%PDF-1.3 % %eCopy-1.1 % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000041858>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R ] /Count 1 >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 4 0 R /Contents 5 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 4 0 obj << /XObject << /Im6 6 0 R>> /Font << /F7 7 0 R /F8 8 0 R /F9 9 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 7 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F7 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 8 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F8 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 9 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F9 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 6 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im6 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 37622 >> stream e_xj)5Br0gbMlB8 AǑiD3T2t_-# e#"ǻ ;#|"T4\ Xcu$DlC -wRn2ߖR@e;[݋K_$:AH4=ح|Ya#r & ?½q;UOͅn$aIܲ`#?@WӰD5d.Kvhid[N+n8"?$8"8nq݄CJJ qS##8V5:Ց:"Y@L7ƨJ>78"|~C /몱||ÇPw=S#,<٭S. +(zơ0`] toHc!ܒӴ~#A}-ׂ Z ɓ. udǬL} ET`D}Ďw u6FzvZ?uLz^-ޔbZe`?(s?_A{WOA_[ń]2T?g\h,z}t!$uKGSֻnLz4`4xȒzT8":N-׮"J R~iRN75tCpu; lށxnve?MT&v|ڧL*pxw]jB.)i˞Oq#3}q w3AoN3`:D#r7,1zoDf{&Dm\]0yvqG jCa,whjǯ"L+"Fs$sAL`i-{?~=ҽ7ᇣkGY{Ӵ}AI3GZ +cKN|p2["?"}P.}SB?1GY `[DUTgd.CIv4G?aۿ4V qM1^믂#@(}0[W8D|)!#.RP t9 hU/_]t3U.J吝_]CX]4KZ;zҷvm^~: A+PuZJ@A!]o b:X[}_{4Й&Gs X7zDJ˯qtUt߃X=e*O? 0÷EmgqmuN߷-*pˢuKp̍ ݸޒǺV+1: 4ꪩ%r]X|S#{jGEE{A"??|ɀ_0Aqg cu!n$on69HAM|TDZYC i}فKƾanqqqzD$.Tj2l \i-S!.^U)=ֵѺ,S<MBzVtW8F[Z ߠEԷw,>!BOh(sV+A'9/ly>[ J_4sڃDEM(XN*V oa{{ݱlSnM> *xzIv \`1pF]or=QmzdK{CڗpDuH@GTG E|;0MVwnq8m %zvv"l>)kWQ}Xm\0p \WI8"?cIPJlպۼBe-va$#XlȯJm4-Ȭ]¤Ұj:ZGytqȐ'̸QEٍ# ջʁht_vn7CQ0$Sm յvSA9R޴XEn GhY{B=ᴤyx3vp ثpc ub ~gRQ|"`t *l+4RDhg1Fq܏­Y " !i0P:3<2DFXq$!= r$:t =5p0LT͇0gK!,sImuޚOPan A4騍~#شnc'g$;7Rvǯ_Ɲ[8,;iByg8/r,eA>&I5h$;m}=_Pn"u7CB ߿]_}U$ܡ\6խɸ7[m&޻_}ۈE:meQ ?":PemEEE}[6) koܱW,w{DpA&5K AWį?$oJo/-gcOX8I'^}۫w-%o~zIwI&[^;ޒuI&_-6~xiYkk~jn67,8XEﶢ?aU]WLWHI&ia44?OL-na*fea[M4m鍡1 XhGM;!Å + $IoJE01Zmm'IF #"`%}%lS:IZIz2jA Jh+HZJJa)A5Ha-RWI@ka$&*i** h"*U 6%M̞ڪErQI&H+ m!Hi.i*@ I n-Ai$m%Ja* i$})t*ZOI^ R"CPAHWIC/PMT*DǴ  H+ Pg!GOץ \+Bq8Ia K(R.8ZT}C9KX%A $qK1_I/ nb dv*HRI*I/TJECI%ªlD쏥I/_I!i*KIuK %A%YB^* %FQOZ ,-BR BBoV4l鴠$2Q!$Iը_OOB0Anbo_}L`NfOA?i=vKcYJF8L fP⽯_ {UvOiU$.3եj?YN>1C?}F]}k_Mǭ;.,u}{_zTH_ھ* ^|חA~ۍ׼I}U-ы]%id="-4N)؈LR~M5EQ AR63 W2Fq\9~q̄x^SGqt r]%b(DȖ%0k]% JjW'A{TI$$=b$TxHAiIm$HnWBI%Ii"cwU %TviRTvN$">REڶ!FUkҥ $!t I%VKJ^J~J"+~괚.IP@_$4*JD]tY `t1KUIՂ$ko %Kq]AJ RH,cKgfH$ąմIPP/Tui[ZU$BH2mIgBKJI,$ .I%J!%A6P ^%J+ %atAXh!d]mj>tT!21s9nZ9$#fhil&Ep!h 3.2v᠃hw(@{ֿw>t)9' ۢ_V}[WdCD"ՠ7kI;'K߭ p߮mvjnz~ZMu#c߷gޯ-}_m1V/ J&akuY_|+^5I6__ X>g}եa3-n?Kֳ wh29/~ VKH1B4[ޗ 4l# }-%[?z3L#S _ +l0Q8|D/ߍ_z] `r/G]_+~>o ӱw[3ޒ{k5!}*_Vt?i^I2pToWKZM ˎB{ K9NI%֗wjWl1Al d8f*ھV~lJha2M-: 4i Ⱦ]]`}dZxD47g &!!q !XI zAL5iv$ """#=h;L% l0#a  aBD0wԷTtL_6 a05vB(ĘF*ݫL0ˮ__Q3%^ r[j t_<QAo+ 4靌*l|RDkt8+ UQ +U@PS!_@h n. < $83@ %|`̓ԀFGA`x!.\ X5 C؂X p<KM qK&uE0"$=Q 2AHr`!r s`&veX4ūAsvf`pIaL$29$!1DCE桐L;x d@e.".^(TnZC !wރnm6>"8<9 a <(B- cB! @6Sjж)܅XD"Iٰ<۽[{IMn0s'0!rѱe_{_%$lb$`R82#ُޓu߰Wtۡ!l Ǻ=5$uhG>F='J5;;Tw_o־z]o_~_mom~g~8UIuu>ǘ K}?!+owMzW{DÇEku}[EwM~~=Uo÷w=ꗶun-iwKacҽm;=~qOݹyzϠUz]AuimP}u]-{V_~S׿/t֭]Vn[0Jo/ uߺB0K7l+X]&Z@fx>Lpa].~|fu!(hgpB@8 z}[koc}a06" mAVۄDDDDDDHR :nAC  6@0fc,hqS b&* Bf0La0Dt"DGdJU(Qa`NDC1#9C9{*`2Hd|3<69NPU )6JY#G3ц_#ln/DDDDDH]#G l##pDx"y0![cqmG0sGͳ|DDDNe>_/ᰎࠎ ArpGd1!3DDhv۷^ޯUץ]RZQM>IjF24%C ™AA rǢٺgew(G5ajB``:kP4 "E6XdOp ' h[ wD[sl2s$:;P|0a:6# "&]v+!$KP>mBc!)OzDX/}?_U_rgww~'#c/W]U%kM%_J~حoӫv]pKMӠm#V[iv !;IV""O`5MS""",&p[ ""&^CN.  y|)f|'ePBH|\gAzϠ31 ߄?᭄r-*ԧl㦑wmnߤ4!hFb ` ͨ eYDZh'o4t_Kt;-3_mj1KWO k}$o}|xXqLߍΉ`_.oMmҗ ~C\D[~Xdizv}nV(~Ӷm{nuP_uoa]`%` Gb=Ħk.`ZpamM$6DDᝊCaWtL`zv{ F㿿_U**Rl#65s),@h:?Ec>A.t'uo 7V,}?ݶ}(9eJ^۽ROO{Wޗtu_k{￿{ qQ[j65ޗ_]&?}校ouo]}ҥ7vݵa}{u]9޽'úm6}i+ݫj[_Z~߸a 0@aA-])GA0(aZA{L=m>b3p2;0mtuA 0 +Ha+Wm$M00ZBq¤41P^~* V!q""""J NI#-"V(*U[J?n݇n߿~KKҭ-BZj?(ffTYD]r 3!$BTF2Blav0lpl)qM5l&n$ n]\KrUޕ@Iս+_޴wWNKnu_SYC׵z@x1 tҫ͎k{HKA ,"o?I$A?wpzjW_ ^_ҷ`]'tz&qo^_ `daOO/^kl_kQ49WwR2:Zay1F"!LUDCGU_Gܣ{}ki泮꛴]ҪҫV5/_ Sf=۫HT!´va$3k% imAM+gͨD".  """""B@ !P{n_WEW֖(MQ'#qTд"!P 0!,r稊fp^ &#, ЈhЃ *ɜ5GMO302YVB#$$Ȝ_7w7"at$pNdvOd0 ;@DІ qb 9IM{? &KL6JDE8Ϡ>[[AOÚmFDh bD\qVnpzv͠ aximzu6 㺿WkݿޓmFwux]ۤުinkjq?ﻇ_v_b^Tu&mMڸ%[k^mrG?..5~aWB*I/_CKy<7t;[?䞯$/QUAtǤD{%S%~״=3\w 0wK_uI[nN>&iq^h?=H{k^[ Q߷m$W[>ǎ۴ʟO´{ڴ4V~VŸ56)6"[¶<77kچIh40 Kuz5A & 0T~}{z"$FkFb1f; [uQ+L&A&a ᮾ 3U6y o ^DDgּ"  A5}DDD֌ÔDF F?""""$Y Ͳn0Jb"""!a-!iaU.2``G`߯,ǽ~ڐ"- "l'Q'E^MX3`@L(PsCmlIJڄU<0 m\28h&s}w_ӆG'IB>No륃64R{{'Q1W|G"g Ј[ak{u7aoo]vo!J}m޿kvb5յzuD-~W i .^RvaEE(N `P&8@׆EE|FDDHyBg@ q]KzqJ#Tj?Џ{v'Fyr#;8ѯ6քDDDDDD9Ȱh3Ha%r]炜)vbusw;q9"Hs8?rnh%P(M"""""'i㑌Gp0\,_3. ˆ0^1dvc1gO0rf/̊u{/">\eGˊG|!.}(|ql˃pab""""j4s.G7 8ADDDNd^1Er# a(KQA*YDΡN  eA"1cDv8]) !dXSNP@D$kK@D"ܛ5SIMȼ AhHR! fx"#li&4)>""qGFAA"QA +!j9A߶A:Vhi\! Ңwd2й3B$cdշtH= 4 pGm`,f4"+/MIu[dO 셀 Wwi/ t"tm'OD& /ޫ3v{}6upIE K@ ?lp`7sz M_ۮ7}mB1 7Ku|wz}NM?ۭ{~d^ ?ܧsc_!l$ k[utҷK\v 0Ii[Iu=[b |9uj+-/7a~ת8=݂ RB$5iҺW[oz{h-,D `VaV_6ot߸kypM)4{tQU!0a&4BX%W[߮Ӎo2?ַqz  Adq dpJ խuiV^ɠ`g8`&;I0H>n뷫]w44q?9' a(6- @0 T#l6U}h8";U/!G! }Xu;T=}n"",@MLq U#6 ! @i&ե`oDO1f!"c␥`7B tjWq)e@< p$߈gt"g4B D((!fUڈ,L xDGYIӄA2l0!Nʚ-cBEBL3-Pq )s!>Gx,Pp`@K 0HpD~ #D Sa;)2 Ah6O%dKd8CMߡ:s99y&ޓh4l شP(2' ' KJQjݾ+ۯ(:iI h' pT\\O׷AXD0AD~ !fΡȶv}a"s'NpnBE0DXNh2,L#/[oV E0A``0DnBjS.Ds%"|?