{{h 14 AnAW&NQ>4gl"[^WO= 7oN֯O}6i>0'L'ml'Kt,U?Cۭ_߮n[t,-wֽU+1._^~Z%*/c kWo b}*i~p[Ga*a,_-B uDuixAz a~oK_W-Ὺ_PGFwGJ_uWίUt{0}/~5H_KL?_7߯ג?$i={O_}_Jت]`zMُt}m/nTZAKzua^]ڭYuO[ibb؊;[XXb+[Kue`'.oҵͫ_6 Smja0^/ݠ 0@iTtA 6zj m&KҍxJ8[MǯiI7݄?at^Ȯ ;^4MS MbAQQLPALU i DbaJ[kizWqŽZm'WRD"(A` `e}4LaSLB $ &h )SfA @T:(6a jG`NA6 qIDDDDDDDDDDDDD#]&:fM AgUPM0A+W $I?dW8aKDG aM4L<0LD4 ‚ŸB)" EU~AyA; 90D9Qdt(lD8B39\[%OGyB$%]V׃$0I8?)҂aU49SPe88& B4.-  hZ"O ͌ DR2d<0& ̏EՄCFB3c>G8.P#"HSbNNz/L[^$_cEEahDBm*o~pSxA0N(N04Z *aߘTC?6e8O ~IdcgnnMl7Ʉ/4OL'T8`ɺL!֚h0p㠨0CP4T tOD` v~L']IRuom_ pdWJApbh C74^]O,24_8[6Zm.Jaa:M?#Ɠ7K!___WD#AYh2#ij`L ! !f0&A t. al'5ͅODRՄ""""tB"""?DgaK?Rl:`(OB?\ TGC 2/);[b8HDvBSd,fB (ML+Ңȴ:Ꙓa0X\0P\ pyǽ*.K\q3hN۾oRey3$@C_~UuS>!M1 #c: JbpSHdIB 8gQfae=ue]tgC xA0 dz!3k%2>#QgYu\'`ÃqDwL"poM0L0'A~  a$ACSY9 2=h:BF|p\"ˡ SMP);0aMA:M4PNH782-ƉEj'tLpCT(*0AB  4qi:?3bCֽ?=zֺ [z0zI~W_Gc+޷_ZWW?_Uk7//; /W5_닯b ,l9:_߿aN7_,o`[18%D="c?aoa#B"iuo7{i#xo_c3R|dK!O_kv?5{o}]v:].wֽj;_J~[WWֿVV{wz§\w}vJnut~_^޿ki1\G0J &?bcbWmvc_Y[[O^׿^-MJB>;d#6 aSj=5Ia{ v8&c)V^c+u$k Bj jdA0MBA*0i! llS!VK1MJ 㺉 bi\i|kj œ0 8i )M wAaB 0dASP0@ b0)ᄤ(NMM6B=II6hA :B""""#107YL(& L&Ij5& 0L AAI}DDDDDG(A &ed0PMI “{Ma‚7A-`n"""""#B""""""""#}_|A^6`6kWd |Ab)Q3  ¦A%! 2R"`\l(PP K?"k@t[+ݮoz܊ !I9F;#*y~__}WU[|'3#qLH sɆFDg0T „! A-@!N 2!-A|CgyRTjU (M ?P L&|PCkV HɸRzw_7;ZVQy"/i[VUNQ_zm_^va޴}01 %|4W~_m/V}VWLT0Io1WkXKoun~u}iKmZL0p*a[jCK6+{ݗ^8anV]n%muԿf>if;a`8h `i i cM4ޓ5톓]KKm&lSiZw 4c+q^FW (Rc^jiL& l A t@": 6)@: T4lWqm6l[i10 4m]VqUJUEDDDDDDՃ&W|A40i5aME i7j* A `?  0@Ȏ 0@4 """"""""" @e}“* 5+4dAɜԿAA\0j¬4Mxk"""$ RB @!Cc a>*ҳb*ˆd /EUsc>)M,݆SE 6>?=l''4౫<A`- 8[ 2f :2Lgs!]B"?t Kgh*i> EJK/VYJMFzlk]:wKT}[kZH=H/ҴA!n=4&6e8^Dpս{d? o{~/[o,}awv$?]M {ܗKu]}mRn_[kO_]$NګvH4u/3UVNIZKm+v0i] ӊMNb a6!2$*LW /AL&MA"""""#MW- *PU! _~~'}}_rCKvbkˆL[Z?尴d Gɰ0-Q@ endstream endobj 124 0 obj << /Length 4339 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im125 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F126 12.10 Tf 74.64 707.76 TD (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the past) Tj /F126 11.96 Tf 358.08 -.48 TD (" but extends to such) Tj /F127 10.97 Tf -357.84 -28.08 TD (other provisions as may be necessar to ") Tj /F126 11.94 Tf 198.24 -.24 TD (close all roads to the prohibited goal) Tj /F126 11.87 Tf 174.48 -.24 TD (, so that its order) Tj /F127 10.81 Tf -372.96 -28.08 TD (may not be by-) Tj /F126 12.27 Tf 71.52 0.00 TD (passed with impunty.) Tj /F126 5.00 Tf 116.40 -.24 TD (FTC ) Tj 25.92 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F128 8.77 Tf 10.80 0.00 TD (Ruberoid Co.) Tj /F126 11.64 Tf 70.80 -.24 TD (343 U.) Tj /F126 11.74 Tf 32.88 0.00 TD (S. 470) Tj /F128 5.00 Tf 30.72 0.24 TD (, 473 \(1952\); ) Tj /F126 12.52 Tf 64.80 0.00 TD (accord) Tj /F128 7.98 Tf -424.56 -28.08 TD (International Salt) Tj /F126 11.55 Tf 92.16 -.24 TD (332 U.) Tj /F126 11.90 Tf 32.88 -.24 TD (S. at 400 \(") Tj /F127 11.09 Tf 54.00 0.24 TD (it is not necessar that all the untraveled ) Tj /F126 11.89 Tf 195.36 -.48 TD (roads to that end be) Tj /F126 11.94 Tf -373.68 -27.84 TD (left open and that only the worn one be closed.) Tj /F126 5.00 Tf 229.68 198.24 TD (\); ) Tj /F128 5.00 Tf 12.72 -198.72 TD (see also United States ) Tj /F126 5.00 Tf 108.72 0.00 TD (v. ) Tj /F127 11.32 Tf 10.80 -.24 TD (National Lead) Tj /F126 11.40 Tf 69.84 0.24 TD (, 332) Tj /F127 10.57 Tf -420.00 -28.08 TD (S. at 335-) Tj /F126 11.39 Tf 64.56 0.00 TD (348-) Tj /F126 11.95 Tf 21.36 0.00 TD (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which the) Tj /F126 12.01 Tf -97.92 -28.08 TD (defendant in the ) Tj /F126 12.20 Tf 80.40 -.24 TD (futue received an exclusive license.) Tj /F126 12.07 Tf -44.64 -28.08 TD (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer. ) Tj /F126 11.81 Tf 351.60 -.48 TD (Any defendant) Tj /F126 11.98 Tf -388.08 -27.84 TD (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim in one of the relevant) Tj /F126 12.03 Tf 0.00 -28.32 TD (markets could complain to the Commission) Tj /F126 11.96 Tf 209.76 -.48 TD (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine) Tj /F127 10.74 Tf -209.76 -28.08 TD (whether Rambus had violated the order.) Tj /F126 13.33 Tf 192.48 4.56 TD (ll The ) Tj /F127 11.17 Tf 34.80 -5.04 TD (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation) Tj /F126 11.98 Tf -227.52 -28.08 TD (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple technologies.) Tj /F126 28.04 Tf 36.48 -107.52 TD (11 ) Tj /F126 11.94 Tf 35.04 -4.80 TD (As merely one example) Tj /F126 12.10 Tf 113.52 -.48 TD (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5) Tj /F126 11.36 Tf 187.92 -.24 TD (915) Tj /F128 8.12 Tf 22.08 0.24 TD (105 patent) Tj /F126 11.96 Tf -395.28 -13.92 TD (against JEDEC-compliant products) Tj /F126 11.97 Tf 169.20 -.24 TD (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10) Tj /F126 11.93 Tf -169.68 -13.92 TD (was within the scope of its order:) Tj /F126 11.97 Tf 36.24 -28.32 TD (A memory device comprising: . . . an output ) Tj /F128 8.34 Tf 214.80 -.48 TD (drver having an output coupled to) Tj /F126 11.92 Tf -214.80 -13.68 TD (the bus) Tj /F126 11.97 Tf 34.80 0.00 TD (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer) Tj /F126 12.01 Tf 238.32 -.48 TD (, the output ) Tj /F127 12.31 Tf 57.36 0.00 TD (drver for) Tj /F126 12.00 Tf -330.48 -13.92 TD (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; and wherein) Tj /F126 12.02 Tf -.24 -14.16 TD (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multiplexer in) Tj /F126 11.99 Tf -.24 -14.16 TD (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle information to the) Tj /F126 12.10 Tf -.24 -14.40 TD (bus) Tj 17.52 0.00 TD (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe ) Tj /F126 12.13 Tf 268.08 -.48 TD (multiplexer in) Tj /F126 11.98 Tf -285.36 -13.68 TD (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle information to the) Tj /F126 11.72 Tf -.24 -14.40 TD (bus.) Tj /F126 11.84 Tf -35.76 -28.56 TD (CX1516 at 30.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000825386 00000 n 0000825445 00000 n 122 7 0000825641 00000 n 0000825808 00000 n 0000869023 00000 n 0000826351 00000 n 0000825964 00000 n 0000826095 00000 n 0000826224 00000 n trailer << /Size 129 /Prev 825057 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 873429 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000931229>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R 122 0 R 129 0 R ] /Count 19 >> endobj 129 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 130 0 R /Contents 131 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 130 0 obj << /XObject << /Im132 132 0 R>> /Font << /F133 133 0 R /F134 134 0 R /F135 135 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 133 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F133 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 134 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F134 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 135 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F135 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 132 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im132 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 50322 >> stream f2+qx-% 9i]gZ-55uj?4(Bj>[Ah;uЉd\2 f2r)C@bM1h}g!\G–k MHVJCC " D*rCd"r= mH,2Wa;ojwB8m_oo}vvjU[ Rtd}W! 0A3\!yM#Ϙٚh΢_(?82qtιGԊtӋwC?AL 'w`д/!PSCh?48 ,wINbHz$ MxMB „GHl[τ030SB4B9qB82%}XcIB;A6h ,m;{ ]J;D;}ŠMh0a; Czk]RooIn[#N'ofx\^`4 N kBz`5 "@Q@ֈa ٱlxS@Y@럊xGTyk;45OT*xD p'cTmS_ w@ d@@ „A0B=)"'HaK#ql J"d, $I8!OoT6ô^Q|yE  LU 0xTipPABgƘ) B4&j(3<(M0UPP3u ό74~|aMi2~FIw\LhŻƋƉB3CTN'|*j7AuUMU5D*&*kBok'7#Ӥ2.5 m'A6 #L&oBT_qAMglMhN mzoW׷\Oa5oiҶڻ%i]ȁfM"IMzN,&80NON ']dr\_\BWzNz[]:^]0&#^_~~zzo~/.?5u\^?_^OpW^Zrm E?~}_}?~ڷ_a_k}hl?/l0ZaG_l?Dw_wUo!^H!_A~_~oG> obK_ FX_/9O|!"8?+J]kvT#/_m'^L/izI׿Wm[~IiiZX_/`/zvi_M 0K[6MwMlG Gb_‘-ե{Ұ[kuڟ[[K_z@ q@#AB=SMvE]Aڷ_i{V{Kl%I/m[Ka0;4bMB 46D@jt0 !0A)UaVW^[I] 6iZ!1B&ب@j 5L(S@4kPi5  lP@i@@i$j'iIצALP@ &`ATPMM8"""""FHhez6M‚$ 00 va0 A! 4ALSJB  4>)b""""""""Tb" *ha lRnIxaK-M0n@g?&n;~ɟ;: N,нb"""""#""""$_M _paiAn'j?u,#;%*d$AQ Al(]0MKrWtMQڧ P_N)RS4;fh YAB/r%# `eaW9720vݫ t }P}N$FԗxaR"?]/UhAwh&_۞3DȌdģ'ǽk~?_-̣t3l_8PFyB.VWMyn0A ?[4- 0B0dAј31NA+5' AȺhGg #U]Wh5MoPAA3T30 TT h4.C(A뮃u9!FuGCJTiMQhgn"aI8a4z'/*Dݟ35CDh!D섈}L?0QB0@0@ 4f͐!C6fbA&D }H%͌!Q0@0P*r" 3v`go-O vPAh&tn47NI9'/K]?M=0PU6(La00U=0AfMB q hY7Vt5 I]\\(IZO"F&re^`ȹKx]5UMQ;wTNTST7`&8h) *]L f0~S׺]Nк OMׄD ȶoH6 Mb{`&=<'tn&\R7&pm?;AS&Ir# doZKzo0+ 'ӰM::0E28zO__:[%_t5[c׷^t]q᾿Uڮ?l-R}-'I[Zv຾!i>W{on prN1ȎN2gߍZ]DH{G_鴟b={޸ c_V蘗^X~ %tl?}{ia/o~$$vQ6+am/_kso~CMl7+[H?D6׿~HoH_7[wku}i~1[\_i>__ GKi}}ڮF޿~I{?6Ka8`cVIb[9w/[jޖC(ڶ]KKlB@ii %bc튮K=I{TI&~tͮizaSͪh&0dHA>D ☠ @Ӧm7!GkUl0m88ubjKWwY)+_bt7m/RSbL. dW/dG 4 (&a 5mB P ؠA xA4 04[KaQQǫmC*i\DDDDDDE!aAOA& \)nRǰ=7L&5&+ C 6A a qQ@ANSAm  ؠDgDDDDED""""",E9ԍa04 a!M4MSIKiL]-tDY|Dul6)wML &A5?Y BeT0H  aL9YS_"""""""""")8"#QҖ@a5K_ ꖭHib $XAX`[U 0f1,J?nxFAxL(Lљ*FD㵳; B edhʜWH((/n vj!4 H;fS~Dx PABPl0prCTE}B2Y ZYpS09ء`K־lE}O___}tynf#5עu_ׄ 0<@'D#yP?!833GxιŔSב;Q]ȡ4 ةAᦆZ `p aN! !PA<.LJJi2iˬ}/]}VPL䡃%2oET'tNߦM(*iWhaaphh0) T„ `u^lgA|gXᙙ8f̾Nf'Hm IMKhc3lDF' M2p$;]S * 0T0AL (!,(@A P d  BA &= 0 d1"i-$w'^H81=AOIA7ihhZ4N'wDtULSUAaABalO WAO0T`L ݡKV\M6OȮ\pO33H;!| A=:Aj慧/*;zzh98h3Duqx_bvIޟ$}mC^]:MC +nG n>g8)E>At 14bh;(q4PN4aEƂlzM"] vHAu}~mתkޞW_^ _<'ߋ :#ӫSyVW+PJ/?|#M_]4]_N}:[ChVm+J`_IBmWaDH[muǫ]׭?a_p__/zߢa[O?k[.V+J?0D';V{CX`u8c~+ }/k }/a;?k]?X?_e?å^Lo__,K~%jA~l?<0__kQ y#?GC  렶43_jHF_ 솻imk}_ky?Dw}6}oGoEHN{Kn\_t%ut[{a_m‘{/{ݥm^K u5[KK/Q 1q`{c]&)k knp6 '~JAG`@d qM ªiUpQJ "m_]|S l$_K)vU ᄶa+K avԓ 5 A0A `i FbޚAjiZեz{i]k}uUquz~f~GDɕ&AKa00a-„L ȃa4Laa0@ڊ 6Ȩ"iLRvpP`ҵᥫ\U_V -ki[j3 y!ae@ @ ( a0MSH0AA!0A0 lEm m@ @ha P xAQ;" ͩ>M8aaP0a5IMP֬-{[ Saq`DDD)0DACab""""" a2I""""""""">Z~>3u^?M rm[Rwesk&d/ PO2AgfdI3.  ;qG`B نUh:a-pPPNL aVM1 "BP… q[#paKsl&}Q|(PWn"wQտ0pq%̃>KI_-3xs3&Gd8v֩ .а @@8.N DdPD "FAU KĂ/DFG\z$apVC0Th g(AC 0aA Hr"c(`)S1z5B_&9vv GuCM5PUA &pU>|'iD" ?#9vG,-YCa%dc3AO!B |) td2!A#]E.A(EHB )M ==4l 4r_;E輅T4](z'Hwl&A֛O`S3¨PP3L!0aA4S0 „66@I7}`ȶG'zl 'yv% m=;P 04NމPjT5L8}z' Š ꨝC#'ukO /o~uw %i&ޟߑzx ސn&4bgݺ/<Ƌt4/pe]M;Iń(h&]>ۥn|kW[ޛilL'5lAy4II3Idnf00Zݯ.?CV>zztz鴟ݦ_7 V{qm^ot'__Wo .ǽ^z_OO_֓U_^[bjݥ__oޯx$?# ~]} k_ذ_SmAz"Oa?ｵLp? iW_Z ,m/O_A0~+ߥ刅 m]?]6$>zM//$#7 m[[o-}_~}07~=o / ~ڤ?itzqL~~}-~bxo!_vK_I~[ss{\z_W/SV+^nao_,ڰkiy{KﵿK}~цV#t6ةװw_ $ޝ}wZl%0O_i:]~]_醕 $6'n#+بI>[[KbXj}w ڶW[}]WOWdHLP 6buAGT0iQa.M5vJS &O_K vkY }VZ~4P¶j E j" aP qQAiARwV}Km/QE4[a 6mQDDDTDMI80^&LaWD 6]@6 `A`QlR 8MV7ؠH<&iLTmuIDDDq 0LCAMbh AM aH z &mL ")LLg^Tgf3<'vq׆PXdp M ).2.1 &M5 KX"""8WWqר0UUQ@ZZkά$0 iQ25< T&2ciXf3!$R B ([pali9U k>Jpm~;?WUU[(F*   E`A(E.SHC#3S0 k+}&$iA~^&&'[n}?E}WMu]^7믏kקW[!Wmq]t_c xJ/a~N؅ֿ~//%޴N=ak_K aװI/Z ~׶Ɨ~Ã~C_x7'?m/]=ȄD_߽.Myyk_Hү/WuM}[ Tb_o G {kty[VSiZD'VLzuz R^aiӂ!GT&Gؤ %acja%ajկM-iHl Ȏ q i `0@ؠA@ڊ @e4hRo -݄j_h4[ڰmZ8""""""""5"'3,@La#"ϐ: J""""""8^UɰSVRkJTVaKQPq)Բ,\ԮvKY\/ĄB;S([,商MS;&+2fE 'G kࠠN  0s#=D~7… Cfx9ʼ?^wh렜Apr\CȒd>_|]: bv}u^_tKWWJHQ͑N N23Q(2nO9:3S1g\$2zxiC0@д,0T$= <0CC `l@@A2ld 2=3Q+NޫDat*֘*h=5P*h }4@BC0)8S0 Sl5DO8PegWB:g=GQD1NE#Nj F՚a}%1[ԼŢa"Ď Z..'N(A.v<"vS 0B80A<`. (L0>!0@ 0,S@ C F");NȷH7(z^ 쳉t& xmU5TL~ h4MA=S6"a=kAA=^k IJVzZOl xOICM Kw}|E4^0>> '6/1a<Ɖ 07D"_TM𞾛߄'I[80[>)ç& NzAdK[]N S~: ~+׾z鵽'VO ovG +]{^O?#ēo_Q]~m6v_WwtZO :|*Z0W+ Nz`X cbct1C_׿"O8`z~Nد1\~ ao?o3 //{h/7 ۯ{//_B$?ai!!ÆK_ o N/68am8?{$f0ٴ~F >;oAKoհ0_<_ȏ?A} 6[[o*׿~a5G _m/3:^V>kk_{o}8/m/C_~?]moK %}հki]^ސOVaR}QkLk[ku'ki1m}i%wod Md#jwZcؘpmCJ*ӈ)[kէ # nԿZڦUaK ԿWmiئPA¦p mED);t) =4 i/4Z}aJR  !ڱV0 w|{'BVY&>&l˸0L()]aS SaB0b0@0AlRiƩLNcOa*6- XzlU5tAQLTq(BHEaAMK4Zi׆L%4ӅH6tA mMAd#5  UT6D6aE22DDUDDDDDDDAA,?&L91a>/ &Ȯ]v kv 0 $U0"""""""""""""""D`DDDDDDDDGe:`_H8W4W 'Ub$M-C U-0VD0PNPM:tkp)QNǺAPaNb?#PS;@LPE1JpO&1&v&vRg`̐bld|r"DxM289ކET@0U5`/-i2ϭ+i2\)tDlMz¸(_uA /@njmʊIO[~"&9\&]wItu{____V "rF!<N f„< B0D<) B@P uz%{?0_K|t ><ٙxe#C0(W蝰 $Nދ'l0HvVO$i]B Ai0T 2`U0g03!Qgp!񑂝cdIID5C2`C:F9FHE(D:duA; `ɗO6dİK k'mUm0 &yiL#pTa3LT iA0 h*`0P Pi>n7WVHҭ-.i*x8;i;Ɖ;rM48hGa Dj &&Dj`AN4_ﾐx YZ\EN &,q,zMiqh '~4蝴O)1Ŭf^?t]~QQZKOzM2V{`ȷG0Los#I/ -~%ԛH6pSb$E} ҈KڿN $ x]7)?h^jGi'KӥpV '<ik;M_tt֓=]t1ܝAtx1?Cz. _AXzZI70=6 v?U}q[ꟽa' D/^ a귷wa? X?nL[-9b725 wo ?o>^_i$}%o_uJ-uD_}^,K_RH!,7iz M6_~#n* /o937__aد!1^CY!?k__k*"Diua~YOM.i߆KnL,K_)oKR'}1{H ~Sv)/!IK_R8!0aW~_ki6߷6A\TkQ (`*za%$ a~ ^MhGM B)mua ؏J j]ikaK_j_  `]^~m04SJiI=da@0GA4INj[I?#_ۥ;b9;VDDAa` 0M4Ik`ڥL 0 j*( a0 Q &]ª=Ni;=""""""#"""Q?hL)a[K 4AAA@G (0 iiA 0AAա`G&ϖhɾ Oa{ k;M00 /0#D6 `ɳ'?KzUי a+K!-HLTTm0@DD-B-j#ʏ%(.?M2e1Kr@ )ޡ]0f_{gxɢ}`4a3栤 D:uЮppwk<]evd3؂G%9FF )R "lSA8(]/rT W& p{mtRgIAQ ?_\S+.`uI7~_U&H,q¡~t"y붗^{7~VVV+k_ a_a~oޟ}x^HG xm l0^]}U֌3}? WO/ZޖNM^U/}KVkݯ޻{{_m_=(o}l8[Ӆ G K $a]-+[]uOt߶]ba݄q q Ƕ8Ӳizw/1?K}kV$ A#@UD0ci0jV)_J鵾‘U={Tu!I:5a5_ Sa2,  D]0BD|1!6M0AS|TUa+Kai6uh+ZG5ϛJ[xel0BH) ,%L/d3* aJ4*hfP lT0Ii=8VKM馛 ) QQKQDDDDDDDDDD#Yg7& ZI¦E7$X j":0A*bj }UDDq "Aɸ&h&L ªڦ a0  a#YcgL8_}DqDDDDDDZHOB""5UKYj_iתo_RHL-i|UX iJ" @j#j"#[E2:@8WɰۦU# #;Dpd^F |uG˰FČD*;{B, .MNS?piX/q; Pd%)ё49_%qtJ!"YDM4\#}W_tZt( e;5#C"I%` ! E B* C=mH%͑"$|Nf!tuޑH2'A7O 82%Ղ#dI&wıʄHz'm=v>T8 :;vu_ץL7ZJ+wnH݄#l&|%0Lk^%! -2b qnԞ4jt ,0ۯ_pKIhRnv { _X0Aޭ`ȸD̋ϊp0| I0~/~_Ut_¸M 7''q+ +I7Z{T3ɎE{A?֕j?_q_Z?'i=>hG ˭n_ׯ _ \|5W^_޿\"1a~`%8b 0_I$ Dz:Z'[k޽ 57//K'_m#u?_?I|W[/[A_^~W_߱_/7J_oJKoI ~__?m//߫i}zC_tK+v}}ҽL.[ۯտ]/u/kkaWҵb/+6))?FުHKv^iBﴩnzm,G66 )ӽ>BzGSo^庨aA 0!8A XA aM4߰JmkLAڦ0⓽{&G`V _O ~ ?!_0*iIZa0A,*iM2#  mAb`:lA0|0U~S{#=`!۱j\DDDDDH} Ca3>&F:idp  g~ҧi!a0@؄ *0UT@ 0@ =ui %!4t<G AGf"udBg?&gAPMAB}PmSM` ! aS"8@IRPd  P""""""""!!a4ʢԿ"Ś4a[N§|0gpM;JS,rj kb""""""""$RYL*դ i"/KQA$=4`D).?fWM31oav!s)̍&ev ӉAH@2?"B?]Cڄ X!5;p#|9AL#@HX&l0|g@ A"XDY@hG!1KLF3P4za4CPPa>)Aauk„ND'GciMޘM $NPP;xomnD*Mth ` '85 PRIoo{֛Iz't [ B >kkLW-:OMm-ҦdYQeER)n/mWNKH]$bN[t^ֽRyn! @LP͑E(SΥ5sRDC04u5)U30}'__$_뤞h0I4 i a   hcB2s0DC0/#:R_]ui}44Hv'aSPT 0U3  a3c(N!P)Cyh?w_J޻#L*@Ag>"a DxO/):.٣TNTN'wU뾩_ lPAB aSеxiifgi. Ӥ :X0Kpd\H7:An4~^4]4HzaBav O &--^P6ӤUk _l6g]I?7EŢ񠛏 0a=&KتN2n8O__]=:M֕t?^ ~n鴜OZNFM"QDWCZ{Hkׯu|B_]t+[_#h'I S]ȸz/O[[Cmm-/WVMOZK_ ~N߮wkji*K_iC ¶Tw]~߷/_z/q}Bئ7zJQnK]-xD?M[k91/'v (KO[O߯m+[X2 A*AhM֌D=rG"CLW__dD+ݵ ($?Jijnu _{ } JIm_u'FO/o붭H=?K]xP}%tI}/MZK{w_4muNcU&KKa+m/Kޛ+{zKJ+)K &?Smӛ,m. ~~۵$T}/HoI}{zV;IئhTiX^ _k^mB [I$_鴿%O6O_M~I7kzH"Eh1A` a7j=ZJ+5K݂[b`+RHkZKn6J޿ͦ}Tiӈimm4 t@A PA" GH@`B!hM4Na`֒ I? $I=!I]K&! ܥš2džim5UMڠB :|00@M h&uH%Q  iKaaGi%DDDDDDDDDDE9DB&0M,gf  kc頃0 `h!JᄚbA X lR!4 $C0Aeu aWҠL&AkIU{UAؤX2,A `Sr ,0&!0h0kjB"""$ pIRȝIqUVBʪ- Mo's"6H-(*)MM3!3)YRG| (LQ l}2Zԙ3""z pjÃT̒2I ʅA6w0nt"z(\;p  @Bvl0|&F"j 1IaFtID.ɜ6i^_ynaڂZP ?὿q K h:shp-"v;h4w?㋃l5zAMIl nWmi6/pWήIdNA??I/onzv[Vzz)ۿh kOAM.%b(fzgLPD{!3/GC5#̧_z}-wUq_gOҠA49 `5.B.-2fk<>|KŢҨ^~B o@ M )SAa "   !L !>OI}QLΙf2Au~AG"$&v% hAv0ai6 O};~tO/.v5T?@*N꺷(A(AOmx?_VZ;%A%o_I'" atȖE|?ŤK~}/TN'Q8p+ߓ|?]uU{kt47 /_/݄'WFtkpl5 Ftok)>kxm_۽~_ֺUjլ%I}'Im^/}d{ko__{o_/TO{2OAa x;V~oVOЏ귥ӧKW?_TZ :>a פKEo}߷AX'_?+&9t8$a+᾿uFwI?Gh,G&_dA<I~hK _uq{kodK$]Xoo?I%/oOigiwsnUAzOKoߴ*+A?o+o^/otKZmok=-$y#>H_IUKҭKJͫ%wW/w|[ook_{jzI$Uiauc+{;m}[%kڻamoK$փa( +kjm]u=׬0`ջ6~֗z_Mi6ҦI}-"H0` ᦝkl4%#^خ @ث@>}ڥZaBm H%j_j_#3߆A4A46 m D @ا(6(0@B0A ~=Z҈>;^@bX _i$;T"4dvQj A> eΞc0*aN4h0@h0h mFGKvJ[;Z}a҆IJ8%qA,F0Dϖh b EZiI5  `t D"@a0B<@ށ8@ CPtK"""""""""""",)Rp 5A0aT&W"""""""""!DB.0B&p3a.c0BNCK$T $JbBˆ !BJ'-ք /&NKֵK^KҮ]% IitVƂNEBUmiɺQ 吷2Pt32erfTad4ms`U5Pj,f0s(ar7 EiOFWKy>'pvR@᠆ ΁^BW Fc;=2~)4FT WX8z [*}n{wdL̏x8;9ؖSs~ocɅ0h60DU!P fy:=yAoWPO4~hX&`0]U)6gLQS4Ç_iMS ^  0@ !r1(5LNda;/J zNXޡ~=w~]''o^$?_0~XrzX//i/7~N[u?$}Ο zi??%am/}_]* d?o[1߿h/ۿ}%z]怒_G#!u?!Z[K c < ݒ=M/͠HmZ[z]uj~kax=v)[yuҰko-{+__uomonm%[qa?;kj_j`0{4+{_n״/MA m l!J&|I4ccӆ+mm?1_jkkK] |4y %l0Z&a-KW h æ `b 0p0@"B b 0DpmjT/0Ui{iGqqViq]Z8CV+;)ɟ8h0o޽ ‚Ȯ ՂM/M!6i ah5+jեbupm4w (i5DD!QRg+MK)m =B 0@ @ڊ P `h0@1UT0A":b z`SL 0 ; 5i}C aK: AkZKe"1f2$I2`)3 .Ј֗Yf%Mzik k-֍tqV :a(6ɸڛ-yn'fEAD6nT`(P6Y:aPP\&d ;Vrܐf`…3B#P_@>I Y4yAP[B$M/sb.q+F[_89[JpGO;j6_酷^uD!6Fb-#AdFu#8a2:8|5vSԞ}ׯKSOAXHa BhX&0P0`= NB fGs'Y !uǪxL:qL&*A T / 1 Ba`A! /ȤIG@U 雉Ȉ0ʢ b5d35Ι)iL՞Kq3t_4O/gNyDpy#gQ;aL4 '& aP`04E*AˑA@Mh0PDN ( Ta4l;TMuƂm CEA8g"vV,8:'DO(4N/ T kФ6i>Ӥ7yttnAs'bXhvAIA7H6|Cg׷q{VG>KkA$'V/0GIzzzm&]'y'ֆ#ҿ./jaš{^}_Э}M%> ]#_񯽥\?jza6ז3]oֻ~_^}Z0W'K_0rӖ#}PX0] Nb݆^"OV^/Zz&3 6_P ޻a'~ u8?Hil0= ^߄6'6_i$AتH _a n_z6 nؤx=i߯_h/6!i}_o=_swE%7vԺMkV[JK?߆ios _ՄՊ[VJ $ڞ,uyi~K[:_iZ]}V D [@b=mbO_i/LS cnݵo^յ3<q `2#cڨiRVŻIT5jv+SjG‘Һ/mզVmja{a(iA,ŷ^l&M 2p M < @i0GL0ӫX8kGimk5 ]61_v_h0B6 `ȁ0A“p "d"9}5LXh4`@HQS!A8*lIo +Vvb0ŴXI ZDDDD!Qs% 2 1a~AL (6)4ftA*B>*(4MEP a@"#B"*""""""'& HyU&:LA00vӰi*Ȯ0 0h8q 0 exL^`t26`FO U"?UDDDDDDDDDDqk%k(a-(,$a@ #a;+#DDQɱ<965a0eљgzj%̄¦UA  fBd&\̀1UpPY T!4B(̒̉E\ 0W];B§P0' 09ǻӺ:jpPPP_l\Aӫ5'utr Z!JSw{Lpq;S O__Hwÿ_}UʚZOA2l pR@$xل9q55#ʟq._W~1pAń & 0@T! ``g8("<`@!$ Q xy}9'Z:.ޠz`ji&pUA qBLhY e -_5B0̉:STS,ԓR5TddKgDs!=hbg_ h? ֨xMb8DUh. …A 8( h0@c'f&E k%Q=.q3aO )TD`A?03j!6 ) b=&׫K' htO ~x<Ai*nxL0 "!i*x*& aOL!zM/I*6 &G:d2.pzt' ڤ_4O1vr.N2g/&/MwT 0d"w|0 v Dn;ņKK[tik_p}nIpȐX;B&A! i>Тkz6wƃU'_iܰ&N̢7F±l7o֝&$^ҎٟMG_P/ҳ麳Vi.oױ1ǿߴ?V5߳Ӥ޽ﾓuWݏ2%򓸿'8چf)çlI82%2 /Uo_ׯ]?{ o[k_u݅/i6Կ%P _Yl뵭]iukx_b>¦ikkj_ǛZ{]ikJd i HGƅ4 ӶXJ V 4[ML]~#:Կ/}K1uym axUL7@ mPAȎIN*B6)b;VI !i{aڱ]_z}'{' `PS&q j ״{M55A6Ru&CI7;NJ-;ITM4ޚOUGF""""!, >Mjn CiT0dHA !7A(ah8  lS  aVoWDDDDDA ܁MJ 0j P׆Ep]iװ a6~"""""""""""""" B"""H®>"; .KTT, J,@(Rhb%YM2즘SL`hQYM:SO^iM!"2f@ESABLrí   wyW 2;H̪ (oukUT(PPw`3vk[ Ȇ$dQ֪ /!2 0 VDJV+X? a U_9W9ަ(~plOCߥB[\J7ڢ/Uݲr6kZUom ߤz0c!h)r!#dj#6G ΐLRA t"6yFH3gLhQF5UUh; *a P0T",0$0PB `&A` " 2AB&P̃zwvM0T5LC5j >($Aa1 !hhA.`R@⑁ 8<FF8G:"i]zx7Ƌ慣{3dNEe"vUMP;`ɠN(N)_5@ t`@D͌f6`d0@\"q E֕fȐ! -^&2(|fg:O96 ݔ8- IyL:S xMA4OM64D3aPi`A]-|&^oxM+haSk6[%  ݄߬ff)I'm_7xQ˷7hhQ8I&S30;z(2s tv!꾿Z: [iy5} zi[6ޒ C-*OJgAi_Z]5_i>{ z&M$٬gOau=buK|1zm|m?u[^w֭tӰXrcWXk+ЯW_[u]^_#{Za19~P߸bx׺ԟd B'?r|u{Bu']~?'B$]z,Gn^X/M/a__ ۝|ufDX8o,"Ka w_;'D{{{~'庖+$uޗHV)/\ Z /mJo}7uK.s = SnT~M߾{V~*Y"_]K]VZ /{J׵/߷beY >J*ǘa[O1kyJJ__oK $a{J8AڶhiE~}k G_ikkkP ئB< MXV4bi1z]n8ڈ}vZNVK /_ vja{ {zI/ oiMS@ jh0@ ` luM2tۧ4vPzm&+JB~^|&a/͉` ~H`ka4 "-ZSAM,  q[A540Klwm/WQt|GAp)5b""""""81(DDDD 0 F=j0a; h `#A  : :B:@6 8@ lEqDD &0r * װ{ ? S IN&AiX A~MSgPLQ!?W*4DDGIR /JL.[H% L0$ZZPS(&h u)Q@xUV9dYgeڦe> WV߅;Ai|(CPP* 27[D\ꫂ&AMB0h: *eY ʬ÷Ys 8 NrU _{zRa~8cuJzotyٿa65^_/_z~r2uCJ@2:m/UaeK뺇Imj/o-+[lR V.J'qv .=O6Km$@0#6-u~­Z]kK/t@i(6J*) 0f 0Aai4MMj1i/!k)&GO1}XR߿ָKI0 SPPIIIL6 l mHQo]J#N#N?خ=մuW (Aam(&I)v&Wh&~M lLS g)h0 aWM&Ȱ `":(B: GPa$ڽ;i6 iH6)0:CB6""""""""""""""""CHDAN<0 /a4ji ڠ A`h6(0 j  "@e """""""""0F`TaLhL& Hxa; Xalᅆ9 [qvkH]a0D_HN*/$A"nd`_QcQaGp.T"-ΡB`Pغ0ΙdqJ"+pUT,!Ć\3$2c-XNaȸ(((PAnD9]^KNKڃd| aUor%89+2ܷ42 C;߆W]dmmu6lg!60Au3N <3AMxy gAk3Ya2>PfʃaOT3bA`Aš @„  ?o_8gL(3z#"UkZSTNڦ.0L8}&IniS ^L SPBCЄD" sdH" sDD;!v1)[5#\j p8dj" gVMOhh&Mn4wi_7}iM"橃&ryDIAjւh<qiE `2 !C0))!$3c 60@0@>*  i`XA 0u-zva<)827Ti$<~h-&ؙMj\Z'm EDN'Ǡh p03g 7MA5Uj oKI0zO^J i ސtz|`gɃ/5 džâ"ʨa:$"pMPa'J&|;&rx=7U}U_{wڿq[ &vόou;u^N14>OACOn-['myMI;:m_V:vOM&lXM9}z67_^-CkQQC]}wWJ[\'ۮUzzɌɈ Ѕ ' _o߻Zu޿IO}6-H]_ E~\4m{ w=aM!=݃ ]x}?_AwAwJ;i~/䘞޿ Xx7k[_s'$u]_\7__4C_{i{_a}%GT}iڹ"$^m6_ o-|7uo}5I}A.{!ZM?ivMu{u{]GHKrG/A~ /~]Z_]+ k葉Zv]z__u׭~߯J)otPECJVKK127ګ﮿{~߿O'I݆AFS`1LwVMv{kIK]m.WҺom{J`@a0*)_j)ګV6إaA]]ui_aS_*M_MW_a{/َka,zjҦa4tP m@4ȎiM 1"!uAV0JLEqG] mM}WLSa;J{LDI 4 0Lfӆ 282~a8i4RMVv(@بG!GIiSjwlmGikLUPOJ""""""""""""""""#8B""$eP\'( aa6Dp AM;@i Lt0A0A$*h  F1hFX()v" ֙-& '[PA\aEpL(Jaj}5T %  """""""""""" `Y^@22. """""" ̆؈)꺧7YIgn҄C0 ՟)IET6DC#cDZfK@93;-04gnesLBtWFSv`vf@ٕdP__]pY\e TS ;% vK(}ࠠi_J?b۝ZX"9U^T  MLt?}'%Hܕҥw _%_}_~͑ _: 8f Jz)̒</YPITqo_^za& )A`h*rD03c<<ϊlRpt DF(L=)_Zzh`4M7pE8/k3z{k(P0P@ Csu=\HDo?ufIz4xH:/2gAO="0pTOŃD* p*zL t 0 2Ḃd.+!zp΢ AE#9 BlgF|S!A?6/ tf!A3adE'0 iU44\;^P͢x34N> 0S0P|P A2a0  &+ BqXAL uMNwۤ$ O#9N)i2.i L;EE]UeIڪ$? 6DݪU;jŃQ8vJ^:/O% 龟H7pdK[&5xAbXx;Dz5/// QI+M 32CD43tg'oqw 0zipt <t{6 =&t[MOȯU}'_ ڷ߫zzR<'I~}_Kk?ҿ鯿nV믽U__p,Xybzl !oQjڏZ}waD~b }_<1u~(u6'aDc^aP>`4L?Akmm_ ߻ =a!KW 6 M6a?K/(Kaa'6 z};5b/ol^#? l?A/l7[M!א:i]xl7ii~Unoow{lOLϠ_zFAZ<7m~—-K6ukum[_~}7j/ G~U~}ZZ J/}m&]l&+Zx؃m+lEk1 m+XV+oN 6_k޶_aȰ 4 0L0AlQ!d !0GW +T 6zu~}u ]vyXv:ke/:P xiC[ ඩOᆚL GL04i}{ [>մ҆KmDDDDDR:1`:PLa`Mz#V&]f5`PD1ʀ ֭B m)0 a06(8Md#Ӎ6- 7AqL|TS |U0TDDDDGDDI0 8ӆ04:a ӄ0A h mP @"@@ TS 4-uM*X""HDNgBfd.$A;S<50sMS h ‚:0a3~\AA; .""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'_cEppP q .3785 @.e6v2+&ʸ !hPS#l Jn AB#-PPW\\o+xaoE@-3C2z뾶?/鐼ׯ_U}u_Mȁ #](f0MAH1d1 #dj8A##s&Dhc589+K꿯u0U5Aa004iA(A(Aa0 2@Bؠ@B$IιKDƦfDM 0Ma M=0*a0T ة0A@`DZ$AtiLGѩDVQKHxRtGA3CDpC)fL:M6wi&}3Z/DŨT<ڪ&YCD͈S 0PBBͅ>(( a3|!͌0DPL D'ł ~`f@$A.ltOn E`ȸIl8LzM=9(b{=A|x^tyD݅ ¦?iTT&h0T yqp]zh0N0? mIS7_VpN|g6.=7";VlKw/2g78eM(UTN'mmSL*h`?HhOs^4^HƋ2tJzn*kO'Il'EN zccIH6 Ob{Ɛopw&x'EƓ'6o7~?tVinնPa$'M#ƗMOt^i7kW!޿Vۈ㷯zzzznOCNOOMU_mkJZ_0'g/Kc+_WK{[T}MW_}{+wЂ&#HczW_]{$<|#9_"Ql"Oޖ'kz ~/=o#o o~J?;D_ ufҖ_3Ɍ|7uH% nAOBp[,ۼ7+KrFHA/n }(_aK961wui0oKA~터/_zu~Zݒ:/$y z $~`~o__o_m/(G C]oaկkַ_Zӭ__}Kף'{[J>KXR?TXRtՆkKm'_4/mo_.ziҵ_N8;V;V#wj#m+KmZ}01ߩJԿ_kkvߺWio5_I+46)꩐ iؤ*[]jҍ>!iZ}=f6 1}. =ծmya&^— +7_ڂWL*L/ 0!40a4`) `d#`QR@i}J8b?am/NՊTU|;[[ǫ $Y^vL!pa5- /h008A0A &,04d#2@ NV*^^VIiSqWiiCJ)J>㈈"""""8 #'M4 a0SdAɡZ!4@ la@ئAqMP m0 6Dta aQN 6 ) [MmmW5j V{  UDDDDDyvrD_%Qt2pDDDDDDDR!: i/X"קK /0M:]?ɼ SaDDU0 #-1ɰheFhl-;TϨ' g  i&6K뮋{ ZSJ"r$dgYM~}H ’Lʨ& nЃGMI̓jU%JӆYqQ 4!U uPwtvK2*G_[lRړ]Vؠ;]Z}^0mq#sJ1"}V܋޺}]kU_(CŸ'gBw!&F _GB:G;F#R#NםQN_ S4' 02"; aI`q Y84r(KqUD.YNh' zoI`. h0ga0D!bt" B5rx#j#\{1ѯdfFY h V$'i̠ITyDMfr陴]a1&=<*a0(A XA1^٠8E$F(fCH" 0)͌" Ecj߯I$~YMpWO 㮐Ab{6'p|CE۵M Pm4Pg ߦ~`a0 @ =B3h43¦ yqrPA%pN3KNߞH6 Obkx@.-4ԼfoET ;Mv j"w;Pvv8vMl>'So-鮛~[KA}>m[d\" K& ޱqhqS}66m 2e l׋AET}_ j*ո`+u]>&M6z:M#`ȷI¯ 'KKI[i`ȹKvU?í*[}k}}UNqWi!M<*vV뷂~_I*K׿i[cַUtoON?uM}]8=y1X6$j`M~R7CkF55xDa va_/cx[ ߶'>mx __ k,L?'[}~kz t/ !D/t? Az%%DЊN?DN?x;fɧ/f /O_u{r#z__zՒ?VHܗOuկki}ֿ__;}[_ZnKJmZayz_޻_v_K.zi 8m.a}a دӺ[+ vk__Pյmvkk:L ؤؤ Mm(w %a+X*km~f6*m.ޗ4zV]+S 0O]k__]xT 0 0dG0A dGT `W $bM %Ua c… 1VMUma0)v&C04AjH!0Hh   `bi *+OҵkIc튦Ja&Kki4qDDDD˳B$%  Lxa{Kh4CC 5Ȏ 1@*6pD $ A t0i() az6lU!DDDDDDDԄYEa%kpj0a6A mR aza4A 눈 &U( Sr)w& nAa2? a8`D"20L)=kX"""""""""*"""""5p]@^/wA%%6d;42IPSX.vDqBf fD2+Fw_ !k+L A}^+3,gza5 A& v qJqڕ]ͦ@t&Ŧ"YKL'%}x4 i.n"l]Tm$lP4]Nmpo;gs 7I6$;Ii[&RKq"Xz_i%}$M_I-/mzקn$^ܐΨS)*_$Tv]nvU``;P@2v!J.`8DC*N {SHw͊8(M>0&^hJH#Y#lz5Z'T@`ɠvai*&;h08li.A0 ~#ff) SH< D<5HDz):2y Y d|:<`!TEALdޫMީ]ؚ!' RMob8gwHaB 4L ϐA@0ff 0@@ ^4,&x@  a0Uiz_&}pa7OML nA_8VMv'hᄓP5L$&S8!k'(P;I +(z`PVS }%IKoik^nGt/8th m;4_8? ^4^bŖŢKq&?6AOW6 doItE82. `Ӄ"]Y2 z}_H6f)pd[#3> kVJzn4„L&Kvu:Mj^p&m_1cސ;>[z꺺uIu[i^ _t_1^ⴿHjҿ\/& WAw8 vuB? ~kJ?DRouׯx\_ Iu_o~׾#/]/ z[/x"C޷#z_WI~/}KK =׿ccGCZN/߯_nZ^H WlV w?k_iwW뮓֩/i^H?d>³ Z^Z~Km+z"ﵵKߥkإ{&Gm%iU/ -ͫ[U{[]_صcb*,F~@մ>#VXm(`Ы~W_[K0_dG@"Qh`2:B:A86)M5QA8avLTmiE&G/ئIKn}vJҍa5|%a0 ! dXMP@؄LTI¶iA6-nV5 Zqҵj"""""" 2L)3R1츆a4  4 &)IbiiNؽxv;R1Vih4xB"". `@ -aza a0A0@ll&"Bp@@ Bh&La^DDDJt aaMy7׆G4 “p'yN2«D6" DDDDDqӤMu4#i6J&մ^i=izm&'(0Ka&0i@A &X&lF );쭳J*%T(S"A Ho}ASʙؖVp|ؑ-\߃kl~^<ڔ꾿."_G/uvU}wWn[f'ft) DRfZfCs!u59FD:Q|f7KI o@'H6 Ot5Zm_u[oz}ZMֺC\'I鿄~l.&x[Wm!DZk2<~խZM7M_c𼃟-°}i~>]k_ZkW4.S yb>.߂Wj_E~Rw_u'K$=^c?h^A!w[i{~_߶OAm8XcEZ_a.۠_P_^"o/:!5o!K//O_ Z~U~G|nt^/WuUtկ?K$y _۷Oׯ_W׿_t$VHG"GL/ҿznt߯W`/p/ZIj_%헻Rf6‚)C >V[ii:kk_kXӊ`Ҋmm(8hq6bo)~Kmnj{kA": l(l$GM5i0vil$[j}v{ (`i.cOa/iP' *m4m*vaE5T E0@DLB0AՅMI .qS\z1U#)= - V" #Sh07 a4 - L(Sh2+'QmE1@ 4 lz &1[m4B)ADDDDDDDDE!b0L)pdW,mB a4Ѡ= jA "8" 0Lgψ0[ 5\a0^""""""""""HL"%"#UK_4'T]zP.Ǵ0J"*AFFP-@L PPUGK?"o{׵tlB0#Bf%0 endstream endobj 131 0 obj << /Length 5494 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im132 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F133 13.26 Tf 75.12 707.76 TD (III.) Tj /F133 12.81 Tf 36.24 0.00 TD (Rambus) Tj /F133 12.72 Tf 46.80 -.24 TD (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable) Tj /F133 12.07 Tf -46.56 -28.32 TD (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: ) Tj /F134 10.95 Tf 314.16 -.48 TD (the Commission) Tj /F134 11.41 Tf -350.88 -27.84 TD (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. ) Tj /F133 11.96 Tf 235.20 -.48 TD (The Commission protects the ) Tj /F133 12.99 Tf 143.52 -.24 TD (integrty of) Tj /F134 10.88 Tf -378.96 -27.84 TD (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neither the role nor the) Tj /F133 12.03 Tf 0.48 -28.32 TD (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should avoid ) Tj /F133 16.90 Tf 374.64 -3.12 TD (trng ) Tj /F133 12.03 Tf 31.44 2.40 TD (to set a) Tj /F133 11.87 Tf -406.80 -27.60 TD (royalty rate for Rambus) Tj /F133 11.79 Tf 117.60 -.48 TD (s technologies.) Tj /F133 11.98 Tf -81.60 -28.08 TD (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus royalties at a) Tj /F133 11.86 Tf -36.00 -28.08 TD (level of at least 2.) Tj /F133 12.38 Tf 85.20 -.24 TD (5%. RB 14-) Tj /F133 11.33 Tf 59.28 0.00 TD (25.) Tj /F133 12.12 Tf 28.08 -.24 TD (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement ) Tj /F135 8.00 Tf 225.84 -.24 TD (- the) Tj /F133 11.96 Tf -398.64 -27.60 TD (Rambus-) Tj /F133 13.68 Tf 43.44 -.24 TD (Hyudai ) Tj /F133 15.61 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F135 5.00 Tf 47.28 0.00 TD (agreement - to justify its proposal. ) Tj /F133 5.00 Tf 171.36 -.48 TD (Id. ) Tj /F133 10.81 Tf 17.76 0.00 TD (17-) Tj /F133 12.25 Tf 15.84 0.00 TD (18. Rambus grossly) Tj /F134 10.82 Tf -339.60 -27.84 TD (mischaracterizes this agreement. ) Tj /F134 12.47 Tf 161.76 -.24 TD (Hyudai did ) Tj /F133 12.02 Tf 62.40 -.24 TD (not initiate negotiations in response to a) Tj /F133 12.91 Tf -224.16 -27.84 TD (RaminkSyncLink-related ) Tj /F135 5.00 Tf 133.68 -.24 TD (waring from Rambus. ) Tj /F133 11.75 Tf 116.64 -.24 TD (Id.) Tj /F133 5.00 Tf 17.52 -.24 TD (17. ) Tj /F133 11.90 Tf 19.92 0.00 TD (In fact) Tj /F133 11.91 Tf 30.96 0.00 TD (, Rambus and ) Tj /F133 13.86 Tf 68.16 0.00 TD (Hyudai) Tj /F133 11.92 Tf -386.64 -27.84 TD (commenced negotiations for an ) Tj /F133 15.77 Tf 152.88 -.24 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F135 5.00 Tf 47.76 0.00 TD (license in early 1995. ) Tj /F133 5.00 Tf 107.76 -.48 TD (See ) Tj /F133 11.93 Tf 19.92 -.24 TD (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-) Tj /F133 11.14 Tf 118.32 0.24 TD (62.) Tj /F133 11.93 Tf -446.88 -27.84 TD (The ") Tj /F133 11.87 Tf 26.88 0.00 TD (Other ) Tj /F133 15.86 Tf 30.00 0.00 TD (DRA" ) Tj /F133 12.01 Tf 43.92 -.24 TD (provision was included in the resulting ) Tj /F133 15.69 Tf 189.36 -.24 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F134 11.16 Tf 47.52 0.00 TD (license. CX1599 at 2) Tj /F133 11.33 Tf -338.16 -27.84 TD (24.) Tj /F133 11.88 Tf 36.00 -28.56 TD (The Rambus-) Tj /F133 13.68 Tf 64.56 0.00 TD (Hyudai ) Tj /F133 15.69 Tf 43.68 0.00 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F133 11.96 Tf 47.52 -.24 TD (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent) Tj /F133 11.93 Tf -192.24 -28.08 TD (Rambus) Tj /F134 10.86 Tf 43.92 0.00 TD (s deception. Indeed) Tj /F133 12.11 Tf 95.28 -.24 TD (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus) Tj /F133 11.81 Tf 227.28 -.48 TD (s deception.) Tj /F133 11.95 Tf -366.48 -27.60 TD (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies potentially covered by its) Tj /F135 13.73 Tf 36.72 -36.48 TD (12 Rambus) Tj /F134 12.01 Tf 78.72 -5.04 TD (s arguent that) Tj /F133 11.93 Tf 73.92 -.24 TD (, pursuant to reasonable and non-) Tj /F134 11.12 Tf 159.12 -.48 TD (discriminatory tenns) Tj /F133 11.59 Tf 99.60 0.00 TD (, it) Tj /F133 12.01 Tf -447.84 -13.44 TD (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p) Tj /F133 11.97 Tf 321.36 -.72 TD (tent validity, RB 13-) Tj /F134 9.74 Tf 111.12 0.00 TD (, has) Tj /F134 11.00 Tf -433.20 -13.44 TD (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available) Tj /F133 11.92 Tf 312.96 -.72 TD (, there is no reason why JEDEC) Tj /F133 11.96 Tf -312.96 -13.68 TD (members would have accepted a ) Tj /F133 22.55 Tf 158.40 -.48 TD (RA ) Tj /F133 11.98 Tf 36.96 0.00 TD (proposal that excluded any company that chose to) Tj /F133 12.14 Tf -195.12 -13.68 TD (challenge the validity ofRambus) Tj /F134 10.84 Tf 162.24 -.24 TD (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus) Tj /F133 11.79 Tf 243.12 -.48 TD (s efforts to) Tj /F133 12.08 Tf -405.60 -13.68 TD (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competitive challenges ) Tj /F133 11.84 Tf 438.48 -.72 TD (to the) Tj /F134 11.59 Tf -438.48 -13.44 TD (validity ofRambus) Tj /F135 5.00 Tf 96.00 0.00 TD (s patents. ) Tj /F133 5.00 Tf 49.92 -.24 TD (See ) Tj /F133 12.33 Tf 25.20 0.00 TD (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of ) Tj /F133 11.95 Tf 229.68 -.48 TD (Competition) Tj /F133 11.92 Tf -400.80 -13.44 TD (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-) Tj /F133 12.01 Tf 158.64 -.24 TD (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit) Tj /F133 11.94 Tf -158.88 -14.16 TD (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\).) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000873758 00000 n 0000873817 00000 n 129 7 0000874021 00000 n 0000874188 00000 n 0000925388 00000 n 0000874731 00000 n 0000874344 00000 n 0000874475 00000 n 0000874604 00000 n trailer << /Size 136 /Prev 873429 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 930949 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000981539>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R 122 0 R 129 0 R 136 0 R ] /Count 20 >> endobj 136 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 137 0 R /Contents 138 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 137 0 obj << /XObject << /Im139 139 0 R>> /Font << /F140 140 0 R /F141 141 0 R /F142 142 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 140 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F140 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 141 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F141 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 142 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F142 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 139 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im139 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 43699 >> stream ) fTd~?ԵyjQGxj &u * Ei,u d bB [2'UH06T38%I^RWH/B ;;Z1ކA(9RD((*L*i!*Kj4n2̥&SLj`JC 6AUprcjPjevHx(Z=W]k}$(Z^Aƍ'IMT6GA "KysD?UUm%]&v! Q8 zE8)8@Υ|:J0zMI4N:DjSSAa NpC8d&CPNGL菥_IۯŤBhc'2T\6A.$=4M E=3bfL'a0 `I DAKȑfY:gB UڭN '#gfo h ɜhz/HLgD.eM' 4fOOL&x 0@FLSF 2xɃ:"!H3GHȬUV +^+a?]>8Iӥi>m}&hprO{t( OL`L.fL'0AA&@ͅ<)8D- a0O<2v`D$ˀdzm-]7O_N\t2-}/BExPdTIA7`M4Mژx[ 5ǥ@DVJ_CM}7[Mޓl+Pzo#0(2(Ew& EA/ ^|0Aimd˗SE6izu?ZOW?}t UA&L':M2/Rm^zwg]ovP{i:_/]y1u[O{mS~km%jw$G Am)7ӫ? ?91A=k[k^6޷CW]{['B?/,G_~ j5׭=_W}_o,G[GKci%?J}/ "w[X/:ۯ_]֒#w}{Ѝbj}/k(y %K_DǰIa_O;oOrH!  0W_u/^AIz[D%m/]{$_d=$i~#ICn/A[ ^c_1 u~, GiwODlm|pإ:Niy7W]^￱LmuD^X`!SH0jWl}q (8=]m~)oָRca~mZ^/o[wkMiAV:C!zLna&5*xADvլWjHt]pW~m}}+_mukjo_I- Rc= A}4 *B:@A A@d A 1qmk_Z jԺuͺKU!!r  $ 0% C[TmZjihad ᅶ)m4*^0m$]~""""""" $Q23 0A{I A @ `LT0Ӵikq &&>aa ߭R=""!W lRn ^PjdG Du o[h!lU` M $qDDDDC ld0a4iP/ ~dMAjȃ&bGMp ϵ0@A!RU"""w؈&0z""5>U88ο>߳𕸿a<:NF pSƓ"I꟯AjIEL#Qy32*j0L؊ BPa 04  " &d0D d*}%M®__KKV_޸B DvD*' *hi0sHzM0T^h&h60UmSPUMS ЮK zzzojop82$PON|i33J GwE<'A6tm_5:B=]澿OZl&K֝z}]mIJz]-n/~j ~)k oMG?nzn~}]^Z_?m(<'-?_WVZ鮮z@"Qoa^L!>wC5 _z ſ=N༘v]QK H_ o/i}װ/B?￵)b?u?߶CoK_~[m}=O"0_mRro_~_]={aR]cmo_i_`y#Ao[DҺi}w_ ~s;/7}䏦7NlxL0a}_oխ{w}_ZA>Ҏ;j݄=o];x` %m*Yja+kkj~ц_m۽d MFquvJƝ_jCcm_ V %_t_^{OoHZtL :  aL|Rwm]oa(c# cO`^߬In_'_o^ L?#2h0P#sO&A*T0@h64t܅{[qLS7XRcbf6M0S}0ow$BkA )M! ) 4 dW,ji A M4*M50@b8;U#Skv=[|{utkDDDDDDDDDTDDA8C Sh MB@ڊi@ 6I׊Mmna&wkjն@P`0a0@R a.Ȏ )aB  m$0@ a 0@ بt""""""80A-0A*Ѡ{A idWIp$tDDDDDDI` "0U$,DDDDh"`%#P(/M+LWa4!1D(@*#`aY^DD O5ȗB!+#⶜dR aJV(%ْWEC 5 B`0Rq#"4d'&I'DtL A0B#;.8 Jіɹ_ZtP3b'l"C ӵ[¦[VExT  I.> aTeݷI&I9xPwi *zA\i-wꞜ|J2H]M3QST a 0 " 8B.3'E="Bҫ_oItMAPafCDo . p.U CO/*0>8cai8(O֭-% uxSuh'H l Z'o]pɅUf ?_ >f]'g3Y) DP V{ .PMC=1HL郃lPϋ20C ApFYB cp3a" r!E0E sPA1B1Qj"1j3=" uuaixK W$4Dv}q<} 2D'mxTLAAPga (A- p ` d0F0Eo a& 't_)ȑIguM 㦚eMJifL qAcOJk(?8m'߫4h qh ;ı0rx/(eZ/h0x㗐C 0D킪$>!X{^N W>3<3b`~ `}?&J X?W`nPRqO6oקIinI~ۤls4am6!ud]}u=6_Kx_ ^a~}Z,vC_ǿxQ=Xoo]KMo&?K`__  -ذ/}GuzTn?a?n aæ:mk+(K_mo__oD"Cqa MK^~{x$_K^^A?!6[_i{{i7uu/_ 6ݰP֭{}~M_7_z_߿% o S%_Ok_H{`C4VC]ނk}iCVo%s6cz $ ZTpյ*&.Ij_dpCIZk{nﾽUֿiDuU k=[um&@҆C[O_[[~5T &>a `Ax" B i6TTRVwI齄\)_/juֿ|D8D33l% MCALS Z"6D|VDÃqVaMeҰ; %PP׳DDDZ>X>ʚ$s2[4L&U>N`aڠ8=nǫ +[IDzqGiCIXcv+Bj—)a33e51?a0ȃL Ȏ lPbLRM4ݪb:X=XhDDDDHp j @*LtaF姨a0!4iA aBS@ 46B6ؾ""""""""" `)n5&=PO!^i4^Ia'["B0AhGDDDDDTDDDDDDDDH4 "eMUŤW}"" ^^H$VZKI!^B a Dk!U `Q ",ܠi#FW !hO]]T+P VWmI|[lOR78L davgfL@߲ 3ૄ,'^5}Au ;f.>z)x;ZMW_~\Ge>v%f*_2eC񬳑k%#F/WS(Lp@(#ڐ$Fml ~*a0v+PB> xAr-AC639!^#GГ_^2|4OȖN8J*XJg8(M54  g("#AMLM#LHH6NzPN,qE;je97'vi &pPxAa (A I N!͑5Fȇd:Fdc0k25DFjYS$}ӯ´|$ lȱ nMhcBjxkTOz` \ A(AaPa,& ʰ3c: C&|$!aI\'N/\"ЏBN}MY5/O_.9[tlIbgËwDxAw`ЛM&`i%D܅&h3  ރ6*h<qhj p'#30=?_Mt _I[h<d,: 15<[MGDa8Z ;Mv'jҢNl_>`鴘%o':} =սm*iƉߍVSDB~31(A(La дD8< дA.`s!N]D3A=a[֩St>ZNM[_Mܸ TtȖXgmtOAj`av07!nL0ᩬ0pktKt-:%ӻNF 0331$Ke8/HQ|Ӌz// Z/8:27H&ψlCe !zn_~nKKׯ~nOoIiu_~ _,g~Ҩ?kUok޾˴uz-!_}b}_6_Qۭݿ~گh"O]7_҇_5  _Dܧ5?K6)K솞A~ {~D[_KcK$id4z['?9^H_U_ozZ_%4n"K!o W zK0]ju;{K_}%ze? !|4V`wv]r$1 o?U/ol.կU?}h?_mK4 <A4N톕Iz6QUa G0J_KoF 턨0b 6)j6X6"׿_L/iV~W簒ezez &jટ[Mڠ@Mn: lM aAmmu@~5/_czk uo"""""&q'@—y {;¦a5^iZi; M ݪ `0AMKJ#Om/m(acq1_`DDDRDDDDDDDYSA ?)2(MVN4ӓ": {LRh4֚ucM6Ik{Mvjj]I\DDDDDDDD?gituM281V+40 qL0Aj* lUSaT0A!C;t(a_uUDDDDDDDDE@D5a&8MV PS8Mva.“maA96$(Ј9R! dk &?Q #a}IX""""6"""% ICIuB!b0*4v U`0,B6JAV8,d;,Yeqh vCzdN%'k#Qv dUPe“ +Xh;@Dn? ;M2$##l?$֗zEL*j v jEY8fGh3">ӧv@+:. aB ;$d#%н8;I889 Mj (^Q$Nd!P8?^PP_W꘻><D~+`zjiC͌eC4yAMUxTx(PдA&pΣʸ<6ԬZzWUO A 𠠃H!t0p'2pE #'f Slgȓ>V7ɗ&rpmTSb.SF\PI4@A0LaOAD5#:k%ϊpS"Z7 5,qhea>AUQySUMwaPa aO͌D?Ð=d359B5h39<5 i-\0GԼSҤ4e0T KP*a;AB4,4E- a 2 ` p2Ț3PBN SAO!_M_ִׄ6? Lpd\qhߡEA:$X'OaҦh5ASmiz :LB 'lT ._}V;]?CM®IKڈ|^$N/1awDhU34N`Nh4aú0 7V%_ >#ݧ~vIa[kO7kХn*'=__kקzzn_ݽ_:W/ __xkCK [X}Oo"Cw'~b!*qzI__Mo봿 [$:Q/g_oG "Q"Q__}~Y>&Q׵Tz+$ ޖ_}Dwo}oM/յ K%_m}'_K.N_ҺxR=ޫk6IW/m9y# H$T7[o Cm-޻__nkkkW(plH4BS4&0ou k]ߥެn6!Ȱa`A iHi>Tikv@WKLj__U{_Km/մ/[of i ( m h>(0@`@ l3pIuþڎDwV~`{/}pUpi7a.چ70WaOaok{pӥN a !AڠAv)+Kji6Zէu`q_ڱL0*۬/i0Q3DDDG5B,A韔ٰڭ+":dGA ;Mm%iDテJTquQMDDDDD0LN a0 I:@ q@AE2@Â0OL]lT}IN")ЈagGM?\ai\i(MB\ta5C $T0MkTDDDp0a0@ua !(2A@a6C 5l90a5VuDDDDDDDDDDDhDDD `-nJHDG $W_n4*̩%UZl0kX :0? M(Q&Ldi>L.j& šperc3T,}Ҙ x@g#|HGa4)YV"GaXB,&F 6B4Yfv`ҫ[C ͒菆0w X^mAl = l;WAG#YCa.  s&&>PkTX m._'Wa`x9"/5fH/qLJ4!Ƈ_UKҪc#8-;!뺿^Kpp( B hA&B"y Zm ΦuE{%Hꂪ_㎵A S < aA 0@A؀Y@r1"DCЊY/ F9:^N RuNd;|$ ɻDM& ?T =XJ P80zU=8: bkH ViP'D駦M<;l鯥?炟8)6GQٮ0E/Nz)5jG/H*E[~tI8bh-xŖrŃ'2Z440B0CD @` $4Ysc A!xmCFL '𗰚y,=82%oIsZ2B'NW 0 aSAC8ةi0(AkS_0uMppz2S' 0U4$nJs3P'$;ڤA?^p__Oq\_EON'jDn8AkN&jd EE㋰WK_j=ni]]&OM`ȶ Ұdoa8:$Se,gNq,]k ]]7Ӥ' [/8fktMȃT+۫JIp?6 N?{u7__Dݯ6I ?K}_$kd[ka__ۥ_/rZ?zu?_ p#U`_-/޿_ziwl~6K__iO~~_ pa1لZO~ֿ^z_0Hu~D{|nZm.L[ -{;K}j_8 <" Mja(m- ҰեaS6m!y]/_u - m:ئBMVxi10XkiDlmw4V_@J~5]+_~t›֭0aU4m ": `UEE2uMmEm %z~_)$ߛZ~7M4K"""""!GVaa+_ij *iL (1GaIݫQwLUQ}ZV]ec븈‚:24Rn M3ML 2z &!GIQ`10Ҵ&VvPm/"""""! /PA4 i 6(tȎ! {(kLRkDDDDE}G8U4Ȯ i jMI ka&L a>4"""""""jLaIRnB (&T<鄡˴8}r6֚J$BzQa i``ӆDaG-uUХɱig23d*kd](LȢ+FwtBwi\9GkຮdJgd̔({d\Et駨L ]WȚh = =߅ v80;3!>ۿj9 IWP}X* ;Ѧ k6,*0sFA%_{o߮"0ph]Ýd=0ݣU}}o;稸s!Mb;03.ү<31O 00ݶBG33f$gS5gSS_N*SEkAB`s4,4A `}H% ',EOa$|zOSL"v-A*gMpAO P3͘#Ft:H3́u] *Y?:ɗT'EOLDƉ#'zlD fP84A PPA  rEЇZ 񬖤zyVDF.r5_:=,JIWuK% '$x:WAsD;H 7|\`vSLD0M0*ੂ !E%@%4A<g6!t d"y^CP^V onzm]}&ńꭤ-s33"';h= vtWGCT'L'PT0PhX!dm/~kM] On +"'A89t_dKZ'mN882ehLT^=V08$JT*?[+{u~7C'xW]=:M lNoERJ3pރt.333$N(~F_uzW_i+ N} v <8Ɨȸz}_#[ V}_UZM}W_?B{zW upm_kh_k&1൯\Bo_}?[_t/U?__^oo[ub[zN,k("Oz_&9NZ1b_j+o[]}_°G] '? /׽+$lW_} /"Oal? Ɍ>?Gm/_/ozl"Qa[K޽{TdqK$vHA`/^l?A?z_iH~_(Kz[u %iik} ~_ -x>[jڿ|hj_}שkuÑўlP &l8z=`kmi7ZyOS Xi~_}_i b !""lVi1Ma+IӺp Gik}6}~~}LMz`i0i9  8 TW!GOXpwS]v;*ǧ 7mkڗǽuߥ_{ADE#&1jxaO 0Vkak h0jL `*d(AI,q@vaׇ`aoHbc}}-,DDDDDE#C80B &QV aL kM"QaBZl&0i{Rv۱Q0[5n;V +[J#mVӮ""""""""""g eef~AL&4jA6 STA!Q 00A#㊆iM:;?X0L" l&POTMv„״ɾ4(QLApcJR& `A 0CeN ‚:)7 h0&Da DDDDDDDDqB & lMLܑQVDDGMHH\4bnd(0MqqhSyiJvvp^؇XCPR\26F!!DB?eK+24} !;0d@@ tOH8axDs?@_D]S [ R4PfWnDED*I 2p„¨API%*4L+uݕ`fw\$F.I\]*ZhuNvPOI7C?9 [n!C03+ 5<8kua? D 3c<^uMAжLRa<=qǿiHԎh#==]z'֘H|6%U\0ph: 4E%s|3Y菚n6 :mѬm3 4Tfa д"$N͌)@x)VXL<=gS5g34~'D!.7u[@azs1Ou/%O Bia4ڠ$8   a0P (A`AaM;63 D'=jBõK\CP\$p~|: H42%¦4@PPM<xT`&ujҋzonONmTm i~//vNHt 84N2]DƉSDi7j+K.lR}N4< <-'@r@)m:7 n'N ƋǯҖ SOP+֟}ޝ[Aa>% oo m'MQۺ?޽m/s[K'kjO''ߺmwX7T!~o{~׭_׷_]Aw\/8HBv,1 >׶m/D([|5}'HK쐳Wq%ou #&08}_/[ݏ=RߴaA ? ߂-%wFG^?BA~ o[uI'oknzꗭ=4=?I- A^]}]Hվ4$a5//a[KݤuMI$Zۿz3K0HPi{M/RCHѥHi4 zVooHuK+hpZHai~ MI4ՊU/^+PaSH8G,0@ a MxN*)+A; ᄫR {m+m/_Ko05S8_.1Gr@`P t**&Oh+اr Mد-~Ծ=/ߛ_a(|i0SXA]&kj 2#)NMcu]i6W=VOqI ! iU!@L&j ihaȎdH0j8ؤ4[aݬT{ .ⵈ8愈0LՃ - SL. iT"Z00A 60@0@:@0A0&kB"""""!F"La>L8A %iv$DAmR0B"%a0L0^a0MtRUDDDDDDDDGIzեj jRшL?ؓѕpPepS"(\  ӰE1?!न0p0̀؞v:q$ ~F| ̫E;$2VfEwYSAƸPPlBf0(RZtR Td1\?U?i6BeDvui+9[k ի%6E:3Z5E:_U]/a<& &P&T #y:gB/:_/M:L*&+ <&`L `h6<)`R@Lf|#G"f/ku'Bx[JLgo'TK$y#z A߹{?tT>4]oz+~7 K]R/oЍׂ;KFp^d$y_:Kk[x/Ca/Aݥ/nWKm//JޗrT0._mtA_dJ?i9zWiH1;aVa// -[_/lj./RI/V:;_IV+aj##&*պk,/wk{~{ څ$~i !`bLII:e%붞 vb`WW__jSI{uV 0¼4¤ A b@8ai; klVlUڭXY Sy1 !H3]v $Nim8#FP Ը@|UMVa O a` 4U\~(prƟ5!}ӦG[iMExR=qHOρ+?WaI7%Boyj]dAIMh6K$zJ"@{﴾؈b)B SB|54C:h0@Kd ݊dGAcv6$]ZDDDDDEtL ~ 5 3T2%.uX(PMBxʬhʓ) ^(. ap@¦SVvVWm!Z_PU t1 f(~oUu.)88>]K׫UR@ ,BPf"~8(L'A0  `>&hd c*D21BCD 4αO'mSOL;O d`BaBfcLP !0AaPD"&ɱLKƜXp'Ozt`t38pd˓DžET;@0=j .* AA(L ύ0A0* "XU~BOM[# ;׉xJНO2oD蓰;M҄0T-&8MTa0U {BM´^񶭃"CAz h-@p_8>yDcDƉ|EU޿zߧzOפzVx:N & fz pd\2%6 A}ሯcO/-pڶzmu[irXo l|!bbW{k^֓M~?uD￰v##`9b?|KJ=CV[]l hv? 0m__J_qt/{l u`2:_Vi~xt76aG$/]6@ג/FXpo!/_m{o?åA}?K&; k__ao}t/${o%NK^/n;dHd]#V]~][ nkۺaҲGGAVմ+wڑf=__ڴմ]Yi&B ,4+imI㵈k_e#يԿa}imwk~Oj dGAbh mF N\0M,vKlװ}MmnaJͭ/iեvyA [Iڦa7dGHTSA@c M:j>?;+m kK4Qo`M0Rq4e* ݄iq„V0:0A$*d `d# '{ *b+ilE-|mXD. Ҋ$"""""""""""'LĂe : V4a^ p m i Ra6( McMd(jKC 4,LÕ\ `XaZ" jA h0 l a0iA 0@ئF &R@ lAA'aL&_#p^‚ 5a=/O4 DD[IJ?jy-uQro™ aJ,L( fJ F nb0pLF.pw20tE0[;־Ʌ#VI4wDW4`h ŢHv*nA ة'qBaqqB d0 ȁ5pSH 'G1/6 O"BH6q6qŬh5TTMP.(A0a 4A0` ͘0$B["L#S3\)N3gm/&ոMt'a7A2.Ar b{v ip'jD &`U<'0g" POTT_eN}o]]}WC?ץ_m+'IVd\Ƃ7=t-2g'}0dNNN2]UD HpÇT SMABv1z_zU~Mp_d\iZY +I;l>kbgtB ı Di]QW_~tz}z' {zW ƛpaJ I&ߠdK_LD&9]NIzMitOB׽tO"+} _im|]5_ַ_ ~%z_鶽ߋoK _o"O~a_=:4)GDد/ub?b ^7 /o_oX_}-m77]%o"O_/տikqY"ï tFwq#jި دZ_I0ki/r.##_U{ ) %ciz]+Ko_+[K6_nz uUOm-i}/akmMWaPvB:l6MXa.#]?u LVva__봿_w v QmA QYC!Ax aAalSZwL]+Q]Sw aafճ _ߪ""""!A*A& ڧVIAhZ n` mP a* R!Gvkimz4!}}ӵAr+]v~$B !  P7˴U_[Hi6 B qLSM 4ݎI6[k+l5>DDDDDDDDDDDDDDD2e2IaTt@P mA0@æ)0Aa0bӥ` Ah5BVMZa5 4-i@*"""""2` " g  Ÿ͙0IxDDDDDDDp b}j…B4wB{A]6/n\ql)N*kM0\*im3KYحU|B…22"[Kuׯ"8;]?HMJ;*_q20C+;I4 h3 a2Z U"K=4v(efk; A a?J?89>$ڴ`¦2< 2^*'4^:޾輤A O' &隲]fh^,Ryh p$BJM &C3t#^zN00B΂B.dF xSH3Y  Ckyι̢!=?ׯKצ%Bp'zzh4]5wPC<4fca haO ‚ !5C *JA3UE$ڄE mQ>i:' "wU *a$M0 4?4„ aB (LB1`Ofq<.5~&a:MLAI;wA'S78JƋʦp'p鵦*`S8д<7%B))rk&UА9':Ui_i Uu=uOMӃ?ფ815q'I O'9N'm4Nઃ :İTPS4 a4wֿگoJoK_+Ҥj|:nta;|O/a4Ni'l&BIڠOU_ƭ}N]_M⭫OBm'W"#A޶YD/; /(\?KK]1i]=z_kڃ"=882.RwJh NLLzK-uo}W_uVvI'LKW냓zzwKO_^uJv D-u>t?}]k_~wצG*o[a_۽A}ecDqT1إyƁ m/ A?;rqCc?!oo__uQ}8{{ 63~y E_h/ݵD$a6WMY>kHi/%^A~ûmޓz_-/ݺ3C}/-/]߆_ikKWzjQ_#$i!d477ߴ0K. /|5o_[KKџvc /-+[ksWV*m80f?a&IWm*_[{\>uK_ P҉ Zl ~A|z|UGZ[ukam+1ޝ/߶__߷ݥk~#~MZv6 mFES 'lzlmZEIaC؃cMUuڗ_o{Vҷ'?wH% 0L9er ,S;ڄ* 2#A ` AME1RT}1۰!궗`R=eR҆۫"&x]B{L興D6"!:`S-281 ȃDpUa 0AƃbX5إn6*ҵ0pI}xKmPAq5& N j0 Ro[ &Bmlt6@:iSi $ q\U=-!!'i+iuq$B Y^00Vm4T0A ATSf]-0B $|DDDDqal&0P VL(TM0bM%bC$$$M0e!0a--DFDDDFQIP!jZErM`AJ*!15U8xaSA3= tC. ;ӑؼEr\PP\$#Am@/ћ8h ?彆Dv3Fgk@ #[U fCB}Ĭd<0tz… ,:%r{%0  D_փb!B 5I>o$\Aƃ]""m oKVlAc:g|~ߤNt>a ‚ ` !fCt6&FD9ԊwT{(g\)kAT$U6(A  Ca0@’A(E <" sc(dH1HyND葝svng_NڦjDP;͊M8*a< 0T``D\"3'f, lԎityJg6@:zEA7ƉDa0vv;MݢZH"NSDx(M0O`ß2Hz@GUȧ&P"N=4 Id\H i;m@;iNaދ&H2$A5MS8*`]iD #4M!Ch͌&hHЋ!R5L.__dnt'K3?W8|L.4NqT?TxL 08-0 (A4 (OzO[ OBVd>,&ȹ'eA>:_Dh&SDj/4¦5g___O__oMI_h&qNZ֨ @Kq48I1yӻ ]aw_]x=I/__]naڹp֗{u]ۧ%5vkz #Kvd$[*ҋ"Oj}?Wk^ x~ mnޛot?i>M]_]^~z-ܑ~Hd7m+{w^KUT= vͦvoaL `&$ݥt4)du\V0m8O]vKam'zV}?:}XAa(1A  0A&&U[4} MC 6_曤W}}0AAA6B: m2#N)a]ƚ`} 'z{m[m+K"cV>Y_3"n p¯ 4"8*L0i8*A!"8Al`A إ_k %[i~aN P`DDDDDDDDDIk `A‚kg&[mAZvA0ibiqWL4mcx?bn␎"""""""(`i؃  m  = (0@d &m i4+aqDpKj 04Nh;M60Ajpp @륈 `l0?&~ˀg6&| tY7_0JR"""""*""""""Hu,Z^X2jJ oSRM7  DK{vC`j&Ϛ2](T΢DYCa34;;d̕zhb Ml*AtAAL򭙲(ᄓv kZ((AdcS;2#"VTgzI*UI}AQ xTAS!bVhi!wi$\L.wZ]J.EB]{_~f3AگE޿"T"fI̕BvAcJwLeHdC0Z߿[".u0SဃL A9PȔ"ᚇ #VufDo?_'`*A(A08A'@xP(;EFȑ,) dx8o) I;A n4N`&rnL*h<&8 Q #bȶ9t' n4t8`}T „ᦃ\(C0h03X` aBa{a0!xqg5EnKbZ鯴鱧^Fpd\uI7atN!:AMU0TNqaWL੄x)ᦈ0ժޫjz}_}ioz["X r wOhoZ |n.˗St;qM   tWR=t!7NPO=?82%doIoy^8lAI>ŤX&3.W׭"_Ku]-WMpu_mB֓'}&([%i&'31M_Q1,`0]_B;-m_k? rO.ߺj߽' /}c`1z:^iu+=mBm/ A(??0_? O_خmAkl=/l?Kb ,~]-?y# 0m/ aD۰o}Q13/abFAK/[ (^Iow[һJ-.-/]anק_տ[0^[K^m/~a,>_0~?~C,D-_b[V* %JA0 +}VدKxo?%V)4Վ=>ᬁb—x—]ծ_o A  40 Th&4ՊJ%}CJ#ںb?mn  z{tUJfA*Zh0hC@M 0A QLC X$Ql0|*= _-oں5o/(`0LLS>P00!E dGؠ@M8o8+aWbzXR?k^cژY:1 ]萉*<0GRa0)7 ) \pȮ dXA7aUv Ӹ0L4"`V]U%8I7? l5 N EU1PA VltiHQRqI $qt!66|e#M: ȹI&&t=X#,gZc/B/(i_[z~z_N'i}IIpd\_X i*{^OǤߥOmmuU֭7[a]zD~Xa\WcC>5#_aiI'0Z v7~b C$t_t6'_}#{1 ,1H(l5 xo( /vKl w'Lo'_Y1^?]{[O$zzi/GC_p  =׶ 6^aч 6?I7( -^+Kۯ!_do-CK}vH$y x{ |6^^[k [wJ׾mz]?<#k<: 8oV&q_ (_մWTcoPϠٴE6ViبnR?#bb1jV}m^޿>L7pL  4x nM-[^ֻ_k/K6(k]~L4 M q@0@ې l 4 1PvKJ#;Kcm+,0 _]mҽ߯vq`DfL Zizӻa0VnL  j*B>6AӴM%%ئ>bMUauYuj^߬5׈3aBMKt_A P0L&8E6DuNkᄞKaF]il4qݭՄ 1v `&8MSmBT m4 ⚊5@ 6iHSM,PQ;[NAʚ av h 4 ! adGTqQa; Lؚ & * ):aBiaBiBMZXtb"""$ &0LUS]'J_ئ+Ua0JYB9 #lTj!Mɱ-Y72ySPi+b„`:AB MNƣt4;PBaBenL-|/'=G M[_W'!fVtzA/5pP _3mӿnlX@VB两p|`v>QZz7M Ye&y*Kwtwм0@‚"'2"TPk%82Z _W_S8*a0pa;0!B .vh͌RDm#5 ՟?dTNn[jmPTa=; @`0L ϑ' h:?'/:0dD(TUk LL&pPA(Af) SPydȚJYScG &pd[tnA 㦚 N-pSUU `h48 903$2paJ:B:g.  *&]ά#=*f𴝄5<'Jf)?r;zA&q4bg|򨝴-ǪiIDf L   CB D`‚0L J EDS":G?m,[itzM48:N4`ȗm0HoUMWM~D`BznT`T "L  HmUں„_ONӤ27Ik%Q3'^Q|> |Xpt^EOM¦ALݡni01ŮHn6~}u[v&<0N[`'"tX1}$ $_8O?1+_Ы |7K{…M/ ]]/Tpd\~`Ȯ}&o4XC!}a_]mjvOۿ?oPZ *]}{®תzkN-pV@ /%?_cbXoZoOw d8:K!a_IۮC6?,7_l7I/9u_/^G__Ig0CR_o } $?l0-._=u~dB0l7l6(~/___K]cWNl_# ~׆A 6uKiom~ ~aKzwZ)SG_mKݤu%AaS x iiZ : P@d i.Xi/j;?0Z8ؤҵn+iԿG>DDDDsT"" `?͙oNNl%M!m2# hTm16iDPa(k;V8%0 &27L6 l9 aEE2#0 ⩠ AKDDDDDpgP͕44g  &SL&kMSIAG_TB!O:b#'0@3b.*^®%"""#B"#+ _TZPA"&^CZQ¬ȸXua'QpˆdQB%PT>v,D0@C"l;"(G̋3!%qTPH" Pܯ^AvV3ܠZ *$34Q#8aAjnptJK gRIAPps";_{RzQgf)dz5)<*kЎ f4.E8aS$D? R9H^oy,{Nod\EA)EA:O/(haxaa[FB3f)S6a*: t"R 0N[!;W'ߡkW"EM#u"[I+ &Nþ]T& w!ׄA SC *0LC ;MMӴWZn_}ZIk?i}l%'bt>0!a0N4V8aB?mZ_]}o?p MńM2.w_ &z/pA^4_64Ƌ |r|-Qkz/xVzltVIH6|S m'DA+-R/W ~_}dž0ůjuZ^&']^'ݭ'H~}zu%V1 T}m}O]륥tM m.?~7~!/O=ow׷__A'ۯ*_Q[Ia!K__,6/__Up!.ip_o^CZ_ _?.#˯7j{OKd5 '~!.O_?0 \-?үcA~Kտki]uW2w_~ o~EOM z)}KoN#G?G` D@…ҵ}z}v׮jZKm/9T8{WPҊ*6!'ݫat[Kcn;—_KڷO[׷vDTղtEh6BvX&=aD4J@(G G ]-_/[~v)˜5Ah&h0dG@UqUQVbcqTiUX^K#) p? J뽴"ш aS \ZTkPR5Q AŠdHULABhhUz0h4+;I׼j_ORpAKR͉&J\aB4)a5005aPL&H0L8 lrkUn6 lp;O|DDqQDDDEt`DMMNP ک y&x al$T BM7i>ᄓMV?&~S—jcҴMihaAiH 0A ت_0&rm0T+90^iq](ZبW+?ɰٕ.(龌3z;İ:*5zװ7)7夕6̳&K_ Ar4W׮WQY#蟲Aia/8l?vоEXO,GL~}zبtK_0!~n/TA<#I/?h};ZV}/[^ou|U//``I8~t_ki}|R7_kG/#!/ab☤ 7ayk׮I-n_enH:lm'i>TWvaW lU5 $__#[[0a 60}4q Xju v)=bcۯR[ p7vU]V80k0 }!9 qH!QKZm0v}Z]5l{V/X=vL@ ,5Z0%t+P<M4Mi㺆^Ja^I++aRcͯ!a3g3Qf͐aa4Ȏ 5Ȑhob o+ (ڵ[M1_C:X3' qMV D1f.C 1H<ab0mElRZlUq{]!DC$u6]h4A4,& NaA6A d#TDDDDDE0Rd,r.!j6[: M{ M&jI!HDHpܙT^I-(-JKP jB0Q\UYn%\ӅLbQe#膩(BO cFAQ.. 0A3g&3y@l@nGG꠸*v˳, 2nƘDtvuxU•H.Jw4v2+Fhgj낙t RƦ NjXC`Zww #`=Ga*ShȁdfK_wL8@pŒM꪿ҥ|ݾ[F!F \|ЂgVSh_I}_M@! d4:tA"!XI-W_4]Ut).!aB Hp!A<ࠈ.Ɍ"D9"a Ȍ"y~pehy><`ɜaΩu0B{0U4?0rvH5I"0_ wޓA}[uvDHaa"pдN)vL0T„(@ ld12]# d H#ah}&KK^NôyH $WROIJ"(3bb A{DY.4# E'bg`43U`'zHT!دzz_c v:֟tnnۭ+ڸ4 f)æM'L /7WcoX_ۭtZO\'m`O CK^|a܎%~ .o_KMֿjMKJn' LYb//]I__{Bޚ!wmҧH/ˮ_tT&ooK} /}v! + l~Ca/ A/P_}*k^9bvj,޾9x7}z_ Da?l?ۏσeB"$MH/!_׸Duw}{[uW7vU;TA/ 6K߭}/c_bRVo]_z[za+j_~^dÃ]iZaWV6m~ L56_o[}az_^{ }vaTR %Q?0I~I)ا)aVj_KS%{}v?M!4E4Ȏ &+I{S\EEEDGGi]iM]/k][t_ &ʄ8M4AȮ 4!a|b*)0@ [!IV0Wvc`_I[ҵ%o"""""" W3ݗ<Ii=AMi ! | *(0Lv{ ?m([xOU= t[d. r a ‚aBjRLA c0c[cmz}vi6DGd ͈0AkVDpIT` Atȏ0A h@la80|TPBl4M%""""HDЁڅVh4O  41MAUC؃ Ꮏ""""") B"!$6?٭2ɟF&O&&SdAH&E_I\FDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDyԵrn(5 zQӪVP&HZ & XQf *!GlQ9BޣGG`: kүIo+}u-_֟kFk endstream endobj 138 0 obj << /Length 4897 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im139 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F140 12.03 Tf 75.12 708.72 TD (patents) Tj /F140 11.89 Tf 34.80 0.00 TD (, it refused to ") Tj /F140 11.88 Tf 71.04 -.24 TD (alert them to a potential problem they can easily work around.) Tj /F141 10.31 Tf 296.16 -1.20 TD (" CX0711 ) Tj /F141 8.29 Tf -401.52 -27.12 TD (73. Instead) Tj /F140 11.93 Tf 55.20 -.24 TD (, Rambus merely stated vaguely that unspecified patents might cover undisclosed) Tj /F140 12.48 Tf -55.44 -28.08 TD (aspects ofSynclink. RX-) Tj /F140 12.31 Tf 122.64 -.48 TD (0663 at 2. Thus) Tj /F140 12.08 Tf 77.28 -.24 TD (, Hyundai had no opportunty to assess the veracity and) Tj /F140 11.49 Tf -199.92 -27.84 TD (strength of Ram bus) Tj /F140 11.91 Tf 97.44 -.48 TD (s claim) Tj /F140 11.95 Tf 34.56 0.00 TD (, to avoid Rambus patents by proposing specific alternatives within) Tj /F140 11.67 Tf -132.00 -28.08 TD (SyncLink) Tj /F140 12.12 Tf 45.84 -.24 TD (, or to negotiate with alternatives in mind. ) Tj /F140 11.96 Tf 205.92 -.48 TD (Many companies thought the changes from) Tj /F140 13.66 Tf -252.48 -27.60 TD (Ramink to ) Tj /F140 11.93 Tf 60.72 -.48 TD (SyncLink \(shifting from a fully to a partially multiplexed bus architecture\) would be) Tj -60.48 -27.84 TD (sufficient to avoid Rambus) Tj /F142 10.51 Tf 130.08 -.48 TD (' s patents. ) Tj /F142 11.32 Tf 53.76 -.24 TD (CCFF 1571. ) Tj /F140 13.10 Tf 64.80 -.24 TD (Hyudai used ) Tj /F140 12.07 Tf 69.12 -.24 TD (the ) Tj /F142 14.15 Tf 17.76 0.00 TD (opportty of ) Tj /F142 10.79 Tf 70.80 0.00 TD (the on-) Tj /F140 11.87 Tf -406.80 -27.12 TD (going ) Tj /F140 15.45 Tf 30.00 0.00 TD (RDRA ) Tj /F140 12.00 Tf 46.80 -.24 TD (negotiations to obtain ") Tj /F140 11.78 Tf 112.32 -.24 TD (insurance) Tj /F140 12.15 Tf 45.60 -.24 TD (" in case it ) Tj /F140 17.04 Tf 54.24 -.24 TD (tued ) Tj /F140 11.86 Tf 33.60 -.24 TD (out that Rambus) Tj /F140 12.00 Tf 82.32 0.00 TD (s patents did) Tj /F140 12.13 Tf -404.88 -27.12 TD (cover SyncLink. CCFF 1550-) Tj /F140 12.34 Tf 145.68 -.48 TD (1552. Because ofthe vagueness ofthe infonnation and the) Tj /F140 11.91 Tf -146.16 -27.84 TD (technological changes to SyncLink) Tj /F140 12.77 Tf 167.52 -.48 TD (, Hyudai never ) Tj /F140 11.92 Tf 78.72 -.48 TD (thought the 2.5% rate would ever apply.) Tj /F140 11.74 Tf -246.00 -27.60 TD (CCFF 1552.) Tj /F140 11.95 Tf 35.52 -28.56 TD (Rambus also relies on its assertion that a hand-) Tj /F140 12.09 Tf 224.64 -.72 TD (picked selection of a limited number of) Tj /F140 11.87 Tf -260.64 -27.60 TD (license agreements) Tj /F140 11.81 Tf 90.72 -.24 TD (, for an ) Tj /F140 12.89 Tf 36.72 -.24 TD (unkown number ) Tj /F140 11.95 Tf 87.36 -.24 TD (of unspecified patents relating to ) Tj /F140 13.86 Tf 159.60 -.48 TD (unkown) Tj /F140 11.94 Tf -374.88 -27.36 TD (technologies used in unidentified products) Tj /F142 11.93 Tf 203.04 -.48 TD (, cared royalty ) Tj /F140 12.16 Tf 78.24 -.48 TD (rates in excess of 3.5%. RB 18-) Tj /F140 11.52 Tf 153.84 -.24 TD (20.) Tj /F140 11.78 Tf -435.36 -27.12 TD (The Commission already rej ected this ) Tj /F140 15.30 Tf 184.56 -.48 TD (arguent. ) Tj /F140 12.20 Tf 53.52 -.24 TD (Decision 115 n. 624 \(comparng licenses for) Tj /F140 11.97 Tf -238.08 -27.60 TD (different technologies ") Tj /F142 11.27 Tf 112.56 -.48 TD (mixes ') Tj /F140 11.80 Tf 36.24 0.00 TD (apples and oranges) Tj /F142 13.11 Tf 97.92 510.00 TD (" ") Tj /F140 12.00 Tf 13.20 -510.48 TD (Rambus fails to provide a basis for treating) Tj /F142 10.75 Tf -260.40 -27.36 TD (the referenced licensing arangements as comparable to licenses for the technologies at issue in) Tj /F141 7.62 Tf 0.00 -28.56 TD (the present case.) Tj /F141 7.51 Tf 84.00 -.48 TD (\). Similarly, the ) Tj /F140 11.95 Tf 81.12 0.00 TD (Commission already dismissed Rambus) Tj 195.36 -.72 TD (s attempt to rely on a) Tj /F140 11.86 Tf -360.72 -27.12 TD (vague) Tj /F141 5.00 Tf 29.04 -.24 TD (, abstract and unsupported passage in an IBM manual. ) Tj /F140 5.00 Tf 264.00 -.72 TD (Id. ) Tj /F142 10.70 Tf 25.92 -.24 TD (The record contains no) Tj /F140 11.82 Tf -318.72 -27.36 TD (evidence) Tj /F140 11.87 Tf 42.72 -.24 TD (, however) Tj /F140 11.59 Tf 47.04 0.00 TD (, that IBM') Tj /F140 11.88 Tf 53.28 -.24 TD (s rates reflected royalties for ) Tj /F140 13.37 Tf 138.24 -.48 TD (DRA technologies) Tj /F140 11.94 Tf 99.84 -.24 TD (, or even that the) Tj /F140 11.83 Tf -381.84 -27.36 TD (rates stated in IBM') Tj /F140 11.86 Tf 95.76 -.24 TD (s policy ever actually applied) Tj /F140 12.08 Tf 142.08 -.72 TD (" and noting that) Tj /F140 11.84 Tf 80.88 -.24 TD (, unlike Rambus) Tj /F140 16.40 Tf 89.04 0.00 TD (DRA-) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000931278 00000 n 0000931337 00000 n 136 7 0000931551 00000 n 0000931718 00000 n 0000976295 00000 n 0000932261 00000 n 0000931874 00000 n 0000932005 00000 n 0000932132 00000 n trailer << /Size 143 /Prev 930949 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 981259 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0001000580>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R 122 0 R 129 0 R 136 0 R 143 0 R ] /Count 21 >> endobj 143 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 144 0 R /Contents 145 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 144 0 obj << /XObject << /Im146 146 0 R>> /Font << /F147 147 0 R /F148 148 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 147 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F147 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 148 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F148 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 146 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im146 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 15910 >> stream @@R49SN2媴 /,ǖWG .3^?,Mdx* :Q <#LʋaL|@IFWwAQ 0@& F_U[.2@$m hMz_i &?!8P(ijtf2_=HAW_]W_(DUAD:h-0` !::^C.M4:ͦ6i "vA7iz]L PAaBiaSšQQCtU=a5uzfi6-(}>'pT;zN0SD`邦(D:aS |al)A(ECF|SQ0cL#:2mc5H0Iozzv}&%n;|z _ ;`MBg axA L   hA0 a 0ء"`L"Eתw`'uӃ#M汜MgxzoީO0F/nSQ8i PҦu0T4D,z :A8m~T]vVM;iS{ȸ ع6 Mo Z/g/Z'"-.4^4_4l:Ń34Nݧ_ߵuuj]I>|;"|Cg6I6"+G'}dA&r].X߷I{tƿa6_W_^u}=6׺\'I84ut}Y܎Oݻް&? Jzo&뮯鿿oV0~aou?鴷I"?+ Vn/~ttOzo;'b?d0/a=ЏzCa oU?AJB__?$ ݺXmK8xD_71}~ߥ T"C_ ߓ[)Ro|A^d/۠on'?{o_UuץC׿W|4})ֿiu_n!!4/Uj_Cem0g[_?kmߦ~WX_oW_K[Ko@ch ئߤ^mlcKW]}okvi׷%klIG@ r5NI4i'}aW]Wb[ uPu]ӳb 0RdžPjb*) 6iSUҴm%if? f>ۯ1VKRbֶ:"!IaPhGAw8Aڪi6dHAa$Na;J>ح8=I8cOմ[ aH\0\DDD~ 0B r0M گjPA 5LP i5P .UKVb;IEZIQ]qFaKp)8LaN 0"86Eh8@b ` P `bU2{NJ.8"""""PR0X0 - B & 5L ALUV!( &h08BhKDDDDDDu%I*SĿOi]hUِj]tA@ҧ\pZ :N" {A8 ;%nW?/,JLE nvUZP2uW_[}uV>E*믫p&A.\H!8Lr%&8vkԆ`64aB 08&H 9*C5W3mg#"5ɞ'mSD&rp0t$TgPP>4&hO@ ShTAA6úv&{,A:voAi *a0i9a&Mwh&vPA2t/'(`ɤ֞xMAVp\$ u߭zwյV'V_|Ou_WMЫjzoX~ޟcC a'+/ E^H-wKC_o^oEK_.Iv__ zͦ_nZubpvWz oz\.7u*(b6*j;`yGAQLii6^aޓ ; ڧV &6O ؠqIVVLAQeIXLBQ˰L a3Zf{A\ki6a D: 6P ai"uDG"? <0Ԙl&ErБ4&Z" 0 `&5DDGoJB =.0Hi f|(p׏eSǎd  &M|es@#&DQoS{;3+& .5 dV(L# |9Ki!PA]? RaABR|Hl(uZ'́d&T` zk[M~iYNU_a3u2r#Og-}WUu<*~AL`TAA2# $3c!ܜSp= _Om :SA0T8!y!p֚aSL.(0P( x e ћDN)2>O3GK_AL_2 |Ix4t-M"X1zؙb(7~-vl p]5iOSL੄ό(BA ޺oJIn~`. MM:AA!t|ރI >vh-j &L8yxzw_u]?Ov)^:28I:O.Ӥ &0fm'H6|SWVK'J۷_vM=bM%P;W~o~_@?v?_cK_Wۮ$/Y~P{_|1B_oiDEܺaa^z m/k࿽?pp]h%aa(VgsnD~_k/w/W_ȏ H$@d!ou׶u5_K7o/?C f'8?~=@ۯӦo8-t+mS~#?= .?ka16 qHtm&/ki~~N_[j@bh&╆K Zb8ki} 6]5MkշV_] a)F R|Pbia`Wkiq0m+1_ki0[K1vu :ڰf?ͯ/ & ZL4&ah.!`W[a6*)iAz3PL [0Dp@ ADDDDDGx" N' 5DDDDDG AN1ҔLq2Gk3!aHQɛ$ 0Bii\R8Tlpveݵ\AQ0~?_K: PlC: APaE6P8.lq32r$*i(L& a/' x!. xa0>*0ٰ!ƞf9'I }] m|(.w[ꗾM1nͭ/K1Bu~i0ooޘw_}_mF"?u 7_Gn?oյ{Wm/qtM?֒m|6J)װծ^Sjց6$AՠiӶL F!ISO>Ca2)7A[ ^W&(00@ڠDDG5„ʝjMM4DDDDDDJZK ^:V,(\-G[E߭*TZtEw ·A07IäplIՐp@r@d 2B#ZAAjHP*=!dd L:El Mv) u SDPH7At" JHm'Gjq8Aa[ՇMdj\&oNp6,=0(+t_M1IҧoWnoml%۲mʥ{(m"Ra6Ktm$gec1a̒>ʷɅA{ݸu5v<" a% n)`">%ae"U$=[An+a&| RW^l S"rQt8%3]Chdxi91K Kh,CvA&ue~ElִIXCI^".+It E-zX">yl^L~0 kzK/WJ2ݾC@30 jWc= $]:ZtaT%| j7U+ -XzJIz A7R[PKA$ Rm)l7*aA%nAqʲ5$m+  M-`A0l }P`J҄T^2RI6Ip 4vRgezAat;DD Q|\pP /AU L4߅2ւl '9KJ[D*ҡYIA%LJ[Z2PD:)/`8A 5`$` MR6H6eIlA4L M8=* A} %a H0ԃ\ A;+V H26& DWX@d2# GFB`@elԁyUA !*Tf27 X.. DAE:l%@vDX0 EȾgH$_g Y^.=?૜Gљ ؈EA e[!e ;4U_#ƂfGp.p^>ADDDDDDDDYJ U86 $5ւBB4$(Zh$QB 3H#qK2A\l4[HR.(a AIADӤ}hSy3E); :;anեjr}U84*!Ep _H782^ MZtz 4l0K>8ᴛq> T0fc>̯!5Ko3Ti! &`S„F{>5M0S Ex ah[TNI: N_P276r-N&q4]1A 3O Dx!M>;q>5*氪4߸5蟲޽K!J!銿m/6oV+K*~zwWiV XI}Z^) ! `0A &bakHkxaT l0m-SMv %""> 0BBlSrftPL&Ɲ!!mQQ Bif. %ZI0A~U!:h:iq0\< 0 /B*"" ɹ@ZiKa!Qj(mgJZz9nh2i4, oQ(* Xƶmg4ួ 6 gPoR\nL{uzp}xe5SB a%z W yj39/45A6d4ǯAB0@0?f%=-NfPT4upAt WчIi-%|TNhhZ'~v BUIjU\m]:A7 v? K֗6uzF|% ZRHiz UT)6AZPZO[UIBU;?Q JZ$j +T ZXtJG__/i_zI$(JG/[kK/vIv-kꂪ%k_\-?i6T.pR(`l uK庘*o=#7 !@TL(L*c=TT)~ 5SaKqAQZ 1 @GArehBᴫ5P2#@d# qeaA27$9C8V0p̠USJș+P”-FW宰;DyC8-tЬd!ܙ*607^޳[""_D7!?d!Bz FtqhFMU$@Il 'Mg]p鿡/rEO]q[:пijZoX$Vm_}"Qoz,7GK}ݥIq?oK߷z_ %A~m֓ q Z6)h6Ш tnut k@0"""""LFf""#ŵDnZ cM`A X9$,[#k%& ؃|%0mxooo﹠"JW g\S!C;ja0?x8:$S2.0t~X~KҴEn& +_~_.//ra_R,]1_ }$\_w_zrGH%YWKKK_kk<%=& DUzxK T!2zh4OBNamKu@.aL  Π] @MaV(& 0DDDDDDA ˜xaDDDG6É gؗXK1*UM50CH+s;22N DsF`Vgx@L`f FA *Չ\zD?M47~N2 D_@IuJn-*vӴZ'^%ZU"):Β ?UFzڥ֖TF3B1_ t3yF}}Uttl@0S :M (( d:GN$/I%DcBj *DHCAM43e eٙ3Qk'H6mZIu:X?h A>sT+z]h*#xDvM A ؠ!'٣4fȑ3YL$fhkD HN#2])=dRK-/J]mS3(4u@A:X8?8^tJ޸L*N`@`> ( pPA#NF&f@iz_=%IU'TX+Y<(_+H'3kYZD+i}:L(*t uoS R\U/OZOItJoz4RA6:3O13h9Ǩ2|A:PC%}V-QwA*^6*UU/T*UI\bukTU%ֿ߄J}$:7 ұkѣI tlͣ=M6xIhkjKZBֽW^ii4Z[uOqKuޗMtj]IE/I֩5}UR4V菉A/].Ttm^q[iIhUZZZTq]i:IkuPZ_. ֪[I.uּPKIuRj[m[ZT(K]zҤ*Ko]%:ZUT}%_uIUzJAkZUK]A+}iV^RI/U%$nuZT%I^Ad]zIz֒'Ij%TsJizIjRJHK[}RIZ+-m%ׯmz_t^ZZIl}$*m- -_J%KЅ%UZJKK.Ge%UU꼈]jܘIW^]%t}-^_OJ&ꑏKozZSZ]9GZKiR%_Kzحy1}tUVJR״uUT/mtTc}ja6HUi/I/.#--/ZkvҊwE( &I6UKJT҄~]Ҥa+}5/jauI}RI*, id%3 *5ILTl4a&T"Ea&A`T.$RT=izǗ1YuK_YH^PPBVTU-1 )3a#XKB :Z\RQ*TZjiiiR]tD)АЋXL)HT *an ­T®a^ЭATuWVQZJizZJ*i6ti$Z^(P` PL*aHhBL-!ER j)ҪҰqR!1IE1M.(q,TTE\AʰL ABaMt !E1IUU2]u b+ UUuUDDDA 2 *atҴa5]ESU]U*FYr3 -a AA,H0&aBa0("")b#Hc_(UU^ i%l/A 2(=΁""?yB( (&&0LȖd9u0 *!l 6k*X KA/gsdhՑyZ~AomRleW#g40AB9 +(ͿIzPTݢw 0pTI82/Rtտj珂I7Z}׺i> b֯i>% G5&Vxurb=h/?_TS\"oaK o!owIz{K]l0n4}[3=+/~tmalRj…~ﰃm&^pv}.2L1mA 0`]a{#AT7 |DDDDDEqp]Nu$0a}*Tc22n;0\NE BlP 9`xdoX2\iSHuZ U}%[[uMizRqib4aZaPgC:dzLR  2 3hԉ36H<:&/%_PaO tx@S @by0)3f/Q#,:A>J (DzJ*jj0YLl &|@zmFzYzALYN>0G}$8հ#M㥰0O'bI %iј;`I7M"7C ( L$i P ``8Y_0[[_DDDGz,wɱ&w52a3GkL2V@8e@4{Ur@oKDG?SAn:; #ok: t Q3O RCA~ (LRm'WENz/iƞ'uEz~:I /JM2%zvPY 5;jޯMl&qtOC_z[rS?uǯ_*_j߫z匂 _ņ:/ྣÇ"Q"P?ڠ_Go;tW둕Aooca//M^N 6*Sj}Ӧ6tFP[ A$ G[L$[[ +O#A"3  ` ADDDDD! &AO¤-hQ-Fjl`3nN[0x8\L{y 쉈SH(0 .50h#b N'M;CpD⠃ADx֭6&ntIaMtm/!t'F kݤ0 h4A& 8vw]0 ;-Pɜ:_AizO#əlkH78hWzzok4 !u]u-l}׭-' Et[ u]/Xn+I?_ֺFȍ'[v]zMZ߿HI_‘HGK;Kdmi>^MSOI~ K[i:Z 00@ۦ( ` 0KVQL0MNS3 %&*iH A4 FGDD^FKi%XP+21G 9Z)̔-^QMƙ*Pl Ė|kNI E?946?æ+]ҶJW[~˚tOMt]%o 5=7%M^#¥y:r~Ls\%&:!xoߡ判٤$FЪ_K뾿*J?Y i*_t=*_I$o4m/$I$HWK j],ڴUIRV麿a(66]ZlWLKSDPZ]5Bu *b״ $ڌ  UVlKM$]'I*a0#O05 alPhjxM(IDDDF  -? bDDDDDYń lq]xJ15k!x@XUx0fQ,ǐ%Q(٢[? 7 1UGY@aXRQ-{~eXqjpTI*;^l_.v]a 7龡$߯}{kNP@Q,Q́xn@ endstream endobj 145 0 obj << /Length 1569 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im146 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F147 11.83 Tf 75.12 708.00 TD (wide royalty rates) Tj /F147 12.76 Tf 85.44 -.24 TD (, ffM') Tj /F148 11.14 Tf 31.92 -.24 TD (s policy potentially applies only to the fraction of the price attrbutable to) Tj /F147 12.14 Tf -117.36 -28.08 TD (the patented portions ofthe product.\).) Tj /F147 11.90 Tf 35.76 -56.88 TD (For the forgoing reasons) Tj /F147 11.96 Tf 117.36 -.72 TD (, Complaint Counsel respectfully requests that the Commission) Tj /F148 10.53 Tf -153.12 -27.84 TD (enter its proposed order.) Tj /F147 11.89 Tf -.96 -141.84 TD (Jeffrey Schmidt) Tj /F147 12.54 Tf -.72 -13.92 TD (Director) Tj /F147 11.94 Tf 0.24 -28.56 TD (Daniel P. Ducore) Tj /F147 12.19 Tf -.72 -14.16 TD (Assistant Director) Tj /F147 11.94 Tf 87.84 -.48 TD (, Compliance Division) Tj /F147 11.90 Tf -87.36 -28.08 TD (Rendell A. Davis) Tj /F147 11.25 Tf 83.04 -.48 TD (, Jr.) Tj /F147 11.83 Tf -83.76 -13.92 TD (Attorney, Compliance Division) Tj /F147 11.92 Tf 0.48 -28.32 TD (Bureau of Competition) Tj /F147 11.95 Tf -.24 -14.16 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F147 11.87 Tf 0.24 -14.40 TD (Washington) Tj /F147 11.08 Tf 57.84 0.00 TD (, D.) Tj /F147 11.78 Tf 17.52 -.24 TD (C. 20580) Tj /F147 11.91 Tf -75.84 -27.84 TD (Dated: September 29) Tj /F147 11.76 Tf 106.80 -.24 TD (2006) Tj /F147 11.99 Tf 110.40 240.96 TD (Respectfully submitted) Tj /F147 11.97 Tf 0.48 -113.76 TD (Counsel Supporting the Complaint) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000981588 00000 n 0000981647 00000 n 143 6 0000981869 00000 n 0000982036 00000 n 0000998683 00000 n 0000982438 00000 n 0000982178 00000 n 0000982309 00000 n trailer << /Size 149 /Prev 981259 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 1000319 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0001027606>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 45 0 R 52 0 R 59 0 R 66 0 R 73 0 R 80 0 R 87 0 R 94 0 R 101 0 R 108 0 R 115 0 R 122 0 R 129 0 R 136 0 R 143 0 R 149 0 R ] /Count 22 >> endobj 149 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 150 0 R /Contents 151 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 150 0 obj << /XObject << /Im152 152 0 R>> /Font << /F153 153 0 R /F154 154 0 R /F155 155 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 153 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F153 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 154 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F154 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 155 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F155 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 152 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im152 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 22806 >> stream Z r5E kqf"Bk(b?U( (u? 92 ̂ D Dyd2nXv?-(-ry]yjqϧ,?*Qn]UEqĀ^? Su~' n:ْ`9h/,Ki:-%$?dm"hDܡDKqu S<2-3@_, \ .@!ԅ3a> 4`\3H!2AOg2<EjD2'9<@p`n;= D AP.Aݹ>"uDK":D\ ݃8Iۭ=$Amm*;)ȱC2YWUIIǦ x`e6׮{tkh,Y_Ꞔ "TEN2@H碞K[uIKR60 " kB (O0@h<xdΤCjHm[\ui$A<=%/'yw0T ੄AA'(!p΃Rʺ_$IX2Q޷ 80UEa8MႨ/ " !<)C00sk%2g3Qw֟kom[IIoFqqRhHU8xAA0Tz §륒c:$#QkyDkzJ+Wi9i=U[۫ViIFIn-AC -`jn֫^תxA Vjk6|S?ȷIFLF]7cumW/M_Mrז"o/߿t龿JI_|߯/zcU.Y I?v}G ,GYjkޢѱa[@ m/߭ۥ_]Tv.+{ubW] ]`]CC#_K3e鴻_|]~?c%I$/~5^ד}zZO~cIJKۭ'?rG__ү$K맄l'i_Oip}i{ג4)]r0|i:Nǰat_붿կ]Z$q_zrG 4O@>j0IkwV1[e|_{i~_4I"Gt~WTD0 5|bŠb x h aK "*_oIJA$=}kkDDDhD00A)Aچ )&A:MXnMZQi1V$ڧmL-oMUkkIDDDDEZeN&\&0Ih!4 ᄚ%M * 1¶#}{y0hq +^„ ә5@ lS0AZi0VCi8[IKتJ0A "!2@ )1ik 1X mHWL|U{L006MZd]Z"" !LiT"8L !ElP" mBHRX"$gxL&&x  00 ivIDDDQQ5 P%2UVjA,ii*IP ږ&(YD”Bqu7S (&BX()-c;&!W"(H)lS#&{)N5$D!&bLڤCX:N:a5%@L;UO Axh  EpkxA;앰hHOPPS$-k\itl27l(*`/}h64jlU_ZZo^UkIR„ˢqfF]WItzXkJ~^" xA NErWU]|R^IDahfc8a|b32|Btz__>fmZ/DL((MSSb4eNϙ'|:C3k_{ӥr-'Mm-NXPdav&x42l'#HPkIizOVI850gN .軪' 0"ࠃ<T<~t"z(Evҵ>nEԿ_R֩QV%Mֽ-R꽹1Nw_vd~ra2>i =-~,t_IUWMKԺZSӣ '*TkKvC]}_#bJkikjZ Ҥ i_꒭M-׼%K}wG턷G]2$& B`h%Ҋba. ER4TUU/iUIzfyv׊ot^(&++W$xnniT״&+ZZ$IҊ[a.%{_0Hz{[}}?x0 0A(‚h0  ^a&4J{I{iiRqECҽuiфkisxN0L&aBU0UPUҶv+ᄡO^ -~үB"""""h0ž$* $uLTUWiZUi=AIV~0:X M˨*cU  %MU[L0IiBAL\L;m-Xv C*ۦV4#B") k8a>a5T)7i☠@aI4a*MaK[Jb""""" 0AL aàaABa*m hAlS` hSa*T")"""""j0 ӻ^M&^jUDDDDAL&,aS:j*9Qd%]zN f֔PK׈QU AMP3# 8 [02@#(S԰] ~Zu)fVDZlڌຌ)e. Uj?u|KTGT *^>J, (bG Sb?+qd%e1)i-3r41-Ku u2b,1 !=ppph0s3-q%k]u_RkW_shf qu<)>e` @ ojUE  &;{, Nt'dN_-t|k8}$ߧT-i*Z-IiU%ikM^$lU*Z%_I,U؉k}ҊU⾪%iRTK%Z)LUkKVt*ZZZJ_UUB_XK뤕i*Ҥt*uiץ%_KU^kZV֫]-mkK-0T.z\ң ttUjG/taiiz*tR%ZI%l"ji$ZK_m9 }EGEEGU6]ieA5UH*!.&'kHpRU S ,x`Z M0& T"""""!Ѝ0 "%:I)6$EM*QZQB*ZI5 )|j_Km7N__I8u_)"#_9 \Bv\ωyOfc5AAA\Sq8v'ypª'L* B & 0D,yCa4= :7MhQvNH&*i5 a0,ۆG&ҰdcC#&n4yE*' L~È׭^-_JlOȐ&7_tU5mZ:V o9_ꞩն>ZUu~~XAko_C0?g4R(AD6׏ /NAk!6~O]}6^һdGul?"EjgvikN>o71i,4ئv_յaukW /mq0x &N U! 54QBM4tt۪jIA ltQ 0 4o&Ʀ`A ( ΃ ^h5  ` `E $D!@0b|DDDDJ Xy\|$Qɰ!4 g`b  RspѮz-1JJm'WI!%X]DF#A7=8:%# DNC Rm&p:58.vlP Iq}-[]W]wE,/~F ɅT],莇޿N*p\2%͑wgToZ,ha~8ba˙O"h&9 Ć!?b:l Q;v14`a MAٲ3?zm&̃qmSXO_9C^[J!$=4` "qqK}q oW}e]~A-bQ+kq oo}'[o? տe;n}F/HkK^=KJuT{i +{ +Ki}QW^m{ %5a0$[嘭[ *kU\y._a 0H aa$mCJZ#OIҿ#I{4M1@ ) d(vݥi!BuRd L ) i6: 0A4SiC DDDDDD*`a5L׶( d0rЏu1?"QA:a^mK}Ckek^owmn}ǰՆi:zs{ئӊ)[XjWT ={ba'Jo v m0V/d#i6Ed8 i 0M;[UnAP iA\& 0 @␠AN""""""&0pCT(*3LL'@AoD+ n9a YIiɱF h8$Ah2h0aؠCPSso4A'A6sMnv.(`5JޚP 0TJKk/w?Km!2Dq By(ʴ}_*aPa Sٰx); >3oq ֫ &WYzX@qq@Hqj۫kA咥Rpd[";J>uACD^w&A׺ }m&u-;{{A-7&ׇW/T^0=!~ }ڄHT߶ 6| "Q/$ Nkޗ\7eޒ_׺uuju۾W~ݫ֖_k}[Zәv6յzik={-&׊o—K]C &ѻE<6aiMn|Fkub! A!+7A l e :jvM k13QpaOqUMh7""""""a4STDBԛ-Dbvg$ tjB >@bEuE&}"^` 4 dJDܩQ x[2 4,D A A3XpD%di a>hƃMS '0Ǣv8e'm% +I&lmxA+IuFz߯u]tow1HlS"k,8~#,j>Y2^?W  d`eC,NzPK4=]}oZVoҺl&kKK=-)>JA1G`#}5A}+! '&&w XwSaOKj69 5hrm1酆~&jMڄC0@d(8aY?Tv!eXL_LTj M}!g03 uDDpzǤ- ,  b6!Pa[u37a3(9n!K vLALV a Pj p|;)vL&)'Fw@"N XYNCƤm'"WӴaCciGit5I9 婿 :h2|kw]Zoh#3:~a GpTATդE,| !>3qP;-QeISD`SL 0L@$ ?h ^j8`1ٱSL" 2vlgA 뛌wr`}h' qh"P 0L?Tt7^`ߨ:W`<4!OwMCU_נOMZOI;%ӏjjK +DCV5ּnt;U.}/ǯu/չ(R7_N a߿ ~D8>/GKv괺u4?Y#,A|AY]-_ſWw^q"Oɻ _t#_ ?V/_iݒ?+TKWjzzZ#KKZkӯk_ %iki?kWi=^Xa^K_A հa(Í6ثAVԺkjA  j@ia!C/z[ '@a  `6 Q{jMu"""!4a #L -U; rAH)wjT"""""""QxRUav0@aP "4tDD0A$s) T'zˡW72iaQ`2 a+ૈYTԷZe80 ;څ DegoRTJP̆k).g֜ЂhA LLRZ&0r0 ªE6馚{N4_E8z0P$g#гžN͌(T / 'ay TF~`?=kZlb{mA=6A]L7{}] %-dxΛ] -to}:xuwҰ`R+}7]ޕ=67n #m/Jz_ouM t߹iuob?vK~j!v,Gպ-eսaoE} H/zK E?]mkV^^U޳[i/Wu߿UA0zWT*AlW~UՅ//ڶ=]6KIݥ}olU4Aa0A B8aA;v oOi;NWꤝl t GMjw;d4 &і9' kM5`}Ԫ␈@2ϖ&ӴzDDDDTre/% R ZAjm(#h[h2̈Xsy)Dap` B &a 4T)D4L%~@Tm+oO'm&nH iAҴZKWJZNZ[WWKZ~$$͑!F0B:}A dx"„uw[ B'b)0TG|&I Dg/}e%`ff E->׵<&>_ۯL_o7B'֐+ % 'vI -*+i`8,7 /KK߿tVi]]7x/"4m'KOXVH==}w6I-ߥ#m/MBM'Inra a0$V״$)SaLPAaMi|0[V^alBb*"""""#1wA R"8kZ BV!%CC 7HiB3[-2Qv]DdQ;ǖѯ *&+ Q6OĶEy6[:E&ʢ5:w1uˢl/2ZJdR/2uS*3, tIQեjVָ֒HF Uj;5~m2|,ԈU4 `$fL&6!N΃ GgJM*.*j!Dq ϊ 2 f<@/g 9Fm#Qg;(t h.lD A$=tOzKҭ%ZF%ZN[II pwkA\"OpDapUAt%괖[I.*RTUz.)SzTg `OdlPAZZPd"pּk_*4^ BK뾒iJ&Pt!&BIkT/B?1Z߾T%UK?A}AUi-5Iim/ q%IUia*^JzJ+kZtЦu%ug3[jֿKi+TЭi ҥRƪ}/ZPꪐ$-ZJUtZ]굮Ҥ)zT+U\t%D?ZJ ZWI%VҪתZZ*jc(]U%mVIkZ *־V,E=k[֪KJRUQKKNUiUJt^zZT}{oKUkkI%ֱ G֌>44Uu${zJ9֔AW\*ꉴEjzJ_˪]U=z*TֵJU*jdY\3RTa*վҥ]"P"F]~kֿh]i*Zq\qHVEEEE*֖a%FIkI_TV*:*Zmtj*kim%bC>IuԾ:/V_^])u0'ҭK 5aBVT0 kUկT&E6XEuJZT^]V$~RC; i0P L&-j%*҆b**+JqZN.D00CXM 0SAĈT-5KMSaM*T:**ҊCL aS ]U1U_U ka6R iV!aUT}4atK"""""L  a5UL*!5&PD` 'xTC, # %dGDG-j !+b`alm~"a ْdCo0:,}3O 6:|d=dxE}& _P 4#\!PDsw .`jCM$~#p YN782 qH=_/i}! =Y#}X}kj׮7^n1?a¿NI|k/GLWA=/ᄣki5Zbu *t*M4a|> էZaaiM6 A d+@ a4!f:o /a5e3 J{5DTz!Р`w% @Ǐɰ")E-T2@e;FB=iD8r+Pt 5;:@ަ9tOD~ւl A*}5%vL? 2Ov/転p§ՙg´ʅ'Cl @AAL0at]"w Rav!L0I4I0a LXxaSL ¸ `f)a!"""L#TE _DDDDDEzj*BM$83&ƊPaA@1`_-LA̫Sc;N50R7SJ>#ROTߛJ Q4+-:U1[+ ?] p:0 b.l\$$f)"6fҲӶA !ž GIp<`vPih0 ńJph+\cA݄DOt {o<@\5H&|pauJ<&۪lmﯼ5C}~O ښ itL+_=t#_)nF:dfA؟uNn_,kZm֫\?MqW_%4Ҵo~ݵn#I + 05mhJ**I҈8^#"Bj)d# l$65b a0MB B6A! m4 W pA aA4 qPZ᠃65ziaDDDD떚ʈ |dث6OMK+9E- 5.tCA1@p=4$K*bx`F9Tsbn:C\}APȋH8?< a. 20T^DҟLB:7c V~]{y ?[[ ܜuw&H¿_kr[Kۧv)@1@a.j.^ |QՅ 9 `8u1噤dYڌ`Cy/%MA 2t*+2= 4 "d}Ƌ'Rpi7AդگO]u]]Z ֪_'#j2"ιNcƾ0taP!@y* ੄M^4<{'_R}4hyvveQtK&2cA~>p`\RuV/֭>Oo[o ix][߾ Gݰiu&S/Ҷ+B< DZ 5~nK~kJKJckFG0+]Djjh>Ln-[K^_I׎ޕimnt > ta.m]|h0iZK3ڵIm.nVlTP@0@hmC lPNm&K-/Z UQXi0A1C+ C3 0^uP@")!"00""%U- (%b eT5E򙢝!GMGd,幐d A $/$"<踡#h+pKaW zJ%lK*wzNmTz_ҥ_?]R_WiKVjCdդi<-TO'INJN7a KB~#PtXm$Bt]z]꾷:TtIRJ!:N h&OZJt)7 *ZVJK}kz;zƶ*PֽEt%I%Z-/]to**T+hPMU%XjP*KnQ^ .K^I/u--~ZJ/JTI XǯJZIV.ꖕ%KVIoIUsWZ*PK܌JU%JJiN-.aR^IwR^m-*K^_n.-#@ABZyi@`Er)$#hR@HGf$\2j>@T)WҥzU/ (}(JeHiRJ+lR0a:4aM[(@sWJHRNDu-^-!X K)d*W,I$2 8\=ehI;MuH9c &AhRZ I+ת"?H"O-FKttPҮp2E@ba#A*ABT,Iji*Kt$I$0 VJ $OEsIL4*H %;YI$*Tv`=W-CEM!GGRJE*"I% F܂ XA!*GҬ]`IRR d4Y7K@B 9"îYLHf4 WTA#T!ZY#% TE$#R %JCIu*I` CJ "CI.TI04wI$PA0A$PmH%J JR&AjRZ'T#$NG$+CI*0IuIR t_HY Ԙྒ\ Lƕs#ZV Ҥmm5J+"E,ޅH% 쁆 4%B "q]$R tR 3gTAbIQ e NGұ#A\Rp (aatޥT|)եTDtX* xjKIW. SaPIRUA&Hk Ӥ,$mRKHIt@Š%UT%ҥP J%T1:T -P=R ("7T@ Vtr"8": T Vޕ$4-N ]DWiI0K"3I4tAaX -*]$PM%1*$k ]H)a%TH5TFPI$!a*$ZKPޑB$qS?iBai$⬨H*] Aa4TS!x@B*I/Ha$ZU#aB*&ҥ 'I/ݪVPIta\<#(g@JJi$JUI)x*M%I ,*UzA"8eQAUJ&H0cI-KP0#R *T t?T㠓 =!bT$[A$! =PA%tI`a[%@kЌCPR1 aRI$oaUrAk:KZ8jIIAu_PBIYj)c(APt%!(-IzpD4@Dw}ARA(i`p@J"\01H-t4)R;f6MCҠDI+0\)Gw`pð˃A` ZI$CB %ZHaluAt 2`@A0^B `%I]4aE 3'PRAC b#H%I"g(A6)S aZ&PJ $ d >iaX$k,j։Q1F'Ht6VւAK\2n\j e8h9v; `pr)#h/GP=#"""'kd| Hc=<\ =ȈfvFq+V DDDn,z].UkNk&CKP7^VKjJ`-pdx5^6d|_oքeI[z/~zX~j,Z咾 {zUu/ЊYyFC4T` {h$3HaDKI_¨L* jAL-]8`XX2([Iq,~WiJVutokWCWOS;~Wk޽WIT_1׿RIKEzuz_moQz_g$x~dإ}nm__⾽ZT'=-"kV4~:QTti_{M=/]a/l'{ ki4'zaLAZZZAT0 $h1@5_R B """8h & …XamA֩e WUIkuJemu^*uI.JTj(ijҪZHatm"5)֐!].H.-'u~<6#gj2[Q *µ@i@I-F@T׏q $$ Hi Q@p-G])G!Umq)^?FrkW2RHN1@QJ\r@?,4M\G (H[/d-QCQ*95u-iIIGl(*Qt(M:ҏ)%H|~Y?Gs\q-hf $MK` LwF ,ZC^SHcCQmR(G .B?宓N?