[ҿ&M$RVB: 6@Un8!f`C sR/͢tIz[UnKo߽Z~TtIa&L$O/!@a!"3a/翿ҴҸoJ&L6;H `iƿJKkV_&ViViy'a`?Z?~VumwX{_ۤ yt_ZP[[O}۪|-~_1FwҶZߤ&7~8=?Drm.. o߯3qA}w뾨G޼q - 0~p뮽&ȮoA""Ɲ/pڷV߯=Zۃȅ"DtZp{_k~_ު]ZMng@;7߿ ?/#ﶗNdt-ײVlWkA?_Ճ%~_w[F{~lB~װuz^\z[]Ep_[zҿi]R_ or$vm&~ޟo뿿\7ȩ߇_l0Iu_z^뭧T,?c-j/J]~A `4IZKI%o| a~N( azj +wz/o"23aa" 0C 6S< vV[ֻUoMb"""x?<|8]Ρ`l m+KKIׯю zQP-a$a4a I4våQu1 $y`6>6u]TDDAKb ![[0@8 m֓`_[DDD&:ƛf` &4I[KU_ADDJtm2 ]UlB S$|5 (fL$҅wKR.Eh0MwBIAUӵQ$Ӕ!OqL9N!8bց  x^0aA F@庑#eDDDDao?)!h!t{RPB$0&<\dp|qd 3/{CB"Ѝ`3A!:/Ma 8@b2'qSXMpjOA' $GNT,)’ l7rԉakդzI"`6ޟPacΑR%/iץvۃ:  OR#B$2I"HOUaU&߃ 'd-  aQ a f3x DH>ȃkK[}wa&Pl0\822P!|w^u3]_IUPߴn=a "?y!l))P d3d\S2.b9;CCNm"`' ]Xд",g LffPZKFx~Ai|8I;"2'N `AAD ]@AN߷Kߠit;@Ȕ!\9rxD|;ޟ;]ݭzݧô 8Ai WZz-utatJZUU ]oV\}z߷ ڜwҫ_on~K۪-*zޣ*i}zޤ Uzz%m~_UF{UZo.u@ȶ_K[^RQ#z?~_aU;|'^K^>cm]{ֿZoIxRUuָpǿikJZ]iWooK{q_꺼TJdG KI]\Z6~i1~ z6j<8I*:mS?~֛a־Iut'AcK_J-t$qz]zJVOU^KIs*;W?_ҶZOk֖ZOKK^7..ꪫU]u_7^zwUJUaVIuNuZW8n]V~f4;Wl$~V^Wkb)Nna5$ hAWKt+]W^z]uU[}*\3X a *֕I߽uοWG_DDE`'U t%kz m,*֝WүzKK_u~)hM\Sa8"0D.C &AkڄjZ_^eO5G BD0!޽%tz^^<'D0!8f .#el^a+_#0LQnS L! U+i6Vn] LY^Sέ4HD%UL5JJ"-DP J'@. @iCI`i a- 6́M &C1a""""",LS (B dYX1aG^125O3l*@n.]eѴ]ˢ)IQ T.Z4#B" dg# TVDTB B A8"Ms90@`(d- D|  _As9H\Nn<"d d$0""Ќ 0\9ٴ_# ޷V62% Ȗ kX"$(0wm-M{6i5dv"v[ޝ Oh2'^jO{~_뷷z>޷ҿ:_S_X_XG}U ~_ۊ׵J=~oh_D.%- }.+ k]!T8~oԄ|}/ȏ vE~__/m^5BL6D + D^w~7A>Aazom't[xO0_'VKWץxv_Q[}_uӊw,w{_a?"}_O ӺP߂}~v_ow޵#^[Uz{nt-[mMa|:r,3.7 JlFh/ܱ᧷  &Av_ g;bSt  ." M0$/ل$O"FBg<5MDDDVixȺ0HF:4B4""""""$&98#rt""$ Hsyo= 5A,s9DDDDᆨP#"""de ;PѢ=G:1EDDDDD,bB x&eA%3SYFI` adl2'úv&o"&aD4O™_Ii:AG "fI@tJondCE)o{ ^ˌpBpAS gI U+Ǹ0)u ́>OLШAN &PKB~;< C#  p]hq`  k}tld[m {a UWY ά~i'ڮӢzMcdGM:ҥ_ B˂0@Z^Pd#ԃ^^4ޕ4Qn Aa8!Nh0@c jn8}jt(L*g 4?:_JVr䎑~-ߠAi'Hv~Aѱ3 H3@ȄIm{m*ZUia%2V#):]O5 a2 RDlIޫx~!v"B'~Jl4Iȶ?X!84aB3pSL3#k{^%vӫie9|-0(L y4BAL2sl һ}]&o{ֶ ӥC6,xaׄ\\"Q",4:݄ 'jտ#*O/ۯo%/2N) &USJvCL%a/}kv_⢯ z _DDD9 P0 ‡u'a kK+wV޺[_N"%?& !a\kM#A!pWY ~^^_Oު>#4""""ͩP` G5@Ӄ 8l$O[Q]Om/JxI,DDDDDDD3>TM1 )4 {޿Pj.*_YfP*Oi󺦚jH= RzlBNӦ9 KmqX.[AVPI(&mm'8tcbDDCu6UI.dG銍_qևQ$F0*aSMS"8dXmxg"-`&QDq(?}> te+ˆMĺ{+EKLN`c2KF?, w;)^OÇ;j]hNүāM"ѐ8~IL= a M&i "0Ar"].E o$ȏM &Z #P) R3&<$d$}B& 7 SEE?#3QdPOB"["v oM{"L DFBI*_[oW >Iﶍd-;EwBTh2y*?KWޑ( tmp͊E d33 exzo^fBD$ lZCR`p" hGvtW^k_ڿMm'I'.$0L 7<"^=@:D|__W߾}NXd.(&C yLMͭz /֒-+o"qK  zJ:WW/)Bv_j넷Uis_ꫯ֒_o^/]/?UMh1 &M8b"?mXFZM_F<)~y?}RZּA7Q izKa_(0 8.dXQJӷ@¾m&+OO k~ru)Wd?I$jVW#5! a0& )\&*)b%@Lq]Z^Z}-?я\.U/Q:*lm_.""",)]h LtMȃaH4 U%ZJimz5뮺öDDDA0Ӗ"< &&W*)_mzҮuO.?b iQMt]VAujEZǙݺDDCʴ5M0MU0 zM6Q+Ibqv*_jKmԢt& -3  )1)mN*8$K]R_K}l/kkWDDE0dp aU0 d#iS*VL5Zk߯Ј`@50j)*jia⡂Jk_DDC&  L a0PGbR_X&L ںkb""""'L! IEmL ԛ"_B"1j/d}*eCKVr3C^+в UPRh)`vXZӝ~J2tPN w.jj 2P2ZdaD)$ C /_ O 0=蓆i|'"yr+yD $-Fkfbir\'_AwJh!a|i'CBjBF*oV@Zk!̆S4N5 EaRq} "L32_(d i7ՄGa;@ZM 6Ы#uHoaf!~ L4C~TB].IdxEȑN A`>(Aa ']/߮׶N([M}'>q/O\u~ۯ =t_#˫ӷ :l0 I(äI8_/d@ΣqȆ#H2" _2t <-&'~GU~4L`h30&G?4M׮ֶ}ohG_l4zߧVЈe![D0 l0 $a.<.DDDMXLbav&kMTDF|0Ha4a1I+Dzkr2N*a ڄASDDDD3i0!%VvbH *YLo6.DDDEEA )yИDs;A)Ⱥ†'T3*tntOM̖T u [ %EIյtFS`K?Wp!Al_ǭ̒dAuɠدoa|J"+gre'۸2(uBJb k`iD U N8iT3%c{Z(L- B" fd$(.gёJl'f0d<~Hlv/"p jCtB9AXir.Jm/om_Fk뻬06M N$dqhCt hCˌ%2 ru pUҦ߷}nZ}[izޝD+_ޞ&Moc|2s8oN1b!FLaFkLE}m1/; }ֿNȱaOtikah]\&@p3l`e̓#s{0m+dm"q&dHhnzWa+E2n;h CлAA$o۷^!}}w<khЭӯ&'Ia6mШDi L'I-O;OݤЈbԋm{K}0|%tPO[m/9oџo&30z]i>~ ]ۛPpD:koO4[Nݰ/ZlU7t;W]:!7iww[zuVa, }u[^tH{k`^WZ{o__" z-mz]:zLS t60In^48?uP~N #4A>j.ITCﴩ\_l%?ݤc H_ |'B?U"FpA:L)Ȱ *)UV+}&Xz!nҿoKkTUۯ7,?)1s &Ed 0 aMBMj+ְWk뽔]Vl_kߏDDE4i6!H4`JI鵇׶_-{k__߿DDD20X`%] ت}6Vu!ju7}Aa(a~QQLB mbtO e}_:/"-vڦiH4㰓؇_IuKl/~!4 M0\ŽDziBwLR":nڻ %?kki֕1:fAӎ#ح5[ 궿U2 C3B@ 鐃.RV*orOaփdW[ a]wck-2JDDDD/i -A6 ؄Ԉw⾕( ?2o`%a4LaT pDDDDDh3qvTDDDp`A VGI Kҡ06Z3"/0Phe_*`U2;تÅ2*HQt̀@vRgbs?JdҾ 1 J/""Y.%"3*3tAknxWJ.kJdKhvNQ z "(D*a(2,ѳ:iy >_^L\a_Z%i^]FE`ႄ3`2`ԜvtY ?'޿Lfq~]u}8d*Jm C^bѹ&83FJ -ܫ W[z_WOM4m-zE"ޠ %B.%^}S:ߪA+HO-SD7t;-?1 ^uwm,+Hz/~7mݰDǧi}7[_ Ҵ䏯oP_i?~Z?{oK?C֟G j1zM_~C d=n=k`/]}m//_HQGX>!XOmm/-_moaLpp ( (ҏb⽴s~0Ki~Twֿɵp`0Ch0$MdGA6m.Zb_V_7_^_YN$`  H;.Qf.g\;_ڿDDDF\&X p 6L('.S u߯ """ GL&SS -bcN% uպ_Gא#e'GM6°nޛ5}~w "B#O0"9b;a$إҴ]u[K]Ikk|DDELDh5iba6iA 0۴z:Ap<0a6!P ؠ"aQ]cŸzDE 58 ) )AR<3)PaVȎ0h44 qϳR! riL8*B"""" ga=!GY ՟T,%ݙM?%dW4gWl/jcu_7ӎ5ޙڑ桙Q#^~"ea A!aB~`d&"np L' "* .2JA}ID݂32]FdK? Q';Ok+I&}H… L&.S3Q&G qE %Z@m4t"4[>шh8]: }kЊ;Km*N7&PL8xM>0 &b8f:25׻AXoarܣDAui!_V- 2GhFNaiv80@7Imh/"B?Ɍ%rm־Ӫ d\#Ml4]7hv|>?KүD:aKz>w^ۃ% H&ѭwֹ7텮KjOICUڷno pZ}pnO.r{(oo/  _?zW_MOo {^VCm~~׿L ~ڽ>~e9/߾߭յ~ ?ֵ}?1 VUH)~C]SLkvI|m;U RYp ?/[?mH刷ڢ4S D|m,Sl%`^ a'I(i]5zU@OpNa}lPaR16KKkz{(q4`œr  6EM2#*m',T /N=ZZ:uMD')DDDD!f.Zja lBxبsa_~rl'fz_ոa  Zii; 1M0_]/MtDDED!/ ҧMl4IJ*D~l$L0]??f! <^L'r#1ul4I WuM_v0E M4M}Bi=8`tskڶDDDDAb |4մ.=LE"=v?چ_""8 àfHr@ " P$V.+aبISgL vl0L qM^=aqDDDI͂|0 SOM;""""""""" 0Cax,FSӳ#(l=@@l͜D3"Ԓx&F TDJh"_L̼^1U*A t4 DZsAJizT 89|FY4\/*4$dQDDIAh(w]SQd&4%l{iuޟ6 RqkT8IݶnHA+d$dB᧮,ށ5">4AFt#6A+gppd8@5܆fy|E5#i.% -ޣ&#Ѥc"Z^]liÈg $F O IG'k`o sfu3S%_ZޒU>WdX "H7]d2D#? U҃AډE ; ֫{xwxiէKJɸQh0Bѡ lFraη]v_]oC&sL$]0B5,ق$ jaP9=o_P_KZ>싏oFɃ/)ɺ_^gqifhqs8D1 ԐC,?aH+}E?PC҂lw04$Gm J{F!t` a5M(( :0B!߅ޗK-I?}?+µ*DZ'0L聭P ft/ނY'mKBWO]" >v=ՂvxM 7ZS=z뿫ONw>-;_] *^Fm }4_ok_oKK}ak^IXdm DxEڶ i6ǯz/&^ƗJ6o ڶ|noGzl0IA0I_A}w_ fMX[a4/\kO]tv/_Q;A}k]moWOL @a2#WA6 %±O׫kاk_K1bLdLZ#j ȎЭ#|Ǽ0AZ_^b+Gi2B;+d+&ǧZ>H8KMK]iZxa0m8 nMXIگy8%o{~~!!L 'kc("l{":a_}UQ $5N4  vUqN U{i{]o];=.""""tlM`^%M-kW6^tn_Zl}h-!5L aFȯ 4Ol%h=>8b!A}kZk|Eit h5a0LmMS_-qRqSi 4bV9 m5}~N"""R!d}`XKI}&0vlWGIu:XfA"0M4k"D-pA:RvӪDDDDD鈃3o 4 b""RFsAVV{PGt maWJ)XQɱBn#˅2(}|ȕkww]+z 78K3%C$ $[}~G8DDqX ! Jd&B~E\lxdk~fB^Fpn¦  d** L&P0("iz騠 ZhX!ii a0!Ss)޾~_?hLz PL@#Ђ! )ĐU nOw p?%'O܋l2-AhŢ0Lv\X wH ͙ԗIzkCL6 }IȽAttXhNzќ0= d !F`diZjW[U/uVׄJ܋.t{IEWA$;L0_!Ti#[ֵ~GuՃ7$bth'08(M5 D<0[l/o;zתuUvK)6EJeaƇp hJ;i60@_Џ꿅}utE6 z/ (M SI 6Nৌd=uH_bWiOII4N+xL hRC_姯&3w^_o^Og/(Z{N(ff22?VzODAˊGi~4'+^HxzT k@ <Gs0d.r Ɗ.C֖ctO[ u "xTv1}vf&;A!ff Z].ɍ^D /~JߴA?B? P RDliHz~~ݥm+tjuIZ܄z|B'm zpjk}}#zN5{Czoh?a!REE붗ZZPrEw_mv/_oZU]^ޕl+I;N[~tuiuj7Z~HB D_(wD#m§Un0JU#/t _M ^KoҺ}_]tx&:cO C[#?%Xa/KJ},3߿w;k&nߺWB !D&**5OG9 %J_u]ﵯFvAsu]tMMS [4 %c )a+ҧ#6Ů۫%t:u㚖"#- Ȯq6!pa&ڧc }Jz_~.B4㈈>A i[]6G˗Yn'L__o_{:"#=6.0& Pҋ?[Kal+kT_cvǐ_z/.""""& aDm-MJ<6H6}nk>w[VaTP ab1 !0_f4$?{\TAӆL5 E2#V*?M?]n׿AD 2" *t B lSJt7anVy_\DDI` Na아IIA4NՋXIiַnXá Ȏ7N6eAim #%q$ &G|2!1 0V0 +uDpS5BATViDD Yʺ­A0qTDhD0LSBa>zB"""!T#}DeP 1<}.3*?PSc"tUa  `B C)ZT2GWviævVWS_Ʊ?AT)2J5/vAB3v#.l9'Z6 }*v2 SL_ 5몦Vh!gbfQ$N.(@` kʤ,'m0 Jvh)TO`%=3 "4!";:4ւav_pi ۥrxDăKcB "#30) H!*~ӇO !5~~SL"nPAA*8!<(D, p"/"}a߆_7A?i8`n SaL pPAh &BO֮NjoqupdxD7 A7w &L*iF$L!s3U; XI+|mmn DwTahS ৆4!^0luM ~Uzv҆"@Impń' S@ôց3fj>}z_ cuuLO\ıdEÖ3?lQ B:2@C]~76[. z;.[׽O@AI)*<?aaV!|Mo}݄@;tN`L.hA;Ds$r'+B5[: ޻zi~<0^ޟwdy}ɜ dnoMA MP2C&x`2 WO*]Oa 7}:_ޗ6:.4B&a0V!a8N)[V+K1}֛[5]{ m7dC[sOaACdWPm`L0 j ~Z?P t1} K}" 54`[ a5mD*0 N֡JAoᐇB$FG'R!a4vȎP'vQWktZo Tzk"""""P6\& ka'q\nSoҺ]Vsxֿ_AjM04)چiA%oWwݫo_;S?SV$rcPL'uVHAߤ_g> hDDDD[ pMt4aG{ +0_^wAeTT"=4ݲr$UqvWwzwDDDDDP0L*#sq B a MDeOݰV!`!@N4Jᨦ!l6BV \}TDD[2ZpSյL bN xa&6vMtDDDC ϩ`¾*uMacM"""""$gRaHX8)ܧNfv$DDF"ҐfaMdbr%D9PUIR[!v~$Lsy̩̾G˲>gRAt,#PfvcInWmgdOuC&d+ „d6='=ݝe*:yUz'ۮ_ƃݦ վT[VROP;A>hGD_)CKZP]и`\!xPE)OT9\TGJ/v\t0 ߄ !#6̕Doף%8e؍L(L !3q2>]bO߭pq4E4Hvk(@., #C[d"Of|"' Wz `ID3u/\_mV=0A`4i B ͑=ku}o_R' mx ݂ a2_:wc>N 7TXX<8G2ˠtV>?CY{Vj_ ;"=A APP33 L~B!d/ob;_mW_տz`#6wa ssBM0pPd3>2rqQ 2‡%WM0~Yep[ou S +lbhq;lnjqO 3\_!ƣ_l7V] B;d}jK{Jڦ ߠzUO.}%8!!N!`x kj }l?ߴ~BB?NmoUG t2t'PT{5_`po] +FƋEŅL'E$gCOao{oGa__txK)7Nvw'_zZ~տkiooQoچ)}i&/}}-]oٜGֿoJvZI?7Za">He-{YyzkWM %zGm'ES B?U ˃ء_iE_ۛ._D_N"QVrg {).*M&NFJ׊J^g$j覆U^zt0{ j&&S@Eawk_Z_eֿ }7␉֕$9:gЙ% B]x//P8m!AL%i0kd{+}!8908i1Wbj] ߴ-0ݿ__]#C?neb `VDnmC ]4ca""""$PaI 6P[`dqukzi$i1lȻI,DJyok0a0iZk lýv$%ըDPD6""!Awla!aja5N8;#)+k*W"W&|P h6x[[%;جE""2!qpqȰ2,h0pxMmxm,!BDDEІA S$ 0}J7SZ"""$uUTmBaUlTxaq1`8 VlLDDH`b%(9mQc\_CBw+3DDD a,rng,s<9NTb""""""""$ ZiABAxh<q 4FqlfdqMf #DDDDDD@[HQo1|#.28"ȗdq G"9DDG#Q#R4F":H,!P3;|7Ok dA  2:j 4omK w (oݷKNvz;=2^'m$fԽ&ViU7`fTpꝠĆ򪯧 nvփ'7-2vgA3#FN)' šq: 6s@` &k h!yM+8_7L"p 5 B.h=H"F gBzoO ,2,4r Z6Rl2OaMl"nд =՚$g#Qw}h=;"ŭ_mamy`'m5pU Du! &L%_Kn z^{XP:&9> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im6 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F7 19.18 Tf 256.80 747.36 TD (ORIGfNAL) Tj /F7 12.08 Tf -30.72 -51.36 TD (UNITED STATES OF AMERICA) Tj /F8 11.85 Tf -4.80 -13.20 TD (FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION) Tj /F7 11.31 Tf -105.12 -118.56 TD (and) Tj /F7 9.37 Tf 212.64 62.88 TD (\)) Tj /F7 8.65 Tf 0.00 -13.44 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -13.44 TD (\)) Tj /F7 9.37 Tf -.24 -13.20 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -13.44 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -12.96 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -13.44 TD (\)) Tj 0.00 -13.20 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -13.20 TD (\)) Tj -.24 -13.20 TD (\)) Tj /F9 11.43 Tf 29.04 100.56 TD (PUBLIC VERSION) Tj /F7 11.54 Tf -270.96 9.36 TD (In the Matter of) Tj /F7 11.42 Tf -.24 -26.88 TD (CCC HOLDINGS INC.,) Tj /F7 11.48 Tf 276.96 -28.56 TD (Docket No. 9334) Tj /F7 12.14 Tf -277.92 -24.24 TD (AURORA EQUIY PARTNERS II L.P.,) Tj /F7 11.37 Tf 34.32 -13.44 TD (Respondents.) Tj /F7 12.08 Tf 6.72 -66.48 TD (COMPLAINT COUNSEL'S RESPONSE TO RESPONDENTS' AND DR.) Tj /F7 12.04 Tf 1.20 -12.96 TD (CHRISTOPHER VELL TURO'S MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AD) Tj /F8 11.56 Tf 9.36 -13.44 TD (TESTIFICANDUM AND SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM ISSUED TO) Tj /F8 11.59 Tf 84.24 -13.92 TD (DR. CHRISTOPHER VELL TURO) Tj /F7 12.28 Tf 36.24 -27.12 TD (I. INTRODUCTION) Tj /F7 11.62 Tf -139.92 -25.20 TD (On February 23,2009, Respondents and Dr. Christopher Vellturo filed two separate) Tj /F7 11.63 Tf -35.28 -26.40 TD (motions to quash the subpoena ad testifcandum and subpoena duces tecum issued by the) Tj /F8 10.90 Tf -.48 -26.40 TD (Secretar of the Commission on Januar 29,2009 and served on Dr. Vellturo on Februar 6,) Tj /F9 8.04 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (2009. As discussed more fully below, Respondents and Dr. Vellturo have failed to car their) Tj /F9 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (substantial burden on these motions, and thus, the motions should be denied. ) Tj /F7 6.05 Tf 355.92 1.92 TD (i) Tj /F7 11.55 Tf -321.84 -28.80 TD (This case is about a merger between two competitors, CCC Information Services) Tj /F7 11.65 Tf -34.80 -28.32 TD (\("CCC"\) and Aurora Equity Partners II L.P., the parent of Mitchell International \("Mitchell"\).) Tj /F7 11.55 Tf -.96 -24.96 TD (The proposed merger between the parents of CCC and Mitchell would leave only two providers) Tj /F7 11.59 Tf -.24 -26.88 TD (of U.S. partial loss estimation systems \("estimatics"\) and U.S. total loss valuation systems) Tj /F8 10.81 Tf -.24 -28.56 TD (\("TL V systems"\). There is only one other significant competitor - Audatex - in these two) Tj /F7 11.69 Tf 34.56 -33.36 TD (i Dr. Vellturo's Report is attached as Annex A.) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 0 10 0000000000 65535 f 0000000078 00000 n 0000000137 00000 n 0000000207 00000 n 0000000368 00000 n 0000038834 00000 n 0000000881 00000 n 0000000506 00000 n 0000000633 00000 n 0000000758 00000 n trailer << /Size 10 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 41581 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000066636>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R ] /Count 2 >> endobj 10 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 11 0 R /Contents 12 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 11 0 obj << /XObject << /Im13 13 0 R>> /Font << /F14 14 0 R /F15 15 0 R /F16 16 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 14 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F14 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 15 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F15 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 16 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F16 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 13 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im13 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 21570 >> stream ,QJ&Qړ2(pL-3ȖPv؄vDW(̍s-/B Gertؽ\nISn& `v$*zS2I84>[A|W^K7+H8LWoZZndڪZ_&¹O Bv\ C`x2ZMp(6 :xH&W ؖ; 'Bv > ;Nd4w Om(i&'͂L0`rm>O TxKKOPa0B%}m]'6-§ vlvjZZ_oj)xki _~[k魮~uu>Wk/mK˃UAko UGzI➗֪_itYoik߆ﶾ" *_z+^zI:mzGPK?wNEY?.NQCO~Y8,p.oa*]m_EE{Z~y %Iic!w!poP[_:}/½L_~n%A}XE ^ Ur*W -ɻoWޫ __Zwnp+oH}J/tb~nH_ .}]޷좯u8{(d ?OaqGnc;`]f?S []+[_mwK]n]ڷzz뻥4ǫpiD.*#! vm&T턕[K_i}Ci_kwi_uz}-o BhVD h4Bv* l>(4q%Pdp+AzN_em]>:[*_لKnSa0NaPAж ;dGLS":cc:Wد#lU먦@4y/`ـO,Gp,vmYXV=H5>#:3$b'L3A@& 3jdc Pi7La"tM5NݏMAai B['+ $ᱦoAQDDDDDDIГs6e%{0aA@D-Aa"<<4݊Q 5Lam4ilBL'"=0AmnAQ9DvU@3L pæq3Uxh02pn  4 Lkd&[Kl}ןv^*KRXBxL(G͠a Ӛw `&y )0MRnDDDDDDRhDFC8ҿU_U0r-l%+0amLB MEІ ?bc"ulݦM/ [;W'flJP@Ȍ21a4 J0 de8"WII_/ڶ8!xBQ~dK=n;bl]~FY֕%ֶ_My6JΌ>aKO&‘3DlgH336Eg3Τt|3$ DUt]UJFkVhjB (L0(PEB`4H3CI!hGS# }nx8q.qjZADa5PTx[@4hS!>xfb3?(α̲Pdb!х5d #yODk g !؇zBàA"ؚ);D쇊M$bc4n`2h5-uѡƉ@aS} 0 h0@s8!C6d2/382322/f| d8X! ͠aA& Cf8)<iN4ۧdn6a7i:VAϊ`>A6|ðv0Qp/0|PhA0D.30Aиkz h0TBM=7vn:-i+WxMjd$,$앤Iޒ 7wKq |CB&MR v;k.$DF"P8ii oDT]7TЭ~;\ 6"aa#ǃ$ؚ:MM:6&xh0/w:7FV7M`ȶ'̄mz}'oN M~ZO%t0Nhi=7)X`'JM=8`wo_%-[Ia` &S$]ZwB5wID$C _ۯW^O.WGwҿ]n/w{zz1-~aNjޯXwZ~/Ћ1lz^'_kYF 1]41[cu|/]{G(?^O^[_F,Rֿ$ 0~}~!zo{Y#򊶿o~t0^ч^Oj_o}$~Y!}{o V_Kk?o߿~7귶/}W]ᥪCKյ۽^UOԊi~J죽x>44פi/נW_Zۺ=pAZ_5^պo}Vk߭kþwv܁ 0_LU/SM׊n__ץ^_w~M}? %? I A0A`0vaQ $l8V֭EZys.Z0_OKZzvP Sa4ih&qA@)fPM m'qzViMW~%eoۧ m TCrـIC~=s(pSB03eb'J4 +̛֧¥IIlBbMޕvoA4Mkæ#c[AWM6Qb >+0ӥh;4IDCl!DAj^x"2: Qu 0AH6D-; 鰲@ݤ 4MSLPUN)` qa8vzʀ0M {=ޡv@ȰN&?bj YiZdv H T_EDDDNF{B,ϓ{;, ˨)ʋ,v"& w1pA0 f 1ϊ\DF`DERib? jָdpCB Y4  =Ae":H 0&fd(P3TZeIBAB;D!m5a< gk\Y 7Yھl`h2e/=UqE h@W{\ 꺽%mlGzOZQiuOY%T=eQPhh7M#:GDAQEL/c;A 0@fB PD ٠4e&]~7q.T'M4MٰcPU X@  \`EdC9 \#su""<6v 9GLhΙ@c4YQbkn @t쳒^cEhZ.DǪ$ L& `@ 65$F͑BeȌfΣ ٨Ψk<.j32: 9G3x4fߜCB`>0 @Jq0=#M4<"x ,4//ai8  <*A0f`L`tP 43?<*`]dp&8`MCUJ 48ASO'P@Um-i Id L6  Ţx 0x|/lZMB7pXi۸B4N`7tN] 4;>-q= t8tO1;M=uֺ4}ZNLnxMG`Er쏄nC hh !\|>aAݪH8~D aBpiu&Mk}Q{ZȑKw~_n[WhXV$MV=9KP2?iffbIAGp]7@kt'a?t)x1~;":uui[^ZҺo׷Cu}t=6[ML tR=bz޷o]>H/{sU/ra-8z'yI_on[Vߥ?v}GUkݰ{ua'VV^ht'Q_߽V {zA߯[oKO_[6د/oO]aO։~.b?azAd}{~CE߸^_޽&׿v ;_݇/"$y#{ߧKۯU֓Mo_A]3~_jVHޒ^z^F/_&8}AUaw~M7XܐoT:~}{ Ȑj i+_V[i=IZtۯ-o[Kb_ro׶|\AZ~;bbaǫJK[K-_᥿կ ko@ +I>)mb֘iu^_tڪ^j]uu[ ,ޗ[uX(Sv pM1H0,$ 5a &dtIJm/o]X@탯KI/&GUi?Vm\>sL*'E`e`AL=lS&6PM4AL a6a՗%^KJ鴶!iSOi 6;@ PrM8B"""-+g8vg .g^Wi 1Q"dG a(tȣa4$_j)(l&I&S6(&"!"223)aBka# & $lTSiLAo WTDDCB"2g DE+(a*3AߥcS0Faʬ€"3'DJ3T ZPB#B""""""2m/U^H%KMeh&V` q\PmX$qDG6^vVDkvvi~אLfűS&Lvgdgq|e9;k8.a  ADd/h6ۅ(L&U'888@dyD^AvEI0MKkݥtno atɲ){}o-o6eAc=严$5Ti3PD8š<_%~(!hj0L&` &0"=a<|R #UWUxvhB¦ (* -&M2i 3COL(AC"<|21VOc :0c]y/ÄO4EWDA4NJ `4jx@, (TF@b hL4 k0(ƄKz rޤ2'pC2$g=3P@JaȀ'I -BA`pd"v8azhhPP'iwaT !x0P@ba0@ux ~3c0@ 6 T:Pà N(ծ_jA I(6m #+,wdHl-Z/n@;0 äMAvL']=Uxo~_wJkk鴟a6 ipN EʰAEy7H2, A:'_8Aڤ`& H ]m%asVB>פ-*X[0G `0ä2>voI; ܗ42V__;~c )?k[nk~ֽ ka-M k]a.]qwO_o_֯/uTBP>uO{^(_u_pZ_0]]#K_$?$?Kvu_/w_!߷NF!/Ul7__?M*wnTM:4IYZ }H_~zU%ikҶOK/_W_a4޿_ii7ɿwޫ$y#%}Kw/ծ A?߶uZO_vQUΎi_WI{*t߾_{( /;zEQ__QKIT}#j_iZMֶ*0oѫwݿu("_ a8GAYDئm-oWl%OmkW >[TB 1Si[ccV . dz齑ANۦWkAOFI64& DA4!iIN$=!}]b\ddq0Uuv)خ3d?zv4CgF$ 5 d%VdW6m{58Aӊ6DxAm:{:Ӵ$[mҮ0KwiU&^=XDDDDDDDDDDD̘H8kva0Z}+Uj r#&0A hPA NڃbLBa5i-6miQ! "Rc&(`䇪ݵkm'H6Z vA4{M)]MGk (C1F&s<&f| 7 z0& las<2pp*ⓈCbʑ(B"QDD8a~""ZZK/ $%U<*A( & N#-0ph( ?N;q̴aI$T!*eLȴ㴿낦wX 1J%FwvWԈwE9Ȃ eKl((\\).$@$MpF;HZa4$;\WhBAm N.:"0x à跨D 2 xG'I]V}Vzzt',}}I/"(dRC t6!rmWd:?Zqߵڿ Ba`@fc0 hF8!O6GQ1Nh0 U4~-io# .j}aSL5O p3 M0h3ih/ 8gVk !Ɉ>CD(~0IwV^o[hidtti=OOȣ7T|ؚS/]{Iҧ {#ƓG Hmtki?MAҵa8aI}dW%޷h]uu_/Qk/_uOץCO}z.iKJ蚿na]U˄^G>ooZZ⾷ r'kL W[/>u[[VhW?u}$_}y]mm0' ӈ___a~߽}ۭt"} \ b~{׿B7ۥK_a>ZnH_H܆_m׶=_Iӿ"Q߽s+{o`_^' ޟKa$}bh/_ z.9  K}umoskÝpޫE޴zKK;_.1׹I{aI_u}}jﾍ}A?{kUV>X)|J[׮i+"G~H_mDxbޚZ{k[ -DJPJLBo|0]<P*W[_]UHnmu Bm2#8t:4 0\@x]1IMc 4J!è:b{ >!0h8^}w!c $ЍI?>Bh t o %g&i=a~N  TLS!G' -ؽJ;|4ZN)> ; ZIkƻ Mj"""")!