嚟5@v[!9j!GV5R`r%l$-Tc$IDQPBYɨW q=G--uE (j)? endstream endobj 151 0 obj << /Length 2347 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im152 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F153 12.78 Tf 227.52 706.80 TD (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) Tj /F154 11.00 Tf -114.00 -27.60 TD (, Beverly A. Dodson) Tj /F153 11.81 Tf 97.68 -.72 TD (, hereby certify that on September 29) Tj /F153 11.76 Tf 181.92 -.72 TD (2006) Tj /F153 12.03 Tf 24.24 0.00 TD (, I caused a copy ofthe) Tj /F153 11.82 Tf -343.68 -12.96 TD (attached) Tj /F153 11.88 Tf 45.84 0.00 TD (Complaint Counsel') Tj /F155 5.00 Tf 95.76 -.48 TD (s Reply Brief On Remedy, ) Tj /F153 11.83 Tf 126.00 -.72 TD (to be served upon the following persons:) Tj /F154 10.77 Tf -267.60 -41.52 TD (by hand delivery to:) Tj /F155 9.29 Tf -.24 -28.32 TD (The Commissioners) Tj /F153 11.86 Tf 12.00 -14.40 TD (S. 鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F154 11.29 Tf -12.00 -14.16 TD (Office of the Secretar, Room H-) Tj /F153 10.56 Tf 159.84 -.72 TD (135) Tj /F153 11.90 Tf -160.32 -13.44 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F153 11.73 Tf 0.24 -14.16 TD (600 Pennsylvania Ave.) Tj /F153 11.25 Tf 109.68 -.48 TD (, N.) Tj /F153 11.82 Tf -109.92 -13.68 TD (Washington) Tj /F154 10.49 Tf 57.36 -.24 TD (, D.) Tj /F153 11.78 Tf 17.52 0.00 TD (C. 20580) Tj /F154 10.99 Tf -74.88 -28.08 TD (by electronic transmission and courier to:) Tj /F153 11.86 Tf -.48 -28.32 TD (A. Douglas Melamed) Tj /F153 11.52 Tf 102.24 -.48 TD (, Esq.) Tj /F154 11.10 Tf -102.00 -13.68 TD (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP) Tj /F154 10.79 Tf 0.96 -14.16 TD (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue) Tj /F153 11.25 Tf 129.12 -.48 TD (, N.) Tj /F153 11.82 Tf -130.32 -13.68 TD (Washington) Tj /F153 11.80 Tf 57.60 -.24 TD (, DC 20006) Tj /F153 12.06 Tf -57.84 -28.08 TD (and by electronic transmission and overnight ) Tj /F154 11.23 Tf 219.60 -.96 TD (courier to:) Tj /F155 8.56 Tf -219.36 -27.36 TD (Steven M. Perr, Esq.) Tj /F153 11.90 Tf -.48 -13.92 TD (Munger) Tj /F153 11.79 Tf 37.92 -.24 TD (, Tolles & Olson LLP) Tj /F154 10.72 Tf -37.92 -14.16 TD (355 South Grand Avenue) Tj /F153 11.85 Tf 20.40 -13.92 TD (Floor) Tj /F153 11.75 Tf -20.88 -14.16 TD (Los Angeles) Tj /F153 11.54 Tf 59.76 -.24 TD (, CA 90071) Tj /F153 11.76 Tf -59.52 -28.32 TD (Counsel for Rambus ) Tj /F153 12.64 Tf 99.60 -.24 TD (Incorporated) Tj ET Q endstream endobj 156 0 obj << /Title (CPY Document) >> endobj xref 1 2 0001000629 00000 n 0001000688 00000 n 149 8 0001000918 00000 n 0001001085 00000 n 0001024769 00000 n 0001001628 00000 n 0001001241 00000 n 0001001372 00000 n 0001001501 00000 n 0001027183 00000 n trailer << /Size 157 /Prev 1000319 /Root 1 0 R /Info 156 0 R /ID [(235401496368116628) (1759029291978715793) ] >> startxref 1027236 %%EOF 1 0 obj<>/ViewerPreferences<>/Metadata 2153 0 R/Pages 2 0 R/StructTreeRoot 1687 0 R/Type/Catalog/Lang(EN-US)>> endobj 3 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 10 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 17 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 24 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 31 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 38 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 45 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 52 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 59 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 66 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 73 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 80 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 87 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 94 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 101 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 108 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 115 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 122 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 129 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 136 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 143 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 149 0 obj<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 156 0 obj<> endobj 157 0 obj<> endobj 158 0 obj<> endobj 159 0 obj<> endobj 160 0 obj<> endobj 162 0 obj<> endobj 164 0 obj<> endobj 169 0 obj<> endobj 171 0 obj<> endobj 172 0 obj<> endobj 173 0 obj<> endobj 174 0 obj[1/space] endobj 175 0 obj[278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 355 556 556 889 667 191 333 333 389 584 278 333 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 584 584 584 556 1015 667 667 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 500 667 556 833 722 778 667 778 722 667 611 722 667 944 667 667 611 278 278 278 469 556 333 556 556 500 556 556 278 556 556 222 222 500 222 833 556 556 556 556 333 500 278 556 500 722 500 500 500 334 260 334 584 350 0 350 222 556 333 1000 556 556 333 1000 667 333 1000 350 611 350 350 222 222 333 333 350 556 1000 333 1000 500 333 944 350 500 667 0 333 556 556 556 556 260 556 333 737 370 556 584 0 737 333 400 584 333 333 333 556 537 278 333 333 365 556 834 834 834 611 667 667 667 667 667 667 1000 722 667 667 667 667 278 278 278 278 722 722 778 778 778 778 778 584 778 722 722 722 722 667 667 611 556 556 556 556 556 556 889 500 556 556 556 556 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 584 611 556 556 556 556 500 556 500] endobj 176 0 obj<> endobj 177 0 obj<> endobj 178 0 obj[1/space] endobj 179 0 obj[250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 350 0 350 333 500 444 1000 500 500 333 1000 556 333 889 350 611 350 350 333 333 444 444 350 500 1000 333 980 389 333 722 350 444 722 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 333 400 564 300 300 333 500 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 564 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500] endobj 180 0 obj<> endobj 181 0 obj<> endobj 182 0 obj[1/space] endobj 183 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 185 0 obj<> endobj 186 0 obj<> endobj 190 0 obj<> endobj 192 0 obj<> endobj 214 0 obj<> endobj 215 0 obj<> endobj 216 0 obj<> endobj 217 0 obj[1689 0 R 1691 0 R 1690 0 R 1693 0 R 1692 0 R 1694 0 R 1695 0 R 1696 0 R 1698 0 R 1697 0 R 1699 0 R 1701 0 R 1700 0 R 1702 0 R 1700 0 R 1703 0 R 1705 0 R 1706 0 R 1704 0 R 1707 0 R 1708 0 R 1709 0 R] endobj 218 0 obj<> endobj 219 0 obj<> endobj 220 0 obj<> endobj 221 0 obj<> endobj 222 0 obj<> endobj 223 0 obj<> endobj 224 0 obj<> endobj 225 0 obj<> endobj 226 0 obj<> endobj 227 0 obj<> endobj 228 0 obj<> endobj 229 0 obj<> endobj 230 0 obj<> endobj 231 0 obj<> endobj 232 0 obj<> endobj 233 0 obj<> endobj 234 0 obj<> endobj 235 0 obj<> endobj 236 0 obj<> endobj 237 0 obj<> endobj 238 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 19.42 0 0 19.42 235.44 739.44 Tm (ORIGINAL )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 19.97 0 0 19.97 223.44 653.76 Tm (UND )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 271.68 653.04 Tm (STATES OF )Tj 13.74 0 0 13.74 336 651.84 Tm (AMRICA )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 193.92 640.56 Tm (BEFORE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.86 0 0 13.86 243.36 639.6 Tm (FEDERA )Tj 19.97 0 0 19.97 300.72 638.16 Tm (TRE )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 343.44 637.68 Tm (COMMSSION )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 14.03 0 0 14.03 258 594.72 Tm (Docket No. 9302 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 287.52 564.48 Tm (PuLIC )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 267.36 508.32 Tm (In the Matter of )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 18.76 0 0 18.76 230.64 480 Tm (RAUS )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 285.36 479.28 Tm (INCORPORATED )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 13.65 0 0 13.65 232.08 437.52 Tm (COMPLA. COUNSEL' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.22 0 0 12.22 228 423.36 Tm (REPLY )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.65 0 0 11.65 269.76 422.64 Tm (BRIF ON )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 325.68 421.44 Tm (REMEDY )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.99 0 0 12.99 108.48 353.76 Tm (efIey Schmdt )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 333.84 349.92 Tm (Geoffey D. Oliver\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.46 0 0 12.46 102.48 339.6 Tm (Director )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.98 0 0 10.98 333.12 335.52 Tm (Richard B. Dagen\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 332.88 321.36 Tm (Robert P. Davis\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 9.15 0 0 9.15 102 311.28 Tm (Danel P. Ducore\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 102 296.88 Tm (Assistant Director)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 189.12 295.2 Tm (, Compliance Division )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 332.88 292.8 Tm (Counsel Supporting the Complaint )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 101.52 268.32 Tm (Rendell A. Davis)Tj 11.57 0 0 11.57 184.32 266.64 Tm (, Jr. )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.32 253.92 Tm (Attorney, Compliance Division )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 100.32 210.96 Tm (Bureau of Competition )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 100.08 196.56 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 13.08 0 0 13.08 100.32 181.92 Tm (Washigton)Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 157.2 180.96 Tm (, DC 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 98.88 124.56 Tm (Dated: September 29)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.44 0 0 10.44 200.4 122.88 Tm (, 2006 )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 239 0 obj<>/CM11<>/CM12<>/CM13<>/CM14<>/CM15<>/CM16<>/CM17<>/CM18<>/CM19<>/CM20<>/CM21<>/CM22<>/CM23<>/CM24<>/CM25<>/CM26<>/CM27<>/CM28<>/CM29<>/CM30<>/CM31<>/CM32<>/CM33<>/CM34<>/CM35<>/CM36<>/CM37<>/CM38<>/CM1<>/CM2<>/CM3<>/CM4<>/CM5<>/CM6<>/CM7<>/CM8<>/CM9<>>> endobj 240 0 obj<> endobj 241 0 obj<<>> endobj 242 0 obj<> endobj 243 0 obj<> endobj 244 0 obj<> endobj 245 0 obj<> endobj 246 0 obj<> endobj 247 0 obj<> endobj 248 0 obj[1/space] endobj 249 0 obj[250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 350 0 350 333 500 444 1000 500 500 333 1000 556 333 889 350 611 350 350 333 333 444 444 350 500 1000 333 980 389 333 722 350 444 722 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 333 400 564 300 300 333 500 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 564 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500] endobj 251 0 obj<> endobj 252 0 obj[1/space] endobj 253 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 256 0 obj<> endobj 258 0 obj<> endobj 260 0 obj<> endobj 261 0 obj[1/space] endobj 262 0 obj[278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 355 556 556 889 667 191 333 333 389 584 278 333 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 584 584 584 556 1015 667 667 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 500 667 556 833 722 778 667 778 722 667 611 722 667 944 667 667 611 278 278 278 469 556 333 556 556 500 556 556 278 556 556 222 222 500 222 833 556 556 556 556 333 500 278 556 500 722 500 500 500 334 260 334 584 350 0 350 222 556 333 1000 556 556 333 1000 667 333 1000 350 611 350 350 222 222 333 333 350 556 1000 333 1000 500 333 944 350 500 667 0 333 556 556 556 556 260 556 333 737 370 556 584 0 737 333 400 584 333 333 333 556 537 278 333 333 365 556 834 834 834 611 667 667 667 667 667 667 1000 722 667 667 667 667 278 278 278 278 722 722 778 778 778 778 778 584 778 722 722 722 722 667 667 611 556 556 556 556 556 556 889 500 556 556 556 556 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 584 611 556 556 556 556 500 556 500] endobj 266 0 obj<> endobj 271 0 obj<> endobj 273 0 obj<> endobj 274 0 obj<> endobj 275 0 obj[1710 0 R 1714 0 R 1715 0 R 1716 0 R 1760 0 R 1720 0 R 1721 0 R 1720 0 R 1724 0 R 1725 0 R 1726 0 R 1723 0 R 1728 0 R 1729 0 R 1730 0 R 1732 0 R 1733 0 R 1734 0 R 1736 0 R 1737 0 R 1738 0 R 1740 0 R 1742 0 R 1743 0 R 1742 0 R 1746 0 R 1747 0 R 1748 0 R 1750 0 R 1752 0 R 1753 0 R 1754 0 R 1756 0 R 1757 0 R 1758 0 R 1759 0 R 1761 0 R] endobj 276 0 obj<> endobj 277 0 obj<> endobj 278 0 obj<> endobj 279 0 obj<> endobj 280 0 obj<> endobj 281 0 obj<> endobj 282 0 obj<> endobj 283 0 obj<> endobj 284 0 obj<> endobj 285 0 obj<> endobj 286 0 obj<> endobj 287 0 obj<> endobj 288 0 obj<> endobj 289 0 obj<> endobj 290 0 obj<> endobj 291 0 obj<> endobj 292 0 obj<> endobj 293 0 obj<> endobj 294 0 obj<> endobj 295 0 obj<> endobj 296 0 obj<> endobj 297 0 obj<> endobj 298 0 obj<> endobj 299 0 obj<> endobj 300 0 obj<> endobj 301 0 obj<> endobj 302 0 obj<> endobj 303 0 obj<> endobj 304 0 obj<> endobj 305 0 obj<> endobj 306 0 obj<> endobj 307 0 obj<> endobj 308 0 obj<> endobj 309 0 obj<> endobj 310 0 obj<> endobj 311 0 obj<> endobj 312 0 obj<> endobj 313 0 obj<> endobj 314 0 obj<> endobj 315 0 obj<> endobj 316 0 obj<> endobj 317 0 obj<> endobj 318 0 obj<> endobj 319 0 obj<> endobj 320 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 10.08 0 0 10.08 178.08 792 Tm (......... ... ... ... ........ "'" .... )Tj 10.72 0 0 10.72 282.96 792 Tm (......... ............ .... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.04 0 0 10.04 358.08 792 Tm (......................... ... ............... ............. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 208.08 792 Tm (..... ........... )Tj 13.52 0 0 13.52 255.84 792 Tm (""""""" )Tj 10.86 0 0 10.86 297.84 792 Tm (............ .... ............ )Tj 11.17 0 0 11.17 382.08 792 Tm (........................ ..... )Tj 13.52 0 0 13.52 468.72 792 Tm ("""""""" )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.59 0 0 12.59 245.04 733.2 Tm (TABLE OF CONTENTS\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 75.6 706.08 Tm (mTRODUCTION )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 166.0746 706.08 Tm (... \001)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5.36 0 0 5.36 525.36 704.64 Tm (... )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5.36 0 0 5.36 538.224 704.64 Tm (1\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 111.36 678.24 Tm (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 111.12 664.32 Tm (Remedial Powers .. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.51 0 0 11.51 516.24 663.12 Tm (...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 29.46 0 0 29.46 111.12 650.4 Tm (A. )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 147.12 650.4 Tm (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict\001\ )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 146.88 636.48 Tm (Royalties To Restore Competition )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 316.73 636.48 Tm (....................................................................... \ )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 535.9699 636.48 Tm (2\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 146.88 622.56 Tm (Rambus Bears the Burden of Any Uncertainty Resulting from Its Unlawful\001\ )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 146.64 594.72 Tm (A Zero Royalty for JEDEC-)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 281.28 594.24 Tm (Compliant Products and Unlimited Royalties for\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 147.12 608.4 Tm (Conduct )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 190.7152 608.4 Tm (........................................................................\ .......................................... )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 535.1401 608.4 Tm (3\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 146.4 580.8 Tm (Non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 171.36 580.8 Tm (JEDEC Uses Is Reasonable )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 308.8943 580.8 Tm (........................................................................\ ... )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 536.2314 580.8 Tm (6\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 146.64 567.12 Tm (The Commission Should Resist the Temptation To Impose )Tj 12.96 0 0 12.96 432 566.4 Tm (Puntive Relief )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.51 0 0 11.51 509.76 565.92 Tm (........ )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.51 0 0 11.51 535.6575 565.92 Tm (8\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 539.76 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 284.64 539.04 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 456 538.56 Tm (Compliant\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 110.4 525.84 Tm (Products Is Appropriate.................................................\ .................................................... 9\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 29.26 0 0 29.26 110.4 512.16 Tm (A. )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 146.16 511.92 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 227.04 511.68 Tm (s Deception)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 283.44 511.2 Tm (, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 146.64 498 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free Of Ram )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 342.96 497.52 Tm (bus Patents )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 402.219 497.52 Tm (............................................ )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 535.5756 497.52 Tm (9\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 146.16 484.32 Tm (To Restore Competitive Conditions and Pennit Effective Administration\001\ )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 146.16 470.64 Tm (The Remedy Must Apply To All Technologies in the JEDEC Standards )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 493.429 470.64 Tm (........... )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 529.459 470.64 Tm (14\001)Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 15.61 0 0 15.61 74.16 443.04 Tm (Il. )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 443.04 Tm (Rambus )Tj 3.661 -0.02 Td (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Leader <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 413.0415 442.8 Tm (...................................... )Tj ET EMC /TOCI_Page <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 529.359 442.8 Tm (16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 9.06 0 0 9.06 299.52 18.24 Tm (-1\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 321 0 obj<<>> endobj 322 0 obj<> endobj 323 0 obj<> endobj 324 0 obj<> endobj 325 0 obj<> endobj 326 0 obj<> endobj 327 0 obj<> endobj 328 0 obj[1/space] endobj 329 0 obj[250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 350 0 350 333 500 444 1000 500 500 333 1000 556 333 889 350 611 350 350 333 333 444 444 350 500 1000 333 980 389 333 722 350 444 722 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 333 400 564 300 300 333 500 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 564 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500] endobj 349 0 obj<> endobj 350 0 obj[1/space] endobj 351 0 obj[278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 355 556 556 889 667 191 333 333 389 584 278 333 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 584 584 584 556 1015 667 667 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 500 667 556 833 722 778 667 778 722 667 611 722 667 944 667 667 611 278 278 278 469 556 333 556 556 500 556 556 278 556 556 222 222 500 222 833 556 556 556 556 333 500 278 556 500 722 500 500 500 334 260 334 584 350 0 350 222 556 333 1000 556 556 333 1000 667 333 1000 350 611 350 350 222 222 333 333 350 556 1000 333 1000 500 333 944 350 500 667 0 333 556 556 556 556 260 556 333 737 370 556 584 0 737 333 400 584 333 333 333 556 537 278 333 333 365 556 834 834 834 611 667 667 667 667 667 667 1000 722 667 667 667 667 278 278 278 278 722 722 778 778 778 778 778 584 778 722 722 722 722 667 667 611 556 556 556 556 556 556 889 500 556 556 556 556 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 584 611 556 556 556 556 500 556 500] endobj 366 0 obj<> endobj 367 0 obj[1/space] endobj 368 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 372 0 obj<> endobj 375 0 obj<> endobj 378 0 obj<>/A 380 0 R/C[0.0 1.0 0.0]/Border[0 0 0]/Type/Annot>> endobj 379 0 obj[378 0 R] endobj 380 0 obj<> endobj 381 0 obj<> endobj 382 0 obj<> endobj 383 0 obj[1762 0 R 1763 0 R 1764 0 R 1765 0 R 1766 0 R 1767 0 R 1768 0 R 1769 0 R 1770 0 R 1771 0 R 1772 0 R 1773 0 R 1773 0 R 1774 0 R 1775 0 R 1776 0 R 1777 0 R 1778 0 R 1779 0 R 1780 0 R 1781 0 R 1782 0 R 1783 0 R 1784 0 R 1785 0 R 1786 0 R 1787 0 R 1788 0 R 1789 0 R 1790 0 R 1791 0 R 1792 0 R 1793 0 R 1794 0 R 1794 0 R 1795 0 R 1796 0 R 1797 0 R 1798 0 R 1799 0 R 1798 0 R 1800 0 R 1801 0 R 1802 0 R 1803 0 R] endobj 384 0 obj<> endobj 385 0 obj<> endobj 386 0 obj<> endobj 387 0 obj<> endobj 388 0 obj<> endobj 389 0 obj<> endobj 390 0 obj<> endobj 391 0 obj<> endobj 392 0 obj<> endobj 393 0 obj<> endobj 394 0 obj<> endobj 395 0 obj<> endobj 396 0 obj<> endobj 397 0 obj<> endobj 398 0 obj<> endobj 399 0 obj<> endobj 400 0 obj<> endobj 401 0 obj<> endobj 402 0 obj<> endobj 403 0 obj<> endobj 404 0 obj<> endobj 405 0 obj<> endobj 406 0 obj<> endobj 407 0 obj<> endobj 408 0 obj<> endobj 409 0 obj<> endobj 410 0 obj<> endobj 411 0 obj<> endobj 412 0 obj<> endobj 413 0 obj<> endobj 414 0 obj<> endobj 415 0 obj<> endobj 416 0 obj<> endobj 417 0 obj<> endobj 418 0 obj<> endobj 419 0 obj<> endobj 420 0 obj<> endobj 421 0 obj<> endobj 422 0 obj<> endobj 423 0 obj<> endobj 424 0 obj<> endobj 425 0 obj<> endobj 426 0 obj<> endobj 427 0 obj<> endobj 428 0 obj<> endobj 429 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 9.5 0 0 9.5 366.48 792 Tm (........... ...... .... ...... )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 203.04 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 232.8 732.96 Tm (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 74.64 705.36 Tm (CASES )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 677.52 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 127.92 677.52 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 274.8 677.28 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 305.52 677.28 Tm (509 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 338.4 677.04 Tm (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 649.68 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 110.4 649.68 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 186 649.68 Tm (352 U.)Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 218.64 649.44 Tm (S. 419 \(1957\) ........................................................\ ........................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 621.84 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.8 0 0 8.8 110.4 622.08 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 181.44 621.84 Tm (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ..................................................\ .............................. 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 594.24 Tm (International Salt Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 21.744 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.06 0 0 8.06 194.64 594 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 264 594 Tm (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1\ )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 523.44 594 Tm (, 15\001)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 566.64 Tm (In re Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.07 0 0 10.07 209.28 566.4 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 249.12 566.16 Tm (C. 616 \(1996\)........................)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 388.56 566.16 Tm (:.............................................. 7\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.91 0 0 10.91 73.2 539.04 Tm (In re Ekco Products Co. )Tj 10.22 0 0 10.22 196.32 538.8 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.56 0 0 12.56 484.56 538.8 Tm (FTC\001)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 230.88 538.56 Tm (C.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 236.88 538.56 Tm ( 1163 \(1964\), )Tj 14.544 0 Td (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 32.832 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 127.92 525.12 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.39 0 0 12.39 158.16 525.12 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 272.4 524.88 Tm (........................................................................\ .............. 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.96 497.52 Tm (In re Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 226.08 497.52 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 266.4 497.04 Tm (C. 263 \(1986\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.42 0 0 13.42 339.12 497.28 Tm (affd)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 360 497.04 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.96 483.84 Tm (FTC, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.33 0 0 10.33 156 483.6 Tm (849 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 186.24 483.84 Tm (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) .............................................\ ............................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 456.24 Tm (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.224 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 166.08 456 Tm (Carmichael )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 456 Tm (526 U.)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 261.36 455.76 Tm (S. 137 \(1999\) ........................................................\ .. 12)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 523.2 455.76 Tm (, 13\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 428.4 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.688 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 156.96 428.4 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 241.2 428.16 Tm (373 F.)Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 271.92 428.16 Tm (3d 1199 \(D.)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 329.28 427.92 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 400.56 Tm (New York )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.128 0.048 Td (v. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 134.16 400.8 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 218.16 400.56 Tm (224 F.)Tj 10.7 0 0 10.7 249.12 400.32 Tm (Supp.2d 76 \(D. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.84 400.08 Tm (C. 2002\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 381.6 400.32 Tm (affd sub nom. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.72 386.88 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.736 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 210.96 386.64 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 295.2 386.4 Tm (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 383.28 386.16 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 358.8 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 152.16 358.8 Tm (General Electric )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 238.8 358.8 Tm (115 F.)Tj 10.66 0 0 10.66 269.04 358.56 Tm (Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 11.02 0 0 11.02 347.28 358.56 Tm (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 331.2 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.112 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 204.24 331.2 Tm (253 F.)Tj 10.85 0 0 10.85 234.96 331.2 Tm (3d 34 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 280.8 330.96 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\) .........................................................\ .. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 303.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.36 0 0 11.36 150.72 303.6 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 226.56 303.6 Tm (332 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 259.44 303.36 Tm (S. 319 \(1947\) ........................................................\ ..... 6)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 522.72 303.36 Tm (, 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 276 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.37 0 0 8.37 150.96 276 Tm (Singer Mfg. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 233.76 276 Tm (231 F. )Tj 10.44 0 0 10.44 264.96 275.76 Tm (Supp. 240 \(S. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 353.04 275.76 Tm (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 248.16 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.2 0 0 14.2 152.16 248.16 Tm (u.s. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 175.44 248.16 Tm (Gypsum Co. )Tj 10.84 0 0 10.84 240 248.16 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 273.12 247.92 Tm (S. 76 \(1950\) .........................................................\ ...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.8 0 0 12.8 72.72 220.8 Tm (OTHER AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 192.96 Tm (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 257.28 192.72 Tm (Antitrust Law \(2005\),\001)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 126.24 179.28 Tm (LEXIS)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 160.08 179.04 Tm (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .............................................\ ............................. 3 )Tj 10.8 0 0 10.8 528.48 178.56 Tm (, 5\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72 151.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 213.84 151.2 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 443.52 150.72 Tm (Competition\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 126.48 137.52 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 253.92 137.04 Tm (" \(October 2003\), )Tj 7.93 0 0 7.93 341.76 137.04 Tm (available at\001)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.93 0 0 13.93 126 123.6 Tm (http://ww.)Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 184.08 123.36 Tm (ftc.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.44 0 0 8.44 199.44 123.36 Tm (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 448.32 123.12 Tm (..,................ ...... 16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 71.76 95.76 Tm (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed\ Final\001)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 125.76 81.84 Tm (Judgment )Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 306.96 81.6 Tm (\(D. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 334.08 81.36 Tm (C. 2002)Tj 12 0 0 12 372.24 81.36 Tm (, Civil Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 479.04 81.6 Tm (1232\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 179.52 81.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.47 0 0 10.47 125.52 68.16 Tm (Feb. 27)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 162 68.16 Tm (, 2002\) ...............................................................\ .............................................. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.36 0 0 8.36 298.32 17.76 Tm (-11\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 430 0 obj<<>> endobj 431 0 obj<> endobj 432 0 obj<> endobj 433 0 obj<> endobj 434 0 obj<> endobj 435 0 obj<> endobj 436 0 obj[1/space] endobj 437 0 obj[250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 350 0 350 333 500 444 1000 500 500 333 1000 556 333 889 350 611 350 350 333 333 444 444 350 500 1000 333 980 389 333 722 350 444 722 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 333 400 564 300 300 333 500 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 564 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500] endobj 440 0 obj<> endobj 441 0 obj[1/space] endobj 442 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 444 0 obj<> endobj 450 0 obj<> endobj 451 0 obj<> endobj 452 0 obj[1804 0 R 1805 0 R 1806 0 R 1807 0 R 1808 0 R 1809 0 R 1810 0 R 1811 0 R 1812 0 R] endobj 453 0 obj<> endobj 454 0 obj<> endobj 455 0 obj<> endobj 456 0 obj<> endobj 457 0 obj<> endobj 458 0 obj<> endobj 459 0 obj<> endobj 460 0 obj<> endobj 461 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 10.33 0 0 10.33 505.2 707.52 Tm (PUBLIC\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.63 0 0 12.63 220.08 665.04 Tm (UNITED STATES OF AMERICA\001)Tj 12.81 0 0 12.81 189.36 650.88 Tm (BEFORE )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 14.67 0 0 14.67 241.68 650.88 Tm (FEDERA TRAE )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.62 0 0 12.62 347.28 650.4 Tm (COMMISSION\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.31 0 0 7.31 74.4 589.92 Tm (il the )Tj 8.53 0 0 8.53 105.12 589.92 Tm (Matter of\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.28 0 0 14.28 74.16 561.12 Tm (RAUS INCORPORATED )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 353.28 561.12 Tm (Docket No. 9302 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 107.76 533.28 Tm (a corporation. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.84 0 0 12.84 155.04 471.84 Tm (COMPLAINT COUNSEL')Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.6 0 0 12.6 294.96 471.6 Tm (S REPLY BRIEF ON REMEDY )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 259.68 429.12 Tm (INTRODUCTION )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 145.2 386.88 Tm (A public interest served by such civil suits is that they effectively pr\ y open )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 145.92 372.48 Tm (to competition a market that has been closed by defendants )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 12.22 0 0 12.22 432 372.24 Tm (\) ilegal )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 145.68 358.32 Tm (restraints. If this decree )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 266.16 358.08 Tm (accomplishes less than that)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 397.44 357.84 Tm (, the Government has )Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 145.68 344.16 Tm (won a lawsuit and lost a cause. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.87 0 0 7.87 144.72 315.84 Tm (International Salt Co. v. United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.36 315.36 Tm (332 )Tj 4.704 -0.048 Td (Us. )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 379.68 315.36 Tm (392 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 403.68 315.12 Tm (401 \(1947\) )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 109.68 273.12 Tm (Starting from an incorrect position of law)Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 308.4 272.88 Tm (, and relying on false assumptions offact )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 72.72 245.04 Tm (Rambus has rendered its brief irrelevant. The law provides that)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 378.24 244.32 Tm (, to the extent possible)Tj 10.24 0 0 10.24 486.48 244.32 Tm (, the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72.96 216.24 Tm (Commission must restore competitive conditions that likely would have pr\ evailed absent )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 187.92 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 116.64 187.92 Tm (s conduct. The facts overwhelmingly confinn that)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 358.08 187.44 Tm (, absent Rambus)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.22 0 0 10.22 438 187.44 Tm (' s deception )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 72.48 159.36 Tm (JEDEC' )Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 113.28 159.36 Tm (s standards today would be free of Ram bus )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 323.28 159.12 Tm (s patent claims. The unsupported and )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 72.24 131.04 Tm (uneliable opinions of )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.2 0 0 9.2 180.72 130.8 Tm (Ram bus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 224.16 130.56 Tm (s experts should be disregarded)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 374.64 130.32 Tm (, but even they demonstrate that )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72 102.48 Tm (had JEDEC used Rambus technologies)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 259.68 102 Tm (, JEDEC members likely would have negotiated )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72 74.16 Tm (Rambus )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 115.92 74.16 Tm (s royalties effectively down to zero. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 462 0 obj<<>> endobj 463 0 obj<> endobj 464 0 obj<> endobj 465 0 obj<> endobj 466 0 obj<> endobj 467 0 obj<> endobj 473 0 obj<> endobj 474 0 obj<> endobj 475 0 obj<> endobj 478 0 obj<> endobj 479 0 obj<> endobj 480 0 obj<> endobj 481 0 obj<> endobj 482 0 obj[1813 0 R 1814 0 R 1815 0 R 1816 0 R 1817 0 R 1817 0 R 1818 0 R 1819 0 R 1820 0 R 1819 0 R 1821 0 R 1819 0 R 1822 0 R 1824 0 R 1823 0 R] endobj 483 0 obj<> endobj 484 0 obj<> endobj 485 0 obj<> endobj 486 0 obj<> endobj 487 0 obj<> endobj 488 0 obj<> endobj 489 0 obj<> endobj 490 0 obj<> endobj 491 0 obj<> endobj 492 0 obj<> endobj 493 0 obj<> endobj 494 0 obj<> endobj 495 0 obj<> endobj 496 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 183.84 792 Tm (\); )Tj 11.76 0 Td (\), )Tj 14.4 0 Td (\), )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.7 0 0 12.7 111.6 679.68 Tm (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission )Tj 12.4 0 0 12.4 451.2 679.44 Tm (s Remedial )Tj 12.39 0 0 12.39 111.84 665.52 Tm (Powers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.79 0 0 12.79 147.6 636.96 Tm (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 147.36 622.56 Tm (Royalties To Restore Competition )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.36 594.48 Tm (Well-settled precedent confinns the Commission )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 350.88 594 Tm (s authority to ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.43 0 0 7.43 421.92 594 Tm (cure the il effects of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.88 566.16 Tm (ilegal conduct." )Tj 17.28 -0.048 Td (United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 239.76 565.68 Tm (u.s.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 257.2663 565.68 Tm ( Gypsum Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 328.08 565.68 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.17 0 0 10.17 360.96 565.44 Tm (S. 76)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 385.44 565.68 Tm (, 88 \(1950\); Complaint )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 75.12 537.6 Tm (Counsel' )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 118.8 537.84 Tm (s Brief \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 162.96 537.6 Tm (CCB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 192 537.6 Tm (\) 3-)Tj 12.62 0 0 12.62 208.8 537.6 Tm (4. Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 267.36 537.6 Tm (s contention that the Commission )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 432.48 537.36 Tm (s power is limited to )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 509.52 Tm (ordering a respondent to reftain from repeating unlawful conduct)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.58 0 0 10.58 387.12 509.04 Tm (, Respondent' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.72 0 0 12.72 453.84 509.04 Tm (s Brief\(")Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 497.52 509.04 Tm (RB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 518.64 509.04 Tm (\) 4\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 80.88 481.2 Tm (, flies in the face of relevant precedent. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.28 0 0 11.28 272.88 480.72 Tm (See, e. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 312.72 480.72 Tm (, Ekco Prods. Co. )Tj 10.32 0 0 10.32 403.92 480.72 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.86 0 0 8.86 438.96 480.72 Tm (C. 1163)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 477.36 480.96 Tm (, 1216 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.64 450.48 Tm (\(1964\), aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 129.6 452.88 Tm (d sub nom. Ecko Prods. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 27.264 -0.096 Td (v. )Tj 12.69 0 0 12.69 276.96 452.64 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 306 452.4 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 336.24 452.4 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.752 0 Td (FTC )Tj 5.136 0 Td (v. )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 486.48 452.16 Tm (National )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 73.68 424.32 Tm (Lead )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 104.88 424.32 Tm (352 U.)Tj 2.825 -0.021 Td (S. 419)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 168.24 424.32 Tm (, 430 \(1957\) \(Commission must assure that a violator )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 15.21 0 0 15.21 426.48 423.84 Tm (wil ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.84 424.08 Tm (relinquish the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.48 0 0 7.48 74.4 396 Tm (frits of his violation. )Tj 5 0 0 5 193.68 395.76 Tm (see also New York )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 296.4 395.52 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 380.4 395.52 Tm (224 F.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 411.36 395.28 Tm (Supp.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 438.96 395.52 Tm (2d 76)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 466.56 395.52 Tm (, 148 \(D. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.16 367.44 Tm (2002\) \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 114.96 367.44 Tm (equitable relief beyond a mere injunction against repetition )Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 400.32 366.96 Tm (ofthe act is )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 459.6 366.96 Tm (generally )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.21 0 0 11.21 74.16 338.88 Tm (appropriate. \(quoting Areeda & )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 230.64 338.64 Tm (HovenkampJ . . . \(TJhe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 344.64 338.4 Tm (Cour finds )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.4 0 0 8.4 401.76 338.4 Tm (unpersuasive Microsoft' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.85 0 0 14.85 73.92 310.56 Tm (arguent )Tj 12 0 0 12 122.16 310.56 Tm (that Plaintiffs are entitled to no more than a simple proscription again\ st the )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 484.8 310.08 Tm (conduct )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.68 282.24 Tm (found to violate the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.86 0 0 7.86 170.64 282 Tm (antitrst laws. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 252.72 282 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 269.52 281.76 Tm (d sub nom Massachusetts )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.104 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.59 0 0 8.59 405.6 281.76 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 490.56 281.76 Tm (373 F.3d )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 74.4 253.92 Tm (1199)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 97.92 253.92 Tm (, 1232 \(D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 146.64 253.68 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\). Applicable precedent requires that the Commission restor\ e )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 73.44 225.36 Tm (competition and deprive the wrongdoer of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.14 0 0 7.14 296.4 225.12 Tm (frits of its )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 352.08 224.88 Tm (anti competitive conduct. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.67 0 0 11.67 477.36 224.88 Tm (CCB 3\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 145.2 140.88 Tm (See also Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 9.99 0 0 9.99 314.88 140.64 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.61 0 0 11.61 354.72 140.4 Tm (C. 263)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 387.12 140.64 Tm (, 368 \(1986\) \(Commission )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 73.2 126.72 Tm (Section 5 consumer protection cease and desist order ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 6.76 0 0 6.76 335.28 126.48 Tm (resu1t\( edJ in a roll )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.73 0 0 11.73 424.56 126.24 Tm (back. . . of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.39 0 0 13.39 481.92 126.48 Tm (the anual )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.48 112.56 Tm (renewal fees on all of Orkin )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 209.28 112.32 Tm (s pre-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 236.88 112.32 Tm (1975 contracts. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 324.48 112.32 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 346.8 112.08 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.968 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.45 0 0 9.45 487.44 112.08 Tm (FTC, 849 )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.43 0 0 10.43 82.08 98.4 Tm (2d 1354 \(11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.13 0 0 11.13 140.64 103.2 Tm (th Cir. 1988\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 497 0 obj<<>> endobj 498 0 obj<> endobj 499 0 obj<> endobj 500 0 obj<> endobj 501 0 obj<> endobj 502 0 obj<> endobj 508 0 obj<> endobj 509 0 obj<> endobj 512 0 obj<> endobj 513 0 obj[1/space] endobj 514 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 516 0 obj<> endobj 518 0 obj<> endobj 519 0 obj<> endobj 520 0 obj[1825 0 R 1826 0 R 1827 0 R 1828 0 R 1829 0 R 1830 0 R 1831 0 R 1832 0 R 1833 0 R 1834 0 R 1835 0 R 1836 0 R 1837 0 R 1838 0 R 1839 0 R] endobj 521 0 obj<> endobj 522 0 obj<> endobj 523 0 obj<> endobj 524 0 obj<> endobj 525 0 obj<> endobj 526 0 obj<> endobj 527 0 obj<> endobj 528 0 obj<> endobj 529 0 obj<> endobj 530 0 obj<> endobj 531 0 obj<> endobj 532 0 obj<> endobj 533 0 obj<> endobj 534 0 obj<> endobj 535 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.89 0 0 11.89 445.68 792 Tm (, " )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.76 0 0 12.76 147.36 708.24 Tm (Rambus Bears the Burden of Any Uncertainty Resulting from Its Unlawful )Tj 12.75 0 0 12.75 147.6 693.84 Tm (Conduct )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.88 665.76 Tm (The Commission found the requisite link between Rambus)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.45 0 0 10.45 394.32 665.28 Tm (' s deception and its )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 489.6 665.28 Tm (acquisition )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 74.64 637.2 Tm (of monopoly power to establish liability. Decision 74)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.61 0 0 10.61 333.6 636.72 Tm (, 118-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.83 0 0 8.83 362.16 636.72 Tm (119. Any remaining doubts )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 74.16 608.64 Tm (regarding remedy must be resolved against Rambus. CCB 9-)Tj 12.41 0 0 12.41 369.36 608.16 Tm (11. Rambus)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 429.36 608.16 Tm (, however)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 476.4 608.4 Tm (, asserts that )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 74.16 580.32 Tm (this case is akin to those which require ")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 268.56 580.08 Tm (a clearer indication of causal connection)Tj 16.154 -0.02 Td (" at the remedy )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.11 0 0 9.11 73.92 552 Tm (phase. RB 7. Areeda & )Tj 5 0 0 5 194.16 551.76 Tm (Hovenkamp and )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (Microsoft, )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 329.04 551.52 Tm (upon which Rambus relies)Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 456.96 551.52 Tm (, say the opposite. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 110.16 523.68 Tm (Rambus maintains that ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 228.72 523.44 Tm (affirmatively to reduce the defendant' )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 410.16 523.2 Tm (s market power)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 484.08 523.2 Tm (" requires a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 79.44 495.36 Tm (clearer indication of causal connection between the creation or maintena\ nce of the market )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 73.44 467.04 Tm (power.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 107.04 467.04 Tm (" RB )Tj 9.09 0 0 9.09 137.52 466.8 Tm (7. Rambus misuses )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 235.68 466.8 Tm (a principle important )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 338.88 466.56 Tm (primarly in monopoly )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 450.24 466.56 Tm (maintenance )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 514.08 466.56 Tm (cases. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.68 438.72 Tm (A company that lawfully acquires a monopoly, and then engages in unlawfu\ l conduct reasonably )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.92 410.16 Tm (likely to maintain that monopoly, should not be subject to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 353.76 409.68 Tm (divestitue or complete deprivation of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 381.6 Tm (patent rights absent a showing that the remedy is linked to the anti com\ petitive effects )Tj 13.2 0 0 13.2 486 381.12 Tm (ofthe )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 73.44 353.04 Tm (conduct. Absent such a link)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 209.52 353.04 Tm (, depriving a monopolist of lawfully-acquired monopoly power can )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 324.72 Tm (restrict pro-competitive incentives. Conversely, monopoly \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 358.56 324.24 Tm (acquisition )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 414.48 324.24 Tm (cases are less likely to )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 296.4 Tm (deprive a monopolist of its legitimate market position. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.96 268.08 Tm (The Areeda & Hovenkamp section relied on by Rambus is straightforward: w\ here a )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 239.52 Tm (company lawfully gains a monopoly through ")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 295.92 239.28 Tm (a succession of brilliant innovations )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 471.6 239.28 Tm (" a subsequent )Tj 13.7 0 0 13.7 72.48 211.2 Tm (unconsumated )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 155.04 211.2 Tm (attempt to acquire a new entrant is insufficient to justify breaking up \ the pre\255)Tj 12.37 0 0 12.37 72.72 182.64 Tm (existing monopoly. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.6 0 0 8.6 171.36 182.64 Tm (il Areeda )Tj 5 0 0 5 222.96 182.4 Tm (& Hovenkamp, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 299.04 182.16 Tm (Antitrust )Tj 5 0 0 5 344.16 182.16 Tm (Law' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.83 0 0 8.83 379.92 182.16 Tm (653b \(2005\). The subsequent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72.24 154.08 Tm (unlawful conduct is unrelated to the pre-existing lawful monopoly, and t\ he remedy should be )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 72.48 125.76 Tm (limited to offsetting the likely anti competitive effects )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.64 0 0 8.64 331.2 125.04 Tm (ofthe unlawful conduct )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 456.96 125.28 Tm (leav\(ing\) the )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 536 0 obj<<>> endobj 537 0 obj<> endobj 538 0 obj<> endobj 539 0 obj<> endobj 540 0 obj<> endobj 541 0 obj<> endobj 544 0 obj<> endobj 547 0 obj<> endobj 549 0 obj<> endobj 554 0 obj<> endobj 556 0 obj<> endobj 557 0 obj[1/space] endobj 558 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 567 0 obj<> endobj 568 0 obj<> endobj 569 0 obj<> endobj 570 0 obj<> endobj 571 0 obj[1841 0 R 1840 0 R 1842 0 R 1843 0 R 1844 0 R 1843 0 R 1845 0 R 1846 0 R 1847 0 R 1846 0 R 1849 0 R 1848 0 R 1850 0 R 1851 0 R 1852 0 R 1853 0 R 1854 0 R 1855 0 R 1856 0 R 1857 0 R 1858 0 R 1859 0 R 1860 0 R 1861 0 R 1862 0 R 1863 0 R 1864 0 R] endobj 572 0 obj<> endobj 573 0 obj<> endobj 574 0 obj<> endobj 575 0 obj<> endobj 576 0 obj<> endobj 577 0 obj<> endobj 578 0 obj<> endobj 579 0 obj<> endobj 580 0 obj<> endobj 581 0 obj<> endobj 582 0 obj<> endobj 583 0 obj<> endobj 584 0 obj<> endobj 585 0 obj<> endobj 586 0 obj<> endobj 587 0 obj<> endobj 588 0 obj<> endobj 589 0 obj<> endobj 590 0 obj<> endobj 591 0 obj<> endobj 592 0 obj<> endobj 593 0 obj<> endobj 594 0 obj<> endobj 595 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.94 0 0 11.94 75.6 708.24 Tm (monopoly as it was before)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 202.08 708.24 Tm (" resting on competitive merit. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 354.24 708 Tm (Id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 111.6 679.92 Tm (The )Tj 4.224 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 183.12 679.68 Tm (decision)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 223.2 679.68 Tm (, applying the treatise)Tj 8.652 -0.02 Td (, presents a more complex)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 451.44 679.68 Tm (, yet similar )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 75.84 651.36 Tm (situation. Microsoft developed the Windows operating )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 343.92 650.88 Tm (system and the Internet Explorer browser )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 75.84 622.8 Tm (lawfully, through its own innovation. Microsoft was found liable of excl\ uding effective )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 75.6 594.24 Tm (competition from middleware )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 223.92 594.24 Tm (Microsoft, )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 277.68 594.24 Tm (373 F.3d at 1228-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 374.88 594 Tm (, conduct that reasonably appeared )Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 75.6 565.92 Tm (capable of making a significant contrbution to maintaining Microsoft' )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 414.48 565.68 Tm (s operating )Tj 15 0 0 15 470.16 565.68 Tm (softare )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 75.12 537.6 Tm (monopoly. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.712 -0.048 Td (United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 264 537.6 Tm (253 F.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 294.72 537.36 Tm (3d 34)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 322.08 537.36 Tm (, 79 \(D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.17 0 0 12.17 358.56 537.12 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\). Massachusetts sought )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 75.36 509.28 Tm (an order requiring Microsoft )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 217.92 509.28 Tm (inter alia )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.2 0 0 12.2 268.08 509.04 Tm (to ")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.55 0 0 7.55 285.84 506.64 Tm (grant a royalty-)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 11.63 0 0 11.63 359.04 509.04 Tm (free. . . right" to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 441.36 509.04 Tm (use the source code )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 75.36 480.96 Tm (for Internet Explorer \(the ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 204 480.96 Tm (open-source IE" provision\). )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 395.76 480.72 Tm (373 F.3d at 1227-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.43 0 0 9.43 480.96 480.96 Tm (28. The)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 342.48 480.72 Tm (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 14.23 0 0 14.23 75.12 452.64 Tm (governent)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 132.48 452.64 Tm (, however)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 179.76 452.64 Tm (, had failed to prove that Microsoft had attempted to monopolize the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 424.08 Tm (browser market or tied the browser to the operating system. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 58.128 -0.048 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.7 0 0 12.7 418.8 423.84 Tm (253 F.3d at 46. Thus )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 74.88 395.76 Tm (the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.65 0 0 9.65 92.4 395.76 Tm (governent argued)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 185.28 395.76 Tm (, in light of ")Tj 5 0 0 5 246.72 395.52 Tm (the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 3.504 0 Td (viable claims )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 330.72 395.52 Tm (remaining after the Cour )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 455.28 395.52 Tm (of Appeals )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.88 367.2 Tm (decision)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 114.72 367.2 Tm (, ... remedial )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 189.36 367.2 Tm (measures targeted at Internet Explorer are unsupportable.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.23 0 0 9.23 463.68 366.96 Tm (" Response of )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.62 0 0 10.62 74.4 338.64 Tm (the U.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 103.92 338.64 Tm (S. to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed Final Judgment 12,- 22 \(D\ . )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 494.16 338.4 Tm (, Civil )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.16 310.32 Tm (Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 147.84 310.32 Tm (1232)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.34 0 0 10.34 171.12 310.32 Tm (, Feb. 27)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.57 0 0 12.57 212.64 310.32 Tm (, 2002\). The cour agreed)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.72 0 0 11.72 336.72 310.08 Tm (, affrming the distrct court finding )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 510 310.08 Tm (that )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 282 Tm (the proposed relief - depriving Microsoft of \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.72 0 0 11.72 288.24 281.76 Tm (lawfully-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.13 0 0 11.13 331.92 281.76 Tm (acquired royalties for IE - was not )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.4 253.68 Tm (suffciently connected to the violation. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 37.92 -0.048 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 317.52 253.2 Tm (373 F.3d at 1228-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.81 0 0 7.81 402.96 253.2 Tm (30. In a nutshell)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.26 0 0 11.26 483.12 253.44 Tm (, the cours )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 74.4 225.36 Tm (found that the proposed remedy of royalty-)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 279.6 225.12 Tm (free licensing of IE ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.67 0 0 7.67 379.44 224.88 Tm (ignores the theory ofliability in )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.72 0 0 11.72 73.92 196.8 Tm (this case. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.42 0 0 10.42 145.44 196.8 Tm (at 1229.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 128.4 196.8 Tm (Id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 109.44 168.24 Tm (A subsequent paragraph of Areeda & Hovenkamp )Tj 12.21 0 0 12.21 352.32 168 Tm (- not cited by Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.13 0 0 8.13 463.2 168 Tm (- confirms that )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 145.68 126.48 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 165.6 126.48 Tm (373 F.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 196.08 126.72 Tm (3d at 1230 \(relief designed to ")Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 345.12 126.24 Tm (eliminate the monopoly altogether )Tj 12 0 0 12 73.44 112.56 Tm (requires a stronger ")Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 171.12 112.32 Tm (causal connection between Microsoft' )Tj 12 0 0 12 353.76 112.08 Tm (s anticompetitive conduct and its )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 73.68 98.16 Tm (dominant position in the. . . market \(for operating )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 317.28 97.92 Tm (systems\)"\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 596 0 obj<<>> endobj 597 0 obj<> endobj 598 0 obj<> endobj 599 0 obj<> endobj 600 0 obj<> endobj 601 0 obj<> endobj 602 0 obj[1/space] endobj 603 0 obj[250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 350 0 350 333 500 444 1000 500 500 333 1000 556 333 889 350 611 350 350 333 333 444 444 350 500 1000 333 980 389 333 722 350 444 722 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 333 400 564 300 300 333 500 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 564 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500] endobj 606 0 obj<> endobj 608 0 obj<> endobj 609 0 obj[1/space] endobj 610 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 614 0 obj<> endobj 615 0 obj<> endobj 616 0 obj<> endobj 617 0 obj<> endobj 618 0 obj<> endobj 619 0 obj<> endobj 620 0 obj<> endobj 622 0 obj<> endobj 623 0 obj<> endobj 625 0 obj<> endobj 626 0 obj<> endobj 627 0 obj<> endobj 628 0 obj<> endobj 629 0 obj[1865 0 R 1866 0 R 1867 0 R 1868 0 R 1867 0 R 1869 0 R 1870 0 R 1871 0 R 1872 0 R 1875 0 R 1876 0 R 1878 0 R 1879 0 R 1881 0 R 1883 0 R 1884 0 R 1885 0 R 1886 0 R 1888 0 R 1887 0 R] endobj 630 0 obj<> endobj 631 0 obj<> endobj 632 0 obj<> endobj 633 0 obj<> endobj 634 0 obj<> endobj 635 0 obj<> endobj 636 0 obj<> endobj 637 0 obj<> endobj 638 0 obj<> endobj 639 0 obj<> endobj 640 0 obj<> endobj 641 0 obj<> endobj 642 0 obj<> endobj 643 0 obj<> endobj 644 0 obj<> endobj 645 0 obj<> endobj 646 0 obj<> endobj 647 0 obj<> endobj 648 0 obj<> endobj 649 0 obj<> endobj 650 0 obj<> endobj 651 0 obj<> endobj 652 0 obj<> endobj 653 0 obj<> endobj 654 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.15 0 0 12.15 331.44 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 75.36 708 Tm (even in monopoly maintenance cases)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 253.44 708 Tm (, more extensive relief is justified as the link between the )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 75.36 679.68 Tm (conduct and the monopoly increases. ")Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 263.52 679.2 Tm (When a monopolist has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 379.92 679.2 Tm (consumated an exclusionar act )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.23 0 0 10.23 75.6 651.12 Tm (. . . \(w Je must also )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 166.56 648.48 Tm (tr to )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 195.36 650.88 Tm (undo the varous effects of that act." )Tj 35.856 -0.048 Td (Antitrust Law )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 452.16 650.88 Tm (653c. In the )Tj 10.74 0 0 10.74 75.12 622.56 Tm (accompanying example)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 188.4 622.56 Tm (, the monopolist actually buys its only rival. The treatise explains tha\ t a )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 75.12 594 Tm (simple cease-and-)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 161.04 594 Tm (desist order would be ineffective)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 318 593.76 Tm (, and more extensive measures would be )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.88 565.68 Tm (appropriate to restore competitive conditions. Indeed )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 342.72 565.44 Tm (one might force the monopolist to )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.88 537.36 Tm (fashion out of its assets a viable firm that would bear the ' )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 353.52 537.12 Tm (same relationship)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 437.52 537.12 Tm (' to itself as \(the )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 74.4 509.04 Tm (target companyJ bore at the time of acquisition. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 390.72 508.8 Tm (653c1. In that specific context)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 312 508.8 Tm (Antitrust Law \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 74.4 480.72 Tm (the treatise notes: )Tj 12.91 0 0 12.91 110.16 452.16 Tm (the monopolist bears the risk of the uncertain )Tj 12.57 0 0 12.57 346.8 451.92 Tm (consequences created by its )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 438 Tm (exclusionary )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 36.144 -0.048 Td (equitable relief)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 178.32 437.76 Tm (acts. Thus)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 228.24 437.76 Tm (, at the least )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 371.04 437.76 Tm (properly goes beyond merely )Tj ET EMC /TD <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 115.2 423.36 Tm (undoing the act; the proper relief is )Tj ET EMC /TD <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.65 0 0 12.65 286.56 423.36 Tm (to eradicate all the consequences of the act and )Tj ET EMC /TD <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 109.68 408.96 Tm (provide deterrence against repetition; and any )Tj ET EMC /TD <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.73 0 0 12.73 331.92 408.72 Tm (plausible doubts should be resolved )Tj ET EMC /TD <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.41 0 0 11.41 110.4 394.56 Tm (against the monopolist. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 366 Tm (Id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 90.48 366 Tm (\(emphasis added\). Notably, in this example)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 300.72 365.76 Tm (, extensive relief is mandated despite ")Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 486 365.76 Tm (plausible )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 73.92 337.44 Tm (doubts)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 105.84 337.44 Tm (" about the causal link to the monopoly position. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 345.6 334.8 Tm (\(No such doubts are present here\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 109.44 309.12 Tm (In short)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 146.4 309.12 Tm (, if the link between the conduct and the )Tj 18.39 0 0 18.39 341.28 308.88 Tm (har )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 369.36 308.88 Tm (is established )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 436.08 308.88 Tm (durng the liability )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 73.2 280.8 Tm (phase)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 101.04 280.8 Tm (, any doubts regarding the remedy are resolved against the wrongdoer)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 433.92 280.56 Tm (, even where )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.31 0 0 11.31 73.68 252.48 Tm (structual relief may be necessar )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 236.4 252.48 Tm (to assure that complete relief is obtained. CCB 9-)Tj 12.55 0 0 12.55 477.36 252.24 Tm (11. Here)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 521.04 252.24 Tm (, the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 73.44 223.92 Tm (Commission found the requisite link between Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 338.4 223.68 Tm (s exclusionar conduct )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 450.72 223.92 Tm (and its acquisition )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.27 0 0 11.27 73.44 195.6 Tm (of monopoly power. Decision 74)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 234.48 195.6 Tm (, 118-)Tj 11.12 0 0 11.12 263.04 195.6 Tm (119. Thus)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 313.2 195.36 Tm (, the causation finding here was not )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 78.72 167.04 Tm (edentulous)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 130.08 167.04 Tm (" as in )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.73 0 0 11.73 163.2 167.04 Tm (Microsoft. )Tj 12 0 0 12 108.72 138.48 Tm (In addition to the link between conduct and the acquisition of monopoly \ power)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.48 0 0 10.48 487.92 138.24 Tm (, the nature )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.22 0 0 12.22 72.96 109.92 Tm (ofthe conduct also influences )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 218.88 109.92 Tm (whether ")Tj 12.37 0 0 12.37 265.44 109.92 Tm (reasonable royalties. . . )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 382.56 109.68 Tm (\(areJ but nominal in value. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 655 0 obj<<>> endobj 656 0 obj<> endobj 657 0 obj<> endobj 658 0 obj<> endobj 659 0 obj<> endobj 660 0 obj<> endobj 662 0 obj<> endobj 663 0 obj[1/space] endobj 664 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 673 0 obj<> endobj 678 0 obj<> endobj 679 0 obj<> endobj 680 0 obj[1889 0 R 1890 0 R 1891 0 R 1892 0 R 1893 0 R 1894 0 R 1895 0 R 1896 0 R 1897 0 R 1899 0 R 1898 0 R 1900 0 R 1901 0 R 1902 0 R] endobj 681 0 obj<> endobj 682 0 obj<> endobj 683 0 obj<> endobj 684 0 obj<> endobj 685 0 obj<> endobj 686 0 obj<> endobj 687 0 obj<> endobj 688 0 obj<> endobj 689 0 obj<> endobj 690 0 obj<> endobj 691 0 obj<> endobj 692 0 obj<> endobj 693 0 obj<> endobj 694 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 337.2 792 Tm (g, )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 75.6 707.76 Tm (United States v. National Lead )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 707.76 Tm (332 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 261.12 707.76 Tm (S. 319)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.2 0 0 12.2 292.08 707.76 Tm (, 349 \(1947\). For example)Tj 11.65 0 0 11.65 420 707.76 Tm (, royalty-)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 463.2 708 Tm (free licensing in )Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 74.64 679.44 Tm (a price-)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 110.88 679.44 Tm (fixing or market allocation case would clearly bestow a windfall on the \ plaintiffs. No )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.4 650.88 Tm (consumer could have expected)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 222.24 650.88 Tm (, but for the conduct)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 318.96 650.88 Tm (, that the intellectual property would have )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 73.92 622.32 Tm (been free. On the other hand)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 214.08 622.32 Tm (, under the present facts \(as with cases involving equitable estoppel )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.4 594 Tm (and laches\), a zero-royalty remedy flows directly from Rambus )Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 381.36 593.76 Tm (s misconduct. CCB 12)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 491.76 594 Tm (, n. 11. )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.16 565.44 Tm (JEDEC members reasonably expected that JEDEC standards would be free of \ Ram bus )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 493.92 565.68 Tm (s patent )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.46 0 0 11.46 74.16 537.36 Tm (claims. Amicus Curae Brief of JEDEC 4-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.36 0 0 12.36 279.36 537.12 Tm (9. Because the facts )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 380.64 537.12 Tm (demonstrate that ")Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.66 0 0 7.66 468 537.36 Tm (but for)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 500.4 537.36 Tm (" the )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 73.92 509.04 Tm (conduct)Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 112.08 509.04 Tm (, royalties for JEDEC-related applications would be zero or ")Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 407.52 508.8 Tm (nominal )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 450.24 509.04 Tm (" the relief does )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 73.44 480.72 Tm (not ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 97.68 480.72 Tm (confiscate)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 145.92 480.72 Tm (" any rewards to Rambus )Tj 12.23 0 0 12.23 409.2 480.48 Tm (373 F.3d at 1230. In short)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 270.96 480.48 Tm (s innovation. )Tj 13.728 0 Td (Cf Microsoft, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 73.92 452.4 Tm (finding that Rambus is entitled to zero or)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 270.96 452.16 Tm (, at most)Tj 3.457 0 Td (, nominal royalties with respect to JEDEC-)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 73.68 423.84 Tm (compliant products \(while stil allowing full compensation for other )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 402.48 423.84 Tm (uses\) is fully supported by )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 395.28 Tm (the )Tj 3.456 0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 140.88 395.28 Tm (decisions and the Antitrust Treatise. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 145.2 366.72 Tm (A Zero Royalty for JEDEC-)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 289.68 366.48 Tm (Compliant Products and Unlimited Royalties for )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.38 0 0 12.38 145.2 352.32 Tm (Non-)Tj 5 0 0 5 170.88 352.32 Tm (JEDEC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.496 0 Td (Uses Is )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.76 0 0 12.76 251.52 352.32 Tm (Reasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 109.2 324.24 Tm (The proposed remedy restores competitive conditions to JEDEC standards)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 466.56 324.24 Tm (, while )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.72 295.92 Tm (permitting Rambus to collect unlimited compensation for its innovation o\ n all non-)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 472.32 295.68 Tm (JEDEC uses. )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 267.6 Tm (Rambus )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 116.4 267.36 Tm (s contention that requiring royalty-)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 282.72 267.36 Tm (free licensing for JEDEC-compliant uses would be )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 72.48 239.28 Tm (punitive and amount to a forfeiture)Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 240.72 239.04 Tm (, RB 5-)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 281.52 239.04 Tm (, is wrong on the law and the facts. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.46 0 0 12.46 155.76 210.72 Tm (Hartford-)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 202.8 210.72 Tm (Empire )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 241.2 210.72 Tm (decision relied upon by Rambus)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 396.24 210.48 Tm (, cours have explained that)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 109.2 210.48 Tm (Since the \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 72.48 182.16 Tm (royalty-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.16 182.16 Tm (free licensing is sometimes appropriate. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.63 0 0 11.63 306.48 181.92 Tm (See)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5.5 0 0 5.5 323.04 181.92 Tm (, e. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 350.16 181.92 Tm (CCB 11-)Tj 5 0 0 5 393.84 181.92 Tm (12; )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.32 181.92 Tm (United States v. General )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 144.48 140.64 Tm (In arguing that the proposed remedy would ")Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 359.76 140.4 Tm (confiscate)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 408.24 140.4 Tm (" royalties to which )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.24 126.48 Tm (Rambus believes itself entitled)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 220.56 126.24 Tm (, Rambus hopes the Commission )Tj 12.39 0 0 12.39 381.36 126.24 Tm (wil ignore Rambus )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 480.24 126.24 Tm (s wholesale )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.72 112.08 Tm (spoliation of evidence and other litigation misconduct \(which already l\ ed one court to bar )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 72 97.92 Tm (Rambus from enforcing its patents\). Decision 19. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 695 0 obj<<>> endobj 696 0 obj<> endobj 697 0 obj<> endobj 698 0 obj<> endobj 699 0 obj<> endobj 702 0 obj<> endobj 704 0 obj<> endobj 705 0 obj<> endobj 707 0 obj<> endobj 708 0 obj[1/space] endobj 709 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 713 0 obj<> endobj 715 0 obj<> endobj 723 0 obj<> endobj 724 0 obj<> endobj 725 0 obj[1903 0 R 1904 0 R 1905 0 R 1906 0 R 1905 0 R 1907 0 R 1909 0 R 1908 0 R 1910 0 R 1911 0 R 1912 0 R 1913 0 R 1914 0 R 1916 0 R 1915 0 R 1917 0 R 1918 0 R 1919 0 R 1920 0 R 1921 0 R 1922 0 R] endobj 726 0 obj<> endobj 727 0 obj<> endobj 728 0 obj<> endobj 729 0 obj<> endobj 730 0 obj<> endobj 731 0 obj<> endobj 732 0 obj<> endobj 733 0 obj<> endobj 734 0 obj<> endobj 735 0 obj<> endobj 736 0 obj<> endobj 737 0 obj<> endobj 738 0 obj<> endobj 739 0 obj<> endobj 740 0 obj<> endobj 741 0 obj<> endobj 742 0 obj<> endobj 743 0 obj<> endobj 744 0 obj<> endobj 745 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.43 0 0 12.43 73.92 708.72 Tm (Electric )Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 119.52 708.72 Tm (115 F. Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 12.07 0 0 12.07 231.12 708.24 Tm (J. 1953\) \(requiring public dedication of patents\). In the remand )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.4 680.16 Tm (in )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 2.688 0 Td (United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.296 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.14 0 0 12.14 165.36 679.68 Tm (Singer )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 202.8 679.92 Tm (while rejecting royalty-)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 314.88 679.68 Tm (free licensing in that case)Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 436.32 679.68 Tm (, the cour examined )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.16 651.6 Tm (the relevant authority to that point and explained that: )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.27 0 0 11.27 110.4 623.04 Tm (The test. . . which )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.83 0 0 8.83 201.84 622.8 Tm (rus through )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 265.44 622.8 Tm (the majority opinions and dissents in the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.46 0 0 12.46 109.68 608.88 Tm (Hartford-)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 156.48 608.88 Tm (Empire )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 287.76 608.4 Tm (cases and the only one which must guide the)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 195.84 608.64 Tm (and )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 3.84 0 Td (National Lead )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.25 0 0 12.25 110.4 594.48 Tm (Cour in framing an anti-)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.71 0 0 7.71 229.92 594.48 Tm (trst decree is )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 299.28 594.24 Tm (what measure must be applied in order to )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 110.16 580.56 Tm (dispel the evil effect ofthe defendant' )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 290.64 580.08 Tm (s wrongful conduct -- which means what )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.13 0 0 8.13 109.92 566.4 Tm (wil restore competition.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 73.68 538.08 Tm (231 F. Supp. 240)Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 156.48 537.84 Tm (, 244 \(S. )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 220.32 537.84 Tm (Y. 1964\). In short)Tj 11.62 0 0 11.62 308.88 537.6 Tm (, a royalty-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 360 537.6 Tm (free licence is remedial)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.51 0 0 12.51 471.6 537.6 Tm (, not puntive )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 509.76 Tm (because it is )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.08 0 0 9.08 135.12 509.52 Tm (necessar ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 189.84 509.52 Tm (to dispel the evil effect" ofRambus )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 364.32 509.04 Tm (s misconduct. )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.44 481.44 Tm (Rambus also obscures a critical fact )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 284.16 480.96 Tm (- the proposed remedy pennits Rambus reasonable )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 453.12 Tm (compensation for its intellectual )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 230.4 452.64 Tm (propert. In )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 292.8 452.64 Tm (contrast to the open-source IE proposal in )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.72 424.56 Tm (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 126 424.56 Tm (the proposed remedy here would allow Rambus unlimited compensation for i\ ts )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 73.2 396.24 Tm (innovation in all uses unaffected by its unlawful conduct. It would proh\ ibit only collection of )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.72 367.68 Tm (royalties \(which it otherwise would have been unable to collect\) for t\ he applications affected by )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.72 339.12 Tm (its unlawful conduct. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.48 310.8 Tm (Rambus argues that)Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 203.52 310.56 Tm (, even with )Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 258.72 310.32 Tm (unestricted royalties on all other uses)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 441.36 310.08 Tm (, a zero royalty on )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.24 282.24 Tm (JEDEC-compliant uses would be harsh given that ")Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 318.96 282 Tm (relevant legal authorities)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 438.24 281.76 Tm (, and in paricular the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.48 253.92 Tm (Commission )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 137.76 253.92 Tm (s consent order in the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 20.832 -0.048 Td (Dell )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 266.4 253.68 Tm (case)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 287.28 253.68 Tm (, are of relatively recent vintage and largely post\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 72.24 225.6 Tm (date Rambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.49 0 0 11.49 138.96 225.6 Tm (s conduct." RB 8. This call for leniency fails for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 378 225.12 Tm (at least two reasons. First)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 502.56 224.88 Tm (, the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 197.04 Tm (Commission found the conduct here to be substantially more egregious tha\ n that alleged in )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 510 196.56 Tm (Dell. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 71.76 168.72 Tm (Rambus acted intentionally to implement its scheme over a period of year\ s; Dell' )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 461.52 168 Tm (s single act was )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 76.8 140.16 Tm (not inadvertent )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 152.64 139.92 Tm (" but not necessarly intentional. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 312.96 139.68 Tm (Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 423.36 139.44 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.61 0 0 11.61 463.68 139.44 Tm (C. 616)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.61 0 0 10.61 495.36 139.44 Tm (, 625\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.76 111.84 Tm (\(1996\); also \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 133.44 111.6 Tm (628-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 155.04 111.6 Tm (29 \(Commissioner Azcuenaga)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 300.48 111.12 Tm (, dissenting: ")Tj 5.532 0 Td (obtain\(ingJ market power by )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 746 0 obj<<>> endobj 747 0 obj<> endobj 748 0 obj<> endobj 749 0 obj<> endobj 750 0 obj<> endobj 752 0 obj<> endobj 753 0 obj[1/space] endobj 754 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 762 0 obj<> endobj 763 0 obj<> endobj 764 0 obj[1923 0 R 1924 0 R 1925 0 R 1926 0 R 1927 0 R 1928 0 R 1929 0 R 1930 0 R 1931 0 R] endobj 765 0 obj<> endobj 766 0 obj<> endobj 767 0 obj<> endobj 768 0 obj<> endobj 769 0 obj<> endobj 770 0 obj<> endobj 771 0 obj<> endobj 772 0 obj<> endobj 773 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.4 708.48 Tm (knowingly or intentionally misleading a standards-setting organization)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 413.04 707.76 Tm (" presents a ")Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 476.88 707.76 Tm (routine )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.03 0 0 8.03 74.64 679.92 Tm (antitrst case\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 111.12 651.12 Tm (Second)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.43 0 0 10.43 146.16 651.12 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 195.6 651.12 Tm (s implication that)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 278.64 650.88 Tm (, at the time of its conduct)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 404.16 650.64 Tm (, it could not have )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.64 622.8 Tm (anticipated that it risked forfeiting the enforcement of its patents)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 383.52 622.32 Tm (, is contradicted by the record. )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 594.48 Tm (From the outset)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 149.76 594.24 Tm (, Rambus consulted with its lawyers about the possible consequences of i\ ts )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.5 0 0 11.5 74.16 566.16 Tm (conduct. CX1941 \(")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 173.76 565.68 Tm (JEDEC - said need )Tj 14.18 0 0 14.18 269.52 565.68 Tm (preplanng )Tj 12.22 0 0 12.22 329.76 565.44 Tm (before accuse others of infrngement" )Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 73.68 537.84 Tm (Repeatedly durng the next four years)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 254.4 537.36 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 303.36 537.12 Tm (s lawyers told Rambus representatives point\255)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.97 0 0 9.97 73.44 509.28 Tm (blan - Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 155.76 509.28 Tm (s conduct could result in the non-enforceability of its patents. CX1942 \ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.04 0 0 8.04 73.92 481.2 Tm (\(Vincent: ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 127.2 480.96 Tm (I said there could be equitable estoppel problem )Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 362.16 480.24 Tm (\); CX1958 at 12 \(")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 452.64 480.48 Tm (Two possible )Tj 12.42 0 0 12.42 73.44 452.88 Tm (theories for non-enforcement: 1\) Estoppel? 2\) Antitrst?")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 352.56 451.92 Tm (\); CX3126 at 552-)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 440.64 452.16 Tm (54; CX0837 at 1 )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 73.68 424.08 Tm (\(Crisp: ")Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 115.44 424.32 Tm (Tony )Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 144.24 424.08 Tm (s worst case scenaro regarding estoppel")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.95 0 0 7.95 341.52 423.6 Tm (\). Despite that advice)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 447.12 423.6 Tm (, and with full )Tj 12.21 0 0 12.21 73.2 395.76 Tm (knowledge ofthe consequences)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 225.84 395.52 Tm (, Rambus intentionally embarked on the deceptive course of )Tj -12.709 -2.338 Td (conduct leading to the Commission )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 247.68 366.96 Tm (s liability finding. Rambus can hardly complain today about )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.72 338.88 Tm (being held to precisely the remedy that its lawyers predicted. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.67 0 0 12.67 144.72 310.08 Tm (The Commission Should Resist the Temptation To Impose Punitive Relief )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 282 Tm (Complaint Counsel acknowledge the persuasive )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 12.58 0 0 12.58 342 281.52 Tm (arguents in )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 407.76 281.52 Tm (support of a stricter )Tj 5 0 0 5 72.24 253.92 Tm (remedy. )Tj 8.928 -0.048 Td (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 136.32 253.68 Tm (Brief of Amici Curae)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 242.4 253.2 Tm (, Gesmer Updegrove LLP and Andrew Updegrove at 2\255)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.72 225.12 Tm (SSO members may recognize that)Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 235.68 224.88 Tm (, ifby deceiving an SSO they can collect monopoly rents for )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 72 197.04 Tm (years)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 97.44 196.8 Tm (, and thereafter be restored to prior conditions)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 316.8 196.32 Tm (, there would be no down-side to the )Tj 5 0 0 5 72 168.48 Tm (deception. )Tj 11.04 -0.048 Td (Id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 143.76 168.24 Tm (at 5. Failure to punish Rambus might ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 333.36 167.76 Tm (shake the faith of the members ofSSOs in )Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 71.76 139.92 Tm (the voluntar )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 138.24 139.68 Tm (consensus standards development process. )Tj 12.23 0 0 12.23 369.6 139.2 Tm (at 12. Many SSOs may)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 352.56 139.2 Tm (Id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.76 111.36 Tm (disappointed that the proposed relief does not go far enough. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 59.232 -0.144 Td (Id. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.13 0 0 7.13 385.2 110.64 Tm (at 14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 774 0 obj<<>> endobj 775 0 obj<> endobj 776 0 obj<> endobj 777 0 obj<> endobj 778 0 obj<> endobj 782 0 obj<> endobj 787 0 obj<> endobj 789 0 obj<> endobj 790 0 obj[1/space] endobj 791 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 795 0 obj<> endobj 796 0 obj<> endobj 797 0 obj<> endobj 798 0 obj[1932 0 R 1933 0 R 1934 0 R 1934 0 R 1935 0 R 1936 0 R 1937 0 R 1938 0 R 1939 0 R 1940 0 R 1941 0 R 1940 0 R 1942 0 R 1942 0 R 1943 0 R 1944 0 R 1945 0 R] endobj 799 0 obj<> endobj 800 0 obj<> endobj 801 0 obj<> endobj 802 0 obj<> endobj 803 0 obj<> endobj 804 0 obj<> endobj 805 0 obj<> endobj 806 0 obj<> endobj 807 0 obj<> endobj 808 0 obj<> endobj 809 0 obj<> endobj 810 0 obj<> endobj 811 0 obj<> endobj 812 0 obj<> endobj 813 0 obj<> endobj 814 0 obj<> endobj 815 0 obj<> endobj 816 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.98 0 0 11.98 111.6 707.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditiona\ l)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 475.2 707.76 Tm (, limited )Tj 13.95 0 0 13.95 75.36 679.2 Tm (antitrst )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 117.6 679.2 Tm (remedy clearly within its well-)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 264.48 679.2 Tm (defined powers. Despite Rambus )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 430.08 678.96 Tm (s windfall gains during )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 650.64 Tm (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 398.88 650.64 Tm (, the Commission )Tj 13.65 0 0 13.65 486.72 650.64 Tm (s primar )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 75.12 622.08 Tm (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive condit\ ions and protect consumers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.02 0 0 11.02 75.12 593.76 Tm (going forward. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 74.64 536.88 Tm (II. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.82 0 0 12.82 110.88 536.88 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 297.6 536.64 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 480 536.64 Tm (Compliant )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.09 0 0 13.09 110.88 522.72 Tm (Products Is Appropriate )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.47 0 0 11.47 146.4 494.4 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 232.8 494.16 Tm (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 146.88 480 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 317.76 480 Tm (Of Rambus Patents )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.64 452.16 Tm (The record demonstrates that)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 250.56 451.92 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 333.12 451.68 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 387.6 451.68 Tm (, JEDEC standards would be )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 74.64 423.6 Tm (ftee of Ram bus )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 152.4 423.36 Tm (s patent claims. CCB 4-)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 270 423.36 Tm (6; CCFF 2101 )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 343.92 423.36 Tm (2435-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 372 423.36 Tm (40. Rambus )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.32 423.36 Tm (errs in asserting that it )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 74.4 395.04 Tm (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents bec\ ause \(it claims\) JEDEC )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 73.92 366.72 Tm (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.87 0 0 8.87 382.56 366.48 Tm (12. Likewise)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 446.88 366.48 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.7 0 0 14.7 74.16 338.16 Tm (arguent )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 121.92 338.16 Tm (that the Commission should credit Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 333.36 337.92 Tm (s retained experts)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 417.84 337.92 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 309.84 Tm (Rapp, to justify a 2.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 168.48 309.6 Tm (5% royalty rate )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 262.8 309.6 Tm (23-)Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 291.12 309.6 Tm (, is baseless.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 247.92 309.6 Tm (id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.44 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj 13.57 0 0 13.57 153.12 281.28 Tm (s arguents are )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 231.12 281.28 Tm (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the )Tj 13.13 0 0 13.13 468.96 281.28 Tm (fudamental )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.75 0 0 7.75 73.68 252.96 Tm (staring point - the concrete factual record of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 292.32 252.72 Tm (what competitive conditions likely would have )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 224.64 Tm (prevailed in the absence of its deception.)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 269.04 229.44 Tm (4 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 322.08 224.4 Tm (s unfounded assumptions include: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 196.32 Tm (1.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.4 196.32 Tm ( Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 364.08 195.84 Tm (The evidence is unequivocal: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.2 167.52 Tm (Rambus refused to give a )Tj 22.99 0 0 22.99 198 167.52 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 235.68 167.52 Tm (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 144.96 126.24 Tm (Even assuming )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 15.312 -0.048 Td (arguendo )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 270.48 126 Tm (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer )Tj 13.28 0 0 13.28 502.8 126 Tm (durng )Tj 12 0 0 12 72.96 111.84 Tm (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate re\ lief by a )Tj -0.02 -1.18 Td (preponderance of the evidence)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 220.08 97.44 Tm (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-)Tj 5 0 0 5 468.72 97.44 Tm (9; )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.6 0 0 7.6 481.2 97.68 Tm (infra 10-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 523.92 97.44 Tm (14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 817 0 obj<<>> endobj 818 0 obj<> endobj 819 0 obj<> endobj 820 0 obj<> endobj 821 0 obj<> endobj 828 0 obj<> endobj 830 0 obj<> endobj 831 0 obj<> endobj 832 0 obj[1946 0 R 1947 0 R 1948 0 R 1949 0 R 1950 0 R 1951 0 R 1951 0 R 1952 0 R 1954 0 R 1953 0 R] endobj 833 0 obj<> endobj 834 0 obj<> endobj 835 0 obj<> endobj 836 0 obj<> endobj 837 0 obj<> endobj 838 0 obj<> endobj 839 0 obj<> endobj 840 0 obj<> endobj 841 0 obj<> endobj 842 0 obj<> endobj 843 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.88 707.52 Tm (\(Diepenbrock\). This was not mere oversight or misunderstanding; it was\ a calculated )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 487.2 707.52 Tm (position. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.52 0 0 10.52 74.64 678.96 Tm (Rambus representatives regarded )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.69 0 0 22.69 236.64 678.72 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 273.84 678.96 Tm (as contrar to Rambus)Tj 10.34 0 0 10.34 381.36 678.96 Tm (' s entire business model. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.88 650.4 Tm (CX0873 \(")Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 127.2 650.4 Tm (Rambus Inc. )Tj 13.22 0 0 13.22 190.8 650.4 Tm (canot agree )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 254.64 650.4 Tm (to the terms ofthe JEDEC patent \(licensing\) )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 470.16 650.64 Tm (policy"\); )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.88 621.84 Tm (CX0874 \(")Tj 12 0 0 12 127.2 622.08 Tm (the patent \(licensing\) policy of JEDEC does not comport with our busin\ ess model" )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 74.64 593.52 Tm (Tr. 6228-)Tj 12 0 0 12 119.76 593.52 Tm (29 \(Diepenbrock: ")Tj 22.69 0 0 22.69 212.16 593.28 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 249.36 593.52 Tm (terms \(were\) inconsistent with Rambus)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 438.24 593.52 Tm (' existing business )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.16 565.2 Tm (practices )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 122.16 564.96 Tm (\); CX2112 at 213 \(Mooring\); CX3129 at 488-)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 342.72 564.96 Tm (89 \(Vincent\); CX2083 at 98 \(Davidow\). )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.16 536.88 Tm (And absent a )Tj 14.66 0 0 14.66 139.44 536.64 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 238.08 536.64 Tm (, JEDEC could not have adopted Rambus )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 441.12 536.88 Tm (s technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.4 508.32 Tm (CX0203A at 11; JX0054 at 9; CX0208 at 19; Tr. 1868-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.71 0 0 10.71 352.08 508.32 Tm (, 1884-)Tj 4.325 0.022 Td (, 1895-)Tj 10.56 0 0 10.56 444.48 508.56 Tm (, 1907-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.65 0 0 11.65 478.08 508.56 Tm (08 \(Kelly\). )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 480.24 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 154.56 480.24 Tm (s deception)Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 209.04 480 Tm (, JEDEC standards would have been ftee ofRambus )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 464.4 480.24 Tm (s patent claims. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 110.16 451.92 Tm (2.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 119.3325 451.92 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 243.6 451.68 Tm (have been satisfied with a RAND commitment from Rambus. )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 423.12 Tm (JEDEC members were focused on minimizing cost. They were particularly co\ ncerned about )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 73.68 394.8 Tm (patents held by non-manufacturng companies)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 295.44 394.8 Tm (, such as Rambus)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 378.72 394.8 Tm (, because they would demand )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.92 366.24 Tm (cash royalties rather than cross-)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 225.36 366.48 Tm (licenses. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 109.92 337.92 Tm (3. JEDEC members would have engaged )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 312.24 337.68 Tm (in a detailed cost comparison of alternatives. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 73.44 309.6 Tm (Rambus argues)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 147.12 309.36 Tm (, based solely on the theories of its retained experts)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 392.16 309.36 Tm (, that JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 73.2 281.28 Tm (have calculated static)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 175.92 281.04 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 212.16 281.04 Tm (to-)Tj 1.151 0 Td (the-)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 244.32 281.04 Tm (penny cost projections)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 352.08 281.04 Tm (, fifteen years into the future)Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 488.4 281.28 Tm (, of )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 252.72 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 116.88 252.72 Tm (s technologies versus alternatives. Rambus presents no factual evidence \ that JEDEC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.38 0 0 7.38 73.68 224.4 Tm (actually did this. In fact)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 189.36 224.4 Tm (, there were multiple reasons why JEDEC did not. Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 479.52 224.4 Tm (s own )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.68 195.84 Tm (experiences with its )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 171.12 195.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 218.88 195.84 Tm (show: )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 15.55 0 0 15.55 109.2 144.96 Tm (5 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 188.4 139.92 Tm (s claims that JEDEC never rejected a patented technology )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.78 0 0 7.78 468.96 140.16 Tm (ifthe patent-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 125.76 Tm (holder offered a )Tj 14.7 0 0 14.7 151.92 125.76 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 250.8 125.76 Tm (, RB 12 n. 9)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 308.4 125.76 Tm (, is simply untrue. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 420.24 125.76 Tm (Tr. 5046-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.15 0 0 11.15 465.36 126 Tm (49 \(Kellogg: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 72.96 111.6 Tm (IBM)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 95.52 111.36 Tm (, Cypress)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 139.68 111.6 Tm (, Kentron and )Tj 13.83 0 0 13.83 208.08 111.6 Tm (Hyudai )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 252.24 111.6 Tm (technologies rejected despite )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.99 0 0 22.99 393.36 111.36 Tm (RA )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 431.04 111.6 Tm (offer\); CX3135 at 104\255)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 97.44 Tm (06 \(Chen: Mitsubishi technologies rejected\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 844 0 obj<<>> endobj 845 0 obj<> endobj 846 0 obj<> endobj 847 0 obj<> endobj 848 0 obj<> endobj 851 0 obj<> endobj 852 0 obj<> endobj 860 0 obj<> endobj 861 0 obj<> endobj 862 0 obj<> endobj 863 0 obj<> endobj 864 0 obj<> endobj 865 0 obj[1955 0 R 1955 0 R 1956 0 R 1959 0 R 1960 0 R 1961 0 R 1960 0 R 1962 0 R 1960 0 R 1964 0 R 1965 0 R 1966 0 R 1967 0 R 1968 0 R 1969 0 R 1970 0 R 1971 0 R 1972 0 R 1973 0 R] endobj 866 0 obj<> endobj 867 0 obj<> endobj 868 0 obj<> endobj 869 0 obj<> endobj 870 0 obj<> endobj 871 0 obj<> endobj 872 0 obj<> endobj 873 0 obj<> endobj 874 0 obj<> endobj 875 0 obj<> endobj 876 0 obj<> endobj 877 0 obj<> endobj 878 0 obj<> endobj 879 0 obj<> endobj 880 0 obj<> endobj 881 0 obj<> endobj 882 0 obj<> endobj 883 0 obj<> endobj 884 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.9 0 0 11.9 111.36 693.36 Tm (\(A\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 127.8772 693.36 Tm ( Cost projections were extremely difficult and subject only to very roug\ h estimates. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 111.12 678.96 Tm (Cost projections were often rounded plus-or-minus 10%. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 111.12 650.64 Tm (\(B\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 126.204 650.64 Tm ( Costs tyically )Tj 5 0 0 5 206.64 650.4 Tm (dropped dramatically over time. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 31.824 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 385.68 650.16 Tm (CX2747 at 68 )Tj 15.21 0 0 15.21 455.76 650.64 Tm (\(RDRA )Tj 11.62 0 0 11.62 506.88 650.64 Tm (cost )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 111.12 636.48 Tm (disadvantage dropping from 80% to 30-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.69 0 0 10.69 301.68 636.24 Tm (40% from 1H99 to 2HOO\).)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 428.64 641.04 Tm (6 As a result)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 489.6 636.24 Tm (, cost )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 110.4 622.08 Tm (projections rarely extended over more than 1-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.5 0 0 7.5 329.04 622.08 Tm (2 years. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.88 593.52 Tm (\(C\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 127.0093 593.52 Tm ( Cost projections vared widely from company to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 364.32 593.52 Tm (company; a single company often )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.4 579.6 Tm (presented a wide range of possible outcomes. RX-)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 355.44 579.36 Tm (1525 at 19 \(Rambus Q400 cost gap )Tj 12.74 0 0 12.74 110.88 565.2 Tm (scenaros )Tj 14.44 0 0 14.44 157.92 565.2 Tm (\(RDRA to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.28 565.2 Tm (PClOO\) ranging from $8.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 342 564.96 Tm (74 to $19.)Tj 11.37 0 0 11.37 390 564.96 Tm (71\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 74.64 537.12 Tm (In sum)Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 107.52 536.88 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 179.28 536.88 Tm (s calculations of unform)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 299.04 536.88 Tm (, static)Tj 10.94 0 0 10.94 330.72 536.88 Tm (, pennes-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 376.56 536.64 Tm (per-chip cost differences among )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 74.64 508.8 Tm (alternatives was completely )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.57 0 0 11.57 209.76 508.56 Tm (irelevant to JEDEC' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.3 0 0 12.3 311.28 508.56 Tm (s processes. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 427.2 508.56 Tm (I don )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 455.52 508.56 Tm (t even know )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 480.48 Tm (whether the questions I was asked to answer were ever asked at JEDEC")Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 422.16 480.24 Tm (\); 9674 \(")Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 468.72 480.24 Tm (I have no )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.16 452.16 Tm (knowledge of how JEDEC folks did their analysis )Tj 12.54 0 0 12.54 318.96 451.92 Tm (\). Dr. Rapp )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 380.16 451.68 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 444.48 451.92 Tm (, relying on Mr. )Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.4 423.36 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 12 0 0 12 120 423.6 Tm (s numbers to opine on the ")Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 251.52 423.36 Tm (but-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 271.2 423.36 Tm (for)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 284.88 423.36 Tm (" world)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 321.36 423.36 Tm (, are therefore equally flawed and rendered )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.72 0 0 7.72 74.16 395.04 Tm (irrelevant. The factual record establishes that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 292.32 394.8 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 375.36 394.8 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 429.84 394.8 Tm (, JEDEC members )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 366.48 Tm (simply would have selected a generally acceptable alternative. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 377.28 366.24 Tm (Decision 74 n. 403 \(JEDEC )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 73.92 338.16 Tm (dropped loop-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 140.4 338.16 Tm (back clock proposal because of Ram bus patent concerns and pursued alter\ natives )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.44 309.84 Tm (without any detailed cost comparison\); Tr. 1416-)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 308.64 309.6 Tm (17 \(Sussman\); Tr. 9022-)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 424.8 309.6 Tm (23 \(Prince\); Tr. 6635\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 91.68 281.28 Tm (6717 )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 121.44 281.28 Tm (6686 \(Lee\); Tr. 5136 )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 227.76 281.28 Tm (5146 )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 258 281.28 Tm (5170 )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 287.52 281.28 Tm (5187 \(Kellogg\); CX2107 at 137 \(Oh\); CX2058 at )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 73.68 252.96 Tm (371-)Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 113.04 253.2 Tm (440-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 134.64 252.96 Tm (41 \(Meyer\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 145.2 209.28 Tm (Cf )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.14 0 0 12.14 161.76 209.52 Tm (Decision 95 \(")Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 232.32 209.52 Tm (Rapp )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 262.08 209.28 Tm (s calculations)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 326.64 209.28 Tm (, like Geilhufe )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 399.6 209.04 Tm (s estimates)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 452.16 209.28 Tm (, wholly ignore )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 73.44 195.12 Tm (several possibilities for cost reductions from adoption of the alternati\ ve technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 144.48 168.72 Tm (Dr. McAfee \(who unlike Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. Rapp studied the record )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.44 154.56 Tm (extensively\) explained that JEDEC members followed a decision-making pr\ ocess known as )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 78.72 140.16 Tm (satisficing.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.55 0 0 8.55 130.08 140.16 Tm (" Because of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 196.8 140.16 Tm (the many uncertainties involved)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 350.64 139.92 Tm (, time-)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 381.6 139.92 Tm (to-market concerns and the )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 126 Tm (importance of reaching consensus)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.93 0 0 10.93 235.68 125.76 Tm (, JEDEC members did not try to conduct detailed comparsons )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.96 111.84 Tm (of each set of alternatives to identify the very best)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 311.28 111.6 Tm (, but rather settled on an acceptable )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 72.96 97.44 Tm (compromise and moved on. Tr. 7255-)Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 257.52 97.44 Tm (56. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 885 0 obj<<>> endobj 886 0 obj<> endobj 887 0 obj<> endobj 888 0 obj<> endobj 889 0 obj<> endobj 891 0 obj<> endobj 892 0 obj[1/space] endobj 893 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 898 0 obj<> endobj 900 0 obj<> endobj 904 0 obj<> endobj 905 0 obj<> endobj 913 0 obj<> endobj 914 0 obj<> endobj 915 0 obj<> endobj 916 0 obj[1974 0 R 1974 0 R 1975 0 R 1976 0 R 1977 0 R 1978 0 R 1981 0 R 1982 0 R 1983 0 R 1982 0 R 1985 0 R 1986 0 R 1987 0 R 1986 0 R 1988 0 R 1991 0 R 1992 0 R 1994 0 R 1995 0 R 1996 0 R 1995 0 R 1997 0 R 1995 0 R 1998 0 R 1998 0 R 1999 0 R 2000 0 R 2001 0 R 2002 0 R 2003 0 R] endobj 917 0 obj<> endobj 918 0 obj<> endobj 919 0 obj<> endobj 920 0 obj<> endobj 921 0 obj<> endobj 922 0 obj<> endobj 923 0 obj<> endobj 924 0 obj<> endobj 925 0 obj<> endobj 926 0 obj<> endobj 927 0 obj<> endobj 928 0 obj<> endobj 929 0 obj<> endobj 930 0 obj<> endobj 931 0 obj<> endobj 932 0 obj<> endobj 933 0 obj<> endobj 934 0 obj<> endobj 935 0 obj<> endobj 936 0 obj<> endobj 937 0 obj<> endobj 938 0 obj<> endobj 939 0 obj<> endobj 940 0 obj<> endobj 941 0 obj<> endobj 942 0 obj<> endobj 943 0 obj<> endobj 944 0 obj<> endobj 945 0 obj<> endobj 946 0 obj<> endobj 947 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 8.3 0 0 8.3 110.64 708.24 Tm (4.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.3 0 0 8.3 120.6 708.24 Tm ( Cost )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 150.48 708 Tm (comparisons would have shown that)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 324.96 707.52 Tm (, on a value-adjusted basis)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.27 0 0 10.27 453.36 707.76 Tm (, Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 679.68 Tm (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 324.72 679.2 Tm (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 74.64 650.88 Tm (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective \ than alternatives. Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.64 622.32 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 120.24 622.56 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 5.419 -0.02 Td (, however)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 231.6 622.32 Tm (, are fatally flawed and uneliable. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 109.68 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 119.5078 579.84 Tm (He lacked the experience )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 242.16 579.6 Tm (necessar to render such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 362.88 579.36 Tm (an opinion. Tr. 9625-)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 465.12 579.36 Tm (9626 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 500.88 577.2 Tm (Q. And )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 109.92 565.68 Tm (your last hands-on )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 200.88 565.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 240 565.44 Tm (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.71 0 0 9.71 462.48 565.2 Tm (A. 1978)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 504.24 565.2 Tm (, 1\255)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 551.52 Tm (that is correct.")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 183.12 551.28 Tm (\); 9550-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.76 551.28 Tm (9551 \(1988-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.04 0 0 11.04 281.76 551.28 Tm (1998)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 305.04 551.04 Tm (, worked for lSD)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 385.44 551.04 Tm (, a fabless company with no )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.94 0 0 8.94 109.68 537.36 Tm (manufacturng\); 9628-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 217.92 537.12 Tm (9631 \(1999-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 276.72 537.12 Tm (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 109.68 523.2 Tm (how outdated 14-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 193.44 522.96 Tm (year-old )Tj 16.87 0 0 16.87 235.68 522.96 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 275.52 522.96 Tm (fabs could be used to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 378.96 522.72 Tm (manufactue other )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 469.44 522.96 Tm (products\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 109.2 494.88 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 116.2292 494.88 Tm (He failed to review any JEDEC records)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 308.4 494.64 Tm (, interview any JEDEC members)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 465.6 494.4 Tm (, or \(with very )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 480.72 Tm (few exceptions\) review the deposition or )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 7.93 0 0 7.93 307.92 480.48 Tm (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 507.12 480.24 Tm (9619\255)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 109.92 466.56 Tm (9623 \(")Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 145.92 464.16 Tm (Q. You never reviewed any )Tj 12.52 0 0 12.52 283.44 466.08 Tm (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 7.79 0 0 7.79 431.28 466.08 Tm (I did not. ... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 501.36 466.08 Tm (I never )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 109.92 452.4 Tm (spoke to a JEDEC member. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 423.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 116.2225 423.84 Tm (He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from )Tj 16.83 0 0 16.83 440.16 423.6 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 409.68 Tm (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 391.68 408.96 Tm (9618 \(")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 427.92 409.2 Tm (wanted to see cost )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 109.44 395.52 Tm (documents from a number of companes )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 306 395.04 Tm (" but they weren )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 388.32 395.04 Tm (t available\); 9666-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 476.88 395.04 Tm (9667 \(never )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 109.44 381.12 Tm (asked to obtain )Tj 13.31 0 0 13.31 184.56 381.12 Tm (DRA manufacturers)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 293.28 380.88 Tm (' cost information\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 108.72 352.8 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 115.7259 352.8 Tm (He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptanc\ e among )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 108.72 338.4 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 147.84 338.4 Tm (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 347.52 335.76 Tm (Q. Now)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 385.2 337.92 Tm (, what did you do to ensure that )Tj -23.156 -1.146 Td (the analysis that you did was the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.48 0 0 13.48 266.88 321.6 Tm (tye of )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 303.6 324 Tm (analysis that' )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 366.72 323.76 Tm (s done at JEDEC? A. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 477.6 323.76 Tm (I did not do )Tj 12.29 0 0 12.29 108.96 310.08 Tm (anything. I did my analysis. . . )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 108.24 281.76 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 118.5958 281.76 Tm (The sources )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.05 0 0 12.05 180.96 281.52 Tm (of his information )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 270.96 281.52 Tm (canot be identified)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 366.24 281.28 Tm (, and his calculations )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 469.92 281.28 Tm (canot be )Tj 8.56 0 0 8.56 108.48 267.6 Tm (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 227.28 267.12 Tm (9715 \(he couldn' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 309.12 267.12 Tm (t remember the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 384 267.12 Tm (manufactuers or par )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 490.56 267.12 Tm (numbers )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 253.44 Tm (of components for which he collected cost information; ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 382.56 252.96 Tm (I believe I specified one or two )Tj 12.67 0 0 12.67 108.48 239.28 Tm (companes)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 159.84 239.04 Tm (, and the others I didn' )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 267.84 238.8 Tm (t recall. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 143.76 140.4 Tm (Whether a method "' )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 247.68 140.4 Tm (has been subjected to peer review)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 409.92 140.16 Tm ('" and " )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 447.6 140.16 Tm (enjoys ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 485.28 140.16 Tm (general )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 72.24 126.48 Tm (acceptance)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 125.04 126.48 Tm (' within a ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 176.88 126.24 Tm (relevant scientific community)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 321.12 126 Tm ('" are factors in determining the reliability of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 112.08 Tm (an expert opinion. )Tj 18.432 0 Td (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 257.52 111.84 Tm (Carmichael )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.63 0 0 8.63 320.16 111.84 Tm (526 U.S. 137)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 383.04 111.6 Tm (, 149-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 412.08 111.6 Tm (150 \(1999\) \(citing )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.04 97.92 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 125.28 97.92 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 272.4 97.68 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 303.36 97.68 Tm (509 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.29 0 0 10.29 336 97.44 Tm (S. 579)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 366.48 97.44 Tm (, 592-)Tj 10.93 0 0 10.93 394.32 97.44 Tm (594 \(1993\)\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 948 0 obj<<>> endobj 949 0 obj<> endobj 950 0 obj<> endobj 951 0 obj<> endobj 952 0 obj<> endobj 962 0 obj<> endobj 964 0 obj<> endobj 965 0 obj[1/space] endobj 966 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 968 0 obj<> endobj 969 0 obj<> endobj 970 0 obj<> endobj 971 0 obj<> endobj 972 0 obj[2004 0 R 2004 0 R 2005 0 R 2005 0 R 2006 0 R 2007 0 R 2008 0 R 2008 0 R 2009 0 R 2010 0 R 2010 0 R 2011 0 R 2012 0 R 2014 0 R 2013 0 R 2015 0 R 2016 0 R] endobj 973 0 obj<> endobj 974 0 obj<> endobj 975 0 obj<> endobj 976 0 obj<> endobj 977 0 obj<> endobj 978 0 obj<> endobj 979 0 obj<> endobj 980 0 obj<> endobj 981 0 obj<> endobj 982 0 obj<> endobj 983 0 obj<> endobj 984 0 obj<> endobj 985 0 obj<> endobj 986 0 obj<> endobj 987 0 obj<> endobj 988 0 obj<> endobj 989 0 obj<> endobj 990 0 obj<> endobj 991 0 obj<> endobj 992 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 993 0 obj<<>> endobj 994 0 obj<> endobj 995 0 obj<> endobj 996 0 obj<> endobj 997 0 obj<> endobj 1000 0 obj<> endobj 1003 0 obj<> endobj 1004 0 obj[1/space] endobj 1005 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 1008 0 obj<> endobj 1010 0 obj<> endobj 1011 0 obj<> endobj 1012 0 obj[2017 0 R 2018 0 R 2019 0 R 2020 0 R 2021 0 R 2022 0 R 2023 0 R 2024 0 R 2026 0 R] endobj 1013 0 obj<> endobj 1014 0 obj<> endobj 1015 0 obj<> endobj 1016 0 obj<> endobj 1017 0 obj<> endobj 1018 0 obj<> endobj 1019 0 obj<> endobj 1020 0 obj<> endobj 1021 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.06 0 0 12.06 74.64 708.24 Tm (Commission )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 139.92 708.24 Tm (s remedy findings)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 225.12 708 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 6.106 0 Td (s own calculations \(adjusted by the Commission to )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 679.92 Tm (reflect the factual record\) demonstrate that the marginal value of the \ Rambus technologies over )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 651.36 Tm (available alternatives was zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 31.008 -0.096 Td (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 249.84 650.88 Tm (CCB 6\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 110.64 622.8 Tm (The Commission should disregard the testimony of Rambus )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 402.24 622.08 Tm (s experts as uneliable and )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.78 0 0 7.78 74.16 594.48 Tm (irrelevant. The factual )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 186.24 594.24 Tm (evidence \(as opposed to theories and assumptions\) establishes that)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 504.72 593.76 Tm (, absent )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 73.68 566.16 Tm (Rambus )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 118.08 565.92 Tm (s deception)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 171.84 565.92 Tm (, the JEDEC standards today would be free ofRambus )Tj 12.19 0 0 12.19 437.28 565.2 Tm (s patent claims. CCB )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.73 0 0 12.73 145.92 509.04 Tm (To Restore Competitive Conditions and Permit Effective Administration, )Tj 12.61 0 0 12.61 145.92 494.88 Tm (The Remedy Must Apply To All Technologies in the JEDEC )Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 457.68 494.4 Tm (Standards )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 109.68 467.04 Tm (An effective remedy must address all \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 290.64 466.56 Tm (nine )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 314.16 466.32 Tm (markets potentially impacted by Rambus)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.44 0 0 7.44 511.2 466.08 Tm (' s )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 438.48 Tm (deception)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 120.72 438.48 Tm (, CCFF 3113-)Tj 5.592 -0.02 Td (3182)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 210.48 438.24 Tm (, and be capable of implementation without detailed review of )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 73.44 410.16 Tm (complex techncal issues and patent claims. Rambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 332.16 409.44 Tm (s arguent that )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 408.48 409.2 Tm (the remedy should be )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 381.6 Tm (limited to the four markets in which Rambus has successfully acquired mo\ nopoly power)Tj 11.6 0 0 11.6 497.28 380.88 Tm (, RB 9\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 85.44 353.28 Tm (, fails on both counts. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 108.96 324.72 Tm (Rambus would ensure that the greater the deception against an SSO)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 433.92 324 Tm (, the weaker the )Tj 12.26 0 0 12.26 72.24 296.4 Tm (remedy. A malfeasant that )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 204.72 295.92 Tm (deceived an SSO regarding multiple technologies could ensure that )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.72 267.84 Tm (any remedy would be inadequate by enforcing with respect to only one tec\ hnology at a time. )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 239.52 Tm (Any remedy would be limited only to that one market)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 329.76 238.8 Tm (, permitting the perpetrator immediately to )Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.48 211.2 Tm (sue on the next technology. To the extent that the perpetrator were succ\ essful in compelling )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 72.24 182.64 Tm (companes to sign license agreements)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 252.48 182.16 Tm (, the payments would continue throughout a series of )Tj 14.22 0 0 14.22 72 154.08 Tm (fritless )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 114.24 154.08 Tm (Commission enforcement actions. No situation could better explain the Su\ preme )Tj 12.96 0 0 12.96 72 125.52 Tm (Cour' )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 103.68 125.76 Tm (s statement that the Commission )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 263.52 125.04 Tm (s authority ")Tj 12.24 0 0 12.24 322.08 125.04 Tm (is not limited to prohibiting the ilegal )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1022 0 obj<<>> endobj 1023 0 obj<> endobj 1024 0 obj<> endobj 1025 0 obj<> endobj 1026 0 obj<> endobj 1027 0 obj<> endobj 1028 0 obj<> endobj 1034 0 obj<> endobj 1036 0 obj<<>> endobj 1037 0 obj<> endobj 1040 0 obj<> endobj 1041 0 obj<> endobj 1042 0 obj[2027 0 R 2028 0 R 2029 0 R 2030 0 R 2031 0 R 2032 0 R 2032 0 R 2033 0 R 2034 0 R 2033 0 R 2036 0 R 2035 0 R 2037 0 R 2038 0 R] endobj 1043 0 obj<> endobj 1044 0 obj<> endobj 1045 0 obj<> endobj 1046 0 obj<> endobj 1047 0 obj<> endobj 1048 0 obj<> endobj 1049 0 obj<> endobj 1050 0 obj<> endobj 1051 0 obj<> endobj 1052 0 obj<> endobj 1053 0 obj<> endobj 1054 0 obj<> endobj 1055 0 obj<> endobj 1056 0 obj<> endobj 1057 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 304.32 792 Tm (\); )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.64 707.76 Tm (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the \ past )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 432.72 707.28 Tm (" but extends to such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 74.88 679.2 Tm (other provisions as may be necessar to ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 273.12 678.96 Tm (close all roads to the prohibited goal)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 447.6 678.72 Tm (, so that its order )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 74.64 650.64 Tm (may not be by-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 146.16 650.64 Tm (passed with impunty. )Tj 5 0 0 5 262.56 650.4 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.77 0 0 8.77 299.28 650.4 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 370.08 650.16 Tm (343 U.)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 402.96 650.16 Tm (S. 470)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 433.68 650.4 Tm (, 473 \(1952\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.52 0 0 12.52 498.48 650.4 Tm (accord)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 288.48 650.4 Tm (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.98 0 0 7.98 73.92 622.32 Tm (International Salt )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 166.08 622.08 Tm (332 U.)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 198.96 621.84 Tm (S. at 400 \(")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 252.96 622.08 Tm (it is not necessar that all the untraveled )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 448.32 621.6 Tm (roads to that end be )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.64 593.76 Tm (left open and that only the worn one be closed. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 436.56 593.04 Tm (National Lead)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.4 0 0 11.4 506.4 593.28 Tm (, 332)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 317.04 593.28 Tm (see also United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 21.744 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 86.4 565.2 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 96.3887 565.2 Tm ( at 335-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 150.96 565.2 Tm (348-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 172.32 565.2 Tm (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which \ the )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 74.4 537.12 Tm (defendant in the )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 154.8 536.88 Tm (futue received an exclusive license. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 110.16 508.8 Tm (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer.\ )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 461.76 508.32 Tm (Any defendant )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.68 480.48 Tm (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim i\ n one of the relevant )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 73.68 452.16 Tm (markets could complain to the Commission)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 283.44 451.68 Tm (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 73.68 423.6 Tm (whether Rambus had violated the order. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.33 0 0 13.33 266.16 428.16 Tm (ll The )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 300.96 423.12 Tm (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 395.04 Tm (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple tech\ nologies. )Tj ET EMC /Figure <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 28.04 0 0 28.04 109.92 287.52 Tm (11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 144.96 282.72 Tm (As merely one example)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 258.48 282.24 Tm (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5 )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 446.4 282 Tm (915 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.12 0 0 8.12 468.48 282.24 Tm (105 patent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.2 268.32 Tm (against JEDEC-compliant products)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 242.4 268.08 Tm (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10 )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 254.16 Tm (was within the scope of its order: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 225.84 Tm (A memory device comprising: . . . an output )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.34 0 0 8.34 323.76 225.36 Tm (drver having an output coupled to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 108.96 211.68 Tm (the bus)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 143.76 211.68 Tm (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 382.08 211.2 Tm (, the output )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.31 0 0 12.31 439.44 211.2 Tm (drver for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 108.96 197.28 Tm (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; an\ d wherein )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.72 183.12 Tm (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multi\ plexer in )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 108.48 168.96 Tm (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 108.24 154.56 Tm (bus)Tj 1.448 0 Td (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 393.84 154.08 Tm (multiplexer in )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 140.4 Tm (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 108.24 126 Tm (bus. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 72.48 97.44 Tm (CX1516 at 30. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1058 0 obj<<>> endobj 1059 0 obj<> endobj 1060 0 obj<> endobj 1061 0 obj<> endobj 1062 0 obj<> endobj 1066 0 obj<> endobj 1076 0 obj<> endobj 1078 0 obj<> endobj 1079 0 obj<> endobj 1080 0 obj<> endobj 1081 0 obj<> endobj 1082 0 obj[2039 0 R 2039 0 R 2040 0 R 2041 0 R 2042 0 R 2043 0 R 2042 0 R 2044 0 R 2045 0 R 2046 0 R 2047 0 R 2048 0 R 2049 0 R 2050 0 R 2051 0 R 2052 0 R 2054 0 R 2053 0 R 2055 0 R] endobj 1083 0 obj<> endobj 1084 0 obj<> endobj 1085 0 obj<> endobj 1086 0 obj<> endobj 1087 0 obj<> endobj 1088 0 obj<> endobj 1089 0 obj<> endobj 1090 0 obj<> endobj 1091 0 obj<> endobj 1092 0 obj<> endobj 1093 0 obj<> endobj 1094 0 obj<> endobj 1095 0 obj<> endobj 1096 0 obj<> endobj 1097 0 obj<> endobj 1098 0 obj<> endobj 1099 0 obj<> endobj 1100 0 obj<> endobj 1101 0 obj<> endobj 1102 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.26 0 0 13.26 75.12 707.76 Tm (III. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.81 0 0 12.81 111.36 707.76 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 158.16 707.52 Tm (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.6 679.2 Tm (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.95 0 0 10.95 425.76 678.72 Tm (the Commission )Tj 11.41 0 0 11.41 74.88 650.88 Tm (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 310.08 650.4 Tm (The Commission protects the )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 453.6 650.16 Tm (integrty of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 74.64 622.32 Tm (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neith\ er the role nor the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 594 Tm (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should \ avoid )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 16.9 0 0 16.9 449.76 590.88 Tm (trng )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 481.2 593.28 Tm (to set a )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 565.68 Tm (royalty rate for Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 192 565.2 Tm (s technologies. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 110.4 537.12 Tm (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus ro\ yalties at a )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 74.4 509.04 Tm (level of at least 2.)Tj 12.38 0 0 12.38 159.6 508.8 Tm (5%. RB 14-)Tj 11.33 0 0 11.33 218.88 508.8 Tm (25. )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 246.96 508.56 Tm (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 472.8 508.32 Tm (- the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.16 480.72 Tm (Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 117.6 480.48 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.61 0 0 15.61 161.28 480.48 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 208.56 480.48 Tm (agreement - to justify its proposal. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 34.272 -0.096 Td (Id. )Tj 10.81 0 0 10.81 397.68 480 Tm (17-)Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 413.52 480 Tm (18. Rambus grossly )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 73.92 452.16 Tm (mischaracterizes this agreement. )Tj 12.47 0 0 12.47 235.68 451.92 Tm (Hyudai did )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 298.08 451.68 Tm (not initiate negotiations in response to a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.91 0 0 12.91 73.92 423.84 Tm (RaminkSyncLink-related )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 207.6 423.6 Tm (waring from Rambus. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 324.24 423.36 Tm (Id. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 361.68 423.12 Tm (In fact)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 392.64 423.12 Tm (, Rambus and )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 460.8 423.12 Tm (Hyudai)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 341.76 423.12 Tm (17. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 395.28 Tm (commenced negotiations for an )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 227.04 395.04 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 274.8 395.04 Tm (license in early 1995. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 402.48 394.32 Tm (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 520.8 394.56 Tm (62.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 382.56 394.56 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.92 366.72 Tm (The ")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.8 366.72 Tm (Other )Tj 15.86 0 0 15.86 130.8 366.72 Tm (DRA" )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 174.72 366.48 Tm (provision was included in the resulting )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 364.08 366.24 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.16 0 0 11.16 411.6 366.24 Tm (license. CX1599 at 2 )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.33 0 0 11.33 73.44 338.4 Tm (24. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 109.44 309.84 Tm (The Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 174 309.84 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 217.68 309.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 265.2 309.6 Tm (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 116.88 281.52 Tm (s deception. Indeed)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 212.16 281.28 Tm (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 439.44 280.8 Tm (s deception. )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 253.2 Tm (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies po\ tentially covered by its )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.73 0 0 13.73 109.68 216.72 Tm (12 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 188.4 211.68 Tm (s arguent that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 262.32 211.44 Tm (, pursuant to reasonable and non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 421.44 210.96 Tm (discriminatory tenns)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 521.04 210.96 Tm (, it )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 73.2 197.52 Tm (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 394.56 196.8 Tm (tent validity, RB 13-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.74 0 0 9.74 505.68 196.8 Tm (, has )Tj 11 0 0 11 72.48 183.36 Tm (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 385.44 182.64 Tm (, there is no reason why JEDEC )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.48 168.96 Tm (members would have accepted a )Tj 22.55 0 0 22.55 230.88 168.48 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 267.84 168.48 Tm (proposal that excluded any company that chose to )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 72.72 154.8 Tm (challenge the validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 234.96 154.56 Tm (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 478.08 154.08 Tm (s efforts to )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 140.4 Tm (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competi\ tive challenges )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 510.96 139.68 Tm (to the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 72.48 126.24 Tm (validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 168.48 126.24 Tm (s patents. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.33 0 0 12.33 243.6 126 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 473.28 125.52 Tm (Competition)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 218.4 126 Tm (See )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.48 112.08 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 231.12 111.84 Tm (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 97.68 Tm (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\)\ . )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1103 0 obj<<>> endobj 1104 0 obj<> endobj 1105 0 obj<> endobj 1106 0 obj<> endobj 1107 0 obj<> endobj 1108 0 obj<> endobj 1114 0 obj<> endobj 1116 0 obj<> endobj 1117 0 obj<> endobj 1118 0 obj[2056 0 R 2057 0 R 2057 0 R 2058 0 R 2059 0 R 2060 0 R 2062 0 R 2061 0 R 2063 0 R] endobj 1119 0 obj<> endobj 1120 0 obj<> endobj 1121 0 obj<> endobj 1122 0 obj<> endobj 1123 0 obj<> endobj 1124 0 obj<> endobj 1125 0 obj<> endobj 1126 0 obj<> endobj 1127 0 obj<> endobj 1128 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.11 0 0 13.11 319.68 792 Tm (" ")Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 708.72 Tm (patents)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 109.92 708.72 Tm (, it refused to ")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 180.96 708.48 Tm (alert them to a potential problem they can easily work around.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.31 0 0 10.31 477.12 707.28 Tm (" CX0711 )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 75.6 680.16 Tm (73.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 90.522 680.16 Tm ( Instead)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 130.8 679.92 Tm (, Rambus merely stated vaguely that unspecified patents might cover undi\ sclosed )Tj 12.48 0 0 12.48 75.36 651.84 Tm (aspects ofSynclink. RX-)Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 198 651.36 Tm (0663 at 2. Thus)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 275.28 651.12 Tm (, Hyundai had no opportunty to assess the veracity and )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 75.36 623.28 Tm (strength of Ram bus )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 172.8 622.8 Tm (s claim)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 207.36 622.8 Tm (, to avoid Rambus patents by proposing specific alternatives within )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 75.36 594.72 Tm (SyncLink)Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 121.2 594.48 Tm (, or to negotiate with alternatives in mind. )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 327.12 594 Tm (Many companies thought the changes from )Tj 13.66 0 0 13.66 74.64 566.4 Tm (Ramink to )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 135.36 565.92 Tm (SyncLink \(shifting from a fully to a partially multiplexed bus architec\ ture\) would be )Tj -5.07 -2.334 Td (sufficient to avoid Rambus)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.51 0 0 10.51 204.96 537.6 Tm (' s patents. )Tj 11.32 0 0 11.32 258.72 537.36 Tm (CCFF 1571. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 323.52 537.12 Tm (Hyudai used )Tj 12.07 0 0 12.07 392.64 536.88 Tm (the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.15 0 0 14.15 410.4 536.88 Tm (opportty of )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 481.2 536.88 Tm (the on\255)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 509.76 Tm (going )Tj 15.45 0 0 15.45 104.4 509.76 Tm (RDRA )Tj 12 0 0 12 151.2 509.52 Tm (negotiations to obtain ")Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 263.52 509.28 Tm (insurance)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 309.12 509.04 Tm (" in case it )Tj 17.04 0 0 17.04 363.36 508.8 Tm (tued )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 396.96 508.56 Tm (out that Rambus )Tj 12 0 0 12 479.28 508.56 Tm (s patents did )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.4 481.44 Tm (cover SyncLink. CCFF 1550-)Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 220.08 480.96 Tm (1552. Because ofthe vagueness ofthe infonnation and the )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 73.92 453.12 Tm (technological changes to SyncLink)Tj 12.77 0 0 12.77 241.44 452.64 Tm (, Hyudai never )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 320.16 452.16 Tm (thought the 2.5% rate would ever apply. )Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 74.16 424.56 Tm (CCFF 1552. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 109.68 396 Tm (Rambus also relies on its assertion that a hand-)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 334.32 395.28 Tm (picked selection of a limited number of )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 73.68 367.68 Tm (license agreements)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 164.4 367.44 Tm (, for an )Tj 12.89 0 0 12.89 201.12 367.2 Tm (unkown number )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 288.48 366.96 Tm (of unspecified patents relating to )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 448.08 366.48 Tm (unkown )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 73.2 339.12 Tm (technologies used in unidentified products)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 276.24 338.64 Tm (, cared royalty )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 354.48 338.16 Tm (rates in excess of 3.5%. RB 18-)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 508.32 337.92 Tm (20. )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 72.96 310.8 Tm (The Commission already rej ected this )Tj 15.3 0 0 15.3 257.52 310.32 Tm (arguent. )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 311.04 310.08 Tm (Decision 115 n. 624 \(comparng licenses for )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 72.96 282.48 Tm (different technologies ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.27 0 0 11.27 185.52 282 Tm (mixes ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 221.76 282 Tm (apples and oranges )Tj 12 0 0 12 332.88 281.52 Tm (Rambus fails to provide a basis for treating )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.75 0 0 10.75 72.48 254.16 Tm (the referenced licensing arangements as comparable to licenses for the t\ echnologies at issue in )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.62 0 0 7.62 72.48 225.6 Tm (the present case. )Tj 7.51 0 0 7.51 156.48 225.12 Tm (\). Similarly, the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 237.6 225.12 Tm (Commission already dismissed Rambus )Tj 16.348 -0.06 Td (s attempt to rely on a )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.24 197.28 Tm (vague)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 101.28 197.04 Tm (, abstract and unsupported passage in an IBM manual. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 52.8 -0.144 Td (Id. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 391.2 196.08 Tm (The record contains no )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 168.72 Tm (evidence)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 115.2 168.48 Tm (, however)Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 162.24 168.48 Tm (, that IBM' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 215.52 168.24 Tm (s rates reflected royalties for )Tj 13.37 0 0 13.37 353.76 167.76 Tm (DRA technologies)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 453.6 167.52 Tm (, or even that the )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 71.76 140.16 Tm (rates stated in IBM' )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 167.52 139.92 Tm (s policy ever actually applied )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 309.6 139.2 Tm (" and noting that)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 390.48 138.96 Tm (, unlike Rambus )Tj 16.4 0 0 16.4 479.52 138.96 Tm (DRA\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1129 0 obj<<>> endobj 1130 0 obj<> endobj 1131 0 obj<> endobj 1132 0 obj<> endobj 1141 0 obj<> endobj 1142 0 obj<> endobj 1143 0 obj[2064 0 R 2065 0 R 2066 0 R 2067 0 R 2068 0 R 2069 0 R 2070 0 R 2071 0 R 2072 0 R] endobj 1144 0 obj<> endobj 1145 0 obj<> endobj 1146 0 obj<> endobj 1147 0 obj<> endobj 1148 0 obj<> endobj 1149 0 obj<> endobj 1150 0 obj<> endobj 1151 0 obj<> endobj 1152 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.83 0 0 11.83 75.12 708 Tm (wide royalty rates)Tj 12.76 0 0 12.76 160.56 707.76 Tm (, ffM' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 192.48 707.52 Tm (s policy potentially applies only to the fraction of the price attrbutab\ le to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.14 0 0 12.14 75.12 679.44 Tm (the patented portions ofthe product.\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 110.88 622.56 Tm (For the forgoing reasons)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 228.24 621.84 Tm (, Complaint Counsel respectfully requests that the Commission )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 75.12 594 Tm (enter its proposed order. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 289.92 508.32 Tm (Respectfully submitted )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.16 452.16 Tm (Jeffrey Schmidt )Tj 12.54 0 0 12.54 73.44 438.24 Tm (Director )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 73.68 409.68 Tm (Daniel P. Ducore )Tj 12.19 0 0 12.19 72.96 395.52 Tm (Assistant Director)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 160.8 395.04 Tm (, Compliance Division )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 290.4 394.56 Tm (Counsel Supporting the Complaint )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 366.96 Tm (Rendell A. Davis)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 156.48 366.48 Tm (, Jr. )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 72.72 352.56 Tm (Attorney, Compliance Division )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 324.24 Tm (Bureau of Competition )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 310.08 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 73.2 295.68 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.08 0 0 11.08 131.04 295.68 Tm (, D.)Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 148.56 295.44 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.72 267.6 Tm (Dated: September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 179.52 267.36 Tm (2006 )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1153 0 obj<<>> endobj 1154 0 obj<> endobj 1155 0 obj<> endobj 1156 0 obj<> endobj 1157 0 obj<> endobj 1161 0 obj<> endobj 1162 0 obj[1/space] endobj 1163 0 obj[600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600] endobj 1169 0 obj<> endobj 1170 0 obj<> endobj 1171 0 obj[2073 0 R 2074 0 R 2075 0 R 2076 0 R 2077 0 R 2077 0 R 2078 0 R 2079 0 R 2079 0 R 2080 0 R 2081 0 R 2082 0 R 2083 0 R 2084 0 R 2085 0 R 2086 0 R] endobj 1172 0 obj<> endobj 1173 0 obj<> endobj 1174 0 obj<> endobj 1175 0 obj<> endobj 1176 0 obj<> endobj 1177 0 obj<> endobj 1178 0 obj<> endobj 1179 0 obj<> endobj 1180 0 obj<> endobj 1181 0 obj<> endobj 1182 0 obj<> endobj 1183 0 obj<> endobj 1184 0 obj<> endobj 1185 0 obj<> endobj 1186 0 obj<> endobj 1187 0 obj<> endobj 1188 0 obj<> endobj 1189 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.78 0 0 12.78 227.52 706.8 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11 0 0 11 113.52 679.2 Tm (, Beverly A. Dodson)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 211.2 678.48 Tm (, hereby certify that on September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 393.12 677.76 Tm (2006)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 417.36 677.76 Tm (, I caused a copy ofthe )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 73.68 664.8 Tm (attached )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 119.52 664.8 Tm (Complaint Counsel' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 215.28 664.32 Tm (s Reply Brief On Remedy, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 341.28 663.6 Tm (to be served upon the following persons: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 73.68 622.08 Tm (by hand delivery to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.29 0 0 9.29 73.44 593.76 Tm (The Commissioners\001)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 85.44 579.36 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 94.9992 579.36 Tm ( 鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.29 0 0 11.29 73.44 565.2 Tm (Office of the Secretar, Room H-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 233.28 564.48 Tm (135 )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 551.04 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 73.2 536.88 Tm (600 Pennsylvania Ave.)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 182.88 536.4 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.96 522.72 Tm (Washington)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.49 0 0 10.49 130.32 522.48 Tm (, D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 147.84 522.48 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.99 0 0 10.99 72.96 494.4 Tm (by electronic transmission and courier to: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.48 466.08 Tm (A.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 84.0079 466.08 Tm ( Douglas Melamed)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 174.72 465.6 Tm (, Esq. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 72.72 451.92 Tm (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 73.68 437.76 Tm (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.25 0 0 11.25 202.8 437.28 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 423.6 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 130.08 423.36 Tm (, DC 20006 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.24 395.28 Tm (and by electronic transmission and overnight )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 291.84 394.32 Tm (courier to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.56 0 0 8.56 72.48 366.96 Tm (Steven M. Perr, Esq.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72 353.04 Tm (Munger)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 109.92 352.8 Tm (, Tolles & Olson LLP )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 72 338.64 Tm (355 South Grand Avenue )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 92.4 324.72 Tm (Floor )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 71.52 310.56 Tm (Los Angeles)Tj 11.54 0 0 11.54 131.28 310.32 Tm (, CA 90071 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 71.76 282 Tm (Counsel for Rambus )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 171.36 281.76 Tm (Incorporated )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1190 0 obj<<>> endobj 1191 0 obj<> endobj 1192 0 obj<> endobj 1193 0 obj<> endobj 1194 0 obj<> endobj 1195 0 obj<> endobj 1196 0 obj<> endobj 1197 0 obj<> endobj 1198 0 obj<> endobj 1199 0 obj<> endobj 1200 0 obj<> endobj 1201 0 obj<> endobj 1202 0 obj<> endobj 1203 0 obj<> endobj 1204 0 obj<> endobj 1205 0 obj<> endobj 1206 0 obj<> endobj 1207 0 obj<> endobj 1208 0 obj<> endobj 1209 0 obj<> endobj 1210 0 obj<> endobj 1211 0 obj<> endobj 1212 0 obj<> endobj 1213 0 obj<> endobj 1214 0 obj<> endobj 1215 0 obj<> endobj 1216 0 obj<> endobj 1217 0 obj<> endobj 1218 0 obj<> endobj 1219 0 obj<> endobj 1220 0 obj<> endobj 1221 0 obj<> endobj 1222 0 obj<> endobj 1223 0 obj<> endobj 1224 0 obj<> endobj 1225 0 obj<> endobj 1226 0 obj<> endobj 1227 0 obj<> endobj 1228 0 obj<> endobj 1229 0 obj<> endobj 1230 0 obj<> endobj 1231 0 obj<> endobj 1232 0 obj<> endobj 1233 0 obj<> endobj 1234 0 obj<> endobj 1235 0 obj<> endobj 1236 0 obj<> endobj 1237 0 obj<> endobj 1238 0 obj<> endobj 1239 0 obj<> endobj 1240 0 obj<> endobj 1241 0 obj<> endobj 1242 0 obj<> endobj 1243 0 obj<> endobj 1244 0 obj<> endobj 1245 0 obj<> endobj 1246 0 obj<> endobj 1247 0 obj<> endobj 1248 0 obj<> endobj 1249 0 obj<> endobj 1250 0 obj<> endobj 1251 0 obj<> endobj 1252 0 obj<> endobj 1253 0 obj<> endobj 1254 0 obj<> endobj 1255 0 obj<> endobj 1256 0 obj<> endobj 1257 0 obj<> endobj 1258 0 obj<> endobj 1259 0 obj<> endobj 1260 0 obj<> endobj 1261 0 obj<> endobj 1262 0 obj<> endobj 1263 0 obj<> endobj 1264 0 obj<> endobj 1265 0 obj<> endobj 1266 0 obj<> endobj 1267 0 obj<> endobj 1268 0 obj<> endobj 1269 0 obj<> endobj 1270 0 obj<> endobj 1271 0 obj<> endobj 1272 0 obj<> endobj 1273 0 obj<> endobj 1274 0 obj<> endobj 1275 0 obj<> endobj 1276 0 obj<> endobj 1277 0 obj<> endobj 1278 0 obj<> endobj 1279 0 obj<> endobj 1280 0 obj<> endobj 1281 0 obj<> endobj 1282 0 obj<> endobj 1283 0 obj<> endobj 1284 0 obj<> endobj 1285 0 obj<> endobj 1286 0 obj<> endobj 1287 0 obj<> endobj 1288 0 obj<> endobj 1289 0 obj<> endobj 1290 0 obj<> endobj 1291 0 obj<> endobj 1292 0 obj<> endobj 1293 0 obj<> endobj 1294 0 obj<> endobj 1295 0 obj<> endobj 1296 0 obj<> endobj 1297 0 obj<> endobj 1298 0 obj<> endobj 1299 0 obj<> endobj 1300 0 obj<> endobj 1301 0 obj<> endobj 1302 0 obj<> endobj 1303 0 obj<> endobj 1304 0 obj<> endobj 1305 0 obj<> endobj 1306 0 obj<> endobj 1307 0 obj<> endobj 1308 0 obj<> endobj 1309 0 obj<> endobj 1310 0 obj<> endobj 1311 0 obj<> endobj 1312 0 obj<> endobj 1313 0 obj<> endobj 1314 0 obj<> endobj 1315 0 obj<> endobj 1316 0 obj<> endobj 1317 0 obj<> endobj 1318 0 obj<> endobj 1319 0 obj<> endobj 1320 0 obj<> endobj 1321 0 obj<> endobj 1322 0 obj<> endobj 1323 0 obj<> endobj 1324 0 obj<> endobj 1325 0 obj<> endobj 1326 0 obj<> endobj 1327 0 obj<> endobj 1328 0 obj<> endobj 1329 0 obj<> endobj 1330 0 obj<> endobj 1331 0 obj<> endobj 1332 0 obj<> endobj 1333 0 obj<> endobj 1334 0 obj<> endobj 1335 0 obj<> endobj 1336 0 obj<> endobj 1337 0 obj<> endobj 1338 0 obj<> endobj 1339 0 obj<> endobj 1340 0 obj<> endobj 1341 0 obj<> endobj 1342 0 obj<> endobj 1343 0 obj<> endobj 1344 0 obj<> endobj 1345 0 obj<> endobj 1346 0 obj<> endobj 1347 0 obj<> endobj 1348 0 obj<> endobj 1349 0 obj<> endobj 1350 0 obj<> endobj 1351 0 obj<> endobj 1352 0 obj<> endobj 1353 0 obj<> endobj 1354 0 obj<> endobj 1355 0 obj<> endobj 1356 0 obj<> endobj 1357 0 obj<> endobj 1358 0 obj<> endobj 1359 0 obj<> endobj 1360 0 obj<> endobj 1361 0 obj<> endobj 1362 0 obj<> endobj 1363 0 obj<> endobj 1364 0 obj<> endobj 1365 0 obj<> endobj 1366 0 obj<> endobj 1367 0 obj<> endobj 1368 0 obj<> endobj 1369 0 obj<> endobj 1370 0 obj<> endobj 1371 0 obj<> endobj 1372 0 obj<> endobj 1373 0 obj<> endobj 1374 0 obj<> endobj 1375 0 obj<> endobj 1376 0 obj<> endobj 1377 0 obj<> endobj 1378 0 obj<> endobj 1379 0 obj<> endobj 1380 0 obj<> endobj 1381 0 obj<> endobj 1382 0 obj<> endobj 1383 0 obj<> endobj 1384 0 obj<> endobj 1385 0 obj<> endobj 1386 0 obj<> endobj 1387 0 obj<> endobj 1388 0 obj<> endobj 1389 0 obj<> endobj 1390 0 obj<> endobj 1391 0 obj<> endobj 1392 0 obj<> endobj 1393 0 obj<> endobj 1394 0 obj<> endobj 1395 0 obj<> endobj 1396 0 obj<> endobj 1397 0 obj<> endobj 1398 0 obj<> endobj 1399 0 obj<> endobj 1400 0 obj<> endobj 1401 0 obj<> endobj 1402 0 obj<> endobj 1403 0 obj<> endobj 1404 0 obj<> endobj 1405 0 obj<> endobj 1406 0 obj<> endobj 1407 0 obj<> endobj 1408 0 obj<> endobj 1409 0 obj<> endobj 1410 0 obj<> endobj 1411 0 obj<> endobj 1412 0 obj<> endobj 1413 0 obj<> endobj 1414 0 obj<> endobj 1415 0 obj<> endobj 1416 0 obj<> endobj 1417 0 obj<> endobj 1418 0 obj<> endobj 1419 0 obj<> endobj 1420 0 obj<> endobj 1421 0 obj<> endobj 1422 0 obj<> endobj 1423 0 obj<> endobj 1424 0 obj<> endobj 1425 0 obj<> endobj 1426 0 obj<> endobj 1427 0 obj<> endobj 1428 0 obj<> endobj 1429 0 obj<> endobj 1430 0 obj<> endobj 1431 0 obj<> endobj 1432 0 obj<> endobj 1433 0 obj<> endobj 1434 0 obj<> endobj 1435 0 obj<> endobj 1436 0 obj<> endobj 1437 0 obj<> endobj 1438 0 obj<> endobj 1439 0 obj<> endobj 1440 0 obj<> endobj 1441 0 obj<> endobj 1442 0 obj<> endobj 1443 0 obj<> endobj 1444 0 obj<> endobj 1445 0 obj<> endobj 1446 0 obj<> endobj 1447 0 obj<> endobj 1448 0 obj<> endobj 1449 0 obj<> endobj 1450 0 obj<> endobj 1451 0 obj<> endobj 1452 0 obj<> endobj 1453 0 obj<> endobj 1454 0 obj<> endobj 1455 0 obj<> endobj 1456 0 obj<> endobj 1457 0 obj<> endobj 1458 0 obj<> endobj 1459 0 obj<> endobj 1460 0 obj<> endobj 1461 0 obj<> endobj 1462 0 obj<> endobj 1463 0 obj<> endobj 1464 0 obj<> endobj 1465 0 obj<> endobj 1466 0 obj<> endobj 1467 0 obj<> endobj 1468 0 obj<> endobj 1469 0 obj<> endobj 1470 0 obj<> endobj 1471 0 obj<> endobj 1472 0 obj<> endobj 1473 0 obj<> endobj 1474 0 obj<> endobj 1475 0 obj<> endobj 1476 0 obj<> endobj 1477 0 obj<> endobj 1478 0 obj<> endobj 1479 0 obj<> endobj 1480 0 obj<> endobj 1481 0 obj<> endobj 1482 0 obj<> endobj 1483 0 obj<> endobj 1484 0 obj<> endobj 1485 0 obj<> endobj 1486 0 obj<> endobj 1487 0 obj<> endobj 1488 0 obj<> endobj 1489 0 obj<> endobj 1490 0 obj<> endobj 1491 0 obj<> endobj 1492 0 obj<> endobj 1493 0 obj<> endobj 1494 0 obj<> endobj 1495 0 obj<> endobj 1496 0 obj<> endobj 1497 0 obj<> endobj 1498 0 obj<> endobj 1499 0 obj<> endobj 1500 0 obj<> endobj 1501 0 obj<> endobj 1502 0 obj<> endobj 1503 0 obj<> endobj 1504 0 obj<> endobj 1505 0 obj<> endobj 1506 0 obj<> endobj 1507 0 obj<> endobj 1508 0 obj<> endobj 1509 0 obj<> endobj 1510 0 obj<> endobj 1511 0 obj<> endobj 1512 0 obj<> endobj 1513 0 obj<> endobj 1514 0 obj<> endobj 1515 0 obj<> endobj 1516 0 obj<> endobj 1517 0 obj<> endobj 1518 0 obj<> endobj 1519 0 obj<> endobj 1520 0 obj<> endobj 1521 0 obj<> endobj 1522 0 obj<> endobj 1523 0 obj<> endobj 1524 0 obj<> endobj 1525 0 obj<> endobj 1526 0 obj<> endobj 1527 0 obj<> endobj 1528 0 obj<> endobj 1529 0 obj<> endobj 1530 0 obj<> endobj 1531 0 obj<> endobj 1532 0 obj<> endobj 1533 0 obj<> endobj 1534 0 obj<> endobj 1535 0 obj<> endobj 1536 0 obj<> endobj 1537 0 obj<<>> endobj 1538 0 obj<> endobj 1539 0 obj<> endobj 1540 0 obj<> endobj 1541 0 obj<> endobj 1542 0 obj<> endobj 1543 0 obj<> endobj 1544 0 obj<> endobj 1545 0 obj<> endobj 1546 0 obj<> endobj 1547 0 obj<> endobj 1548 0 obj<> endobj 1549 0 obj<> endobj 1550 0 obj<> endobj 1551 0 obj<> endobj 1552 0 obj<> endobj 1553 0 obj<> endobj 1554 0 obj<> endobj 1555 0 obj<> endobj 1556 0 obj<> endobj 1557 0 obj<> endobj 1558 0 obj<> endobj 1559 0 obj<> endobj 1560 0 obj<> endobj 1561 0 obj<> endobj 1562 0 obj<> endobj 1563 0 obj<> endobj 1564 0 obj<> endobj 1565 0 obj<> endobj 1566 0 obj<> endobj 1567 0 obj<> endobj 1568 0 obj<> endobj 1569 0 obj<> endobj 1570 0 obj<> endobj 1571 0 obj<> endobj 1572 0 obj<> endobj 1573 0 obj<> endobj 1574 0 obj<> endobj 1575 0 obj<> endobj 1576 0 obj<> endobj 1577 0 obj<> endobj 1578 0 obj<> endobj 1579 0 obj<> endobj 1580 0 obj<> endobj 1581 0 obj<> endobj 1582 0 obj<> endobj 1583 0 obj<> endobj 1584 0 obj<> endobj 1585 0 obj<> endobj 1586 0 obj<> endobj 1587 0 obj<> endobj 1588 0 obj<> endobj 1589 0 obj<> endobj 1590 0 obj<> endobj 1591 0 obj<> endobj 1592 0 obj<> endobj 1593 0 obj<> endobj 1594 0 obj<> endobj 1595 0 obj<> endobj 1596 0 obj<> endobj 1597 0 obj<> endobj 1598 0 obj<> endobj 1599 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 9.5 0 0 9.5 366.48 792 Tm (........... ...... .... ...... )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 203.04 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 232.8 732.96 Tm (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 74.64 705.36 Tm (CASES )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 677.52 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 127.92 677.52 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 274.8 677.28 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 305.52 677.28 Tm (509 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 338.4 677.04 Tm (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 649.68 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 110.4 649.68 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 186 649.68 Tm (352 U.)Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 218.64 649.44 Tm (S. 419 \(1957\) ........................................................\ ........................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 621.84 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.8 0 0 8.8 110.4 622.08 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 181.44 621.84 Tm (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ..................................................\ .............................. 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 594.24 Tm (International Salt Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 21.744 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.06 0 0 8.06 194.64 594 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 264 594 Tm (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1\ )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 523.44 594 Tm (, 15\001)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 566.64 Tm (In re Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.07 0 0 10.07 209.28 566.4 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 249.12 566.16 Tm (C. 616 \(1996\)........................)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 388.56 566.16 Tm (:.............................................. 7\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.91 0 0 10.91 73.2 539.04 Tm (In re Ekco Products Co. )Tj 10.22 0 0 10.22 196.32 538.8 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.56 0 0 12.56 484.56 538.8 Tm (FTC\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 230.88 538.56 Tm (C.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 236.88 538.56 Tm ( 1163 \(1964\), )Tj 14.544 0 Td (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 32.832 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 127.92 525.12 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.39 0 0 12.39 158.16 525.12 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 272.4 524.88 Tm (........................................................................\ .............. 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.96 497.52 Tm (In re Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 226.08 497.52 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 266.4 497.04 Tm (C. 263 \(1986\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.42 0 0 13.42 339.12 497.28 Tm (affd)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 360 497.04 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.96 483.84 Tm (FTC, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.33 0 0 10.33 156 483.6 Tm (849 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 186.24 483.84 Tm (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) .............................................\ ............................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 456.24 Tm (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.224 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 166.08 456 Tm (Carmichael )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 456 Tm (526 U.)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 261.36 455.76 Tm (S. 137 \(1999\) ........................................................\ .. 12)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 523.2 455.76 Tm (, 13\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 428.4 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.688 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 156.96 428.4 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 241.2 428.16 Tm (373 F.)Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 271.92 428.16 Tm (3d 1199 \(D.)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 329.28 427.92 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 400.56 Tm (New York )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.128 0.048 Td (v. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 134.16 400.8 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 218.16 400.56 Tm (224 F.)Tj 10.7 0 0 10.7 249.12 400.32 Tm (Supp.2d 76 \(D. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.84 400.08 Tm (C. 2002\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 381.6 400.32 Tm (affd sub nom. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.72 386.88 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.736 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 210.96 386.64 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 295.2 386.4 Tm (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 383.28 386.16 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 358.8 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 152.16 358.8 Tm (General Electric )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 238.8 358.8 Tm (115 F.)Tj 10.66 0 0 10.66 269.04 358.56 Tm (Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 11.02 0 0 11.02 347.28 358.56 Tm (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 331.2 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.112 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 204.24 331.2 Tm (253 F.)Tj 10.85 0 0 10.85 234.96 331.2 Tm (3d 34 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 280.8 330.96 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\) .........................................................\ .. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 303.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.36 0 0 11.36 150.72 303.6 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 226.56 303.6 Tm (332 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 259.44 303.36 Tm (S. 319 \(1947\) ........................................................\ ..... 6)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 522.72 303.36 Tm (, 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 276 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.37 0 0 8.37 150.96 276 Tm (Singer Mfg. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 233.76 276 Tm (231 F. )Tj 10.44 0 0 10.44 264.96 275.76 Tm (Supp. 240 \(S. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 353.04 275.76 Tm (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 248.16 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.2 0 0 14.2 152.16 248.16 Tm (u.s. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 175.44 248.16 Tm (Gypsum Co. )Tj 10.84 0 0 10.84 240 248.16 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 273.12 247.92 Tm (S. 76 \(1950\) .........................................................\ ...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.8 0 0 12.8 72.72 220.8 Tm (OTHER AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 192.96 Tm (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 257.28 192.72 Tm (Antitrust Law \(2005\),\001)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 126.24 179.28 Tm (LEXIS)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 160.08 179.04 Tm (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .............................................\ ............................. 3 )Tj 10.8 0 0 10.8 528.48 178.56 Tm (, 5\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72 151.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 213.84 151.2 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 443.52 150.72 Tm (Competition\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 126.48 137.52 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 253.92 137.04 Tm (" \(October 2003\), )Tj 7.93 0 0 7.93 341.76 137.04 Tm (available at\001)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.93 0 0 13.93 126 123.6 Tm (http://ww.)Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 184.08 123.36 Tm (ftc.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.44 0 0 8.44 199.44 123.36 Tm (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 448.32 123.12 Tm (..,................ ...... 16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 71.76 95.76 Tm (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed\ Final\001)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 125.76 81.84 Tm (Judgment )Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 306.96 81.6 Tm (\(D. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 334.08 81.36 Tm (C. 2002)Tj 12 0 0 12 372.24 81.36 Tm (, Civil Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 479.04 81.6 Tm (1232\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 179.52 81.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.47 0 0 10.47 125.52 68.16 Tm (Feb. 27)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 162 68.16 Tm (, 2002\) ...............................................................\ .............................................. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.36 0 0 8.36 298.32 17.76 Tm (-11\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1600 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 9.5 0 0 9.5 366.48 792 Tm (........... ...... .... ...... )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 203.04 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 232.8 732.96 Tm (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 74.64 705.36 Tm (CASES )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 677.52 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 127.92 677.52 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 274.8 677.28 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 305.52 677.28 Tm (509 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 338.4 677.04 Tm (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 649.68 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 110.4 649.68 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 186 649.68 Tm (352 U.)Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 218.64 649.44 Tm (S. 419 \(1957\) ........................................................\ ........................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 621.84 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.8 0 0 8.8 110.4 622.08 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 181.44 621.84 Tm (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ..................................................\ .............................. 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 594.24 Tm (International Salt Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 21.744 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.06 0 0 8.06 194.64 594 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 264 594 Tm (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1\ )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 523.44 594 Tm (, 15\001)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 566.64 Tm (In re Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.07 0 0 10.07 209.28 566.4 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 249.12 566.16 Tm (C. 616 \(1996\)........................)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 388.56 566.16 Tm (:.............................................. 7\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.91 0 0 10.91 73.2 539.04 Tm (In re Ekco Products Co. )Tj 10.22 0 0 10.22 196.32 538.8 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.56 0 0 12.56 484.56 538.8 Tm (FTC\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 230.88 538.56 Tm (C.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 236.88 538.56 Tm ( 1163 \(1964\), )Tj 14.544 0 Td (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 32.832 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 127.92 525.12 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.39 0 0 12.39 158.16 525.12 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 272.4 524.88 Tm (........................................................................\ .............. 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.96 497.52 Tm (In re Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 226.08 497.52 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 266.4 497.04 Tm (C. 263 \(1986\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.42 0 0 13.42 339.12 497.28 Tm (affd)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 360 497.04 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.96 483.84 Tm (FTC, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.33 0 0 10.33 156 483.6 Tm (849 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 186.24 483.84 Tm (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) .............................................\ ............................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 456.24 Tm (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.224 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 166.08 456 Tm (Carmichael )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 456 Tm (526 U.)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 261.36 455.76 Tm (S. 137 \(1999\) ........................................................\ .. 12)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 523.2 455.76 Tm (, 13\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 428.4 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.688 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 156.96 428.4 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 241.2 428.16 Tm (373 F.)Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 271.92 428.16 Tm (3d 1199 \(D.)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 329.28 427.92 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 400.56 Tm (New York )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.128 0.048 Td (v. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 134.16 400.8 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 218.16 400.56 Tm (224 F.)Tj 10.7 0 0 10.7 249.12 400.32 Tm (Supp.2d 76 \(D. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.84 400.08 Tm (C. 2002\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 381.6 400.32 Tm (affd sub nom. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.72 386.88 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.736 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 210.96 386.64 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 295.2 386.4 Tm (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 383.28 386.16 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 358.8 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 152.16 358.8 Tm (General Electric )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 238.8 358.8 Tm (115 F.)Tj 10.66 0 0 10.66 269.04 358.56 Tm (Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 11.02 0 0 11.02 347.28 358.56 Tm (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 331.2 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.112 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 204.24 331.2 Tm (253 F.)Tj 10.85 0 0 10.85 234.96 331.2 Tm (3d 34 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 280.8 330.96 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\) .........................................................\ .. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 303.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.36 0 0 11.36 150.72 303.6 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 226.56 303.6 Tm (332 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 259.44 303.36 Tm (S. 319 \(1947\) ........................................................\ ..... 6)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 522.72 303.36 Tm (, 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 276 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.37 0 0 8.37 150.96 276 Tm (Singer Mfg. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 233.76 276 Tm (231 F. )Tj 10.44 0 0 10.44 264.96 275.76 Tm (Supp. 240 \(S. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 353.04 275.76 Tm (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 248.16 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.2 0 0 14.2 152.16 248.16 Tm (u.s. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 175.44 248.16 Tm (Gypsum Co. )Tj 10.84 0 0 10.84 240 248.16 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 273.12 247.92 Tm (S. 76 \(1950\) .........................................................\ ...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.8 0 0 12.8 72.72 220.8 Tm (OTHER AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 192.96 Tm (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 257.28 192.72 Tm (Antitrust Law \(2005\),\001)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 126.24 179.28 Tm (LEXIS)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 160.08 179.04 Tm (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .............................................\ ............................. 3 )Tj 10.8 0 0 10.8 528.48 178.56 Tm (, 5\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72 151.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 213.84 151.2 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 443.52 150.72 Tm (Competition\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 126.48 137.52 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 253.92 137.04 Tm (" \(October 2003\), )Tj 7.93 0 0 7.93 341.76 137.04 Tm (available at\001)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.93 0 0 13.93 126 123.6 Tm (http://ww.)Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 184.08 123.36 Tm (ftc.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.44 0 0 8.44 199.44 123.36 Tm (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 448.32 123.12 Tm (..,................ ...... 16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 71.76 95.76 Tm (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed\ Final\001)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 125.76 81.84 Tm (Judgment )Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 306.96 81.6 Tm (\(D. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 334.08 81.36 Tm (C. 2002)Tj 12 0 0 12 372.24 81.36 Tm (, Civil Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 479.04 81.6 Tm (1232\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 179.52 81.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.47 0 0 10.47 125.52 68.16 Tm (Feb. 27)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 162 68.16 Tm (, 2002\) ...............................................................\ .............................................. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.36 0 0 8.36 298.32 17.76 Tm (-11\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1601 0 obj<> endobj 1602 0 obj<> endobj 1603 0 obj<> endobj 1604 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 9.5 0 0 9.5 366.48 792 Tm (........... ...... .... ...... )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 203.04 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 232.8 732.96 Tm (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 74.64 705.36 Tm (CASES )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 677.52 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 127.92 677.52 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 274.8 677.28 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 305.52 677.28 Tm (509 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 338.4 677.04 Tm (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 649.68 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 110.4 649.68 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 186 649.68 Tm (352 U.)Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 218.64 649.44 Tm (S. 419 \(1957\) ........................................................\ ........................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 621.84 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.8 0 0 8.8 110.4 622.08 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 181.44 621.84 Tm (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ..................................................\ .............................. 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 594.24 Tm (International Salt Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 21.744 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.06 0 0 8.06 194.64 594 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 264 594 Tm (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1\ )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 523.44 594 Tm (, 15\001)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 566.64 Tm (In re Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.07 0 0 10.07 209.28 566.4 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 249.12 566.16 Tm (C. 616 \(1996\)........................)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 388.56 566.16 Tm (:.............................................. 7\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.91 0 0 10.91 73.2 539.04 Tm (In re Ekco Products Co. )Tj 10.22 0 0 10.22 196.32 538.8 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.56 0 0 12.56 484.56 538.8 Tm (FTC\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 230.88 538.56 Tm (C.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 236.88 538.56 Tm ( 1163 \(1964\), )Tj 14.544 0 Td (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 32.832 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 127.92 525.12 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.39 0 0 12.39 158.16 525.12 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 272.4 524.88 Tm (........................................................................\ .............. 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.96 497.52 Tm (In re Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 226.08 497.52 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 266.4 497.04 Tm (C. 263 \(1986\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.42 0 0 13.42 339.12 497.28 Tm (affd)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 360 497.04 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.96 483.84 Tm (FTC, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.33 0 0 10.33 156 483.6 Tm (849 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 186.24 483.84 Tm (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) .............................................\ ............................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 456.24 Tm (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.224 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 166.08 456 Tm (Carmichael )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 456 Tm (526 U.)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 261.36 455.76 Tm (S. 137 \(1999\) ........................................................\ .. 12)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 523.2 455.76 Tm (, 13\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 428.4 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.688 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 156.96 428.4 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 241.2 428.16 Tm (373 F.)Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 271.92 428.16 Tm (3d 1199 \(D.)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 329.28 427.92 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 400.56 Tm (New York )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.128 0.048 Td (v. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 134.16 400.8 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 218.16 400.56 Tm (224 F.)Tj 10.7 0 0 10.7 249.12 400.32 Tm (Supp.2d 76 \(D. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.84 400.08 Tm (C. 2002\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 381.6 400.32 Tm (affd sub nom. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.72 386.88 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.736 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 210.96 386.64 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 295.2 386.4 Tm (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 383.28 386.16 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 358.8 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 152.16 358.8 Tm (General Electric )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 238.8 358.8 Tm (115 F.)Tj 10.66 0 0 10.66 269.04 358.56 Tm (Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 11.02 0 0 11.02 347.28 358.56 Tm (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 331.2 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.112 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 204.24 331.2 Tm (253 F.)Tj 10.85 0 0 10.85 234.96 331.2 Tm (3d 34 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 280.8 330.96 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\) .........................................................\ .. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 303.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.36 0 0 11.36 150.72 303.6 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 226.56 303.6 Tm (332 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 259.44 303.36 Tm (S. 319 \(1947\) ........................................................\ ..... 6)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 522.72 303.36 Tm (, 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 276 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.37 0 0 8.37 150.96 276 Tm (Singer Mfg. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 233.76 276 Tm (231 F. )Tj 10.44 0 0 10.44 264.96 275.76 Tm (Supp. 240 \(S. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 353.04 275.76 Tm (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 248.16 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.2 0 0 14.2 152.16 248.16 Tm (u.s. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 175.44 248.16 Tm (Gypsum Co. )Tj 10.84 0 0 10.84 240 248.16 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 273.12 247.92 Tm (S. 76 \(1950\) .........................................................\ ...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.8 0 0 12.8 72.72 220.8 Tm (OTHER AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 192.96 Tm (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 257.28 192.72 Tm (Antitrust Law \(2005\),\001)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 126.24 179.28 Tm (LEXIS)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 160.08 179.04 Tm (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .............................................\ ............................. 3 )Tj 10.8 0 0 10.8 528.48 178.56 Tm (, 5\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72 151.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 213.84 151.2 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 443.52 150.72 Tm (Competition\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 126.48 137.52 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 253.92 137.04 Tm (" \(October 2003\), )Tj 7.93 0 0 7.93 341.76 137.04 Tm (available at\001)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.93 0 0 13.93 126 123.6 Tm (http://ww.)Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 184.08 123.36 Tm (ftc.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.44 0 0 8.44 199.44 123.36 Tm (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 448.32 123.12 Tm (..,................ ...... 16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 71.76 95.76 Tm (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed\ Final\001)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 125.76 81.84 Tm (Judgment )Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 306.96 81.6 Tm (\(D. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 334.08 81.36 Tm (C. 2002)Tj 12 0 0 12 372.24 81.36 Tm (, Civil Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 479.04 81.6 Tm (1232\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 179.52 81.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.47 0 0 10.47 125.52 68.16 Tm (Feb. 27)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 162 68.16 Tm (, 2002\) ...............................................................\ .............................................. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.36 0 0 8.36 298.32 17.76 Tm (-11\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1605 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 9.5 0 0 9.5 366.48 792 Tm (........... ...... .... ...... )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 203.04 792 Tm (, "\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.71 0 0 12.71 232.8 732.96 Tm (TABLE OF AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 74.64 705.36 Tm (CASES )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 677.52 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.24 0 0 12.24 127.92 677.52 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 274.8 677.28 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 305.52 677.28 Tm (509 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 338.4 677.04 Tm (S. 579 \(1993\)........................................ 12\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 649.68 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 110.4 649.68 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 186 649.68 Tm (352 U.)Tj 12.16 0 0 12.16 218.64 649.44 Tm (S. 419 \(1957\) ........................................................\ ........................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 621.84 Tm (FTC )Tj 5.184 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.8 0 0 8.8 110.4 622.08 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 181.44 621.84 Tm (343 U.S. 470 \(1952\) ..................................................\ .............................. 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.44 594.24 Tm (International Salt Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 21.744 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.06 0 0 8.06 194.64 594 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 264 594 Tm (332 U.S. 392 \(1947\) ................................................ 1\ )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 523.44 594 Tm (, 15\001)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 566.64 Tm (In re Dell Computer Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.07 0 0 10.07 209.28 566.4 Tm (121 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 249.12 566.16 Tm (C. 616 \(1996\)........................)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 388.56 566.16 Tm (:.............................................. 7\001)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.91 0 0 10.91 73.2 539.04 Tm (In re Ekco Products Co. )Tj 10.22 0 0 10.22 196.32 538.8 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.56 0 0 12.56 484.56 538.8 Tm (FTC\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 230.88 538.56 Tm (C.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 236.88 538.56 Tm ( 1163 \(1964\), )Tj 14.544 0 Td (affd sub nom. Ecko Products Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 32.832 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 127.92 525.12 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.39 0 0 12.39 158.16 525.12 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\) )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 272.4 524.88 Tm (........................................................................