#(BB# Du M|&MB: H0MdW@iUa ؅aP<|:qI1 h& pRq 68:Ah B3Ι`MB\40[ ]04t0 "8h aia1H0p BiKeHHPB!! a0w }[ dQs:DFph0\; M2xX)30DF hDDDDDD)g]N""""""""4"=R$Zڵ Ir%ERq N]gQM28)!˓U+`Ba0%$%DdK!dv+US <&)ެ 6wѬgNga ,a0L 4w/+A(();SM@CٷFj AsY6^p ]/u ! // +Æ"1GpGOCOM2!AFq4%RKNO M]]'HJ7k1__A?^_WUK}&׿2D#uI^ y$!C3AjC0 糤CkWi?Ja0LA0C0 PBWr$2Fd1"癭]:Km}҃"v ,"p 4NHv &0Ap' lD-45P@"HxD=&Ȇ) gPrfd&*0rcܷ ]ickK~z!!~ x|!z0cނ/V__nC׸ߪ"Qoo{DuDiNw"9z&%&9$8_]_U߯ߪP~O{[Ј?myuN__^LGWzp#Wquz^a(<" 7wJ/ wK}3pI?%_K]kM^_3hK(rF9Ѻea _C]dtQ_u~_#2}/$_H)Fdb|I^ݭ~WM0ZL0_m/%Zm.m/zӲn>!/L~8>[m+[]Jk__om}uK/o{TMGZQ ߭NBWOr/a-a0J퇶}ҷzPҭ WMm. 6xl$ E'] 0LAV~{dpG/{ }[J0K1%  ISxLeM%"„@ڠ QLS"qZi xl0KWئJ8~T?l+tQ8=<ƞkǽa; G]( fA7&h0N˰ںiaa4L1@ aMiJAZvXPȎq` :Tk ]'V h8iȞe •aOy' JMZM2  48A<l`8LP1Lq G<: &h,6Etׄ DDDDDDDDJ2Aha0);#-09HMma*iA.6Ȯ]V (I8`4a4O LA*ᘃghB'LD0@Ȧ :UDaAe9cZEDDDDDDDDAM̭3zj B/~oܷ9% \+j{l?UkZ^)ue<}2@p Üpάs# m 9Ng2W"]/ <&t'x&@a(PB0D82.ι!|itG>k%0h^0V SA𩂦S4 ah !fc{/Ld8d4Ndhڢq ToP \Շ R] A^fM} /!!D/L_CBaڡj $.ޯuӯ^/IM{bk[CeO zַޛo+OK C{kڧu~=l1 *Cc_/VYt1섧_+p뿆?ӯZo|/p` Kazl"ok'ɎnW?]ߦ]?HE/7 oץk?}~x6dj_ҰfOOa(o_Uu/و?UEoͫa.ۺv_aWbvj_Նk  ?lWmEGwiDiui}݂)Mgh qHtf85j lKk ZC% &NAB a* AAb 'NA`YGL& aUL&¾4Ҧ"G?B D*$AL | =|(M`aN|S4j"""""#h A`p pM>^|x^5 7ϲCrý>#7Բ|7ݲԿo±z?C<8OM!6W?#~?*mTm|% ? Hl3b lJa}D*Db#Gg;-d%tTԌ lx0[2Ve3RN>2.()dvˣ*vKv"NGܒB]l?׶.K0h2+  VW]iu+Eu^è?}5tէ]ZIW׿AD:yEO$R$%ֵWWL¦ D'pha sd5G>SL*=uWWh0 ~BL0P` 6ANe"hF?௺OB%IObGhFۿk/ [AOs\|yt!n[I~oaKP#y1O݃`tXu&0._7_DoFAk_[F_:Z'W_ {K_m_Qۿ/ۿktj6/K} xa~ vJPׯ_\̭uKtD2'@H!~A}~kn{s_{U^ ַ_ oF0]{_k`]xi]vkw}/o0uac_Wmӫu_a}_i}~~4[z`ڰ06:ӫJ[#+M׫)ime8{ L?_N@`Ҿm/?OI;j)h 0MC4 0D8دwk{ mGPbXA! U˭xl'z}wQI88om&2?c`$Lpdn m~'vXAA'A1@!G ZbN L0⢴NˋwKۅl&hTvB6DDDD tyOs 7?N3 !d@PXg")Ik%S7!F΂͡D#%D6Qu bXAjC 0 (C5 x "'8 hmf2"2tt_4^Q|-$pN. $n DjE ' (L?6%i_iAmy=j >Αxkm dT~IkRm&앥ljGt821ɹ}'zKEt7JJIҺ)}_tC_?ӯzoW6OOQ]?z,xr%B9+ }6Ѝ/&k,gR#&]'tJ ?_{~C^OqMF!.}o'KDO4>r9Fڤ~UrA4u݆a/KoݑZc׺ %~] -+^+Nv8JLRDtv%M}0zAӴ46*=xto֭ Z,‚WڰjMh x0IӍnb &[` )8L'j )j +A@0 TY oDDDDDDD`)P: A)1al'a~v2,qUDDDhDDM"N!` &i`a#-r  #``(8 P5o~ò$3tr3g >R8>q =W} ;H?_Vu_x{>?~zK.76л^o_m꿵{o].CmUw]Ia\VE iU'DI"}D-% Yl3aJ % en"d2;U3S8" P[Mt,&8Z™..z}oӒ` %ڄ~"jiKqQwׯj#[:]d]/뮿BЇ93bB̈ B,f$|D՚eMȺ jL>A a0PA4,) A-" \A2Q 2KȈd$E#: ~m2D蓴0-j L(&0P&@h4&dϐDQ&xz6P.'/2^hav<8r]Dx% Zn$p&vAAҺm5:ZNwt5't6 ^x/|'n\Qv'J'l2eh&x7Mzۯdp[vG;tGͦGAt=V Xd :.l$KWVW{_z_=6 ҧd>t|vU!G{Uտ__z{_ۯCq??׵_OpҲ:Zd(&AV!kb_1 C\1*#~"7,N`&-_wWn[$齆 z? B`ຐay1&zu \DxD`7MHIz0WoXoUz >QkZ. ,}K[6D{m?k74G^_8G#bKۯ_Um7owU=w^^zW]._꿱Mf鶗uַޕ{jjߴOҰثæ?d#4T?V%Vi~ QM&GLlmC DkPv +]5B!KPޣ=~)='Ph!rt!nh4N4)'lPAzyuMD0IM_zTi>vNזGL6΃a4 { 0I`a0 q!#L*Ata8A """""""" fOC!g a XUL&updX^SdW,"TD""""""" ,DDDRZf/0|w n;Epz;+EI\=Z;Un?JK]zUf/CF9{.dbvBq-LBնٶ<3Qx"P.ujvBR&;pia7mL'$0A: 2@"̄9!Ay:G @2sNaB *1ý(4M:0@aGa аA248 s#AGۄ[M0 D2:l-0Tj4/W 4d\tuxԁ.6g/Z't0d]=>$>v 2 "P^ ޭ'[:};[Z29ݿK^Mu!(b6 i_{G׶DO {Cj:+zчA[ ~6 )rܒ=R[_i_Dߣ=/BO&C &Kۯm] a]taF?&}{] n[_6zo_ￊk81]5ZFߥ_}{_붗U0}( |}W/$o7Yj_wꫫu}{v^{W=XOKֺ>u?][_iuz]c=`T]& v[>ۮJs!vMڈpcdH\U}ͯ0J#r׵N$@ "bA='JV8iGPՊ G1^Ȏ<'M2q [kvER$/6 mGZ &Al0Jկ %DXFuL!g DTpN 4Vj* aa """"a`DD0[d2a^M _ !a0@*ʡN2֕΋!HDDDDDDDDDDDapj?k`0jT n6sAzò'19zAmIo?^g|{KVw+z߽\^ػҿ7}ѻ^>{.]ҫJ { ?O"@  $3boWһbk_pVS#ܧL`SgwL<:eg#kB@qaG[J?i /?m3T"C!F9 FQȎA A A1a97$9+ƳasX䠅g D9X¸hrDЬh!!06#dfDQgl㙦^9b1#aoYuqڼ9 @S2;̎f0q" {4":5dtF]]a!CJMB#FN%* A 5Dɏ ;v |MN$I Xzt&壶+m^oNîTפzn45Q! ʡIS#NM]} a=8hY:2y2wեۮӵ0<4A?n`EE npJ>o|&6Ha 2(V+__!ߤn[q_ZZsE{!^u"*!_¾;z^oU>z5wIѝM_ox_V[_~}?MI?WMU.k[p+Oշf4+Z#uMoM.?k7]Azե}]NӴV =A^FE mHA0:#4B X%`6tU}BWM' 4بl0B"tDVg " l]4M1UQep`@k"">\%1l,Ny1)fGJKT8Jˆ endstream endobj 12 0 obj << /Length 1656 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im13 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F14 11.54 Tf 84.24 692.64 TD (markets, thus creating a duopoly in each market, leading to coordinated interaction among the) Tj /F14 11.64 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (remaining competitors. Moreover, the $1.4 billion transaction would create a company with) Tj /F15 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (huge market shares, reflective of ) Tj /F16 10.69 Tf 154.08 -.48 TD (monopoly or near-monopoly market power. The Commission) Tj /F14 11.75 Tf -154.08 -26.16 TD (issued an adminstrative complaint challenging this merger on November 25,2008, and a) Tj /F16 10.55 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (hearng on the merits before ths Court is scheduled to begin on March 31, 2009. Par and parcel) Tj /F14 11.74 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (to the case before this Cour is the head-to-head competition between CCC and Mitchell that wil) Tj /F14 11.55 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (be lost if the transaction is consummated.) Tj /F14 10.22 Tf 192.96 -44.88 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F14 11.64 Tf -158.16 -60.96 TD (Respondents, in their motion, made three separate arguments. First, Respondents argued) Tj /F14 11.56 Tf -35.52 -26.64 TD (that Dr. Vellturo's expert report is irrelevant.) Tj /F14 10.22 Tf 198.72 -32.64 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F14 11.60 Tf -84.24 -47.28 TD (These facts are admissions in this case that can be verified by) Tj /F14 11.76 Tf -115.68 -26.16 TD (Dr. Velltuo, who was a witness to these statements.) Tj /F14 10.22 Tf 201.12 -45.84 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F14 11.54 Tf -166.80 -137.52 TD (2 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003.) Tj /F14 10.08 Tf 188.16 -30.00 TD (2) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000041907 00000 n 0000041966 00000 n 10 7 0000042043 00000 n 0000042207 00000 n 0000064638 00000 n 0000042735 00000 n 0000042354 00000 n 0000042483 00000 n 0000042608 00000 n trailer << /Size 17 /Prev 41581 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 66360 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000104822>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R ] /Count 3 >> endobj 17 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 18 0 R /Contents 19 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 18 0 obj << /XObject << /Im20 20 0 R>> /Font << /F21 21 0 R /F22 22 0 R /F23 23 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 21 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F21 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 22 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F22 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 23 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F23 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 20 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im20 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 34139 >> stream vIUŕ.+giHՐTITv*Ϣ.~1‰d \[+WErsDDDDDDDFY"H2+f%EѪ(2r|j#ȢQ"mngk χxDAǽ]$hE3uipe"rz?t]'O[K=|G[//\J#~鿛টU_w?ѻx>mJVհK%vODqYb\l{ ZP5DDD61,buI\2)a R`+2%fl2QK;p5 @ [@E[H it`4"BmAwZ pdrw]ak^at qN6 i;aQ8@iů~^zn_UK]#*^Jr3)2]!!"k$!@A2 jHE\"NwtDkH @u EA:'x`̻w8wD: l0@Z$"ABPBwr(753~[iCIBB,=6DݡV¼,%x%M# A#Pti*wH6k&U#P|vHWu۶t+vm _^'z;(fߔOyݯ_K}mo)+}L^.d]+(HWvQNj/$n_tVo֗5J7V}?oOdF}ޗZ{ֵ` -=jo}֕}^]=c_oڽtҊcӽ_Æ ]eǫ WT6W&K 7Z_륒>/{K[Km'=v xq >#4 ~Ȏbӈp7A=dKP P`ZVKA-^paS]-*ߗ⚦!M `ڈA@c5m1T~1"^)i D?$3R%R\;kLrcxL&L4LфDIP)fhB' 0t &h hGh#A r4H1 yx͘WyFⶎ"+dUL靑PAH;j~ mZ'l"cP¦ab fż lTBP!BviD"df!"hBY'L!K'dd I#D ֭WPGidKKˊ'AB%'-8"PopL A g,5-0ڦ<&!kA3¨IjO_{l>jI}¤+A:ArVUTd|'!]dB'2.4_Q|_Q}O ɜd×m0Rᴉp.mh9z'{tF;E 'WMst%[Z-iў?>׽7k­Mդ$d[' ڷME5N2:5tׯ0ڿzu }&Wii#(պkO7_a[,6 ?I^}il/x' #a?uTiRU}_]7ֻu_}~]-Rk`aRTRVh%L%ZI/Vu<5xPǯkVoצ굧BG}_^ny1UU/Tׯ~۬x;[kaV׏atJ T¯^"L&ÊaTxk__o_hW*aJ߭X$S ç|*iPa}t ~6a'T!z~\XvAV]Wz_t <9(V T߷~ihۯaN??ON7MCJNwuO ap nwK𗠟ZҭT]/_ۮ K a-;AVQ~1Q[;RCpj Dc vHGLSث4d-3ga> lASD0hn7Pa2Gv"!h/D 0\ @V!֯jv;D;% SM`|v%G`jm" Q84OJKwӯ.K^]MȇhE={IƷ^] !P;3fٳ2Fy/eC5ʉֿa]55k   s9zG˳3l:YFKr#^[Z$ BU6"j8>`BC8 !0a:H0}b%:{1G2D8GLdFg3"|4d'͞l=$ ӵ|q7 \XM '섅`Ҡ§@(C;0ː `hF\,20x.f` hFe<.=hZj K ,6AxE^?I 0w1\(iC40 c4`PhZx(Ml*q~TAۭ`D`Vud uu`u8fT#.y}´_< ~(|1|2S.܃NMf.SL.㴑c Ɖ0~R}+iǪoq#m xI+6 ^H?#A[" $34`Ȱ>K[@HuOJ[_z[ %ܕM:N3pպ%i{J״*_ڡկn{q[+-~on]}맴H_[k[CUGZ#K tznZR5}w=-B=K(ik[tNU2_W[װ­[OwᇵoխD]?`lzX__#q7i/7O_T.~~k_~7U u;Z}}Oy_#.7__GaoկW__|yOG7$>7 QQ֖H6rrEi_Kkvo47{_uuvPX޿Z-0J1ҺMi_׫k]__tzRi_1}{oa%o u_]u }0nӄ-X3ޝȏ^{u~+UcUiy4 6ͥ lvv_aZA ( ӈ[ 4K & C pka{aS6½1_߱Vz Cڮ$ NR!tJ K47dG QC-886o 1I%$NoMOM'A_Ciiq L 0A+ pw` ҪOaAb 'Pai ZqDDD!I05 SB`a5v]5[IᦃPbO": 4ZDb"4" ( Lp h2Puay{503M P[ fgL"""""""" ЈaPaRh ;AӅ. .\CF!_aA4D&m%!mNxR TF|Ns_EH'+!ÅvM.#CKiz U C;J_[v[uֵށ)2C7^5_'F/] 0T"0@h?)TI[<'Pgkh¦ M0P`a 2p !!x3H6ATgA ;.8FagLLƳ5.#K!ZA(q$Bд]а aH"pPDMz.&\Cb1``K>`D'CAh3@a0P $)8moZA4hհ^Ka?bjO &؃m&8Ƽp05S [L ⩪ 0 iM1 nV@LSB JLpa2+a0& 8""""">" T !D\DDDib""? #] ; v.DP[AA$\[P ]ŒQ(T<d ,AL9YI?avA0 դ߭%L-k2\-z\VbVwIGfx4HU}Wwݻֺ^^:l6)#6 3R /֗_d C"0a"' 4BNTaL]%](L!ih? &\CPL`!r' )?"6FfkR>P럍Zy8ha"TEOM40@!pa0L0ScB0DO!(\!vE ZyR;'eN3#XH3L4V$% VMAϝ+ 0%Ah`5 Pnڭ04U(Aašfb3y@O8d`:( !<0D9Ȣ'ZJBq"H27b$ "AC:C JOiv}X_4O(0d"X'pD0aELw{XA' qA{ '2LP a0a0Pi 6 M  U¯z:[m-^l' OMNoȸE4ȹEt#$1E_t%n0Epd"x0-h\P&IaPa[A\mzүWzmwڪ^~I? &}TH4ƂРa&HaEt_R,2XA.P6(iG_¯ J}տa/`ȶ"7O^dyK] d\ȷ|=IIc D/뿺ڰwYp^޶BZҼ'akz5a KN '{s ^Wanء;}kn>~իֿ_-z}A_G,pD}xJa7v/_Ih{i}x_oOa_ԱWÓ׿^+l>\_lxK_Uu__*ת05/&']s9@Zץ_ L>jWw}m]\]_l8_a" }c5௅,(G0򎷮bp{_oMڪ__omM7=u냿'ݿa'o/yOA?oV]v߮@*7BIvHY {4*뤷 o脋 $_J6oO_k齫~jcXn:҄{Q[v2$_t/_+O;k뺭k7ZuAOVaa?vU׻mvߴ8W[{[u꿵_Gm4B<4&ӅM]U &Kaj دҲ=GdM@*צ6w ҩq}i:O}턻 謹ݯ`q * 4Aû41GiZӨMX; q_]AH"XնbW/1HA }Uܛ !e=?KAk  Ern 0@ &L d E4ኻVq'j #h 6#+=R8"#˃ f&g/i: aEp ;a66:vX{Kݱm&TۤMZXӉ $DDDDDDD0CC) g9A 0'AeAiQ0 L a4WVvEMa]&m0naa0{AoLpa$c Ɏ8cv 27+ Zȣ xЈE0B$""""!,TΠ& ω4B$RÄ.2`Pz'xѹ2t&"W U.Hv1iƋZIx&av菮?p&[M$MSm 2V+d}IN ~Ez|S"""!DDDDv"zTS[Ih:NBb@B\0 bDzi`dKX0]\E"?!T[ x((]H%v5̢-vgP vU wI pb"¶ȉf8wT?Z"Q9?0ޫ !{#W_uwz߯ΦH"mTe?p/#g32:d{9I׮ߠ㓼A8]8 !C91Zx@  иZBC dFpFQ#c#Vc13(uJU GH2?Fo0Jk[A7[!ANQ`a 'J''lha0Bt,"vô !C >3Ba0" `gع@9.qjL"-` N DHftD0zUo@l iOXdp n|! ~AݪPh4N! $8aƉaSA0B Pa0T B COOZ4Ol#2;3#ixv4/p"×p8y4^CEqrpаX p?OwO׃{պOR_[K,`m+I wzIum[ށAVwNzA2g'~jk=:O:$W>`ȹ_W =+I[d;H{hQҽ!j^ޫ$U/k;= Ј^XLO9N]ߦ?~׿>}7l%[:^[_ߎ "Og_']Bp/}xau1CA{O}"QK{KEa_K郓@ɡx?7ߐ6]Z[KFI!7_¿xJ_~^O4WKiw)߯i~:A;o0+}ǰ'#[K^_Mc~ֵ~N_׿%K}m0AgQ_Z~ ߤW{a*`[ik44_y{ nڑB@uh|'NMa_(vGW׺~{n׽}N5-Mc&/{Ga_Ca+a_{ּ pQQLP p ź C7W~Z^'-Snﰗo^}Նna,e A]2+2#6HMSA4.B:h&047Ɵu+IuXV Vڑpv=m//Z""2ʬ:<N;ev|32PX5M4Wh84nmn!!LBj U0QlmDqjGjlCa_MҍDDDDDDDDDE!"""""f `s3F3 ikj h!#4 ݧxt4{h&hRvU ']\DDDDDd"3]'cPA>dp CAEpR,GȮ 4 ai !)?(qLR4vJά# 0L&S}; +%28ֽ Z֫""""""""" jL"r|ؒpv]}Zj9apI0ҥMbW;AH;Sl't(28N3*#+m8)73#&3gbs> pTPNerH&W/3%(VEkP([ %h }YMdpl+:_Z U "`0\>ЃD&dk8h4O \'n۽EJ0s"TT_mn__׿ *9,8vpE&;!;_Kk q@Ip_ֽ}M󨞁#4Ͳqh#" Z{BkfƘ'L‚ (f"R쏚ְLk륯߿êix&L(M 3  @!SBA-gQ"xFAs%[uZuO.]D5@а<&7 rc^XA m@l'aGvGNˈkC6aKA"  )p΢ P2Ԃ'y<)&D|txf8Ψ)t>j $ނAȐd% t\22~_C%4 0HTNDHt) [}j5O@ >! \YpDgLx" 0}k$a6?I`2%ƤW}Nn…\Z (!Dm2(6wa5M^wO[J``Zw_)Mj]dW; m A"EޝE 1Q~k/Gm-uG*owoSo%:b|=a _Ɍ`G_zaoTv[ ֿnZ~ԵK~:y1\w9;U ev{}? A-_3үv  FT#k u{Da#mw___߶^m.7(bB(acRU߽j{vO^nkAw_A`Wߧb} UovSuK91=~_5j]t=jT5i{.1Xk_~Vo{_ThkAV6حmPl%i'`Sƻdqߥa7Նzau6UEwZ ":@ !1EE1AA֢;`55V+u~ߥY_Oשaxa0P[NjP TkdGA am==i;m(b ^ڵb.