\ .............. 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.96 497.52 Tm (In re Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 226.08 497.52 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 266.4 497.04 Tm (C. 263 \(1986\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.42 0 0 13.42 339.12 497.28 Tm (affd)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 360 497.04 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.96 483.84 Tm (FTC, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.33 0 0 10.33 156 483.6 Tm (849 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 186.24 483.84 Tm (2d 1354 \(11th Cir. 1988\) .............................................\ ............................ 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 456.24 Tm (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.224 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 166.08 456 Tm (Carmichael )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 228.48 456 Tm (526 U.)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 261.36 455.76 Tm (S. 137 \(1999\) ........................................................\ .. 12)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 523.2 455.76 Tm (, 13\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 428.4 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.688 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 156.96 428.4 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 241.2 428.16 Tm (373 F.)Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 271.92 428.16 Tm (3d 1199 \(D.)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 329.28 427.92 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) ................................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.96 400.56 Tm (New York )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.128 0.048 Td (v. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 134.16 400.8 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 218.16 400.56 Tm (224 F.)Tj 10.7 0 0 10.7 249.12 400.32 Tm (Supp.2d 76 \(D. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 333.84 400.08 Tm (C. 2002\), )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 381.6 400.32 Tm (affd sub nom. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 126.72 386.88 Tm (Massachusetts )Tj 14.736 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.51 0 0 8.51 210.96 386.64 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 295.2 386.4 Tm (373 F.3d 1199 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 383.28 386.16 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\) .......................... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.16 358.8 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.18 0 0 12.18 152.16 358.8 Tm (General Electric )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.16 0 0 10.16 238.8 358.8 Tm (115 F.)Tj 10.66 0 0 10.66 269.04 358.56 Tm (Supp. 835 \(D. )Tj 11.02 0 0 11.02 347.28 358.56 Tm (J. 1953\) .............................................. 6\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 331.2 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.112 0 Td (Microsoft, )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 204.24 331.2 Tm (253 F.)Tj 10.85 0 0 10.85 234.96 331.2 Tm (3d 34 \(D.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.32 0 0 12.32 280.8 330.96 Tm (C. Cir. 2001\) .........................................................\ .. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.92 303.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.36 0 0 11.36 150.72 303.6 Tm (National Lead )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 226.56 303.6 Tm (332 U.)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 259.44 303.36 Tm (S. 319 \(1947\) ........................................................\ ..... 6)Tj 11.2 0 0 11.2 522.72 303.36 Tm (, 15\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 276 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.37 0 0 8.37 150.96 276 Tm (Singer Mfg. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 233.76 276 Tm (231 F. )Tj 10.44 0 0 10.44 264.96 275.76 Tm (Supp. 240 \(S. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 353.04 275.76 Tm (Y. 1964\)............................................ 7\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 73.68 248.16 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 14.2 0 0 14.2 152.16 248.16 Tm (u.s. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.24 0 0 10.24 175.44 248.16 Tm (Gypsum Co. )Tj 10.84 0 0 10.84 240 248.16 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 273.12 247.92 Tm (S. 76 \(1950\) .........................................................\ ...... 2\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.8 0 0 12.8 72.72 220.8 Tm (OTHER AUTHORITIES\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72.24 192.96 Tm (Philip Areeda & Herbert Hovenkamp, \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 257.28 192.72 Tm (Antitrust Law \(2005\),\001)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 126.24 179.28 Tm (LEXIS)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 160.08 179.04 Tm (, Antitrust Law \(Areeda\) .............................................\ ............................. 3 )Tj 10.8 0 0 10.8 528.48 178.56 Tm (, 5\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 72 151.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 213.84 151.2 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 443.52 150.72 Tm (Competition\001)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 126.48 137.52 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 253.92 137.04 Tm (" \(October 2003\), )Tj 7.93 0 0 7.93 341.76 137.04 Tm (available at\001)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.93 0 0 13.93 126 123.6 Tm (http://ww.)Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 184.08 123.36 Tm (ftc.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.44 0 0 8.44 199.44 123.36 Tm (gov/os/2003/1 O/innovationrt.pdf )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 448.32 123.12 Tm (..,................ ...... 16\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 71.76 95.76 Tm (Response of the United States to Public Comments on the Revised Proposed\ Final\001)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 125.76 81.84 Tm (Judgment )Tj 11.03 0 0 11.03 306.96 81.6 Tm (\(D. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 334.08 81.36 Tm (C. 2002)Tj 12 0 0 12 372.24 81.36 Tm (, Civil Action No. 98-)Tj 11.16 0 0 11.16 479.04 81.6 Tm (1232\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 179.52 81.6 Tm (United States )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.248 0.048 Td (v. )Tj 2.16 -0.048 Td (Microsoft )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.47 0 0 10.47 125.52 68.16 Tm (Feb. 27)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 162 68.16 Tm (, 2002\) ...............................................................\ .............................................. 4\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 8.36 0 0 8.36 298.32 17.76 Tm (-11\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1606 0 obj<> endobj 1607 0 obj<> endobj 1608 0 obj<> endobj 1609 0 obj<> endobj 1610 0 obj<> endobj 1611 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 183.84 792 Tm (\); )Tj 11.76 0 Td (\), )Tj 14.4 0 Td (\), )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.7 0 0 12.7 111.6 679.68 Tm (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission )Tj 12.4 0 0 12.4 451.2 679.44 Tm (s Remedial )Tj 12.39 0 0 12.39 111.84 665.52 Tm (Powers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.79 0 0 12.79 147.6 636.96 Tm (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 147.36 622.56 Tm (Royalties To Restore Competition )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.36 594.48 Tm (Well-settled precedent confinns the Commission )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 350.88 594 Tm (s authority to ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.43 0 0 7.43 421.92 594 Tm (cure the il effects of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.88 566.16 Tm (ilegal conduct." )Tj 17.28 -0.048 Td (United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 239.76 565.68 Tm (u.s.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 257.2663 565.68 Tm ( Gypsum Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 328.08 565.68 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.17 0 0 10.17 360.96 565.44 Tm (S. 76)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 385.44 565.68 Tm (, 88 \(1950\); Complaint )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 75.12 537.6 Tm (Counsel' )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 118.8 537.84 Tm (s Brief \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 162.96 537.6 Tm (CCB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 192 537.6 Tm (\) 3-)Tj 12.62 0 0 12.62 208.8 537.6 Tm (4. Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 267.36 537.6 Tm (s contention that the Commission )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 432.48 537.36 Tm (s power is limited to )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 509.52 Tm (ordering a respondent to reftain from repeating unlawful conduct)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.58 0 0 10.58 387.12 509.04 Tm (, Respondent' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.72 0 0 12.72 453.84 509.04 Tm (s Brief\(")Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 497.52 509.04 Tm (RB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 518.64 509.04 Tm (\) 4\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 80.88 481.2 Tm (, flies in the face of relevant precedent. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.28 0 0 11.28 272.88 480.72 Tm (See, e. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 312.72 480.72 Tm (, Ekco Prods. Co. )Tj 10.32 0 0 10.32 403.92 480.72 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.86 0 0 8.86 438.96 480.72 Tm (C. 1163)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 477.36 480.96 Tm (, 1216 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.64 450.48 Tm (\(1964\), aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 129.6 452.88 Tm (d sub nom. Ecko Prods. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 27.264 -0.096 Td (v. )Tj 12.69 0 0 12.69 276.96 452.64 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 306 452.4 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 336.24 452.4 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.752 0 Td (FTC )Tj 5.136 0 Td (v. )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 486.48 452.16 Tm (National )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 73.68 424.32 Tm (Lead )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 104.88 424.32 Tm (352 U.)Tj 2.825 -0.021 Td (S. 419)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 168.24 424.32 Tm (, 430 \(1957\) \(Commission must assure that a violator )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 15.21 0 0 15.21 426.48 423.84 Tm (wil ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.84 424.08 Tm (relinquish the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.48 0 0 7.48 74.4 396 Tm (frits of his violation. )Tj 5 0 0 5 193.68 395.76 Tm (see also New York )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 296.4 395.52 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 380.4 395.52 Tm (224 F.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 411.36 395.28 Tm (Supp.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 438.96 395.52 Tm (2d 76)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 466.56 395.52 Tm (, 148 \(D. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.16 367.44 Tm (2002\) \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 114.96 367.44 Tm (equitable relief beyond a mere injunction against repetition )Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 400.32 366.96 Tm (ofthe act is )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 459.6 366.96 Tm (generally )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.21 0 0 11.21 74.16 338.88 Tm (appropriate. \(quoting Areeda & )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 230.64 338.64 Tm (HovenkampJ . . . \(TJhe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 344.64 338.4 Tm (Cour finds )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.4 0 0 8.4 401.76 338.4 Tm (unpersuasive Microsoft' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.85 0 0 14.85 73.92 310.56 Tm (arguent )Tj 12 0 0 12 122.16 310.56 Tm (that Plaintiffs are entitled to no more than a simple proscription again\ st the )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 484.8 310.08 Tm (conduct )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.68 282.24 Tm (found to violate the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.86 0 0 7.86 170.64 282 Tm (antitrst laws. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 252.72 282 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 269.52 281.76 Tm (d sub nom Massachusetts )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.104 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.59 0 0 8.59 405.6 281.76 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 490.56 281.76 Tm (373 F.3d )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 74.4 253.92 Tm (1199)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 97.92 253.92 Tm (, 1232 \(D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 146.64 253.68 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\). Applicable precedent requires that the Commission restor\ e )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 73.44 225.36 Tm (competition and deprive the wrongdoer of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.14 0 0 7.14 296.4 225.12 Tm (frits of its )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 352.08 224.88 Tm (anti competitive conduct. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.67 0 0 11.67 477.36 224.88 Tm (CCB 3\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 145.2 140.88 Tm (See also Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 9.99 0 0 9.99 314.88 140.64 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.61 0 0 11.61 354.72 140.4 Tm (C. 263)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 387.12 140.64 Tm (, 368 \(1986\) \(Commission )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 73.2 126.72 Tm (Section 5 consumer protection cease and desist order ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 6.76 0 0 6.76 335.28 126.48 Tm (resu1t\( edJ in a roll )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.73 0 0 11.73 424.56 126.24 Tm (back. . . of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.39 0 0 13.39 481.92 126.48 Tm (the anual )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.48 112.56 Tm (renewal fees on all of Orkin )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 209.28 112.32 Tm (s pre-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 236.88 112.32 Tm (1975 contracts. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 324.48 112.32 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 346.8 112.08 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.968 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.45 0 0 9.45 487.44 112.08 Tm (FTC, 849 )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.43 0 0 10.43 82.08 98.4 Tm (2d 1354 \(11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.13 0 0 11.13 140.64 103.2 Tm (th Cir. 1988\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1612 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 183.84 792 Tm (\); )Tj 11.76 0 Td (\), )Tj 14.4 0 Td (\), )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.7 0 0 12.7 111.6 679.68 Tm (Restoring Competitive Conditions Is Central To The Commission )Tj 12.4 0 0 12.4 451.2 679.44 Tm (s Remedial )Tj 12.39 0 0 12.39 111.84 665.52 Tm (Powers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.79 0 0 12.79 147.6 636.96 Tm (The Commission Has the Power To Enjoin Patent 鶹ý or Restrict )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 147.36 622.56 Tm (Royalties To Restore Competition )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.36 594.48 Tm (Well-settled precedent confinns the Commission )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 350.88 594 Tm (s authority to ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.43 0 0 7.43 421.92 594 Tm (cure the il effects of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.88 566.16 Tm (ilegal conduct." )Tj 17.28 -0.048 Td (United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.2 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 239.76 565.68 Tm (u.s.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 257.2663 565.68 Tm ( Gypsum Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 328.08 565.68 Tm (340 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.17 0 0 10.17 360.96 565.44 Tm (S. 76)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 385.44 565.68 Tm (, 88 \(1950\); Complaint )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 75.12 537.6 Tm (Counsel' )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 118.8 537.84 Tm (s Brief \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 162.96 537.6 Tm (CCB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 192 537.6 Tm (\) 3-)Tj 12.62 0 0 12.62 208.8 537.6 Tm (4. Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 267.36 537.6 Tm (s contention that the Commission )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 432.48 537.36 Tm (s power is limited to )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 509.52 Tm (ordering a respondent to reftain from repeating unlawful conduct)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.58 0 0 10.58 387.12 509.04 Tm (, Respondent' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.72 0 0 12.72 453.84 509.04 Tm (s Brief\(")Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 497.52 509.04 Tm (RB")Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 518.64 509.04 Tm (\) 4\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 80.88 481.2 Tm (, flies in the face of relevant precedent. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.28 0 0 11.28 272.88 480.72 Tm (See, e. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 312.72 480.72 Tm (, Ekco Prods. Co. )Tj 10.32 0 0 10.32 403.92 480.72 Tm (65 F. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.86 0 0 8.86 438.96 480.72 Tm (C. 1163)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 477.36 480.96 Tm (, 1216 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.64 450.48 Tm (\(1964\), aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 129.6 452.88 Tm (d sub nom. Ecko Prods. Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 27.264 -0.096 Td (v. )Tj 12.69 0 0 12.69 276.96 452.64 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.41 0 0 10.41 306 452.4 Tm (347 F.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 336.24 452.4 Tm (2d 745 \(7th Cir. 1965\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.752 0 Td (FTC )Tj 5.136 0 Td (v. )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 486.48 452.16 Tm (National )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 73.68 424.32 Tm (Lead )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 104.88 424.32 Tm (352 U.)Tj 2.825 -0.021 Td (S. 419)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 168.24 424.32 Tm (, 430 \(1957\) \(Commission must assure that a violator )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 15.21 0 0 15.21 426.48 423.84 Tm (wil ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.84 424.08 Tm (relinquish the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.48 0 0 7.48 74.4 396 Tm (frits of his violation. )Tj 5 0 0 5 193.68 395.76 Tm (see also New York )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 296.4 395.52 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 380.4 395.52 Tm (224 F.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 411.36 395.28 Tm (Supp.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 438.96 395.52 Tm (2d 76)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 466.56 395.52 Tm (, 148 \(D. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.16 367.44 Tm (2002\) \(")Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 114.96 367.44 Tm (equitable relief beyond a mere injunction against repetition )Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 400.32 366.96 Tm (ofthe act is )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 459.6 366.96 Tm (generally )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.21 0 0 11.21 74.16 338.88 Tm (appropriate. \(quoting Areeda & )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 230.64 338.64 Tm (HovenkampJ . . . \(TJhe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 344.64 338.4 Tm (Cour finds )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.4 0 0 8.4 401.76 338.4 Tm (unpersuasive Microsoft' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.85 0 0 14.85 73.92 310.56 Tm (arguent )Tj 12 0 0 12 122.16 310.56 Tm (that Plaintiffs are entitled to no more than a simple proscription again\ st the )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 484.8 310.08 Tm (conduct )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.68 282.24 Tm (found to violate the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.86 0 0 7.86 170.64 282 Tm (antitrst laws. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 252.72 282 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 269.52 281.76 Tm (d sub nom Massachusetts )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.104 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.59 0 0 8.59 405.6 281.76 Tm (Microsoft Corp. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 490.56 281.76 Tm (373 F.3d )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 74.4 253.92 Tm (1199)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 97.92 253.92 Tm (, 1232 \(D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.09 0 0 12.09 146.64 253.68 Tm (C. Cir. 2004\). Applicable precedent requires that the Commission restor\ e )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 73.44 225.36 Tm (competition and deprive the wrongdoer of the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 7.14 0 0 7.14 296.4 225.12 Tm (frits of its )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 352.08 224.88 Tm (anti competitive conduct. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.67 0 0 11.67 477.36 224.88 Tm (CCB 3\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 145.2 140.88 Tm (See also Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 9.99 0 0 9.99 314.88 140.64 Tm (108 F. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.61 0 0 11.61 354.72 140.4 Tm (C. 263)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 387.12 140.64 Tm (, 368 \(1986\) \(Commission )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 73.2 126.72 Tm (Section 5 consumer protection cease and desist order ")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 6.76 0 0 6.76 335.28 126.48 Tm (resu1t\( edJ in a roll )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.73 0 0 11.73 424.56 126.24 Tm (back. . . of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.39 0 0 13.39 481.92 126.48 Tm (the anual )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 72.48 112.56 Tm (renewal fees on all of Orkin )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 209.28 112.32 Tm (s pre-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.5 0 0 10.5 236.88 112.32 Tm (1975 contracts. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 324.48 112.32 Tm (aff' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 346.8 112.08 Tm (, Orkin Exterminating Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 25.968 0 Td (v. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.45 0 0 9.45 487.44 112.08 Tm (FTC, 849 )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 10.43 0 0 10.43 82.08 98.4 Tm (2d 1354 \(11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.13 0 0 11.13 140.64 103.2 Tm (th Cir. 1988\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1613 0 obj<> endobj 1614 0 obj<> endobj 1615 0 obj<> endobj 1616 0 obj<> endobj 1617 0 obj<> endobj 1618 0 obj<> endobj 1619 0 obj<> endobj 1620 0 obj<> endobj 1621 0 obj<> endobj 1622 0 obj<> endobj 1623 0 obj<> endobj 1624 0 obj<> endobj 1625 0 obj<> endobj 1626 0 obj<> endobj 1627 0 obj<> endobj 1628 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.98 0 0 11.98 111.6 707.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditiona\ l)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 475.2 707.76 Tm (, limited )Tj 13.95 0 0 13.95 75.36 679.2 Tm (antitrst )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 117.6 679.2 Tm (remedy clearly within its well-)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 264.48 679.2 Tm (defined powers. Despite Rambus )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 430.08 678.96 Tm (s windfall gains during )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 650.64 Tm (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 398.88 650.64 Tm (, the Commission )Tj 13.65 0 0 13.65 486.72 650.64 Tm (s primar )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 75.12 622.08 Tm (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive condit\ ions and protect consumers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.02 0 0 11.02 75.12 593.76 Tm (going forward. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 74.64 536.88 Tm (II. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.82 0 0 12.82 110.88 536.88 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 297.6 536.64 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 480 536.64 Tm (Compliant )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.09 0 0 13.09 110.88 522.72 Tm (Products Is Appropriate )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.47 0 0 11.47 146.4 494.4 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 232.8 494.16 Tm (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 146.88 480 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 317.76 480 Tm (Of Rambus Patents )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.64 452.16 Tm (The record demonstrates that)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 250.56 451.92 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 333.12 451.68 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 387.6 451.68 Tm (, JEDEC standards would be )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 74.64 423.6 Tm (ftee of Ram bus )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 152.4 423.36 Tm (s patent claims. CCB 4-)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 270 423.36 Tm (6; CCFF 2101 )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 343.92 423.36 Tm (2435-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 372 423.36 Tm (40. Rambus )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.32 423.36 Tm (errs in asserting that it )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 74.4 395.04 Tm (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents bec\ ause \(it claims\) JEDEC )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 73.92 366.72 Tm (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.87 0 0 8.87 382.56 366.48 Tm (12. Likewise)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 446.88 366.48 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.7 0 0 14.7 74.16 338.16 Tm (arguent )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 121.92 338.16 Tm (that the Commission should credit Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 333.36 337.92 Tm (s retained experts)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 417.84 337.92 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 309.84 Tm (Rapp, to justify a 2.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 168.48 309.6 Tm (5% royalty rate )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 262.8 309.6 Tm (23-)Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 291.12 309.6 Tm (, is baseless.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 247.92 309.6 Tm (id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.44 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj 13.57 0 0 13.57 153.12 281.28 Tm (s arguents are )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 231.12 281.28 Tm (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the )Tj 13.13 0 0 13.13 468.96 281.28 Tm (fudamental )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.75 0 0 7.75 73.68 252.96 Tm (staring point - the concrete factual record of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 292.32 252.72 Tm (what competitive conditions likely would have )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 224.64 Tm (prevailed in the absence of its deception.)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 269.04 229.44 Tm (4 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 322.08 224.4 Tm (s unfounded assumptions include: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 196.32 Tm (1.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.4 196.32 Tm ( Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 364.08 195.84 Tm (The evidence is unequivocal: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.2 167.52 Tm (Rambus refused to give a )Tj 22.99 0 0 22.99 198 167.52 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 235.68 167.52 Tm (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 144.96 126.24 Tm (Even assuming )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 15.312 -0.048 Td (arguendo )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 270.48 126 Tm (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer )Tj 13.28 0 0 13.28 502.8 126 Tm (durng )Tj 12 0 0 12 72.96 111.84 Tm (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate re\ lief by a )Tj -0.02 -1.18 Td (preponderance of the evidence)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 220.08 97.44 Tm (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-)Tj 5 0 0 5 468.72 97.44 Tm (9; )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.6 0 0 7.6 481.2 97.68 Tm (infra 10-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 523.92 97.44 Tm (14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1629 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.98 0 0 11.98 111.6 707.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditiona\ l)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 475.2 707.76 Tm (, limited )Tj 13.95 0 0 13.95 75.36 679.2 Tm (antitrst )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 117.6 679.2 Tm (remedy clearly within its well-)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 264.48 679.2 Tm (defined powers. Despite Rambus )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 430.08 678.96 Tm (s windfall gains during )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 650.64 Tm (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 398.88 650.64 Tm (, the Commission )Tj 13.65 0 0 13.65 486.72 650.64 Tm (s primar )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 75.12 622.08 Tm (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive condit\ ions and protect consumers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.02 0 0 11.02 75.12 593.76 Tm (going forward. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 74.64 536.88 Tm (II. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.82 0 0 12.82 110.88 536.88 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 297.6 536.64 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 480 536.64 Tm (Compliant )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.09 0 0 13.09 110.88 522.72 Tm (Products Is Appropriate )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.47 0 0 11.47 146.4 494.4 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 232.8 494.16 Tm (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 146.88 480 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 317.76 480 Tm (Of Rambus Patents )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.64 452.16 Tm (The record demonstrates that)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 250.56 451.92 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 333.12 451.68 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 387.6 451.68 Tm (, JEDEC standards would be )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 74.64 423.6 Tm (ftee of Ram bus )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 152.4 423.36 Tm (s patent claims. CCB 4-)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 270 423.36 Tm (6; CCFF 2101 )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 343.92 423.36 Tm (2435-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 372 423.36 Tm (40. Rambus )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.32 423.36 Tm (errs in asserting that it )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 74.4 395.04 Tm (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents bec\ ause \(it claims\) JEDEC )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 73.92 366.72 Tm (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.87 0 0 8.87 382.56 366.48 Tm (12. Likewise)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 446.88 366.48 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.7 0 0 14.7 74.16 338.16 Tm (arguent )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 121.92 338.16 Tm (that the Commission should credit Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 333.36 337.92 Tm (s retained experts)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 417.84 337.92 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 309.84 Tm (Rapp, to justify a 2.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 168.48 309.6 Tm (5% royalty rate )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 262.8 309.6 Tm (23-)Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 291.12 309.6 Tm (, is baseless.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 247.92 309.6 Tm (id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.44 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj 13.57 0 0 13.57 153.12 281.28 Tm (s arguents are )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 231.12 281.28 Tm (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the )Tj 13.13 0 0 13.13 468.96 281.28 Tm (fudamental )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.75 0 0 7.75 73.68 252.96 Tm (staring point - the concrete factual record of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 292.32 252.72 Tm (what competitive conditions likely would have )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 224.64 Tm (prevailed in the absence of its deception.)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 269.04 229.44 Tm (4 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 322.08 224.4 Tm (s unfounded assumptions include: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 196.32 Tm (1.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.4 196.32 Tm ( Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 364.08 195.84 Tm (The evidence is unequivocal: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.2 167.52 Tm (Rambus refused to give a )Tj 22.99 0 0 22.99 198 167.52 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 235.68 167.52 Tm (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 144.96 126.24 Tm (Even assuming )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 15.312 -0.048 Td (arguendo )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 270.48 126 Tm (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer )Tj 13.28 0 0 13.28 502.8 126 Tm (durng )Tj 12 0 0 12 72.96 111.84 Tm (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate re\ lief by a )Tj -0.02 -1.18 Td (preponderance of the evidence)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 220.08 97.44 Tm (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-)Tj 5 0 0 5 468.72 97.44 Tm (9; )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.6 0 0 7.6 481.2 97.68 Tm (infra 10-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 523.92 97.44 Tm (14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1630 0 obj<> endobj 1631 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.98 0 0 11.98 111.6 707.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditiona\ l)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 475.2 707.76 Tm (, limited )Tj 13.95 0 0 13.95 75.36 679.2 Tm (antitrst )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 117.6 679.2 Tm (remedy clearly within its well-)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 264.48 679.2 Tm (defined powers. Despite Rambus )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 430.08 678.96 Tm (s windfall gains during )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 650.64 Tm (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 398.88 650.64 Tm (, the Commission )Tj 13.65 0 0 13.65 486.72 650.64 Tm (s primar )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 75.12 622.08 Tm (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive condit\ ions and protect consumers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.02 0 0 11.02 75.12 593.76 Tm (going forward. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 74.64 536.88 Tm (II. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.82 0 0 12.82 110.88 536.88 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 297.6 536.64 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 480 536.64 Tm (Compliant )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.09 0 0 13.09 110.88 522.72 Tm (Products Is Appropriate )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.47 0 0 11.47 146.4 494.4 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 232.8 494.16 Tm (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 146.88 480 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 317.76 480 Tm (Of Rambus Patents )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.64 452.16 Tm (The record demonstrates that)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 250.56 451.92 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 333.12 451.68 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 387.6 451.68 Tm (, JEDEC standards would be )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 74.64 423.6 Tm (ftee of Ram bus )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 152.4 423.36 Tm (s patent claims. CCB 4-)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 270 423.36 Tm (6; CCFF 2101 )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 343.92 423.36 Tm (2435-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 372 423.36 Tm (40. Rambus )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.32 423.36 Tm (errs in asserting that it )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 74.4 395.04 Tm (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents bec\ ause \(it claims\) JEDEC )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 73.92 366.72 Tm (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.87 0 0 8.87 382.56 366.48 Tm (12. Likewise)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 446.88 366.48 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.7 0 0 14.7 74.16 338.16 Tm (arguent )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 121.92 338.16 Tm (that the Commission should credit Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 333.36 337.92 Tm (s retained experts)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 417.84 337.92 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 309.84 Tm (Rapp, to justify a 2.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 168.48 309.6 Tm (5% royalty rate )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 262.8 309.6 Tm (23-)Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 291.12 309.6 Tm (, is baseless.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 247.92 309.6 Tm (id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.44 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj 13.57 0 0 13.57 153.12 281.28 Tm (s arguents are )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 231.12 281.28 Tm (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the )Tj 13.13 0 0 13.13 468.96 281.28 Tm (fudamental )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.75 0 0 7.75 73.68 252.96 Tm (staring point - the concrete factual record of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 292.32 252.72 Tm (what competitive conditions likely would have )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 224.64 Tm (prevailed in the absence of its deception.)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 269.04 229.44 Tm (4 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 322.08 224.4 Tm (s unfounded assumptions include: )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 196.32 Tm (1.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.4 196.32 Tm ( Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 364.08 195.84 Tm (The evidence is unequivocal: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.2 167.52 Tm (Rambus refused to give a )Tj 22.99 0 0 22.99 198 167.52 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 235.68 167.52 Tm (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 144.96 126.24 Tm (Even assuming )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 15.312 -0.048 Td (arguendo )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 270.48 126 Tm (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer )Tj 13.28 0 0 13.28 502.8 126 Tm (durng )Tj 12 0 0 12 72.96 111.84 Tm (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate re\ lief by a )Tj -0.02 -1.18 Td (preponderance of the evidence)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 220.08 97.44 Tm (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-)Tj 5 0 0 5 468.72 97.44 Tm (9; )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.6 0 0 7.6 481.2 97.68 Tm (infra 10-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 523.92 97.44 Tm (14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1632 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.98 0 0 11.98 111.6 707.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel nevertheless urge the Commission to adopt a traditiona\ l)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 475.2 707.76 Tm (, limited )Tj 13.95 0 0 13.95 75.36 679.2 Tm (antitrst )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 117.6 679.2 Tm (remedy clearly within its well-)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 264.48 679.2 Tm (defined powers. Despite Rambus )Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 430.08 678.96 Tm (s windfall gains during )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 74.88 650.64 Tm (the past six years and the possibility of perverse incentives in SSOs)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 398.88 650.64 Tm (, the Commission )Tj 13.65 0 0 13.65 486.72 650.64 Tm (s primar )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 75.12 622.08 Tm (objective \(as explained above\) should be to restore competitive condit\ ions and protect consumers )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.02 0 0 11.02 75.12 593.76 Tm (going forward. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 74.64 536.88 Tm (II. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.82 0 0 12.82 110.88 536.88 Tm (Enjoining 鶹ý Of Rambus )Tj 12.73 0 0 12.73 297.6 536.64 Tm (s Relevant Patents Against JEDEC-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 480 536.64 Tm (Compliant )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.09 0 0 13.09 110.88 522.72 Tm (Products Is Appropriate )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.47 0 0 11.47 146.4 494.4 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.5 0 0 12.5 232.8 494.16 Tm (s Deception, Competitive Conditions Would Have Been A )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 146.88 480 Tm (Series of JEDEC Standards Free )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.9 0 0 12.9 317.76 480 Tm (Of Rambus Patents )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 110.64 452.16 Tm (The record demonstrates that)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 250.56 451.92 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 333.12 451.68 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 387.6 451.68 Tm (, JEDEC standards would be )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 74.64 423.6 Tm (ftee of Ram bus )Tj 12.27 0 0 12.27 152.4 423.36 Tm (s patent claims. CCB 4-)Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 270 423.36 Tm (6; CCFF 2101 )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 343.92 423.36 Tm (2435-)Tj 12.79 0 0 12.79 372 423.36 Tm (40. Rambus )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.32 423.36 Tm (errs in asserting that it )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 74.4 395.04 Tm (is entitled to compensation for the incremental value of its patents bec\ ause \(it claims\) JEDEC )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 73.92 366.72 Tm (members would have paid Rambus for its technologies. RB 10-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.87 0 0 8.87 382.56 366.48 Tm (12. Likewise)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.38 0 0 10.38 446.88 366.48 Tm (, Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.7 0 0 14.7 74.16 338.16 Tm (arguent )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 121.92 338.16 Tm (that the Commission should credit Rambus )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 333.36 337.92 Tm (s retained experts)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 417.84 337.92 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.44 309.84 Tm (Rapp, to justify a 2.)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 168.48 309.6 Tm (5% royalty rate )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 262.8 309.6 Tm (23-)Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 291.12 309.6 Tm (, is baseless.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 247.92 309.6 Tm (id. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.44 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj 13.57 0 0 13.57 153.12 281.28 Tm (s arguents are )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 231.12 281.28 Tm (based on false assumptions. Rambus ignores the )Tj 13.13 0 0 13.13 468.96 281.28 Tm (fudamental )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.75 0 0 7.75 73.68 252.96 Tm (staring point - the concrete factual record of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 292.32 252.72 Tm (what competitive conditions likely would have )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.2 224.64 Tm (prevailed in the absence of its deception.)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 269.04 229.44 Tm (4 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 322.08 224.4 Tm (s unfounded assumptions include: )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.4 196.32 Tm (1.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.4 196.32 Tm ( Rambus would have made a RAND commitment. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 364.08 195.84 Tm (The evidence is unequivocal: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.2 167.52 Tm (Rambus refused to give a )Tj 22.99 0 0 22.99 198 167.52 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 235.68 167.52 Tm (commitment. CCFF 1091; CX0490; CX0869; Tr. 6223\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 144.96 126.24 Tm (Even assuming )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 15.312 -0.048 Td (arguendo )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 270.48 126 Tm (doubts were not resolved against the wrongdoer )Tj 13.28 0 0 13.28 502.8 126 Tm (durng )Tj 12 0 0 12 72.96 111.84 Tm (the remedy phase and Complaint Counsel must establish the appropriate re\ lief by a )Tj -0.02 -1.18 Td (preponderance of the evidence)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 220.08 97.44 Tm (, Complaint Counsel have already done so. CCB 4-)Tj 5 0 0 5 468.72 97.44 Tm (9; )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.6 0 0 7.6 481.2 97.68 Tm (infra 10-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 523.92 97.44 Tm (14. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1633 0 obj<> endobj 1634 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.88 707.52 Tm (\(Diepenbrock\). This was not mere oversight or misunderstanding; it was\ a calculated )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 487.2 707.52 Tm (position. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.52 0 0 10.52 74.64 678.96 Tm (Rambus representatives regarded )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.69 0 0 22.69 236.64 678.72 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 273.84 678.96 Tm (as contrar to Rambus)Tj 10.34 0 0 10.34 381.36 678.96 Tm (' s entire business model. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.88 650.4 Tm (CX0873 \(")Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 127.2 650.4 Tm (Rambus Inc. )Tj 13.22 0 0 13.22 190.8 650.4 Tm (canot agree )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 254.64 650.4 Tm (to the terms ofthe JEDEC patent \(licensing\) )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 470.16 650.64 Tm (policy"\); )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.88 621.84 Tm (CX0874 \(")Tj 12 0 0 12 127.2 622.08 Tm (the patent \(licensing\) policy of JEDEC does not comport with our busin\ ess model" )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 74.64 593.52 Tm (Tr. 6228-)Tj 12 0 0 12 119.76 593.52 Tm (29 \(Diepenbrock: ")Tj 22.69 0 0 22.69 212.16 593.28 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 249.36 593.52 Tm (terms \(were\) inconsistent with Rambus)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 438.24 593.52 Tm (' existing business )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.16 565.2 Tm (practices )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 122.16 564.96 Tm (\); CX2112 at 213 \(Mooring\); CX3129 at 488-)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 342.72 564.96 Tm (89 \(Vincent\); CX2083 at 98 \(Davidow\). )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.16 536.88 Tm (And absent a )Tj 14.66 0 0 14.66 139.44 536.64 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 238.08 536.64 Tm (, JEDEC could not have adopted Rambus )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 441.12 536.88 Tm (s technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.4 508.32 Tm (CX0203A at 11; JX0054 at 9; CX0208 at 19; Tr. 1868-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.71 0 0 10.71 352.08 508.32 Tm (, 1884-)Tj 4.325 0.022 Td (, 1895-)Tj 10.56 0 0 10.56 444.48 508.56 Tm (, 1907-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.65 0 0 11.65 478.08 508.56 Tm (08 \(Kelly\). )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 480.24 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 154.56 480.24 Tm (s deception)Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 209.04 480 Tm (, JEDEC standards would have been ftee ofRambus )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 464.4 480.24 Tm (s patent claims. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 110.16 451.92 Tm (2.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 119.3325 451.92 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 243.6 451.68 Tm (have been satisfied with a RAND commitment from Rambus. )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 423.12 Tm (JEDEC members were focused on minimizing cost. They were particularly co\ ncerned about )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 73.68 394.8 Tm (patents held by non-manufacturng companies)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 295.44 394.8 Tm (, such as Rambus)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 378.72 394.8 Tm (, because they would demand )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.92 366.24 Tm (cash royalties rather than cross-)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 225.36 366.48 Tm (licenses. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 109.92 337.92 Tm (3. JEDEC members would have engaged )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 312.24 337.68 Tm (in a detailed cost comparison of alternatives. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 73.44 309.6 Tm (Rambus argues)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 147.12 309.36 Tm (, based solely on the theories of its retained experts)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 392.16 309.36 Tm (, that JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 73.2 281.28 Tm (have calculated static)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 175.92 281.04 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 212.16 281.04 Tm (to-)Tj 1.151 0 Td (the-)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 244.32 281.04 Tm (penny cost projections)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 352.08 281.04 Tm (, fifteen years into the future)Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 488.4 281.28 Tm (, of )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 252.72 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 116.88 252.72 Tm (s technologies versus alternatives. Rambus presents no factual evidence \ that JEDEC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.38 0 0 7.38 73.68 224.4 Tm (actually did this. In fact)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 189.36 224.4 Tm (, there were multiple reasons why JEDEC did not. Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 479.52 224.4 Tm (s own )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.68 195.84 Tm (experiences with its )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 171.12 195.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 218.88 195.84 Tm (show: )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 15.55 0 0 15.55 109.2 144.96 Tm (5 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 188.4 139.92 Tm (s claims that JEDEC never rejected a patented technology )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.78 0 0 7.78 468.96 140.16 Tm (ifthe patent-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 125.76 Tm (holder offered a )Tj 14.7 0 0 14.7 151.92 125.76 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 250.8 125.76 Tm (, RB 12 n. 9)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 308.4 125.76 Tm (, is simply untrue. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 420.24 125.76 Tm (Tr. 5046-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.15 0 0 11.15 465.36 126 Tm (49 \(Kellogg: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 72.96 111.6 Tm (IBM)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 95.52 111.36 Tm (, Cypress)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 139.68 111.6 Tm (, Kentron and )Tj 13.83 0 0 13.83 208.08 111.6 Tm (Hyudai )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 252.24 111.6 Tm (technologies rejected despite )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.99 0 0 22.99 393.36 111.36 Tm (RA )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 431.04 111.6 Tm (offer\); CX3135 at 104\255)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 97.44 Tm (06 \(Chen: Mitsubishi technologies rejected\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1635 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.88 707.52 Tm (\(Diepenbrock\). This was not mere oversight or misunderstanding; it was\ a calculated )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 487.2 707.52 Tm (position. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.52 0 0 10.52 74.64 678.96 Tm (Rambus representatives regarded )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.69 0 0 22.69 236.64 678.72 Tm (RA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 273.84 678.96 Tm (as contrar to Rambus)Tj 10.34 0 0 10.34 381.36 678.96 Tm (' s entire business model. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 74.88 650.4 Tm (CX0873 \(")Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 127.2 650.4 Tm (Rambus Inc. )Tj 13.22 0 0 13.22 190.8 650.4 Tm (canot agree )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 254.64 650.4 Tm (to the terms ofthe JEDEC patent \(licensing\) )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 470.16 650.64 Tm (policy"\); )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.88 621.84 Tm (CX0874 \(")Tj 12 0 0 12 127.2 622.08 Tm (the patent \(licensing\) policy of JEDEC does not comport with our busin\ ess model" )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 74.64 593.52 Tm (Tr. 6228-)Tj 12 0 0 12 119.76 593.52 Tm (29 \(Diepenbrock: ")Tj 22.69 0 0 22.69 212.16 593.28 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 249.36 593.52 Tm (terms \(were\) inconsistent with Rambus)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 438.24 593.52 Tm (' existing business )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 74.16 565.2 Tm (practices )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 122.16 564.96 Tm (\); CX2112 at 213 \(Mooring\); CX3129 at 488-)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 342.72 564.96 Tm (89 \(Vincent\); CX2083 at 98 \(Davidow\). )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 74.16 536.88 Tm (And absent a )Tj 14.66 0 0 14.66 139.44 536.64 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 238.08 536.64 Tm (, JEDEC could not have adopted Rambus )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 441.12 536.88 Tm (s technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.4 508.32 Tm (CX0203A at 11; JX0054 at 9; CX0208 at 19; Tr. 1868-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.71 0 0 10.71 352.08 508.32 Tm (, 1884-)Tj 4.325 0.022 Td (, 1895-)Tj 10.56 0 0 10.56 444.48 508.56 Tm (, 1907-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.65 0 0 11.65 478.08 508.56 Tm (08 \(Kelly\). )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 480.24 Tm (Absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 154.56 480.24 Tm (s deception)Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 209.04 480 Tm (, JEDEC standards would have been ftee ofRambus )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 464.4 480.24 Tm (s patent claims. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 110.16 451.92 Tm (2.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 119.3325 451.92 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 243.6 451.68 Tm (have been satisfied with a RAND commitment from Rambus. )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 423.12 Tm (JEDEC members were focused on minimizing cost. They were particularly co\ ncerned about )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 73.68 394.8 Tm (patents held by non-manufacturng companies)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 295.44 394.8 Tm (, such as Rambus)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 378.72 394.8 Tm (, because they would demand )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.92 366.24 Tm (cash royalties rather than cross-)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 225.36 366.48 Tm (licenses. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 109.92 337.92 Tm (3. JEDEC members would have engaged )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 312.24 337.68 Tm (in a detailed cost comparison of alternatives. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 73.44 309.6 Tm (Rambus argues)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 147.12 309.36 Tm (, based solely on the theories of its retained experts)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 392.16 309.36 Tm (, that JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 73.2 281.28 Tm (have calculated static)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 175.92 281.04 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 212.16 281.04 Tm (to-)Tj 1.151 0 Td (the-)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 244.32 281.04 Tm (penny cost projections)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 352.08 281.04 Tm (, fifteen years into the future)Tj 12.78 0 0 12.78 488.4 281.28 Tm (, of )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 252.72 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 116.88 252.72 Tm (s technologies versus alternatives. Rambus presents no factual evidence \ that JEDEC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.38 0 0 7.38 73.68 224.4 Tm (actually did this. In fact)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 189.36 224.4 Tm (, there were multiple reasons why JEDEC did not. Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 479.52 224.4 Tm (s own )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 73.68 195.84 Tm (experiences with its )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 171.12 195.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 218.88 195.84 Tm (show: )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 15.55 0 0 15.55 109.2 144.96 Tm (5 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 188.4 139.92 Tm (s claims that JEDEC never rejected a patented technology )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.78 0 0 7.78 468.96 140.16 Tm (ifthe patent-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 125.76 Tm (holder offered a )Tj 14.7 0 0 14.7 151.92 125.76 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 250.8 125.76 Tm (, RB 12 n. 9)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 308.4 125.76 Tm (, is simply untrue. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 18.384 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 420.24 125.76 Tm (Tr. 5046-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.15 0 0 11.15 465.36 126 Tm (49 \(Kellogg: )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 72.96 111.6 Tm (IBM)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 95.52 111.36 Tm (, Cypress)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 139.68 111.6 Tm (, Kentron and )Tj 13.83 0 0 13.83 208.08 111.6 Tm (Hyudai )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.67 0 0 10.67 252.24 111.6 Tm (technologies rejected despite )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 22.99 0 0 22.99 393.36 111.36 Tm (RA )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 431.04 111.6 Tm (offer\); CX3135 at 104\255)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.2 97.44 Tm (06 \(Chen: Mitsubishi technologies rejected\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1636 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.9 0 0 11.9 111.36 693.36 Tm (\(A\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 127.8772 693.36 Tm ( Cost projections were extremely difficult and subject only to very roug\ h estimates. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 111.12 678.96 Tm (Cost projections were often rounded plus-or-minus 10%. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 111.12 650.64 Tm (\(B\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 126.204 650.64 Tm ( Costs tyically )Tj 5 0 0 5 206.64 650.4 Tm (dropped dramatically over time. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 31.824 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 385.68 650.16 Tm (CX2747 at 68 )Tj 15.21 0 0 15.21 455.76 650.64 Tm (\(RDRA )Tj 11.62 0 0 11.62 506.88 650.64 Tm (cost )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 111.12 636.48 Tm (disadvantage dropping from 80% to 30-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.69 0 0 10.69 301.68 636.24 Tm (40% from 1H99 to 2HOO\).)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 428.64 641.04 Tm (6 As a result)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 489.6 636.24 Tm (, cost )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 110.4 622.08 Tm (projections rarely extended over more than 1-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.5 0 0 7.5 329.04 622.08 Tm (2 years. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.88 593.52 Tm (\(C\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 127.0093 593.52 Tm ( Cost projections vared widely from company to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 364.32 593.52 Tm (company; a single company often )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.4 579.6 Tm (presented a wide range of possible outcomes. RX-)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 355.44 579.36 Tm (1525 at 19 \(Rambus Q400 cost gap )Tj 12.74 0 0 12.74 110.88 565.2 Tm (scenaros )Tj 14.44 0 0 14.44 157.92 565.2 Tm (\(RDRA to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.28 565.2 Tm (PClOO\) ranging from $8.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 342 564.96 Tm (74 to $19.)Tj 11.37 0 0 11.37 390 564.96 Tm (71\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 74.64 537.12 Tm (In sum)Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 107.52 536.88 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 179.28 536.88 Tm (s calculations of unform)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 299.04 536.88 Tm (, static)Tj 10.94 0 0 10.94 330.72 536.88 Tm (, pennes-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 376.56 536.64 Tm (per-chip cost differences among )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 74.64 508.8 Tm (alternatives was completely )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.57 0 0 11.57 209.76 508.56 Tm (irelevant to JEDEC' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.3 0 0 12.3 311.28 508.56 Tm (s processes. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 427.2 508.56 Tm (I don )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 455.52 508.56 Tm (t even know )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 480.48 Tm (whether the questions I was asked to answer were ever asked at JEDEC")Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 422.16 480.24 Tm (\); 9674 \(")Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 468.72 480.24 Tm (I have no )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.16 452.16 Tm (knowledge of how JEDEC folks did their analysis )Tj 12.54 0 0 12.54 318.96 451.92 Tm (\). Dr. Rapp )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 380.16 451.68 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 444.48 451.92 Tm (, relying on Mr. )Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.4 423.36 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 12 0 0 12 120 423.6 Tm (s numbers to opine on the ")Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 251.52 423.36 Tm (but-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 271.2 423.36 Tm (for)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 284.88 423.36 Tm (" world)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 321.36 423.36 Tm (, are therefore equally flawed and rendered )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.72 0 0 7.72 74.16 395.04 Tm (irrelevant. The factual record establishes that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 292.32 394.8 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 375.36 394.8 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 429.84 394.8 Tm (, JEDEC members )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 366.48 Tm (simply would have selected a generally acceptable alternative. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 377.28 366.24 Tm (Decision 74 n. 403 \(JEDEC )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 73.92 338.16 Tm (dropped loop-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 140.4 338.16 Tm (back clock proposal because of Ram bus patent concerns and pursued alter\ natives )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.44 309.84 Tm (without any detailed cost comparison\); Tr. 1416-)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 308.64 309.6 Tm (17 \(Sussman\); Tr. 9022-)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 424.8 309.6 Tm (23 \(Prince\); Tr. 6635\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 91.68 281.28 Tm (6717 )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 121.44 281.28 Tm (6686 \(Lee\); Tr. 5136 )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 227.76 281.28 Tm (5146 )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 258 281.28 Tm (5170 )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 287.52 281.28 Tm (5187 \(Kellogg\); CX2107 at 137 \(Oh\); CX2058 at )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 73.68 252.96 Tm (371-)Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 113.04 253.2 Tm (440-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 134.64 252.96 Tm (41 \(Meyer\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 145.2 209.28 Tm (Cf )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.14 0 0 12.14 161.76 209.52 Tm (Decision 95 \(")Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 232.32 209.52 Tm (Rapp )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 262.08 209.28 Tm (s calculations)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 326.64 209.28 Tm (, like Geilhufe )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 399.6 209.04 Tm (s estimates)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 452.16 209.28 Tm (, wholly ignore )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 73.44 195.12 Tm (several possibilities for cost reductions from adoption of the alternati\ ve technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 144.48 168.72 Tm (Dr. McAfee \(who unlike Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. Rapp studied the record )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.44 154.56 Tm (extensively\) explained that JEDEC members followed a decision-making pr\ ocess known as )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 78.72 140.16 Tm (satisficing.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.55 0 0 8.55 130.08 140.16 Tm (" Because of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 196.8 140.16 Tm (the many uncertainties involved)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 350.64 139.92 Tm (, time-)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 381.6 139.92 Tm (to-market concerns and the )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 126 Tm (importance of reaching consensus)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.93 0 0 10.93 235.68 125.76 Tm (, JEDEC members did not try to conduct detailed comparsons )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.96 111.84 Tm (of each set of alternatives to identify the very best)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 311.28 111.6 Tm (, but rather settled on an acceptable )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 72.96 97.44 Tm (compromise and moved on. Tr. 7255-)Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 257.52 97.44 Tm (56. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1637 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 11.9 0 0 11.9 111.36 693.36 Tm (\(A\))Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 127.8772 693.36 Tm ( Cost projections were extremely difficult and subject only to very roug\ h estimates. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 111.12 678.96 Tm (Cost projections were often rounded plus-or-minus 10%. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 111.12 650.64 Tm (\(B\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.38 0 0 8.38 126.204 650.64 Tm ( Costs tyically )Tj 5 0 0 5 206.64 650.4 Tm (dropped dramatically over time. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 31.824 -0.048 Td (See )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 385.68 650.16 Tm (CX2747 at 68 )Tj 15.21 0 0 15.21 455.76 650.64 Tm (\(RDRA )Tj 11.62 0 0 11.62 506.88 650.64 Tm (cost )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 111.12 636.48 Tm (disadvantage dropping from 80% to 30-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.69 0 0 10.69 301.68 636.24 Tm (40% from 1H99 to 2HOO\).)Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 428.64 641.04 Tm (6 As a result)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 489.6 636.24 Tm (, cost )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 110.4 622.08 Tm (projections rarely extended over more than 1-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.5 0 0 7.5 329.04 622.08 Tm (2 years. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.88 593.52 Tm (\(C\))Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 127.0093 593.52 Tm ( Cost projections vared widely from company to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 364.32 593.52 Tm (company; a single company often )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 110.4 579.6 Tm (presented a wide range of possible outcomes. RX-)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 355.44 579.36 Tm (1525 at 19 \(Rambus Q400 cost gap )Tj 12.74 0 0 12.74 110.88 565.2 Tm (scenaros )Tj 14.44 0 0 14.44 157.92 565.2 Tm (\(RDRA to )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.28 565.2 Tm (PClOO\) ranging from $8.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 342 564.96 Tm (74 to $19.)Tj 11.37 0 0 11.37 390 564.96 Tm (71\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 74.64 537.12 Tm (In sum)Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 107.52 536.88 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 179.28 536.88 Tm (s calculations of unform)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 299.04 536.88 Tm (, static)Tj 10.94 0 0 10.94 330.72 536.88 Tm (, pennes-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 376.56 536.64 Tm (per-chip cost differences among )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 74.64 508.8 Tm (alternatives was completely )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.57 0 0 11.57 209.76 508.56 Tm (irelevant to JEDEC' )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.3 0 0 12.3 311.28 508.56 Tm (s processes. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 427.2 508.56 Tm (I don )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 455.52 508.56 Tm (t even know )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 480.48 Tm (whether the questions I was asked to answer were ever asked at JEDEC")Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 422.16 480.24 Tm (\); 9674 \(")Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 468.72 480.24 Tm (I have no )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.16 452.16 Tm (knowledge of how JEDEC folks did their analysis )Tj 12.54 0 0 12.54 318.96 451.92 Tm (\). Dr. Rapp )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 380.16 451.68 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 444.48 451.92 Tm (, relying on Mr. )Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.4 423.36 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 12 0 0 12 120 423.6 Tm (s numbers to opine on the ")Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 251.52 423.36 Tm (but-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 271.2 423.36 Tm (for)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 284.88 423.36 Tm (" world)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 321.36 423.36 Tm (, are therefore equally flawed and rendered )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.72 0 0 7.72 74.16 395.04 Tm (irrelevant. The factual record establishes that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 292.32 394.8 Tm (, absent Rambus )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 375.36 394.8 Tm (s deception)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 429.84 394.8 Tm (, JEDEC members )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 74.16 366.48 Tm (simply would have selected a generally acceptable alternative. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 377.28 366.24 Tm (Decision 74 n. 403 \(JEDEC )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 73.92 338.16 Tm (dropped loop-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 140.4 338.16 Tm (back clock proposal because of Ram bus patent concerns and pursued alter\ natives )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.44 309.84 Tm (without any detailed cost comparison\); Tr. 1416-)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 308.64 309.6 Tm (17 \(Sussman\); Tr. 9022-)Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 424.8 309.6 Tm (23 \(Prince\); Tr. 6635\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.52 0 0 11.52 91.68 281.28 Tm (6717 )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 121.44 281.28 Tm (6686 \(Lee\); Tr. 5136 )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 227.76 281.28 Tm (5146 )Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 258 281.28 Tm (5170 )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 287.52 281.28 Tm (5187 \(Kellogg\); CX2107 at 137 \(Oh\); CX2058 at )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 73.68 252.96 Tm (371-)Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 113.04 253.2 Tm (440-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 134.64 252.96 Tm (41 \(Meyer\). )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 145.2 209.28 Tm (Cf )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.14 0 0 12.14 161.76 209.52 Tm (Decision 95 \(")Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 232.32 209.52 Tm (Rapp )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 262.08 209.28 Tm (s calculations)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 326.64 209.28 Tm (, like Geilhufe )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 399.6 209.04 Tm (s estimates)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 452.16 209.28 Tm (, wholly ignore )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 73.44 195.12 Tm (several possibilities for cost reductions from adoption of the alternati\ ve technologies. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 144.48 168.72 Tm (Dr. McAfee \(who unlike Mr. Geilhufe and Dr. Rapp studied the record )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 73.44 154.56 Tm (extensively\) explained that JEDEC members followed a decision-making pr\ ocess known as )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 78.72 140.16 Tm (satisficing.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.55 0 0 8.55 130.08 140.16 Tm (" Because of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 196.8 140.16 Tm (the many uncertainties involved)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 350.64 139.92 Tm (, time-)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 381.6 139.92 Tm (to-market concerns and the )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 126 Tm (importance of reaching consensus)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.93 0 0 10.93 235.68 125.76 Tm (, JEDEC members did not try to conduct detailed comparsons )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.96 111.84 Tm (of each set of alternatives to identify the very best)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 311.28 111.6 Tm (, but rather settled on an acceptable )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 72.96 97.44 Tm (compromise and moved on. Tr. 7255-)Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 257.52 97.44 Tm (56. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1638 0 obj<> endobj 1639 0 obj<> endobj 1640 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 8.3 0 0 8.3 110.64 708.24 Tm (4.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.3 0 0 8.3 120.6 708.24 Tm ( Cost )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 150.48 708 Tm (comparisons would have shown that)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 324.96 707.52 Tm (, on a value-adjusted basis)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.27 0 0 10.27 453.36 707.76 Tm (, Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 679.68 Tm (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 324.72 679.2 Tm (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 74.64 650.88 Tm (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective \ than alternatives. Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.64 622.32 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 120.24 622.56 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 5.419 -0.02 Td (, however)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 231.6 622.32 Tm (, are fatally flawed and uneliable. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 109.68 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 119.5078 579.84 Tm (He lacked the experience )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 242.16 579.6 Tm (necessar to render such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 362.88 579.36 Tm (an opinion. Tr. 9625-)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 465.12 579.36 Tm (9626 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 500.88 577.2 Tm (Q. And )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 109.92 565.68 Tm (your last hands-on )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 200.88 565.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 240 565.44 Tm (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.71 0 0 9.71 462.48 565.2 Tm (A. 1978)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 504.24 565.2 Tm (, 1\255)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 551.52 Tm (that is correct.")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 183.12 551.28 Tm (\); 9550-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.76 551.28 Tm (9551 \(1988-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.04 0 0 11.04 281.76 551.28 Tm (1998)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 305.04 551.04 Tm (, worked for lSD)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 385.44 551.04 Tm (, a fabless company with no )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.94 0 0 8.94 109.68 537.36 Tm (manufacturng\); 9628-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 217.92 537.12 Tm (9631 \(1999-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 276.72 537.12 Tm (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 109.68 523.2 Tm (how outdated 14-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 193.44 522.96 Tm (year-old )Tj 16.87 0 0 16.87 235.68 522.96 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 275.52 522.96 Tm (fabs could be used to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 378.96 522.72 Tm (manufactue other )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 469.44 522.96 Tm (products\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 109.2 494.88 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 116.2292 494.88 Tm (He failed to review any JEDEC records)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 308.4 494.64 Tm (, interview any JEDEC members)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 465.6 494.4 Tm (, or \(with very )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 480.72 Tm (few exceptions\) review the deposition or )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 7.93 0 0 7.93 307.92 480.48 Tm (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 507.12 480.24 Tm (9619\255)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 109.92 466.56 Tm (9623 \(")Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 145.92 464.16 Tm (Q. You never reviewed any )Tj 12.52 0 0 12.52 283.44 466.08 Tm (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 7.79 0 0 7.79 431.28 466.08 Tm (I did not. ... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 501.36 466.08 Tm (I never )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 109.92 452.4 Tm (spoke to a JEDEC member. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 423.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 116.2225 423.84 Tm (He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from )Tj 16.83 0 0 16.83 440.16 423.6 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 409.68 Tm (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 391.68 408.96 Tm (9618 \(")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 427.92 409.2 Tm (wanted to see cost )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 109.44 395.52 Tm (documents from a number of companes )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 306 395.04 Tm (" but they weren )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 388.32 395.04 Tm (t available\); 9666-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 476.88 395.04 Tm (9667 \(never )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 109.44 381.12 Tm (asked to obtain )Tj 13.31 0 0 13.31 184.56 381.12 Tm (DRA manufacturers)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 293.28 380.88 Tm (' cost information\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 108.72 352.8 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 115.7259 352.8 Tm (He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptanc\ e among )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 108.72 338.4 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 147.84 338.4 Tm (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 347.52 335.76 Tm (Q. Now)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 385.2 337.92 Tm (, what did you do to ensure that )Tj -23.156 -1.146 Td (the analysis that you did was the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.48 0 0 13.48 266.88 321.6 Tm (tye of )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 303.6 324 Tm (analysis that' )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 366.72 323.76 Tm (s done at JEDEC? A. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 477.6 323.76 Tm (I did not do )Tj 12.29 0 0 12.29 108.96 310.08 Tm (anything. I did my analysis. . . )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 108.24 281.76 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 118.5958 281.76 Tm (The sources )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.05 0 0 12.05 180.96 281.52 Tm (of his information )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 270.96 281.52 Tm (canot be identified)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 366.24 281.28 Tm (, and his calculations )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 469.92 281.28 Tm (canot be )Tj 8.56 0 0 8.56 108.48 267.6 Tm (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 227.28 267.12 Tm (9715 \(he couldn' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 309.12 267.12 Tm (t remember the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 384 267.12 Tm (manufactuers or par )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 490.56 267.12 Tm (numbers )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 253.44 Tm (of components for which he collected cost information; ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 382.56 252.96 Tm (I believe I specified one or two )Tj 12.67 0 0 12.67 108.48 239.28 Tm (companes)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 159.84 239.04 Tm (, and the others I didn' )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 267.84 238.8 Tm (t recall. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 143.76 140.4 Tm (Whether a method "' )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 247.68 140.4 Tm (has been subjected to peer review)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 409.92 140.16 Tm ('" and " )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 447.6 140.16 Tm (enjoys ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 485.28 140.16 Tm (general )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 72.24 126.48 Tm (acceptance)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 125.04 126.48 Tm (' within a ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 176.88 126.24 Tm (relevant scientific community)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 321.12 126 Tm ('" are factors in determining the reliability of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 112.08 Tm (an expert opinion. )Tj 18.432 0 Td (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 257.52 111.84 Tm (Carmichael )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.63 0 0 8.63 320.16 111.84 Tm (526 U.S. 137)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 383.04 111.6 Tm (, 149-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 412.08 111.6 Tm (150 \(1999\) \(citing )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.04 97.92 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 125.28 97.92 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 272.4 97.68 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 303.36 97.68 Tm (509 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.29 0 0 10.29 336 97.44 Tm (S. 579)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 366.48 97.44 Tm (, 592-)Tj 10.93 0 0 10.93 394.32 97.44 Tm (594 \(1993\)\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1641 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 8.3 0 0 8.3 110.64 708.24 Tm (4.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.3 0 0 8.3 120.6 708.24 Tm ( Cost )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 150.48 708 Tm (comparisons would have shown that)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 324.96 707.52 Tm (, on a value-adjusted basis)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.27 0 0 10.27 453.36 707.76 Tm (, Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 679.68 Tm (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 324.72 679.2 Tm (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 74.64 650.88 Tm (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective \ than alternatives. Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.64 622.32 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 120.24 622.56 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 5.419 -0.02 Td (, however)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 231.6 622.32 Tm (, are fatally flawed and uneliable. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 109.68 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 119.5078 579.84 Tm (He lacked the experience )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 242.16 579.6 Tm (necessar to render such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 362.88 579.36 Tm (an opinion. Tr. 9625-)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 465.12 579.36 Tm (9626 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 500.88 577.2 Tm (Q. And )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 109.92 565.68 Tm (your last hands-on )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 200.88 565.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 240 565.44 Tm (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.71 0 0 9.71 462.48 565.2 Tm (A. 1978)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 504.24 565.2 Tm (, 1\255)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 551.52 Tm (that is correct.")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 183.12 551.28 Tm (\); 9550-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.76 551.28 Tm (9551 \(1988-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.04 0 0 11.04 281.76 551.28 Tm (1998)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 305.04 551.04 Tm (, worked for lSD)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 385.44 551.04 Tm (, a fabless company with no )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.94 0 0 8.94 109.68 537.36 Tm (manufacturng\); 9628-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 217.92 537.12 Tm (9631 \(1999-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 276.72 537.12 Tm (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 109.68 523.2 Tm (how outdated 14-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 193.44 522.96 Tm (year-old )Tj 16.87 0 0 16.87 235.68 522.96 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 275.52 522.96 Tm (fabs could be used to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 378.96 522.72 Tm (manufactue other )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 469.44 522.96 Tm (products\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 109.2 494.88 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 116.2292 494.88 Tm (He failed to review any JEDEC records)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 308.4 494.64 Tm (, interview any JEDEC members)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 465.6 494.4 Tm (, or \(with very )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 480.72 Tm (few exceptions\) review the deposition or )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 7.93 0 0 7.93 307.92 480.48 Tm (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 507.12 480.24 Tm (9619\255)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 109.92 466.56 Tm (9623 \(")Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 145.92 464.16 Tm (Q. You never reviewed any )Tj 12.52 0 0 12.52 283.44 466.08 Tm (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 7.79 0 0 7.79 431.28 466.08 Tm (I did not. ... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 501.36 466.08 Tm (I never )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 109.92 452.4 Tm (spoke to a JEDEC member. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 423.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 116.2225 423.84 Tm (He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from )Tj 16.83 0 0 16.83 440.16 423.6 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 409.68 Tm (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 391.68 408.96 Tm (9618 \(")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 427.92 409.2 Tm (wanted to see cost )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 109.44 395.52 Tm (documents from a number of companes )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 306 395.04 Tm (" but they weren )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 388.32 395.04 Tm (t available\); 9666-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 476.88 395.04 Tm (9667 \(never )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 109.44 381.12 Tm (asked to obtain )Tj 13.31 0 0 13.31 184.56 381.12 Tm (DRA manufacturers)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 293.28 380.88 Tm (' cost information\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 108.72 352.8 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 115.7259 352.8 Tm (He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptanc\ e among )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 108.72 338.4 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 147.84 338.4 Tm (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 347.52 335.76 Tm (Q. Now)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 385.2 337.92 Tm (, what did you do to ensure that )Tj -23.156 -1.146 Td (the analysis that you did was the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.48 0 0 13.48 266.88 321.6 Tm (tye of )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 303.6 324 Tm (analysis that' )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 366.72 323.76 Tm (s done at JEDEC? A. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 477.6 323.76 Tm (I did not do )Tj 12.29 0 0 12.29 108.96 310.08 Tm (anything. I did my analysis. . . )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 108.24 281.76 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 118.5958 281.76 Tm (The sources )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.05 0 0 12.05 180.96 281.52 Tm (of his information )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 270.96 281.52 Tm (canot be identified)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 366.24 281.28 Tm (, and his calculations )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 469.92 281.28 Tm (canot be )Tj 8.56 0 0 8.56 108.48 267.6 Tm (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 227.28 267.12 Tm (9715 \(he couldn' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 309.12 267.12 Tm (t remember the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 384 267.12 Tm (manufactuers or par )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 490.56 267.12 Tm (numbers )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 253.44 Tm (of components for which he collected cost information; ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 382.56 252.96 Tm (I believe I specified one or two )Tj 12.67 0 0 12.67 108.48 239.28 Tm (companes)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 159.84 239.04 Tm (, and the others I didn' )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 267.84 238.8 Tm (t recall. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 143.76 140.4 Tm (Whether a method "' )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 247.68 140.4 Tm (has been subjected to peer review)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 409.92 140.16 Tm ('" and " )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 447.6 140.16 Tm (enjoys ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 485.28 140.16 Tm (general )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 72.24 126.48 Tm (acceptance)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 125.04 126.48 Tm (' within a ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 176.88 126.24 Tm (relevant scientific community)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 321.12 126 Tm ('" are factors in determining the reliability of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 112.08 Tm (an expert opinion. )Tj 18.432 0 Td (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 257.52 111.84 Tm (Carmichael )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.63 0 0 8.63 320.16 111.84 Tm (526 U.S. 137)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 383.04 111.6 Tm (, 149-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 412.08 111.6 Tm (150 \(1999\) \(citing )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.04 97.92 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 125.28 97.92 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 272.4 97.68 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 303.36 97.68 Tm (509 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.29 0 0 10.29 336 97.44 Tm (S. 579)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 366.48 97.44 Tm (, 592-)Tj 10.93 0 0 10.93 394.32 97.44 Tm (594 \(1993\)\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1642 0 obj<> endobj 1643 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 8.3 0 0 8.3 110.64 708.24 Tm (4.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.3 0 0 8.3 120.6 708.24 Tm ( Cost )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 150.48 708 Tm (comparisons would have shown that)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 324.96 707.52 Tm (, on a value-adjusted basis)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.27 0 0 10.27 453.36 707.76 Tm (, Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 679.68 Tm (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 324.72 679.2 Tm (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 74.64 650.88 Tm (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective \ than alternatives. Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.64 622.32 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 120.24 622.56 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 5.419 -0.02 Td (, however)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 231.6 622.32 Tm (, are fatally flawed and uneliable. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 109.68 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 119.5078 579.84 Tm (He lacked the experience )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 242.16 579.6 Tm (necessar to render such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 362.88 579.36 Tm (an opinion. Tr. 9625-)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 465.12 579.36 Tm (9626 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 500.88 577.2 Tm (Q. And )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 109.92 565.68 Tm (your last hands-on )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 200.88 565.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 240 565.44 Tm (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.71 0 0 9.71 462.48 565.2 Tm (A. 1978)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 504.24 565.2 Tm (, 1\255)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 551.52 Tm (that is correct.")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 183.12 551.28 Tm (\); 9550-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.76 551.28 Tm (9551 \(1988-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.04 0 0 11.04 281.76 551.28 Tm (1998)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 305.04 551.04 Tm (, worked for lSD)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 385.44 551.04 Tm (, a fabless company with no )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.94 0 0 8.94 109.68 537.36 Tm (manufacturng\); 9628-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 217.92 537.12 Tm (9631 \(1999-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 276.72 537.12 Tm (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 109.68 523.2 Tm (how outdated 14-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 193.44 522.96 Tm (year-old )Tj 16.87 0 0 16.87 235.68 522.96 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 275.52 522.96 Tm (fabs could be used to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 378.96 522.72 Tm (manufactue other )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 469.44 522.96 Tm (products\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 109.2 494.88 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 116.2292 494.88 Tm (He failed to review any JEDEC records)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 308.4 494.64 Tm (, interview any JEDEC members)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 465.6 494.4 Tm (, or \(with very )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 480.72 Tm (few exceptions\) review the deposition or )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 7.93 0 0 7.93 307.92 480.48 Tm (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 507.12 480.24 Tm (9619\255)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 109.92 466.56 Tm (9623 \(")Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 145.92 464.16 Tm (Q. You never reviewed any )Tj 12.52 0 0 12.52 283.44 466.08 Tm (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 7.79 0 0 7.79 431.28 466.08 Tm (I did not. ... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 501.36 466.08 Tm (I never )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 109.92 452.4 Tm (spoke to a JEDEC member. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 423.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 116.2225 423.84 Tm (He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from )Tj 16.83 0 0 16.83 440.16 423.6 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 409.68 Tm (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 391.68 408.96 Tm (9618 \(")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 427.92 409.2 Tm (wanted to see cost )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 109.44 395.52 Tm (documents from a number of companes )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 306 395.04 Tm (" but they weren )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 388.32 395.04 Tm (t available\); 9666-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 476.88 395.04 Tm (9667 \(never )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 109.44 381.12 Tm (asked to obtain )Tj 13.31 0 0 13.31 184.56 381.12 Tm (DRA manufacturers)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 293.28 380.88 Tm (' cost information\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 108.72 352.8 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 115.7259 352.8 Tm (He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptanc\ e among )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 108.72 338.4 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 147.84 338.4 Tm (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 347.52 335.76 Tm (Q. Now)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 385.2 337.92 Tm (, what did you do to ensure that )Tj -23.156 -1.146 Td (the analysis that you did was the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.48 0 0 13.48 266.88 321.6 Tm (tye of )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 303.6 324 Tm (analysis that' )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 366.72 323.76 Tm (s done at JEDEC? A. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 477.6 323.76 Tm (I did not do )Tj 12.29 0 0 12.29 108.96 310.08 Tm (anything. I did my analysis. . . )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 108.24 281.76 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 118.5958 281.76 Tm (The sources )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.05 0 0 12.05 180.96 281.52 Tm (of his information )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 270.96 281.52 Tm (canot be identified)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 366.24 281.28 Tm (, and his calculations )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 469.92 281.28 Tm (canot be )Tj 8.56 0 0 8.56 108.48 267.6 Tm (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 227.28 267.12 Tm (9715 \(he couldn' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 309.12 267.12 Tm (t remember the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 384 267.12 Tm (manufactuers or par )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 490.56 267.12 Tm (numbers )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 253.44 Tm (of components for which he collected cost information; ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 382.56 252.96 Tm (I believe I specified one or two )Tj 12.67 0 0 12.67 108.48 239.28 Tm (companes)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 159.84 239.04 Tm (, and the others I didn' )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 267.84 238.8 Tm (t recall. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 143.76 140.4 Tm (Whether a method "' )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 247.68 140.4 Tm (has been subjected to peer review)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 409.92 140.16 Tm ('" and " )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 447.6 140.16 Tm (enjoys ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 485.28 140.16 Tm (general )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 72.24 126.48 Tm (acceptance)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 125.04 126.48 Tm (' within a ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 176.88 126.24 Tm (relevant scientific community)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 321.12 126 Tm ('" are factors in determining the reliability of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 112.08 Tm (an expert opinion. )Tj 18.432 0 Td (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 257.52 111.84 Tm (Carmichael )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.63 0 0 8.63 320.16 111.84 Tm (526 U.S. 137)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 383.04 111.6 Tm (, 149-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 412.08 111.6 Tm (150 \(1999\) \(citing )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.04 97.92 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 125.28 97.92 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 272.4 97.68 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 303.36 97.68 Tm (509 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.29 0 0 10.29 336 97.44 Tm (S. 579)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 366.48 97.44 Tm (, 592-)Tj 10.93 0 0 10.93 394.32 97.44 Tm (594 \(1993\)\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1644 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 8.3 0 0 8.3 110.64 708.24 Tm (4.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.3 0 0 8.3 120.6 708.24 Tm ( Cost )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 150.48 708 Tm (comparisons would have shown that)Tj 12.18 0 0 12.18 324.96 707.52 Tm (, on a value-adjusted basis)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.27 0 0 10.27 453.36 707.76 Tm (, Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 679.68 Tm (technologies were less expensive than alternatives. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 324.72 679.2 Tm (Rambus relies solely on the opinion of Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 74.64 650.88 Tm (Geilhufe to argue that the Rambus technologies were more cost-effective \ than alternatives. Mr. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 74.64 622.32 Tm (Geilhufe )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 120.24 622.56 Tm (s conclusions)Tj 5.419 -0.02 Td (, however)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 231.6 622.32 Tm (, are fatally flawed and uneliable. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 109.68 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 119.5078 579.84 Tm (He lacked the experience )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 242.16 579.6 Tm (necessar to render such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 362.88 579.36 Tm (an opinion. Tr. 9625-)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 465.12 579.36 Tm (9626 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 500.88 577.2 Tm (Q. And )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 109.92 565.68 Tm (your last hands-on )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 200.88 565.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 240 565.44 Tm (design experience was in 1978. Is that right? )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.71 0 0 9.71 462.48 565.2 Tm (A. 1978)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.68 0 0 13.68 504.24 565.2 Tm (, 1\255)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 551.52 Tm (that is correct.")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 183.12 551.28 Tm (\); 9550-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 221.76 551.28 Tm (9551 \(1988-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.04 0 0 11.04 281.76 551.28 Tm (1998)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 305.04 551.04 Tm (, worked for lSD)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 385.44 551.04 Tm (, a fabless company with no )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.94 0 0 8.94 109.68 537.36 Tm (manufacturng\); 9628-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 217.92 537.12 Tm (9631 \(1999-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 276.72 537.12 Tm (2000 experience at Winbond consisted of analyzing )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.78 0 0 10.78 109.68 523.2 Tm (how outdated 14-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 193.44 522.96 Tm (year-old )Tj 16.87 0 0 16.87 235.68 522.96 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 275.52 522.96 Tm (fabs could be used to )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 378.96 522.72 Tm (manufactue other )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 469.44 522.96 Tm (products\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 109.2 494.88 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 116.2292 494.88 Tm (He failed to review any JEDEC records)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 308.4 494.64 Tm (, interview any JEDEC members)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 465.6 494.4 Tm (, or \(with very )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 109.92 480.72 Tm (few exceptions\) review the deposition or )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 7.93 0 0 7.93 307.92 480.48 Tm (tral testimony of relevant witnesses. Tr. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.53 0 0 11.53 507.12 480.24 Tm (9619\255)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 109.92 466.56 Tm (9623 \(")Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 145.92 464.16 Tm (Q. You never reviewed any )Tj 12.52 0 0 12.52 283.44 466.08 Tm (JEDEC meeting minutes? A. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 7.79 0 0 7.79 431.28 466.08 Tm (I did not. ... )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 501.36 466.08 Tm (I never )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 109.92 452.4 Tm (spoke to a JEDEC member. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 423.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 116.2225 423.84 Tm (He admitted he lacked cost documents and other information from )Tj 16.83 0 0 16.83 440.16 423.6 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 109.2 409.68 Tm (manufacturers essential to accurate calculations. Tr. 9617-)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 391.68 408.96 Tm (9618 \(")Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 427.92 409.2 Tm (wanted to see cost )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 109.44 395.52 Tm (documents from a number of companes )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 306 395.04 Tm (" but they weren )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 388.32 395.04 Tm (t available\); 9666-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.66 0 0 10.66 476.88 395.04 Tm (9667 \(never )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 109.44 381.12 Tm (asked to obtain )Tj 13.31 0 0 13.31 184.56 381.12 Tm (DRA manufacturers)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 293.28 380.88 Tm (' cost information\). )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 108.72 352.8 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 115.7259 352.8 Tm (He had no identifiable methodology, let alone one with general acceptanc\ e among )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 108.72 338.4 Tm (DRA )Tj 12.17 0 0 12.17 147.84 338.4 Tm (designers and manufacturers. Tr. 9622 \(")Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 347.52 335.76 Tm (Q. Now)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 385.2 337.92 Tm (, what did you do to ensure that )Tj -23.156 -1.146 Td (the analysis that you did was the )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.48 0 0 13.48 266.88 321.6 Tm (tye of )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 303.6 324 Tm (analysis that' )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 366.72 323.76 Tm (s done at JEDEC? A. )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 477.6 323.76 Tm (I did not do )Tj 12.29 0 0 12.29 108.96 310.08 Tm (anything. I did my analysis. . . )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 108.24 281.76 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 8.66 0 0 8.66 118.5958 281.76 Tm (The sources )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.05 0 0 12.05 180.96 281.52 Tm (of his information )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 270.96 281.52 Tm (canot be identified)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 366.24 281.28 Tm (, and his calculations )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 469.92 281.28 Tm (canot be )Tj 8.56 0 0 8.56 108.48 267.6 Tm (reconstrcted. Tr. 9711-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 227.28 267.12 Tm (9715 \(he couldn' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 309.12 267.12 Tm (t remember the )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 384 267.12 Tm (manufactuers or par )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 490.56 267.12 Tm (numbers )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 253.44 Tm (of components for which he collected cost information; ")Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 382.56 252.96 Tm (I believe I specified one or two )Tj 12.67 0 0 12.67 108.48 239.28 Tm (companes)Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 159.84 239.04 Tm (, and the others I didn' )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 267.84 238.8 Tm (t recall. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 143.76 140.4 Tm (Whether a method "' )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 247.68 140.4 Tm (has been subjected to peer review)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 409.92 140.16 Tm ('" and " )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.76 0 0 10.76 447.6 140.16 Tm (enjoys ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 485.28 140.16 Tm (general )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 72.24 126.48 Tm (acceptance)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 125.04 126.48 Tm (' within a ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 176.88 126.24 Tm (relevant scientific community)Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 321.12 126 Tm ('" are factors in determining the reliability of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 112.08 Tm (an expert opinion. )Tj 18.432 0 Td (Kumho Tire Co. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 16.272 -0.048 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.23 0 0 12.23 257.52 111.84 Tm (Carmichael )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.63 0 0 8.63 320.16 111.84 Tm (526 U.S. 137)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 383.04 111.6 Tm (, 149-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 412.08 111.6 Tm (150 \(1999\) \(citing )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 71.04 97.92 Tm (Daubert )Tj 8.736 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.26 0 0 12.26 125.28 97.92 Tm (Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 272.4 97.68 Tm (, Inc. )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 303.36 97.68 Tm (509 U.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.29 0 0 10.29 336 97.44 Tm (S. 579)Tj 10.61 0 0 10.61 366.48 97.44 Tm (, 592-)Tj 10.93 0 0 10.93 394.32 97.44 Tm (594 \(1993\)\). )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1645 0 obj<> endobj 1646 0 obj<> endobj 1647 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1648 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1649 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1650 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1651 0 obj<> endobj 1652 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1653 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1654 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1655 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.04 0 0 12.04 110.64 708 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 117.6492 708 Tm (He admitted that he had no way to test or verify his )Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 367.68 707.52 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9665-)Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 463.68 707.52 Tm (9666. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 110.4 679.44 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 16.96 0 0 16.96 120.7275 679.44 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 161.28 679.44 Tm (manufactuers \(his only potential )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 323.28 679.2 Tm (source of verification\) contradicted his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 110.88 665.28 Tm (opinions. Tr. 9666 \(if alternatives were implemented)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 366.48 664.8 Tm (, asking a )Tj 16.47 0 0 16.47 414.72 664.8 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 453.6 664.8 Tm (manufacturer )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 651.12 Tm (would be one way to verify his opinions\); 9680-)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 341.04 650.4 Tm (9691 \(Dr. Peisl ofInfineon disagreed )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 110.64 636.96 Tm (with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 201.36 636.48 Tm (s opinions\); Tr. 10995-)Tj 11.24 0 0 11.24 313.2 636.48 Tm (11009)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.6 0 0 10.6 342.24 636.24 Tm (, 11012-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 382.56 636.24 Tm (11019)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.73 0 0 10.73 412.08 636.24 Tm (, 11024-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 452.88 636.24 Tm (11038)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.53 0 0 10.53 481.92 636.48 Tm (, 11040\255)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 111.84 622.56 Tm (11042 \(Mr. Lee of Micron disagreed with Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 379.44 622.08 Tm (s assumptions and opinions\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 520.32 622.08 Tm (see )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 110.64 608.4 Tm (also )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 133.68 608.4 Tm (Tr. 9667 \(Geilhufe ")Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 231.6 608.16 Tm (cannot speak for the actual costs at a )Tj 13.93 0 0 13.93 409.68 607.92 Tm (DRA manufactuer )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 110.16 579.84 Tm (-)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.08 0 0 12.08 117.1825 579.84 Tm (His opinions require finding that IBM)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 301.44 579.6 Tm (, Intel)Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 329.04 579.36 Tm (, Texas Instruents)Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 422.88 579.36 Tm (, Samsung, Mitsubishi )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 110.88 565.68 Tm (Sun Microsystems)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 198.96 565.44 Tm (, Micron)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 240.24 565.2 Tm (, Silicon Graphics and Cray, among others)Tj 11.4 0 0 11.4 443.76 565.2 Tm (, acted ilTatiolially )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 109.92 551.52 Tm (by deliberately proposing or supporting allegedly inferior and more expe\ nsive )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 110.16 537.36 Tm (technologies at JEDEC. CC Appeal Brief91-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 330.48 536.88 Tm (95. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.29 0 0 12.29 73.44 509.04 Tm (For all ofthese reasons)Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 185.04 508.8 Tm (, the Commission should disregard entirely the testimony of Mr. Geilhufe\ )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.03 0 0 11.03 73.92 480.96 Tm (and Dr. Rapp \(who relied on Mr. Geilhufe \) as uneliable)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 344.16 480.24 Tm (, and find that JEDEC would have )Tj -22.615 -2.328 Td (adopted alternative technologies based on contemporaneous documents)Tj 11.85 0 0 11.85 416.4 451.92 Tm (, the testimony of JEDEC )Tj 12.05 0 0 12.05 73.2 424.08 Tm (members)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 118.08 424.08 Tm (, and the actual experience relating to the loop-)Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 342.24 423.36 Tm (back clock in March-)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.22 0 0 8.22 444.72 423.6 Tm (April 1997. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 73.2 395.52 Tm (Decision 74. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 109.92 366.96 Tm (5.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.12 0 0 12.12 119.01 366.96 Tm ( JEDEC members would )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 242.16 366.72 Tm (not have negotiated Rambus royalties down to zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.35 0 0 12.35 497.52 366.48 Tm (Even if )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 72.72 338.64 Tm (the Commission were to find )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 215.28 338.4 Tm (\(contrar to the )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 292.08 338.16 Tm (factual record\) that Rambus would have offered a )Tj 14.63 0 0 14.63 72.48 310.08 Tm (RA commitment)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 170.88 309.84 Tm (, JEDEC members would not have adopted alternatives)Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 436.08 309.6 Tm (, but rather would )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 72.24 282 Tm (have performed detailed)Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 189.12 281.52 Tm (, down-)Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 225.12 281.52 Tm (to-)Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 238.56 281.52 Tm (the-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 257.04 281.52 Tm (penny calculations extending over the 15+ year expected )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 72.48 253.44 Tm (life of Ram bus patents)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 180.96 253.2 Tm (, and that Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 9.548 -0.02 Td (s methodology is a reliable basis to support the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 144.48 195.6 Tm (Reliability of an expert opinion may also depend on whether it "' )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 456.96 195.12 Tm (can be \(and has )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.59 0 0 10.59 71.76 181.44 Tm (been\) tested' )Tj 11.19 0 0 11.19 147.6 181.44 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 211.92 181.2 Tm (526 U.)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.37 0 0 10.37 244.56 180.96 Tm (S. at 149. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 19.18 0 0 19.18 109.2 159.84 Tm (10 A ")Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.35 0 0 11.35 161.04 154.8 Tm (high ')Tj 10.95 0 0 10.95 188.88 154.8 Tm (known or potential rate of elTor)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 340.56 154.56 Tm ('" may be indicative )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.14 0 0 8.14 440.64 154.56 Tm (ofuneliability of an )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 72 140.88 Tm (expert opinion. \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.14 0 0 11.14 150.48 140.64 Tm (Kumho Tire )Tj 11.27 0 0 11.27 214.56 140.4 Tm (526 U.S. at 149. Mr. Geilhufe )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 13.14 0 0 13.14 365.04 140.16 Tm (s elTor rate is unown)Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 476.16 140.16 Tm (, since his )Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 71.76 126.48 Tm (opinions can )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 137.04 126.48 Tm (t be tested. His potential elTor )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.91 0 0 11.91 285.36 126.24 Tm (rate is high, as )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 357.12 126 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 396.24 126 Tm (manufacturers are the only )Tj 12.11 0 0 12.11 71.28 112.32 Tm (possible source of verifyng his opinions and representatives of )Tj 16.57 0 0 16.57 377.04 111.84 Tm (DRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 416.16 111.6 Tm (manufacturers rejected )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.05 0 0 11.05 71.28 98.16 Tm (his opinions. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1656 0 obj<> endobj 1657 0 obj<> endobj 1658 0 obj<> endobj 1659 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.06 0 0 12.06 74.64 708.24 Tm (Commission )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 139.92 708.24 Tm (s remedy findings)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 225.12 708 Tm (, Mr. Geilhufe )Tj 6.106 0 Td (s own calculations \(adjusted by the Commission to )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 74.16 679.92 Tm (reflect the factual record\) demonstrate that the marginal value of the \ Rambus technologies over )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 74.64 651.36 Tm (available alternatives was zero. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 31.008 -0.096 Td (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 249.84 650.88 Tm (CCB 6\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 110.64 622.8 Tm (The Commission should disregard the testimony of Rambus )Tj 12.33 0 0 12.33 402.24 622.08 Tm (s experts as uneliable and )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 7.78 0 0 7.78 74.16 594.48 Tm (irrelevant. The factual )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 186.24 594.24 Tm (evidence \(as opposed to theories and assumptions\) establishes that)Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 504.72 593.76 Tm (, absent )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 73.68 566.16 Tm (Rambus )Tj 11.77 0 0 11.77 118.08 565.92 Tm (s deception)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 171.84 565.92 Tm (, the JEDEC standards today would be free ofRambus )Tj 12.19 0 0 12.19 437.28 565.2 Tm (s patent claims. CCB )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.73 0 0 12.73 145.92 509.04 Tm (To Restore Competitive Conditions and Permit Effective Administration, )Tj 12.61 0 0 12.61 145.92 494.88 Tm (The Remedy Must Apply To All Technologies in the JEDEC )Tj 13.15 0 0 13.15 457.68 494.4 Tm (Standards )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 109.68 467.04 Tm (An effective remedy must address all \001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 290.64 466.56 Tm (nine )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 314.16 466.32 Tm (markets potentially impacted by Rambus)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 7.44 0 0 7.44 511.2 466.08 Tm (' s )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.04 0 0 12.04 73.44 438.48 Tm (deception)Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 120.72 438.48 Tm (, CCFF 3113-)Tj 5.592 -0.02 Td (3182)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 210.48 438.24 Tm (, and be capable of implementation without detailed review of )Tj 12.28 0 0 12.28 73.44 410.16 Tm (complex techncal issues and patent claims. Rambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 332.16 409.44 Tm (s arguent that )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 408.48 409.2 Tm (the remedy should be )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 381.6 Tm (limited to the four markets in which Rambus has successfully acquired mo\ nopoly power)Tj 11.6 0 0 11.6 497.28 380.88 Tm (, RB 9\255)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 85.44 353.28 Tm (, fails on both counts. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 108.96 324.72 Tm (Rambus would ensure that the greater the deception against an SSO)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 433.92 324 Tm (, the weaker the )Tj 12.26 0 0 12.26 72.24 296.4 Tm (remedy. A malfeasant that )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 204.72 295.92 Tm (deceived an SSO regarding multiple technologies could ensure that )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 72.72 267.84 Tm (any remedy would be inadequate by enforcing with respect to only one tec\ hnology at a time. )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 239.52 Tm (Any remedy would be limited only to that one market)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 329.76 238.8 Tm (, permitting the perpetrator immediately to )Tj 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.48 211.2 Tm (sue on the next technology. To the extent that the perpetrator were succ\ essful in compelling )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 72.24 182.64 Tm (companes to sign license agreements)Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 252.48 182.16 Tm (, the payments would continue throughout a series of )Tj 14.22 0 0 14.22 72 154.08 Tm (fritless )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 114.24 154.08 Tm (Commission enforcement actions. No situation could better explain the Su\ preme )Tj 12.96 0 0 12.96 72 125.52 Tm (Cour' )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 103.68 125.76 Tm (s statement that the Commission )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 263.52 125.04 Tm (s authority ")Tj 12.24 0 0 12.24 322.08 125.04 Tm (is not limited to prohibiting the ilegal )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1660 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 304.32 792 Tm (\); )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.64 707.76 Tm (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the \ past )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 432.72 707.28 Tm (" but extends to such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 74.88 679.2 Tm (other provisions as may be necessar to ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 273.12 678.96 Tm (close all roads to the prohibited goal)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 447.6 678.72 Tm (, so that its order )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 74.64 650.64 Tm (may not be by-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 146.16 650.64 Tm (passed with impunty. )Tj 5 0 0 5 262.56 650.4 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.77 0 0 8.77 299.28 650.4 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 370.08 650.16 Tm (343 U.)