ۨxua-oUavG 1DDDDB@0GS428>3=:itLWMCM6N &6(2+ @փh8mE i5U]G a _bx3/]DDDGX ! Ä DʂjX0 (PG&L*oQޚ0A'MI5(P\7b d%J/|8Gbb~k:)}Ý1 ]v}ǿy& Ľ"<"h4FW3Ͷ~ֿ}3¨/  0BވJp#9/"0dPD<fHΑ"^t¾'¦^O2 PCЃ<``YB4tlS>fpRlA0.E H2Q%B:y"3R5d[aŢ}drbT^?Jpz'\; 𞩪$>o`0O &k O aAB# 2C60{3Tf3/MC83Lᚌ՟E"$#̍Hd"LЎwWӲ.R =wJӤd+hxD:' {B7hXdc$a+ A?ֶﴺ+KҵN~LDx lB N I6LlC_b i6G}/ .L-TDxeǰa}].o_m/&wGLs:aB *0 QLlSX@¦w.V]}ۃA]]/M⚸ӇqVL{&`8M2 ip¦G0a; dXJA UnA. 'ua|wnҺj;Iwikǰ"""""" Нq&:A9P3&=XԘaPd'm(M0il II!T0@A0i)4ith0 @"""""""""""R0¦SNU dg{8a4kھ >LPji (&E DJ3*hDDJdQ:ꥸ,'GB !g0T!DDDDDq_;?P 0먈?&NIqzu@+2N˂wVK3!!T@;23yw0 EC$ŹNAcUZ!ds'8p iaS>;^ӆÕڅ KtÃARu@ri߯׷봮O%hA}7z~l%hr5D[)ɱA f)<ÐE>pϑ$2;:jD@AL B&L"0Hc$# 22&α)UIkJ EhhZhH[A0M C3 L   @By-&Ȇ31Ȫ$@D82ZB!rlgS&,(GלA.E;=:dv~.(q *&;4 i0S(BAC g6(&3: 00DQ dO"qf@2MGlY>COVdyKF.HH;!8d# '"&4' ց(M084 Ux Xz &`ŸL 4 itt+ֺpa:Xa=S7Nw'i?2`h9]i} AqCawI``Pu0!=7U}ӥi&ݿ*{ޡ>ޒ W; G_8DQwc ˺/(m8I1 @hLx8x1vz]AY=jkkV}7[]=piii: #&4E}7"ߑmN=iBasOuF=\N[[_i{uBո^N¾ӭ# m&jɁ_i}\1"Kz$-}o=uk~nN_:tM8=@O0A~z>]uOUhptkoǾ UZnڿHűc%kO>!U}+!Wo_"!?u^ $~HVD%iv'`ez/LhTڿy?ҭA?]^wK/a ?__=_Za1_}I$a/$ nkwo"wZJom_H~b %^h9m¯ZmuE{Ye6yVQz.DZ:^^ރv-W_}_mg]޽?ܢ:)~utJﰁ[b_b]k`~֗k_N0Wu_$$J l @چGa$L*lqVul%pzQ ԿW_ګiC[Ia( a9h6Ma^զ6 =#}ӑݥv^]鰺_Ұ:cWIi7 ɰ!D!O0ڂjiaLU!tm=1 qMi1Pҽ^0@X!""##*#>#sð IuTȮ 8݊3a]ؘziJqGp{Ia$Mq\qةC,A- &3:d(a0jզV4 ªL&j0ՄAVA )LTBb dG[Q `M# &US:>6FPg0'P NnP5M2 µi%ЈE!>G !'&  InJj+%Urj +SW=HW鐏ꘪ# p`8GCj?`E&DMY AJHGȃ;Ige1Da5[C7&d背{+ap@a4ɾ", Cٚ;a4̆DA'#y٠u )脄 H@PªIe*dQd᱂ x_obwP0z@-ZWw̰^ڤm׽V^=- '3 jN! S6f>y C'30D> AvHJ8T}2 vK v\& fM=SL*apxTf )C3f U#dQLO=EtN(hCAxDa/(:A< ¦6-gMi[qAC|(AS /U߯ojޅ-{t2-߃^oR;ȱA괕 A,zTZ__O_6ִ}M{&RJZ~޿p$Uzu=ءZ"'~#ߺzoJ|Z[[}*zJP-/|W~_ j?`ǯxc(Ij/J% >u _ܡ '2c7^[]ǭXOz넫[oGBЈYn,m_uKMC$-vW'nmtmW>?[/kIm޺~zoadJ/\J_}7e׫_z_ݾIWMތv?z}Ȅ]{mN{jrG Q!kiZijl*uRGm׭_zu&]z|m:lRvaTU+KIzmukw^w@/߿^o{1 * b%jŰ6v\No5߿][ ~~iV_V0xLB,m11H XnҸJQ}^?ilv߽JHmXKOմUau[{  N: & =!2 0KJPM `PMxlثTk]v %Aq ]6WW:׊_4hDg/>< V2M; Z,Ph0)qNIajKq~U2P`>pL&a0O& iQM 0AQ TB@0AՄ{4@L qZDDDD9gzূ@ Ka#M[8`M4@(a_J Z""""""""#ć8B&8A4 4",3{4dc j"8KֺתX% ˈAcE6QQ",SPL%fwGABFFG\**B;AmKp)IbK3\qN"FtL& (OX)_AkU D͕z h>K}4+ep(Ò8pt-* LE !6Eh2@Rq͘D`dQ T͙ٝ f—HYVEfeC#݄m;uEzN6 \46xwkqpдݥAU‚ 44` D*h5h=s "&9b 'kWzХ]'`KI"[6T w0jDĊ:j-8`д(*`N-iC\  ޓ^ֻZ믮ov'_ڦ#}8d[7 'iE/"W^9wEb_42bp'l0k[;hl wWiu뾴8}:t-n NN t&l2-+IEOR-ȱ'aO/ A:@սa_^~Uw;z~_|~mihXZO%,0JOt'6MJuK|\1k/mZbK_KKZIۮZ\p_}Zu8pw*u B:__u!c!ꐿ]~"woO ָ"jUܘ Oޗp{/kZaUozwj}/Rwe_ɺ`䜔._|A{ VWDï}D]z./á:x_}NRi}Rm_$vH~-xaZO[_ڮpu?ͥ֗_I붞_oW(خ_{(־կ~~kKZڶ/i6w_ZS_kDcoNKr2@E>A?I=.aa:28wSJKۧ_Pm~~ ;bKݱ|CL^A҈vݱ_ +%pˎ:VT?ko~տ^*`6{h0Aj9[r -xb[)?k v %+Iskzi=C ۫Ԟ_;& ^GdjPUa`L`0NIMOV}%>볦;+nz0<4Pi(a4 AJ @)`0`vjӆ 4M &8ib{ثjD=רy~!}bZb"iDDDDhDDDDRpP1| e8"5=tQӰ&ia: haHiaa^`t 4QM {LqOႱWU5uDDDDDDDAeA x=W )c \; -it5 7TA ӂm ;AIZTEM.M M9AႪ G:0As( #{ Ih0M*A?ԛ(K]""""#/c J #Q++  )7@`dy$DDDDDDDDDDD!A-|h-,('jZD AfJMښ .3!Jrgu]R3Gd  aP]V#N4M& N(_X3*258Hj*4h'Tv.%@ j0RY&=O('K I'pv tHT_:nh4zP[W ؋ӆCOp^:i+$n"Aĝ)1hɰO:]V.x/Ojq*g P3`h9 3dG#!OgEA#8u^coXahha]..!߄a4LXD)Ǧ20d@c!~6GQITFs% sq_G n_`ȸwI}n dḸ&0A io 0O* `X'`P@!!wۡ޷K*_6m=77&W4UE%ݤ OWNd^Qa`$2#0xri蝈+lHܑtܑOƩ}WZ}^Z;"ztA  Nt]íM?[ w~ lN Zw Vi+8'~vzպ|%__aƻ (Wq]~o?{,?AXto}.Ҿ0ҿ~ }i˭aad$Y? zn}:IH o_J]uDom#Z7PO6GM}_O 4 5Zop=iv^!o _>~Qz t/I7_n{`;__OK%~^ CzK?|3߭^ֽ5Sޟ죵 ?\ҭuB=&ltM[_kMZW{u h* TM(4lI[ $ uvZ~v/_K_4Mb (ƭ1J*iA&8b`dujM*i0&m%[_G:0Kh4ji@qL4ƷȮ"bID%a-w꬏ޮ_6?n ]7M_V"" gPs;h&N M`dW0AOj+l%j[  qkڥ[jKDDDDDDYSʴ3Ba MAtz dGQ@0AMb(H4 ` Vr1 AMpqL$ o`HADDDDDDDDDDDNDDDD3~>[cه9Oj 0O m5M5A4mD AMDDDDDDDDDC"&le$ GI" @S:d*ki 5DDFM ! FSvw8}ɱs ?_;(.*zn(y !pRpU7twDۢz&}Z߯`aXp |k8oFxlHڸHVbX+BMtڦe9O'` e"""#+A0V5;ZȇᬄP 0B’dUӲtAYqP]3c;HuX'589>- 0aa" / >^sMw[{+ r4w^{ꮺn5MoL 8 EHFDT%.속_K]^͍0(* _)lST)|3C+$A_H6 ؍!.lɻtMߠ Oh0M  AL00,t`T!,*a)m aK fb03:{ SemiJVKV"*pA ŢƋZrc{M h91"CAo&O h0 6* ha6_/aZMj'zn X!Gd(g6p2^i' "nat NXp0DvD8wޚsC]zzNn߽uZO a^} #3Ä$Ewl)|NzN'H;hf /?ֵ}zk'K׽7? xOp"ZGWRp XֺֽuWMCޯރoׅ~.Zn.C#Ƶ:8&.B,'_1W\n껯?ۯ_DA"O+}k[vD^ 8/ZCd~ꫯ+u`~B5_,D?*~N /@J~]F}{Dp+nnza~O*o|?+ _"Q_U__kk_~ڷ_`ߥ+^~m. ;$ۤޗ_}Y/!ִkG*ا?K݃I~^Wz޻~{5a}~^T.ouxzdp~ڏV8$%)Kf=/w/Zn B`AX`K0u[ik9kk]7Ukk]X~]Cu t'Q0Loi0J*qQ\>;LצԄ)Z{ ouVg8:r:5na2,+pݪAcLا6OMO!^PՊbB=1I" cm8`w Nc'` h0z 0LkNꝑa|AA 7*6ڻ HQ1+aŪH (!݂(/GdaȰTS& :j&AtA 4AB ⸈""Q6p3A`<,NHaB}0P,'0& 1M[L&M2, mKuODDDDDDDDHD8 "Aq`L& )wg 8猍Ѥ ڜt1@WQDDDDAtb"""""""5Ip,-4Ja1+*U>Mfp΁I]%CBA)v &w"aNA0Jٞ[# J"![% ÓPMBey5"nzw;AA4 pޯKdBavmwio{ 2K[7v_]/_MzB(| j־+ ˑԼ"8 Ќ sYt&rG,3 4ByՅ_WN0an`aO \p͈Ch!qPfyBҿ_h@ mT[ Ba5L"CaWL p,"GQ#c(3F]yF}zC ';D8A: ]h;}TA0!j 3'("jȥ/dNK *3j"2:hԂ*y`¸28 oȣop>pF2B Lh0MSUM55 (M5L  83N0D% :hA?a4BD="=Ld2D\{ouUKº[/w׊_~a%]7"C__&@]a?&J܋e_tҫh-S't? S_ ޟI݆~?&#w^Z _@޾z /az'P=WmWom/{mz{ $= _tn%_YCj^~C%{itGvAAUM1_Mi.뭤t~} jboo^vQ/VH^׵<% ]rs l4տ[V~~=~~v*T8!*K݄> bh;#߄ɑKi~׭i{U0B`Ր@ڪ@ӂlSw\~dpEKJb@B?^KZo[ i/k 4LL+l U jb+ 6Ӹ}>:^D^lkHmE$LV1;R?)Vӳ4ȎDm"CPdF ) 5 f0 8a0N   ^iM0ŠdAA"a a6؏a i{]>c5t0N6iQDDDDDDDDh 4Fr 2̀PAMAj:j,&)Aa4 A) `v;MIi6W눈Ը82AeLA)5a4P0L(%aY lB4"lr#p M%DDDDDF\ eԪ ˰M03^]ɉ!Mdq°UM4T-4t-0iK|DDDDDDDDDDG"&a!pɖe8"?Ұ""*Z DZcK^iK0mB Q3^ˆjj?