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 402.96 650.16 Tm (S. 470)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 433.68 650.4 Tm (, 473 \(1952\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.52 0 0 12.52 498.48 650.4 Tm (accord)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 288.48 650.4 Tm (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.98 0 0 7.98 73.92 622.32 Tm (International Salt )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 166.08 622.08 Tm (332 U.)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 198.96 621.84 Tm (S. at 400 \(")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 252.96 622.08 Tm (it is not necessar that all the untraveled )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 448.32 621.6 Tm (roads to that end be )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.64 593.76 Tm (left open and that only the worn one be closed. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 436.56 593.04 Tm (National Lead)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.4 0 0 11.4 506.4 593.28 Tm (, 332)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 317.04 593.28 Tm (see also United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 21.744 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 86.4 565.2 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 96.3887 565.2 Tm ( at 335-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 150.96 565.2 Tm (348-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 172.32 565.2 Tm (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which \ the )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 74.4 537.12 Tm (defendant in the )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 154.8 536.88 Tm (futue received an exclusive license. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 110.16 508.8 Tm (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer.\ )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 461.76 508.32 Tm (Any defendant )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.68 480.48 Tm (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim i\ n one of the relevant )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 73.68 452.16 Tm (markets could complain to the Commission)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 283.44 451.68 Tm (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 73.68 423.6 Tm (whether Rambus had violated the order. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.33 0 0 13.33 266.16 428.16 Tm (ll The )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 300.96 423.12 Tm (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 395.04 Tm (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple tech\ nologies. )Tj ET EMC /Figure <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 28.04 0 0 28.04 109.92 287.52 Tm (11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 144.96 282.72 Tm (As merely one example)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 258.48 282.24 Tm (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5 )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 446.4 282 Tm (915 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.12 0 0 8.12 468.48 282.24 Tm (105 patent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.2 268.32 Tm (against JEDEC-compliant products)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 242.4 268.08 Tm (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10 )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 254.16 Tm (was within the scope of its order: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 225.84 Tm (A memory device comprising: . . . an output )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.34 0 0 8.34 323.76 225.36 Tm (drver having an output coupled to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 108.96 211.68 Tm (the bus)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 143.76 211.68 Tm (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 382.08 211.2 Tm (, the output )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.31 0 0 12.31 439.44 211.2 Tm (drver for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 108.96 197.28 Tm (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; an\ d wherein )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.72 183.12 Tm (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multi\ plexer in )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 108.48 168.96 Tm (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 108.24 154.56 Tm (bus)Tj 1.448 0 Td (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 393.84 154.08 Tm (multiplexer in )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 140.4 Tm (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 108.24 126 Tm (bus. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 72.48 97.44 Tm (CX1516 at 30. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1661 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 304.32 792 Tm (\); )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.64 707.76 Tm (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the \ past )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 432.72 707.28 Tm (" but extends to such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 74.88 679.2 Tm (other provisions as may be necessar to ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 273.12 678.96 Tm (close all roads to the prohibited goal)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 447.6 678.72 Tm (, so that its order )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 74.64 650.64 Tm (may not be by-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 146.16 650.64 Tm (passed with impunty. )Tj 5 0 0 5 262.56 650.4 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.77 0 0 8.77 299.28 650.4 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 370.08 650.16 Tm (343 U.)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 402.96 650.16 Tm (S. 470)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 433.68 650.4 Tm (, 473 \(1952\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.52 0 0 12.52 498.48 650.4 Tm (accord)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 288.48 650.4 Tm (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.98 0 0 7.98 73.92 622.32 Tm (International Salt )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 166.08 622.08 Tm (332 U.)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 198.96 621.84 Tm (S. at 400 \(")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 252.96 622.08 Tm (it is not necessar that all the untraveled )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 448.32 621.6 Tm (roads to that end be )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.64 593.76 Tm (left open and that only the worn one be closed. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 436.56 593.04 Tm (National Lead)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.4 0 0 11.4 506.4 593.28 Tm (, 332)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 317.04 593.28 Tm (see also United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 21.744 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 86.4 565.2 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 96.3887 565.2 Tm ( at 335-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 150.96 565.2 Tm (348-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 172.32 565.2 Tm (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which \ the )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 74.4 537.12 Tm (defendant in the )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 154.8 536.88 Tm (futue received an exclusive license. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 110.16 508.8 Tm (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer.\ )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 461.76 508.32 Tm (Any defendant )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.68 480.48 Tm (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim i\ n one of the relevant )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 73.68 452.16 Tm (markets could complain to the Commission)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 283.44 451.68 Tm (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 73.68 423.6 Tm (whether Rambus had violated the order. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.33 0 0 13.33 266.16 428.16 Tm (ll The )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 300.96 423.12 Tm (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 395.04 Tm (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple tech\ nologies. )Tj ET EMC /Figure <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 28.04 0 0 28.04 109.92 287.52 Tm (11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 144.96 282.72 Tm (As merely one example)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 258.48 282.24 Tm (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5 )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 446.4 282 Tm (915 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.12 0 0 8.12 468.48 282.24 Tm (105 patent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.2 268.32 Tm (against JEDEC-compliant products)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 242.4 268.08 Tm (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10 )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 254.16 Tm (was within the scope of its order: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 225.84 Tm (A memory device comprising: . . . an output )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.34 0 0 8.34 323.76 225.36 Tm (drver having an output coupled to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 108.96 211.68 Tm (the bus)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 143.76 211.68 Tm (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 382.08 211.2 Tm (, the output )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.31 0 0 12.31 439.44 211.2 Tm (drver for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 108.96 197.28 Tm (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; an\ d wherein )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.72 183.12 Tm (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multi\ plexer in )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 108.48 168.96 Tm (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 108.24 154.56 Tm (bus)Tj 1.448 0 Td (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 393.84 154.08 Tm (multiplexer in )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 140.4 Tm (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 108.24 126 Tm (bus. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 72.48 97.44 Tm (CX1516 at 30. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1662 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 304.32 792 Tm (\); )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.64 707.76 Tm (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the \ past )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 432.72 707.28 Tm (" but extends to such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 74.88 679.2 Tm (other provisions as may be necessar to ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 273.12 678.96 Tm (close all roads to the prohibited goal)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 447.6 678.72 Tm (, so that its order )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 74.64 650.64 Tm (may not be by-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 146.16 650.64 Tm (passed with impunty. )Tj 5 0 0 5 262.56 650.4 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.77 0 0 8.77 299.28 650.4 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 370.08 650.16 Tm (343 U.)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 402.96 650.16 Tm (S. 470)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 433.68 650.4 Tm (, 473 \(1952\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.52 0 0 12.52 498.48 650.4 Tm (accord)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 288.48 650.4 Tm (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.98 0 0 7.98 73.92 622.32 Tm (International Salt )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 166.08 622.08 Tm (332 U.)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 198.96 621.84 Tm (S. at 400 \(")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 252.96 622.08 Tm (it is not necessar that all the untraveled )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 448.32 621.6 Tm (roads to that end be )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.64 593.76 Tm (left open and that only the worn one be closed. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 436.56 593.04 Tm (National Lead)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.4 0 0 11.4 506.4 593.28 Tm (, 332)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 317.04 593.28 Tm (see also United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 21.744 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 86.4 565.2 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 96.3887 565.2 Tm ( at 335-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 150.96 565.2 Tm (348-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 172.32 565.2 Tm (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which \ the )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 74.4 537.12 Tm (defendant in the )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 154.8 536.88 Tm (futue received an exclusive license. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 110.16 508.8 Tm (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer.\ )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 461.76 508.32 Tm (Any defendant )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.68 480.48 Tm (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim i\ n one of the relevant )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 73.68 452.16 Tm (markets could complain to the Commission)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 283.44 451.68 Tm (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 73.68 423.6 Tm (whether Rambus had violated the order. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.33 0 0 13.33 266.16 428.16 Tm (ll The )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 300.96 423.12 Tm (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 395.04 Tm (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple tech\ nologies. )Tj ET EMC /Figure <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 28.04 0 0 28.04 109.92 287.52 Tm (11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 144.96 282.72 Tm (As merely one example)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 258.48 282.24 Tm (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5 )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 446.4 282 Tm (915 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.12 0 0 8.12 468.48 282.24 Tm (105 patent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.2 268.32 Tm (against JEDEC-compliant products)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 242.4 268.08 Tm (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10 )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 254.16 Tm (was within the scope of its order: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 225.84 Tm (A memory device comprising: . . . an output )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.34 0 0 8.34 323.76 225.36 Tm (drver having an output coupled to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 108.96 211.68 Tm (the bus)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 143.76 211.68 Tm (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 382.08 211.2 Tm (, the output )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.31 0 0 12.31 439.44 211.2 Tm (drver for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 108.96 197.28 Tm (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; an\ d wherein )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.72 183.12 Tm (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multi\ plexer in )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 108.48 168.96 Tm (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 108.24 154.56 Tm (bus)Tj 1.448 0 Td (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 393.84 154.08 Tm (multiplexer in )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 140.4 Tm (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 108.24 126 Tm (bus. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 72.48 97.44 Tm (CX1516 at 30. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1663 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 304.32 792 Tm (\); )Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.1 0 0 12.1 74.64 707.76 Tm (practice in the precise form in which it is found tohave existed in the \ past )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 432.72 707.28 Tm (" but extends to such )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 74.88 679.2 Tm (other provisions as may be necessar to ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 273.12 678.96 Tm (close all roads to the prohibited goal)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 447.6 678.72 Tm (, so that its order )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 74.64 650.64 Tm (may not be by-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.27 0 0 12.27 146.16 650.64 Tm (passed with impunty. )Tj 5 0 0 5 262.56 650.4 Tm (FTC )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.77 0 0 8.77 299.28 650.4 Tm (Ruberoid Co. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.64 0 0 11.64 370.08 650.16 Tm (343 U.)Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 402.96 650.16 Tm (S. 470)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 433.68 650.4 Tm (, 473 \(1952\); )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.52 0 0 12.52 498.48 650.4 Tm (accord)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 288.48 650.4 Tm (v. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.98 0 0 7.98 73.92 622.32 Tm (International Salt )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 166.08 622.08 Tm (332 U.)Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 198.96 621.84 Tm (S. at 400 \(")Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 252.96 622.08 Tm (it is not necessar that all the untraveled )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.89 0 0 11.89 448.32 621.6 Tm (roads to that end be )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 74.64 593.76 Tm (left open and that only the worn one be closed. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.32 0 0 11.32 436.56 593.04 Tm (National Lead)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.4 0 0 11.4 506.4 593.28 Tm (, 332)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 317.04 593.28 Tm (see also United States )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 21.744 0 Td (v. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 86.4 565.2 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.57 0 0 10.57 96.3887 565.2 Tm ( at 335-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 150.96 565.2 Tm (348-)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 172.32 565.2 Tm (49 \(broad relief included later acquired patents and patents for which \ the )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 74.4 537.12 Tm (defendant in the )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 154.8 536.88 Tm (futue received an exclusive license. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 110.16 508.8 Tm (Additionally, a market-specific remedy would be difficult to administer.\ )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 461.76 508.32 Tm (Any defendant )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.68 480.48 Tm (believing that a Rambus enforcement action was based on a patent claim i\ n one of the relevant )Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 73.68 452.16 Tm (markets could complain to the Commission)Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 283.44 451.68 Tm (, asking it to interpret the claim and determine )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 73.68 423.6 Tm (whether Rambus had violated the order. )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 13.33 0 0 13.33 266.16 428.16 Tm (ll The )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.17 0 0 11.17 300.96 423.12 Tm (complexity of the necessar claim interpretation )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.98 0 0 11.98 73.44 395.04 Tm (would be compounded for claims combining elements based on multiple tech\ nologies. )Tj ET EMC /Figure <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 28.04 0 0 28.04 109.92 287.52 Tm (11 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 144.96 282.72 Tm (As merely one example)Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 258.48 282.24 Tm (, ifRambus were to try to enforce its 5 )Tj 11.36 0 0 11.36 446.4 282 Tm (915 )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.12 0 0 8.12 468.48 282.24 Tm (105 patent )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 73.2 268.32 Tm (against JEDEC-compliant products)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 242.4 268.08 Tm (, the Commission would have to determine whether claim 10 )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.72 254.16 Tm (was within the scope of its order: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.97 0 0 11.97 108.96 225.84 Tm (A memory device comprising: . . . an output )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8.34 0 0 8.34 323.76 225.36 Tm (drver having an output coupled to )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 108.96 211.68 Tm (the bus)Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 143.76 211.68 Tm (, an input coupled to the output of the multiplexer)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 382.08 211.2 Tm (, the output )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.31 0 0 12.31 439.44 211.2 Tm (drver for )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12 0 0 12 108.96 197.28 Tm (driving data on the bus in response to the output of the multiplexer; an\ d wherein )Tj 12.02 0 0 12.02 108.72 183.12 Tm (the multiplexer couples the first output line to the output of the multi\ plexer in )Tj 11.99 0 0 11.99 108.48 168.96 Tm (response to the first internal clock to provide even bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 12.1 0 0 12.1 108.24 154.56 Tm (bus)Tj 1.448 0 Td (, and couples the second output line to the output ofthe )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 393.84 154.08 Tm (multiplexer in )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 108.48 140.4 Tm (response to the second internal clock to provide odd bus cycle informati\ on to the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 108.24 126 Tm (bus. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.84 0 0 11.84 72.48 97.44 Tm (CX1516 at 30. )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1664 0 obj<> endobj 1665 0 obj<> endobj 1666 0 obj<> endobj 1667 0 obj<> endobj 1668 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.26 0 0 13.26 75.12 707.76 Tm (III. )Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.81 0 0 12.81 111.36 707.76 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 158.16 707.52 Tm (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.6 679.2 Tm (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.95 0 0 10.95 425.76 678.72 Tm (the Commission )Tj 11.41 0 0 11.41 74.88 650.88 Tm (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 310.08 650.4 Tm (The Commission protects the )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 453.6 650.16 Tm (integrty of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 74.64 622.32 Tm (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neith\ er the role nor the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 594 Tm (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should \ avoid )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 16.9 0 0 16.9 449.76 590.88 Tm (trng )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 481.2 593.28 Tm (to set a )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 565.68 Tm (royalty rate for Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 192 565.2 Tm (s technologies. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 110.4 537.12 Tm (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus ro\ yalties at a )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 74.4 509.04 Tm (level of at least 2.)Tj 12.38 0 0 12.38 159.6 508.8 Tm (5%. RB 14-)Tj 11.33 0 0 11.33 218.88 508.8 Tm (25. )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 246.96 508.56 Tm (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 472.8 508.32 Tm (- the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.16 480.72 Tm (Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 117.6 480.48 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.61 0 0 15.61 161.28 480.48 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 208.56 480.48 Tm (agreement - to justify its proposal. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 34.272 -0.096 Td (Id. )Tj 10.81 0 0 10.81 397.68 480 Tm (17-)Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 413.52 480 Tm (18. Rambus grossly )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 73.92 452.16 Tm (mischaracterizes this agreement. )Tj 12.47 0 0 12.47 235.68 451.92 Tm (Hyudai did )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 298.08 451.68 Tm (not initiate negotiations in response to a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.91 0 0 12.91 73.92 423.84 Tm (RaminkSyncLink-related )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 207.6 423.6 Tm (waring from Rambus. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 324.24 423.36 Tm (Id. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 361.68 423.12 Tm (In fact)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 392.64 423.12 Tm (, Rambus and )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 460.8 423.12 Tm (Hyudai)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 341.76 423.12 Tm (17. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 395.28 Tm (commenced negotiations for an )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 227.04 395.04 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 274.8 395.04 Tm (license in early 1995. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 402.48 394.32 Tm (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 520.8 394.56 Tm (62.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 382.56 394.56 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.92 366.72 Tm (The ")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.8 366.72 Tm (Other )Tj 15.86 0 0 15.86 130.8 366.72 Tm (DRA" )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 174.72 366.48 Tm (provision was included in the resulting )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 364.08 366.24 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.16 0 0 11.16 411.6 366.24 Tm (license. CX1599 at 2 )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.33 0 0 11.33 73.44 338.4 Tm (24. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 109.44 309.84 Tm (The Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 174 309.84 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 217.68 309.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 265.2 309.6 Tm (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 116.88 281.52 Tm (s deception. Indeed)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 212.16 281.28 Tm (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 439.44 280.8 Tm (s deception. )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 253.2 Tm (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies po\ tentially covered by its )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.73 0 0 13.73 109.68 216.72 Tm (12 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 188.4 211.68 Tm (s arguent that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 262.32 211.44 Tm (, pursuant to reasonable and non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 421.44 210.96 Tm (discriminatory tenns)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 521.04 210.96 Tm (, it )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 73.2 197.52 Tm (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 394.56 196.8 Tm (tent validity, RB 13-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.74 0 0 9.74 505.68 196.8 Tm (, has )Tj 11 0 0 11 72.48 183.36 Tm (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 385.44 182.64 Tm (, there is no reason why JEDEC )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.48 168.96 Tm (members would have accepted a )Tj 22.55 0 0 22.55 230.88 168.48 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 267.84 168.48 Tm (proposal that excluded any company that chose to )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 72.72 154.8 Tm (challenge the validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 234.96 154.56 Tm (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 478.08 154.08 Tm (s efforts to )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 140.4 Tm (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competi\ tive challenges )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 510.96 139.68 Tm (to the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 72.48 126.24 Tm (validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 168.48 126.24 Tm (s patents. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.33 0 0 12.33 243.6 126 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 473.28 125.52 Tm (Competition)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 218.4 126 Tm (See )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.48 112.08 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 231.12 111.84 Tm (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 97.68 Tm (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\)\ . )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1669 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.26 0 0 13.26 75.12 707.76 Tm (III. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.81 0 0 12.81 111.36 707.76 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 158.16 707.52 Tm (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.6 679.2 Tm (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.95 0 0 10.95 425.76 678.72 Tm (the Commission )Tj 11.41 0 0 11.41 74.88 650.88 Tm (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 310.08 650.4 Tm (The Commission protects the )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 453.6 650.16 Tm (integrty of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 74.64 622.32 Tm (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neith\ er the role nor the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 594 Tm (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should \ avoid )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 16.9 0 0 16.9 449.76 590.88 Tm (trng )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 481.2 593.28 Tm (to set a )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 565.68 Tm (royalty rate for Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 192 565.2 Tm (s technologies. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 110.4 537.12 Tm (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus ro\ yalties at a )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 74.4 509.04 Tm (level of at least 2.)Tj 12.38 0 0 12.38 159.6 508.8 Tm (5%. RB 14-)Tj 11.33 0 0 11.33 218.88 508.8 Tm (25. )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 246.96 508.56 Tm (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 472.8 508.32 Tm (- the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.16 480.72 Tm (Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 117.6 480.48 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.61 0 0 15.61 161.28 480.48 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 208.56 480.48 Tm (agreement - to justify its proposal. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 34.272 -0.096 Td (Id. )Tj 10.81 0 0 10.81 397.68 480 Tm (17-)Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 413.52 480 Tm (18. Rambus grossly )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 73.92 452.16 Tm (mischaracterizes this agreement. )Tj 12.47 0 0 12.47 235.68 451.92 Tm (Hyudai did )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 298.08 451.68 Tm (not initiate negotiations in response to a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.91 0 0 12.91 73.92 423.84 Tm (RaminkSyncLink-related )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 207.6 423.6 Tm (waring from Rambus. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 324.24 423.36 Tm (Id. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 361.68 423.12 Tm (In fact)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 392.64 423.12 Tm (, Rambus and )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 460.8 423.12 Tm (Hyudai)Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 341.76 423.12 Tm (17. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 395.28 Tm (commenced negotiations for an )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 227.04 395.04 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 274.8 395.04 Tm (license in early 1995. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 402.48 394.32 Tm (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 520.8 394.56 Tm (62.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 382.56 394.56 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.92 366.72 Tm (The ")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.8 366.72 Tm (Other )Tj 15.86 0 0 15.86 130.8 366.72 Tm (DRA" )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 174.72 366.48 Tm (provision was included in the resulting )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 364.08 366.24 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.16 0 0 11.16 411.6 366.24 Tm (license. CX1599 at 2 )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.33 0 0 11.33 73.44 338.4 Tm (24. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 109.44 309.84 Tm (The Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 174 309.84 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 217.68 309.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 265.2 309.6 Tm (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 116.88 281.52 Tm (s deception. Indeed)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 212.16 281.28 Tm (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 439.44 280.8 Tm (s deception. )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 253.2 Tm (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies po\ tentially covered by its )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.73 0 0 13.73 109.68 216.72 Tm (12 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 188.4 211.68 Tm (s arguent that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 262.32 211.44 Tm (, pursuant to reasonable and non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 421.44 210.96 Tm (discriminatory tenns)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 521.04 210.96 Tm (, it )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 73.2 197.52 Tm (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 394.56 196.8 Tm (tent validity, RB 13-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.74 0 0 9.74 505.68 196.8 Tm (, has )Tj 11 0 0 11 72.48 183.36 Tm (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 385.44 182.64 Tm (, there is no reason why JEDEC )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.48 168.96 Tm (members would have accepted a )Tj 22.55 0 0 22.55 230.88 168.48 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 267.84 168.48 Tm (proposal that excluded any company that chose to )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 72.72 154.8 Tm (challenge the validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 234.96 154.56 Tm (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 478.08 154.08 Tm (s efforts to )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 140.4 Tm (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competi\ tive challenges )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 510.96 139.68 Tm (to the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 72.48 126.24 Tm (validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 168.48 126.24 Tm (s patents. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.33 0 0 12.33 243.6 126 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 473.28 125.52 Tm (Competition)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 218.4 126 Tm (See )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.48 112.08 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 231.12 111.84 Tm (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 97.68 Tm (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\)\ . )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1670 0 obj<> endobj 1671 0 obj<> endobj 1672 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.26 0 0 13.26 75.12 707.76 Tm (III. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.81 0 0 12.81 111.36 707.76 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 158.16 707.52 Tm (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.6 679.2 Tm (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.95 0 0 10.95 425.76 678.72 Tm (the Commission )Tj 11.41 0 0 11.41 74.88 650.88 Tm (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 310.08 650.4 Tm (The Commission protects the )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 453.6 650.16 Tm (integrty of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 74.64 622.32 Tm (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neith\ er the role nor the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 594 Tm (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should \ avoid )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 16.9 0 0 16.9 449.76 590.88 Tm (trng )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 481.2 593.28 Tm (to set a )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 565.68 Tm (royalty rate for Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 192 565.2 Tm (s technologies. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 110.4 537.12 Tm (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus ro\ yalties at a )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 74.4 509.04 Tm (level of at least 2.)Tj 12.38 0 0 12.38 159.6 508.8 Tm (5%. RB 14-)Tj 11.33 0 0 11.33 218.88 508.8 Tm (25. )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 246.96 508.56 Tm (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 472.8 508.32 Tm (- the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.16 480.72 Tm (Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 117.6 480.48 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.61 0 0 15.61 161.28 480.48 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 208.56 480.48 Tm (agreement - to justify its proposal. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 34.272 -0.096 Td (Id. )Tj 10.81 0 0 10.81 397.68 480 Tm (17-)Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 413.52 480 Tm (18. Rambus grossly )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 73.92 452.16 Tm (mischaracterizes this agreement. )Tj 12.47 0 0 12.47 235.68 451.92 Tm (Hyudai did )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 298.08 451.68 Tm (not initiate negotiations in response to a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.91 0 0 12.91 73.92 423.84 Tm (RaminkSyncLink-related )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 207.6 423.6 Tm (waring from Rambus. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 324.24 423.36 Tm (Id. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 361.68 423.12 Tm (In fact)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 392.64 423.12 Tm (, Rambus and )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 460.8 423.12 Tm (Hyudai)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 341.76 423.12 Tm (17. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 395.28 Tm (commenced negotiations for an )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 227.04 395.04 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 274.8 395.04 Tm (license in early 1995. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 402.48 394.32 Tm (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 520.8 394.56 Tm (62.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 382.56 394.56 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.92 366.72 Tm (The ")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.8 366.72 Tm (Other )Tj 15.86 0 0 15.86 130.8 366.72 Tm (DRA" )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 174.72 366.48 Tm (provision was included in the resulting )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 364.08 366.24 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.16 0 0 11.16 411.6 366.24 Tm (license. CX1599 at 2 )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.33 0 0 11.33 73.44 338.4 Tm (24. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 109.44 309.84 Tm (The Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 174 309.84 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 217.68 309.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 265.2 309.6 Tm (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 116.88 281.52 Tm (s deception. Indeed)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 212.16 281.28 Tm (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 439.44 280.8 Tm (s deception. )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 253.2 Tm (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies po\ tentially covered by its )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.73 0 0 13.73 109.68 216.72 Tm (12 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 188.4 211.68 Tm (s arguent that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 262.32 211.44 Tm (, pursuant to reasonable and non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 421.44 210.96 Tm (discriminatory tenns)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 521.04 210.96 Tm (, it )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 73.2 197.52 Tm (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 394.56 196.8 Tm (tent validity, RB 13-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.74 0 0 9.74 505.68 196.8 Tm (, has )Tj 11 0 0 11 72.48 183.36 Tm (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 385.44 182.64 Tm (, there is no reason why JEDEC )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.48 168.96 Tm (members would have accepted a )Tj 22.55 0 0 22.55 230.88 168.48 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 267.84 168.48 Tm (proposal that excluded any company that chose to )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 72.72 154.8 Tm (challenge the validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 234.96 154.56 Tm (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 478.08 154.08 Tm (s efforts to )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 140.4 Tm (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competi\ tive challenges )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 510.96 139.68 Tm (to the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 72.48 126.24 Tm (validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 168.48 126.24 Tm (s patents. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.33 0 0 12.33 243.6 126 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 473.28 125.52 Tm (Competition)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 218.4 126 Tm (See )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.48 112.08 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 231.12 111.84 Tm (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 97.68 Tm (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\)\ . )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1673 0 obj<> endobj 1674 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /Span <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.26 0 0 13.26 75.12 707.76 Tm (III. )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.81 0 0 12.81 111.36 707.76 Tm (Rambus )Tj 12.72 0 0 12.72 158.16 707.52 Tm (s Proposed Royalty Rates Are Palpably Unreasonable )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.07 0 0 12.07 111.6 679.2 Tm (Complaint Counsel agree with Rambus on one critical principle: )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.95 0 0 10.95 425.76 678.72 Tm (the Commission )Tj 11.41 0 0 11.41 74.88 650.88 Tm (nonnally avoids direct price regulation. RB 15. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 310.08 650.4 Tm (The Commission protects the )Tj 12.99 0 0 12.99 453.6 650.16 Tm (integrty of )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.88 0 0 10.88 74.64 622.32 Tm (markets and allows markets to detennine prices. The Commission has neith\ er the role nor the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 594 Tm (ability to regulate prices. This is precisely why the Commission should \ avoid )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 16.9 0 0 16.9 449.76 590.88 Tm (trng )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 481.2 593.28 Tm (to set a )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 565.68 Tm (royalty rate for Rambus )Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 192 565.2 Tm (s technologies. )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 110.4 537.12 Tm (Rambus nevertheless argues that the Commission should regulate Rambus ro\ yalties at a )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 74.4 509.04 Tm (level of at least 2.)Tj 12.38 0 0 12.38 159.6 508.8 Tm (5%. RB 14-)Tj 11.33 0 0 11.33 218.88 508.8 Tm (25. )Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 246.96 508.56 Tm (Rambus relies primarly on a single agreement )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 8 0 0 8 472.8 508.32 Tm (- the )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.96 0 0 11.96 74.16 480.72 Tm (Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 117.6 480.48 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.61 0 0 15.61 161.28 480.48 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 208.56 480.48 Tm (agreement - to justify its proposal. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 34.272 -0.096 Td (Id. )Tj 10.81 0 0 10.81 397.68 480 Tm (17-)Tj 12.25 0 0 12.25 413.52 480 Tm (18. Rambus grossly )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.82 0 0 10.82 73.92 452.16 Tm (mischaracterizes this agreement. )Tj 12.47 0 0 12.47 235.68 451.92 Tm (Hyudai did )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.02 0 0 12.02 298.08 451.68 Tm (not initiate negotiations in response to a )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.91 0 0 12.91 73.92 423.84 Tm (RaminkSyncLink-related )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 207.6 423.6 Tm (waring from Rambus. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 324.24 423.36 Tm (Id. )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 361.68 423.12 Tm (In fact)Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 392.64 423.12 Tm (, Rambus and )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 460.8 423.12 Tm (Hyudai)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 341.76 423.12 Tm (17. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 74.16 395.28 Tm (commenced negotiations for an )Tj 15.77 0 0 15.77 227.04 395.04 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 274.8 395.04 Tm (license in early 1995. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 402.48 394.32 Tm (CX0782; CX0711 at 61-)Tj 11.14 0 0 11.14 520.8 394.56 Tm (62.)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 382.56 394.56 Tm (See )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 73.92 366.72 Tm (The ")Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 100.8 366.72 Tm (Other )Tj 15.86 0 0 15.86 130.8 366.72 Tm (DRA" )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 174.72 366.48 Tm (provision was included in the resulting )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 364.08 366.24 Tm (RDRA )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.16 0 0 11.16 411.6 366.24 Tm (license. CX1599 at 2 )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.33 0 0 11.33 73.44 338.4 Tm (24. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 109.44 309.84 Tm (The Rambus-)Tj 13.68 0 0 13.68 174 309.84 Tm (Hyudai )Tj 15.69 0 0 15.69 217.68 309.84 Tm (RDRA )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 265.2 309.6 Tm (agreement does not represent the likely outcome absent )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 72.96 281.52 Tm (Rambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.86 0 0 10.86 116.88 281.52 Tm (s deception. Indeed)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.11 0 0 12.11 212.16 281.28 Tm (, this agreement was also a product ofRambus )Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 439.44 280.8 Tm (s deception. )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 72.96 253.2 Tm (Although internally, Rambus had identified five specific technologies po\ tentially covered by its )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 13.73 0 0 13.73 109.68 216.72 Tm (12 Rambus )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.01 0 0 12.01 188.4 211.68 Tm (s arguent that)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 262.32 211.44 Tm (, pursuant to reasonable and non-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.12 0 0 11.12 421.44 210.96 Tm (discriminatory tenns)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 521.04 210.96 Tm (, it )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 73.2 197.52 Tm (should be pennitted to discriminate against those who challenge p )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 394.56 196.8 Tm (tent validity, RB 13-)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 9.74 0 0 9.74 505.68 196.8 Tm (, has )Tj 11 0 0 11 72.48 183.36 Tm (no record support. Given the technological alternatives available)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 385.44 182.64 Tm (, there is no reason why JEDEC )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 72.48 168.96 Tm (members would have accepted a )Tj 22.55 0 0 22.55 230.88 168.48 Tm (RA )Tj 11.98 0 0 11.98 267.84 168.48 Tm (proposal that excluded any company that chose to )Tj 12.14 0 0 12.14 72.72 154.8 Tm (challenge the validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.84 0 0 10.84 234.96 154.56 Tm (s patents. The Commission should resist Rambus )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.79 0 0 11.79 478.08 154.08 Tm (s efforts to )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 72.48 140.4 Tm (use it as a weapon to compel companes to abandon potentially pro-competi\ tive challenges )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 510.96 139.68 Tm (to the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.59 0 0 11.59 72.48 126.24 Tm (validity ofRambus )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 168.48 126.24 Tm (s patents. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 12.33 0 0 12.33 243.6 126 Tm (To Promote Inovation: The Proper Balance of )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 473.28 125.52 Tm (Competition)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 218.4 126 Tm (See )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 72.48 112.08 Tm (and Patent Law and Policy" at 5-)Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 231.12 111.84 Tm (18 \(October 2003\) \(recommending legislation to pennit )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 72.24 97.68 Tm (challenges to patent validity based on a preponderance of the evidence\)\ . )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1675 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.11 0 0 13.11 319.68 792 Tm (" ")Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 708.72 Tm (patents)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 109.92 708.72 Tm (, it refused to ")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 180.96 708.48 Tm (alert them to a potential problem they can easily work around.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.31 0 0 10.31 477.12 707.28 Tm (" CX0711 )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 75.6 680.16 Tm (73.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 90.522 680.16 Tm ( Instead)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 130.8 679.92 Tm (, Rambus merely stated vaguely that unspecified patents might cover undi\ sclosed )Tj 12.48 0 0 12.48 75.36 651.84 Tm (aspects ofSynclink. RX-)Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 198 651.36 Tm (0663 at 2. Thus)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 275.28 651.12 Tm (, Hyundai had no opportunty to assess the veracity and )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 75.36 623.28 Tm (strength of Ram bus )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 172.8 622.8 Tm (s claim)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 207.36 622.8 Tm (, to avoid Rambus patents by proposing specific alternatives within )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 75.36 594.72 Tm (SyncLink)Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 121.2 594.48 Tm (, or to negotiate with alternatives in mind. )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 327.12 594 Tm (Many companies thought the changes from )Tj 13.66 0 0 13.66 74.64 566.4 Tm (Ramink to )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 135.36 565.92 Tm (SyncLink \(shifting from a fully to a partially multiplexed bus architec\ ture\) would be )Tj -5.07 -2.334 Td (sufficient to avoid Rambus)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.51 0 0 10.51 204.96 537.6 Tm (' s patents. )Tj 11.32 0 0 11.32 258.72 537.36 Tm (CCFF 1571. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 323.52 537.12 Tm (Hyudai used )Tj 12.07 0 0 12.07 392.64 536.88 Tm (the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.15 0 0 14.15 410.4 536.88 Tm (opportty of )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 481.2 536.88 Tm (the on\255)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 509.76 Tm (going )Tj 15.45 0 0 15.45 104.4 509.76 Tm (RDRA )Tj 12 0 0 12 151.2 509.52 Tm (negotiations to obtain ")Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 263.52 509.28 Tm (insurance)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 309.12 509.04 Tm (" in case it )Tj 17.04 0 0 17.04 363.36 508.8 Tm (tued )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 396.96 508.56 Tm (out that Rambus )Tj 12 0 0 12 479.28 508.56 Tm (s patents did )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.4 481.44 Tm (cover SyncLink. CCFF 1550-)Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 220.08 480.96 Tm (1552. Because ofthe vagueness ofthe infonnation and the )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 73.92 453.12 Tm (technological changes to SyncLink)Tj 12.77 0 0 12.77 241.44 452.64 Tm (, Hyudai never )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 320.16 452.16 Tm (thought the 2.5% rate would ever apply. )Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 74.16 424.56 Tm (CCFF 1552. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 109.68 396 Tm (Rambus also relies on its assertion that a hand-)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 334.32 395.28 Tm (picked selection of a limited number of )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 73.68 367.68 Tm (license agreements)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 164.4 367.44 Tm (, for an )Tj 12.89 0 0 12.89 201.12 367.2 Tm (unkown number )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 288.48 366.96 Tm (of unspecified patents relating to )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 448.08 366.48 Tm (unkown )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 73.2 339.12 Tm (technologies used in unidentified products)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 276.24 338.64 Tm (, cared royalty )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 354.48 338.16 Tm (rates in excess of 3.5%. RB 18-)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 508.32 337.92 Tm (20. )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 72.96 310.8 Tm (The Commission already rej ected this )Tj 15.3 0 0 15.3 257.52 310.32 Tm (arguent. )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 311.04 310.08 Tm (Decision 115 n. 624 \(comparng licenses for )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 72.96 282.48 Tm (different technologies ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.27 0 0 11.27 185.52 282 Tm (mixes ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 221.76 282 Tm (apples and oranges )Tj 12 0 0 12 332.88 281.52 Tm (Rambus fails to provide a basis for treating )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.75 0 0 10.75 72.48 254.16 Tm (the referenced licensing arangements as comparable to licenses for the t\ echnologies at issue in )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.62 0 0 7.62 72.48 225.6 Tm (the present case. )Tj 7.51 0 0 7.51 156.48 225.12 Tm (\). Similarly, the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 237.6 225.12 Tm (Commission already dismissed Rambus )Tj 16.348 -0.06 Td (s attempt to rely on a )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.24 197.28 Tm (vague)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 101.28 197.04 Tm (, abstract and unsupported passage in an IBM manual. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 52.8 -0.144 Td (Id. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 391.2 196.08 Tm (The record contains no )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 168.72 Tm (evidence)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 115.2 168.48 Tm (, however)Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 162.24 168.48 Tm (, that IBM' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 215.52 168.24 Tm (s rates reflected royalties for )Tj 13.37 0 0 13.37 353.76 167.76 Tm (DRA technologies)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 453.6 167.52 Tm (, or even that the )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 71.76 140.16 Tm (rates stated in IBM' )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 167.52 139.92 Tm (s policy ever actually applied )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 309.6 139.2 Tm (" and noting that)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 390.48 138.96 Tm (, unlike Rambus )Tj 16.4 0 0 16.4 479.52 138.96 Tm (DRA\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1676 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 13.11 0 0 13.11 319.68 792 Tm (" ")Tj ET EMC /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 12.03 0 0 12.03 75.12 708.72 Tm (patents)Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 109.92 708.72 Tm (, it refused to ")Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 180.96 708.48 Tm (alert them to a potential problem they can easily work around.)Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 10.31 0 0 10.31 477.12 707.28 Tm (" CX0711 )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 75.6 680.16 Tm (73.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 90.522 680.16 Tm ( Instead)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 130.8 679.92 Tm (, Rambus merely stated vaguely that unspecified patents might cover undi\ sclosed )Tj 12.48 0 0 12.48 75.36 651.84 Tm (aspects ofSynclink. RX-)Tj 12.31 0 0 12.31 198 651.36 Tm (0663 at 2. Thus)Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 275.28 651.12 Tm (, Hyundai had no opportunty to assess the veracity and )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 75.36 623.28 Tm (strength of Ram bus )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 172.8 622.8 Tm (s claim)Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 207.36 622.8 Tm (, to avoid Rambus patents by proposing specific alternatives within )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 75.36 594.72 Tm (SyncLink)Tj 12.12 0 0 12.12 121.2 594.48 Tm (, or to negotiate with alternatives in mind. )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 327.12 594 Tm (Many companies thought the changes from )Tj 13.66 0 0 13.66 74.64 566.4 Tm (Ramink to )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 135.36 565.92 Tm (SyncLink \(shifting from a fully to a partially multiplexed bus architec\ ture\) would be )Tj -5.07 -2.334 Td (sufficient to avoid Rambus)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.51 0 0 10.51 204.96 537.6 Tm (' s patents. )Tj 11.32 0 0 11.32 258.72 537.36 Tm (CCFF 1571. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 13.1 0 0 13.1 323.52 537.12 Tm (Hyudai used )Tj 12.07 0 0 12.07 392.64 536.88 Tm (the )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 14.15 0 0 14.15 410.4 536.88 Tm (opportty of )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 481.2 536.88 Tm (the on\255)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 74.4 509.76 Tm (going )Tj 15.45 0 0 15.45 104.4 509.76 Tm (RDRA )Tj 12 0 0 12 151.2 509.52 Tm (negotiations to obtain ")Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 263.52 509.28 Tm (insurance)Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 309.12 509.04 Tm (" in case it )Tj 17.04 0 0 17.04 363.36 508.8 Tm (tued )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 396.96 508.56 Tm (out that Rambus )Tj 12 0 0 12 479.28 508.56 Tm (s patents did )Tj 12.13 0 0 12.13 74.4 481.44 Tm (cover SyncLink. CCFF 1550-)Tj 12.34 0 0 12.34 220.08 480.96 Tm (1552. Because ofthe vagueness ofthe infonnation and the )Tj 11.91 0 0 11.91 73.92 453.12 Tm (technological changes to SyncLink)Tj 12.77 0 0 12.77 241.44 452.64 Tm (, Hyudai never )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 320.16 452.16 Tm (thought the 2.5% rate would ever apply. )Tj 11.74 0 0 11.74 74.16 424.56 Tm (CCFF 1552. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 109.68 396 Tm (Rambus also relies on its assertion that a hand-)Tj 12.09 0 0 12.09 334.32 395.28 Tm (picked selection of a limited number of )Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 73.68 367.68 Tm (license agreements)Tj 11.81 0 0 11.81 164.4 367.44 Tm (, for an )Tj 12.89 0 0 12.89 201.12 367.2 Tm (unkown number )Tj 11.95 0 0 11.95 288.48 366.96 Tm (of unspecified patents relating to )Tj 13.86 0 0 13.86 448.08 366.48 Tm (unkown )Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 73.2 339.12 Tm (technologies used in unidentified products)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.93 0 0 11.93 276.24 338.64 Tm (, cared royalty )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 12.16 0 0 12.16 354.48 338.16 Tm (rates in excess of 3.5%. RB 18-)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 508.32 337.92 Tm (20. )Tj 11.78 0 0 11.78 72.96 310.8 Tm (The Commission already rej ected this )Tj 15.3 0 0 15.3 257.52 310.32 Tm (arguent. )Tj 12.2 0 0 12.2 311.04 310.08 Tm (Decision 115 n. 624 \(comparng licenses for )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 72.96 282.48 Tm (different technologies ")Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.27 0 0 11.27 185.52 282 Tm (mixes ' )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 221.76 282 Tm (apples and oranges )Tj 12 0 0 12 332.88 281.52 Tm (Rambus fails to provide a basis for treating )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 10.75 0 0 10.75 72.48 254.16 Tm (the referenced licensing arangements as comparable to licenses for the t\ echnologies at issue in )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 7.62 0 0 7.62 72.48 225.6 Tm (the present case. )Tj 7.51 0 0 7.51 156.48 225.12 Tm (\). Similarly, the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.95 0 0 11.95 237.6 225.12 Tm (Commission already dismissed Rambus )Tj 16.348 -0.06 Td (s attempt to rely on a )Tj ET EMC /StyleSpan <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.24 197.28 Tm (vague)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 101.28 197.04 Tm (, abstract and unsupported passage in an IBM manual. )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 52.8 -0.144 Td (Id. )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 391.2 196.08 Tm (The record contains no )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 168.72 Tm (evidence)Tj 11.87 0 0 11.87 115.2 168.48 Tm (, however)Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 162.24 168.48 Tm (, that IBM' )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 215.52 168.24 Tm (s rates reflected royalties for )Tj 13.37 0 0 13.37 353.76 167.76 Tm (DRA technologies)Tj 11.94 0 0 11.94 453.6 167.52 Tm (, or even that the )Tj 11.83 0 0 11.83 71.76 140.16 Tm (rates stated in IBM' )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 167.52 139.92 Tm (s policy ever actually applied )Tj 12.08 0 0 12.08 309.6 139.2 Tm (" and noting that)Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 390.48 138.96 Tm (, unlike Rambus )Tj 16.4 0 0 16.4 479.52 138.96 Tm (DRA\255)Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1677 0 obj<> endobj 1678 0 obj<> endobj 1679 0 obj<> endobj 1680 0 obj<> endobj 1681 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.78 0 0 12.78 227.52 706.8 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11 0 0 11 113.52 679.2 Tm (, Beverly A. Dodson)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 211.2 678.48 Tm (, hereby certify that on September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 393.12 677.76 Tm (2006)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 417.36 677.76 Tm (, I caused a copy ofthe )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 73.68 664.8 Tm (attached )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 119.52 664.8 Tm (Complaint Counsel' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 215.28 664.32 Tm (s Reply Brief On Remedy, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 341.28 663.6 Tm (to be served upon the following persons: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 73.68 622.08 Tm (by hand delivery to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.29 0 0 9.29 73.44 593.76 Tm (The Commissioners\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 85.44 579.36 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 94.9992 579.36 Tm ( 鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.29 0 0 11.29 73.44 565.2 Tm (Office of the Secretar, Room H-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 233.28 564.48 Tm (135 )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 551.04 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 73.2 536.88 Tm (600 Pennsylvania Ave.)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 182.88 536.4 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.96 522.72 Tm (Washington)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.49 0 0 10.49 130.32 522.48 Tm (, D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 147.84 522.48 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.99 0 0 10.99 72.96 494.4 Tm (by electronic transmission and courier to: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.48 466.08 Tm (A.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 84.0079 466.08 Tm ( Douglas Melamed)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 174.72 465.6 Tm (, Esq. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 72.72 451.92 Tm (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 73.68 437.76 Tm (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.25 0 0 11.25 202.8 437.28 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 423.6 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 130.08 423.36 Tm (, DC 20006 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.24 395.28 Tm (and by electronic transmission and overnight )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 291.84 394.32 Tm (courier to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.56 0 0 8.56 72.48 366.96 Tm (Steven M. Perr, Esq.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72 353.04 Tm (Munger)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 109.92 352.8 Tm (, Tolles & Olson LLP )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 72 338.64 Tm (355 South Grand Avenue )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 92.4 324.72 Tm (Floor )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 71.52 310.56 Tm (Los Angeles)Tj 11.54 0 0 11.54 131.28 310.32 Tm (, CA 90071 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 71.76 282 Tm (Counsel for Rambus )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 171.36 281.76 Tm (Incorporated )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1682 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.78 0 0 12.78 227.52 706.8 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11 0 0 11 113.52 679.2 Tm (, Beverly A. Dodson)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 211.2 678.48 Tm (, hereby certify that on September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 393.12 677.76 Tm (2006)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 417.36 677.76 Tm (, I caused a copy ofthe )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 73.68 664.8 Tm (attached )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 119.52 664.8 Tm (Complaint Counsel' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 215.28 664.32 Tm (s Reply Brief On Remedy, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 341.28 663.6 Tm (to be served upon the following persons: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 73.68 622.08 Tm (by hand delivery to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.29 0 0 9.29 73.44 593.76 Tm (The Commissioners\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 85.44 579.36 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 94.9992 579.36 Tm ( 鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.29 0 0 11.29 73.44 565.2 Tm (Office of the Secretar, Room H-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 233.28 564.48 Tm (135 )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 551.04 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 73.2 536.88 Tm (600 Pennsylvania Ave.)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 182.88 536.4 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.96 522.72 Tm (Washington)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.49 0 0 10.49 130.32 522.48 Tm (, D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 147.84 522.48 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.99 0 0 10.99 72.96 494.4 Tm (by electronic transmission and courier to: )Tj ET EMC /LI_Label <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.48 466.08 Tm (A.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 84.0079 466.08 Tm ( Douglas Melamed)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 174.72 465.6 Tm (, Esq. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 72.72 451.92 Tm (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 73.68 437.76 Tm (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.25 0 0 11.25 202.8 437.28 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 423.6 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 130.08 423.36 Tm (, DC 20006 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.24 395.28 Tm (and by electronic transmission and overnight )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 291.84 394.32 Tm (courier to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.56 0 0 8.56 72.48 366.96 Tm (Steven M. Perr, Esq.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72 353.04 Tm (Munger)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 109.92 352.8 Tm (, Tolles & Olson LLP )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 72 338.64 Tm (355 South Grand Avenue )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 92.4 324.72 Tm (Floor )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 71.52 310.56 Tm (Los Angeles)Tj 11.54 0 0 11.54 131.28 310.32 Tm (, CA 90071 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 71.76 282 Tm (Counsel for Rambus )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 171.36 281.76 Tm (Incorporated )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1683 0 obj<> endobj 1684 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.78 0 0 12.78 227.52 706.8 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11 0 0 11 113.52 679.2 Tm (, Beverly A. Dodson)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 211.2 678.48 Tm (, hereby certify that on September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 393.12 677.76 Tm (2006)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 417.36 677.76 Tm (, I caused a copy ofthe )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 73.68 664.8 Tm (attached )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 119.52 664.8 Tm (Complaint Counsel' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 215.28 664.32 Tm (s Reply Brief On Remedy, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 341.28 663.6 Tm (to be served upon the following persons: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 73.68 622.08 Tm (by hand delivery to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.29 0 0 9.29 73.44 593.76 Tm (The Commissioners\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 85.44 579.36 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 94.9992 579.36 Tm ( 鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.29 0 0 11.29 73.44 565.2 Tm (Office of the Secretar, Room H-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 233.28 564.48 Tm (135 )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 551.04 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 73.2 536.88 Tm (600 Pennsylvania Ave.)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 182.88 536.4 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.96 522.72 Tm (Washington)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.49 0 0 10.49 130.32 522.48 Tm (, D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 147.84 522.48 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.99 0 0 10.99 72.96 494.4 Tm (by electronic transmission and courier to: )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.48 466.08 Tm (A.)Tj ET EMC /LI_Title <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 84.0079 466.08 Tm ( Douglas Melamed)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 174.72 465.6 Tm (, Esq. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 72.72 451.92 Tm (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 73.68 437.76 Tm (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.25 0 0 11.25 202.8 437.28 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 423.6 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 130.08 423.36 Tm (, DC 20006 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.24 395.28 Tm (and by electronic transmission and overnight )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 291.84 394.32 Tm (courier to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.56 0 0 8.56 72.48 366.96 Tm (Steven M. Perr, Esq.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72 353.04 Tm (Munger)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 109.92 352.8 Tm (, Tolles & Olson LLP )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 72 338.64 Tm (355 South Grand Avenue )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 92.4 324.72 Tm (Floor )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 71.52 310.56 Tm (Los Angeles)Tj 11.54 0 0 11.54 131.28 310.32 Tm (, CA 90071 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 71.76 282 Tm (Counsel for Rambus )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 171.36 281.76 Tm (Incorporated )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1685 0 obj<>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC /P <>BDC 0 g 1 i BT /T1_0 1 Tf 0 Tc 0 Tw 0 Ts 100 Tz 3 Tr 12.78 0 0 12.78 227.52 706.8 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11 0 0 11 113.52 679.2 Tm (, Beverly A. Dodson)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.81 0 0 11.81 211.2 678.48 Tm (, hereby certify that on September 29 )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 393.12 677.76 Tm (2006)Tj 12.03 0 0 12.03 417.36 677.76 Tm (, I caused a copy ofthe )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 73.68 664.8 Tm (attached )Tj 11.88 0 0 11.88 119.52 664.8 Tm (Complaint Counsel' )Tj /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 215.28 664.32 Tm (s Reply Brief On Remedy, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.83 0 0 11.83 341.28 663.6 Tm (to be served upon the following persons: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.77 0 0 10.77 73.68 622.08 Tm (by hand delivery to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 9.29 0 0 9.29 73.44 593.76 Tm (The Commissioners\001)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 85.44 579.36 Tm (S.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 94.9992 579.36 Tm ( 鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.29 0 0 11.29 73.44 565.2 Tm (Office of the Secretar, Room H-)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 10.56 0 0 10.56 233.28 564.48 Tm (135 )Tj 11.9 0 0 11.9 72.96 551.04 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 73.2 536.88 Tm (600 Pennsylvania Ave.)Tj 11.25 0 0 11.25 182.88 536.4 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.96 522.72 Tm (Washington)Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.49 0 0 10.49 130.32 522.48 Tm (, D.)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.78 0 0 11.78 147.84 522.48 Tm (C. 20580 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.99 0 0 10.99 72.96 494.4 Tm (by electronic transmission and courier to: )Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 72.48 466.08 Tm (A.)Tj ET EMC /Span <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.86 0 0 11.86 84.0079 466.08 Tm ( Douglas Melamed)Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 174.72 465.6 Tm (, Esq. )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 11.1 0 0 11.1 72.72 451.92 Tm (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and DOff LLP )Tj 10.79 0 0 10.79 73.68 437.76 Tm (1875 Pennsylvana Avenue)Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.25 0 0 11.25 202.8 437.28 Tm (, N. )Tj 11.82 0 0 11.82 72.48 423.6 Tm (Washington)Tj 11.8 0 0 11.8 130.08 423.36 Tm (, DC 20006 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 12.06 0 0 12.06 72.24 395.28 Tm (and by electronic transmission and overnight )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.23 0 0 11.23 291.84 394.32 Tm (courier to: )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_2 1 Tf 8.56 0 0 8.56 72.48 366.96 Tm (Steven M. Perr, Esq.\001)Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.9 0 0 11.9 72 353.04 Tm (Munger)Tj 11.79 0 0 11.79 109.92 352.8 Tm (, Tolles & Olson LLP )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_1 1 Tf 10.72 0 0 10.72 72 338.64 Tm (355 South Grand Avenue )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 92.4 324.72 Tm (Floor )Tj 11.75 0 0 11.75 71.52 310.56 Tm (Los Angeles)Tj 11.54 0 0 11.54 131.28 310.32 Tm (, CA 90071 )Tj ET EMC /P <>BDC BT /T1_0 1 Tf 11.76 0 0 11.76 71.76 282 Tm (Counsel for Rambus )Tj 12.64 0 0 12.64 171.36 281.76 Tm (Incorporated )Tj ET EMC endstream endobj 1686 0 obj<> endobj 1687 0 obj<> endobj 1688 0 obj<> endobj 1689 0 obj<> endobj 1690 0 obj<> endobj 1691 0 obj<> endobj 1692 0 obj<> endobj 1693 0 obj<> endobj 1694 0 obj<> endobj 1695 0 obj<> endobj 1696 0 obj<> endobj 1697 0 obj<> endobj 1698 0 obj<> endobj 1699 0 obj<> endobj 1700 0 obj<> endobj 1701 0 obj<> endobj 1702 0 obj<> endobj 1703 0 obj<> endobj 1704 0 obj<> endobj 1705 0 obj<> endobj 1706 0 obj<> endobj 1707 0 obj<> endobj 1708 0 obj<> endobj 1709 0 obj<> endobj 1710 0 obj<> endobj 1711 0 obj<> endobj 1712 0 obj<> endobj 1713 0 obj<> endobj 1714 0 obj<> endobj 1715 0 obj<> endobj 1716 0 obj<> endobj 1717 0 obj<> endobj 1718 0 obj<> endobj 1719 0 obj<> endobj 1720 0 obj<> endobj 1721 0 obj<> endobj 1722 0 obj<> endobj 1723 0 obj<> endobj 1724 0 obj<> endobj 1725 0 obj<> endobj 1726 0 obj<> endobj 1727 0 obj<> endobj 1728 0 obj<> endobj 1729 0 obj<> endobj 1730 0 obj<> endobj 1731 0 obj<> endobj 1732 0 obj<> endobj 1733 0 obj<> endobj 1734 0 obj<> endobj 1735 0 obj<> endobj 1736 0 obj<> endobj 1737 0 obj<> endobj 1738 0 obj<> endobj 1739 0 obj<> endobj 1740 0 obj<> endobj 1741 0 obj<> endobj 1742 0 obj<> endobj 1743 0 obj<> endobj 1744 0 obj<> endobj 1745 0 obj<> endobj 1746 0 obj<> endobj 1747 0 obj<> endobj 1748 0 obj<> endobj 1749 0 obj<> endobj 1750 0 obj<> endobj 1751 0 obj<> endobj 1752 0 obj<> endobj 1753 0 obj<> endobj 1754 0 obj<> endobj 1755 0 obj<> endobj 1756 0 obj<> endobj 1757 0 obj<> endobj 1758 0 obj<> endobj 1759 0 obj<> endobj 1760 0 obj<> endobj 1761 0 obj<> endobj 1762 0 obj<> endobj 1763 0 obj<> endobj 1764 0 obj<> endobj 1765 0 obj<> endobj 1766 0 obj<> endobj 1767 0 obj<> endobj 1768 0 obj<> endobj 1769 0 obj<> endobj 1770 0 obj<> endobj 1771 0 obj<> endobj 1772 0 obj<> endobj 1773 0 obj<> endobj 1774 0 obj<> endobj 1775 0 obj<> endobj 1776 0 obj<> endobj 1777 0 obj<> endobj 1778 0 obj<> endobj 1779 0 obj<> endobj 1780 0 obj<> endobj 1781 0 obj<> endobj 1782 0 obj<> endobj 1783 0 obj<> endobj 1784 0 obj<> endobj 1785 0 obj<> endobj 1786 0 obj<> endobj 1787 0 obj<> endobj 1788 0 obj<> endobj 1789 0 obj<> endobj 1790 0 obj<> endobj 1791 0 obj<> endobj 1792 0 obj<> endobj 1793 0 obj<> endobj 1794 0 obj<> endobj 1795 0 obj<> endobj 1796 0 obj<> endobj 1797 0 obj<> endobj 1798 0 obj<> endobj 1799 0 obj<> endobj 1800 0 obj<> endobj 1801 0 obj<> endobj 1802 0 obj<> endobj 1803 0 obj<> endobj 1804 0 obj<> endobj 1805 0 obj<> endobj 1806 0 obj<> endobj 1807 0 obj<> endobj 1808 0 obj<> endobj 1809 0 obj<> endobj 1810 0 obj<> endobj 1811 0 obj<> endobj 1812 0 obj<> endobj 1813 0 obj<> endobj 1814 0 obj<> endobj 1815 0 obj<> endobj 1816 0 obj<> endobj 1817 0 obj<> endobj 1818 0 obj<> endobj 1819 0 obj<> endobj 1820 0 obj<> endobj 1821 0 obj<> endobj 1822 0 obj<> endobj 1823 0 obj<> endobj 1824 0 obj<> endobj 1825 0 obj<> endobj 1826 0 obj<> endobj 1827 0 obj<> endobj 1828 0 obj<> endobj 1829 0 obj<> endobj 1830 0 obj<> endobj 1831 0 obj<> endobj 1832 0 obj<> endobj 1833 0 obj<> endobj 1834 0 obj<> endobj 1835 0 obj<> endobj 1836 0 obj<> endobj 1837 0 obj<> endobj 1838 0 obj<> endobj 1839 0 obj<> endobj 1840 0 obj<> endobj 1841 0 obj<> endobj 1842 0 obj<> endobj 1843 0 obj<> endobj 1844 0 obj<> endobj 1845 0 obj<> endobj 1846 0 obj<> endobj 1847 0 obj<> endobj 1848 0 obj<> endobj 1849 0 obj<> endobj 1850 0 obj<> endobj 1851 0 obj<> endobj 1852 0 obj<> endobj 1853 0 obj<> endobj 1854 0 obj<> endobj 1855 0 obj<> endobj 1856 0 obj<> endobj 1857 0 obj<> endobj 1858 0 obj<> endobj 1859 0 obj<> endobj 1860 0 obj<> endobj 1861 0 obj<> endobj 1862 0 obj<> endobj 1863 0 obj<> endobj 1864 0 obj<> endobj 1865 0 obj<> endobj 1866 0 obj<> endobj 1867 0 obj<> endobj 1868 0 obj<> endobj 1869 0 obj<> endobj 1870 0 obj<> endobj 1871 0 obj<> endobj 1872 0 obj<> endobj 1873 0 obj<> endobj 1874 0 obj<> endobj 1875 0 obj<> endobj 1876 0 obj<> endobj 1877 0 obj<> endobj 1878 0 obj<> endobj 1879 0 obj<> endobj 1880 0 obj<> endobj 1881 0 obj<> endobj 1882 0 obj<> endobj 1883 0 obj<> endobj 1884 0 obj<> endobj 1885 0 obj<> endobj 1886 0 obj<> endobj 1887 0 obj<> endobj 1888 0 obj<> endobj 1889 0 obj<> endobj 1890 0 obj<> endobj 1891 0 obj<> endobj 1892 0 obj<> endobj 1893 0 obj<> endobj 1894 0 obj<> endobj 1895 0 obj<> endobj 1896 0 obj<> endobj 1897 0 obj<> endobj 1898 0 obj<> endobj 1899 0 obj<> endobj 1900 0 obj<> endobj 1901 0 obj<> endobj 1902 0 obj<> endobj 1903 0 obj<> endobj 1904 0 obj<> endobj 1905 0 obj<> endobj 1906 0 obj<> endobj 1907 0 obj<> endobj 1908 0 obj<> endobj 1909 0 obj<> endobj 1910 0 obj<> endobj 1911 0 obj<> endobj 1912 0 obj<> endobj 1913 0 obj<> endobj 1914 0 obj<> endobj 1915 0 obj<> endobj 1916 0 obj<> endobj 1917 0 obj<> endobj 1918 0 obj<> endobj 1919 0 obj<> endobj 1920 0 obj<> endobj 1921 0 obj<> endobj 1922 0 obj<> endobj 1923 0 obj<> endobj 1924 0 obj<> endobj 1925 0 obj<> endobj 1926 0 obj<> endobj 1927 0 obj<> endobj 1928 0 obj<> endobj 1929 0 obj<> endobj 1930 0 obj<> endobj 1931 0 obj<> endobj 1932 0 obj<> endobj 1933 0 obj<> endobj 1934 0 obj<> endobj 1935 0 obj<> endobj 1936 0 obj<> endobj 1937 0 obj<> endobj 1938 0 obj<> endobj 1939 0 obj<> endobj 1940 0 obj<> endobj 1941 0 obj<> endobj 1942 0 obj<> endobj 1943 0 obj<> endobj 1944 0 obj<> endobj 1945 0 obj<> endobj 1946 0 obj<> endobj 1947 0 obj<> endobj 1948 0 obj<> endobj 1949 0 obj<> endobj 1950 0 obj<> endobj 1951 0 obj<> endobj 1952 0 obj<> endobj 1953 0 obj<> endobj 1954 0 obj<> endobj 1955 0 obj<> endobj 1956 0 obj<> endobj 1957 0 obj<> endobj 1958 0 obj<> endobj 1959 0 obj<> endobj 1960 0 obj<> endobj 1961 0 obj<> endobj 1962 0 obj<> endobj 1963 0 obj<> endobj 1964 0 obj<> endobj 1965 0 obj<> endobj 1966 0 obj<> endobj 1967 0 obj<> endobj 1968 0 obj<> endobj 1969 0 obj<> endobj 1970 0 obj<> endobj 1971 0 obj<> endobj 1972 0 obj<> endobj 1973 0 obj<> endobj 1974 0 obj<> endobj 1975 0 obj<> endobj 1976 0 obj<> endobj 1977 0 obj<> endobj 1978 0 obj<> endobj 1979 0 obj<> endobj 1980 0 obj<> endobj 1981 0 obj<> endobj 1982 0 obj<> endobj 1983 0 obj<> endobj 1984 0 obj<> endobj 1985 0 obj<> endobj 1986 0 obj<> endobj 1987 0 obj<> endobj 1988 0 obj<> endobj 1989 0 obj<> endobj 1990 0 obj<> endobj 1991 0 obj<> endobj 1992 0 obj<> endobj 1993 0 obj<> endobj 1994 0 obj<> endobj 1995 0 obj<> endobj 1996 0 obj<> endobj 1997 0 obj<> endobj 1998 0 obj<> endobj 1999 0 obj<> endobj 2000 0 obj<> endobj 2001 0 obj<> endobj 2002 0 obj<> endobj 2003 0 obj<> endobj 2004 0 obj<> endobj 2005 0 obj<> endobj 2006 0 obj<> endobj 2007 0 obj<> endobj 2008 0 obj<> endobj 2009 0 obj<> endobj 2010 0 obj<> endobj 2011 0 obj<> endobj 2012 0 obj<> endobj 2013 0 obj<> endobj 2014 0 obj<> endobj 2015 0 obj<> endobj 2016 0 obj<> endobj 2017 0 obj<> endobj 2018 0 obj<> endobj 2019 0 obj<> endobj 2020 0 obj<> endobj 2021 0 obj<> endobj 2022 0 obj<> endobj 2023 0 obj<> endobj 2024 0 obj<> endobj 2025 0 obj<> endobj 2026 0 obj<> endobj 2027 0 obj<> endobj 2028 0 obj<> endobj 2029 0 obj<> endobj 2030 0 obj<> endobj 2031 0 obj<> endobj 2032 0 obj<> endobj 2033 0 obj<> endobj 2034 0 obj<> endobj 2035 0 obj<> endobj 2036 0 obj<> endobj 2037 0 obj<> endobj 2038 0 obj<> endobj 2039 0 obj<> endobj 2040 0 obj<> endobj 2041 0 obj<> endobj 2042 0 obj<> endobj 2043 0 obj<> endobj 2044 0 obj<> endobj 2045 0 obj<> endobj 2046 0 obj<> endobj 2047 0 obj<> endobj 2048 0 obj<> endobj 2049 0 obj<> endobj 2050 0 obj<> endobj 2051 0 obj<> endobj 2052 0 obj<> endobj 2053 0 obj<> endobj 2054 0 obj<> endobj 2055 0 obj<> endobj 2056 0 obj<> endobj 2057 0 obj<> endobj 2058 0 obj<> endobj 2059 0 obj<> endobj 2060 0 obj<> endobj 2061 0 obj<> endobj 2062 0 obj<> endobj 2063 0 obj<> endobj 2064 0 obj<> endobj 2065 0 obj<> endobj 2066 0 obj<> endobj 2067 0 obj<> endobj 2068 0 obj<> endobj 2069 0 obj<> endobj 2070 0 obj<> endobj 2071 0 obj<> endobj 2072 0 obj<> endobj 2073 0 obj<> endobj 2074 0 obj<> endobj 2075 0 obj<> endobj 2076 0 obj<> endobj 2077 0 obj<> endobj 2078 0 obj<> endobj 2079 0 obj<> endobj 2080 0 obj<> endobj 2081 0 obj<> endobj 2082 0 obj<> endobj 2083 0 obj<> endobj 2084 0 obj<> endobj 2085 0 obj<> endobj 2086 0 obj<> endobj 2087 0 obj<>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 2088 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2089 0 obj<>stream H\0E/gE|@b .bڪ7" ! }}_ ±+_}7x41]/1&sL/Li&a(|~y߷ϼxw5ISghIcן/~]6 oX!ݼoL$K`J4:ПRvgm+Rf6̱՛mgvV <<)&X+!(PT +G *4 $@K ( ; ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (**fs(s!l%qAY΂$,,#PD~džjGM7EA7ήdHXlЍD Fb-\¢kU߳ _,r˯sGʀ\#%0a/{%{K9y){yUγ_Ѻg/ x>98\8>Tc_2"elqJu}e)?E.c endstream endobj 2090 0 obj<>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 2091 0 obj<>stream H\0E/gE|@b .bڪ7" ! }}_ ±+_}7x41]/1&sL/Li&a(|~y߷ϼxw5ISghIcן/~]6 oX!ݼoL$K`J4:ПRvgm+Rf6̱՛mgvV <<)&X+!(PT +G *4 $@K ( ; ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (**fs(s!l%qAY΂$,,#PD~džjGM7EA7ήdHXlЍD Fb-\¢kU߳ _,r˯sGʀ\#%0a/{%{K9y){yUγ_Ѻg/ x>98\8>Tc_2"elqJu}e)?E.c endstream endobj 2092 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2093 0 obj<>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 2094 0 obj<>stream H\0E/gE|@b .bڪ7" ! }}_ ±+_}7x41]/1&sL/Li&a(|~y߷ϼxw5ISghIcן/~]6 oX!ݼoL$K`J4:ПRvgm+Rf6̱՛mgvV <<)&X+!(PT +G *4 $@K ( ; ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (**fs(s!l%qAY΂$,,#PD~džjGM7EA7ήdHXlЍD Fb-\¢kU߳ _,r˯sGʀ\#%0a/{%{K9y){yUγ_Ѻg/ x>98\8>Tc_2"elqJu}e)?E.c endstream endobj 2095 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2096 0 obj<>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 2097 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2098 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2099 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2100 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2101 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2102 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2103 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2104 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2105 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2106 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2107 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2108 0 obj<>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 2109 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2110 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2111 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2112 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2113 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2114 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2115 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2116 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2117 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2118 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2119 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2120 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2121 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2122 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2123 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2124 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2125 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2126 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2127 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2128 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2129 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2130 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2131 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2132 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2133 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2134 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2135 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2136 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2137 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2138 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2139 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2140 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2141 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2142 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2143 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2144 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2145 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mOP86^ ^l( JRRxjZ3Y@h"AT%hPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPGh9ە\pֹ*p%AYΦ '@Y^vPD (K" \QэuAvЍA7H;<HXlt#:KXQy{6V6kۊEZ<{:r~)H _5r$#r `/d^~-'/e/yk9Z%^~zDyLNx iJKƣ -N :#OɲO tb endstream endobj 2146 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2147 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2148 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2149 0 obj<>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 2150 0 obj<>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 2151 0 obj<>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 2152 0 obj<> endobj 2153 0 obj<>stream application/pdf Complaint Counsel's Reply Brief on Remedy FTC 2006-10-05T11:16:06-04:00 2006-10-05T11:16:06-04:00 2006-10-05T11:16:06-04:00 uuid:86f70fb3-16a3-47b2-ac39-ced48c1d05f0 uuid:e3e699ce-68d9-4623-b922-ba60c346eee8 endstream endobj xref 0 2 0000001168 65535 f 0001027608 00000 n 3 1 0001027774 00000 n 10 1 0001028020 00000 n 17 1 0001028268 00000 n 24 1 0001028532 00000 n 31 1 0001028780 00000 n 38 1 0001029029 00000 n 45 1 0001029277 00000 n 52 1 0001029525 00000 n 59 1 0001029773 00000 n 66 1 0001030021 00000 n 73 1 0001030270 00000 n 80 1 0001030519 00000 n 87 1 0001030769 00000 n 94 1 0001031019 00000 n 101 1 0001031269 00000 n 108 1 0001031521 00000 n 115 1 0001031773 00000 n 122 1 0001032025 00000 n 129 1 0001032280 00000 n 136 1 0001032535 00000 n 143 1 0001032790 00000 n 149 1 0001033031 00000 n 156 1998 0001033286 00000 n 0001033356 00000 n 0001034512 00000 n 0001035667 00000 n 0001036825 00000 n 0000000213 00001 f 0001036876 00000 n 0000000161 00001 f 0001036922 00000 n 0000000163 00001 f 0000000165 00001 f 0000000166 00001 f 0000000167 00001 f 0001036972 00000 n 0000000168 00001 f 0001037020 00000 n 0001037139 00000 n 0001037189 00000 n 0001037273 00000 n 0001037299 00000 n 0001038342 00000 n 0001038392 00000 n 0001038476 00000 n 0001038502 00000 n 0001039541 00000 n 0001039652 00000 n 0001039736 00000 n 0001039762 00000 n 0000000170 00001 f 0001040804 00000 n 0001040854 00000 n 0000000184 00001 f 0000000187 00001 f 0000000188 00001 f 0001040904 00000 n 0000000000 00001 f 0001041145 00000 n 0000000191 00001 f 0000000193 00001 f 0000000194 00001 f 0000000195 00001 f 0000000196 00001 f 0000000197 00001 f 0000000198 00001 f 0000000199 00001 f 0000000200 00001 f 0000000201 00001 f 0000000202 00001 f 0000000203 00001 f 0000000204 00001 f 0000000205 00001 f 0000000206 00001 f 0000000207 00001 f 0000000208 00001 f 0000000209 00001 f 0000000210 00001 f 0000000211 00001 f 0000000212 00001 f 0001041523 00000 n 0001041691 00000 n 0001041739 00000 n 0001042005 00000 n 0001042221 00000 n 0001042278 00000 n 0001042344 00000 n 0001042401 00000 n 0001042467 00000 n 0001042515 00000 n 0001042563 00000 n 0001042611 00000 n 0001042668 00000 n 0001042734 00000 n 0001042793 00000 n 0001042872 00000 n 0001042939 00000 n 0001043006 00000 n 0001043055 00000 n 0001043121 00000 n 0001043188 00000 n 0001043255 00000 n 0001043304 00000 n 0001043353 00000 n 0001043402 00000 n 0001046389 00000 n 0001048017 00000 n 0001048178 00000 n 0001048199 00000 n 0001049355 00000 n 0001050513 00000 n 0001051668 00000 n 0001051721 00000 n 0001051772 00000 n 0001051856 00000 n 0001051882 00000 n 0000000189 00001 f 0001052921 00000 n 0001053005 00000 n 0001053031 00000 n 0000000250 00001 f 0000000270 00001 f 0001054073 00000 n 0000000254 00001 f 0001054121 00000 n 0000000257 00001 f 0001054205 00000 n 0001054289 00000 n 0001054315 00000 n 0000000259 00001 f 0000000263 00001 f 0000000264 00001 f 0001055358 00000 n 0000000265 00001 f 0000000267 00001 f 0000000268 00001 f 0000000269 00001 f 0001055406 00000 n 0000000255 00001 f 0001055454 00000 n 0001055630 00000 n 0001055679 00000 n 0001056030 00000 n 0001056095 00000 n 0001056153 00000 n 0001056212 00000 n 0001056269 00000 n 0001056318 00000 n 0001056366 00000 n 0001056435 00000 n 0001056502 00000 n 0001056590 00000 n 0001056648 00000 n 0001056707 00000 n 0001056765 00000 n 0001056830 00000 n 0001056889 00000 n 0001056949 00000 n 0001057007 00000 n 0001057072 00000 n 0001057131 00000 n 0001057191 00000 n 0001057249 00000 n 0001057314 00000 n 0001057373 00000 n 0001057433 00000 n 0001057491 00000 n 0001057539 00000 n 0001057598 00000 n 0001057646 00000 n 0001057717 00000 n 0001057785 00000 n 0001057850 00000 n 0001057909 00000 n 0001057969 00000 n 0001058027 00000 n 0001058080 00000 n 0001058145 00000 n 0001058204 00000 n 0001058264 00000 n 0001058322 00000 n 0001058405 00000 n 0001058464 00000 n 0001058523 00000 n 0001058583 00000 n 0001058641 00000 n 0001058691 00000 n 0001064684 00000 n 0001064705 00000 n 0001065861 00000 n 0001067019 00000 n 0001068174 00000 n 0001068227 00000 n 0001068278 00000 n 0001068362 00000 n 0001068388 00000 n 0000000272 00001 f 0000000330 00001 f 0000000331 00001 f 0000000332 00001 f 0000000333 00001 f 0000000334 00001 f 0000000335 00001 f 0000000336 00001 f 0000000337 00001 f 0000000338 00001 f 0000000339 00001 f 0000000340 00001 f 0000000341 00001 f 0000000342 00001 f 0000000343 00001 f 0000000344 00001 f 0000000345 00001 f 0000000346 00001 f 0000000347 00001 f 0001069427 00000 n 0001069511 00000 n 0001069537 00000 n 0000000348 00001 f 0000000352 00001 f 0000000353 00001 f 0000000354 00001 f 0000000355 00001 f 0000000356 00001 f 0000000357 00001 f 0000000358 00001 f 0000000359 00001 f 0000000360 00001 f 0000000361 00001 f 0000000362 00001 f 0000000363 00001 f 0000000364 00001 f 0001070580 00000 n 0001070664 00000 n 0001070690 00000 n 0000000365 00001 f 0000000369 00001 f 0000000370 00001 f 0001071732 00000 n 0000000371 00001 f 0000000373 00001 f 0001071779 00000 n 0000000374 00001 f 0000000376 00001 f 0001071828 00000 n 0001071977 00000 n 0001072003 00000 n 0001072070 00000 n 0001072454 00000 n 0001072503 00000 n 0001072926 00000 n 0001072975 00000 n 0001073024 00000 n 0001073073 00000 n 0001073122 00000 n 0001073171 00000 n 0001073220 00000 n 0001073269 00000 n 0001073318 00000 n 0001073367 00000 n 0001073417 00000 n 0001073472 00000 n 0001073529 00000 n 0001073586 00000 n 0001073636 00000 n 0001073686 00000 n 0001073736 00000 n 0001073786 00000 n 0001073836 00000 n 0001073886 00000 n 0001073936 00000 n 0001073986 00000 n 0001074036 00000 n 0001074086 00000 n 0001074136 00000 n 0001074186 00000 n 0001074236 00000 n 0001074286 00000 n 0001074336 00000 n 0001074386 00000 n 0001074436 00000 n 0001074486 00000 n 0001074536 00000 n 0001074586 00000 n 0001074641 00000 n 0001074698 00000 n 0001074755 00000 n 0001074805 00000 n 0001074855 00000 n 0001074905 00000 n 0001074967 00000 n 0001075035 00000 n 0001075085 00000 n 0001075145 00000 n 0001075195 00000 n 0001075245 00000 n 0001084941 00000 n 0001084962 00000 n 0001086118 00000 n 0001087273 00000 n 0001087381 00000 n 0001087432 00000 n 0001087516 00000 n 0001087542 00000 n 0000000377 00001 f 0000000438 00001 f 0001088581 00000 n 0001088665 00000 n 0001088691 00000 n 0000000439 00001 f 0001089733 00000 n 0000000443 00001 f 0000000445 00001 f 0000000446 00001 f 0000000447 00001 f 0000000448 00001 f 0001089852 00000 n 0001089980 00000 n 0001090029 00000 n 0001090128 00000 n 0001090177 00000 n 0001090226 00000 n 0001090285 00000 n 0001090334 00000 n 0001090383 00000 n 0001090432 00000 n 0001090481 00000 n 0001090530 00000 n 0001094112 00000 n 0001094133 00000 n 0001094243 00000 n 0001094349 00000 n 0001094457 00000 n 0001094510 00000 n 0000000449 00001 f 0000000468 00001 f 0000000469 00001 f 0000000470 00001 f 0000000471 00001 f 0001094561 00000 n 0001094622 00000 n 0001094670 00000 n 0000000472 00001 f 0000000476 00001 f 0001094716 00000 n 0001094769 00000 n 0001094816 00000 n 0001094944 00000 n 0001094993 00000 n 0001095146 00000 n 0001095195 00000 n 0001095244 00000 n 0001095293 00000 n 0001095348 00000 n 0001095404 00000 n 0001095460 00000 n 0001095519 00000 n 0001095590 00000 n 0001095657 00000 n 0001095725 00000 n 0001095775 00000 n 0001095844 00000 n 0001095912 00000 n 0001102640 00000 n 0001102661 00000 n 0001102771 00000 n 0001102879 00000 n 0001104034 00000 n 0001104085 00000 n 0000000477 00001 f 0000000503 00001 f 0000000504 00001 f 0000000505 00001 f 0000000506 00001 f 0001104153 00000 n 0001104220 00000 n 0000000507 00001 f 0000000510 00001 f 0001104281 00000 n 0001104365 00000 n 0001104391 00000 n 0000000511 00001 f 0001105433 00000 n 0000000515 00001 f 0001105517 00000 n 0001105693 00000 n 0001105752 00000 n 0001105905 00000 n 0001105954 00000 n 0001106003 00000 n 0001106052 00000 n 0001106101 00000 n 0001106150 00000 n 0001106199 00000 n 0001106258 00000 n 0001106317 00000 n 0001106366 00000 n 0001106416 00000 n 0001106466 00000 n 0001106516 00000 n 0001106576 00000 n 0001106626 00000 n 0001111684 00000 n 0001111705 00000 n 0001111815 00000 n 0001112970 00000 n 0001113078 00000 n 0001113129 00000 n 0000000517 00001 f 0000000542 00001 f 0001113176 00000 n 0000000543 00001 f 0000000545 00001 f 0001113224 00000 n 0000000546 00001 f 0001113277 00000 n 0000000548 00001 f 0000000550 00001 f 0000000551 00001 f 0000000552 00001 f 0001113325 00000 n 0000000553 00001 f 0001113409 00000 n 0001113493 00000 n 0001113519 00000 n 0000000555 00001 f 0000000559 00001 f 0000000560 00001 f 0000000561 00001 f 0000000562 00001 f 0000000563 00001 f 0000000564 00001 f 0000000565 00001 f 0001114561 00000 n 0001114639 00000 n 0001114863 00000 n 0001114921 00000 n 0001114988 00000 n 0001115249 00000 n 0001115298 00000 n 0001115358 00000 n 0001115425 00000 n 0001115474 00000 n 0001115534 00000 n 0001115601 00000 n 0001115660 00000 n 0001115728 00000 n 0001115778 00000 n 0001115828 00000 n 0001115878 00000 n 0001115938 00000 n 0001115988 00000 n 0001116038 00000 n 0001116088 00000 n 0001116138 00000 n 0001116188 00000 n 0001116238 00000 n 0001116288 00000 n 0001116338 00000 n 0001116388 00000 n 0001116438 00000 n 0001116498 00000 n 0001123272 00000 n 0001123293 00000 n 0001124449 00000 n 0001124557 00000 n 0001125712 00000 n 0001125763 00000 n 0001125847 00000 n 0001125873 00000 n 0000000566 00001 f 0000000604 00001 f 0001126912 00000 n 0000000605 00001 f 0001126965 00000 n 0001127049 00000 n 0001127075 00000 n 0000000607 00001 f 0000000611 00001 f 0000000612 00001 f 0001128117 00000 n 0001128211 00000 n 0001128304 00000 n 0001128397 00000 n 0001128489 00000 n 0001128582 00000 n 0001128656 00000 n 0000000613 00001 f 0001128759 00000 n 0001128812 00000 n 0000000621 00001 f 0001128874 00000 n 0001128922 00000 n 0001129034 00000 n 0001129186 00000 n 0001129235 00000 n 0001129433 00000 n 0001129482 00000 n 0001129542 00000 n 0001129609 00000 n 0001129658 00000 n 0001129707 00000 n 0001129756 00000 n 0001129805 00000 n 0001129881 00000 n 0001129936 00000 n 0001129996 00000 n 0001130057 00000 n 0001130112 00000 n 0001130173 00000 n 0001130234 00000 n 0001130289 00000 n 0001130350 00000 n 0001130396 00000 n 0001130446 00000 n 0001130496 00000 n 0001130565 00000 n 0001130633 00000 n 0001130683 00000 n 0001130752 00000 n 0001130820 00000 n 0001136630 00000 n 0001136651 00000 n 0001136761 00000 n 0001136869 00000 n 0001138024 00000 n 0001138077 00000 n 0000000624 00001 f 0001138128 00000 n 0001138212 00000 n 0001138238 00000 n 0000000661 00001 f 0000000665 00001 f 0000000666 00001 f 0000000667 00001 f 0000000668 00001 f 0000000669 00001 f 0000000670 00001 f 0000000671 00001 f 0001139280 00000 n 0000000672 00001 f 0000000674 00001 f 0000000675 00001 f 0000000676 00001 f 0001139328 00000 n 0001139488 00000 n 0001139537 00000 n 0001139681 00000 n 0001139730 00000 n 0001139779 00000 n 0001139828 00000 n 0001139877 00000 n 0001139926 00000 n 0001139975 00000 n 0001140024 00000 n 0001140073 00000 n 0001140132 00000 n 0001140199 00000 n 0001140249 00000 n 0001140299 00000 n 0001140349 00000 n 0001146212 00000 n 0001146233 00000 n 0001146343 00000 n 0001147498 00000 n 0001147606 00000 n 0000000677 00001 f 0000000700 00001 f 0001147657 00000 n 0000000701 00001 f 0001147704 00000 n 0001147754 00000 n 0000000703 00001 f 0001147798 00000 n 0001147882 00000 n 0001147908 00000 n 0000000706 00001 f 0000000710 00001 f 0000000711 00001 f 0001148950 00000 n 0000000712 00001 f 0001149029 00000 n 0000000714 00001 f 0000000716 00001 f 0000000717 00001 f 0000000718 00001 f 0000000719 00001 f 0000000720 00001 f 0000000721 00001 f 0001149077 00000 n 0001149270 00000 n 0001149319 00000 n 0001149526 00000 n 0001149575 00000 n 0001149635 00000 n 0001149702 00000 n 0001149761 00000 n 0001149819 00000 n 0001149886 00000 n 0001149935 00000 n 0001149984 00000 n 0001150034 00000 n 0001150094 00000 n 0001150144 00000 n 0001150203 00000 n 0001150271 00000 n 0001150321 00000 n 0001150371 00000 n 0001150421 00000 n 0001150471 00000 n 0001150521 00000 n 0001150571 00000 n 0001156596 00000 n 0001156617 00000 n 0001156727 00000 n 0001157882 00000 n 0001157990 00000 n 0000000722 00001 f 0001158041 00000 n 0001158125 00000 n 0001158151 00000 n 0000000751 00001 f 0000000755 00001 f 0000000756 00001 f 0000000757 00001 f 0000000758 00001 f 0000000759 00001 f 0000000760 00001 f 0001159193 00000 n 0001159322 00000 n 0001159371 00000 n 0001159470 00000 n 0001159519 00000 n 0001159568 00000 n 0001159617 00000 n 0001159666 00000 n 0001159715 00000 n 0001159764 00000 n 0001159813 00000 n 0001159862 00000 n 0001164692 00000 n 0001164713 00000 n 0001164823 00000 n 0001164931 00000 n 0001166086 00000 n 0000000761 00001 f 0000000779 00001 f 0000000780 00001 f 0001166137 00000 n 0000000781 00001 f 0000000783 00001 f 0000000784 00001 f 0000000785 00001 f 0001166221 00000 n 0000000786 00001 f 0001166270 00000 n 0001166354 00000 n 0001166380 00000 n 0000000788 00001 f 0000000792 00001 f 0000000793 00001 f 0001167422 00000 n 0001167501 00000 n 0001167662 00000 n 0001167711 00000 n 0001167882 00000 n 0001167931 00000 n 0001167986 00000 n 0001168042 00000 n 0001168098 00000 n 0001168157 00000 n 0001168206 00000 n 0001168255 00000 n 0001168304 00000 n 0001168353 00000 n 0001168414 00000 n 0001168482 00000 n 0001168537 00000 n 0001168594 00000 n 0001168651 00000 n 0001168701 00000 n 0001168751 00000 n 0001168811 00000 n 0001174092 00000 n 0001174113 00000 n 0001174223 00000 n 0001174331 00000 n 0001174437 00000 n 0000000794 00001 f 0000000822 00001 f 0000000823 00001 f 0000000824 00001 f 0000000825 00001 f 0000000826 00001 f 0001174488 00000 n 0000000827 00001 f 0001174534 00000 n 0001174655 00000 n 0001174704 00000 n 0001174812 00000 n 0001174861 00000 n 0001174910 00000 n 0001174959 00000 n 0001175008 00000 n 0001175063 00000 n 0001175119 00000 n 0001175175 00000 n 0001175224 00000 n 0001175282 00000 n 0001175349 00000 n 0001181035 00000 n 0001181056 00000 n 0001181166 00000 n 0001181274 00000 n 0001181380 00000 n 0000000829 00001 f 0000000849 00001 f 0001181431 00000 n 0001181479 00000 n 0000000850 00001 f 0000000853 00001 f 0000000854 00001 f 0000000855 00001 f 0000000856 00001 f 0000000857 00001 f 0000000858 00001 f 0001181527 00000 n 0001181606 00000 n 0001181669 00000 n 0001181822 00000 n 0001181877 00000 n 0001181933 00000 n 0001182122 00000 n 0001182178 00000 n 0001182227 00000 n 0001182282 00000 n 0001182338 00000 n 0001182415 00000 n 0001182482 00000 n 0001182549 00000 n 0001182604 00000 n 0001182660 00000 n 0001182717 00000 n 0001182767 00000 n 0001182817 00000 n 0001182867 00000 n 0001182917 00000 n 0001182967 00000 n 0001183017 00000 n 0001183077 00000 n 0001183137 00000 n 0001189862 00000 n 0001189883 00000 n 0001191038 00000 n 0001191148 00000 n 0001191256 00000 n 0000000859 00001 f 0001191307 00000 n 0001191391 00000 n 0001191417 00000 n 0000000890 00001 f 0000000894 00001 f 0000000895 00001 f 0000000896 00001 f 0001192459 00000 n 0000000897 00001 f 0001192512 00000 n 0000000899 00001 f 0000000901 00001 f 0000000902 00001 f 0001192559 00000 n 0001192612 00000 n 0000000903 00001 f 0000000906 00001 f 0000000907 00001 f 0000000908 00001 f 0000000909 00001 f 0000000910 00001 f 0000000911 00001 f 0001192665 00000 n 0001192850 00000 n 0001192905 00000 n 0001192962 00000 n 0001193250 00000 n 0001193307 00000 n 0001193357 00000 n 0001193407 00000 n 0001193457 00000 n 0001193507 00000 n 0001193562 00000 n 0001193619 00000 n 0001193687 00000 n 0001193755 00000 n 0001193810 00000 n 0001193868 00000 n 0001193938 00000 n 0001194007 00000 n 0001194058 00000 n 0001194113 00000 n 0001194171 00000 n 0001194229 00000 n 0001194284 00000 n 0001194342 00000 n 0001194423 00000 n 0001194492 00000 n 0001194561 00000 n 0001194616 00000 n 0001194674 00000 n 0001194732 00000 n 0001194783 00000 n 0001194834 00000 n 0001194885 00000 n 0001194936 00000 n 0001194987 00000 n 0001203477 00000 n 0001203498 00000 n 0001203608 00000 n 0001203716 00000 n 0001204871 00000 n 0000000912 00001 f 0000000953 00001 f 0000000954 00001 f 0000000955 00001 f 0000000956 00001 f 0000000957 00001 f 0000000958 00001 f 0000000959 00001 f 0000000960 00001 f 0001204922 00000 n 0000000961 00001 f 0001204968 00000 n 0001205052 00000 n 0001205078 00000 n 0000000963 00001 f 0001206120 00000 n 0001206198 00000 n 0001206351 00000 n 0001206406 00000 n 0001206463 00000 n 0001206634 00000 n 0001206691 00000 n 0001206746 00000 n 0001206803 00000 n 0001206860 00000 n 0001206910 00000 n 0001206960 00000 n 0001207015 00000 n 0001207072 00000 n 0001207129 00000 n 0001207179 00000 n 0001207234 00000 n 0001207291 00000 n 0001207349 00000 n 0001207400 00000 n 0001207451 00000 n 0001207511 00000 n 0001207580 00000 n 0001207631 00000 n 0001207692 00000 n 0001214618 00000 n 0001214639 00000 n 0001214749 00000 n 0001215905 00000 n 0001216013 00000 n 0000000967 00001 f 0000000998 00001 f 0001216064 00000 n 0000000999 00001 f 0000001001 00001 f 0001216115 00000 n 0001216201 00000 n 0001216228 00000 n 0000001002 00001 f 0000001006 00001 f 0001217271 00000 n 0000001007 00001 f 0001217316 00000 n 0001217455 00000 n 0001217507 00000 n 0001217607 00000 n 0001217659 00000 n 0001217722 00000 n 0001217774 00000 n 0001217826 00000 n 0001217878 00000 n 0001217930 00000 n 0001217993 00000 n 0001218045 00000 n 0001222230 00000 n 0001222252 00000 n 0001222363 00000 n 0001222472 00000 n 0001222579 00000 n 0001222633 00000 n 0001222685 00000 n 0000001009 00001 f 0000001029 00001 f 0000001030 00001 f 0000001031 00001 f 0000001032 00001 f 0001222764 00000 n 0000001033 00001 f 0001222811 00000 n 0001222833 00000 n 0000001035 00001 f 0000001038 00001 f 0001222902 00000 n 0001223050 00000 n 0001223113 00000 n 0001223258 00000 n 0001223307 00000 n 0001223366 00000 n 0001223418 00000 n 0001223470 00000 n 0001223522 00000 n 0001223581 00000 n 0001223640 00000 n 0001223699 00000 n 0001223763 00000 n 0001223834 00000 n 0001223897 00000 n 0001223987 00000 n 0001224040 00000 n 0001224093 00000 n 0001229353 00000 n 0001229375 00000 n 0001229486 00000 n 0001229595 00000 n 0001229702 00000 n 0000001039 00001 f 0000001063 00001 f 0000001064 00001 f 0001229754 00000 n 0000001065 00001 f 0000001067 00001 f 0000001068 00001 f 0000001069 00001 f 0000001070 00001 f 0000001071 00001 f 0000001072 00001 f 0000001073 00001 f 0000001074 00001 f 0001229808 00000 n 0000001075 00001 f 0001229858 00000 n 0001229926 00000 n 0001230119 00000 n 0001230178 00000 n 0001230237 00000 n 0001230427 00000 n 0001230486 00000 n 0001230538 00000 n 0001230590 00000 n 0001230654 00000 n 0001230725 00000 n 0001230777 00000 n 0001230829 00000 n 0001230881 00000 n 0001230930 00000 n 0001230990 00000 n 0001231043 00000 n 0001231096 00000 n 0001231149 00000 n 0001231198 00000 n 0001231258 00000 n 0001231311 00000 n 0001231374 00000 n 0001231446 00000 n 0001231510 00000 n 0001237965 00000 n 0001237987 00000 n 0001238098 00000 n 0001238205 00000 n 0001238314 00000 n 0001238368 00000 n 0000001077 00001 f 0000001109 00001 f 0000001110 00001 f 0000001111 00001 f 0000001112 00001 f 0001238420 00000 n 0000001113 00001 f 0001238467 00000 n 0001238588 00000 n 0001238640 00000 n 0001238740 00000 n 0001238799 00000 n 0001238858 00000 n 0001238917 00000 n 0001238969 00000 n 0001239021 00000 n 0001239073 00000 n 0001239135 00000 n 0001239206 00000 n 0001239258 00000 n 0001244721 00000 n 0001244743 00000 n 0001244854 00000 n 0001244963 00000 n 0000001115 00001 f 0000001133 00001 f 0000001134 00001 f 0000001135 00001 f 0000001136 00001 f 0000001137 00001 f 0000001138 00001 f 0000001139 00001 f 0001245015 00000 n 0001245154 00000 n 0001245206 00000 n 0001245306 00000 n 0001245358 00000 n 0001245410 00000 n 0001245462 00000 n 0001245514 00000 n 0001245566 00000 n 0001245618 00000 n 0001245670 00000 n 0001245722 00000 n 0001247737 00000 n 0001247759 00000 n 0001247870 00000 n 0001247979 00000 n 0001249136 00000 n 0000001140 00001 f 0000001158 00001 f 0000001159 00001 f 0001249188 00000 n 0001249274 00000 n 0001249301 00000 n 0000001160 00001 f 0000001164 00001 f 0000001165 00001 f 0000001166 00001 f 0000001167 00001 f 0001250344 00000 n 0001250528 00000 n 0001250580 00000 n 0001250743 00000 n 0001250795 00000 n 0001250847 00000 n 0001250899 00000 n 0001250958 00000 n 0001251017 00000 n 0001251076 00000 n 0001251128 00000 n 0001251187 00000 n 0001251246 00000 n 0001251305 00000 n 0001251357 00000 n 0001251410 00000 n 0001251463 00000 n 0001251516 00000 n 0001251569 00000 n 0001251622 00000 n 0001251675 00000 n 0001254890 00000 n 0001254912 00000 n 0001254959 00000 n 0001255006 00000 n 0001255053 00000 n 0001255100 00000 n 0001255147 00000 n 0001255194 00000 n 0001255241 00000 n 0001255288 00000 n 0001255335 00000 n 0001255382 00000 n 0001255430 00000 n 0001255478 00000 n 0001255526 00000 n 0001255574 00000 n 0001255622 00000 n 0001255670 00000 n 0001255718 00000 n 0001255766 00000 n 0001255814 00000 n 0001255862 00000 n 0001255910 00000 n 0001255958 00000 n 0001256006 00000 n 0001256054 00000 n 0001256102 00000 n 0001256150 00000 n 0001256198 00000 n 0001256246 00000 n 0001256294 00000 n 0001256342 00000 n 0001256390 00000 n 0001256438 00000 n 0001256487 00000 n 0001256536 00000 n 0001256585 00000 n 0001256634 00000 n 0001256683 00000 n 0001256732 00000 n 0001256781 00000 n 0001256830 00000 n 0001256879 00000 n 0001256928 00000 n 0001256977 00000 n 0001257026 00000 n 0001257075 00000 n 0001257124 00000 n 0001257173 00000 n 0001257222 00000 n 0001257271 00000 n 0001257320 00000 n 0001257369 00000 n 0001257418 00000 n 0001257467 00000 n 0001257516 00000 n 0001257565 00000 n 0001257614 00000 n 0001257663 00000 n 0001257712 00000 n 0001257761 00000 n 0001257809 00000 n 0001257857 00000 n 0001257905 00000 n 0001257953 00000 n 0001258001 00000 n 0001258049 00000 n 0001258097 00000 n 0001258145 00000 n 0001258193 00000 n 0001258241 00000 n 0001258290 00000 n 0001258339 00000 n 0001258388 00000 n 0001258437 00000 n 0001258486 00000 n 0001258535 00000 n 0001258584 00000 n 0001258633 00000 n 0001258682 00000 n 0001258731 00000 n 0001258780 00000 n 0001258829 00000 n 0001258878 00000 n 0001258927 00000 n 0001258976 00000 n 0001259025 00000 n 0001259074 00000 n 0001259123 00000 n 0001259172 00000 n 0001259221 00000 n 0001259270 00000 n 0001259319 00000 n 0001259368 00000 n 0001259417 00000 n 0001259466 00000 n 0001259515 00000 n 0001259564 00000 n 0001259613 00000 n 0001259662 00000 n 0001259711 00000 n 0001259760 00000 n 0001259809 00000 n 0001259858 00000 n 0001259907 00000 n 0001259956 00000 n 0001260004 00000 n 0001260052 00000 n 0001260100 00000 n 0001260148 00000 n 0001260196 00000 n 0001260244 00000 n 0001260292 00000 n 0001260340 00000 n 0001260388 00000 n 0001260436 00000 n 0001260484 00000 n 0001260532 00000 n 0001260580 00000 n 0001260628 00000 n 0001260676 00000 n 0001260724 00000 n 0001260772 00000 n 0001260820 00000 n 0001260868 00000 n 0001260917 00000 n 0001260966 00000 n 0001261015 00000 n 0001261064 00000 n 0001261113 00000 n 0001261161 00000 n 0001261209 00000 n 0001261257 00000 n 0001261305 00000 n 0001261353 00000 n 0001261401 00000 n 0001261449 00000 n 0001261497 00000 n 0001261545 00000 n 0001261593 00000 n 0001261642 00000 n 0001261691 00000 n 0001261740 00000 n 0001261789 00000 n 0001261838 00000 n 0001261886 00000 n 0001261934 00000 n 0001261982 00000 n 0001262030 00000 n 0001262078 00000 n 0001262126 00000 n 0001262174 00000 n 0001262222 00000 n 0001262270 00000 n 0001262318 00000 n 0001262367 00000 n 0001262416 00000 n 0001262465 00000 n 0001262514 00000 n 0001262563 00000 n 0001262612 00000 n 0001262661 00000 n 0001262710 00000 n 0001262759 00000 n 0001262808 00000 n 0001262857 00000 n 0001262906 00000 n 0001262955 00000 n 0001263004 00000 n 0001263053 00000 n 0001263102 00000 n 0001263151 00000 n 0001263199 00000 n 0001263247 00000 n 0001263295 00000 n 0001263343 00000 n 0001263391 00000 n 0001263439 00000 n 0001263487 00000 n 0001263535 00000 n 0001263583 00000 n 0001263631 00000 n 0001263680 00000 n 0001263729 00000 n 0001263778 00000 n 0001263827 00000 n 0001263876 00000 n 0001263925 00000 n 0001263974 00000 n 0001264023 00000 n 0001264072 00000 n 0001264121 00000 n 0001264169 00000 n 0001264217 00000 n 0001264265 00000 n 0001264313 00000 n 0001264361 00000 n 0001264409 00000 n 0001264457 00000 n 0001264505 00000 n 0001264553 00000 n 0001264601 00000 n 0001264650 00000 n 0001264699 00000 n 0001264748 00000 n 0001264797 00000 n 0001264845 00000 n 0001264893 00000 n 0001264941 00000 n 0001264989 00000 n 0001265037 00000 n 0001265085 00000 n 0001265133 00000 n 0001265181 00000 n 0001265229 00000 n 0001265277 00000 n 0001265326 00000 n 0001265375 00000 n 0001265424 00000 n 0001265473 00000 n 0001265522 00000 n 0001265571 00000 n 0001265620 00000 n 0001265669 00000 n 0001265718 00000 n 0001265767 00000 n 0001265816 00000 n 0001265864 00000 n 0001265912 00000 n 0001265960 00000 n 0001266008 00000 n 0001266056 00000 n 0001266104 00000 n 0001266152 00000 n 0001266200 00000 n 0001266248 00000 n 0001266296 00000 n 0001266344 00000 n 0001266392 00000 n 0001266440 00000 n 0001266488 00000 n 0001266536 00000 n 0001266584 00000 n 0001266632 00000 n 0001266680 00000 n 0001266728 00000 n 0001266777 00000 n 0001266826 00000 n 0001266875 00000 n 0001266924 00000 n 0001266973 00000 n 0001267022 00000 n 0001267071 00000 n 0001267119 00000 n 0001267167 00000 n 0001267215 00000 n 0001267263 00000 n 0001267311 00000 n 0001267359 00000 n 0001267407 00000 n 0001267455 00000 n 0001267503 00000 n 0001267551 00000 n 0001267599 00000 n 0001267647 00000 n 0001267695 00000 n 0001267743 00000 n 0001267791 00000 n 0001267839 00000 n 0001267887 00000 n 0001267935 00000 n 0001267983 00000 n 0001268031 00000 n 0001268080 00000 n 0001268129 00000 n 0001268178 00000 n 0001268227 00000 n 0001268276 00000 n 0001268325 00000 n 0001268374 00000 n 0001268423 00000 n 0001268472 00000 n 0001268521 00000 n 0001268570 00000 n 0001268619 00000 n 0001268668 00000 n 0001268717 00000 n 0001268766 00000 n 0001268815 00000 n 0001268864 00000 n 0001268913 00000 n 0001268962 00000 n 0001269012 00000 n 0001269062 00000 n 0001269112 00000 n 0001269162 00000 n 0001269212 00000 n 0001269262 00000 n 0001269312 00000 n 0001269362 00000 n 0001269412 00000 n 0001269462 00000 n 0001269512 00000 n 0001269562 00000 n 0001269612 00000 n 0001269662 00000 n 0001269712 00000 n 0001269762 00000 n 0001269812 00000 n 0001269862 00000 n 0001269912 00000 n 0001269962 00000 n 0001270011 00000 n 0001270060 00000 n 0001270109 00000 n 0001270158 00000 n 0001270207 00000 n 0001270256 00000 n 0001270305 00000 n 0001270354 00000 n 0001270403 00000 n 0001270452 00000 n 0001270502 00000 n 0001270552 00000 n 0001270602 00000 n 0001270652 00000 n 0001270702 00000 n 0001270752 00000 n 0001270802 00000 n 0001270851 00000 n 0001270900 00000 n 0001270949 00000 n 0001270998 00000 n 0001271047 00000 n 0001271096 00000 n 0001271145 00000 n 0001271194 00000 n 0001271243 00000 n 0001271292 00000 n 0001271341 00000 n 0001271390 00000 n 0001271439 00000 n 0001271488 00000 n 0001271537 00000 n 0001271586 00000 n 0001271635 00000 n 0001271684 00000 n 0001271733 00000 n 0001271755 00000 n 0001271805 00000 n 0001271855 00000 n 0001271905 00000 n 0001271955 00000 n 0001272004 00000 n 0001272053 00000 n 0001272102 00000 n 0001272151 00000 n 0001272200 00000 n 0001272249 00000 n 0001272298 00000 n 0001272347 00000 n 0001272396 00000 n 0001272445 00000 n 0001272495 00000 n 0001272545 00000 n 0001272595 00000 n 0001272645 00000 n 0001272695 00000 n 0001272745 00000 n 0001272795 00000 n 0001272845 00000 n 0001272895 00000 n 0001272944 00000 n 0001272993 00000 n 0001273042 00000 n 0001273091 00000 n 0001273140 00000 n 0001273189 00000 n 0001273238 00000 n 0001273287 00000 n 0001273336 00000 n 0001273385 00000 n 0001273434 00000 n 0001273483 00000 n 0001273532 00000 n 0001273581 00000 n 0001273630 00000 n 0001273679 00000 n 0001273728 00000 n 0001273777 00000 n 0001273826 00000 n 0001273875 00000 n 0001273924 00000 n 0001273973 00000 n 0001274022 00000 n 0001274071 00000 n 0001274120 00000 n 0001274169 00000 n 0001274218 00000 n 0001274267 00000 n 0001274317 00000 n 0001274367 00000 n 0001274417 00000 n 0001274467 00000 n 0001274517 00000 n 0001274567 00000 n 0001274616 00000 n 0001274681 00000 n 0001274742 00000 n 0001274807 00000 n 0001284500 00000 n 0001294189 00000 n 0001294240 00000 n 0001294290 00000 n 0001294340 00000 n 0001304025 00000 n 0001313706 00000 n 0001313787 00000 n 0001313870 00000 n 0001313966 00000 n 0001314049 00000 n 0001314133 00000 n 0001320858 00000 n 0001327579 00000 n 0001327647 00000 n 0001327714 00000 n 0001327798 00000 n 0001327844 00000 n 0001327892 00000 n 0001327941 00000 n 0001328024 00000 n 0001328074 00000 n 0001328123 00000 n 0001328239 00000 n 0001328316 00000 n 0001328399 00000 n 0001328465 00000 n 0001328528 00000 n 0001328578 00000 n 0001333856 00000 n 0001339130 00000 n 0001339180 00000 n 0001344450 00000 n 0001349716 00000 n 0001349801 00000 n 0001355484 00000 n 0001361163 00000 n 0001367885 00000 n 0001374603 00000 n 0001374682 00000 n 0001374766 00000 n 0001383253 00000 n 0001391736 00000 n 0001391787 00000 n 0001400266 00000 n 0001408741 00000 n 0001408789 00000 n 0001408838 00000 n 0001415761 00000 n 0001422680 00000 n 0001429595 00000 n 0001436506 00000 n 0001436556 00000 n 0001443463 00000 n 0001450366 00000 n 0001457265 00000 n 0001464160 00000 n 0001464242 00000 n 0001464327 00000 n 0001464409 00000 n 0001468597 00000 n 0001473860 00000 n 0001479119 00000 n 0001484374 00000 n 0001489625 00000 n 0001489704 00000 n 0001489752 00000 n 0001489813 00000 n 0001489892 00000 n 0001496343 00000 n 0001502790 00000 n 0001502871 00000 n 0001502951 00000 n 0001509394 00000 n 0001509444 00000 n 0001515883 00000 n 0001521342 00000 n 0001526797 00000 n 0001526864 00000 n 0001526931 00000 n 0001526997 00000 n 0001527064 00000 n 0001530275 00000 n 0001533482 00000 n 0001533562 00000 n 0001536765 00000 n 0001539964 00000 n 0001540031 00000 n 0001540157 00000 n 0001542765 00000 n 0001542834 00000 n 0001542900 00000 n 0001542968 00000 n 0001543041 00000 n 0001543109 00000 n 0001543172 00000 n 0001543235 00000 n 0001543298 00000 n 0001543371 00000 n 0001543439 00000 n 0001543500 00000 n 0001543583 00000 n 0001543652 00000 n 0001543721 00000 n 0001543785 00000 n 0001543868 00000 n 0001543937 00000 n 0001544006 00000 n 0001544075 00000 n 0001544144 00000 n 0001544195 00000 n 0001544259 00000 n 0001544328 00000 n 0001544388 00000 n 0001544465 00000 n 0001544525 00000 n 0001544586 00000 n 0001544645 00000 n 0001544732 00000 n 0001544792 00000 n 0001544849 00000 n 0001544921 00000 n 0001544990 00000 n 0001545050 00000 n 0001545143 00000 n 0001545203 00000 n 0001545264 00000 n 0001545324 00000 n 0001545407 00000 n 0001545468 00000 n 0001545530 00000 n 0001545590 00000 n 0001545673 00000 n 0001545734 00000 n 0001545796 00000 n 0001545856 00000 n 0001545939 00000 n 0001546000 00000 n 0001546062 00000 n 0001546122 00000 n 0001546179 00000 n 0001546240 00000 n 0001546297 00000 n 0001546371 00000 n 0001546441 00000 n 0001546501 00000 n 0001546577 00000 n 0001546638 00000 n 0001546700 00000 n 0001546760 00000 n 0001546820 00000 n 0001546881 00000 n 0001546964 00000 n 0001547025 00000 n 0001547087 00000 n 0001547147 00000 n 0001547236 00000 n 0001547297 00000 n 0001547358 00000 n 0001547420 00000 n 0001547480 00000 n 0001547537 00000 n 0001547595 00000 n 0001547659 00000 n 0001547716 00000 n 0001547780 00000 n 0001547838 00000 n 0001547902 00000 n 0001547960 00000 n 0001548024 00000 n 0001548082 00000 n 0001548146 00000 n 0001548204 00000 n 0001548274 00000 n 0001548341 00000 n 0001548406 00000 n 0001548465 00000 n 0001548530 00000 n 0001548595 00000 n 0001548654 00000 n 0001548724 00000 n 0001548783 00000 n 0001548848 00000 n 0001548907 00000 n 0001548972 00000 n 0001549042 00000 n 0001549107 00000 n 0001549172 00000 n 0001549231 00000 n 0001549296 00000 n 0001549355 00000 n 0001549420 00000 n 0001549479 00000 n 0001549544 00000 n 0001549603 00000 n 0001549672 00000 n 0001549731 00000 n 0001549790 00000 n 0001549860 00000 n 0001549943 00000 n 0001550013 00000 n 0001550083 00000 n 0001550145 00000 n 0001550210 00000 n 0001550268 00000 n 0001550325 00000 n 0001550390 00000 n 0001550447 00000 n 0001550508 00000 n 0001550572 00000 n 0001550636 00000 n 0001550705 00000 n 0001550770 00000 n 0001550828 00000 n 0001550897 00000 n 0001550962 00000 n 0001551026 00000 n 0001551090 00000 n 0001551162 00000 n 0001551223 00000 n 0001551312 00000 n 0001551381 00000 n 0001551451 00000 n 0001551517 00000 n 0001551589 00000 n 0001551659 00000 n 0001551720 00000 n 0001551785 00000 n 0001551849 00000 n 0001551913 00000 n 0001551971 00000 n 0001552029 00000 n 0001552080 00000 n 0001552141 00000 n 0001552202 00000 n 0001552267 00000 n 0001552319 00000 n 0001552385 00000 n 0001552444 00000 n 0001552506 00000 n 0001552565 00000 n 0001552633 00000 n 0001552702 00000 n 0001552767 00000 n 0001552848 00000 n 0001552917 00000 n 0001552975 00000 n 0001553056 00000 n 0001553125 00000 n 0001553194 00000 n 0001553264 00000 n 0001553330 00000 n 0001553389 00000 n 0001553448 00000 n 0001553510 00000 n 0001553576 00000 n 0001553628 00000 n 0001553694 00000 n 0001553753 00000 n 0001553819 00000 n 0001553878 00000 n 0001553937 00000 n 0001554002 00000 n 0001554072 00000 n 0001554142 00000 n 0001554204 00000 n 0001554272 00000 n 0001554330 00000 n 0001554407 00000 n 0001554476 00000 n 0001554527 00000 n 0001554596 00000 n 0001554654 00000 n 0001554712 00000 n 0001554793 00000 n 0001554852 00000 n 0001554914 00000 n 0001554977 00000 n 0001555036 00000 n 0001555099 00000 n 0001555162 00000 n 0001555221 00000 n 0001555284 00000 n 0001555332 00000 n 0001555391 00000 n 0001555463 00000 n 0001555533 00000 n 0001555592 00000 n 0001555664 00000 n 0001555734 00000 n 0001555799 00000 n 0001555863 00000 n 0001555921 00000 n 0001555979 00000 n 0001556037 00000 n 0001556106 00000 n 0001556164 00000 n 0001556222 00000 n 0001556287 00000 n 0001556362 00000 n 0001556431 00000 n 0001556496 00000 n 0001556555 00000 n 0001556614 00000 n 0001556672 00000 n 0001556740 00000 n 0001556821 00000 n 0001556890 00000 n 0001556951 00000 n 0001557026 00000 n 0001557095 00000 n 0001557152 00000 n 0001557221 00000 n 0001557280 00000 n 0001557342 00000 n 0001557408 00000 n 0001557477 00000 n 0001557547 00000 n 0001557606 00000 n 0001557665 00000 n 0001557724 00000 n 0001557789 00000 n 0001557848 00000 n 0001557906 00000 n 0001557970 00000 n 0001558027 00000 n 0001558092 00000 n 0001558150 00000 n 0001558219 00000 n 0001558288 00000 n 0001558357 00000 n 0001558426 00000 n 0001558477 00000 n 0001558542 00000 n 0001558606 00000 n 0001558667 00000 n 0001558728 00000 n 0001558793 00000 n 0001558862 00000 n 0001558926 00000 n 0001558984 00000 n 0001559055 00000 n 0001559125 00000 n 0001559195 00000 n 0001559265 00000 n 0001559331 00000 n 0001559393 00000 n 0001559451 00000 n 0001559509 00000 n 0001559560 00000 n 0001559618 00000 n 0001559676 00000 n 0001559737 00000 n 0001559802 00000 n 0001559870 00000 n 0001559939 00000 n 0001559999 00000 n 0001560063 00000 n 0001560121 00000 n 0001560193 00000 n 0001560251 00000 n 0001560332 00000 n 0001560401 00000 n 0001560470 00000 n 0001560535 00000 n 0001560593 00000 n 0001560652 00000 n 0001560718 00000 n 0001560770 00000 n 0001560829 00000 n 0001560899 00000 n 0001560965 00000 n 0001561035 00000 n 0001561097 00000 n 0001561159 00000 n 0001561227 00000 n 0001561292 00000 n 0001561362 00000 n 0001561427 00000 n 0001561492 00000 n 0001561550 00000 n 0001561622 00000 n 0001561681 00000 n 0001561752 00000 n 0001561822 00000 n 0001561887 00000 n 0001561947 00000 n 0001562020 00000 n 0001562091 00000 n 0001562157 00000 n 0001562215 00000 n 0001562287 00000 n 0001562347 00000 n 0001562407 00000 n 0001562479 00000 n 0001562539 00000 n 0001562624 00000 n 0001562695 00000 n 0001562766 00000 n 0001562841 00000 n 0001562908 00000 n 0001562968 00000 n 0001563039 00000 n 0001563099 00000 n 0001563158 00000 n 0001563226 00000 n 0001563294 00000 n 0001563359 00000 n 0001563429 00000 n 0001563491 00000 n 0001563557 00000 n 0001563619 00000 n 0001563686 00000 n 0001563757 00000 n 0001563833 00000 n 0001563904 00000 n 0001563964 00000 n 0001564027 00000 n 0001564093 00000 n 0001564158 00000 n 0001564221 00000 n 0001564287 00000 n 0001564357 00000 n 0001564422 00000 n 0001564492 00000 n 0001564555 00000 n 0001564627 00000 n 0001564691 00000 n 0001564755 00000 n 0001564821 00000 n 0001564880 00000 n 0001564939 00000 n 0001564998 00000 n 0001565064 00000 n 0001565146 00000 n 0001565217 00000 n 0001565298 00000 n 0001565388 00000 n 0001565459 00000 n 0001565512 00000 n 0001565573 00000 n 0001565643 00000 n 0001565701 00000 n 0001565783 00000 n 0001565854 00000 n 0001565913 00000 n 0001565972 00000 n 0001566031 00000 n 0001566098 00000 n 0001566158 00000 n 0001566229 00000 n 0001566289 00000 n 0001566342 00000 n 0001566409 00000 n 0001566486 00000 n 0001566558 00000 n 0001566622 00000 n 0001566680 00000 n 0001566742 00000 n 0001566808 00000 n 0001566867 00000 n 0001566926 00000 n 0001566988 00000 n 0001567059 00000 n 0001567118 00000 n 0001567184 00000 n 0001567249 00000 n 0001567314 00000 n 0001567373 00000 n 0001567443 00000 n 0001567509 00000 n 0001567579 00000 n 0001567649 00000 n 0001567701 00000 n 0001567766 00000 n 0001567836 00000 n 0001567895 00000 n 0001567947 00000 n 0001568020 00000 n 0001568079 00000 n 0001568134 00000 n 0001568200 00000 n 0001568260 00000 n 0001568313 00000 n 0001568366 00000 n 0001568419 00000 n 0001568490 00000 n 0001568543 00000 n 0001569178 00000 n 0001569808 00000 n 0001570442 00000 n 0001571077 00000 n 0001571711 00000 n 0001572341 00000 n 0001572976 00000 n 0001573610 00000 n 0001574240 00000 n 0001574875 00000 n 0001575505 00000 n 0001576135 00000 n 0001576766 00000 n 0001577393 00000 n 0001578023 00000 n 0001578654 00000 n 0001579284 00000 n 0001579914 00000 n 0001580545 00000 n 0001581175 00000 n 0001581805 00000 n 0001582440 00000 n 0001583070 00000 n 0001583700 00000 n 0001584331 00000 n 0001584961 00000 n 0001585591 00000 n 0001586222 00000 n 0001586852 00000 n 0001587482 00000 n 0001588113 00000 n 0001588743 00000 n 0001589373 00000 n 0001590004 00000 n 0001590634 00000 n 0001591264 00000 n 0001591895 00000 n 0001592525 00000 n 0001593152 00000 n 0001593783 00000 n 0001594413 00000 n 0001595040 00000 n 0001595670 00000 n 0001596301 00000 n 0001596931 00000 n 0001597562 00000 n 0001598192 00000 n 0001598822 00000 n 0001599453 00000 n 0001600083 00000 n 0001600713 00000 n 0001601344 00000 n 0001601974 00000 n 0001602601 00000 n 0001603232 00000 n 0001603862 00000 n 0001604489 00000 n 0001605120 00000 n 0001605747 00000 n 0001606377 00000 n 0001607008 00000 n 0001607638 00000 n 0001608269 00000 n 0001608899 00000 n 0001609529 00000 n 0001609683 00000 n trailer <]/Prev 1027236 >> startxref 1613126 %%EOF