%_?pZQ@jϨh9 U AYɹr,r;r|tЬDDDC;S; T9ܨ;qXHr4q93Cs 9nMȣr$H|DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDNB3GFtm3hdqkGY:#0ӣF/8aAS ҈… v4 #4;! v:id4K4- 0L":ဃ"SpYq&4`XL&;uAÓ2PDLv7 ]@jmwKoA$ݐm+DjtuBM ;M.MJ][]t_[~ƻR"338K OT0LdBCf4, ͏*ݭR~$_=C'4E4-{}_|[F8,Q+>ZH7`Ȱհ׭+-& /:MwU/M^k]2cի_on~"Kmz׫zn5ֺ]/_IK^z¶Okؐa;+WH"T`jDt0쉊(1A8h6aUai5@0M3s / SPm) hESi $.""4xl*a+"", ' &J_uU-Ԛ吣Sy QaY  *;ˣ*0Gr!E= p!Î4 a:!IL''";a iރK : gbN?i5^鰉$Q!m$b\ ݭ'׵u; פ?9/ݷv?mNtL/j<^I] hA0Ak^uwPC=$6 VҍOn L=$o農 bb 5`5l5Uq Wt;ծ?;WUU '~j !vuW['ӾOd`ݽ,G ;_C9տEuճYzyc:[շp{_P>ث_nI$}7Io mM]i'm ${ +N_]5m-_^m'J.u m%xA0OK,a "D ` E 5!a Zkv>Ga$ڠѤa&566m) l+mbX^M &kɂX`UIXq٬3:a M0MzDDDD2n3 DDzkl( lNMf*KT:rJ-" P+R$@ endstream endobj 19 0 obj << /Length 2487 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im20 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F21 10.26 Tf 282.00 689.04 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F21 11.62 Tf -150.00 -50.16 TD (Second, Respondents argued that the discovery sought from Dr. Velltuo is irrelevant.) Tj /F21 11.56 Tf -48.00 -26.16 TD (In its subpoena duces tecum, Complaint Counsel asks for "a copy of all documents and/or data) Tj /F22 10.94 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (cited in Dr. Chrstopher Vellturo's Expert Report. . . or otherwise relied on by Dr. Vellturo in) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (the preparation and drafting of ) Tj /F21 11.56 Tf 144.48 -.48 TD (the aforementioned report.") Tj /F21 10.26 Tf 53.52 -31.92 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F22 10.74 Tf 115.68 -21.36 TD (These tyes of documents) Tj /F21 11.71 Tf -314.16 -25.68 TD (are exactly the tyes of documents that are used to investigate, prosecute, and defend an antitrust) Tj /F23 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (case, especially ) Tj /F21 11.63 Tf 74.64 -.24 TD (one in which the parties referenced in the documents are merging. Third,) Tj /F21 11.49 Tf -74.88 -26.16 TD (Respondents argued that complying with the subpoenas would cause an undue hardshp to Dr.) Tj /F21 11.67 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (Vellturo. Respondents fail to meet their burden with respect to that issue as well. In Exhbit 2 to) Tj /F21 11.60 Tf -.24 -26.88 TD (his report, Dr. Vellturo identifies documents and information that he relied upon in preparation) Tj /F21 11.66 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (of the report. Thus, Respondents already have a list of the documents sought by the subpoena) Tj /F21 11.76 Tf -.48 -26.40 TD (duces tecum. In addition, Complaint Counsel is requesting to depose Dr. Velltuo, which is) Tj /F21 11.55 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (hardly unduly burdensome, especially for an expert who represented that he had testified over 25) Tj /F21 11.71 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (times from 2002 to 2006 on his currculum vita submitted as Exhibit 1 to the expert report at) Tj /F21 10.74 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (issue.4) Tj /F21 11.69 Tf 34.56 -26.64 TD (Dr. Velltuo also filed a motion to quash, and made two separate, but related arguments.) Tj /F21 11.61 Tf -35.28 -26.64 TD (First, Dr. Vellturo argued that the subpoenas impose a burden and expense that far outweigh any) Tj /F21 11.62 Tf 34.80 -51.84 TD (3 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003.) Tj /F21 11.61 Tf -.48 -24.96 TD (4 Vellturo Report, PX 0837-053.) Tj /F21 9.12 Tf 188.64 -30.48 TD (3) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000066685 00000 n 0000066744 00000 n 17 7 0000066828 00000 n 0000066992 00000 n 0000101992 00000 n 0000067520 00000 n 0000067139 00000 n 0000067268 00000 n 0000067395 00000 n trailer << /Size 24 /Prev 66360 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 104545 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000135727>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R ] /Count 4 >> endobj 24 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 25 0 R /Contents 26 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 25 0 obj << /XObject << /Im27 27 0 R>> /Font << /F28 28 0 R /F29 29 0 R /F30 30 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 28 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F28 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 29 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F29 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 30 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F30 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 27 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im27 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 27261 >> stream 4Q@`jg6 %+ƑZ`\t ٰ0l \(L!pUPBw":ީVkY"3u4q3 zw>hOWί뮘^#g4,؆e3JHd{z~ (@^=u<^ ExWώ?#6=h7M_kI'ޤqIqltO 9I>ڤְ/KSz|ܿл^Qtօև﷿b_?"$I>N ol]{%K_[ ?^_%a4DJ`Ms00`_~X/~_{ ڿI0FkjOmWR yà`t4 kMxapaDV#aI]4{OQ !KɺJaC ? 4@hSfvGaYoN",2\i Kvð4v)`iÙ n8zۧx־k^J0FGbYRDf!4#Fc("a8B+xD/Ȩ?ԛxјF:h3l0A[$Aa d싄 S 30腠?DBCЄ;"MaL0CL8DTAahNCp'o05lU4… 4-nvO45L"WP $NEXv`xа`yD22%d菛!{֕D i+WKr\@@xtJXdL#"MaJam;L-]եZZM{U_kmkI~~bJnU__W]zUI"wVb5=w]ڦ׵߭c??Ub _~!m}HÖ9:O__+,{l5_3^ qHo_D6XK}׻0Oo__ۭd+}H?ײGk>_ZumZZK߽_\5n_jZZ_m/ilVҶҵ^%߄޿#HK޿?k]ZAǻ";V-mAm_&ESa&Mv.4`@ؤ 2:0dGMMS@N"BN` S SR$GAh:"8Ih&A0{ * MYl-{ L q}ZTM4#\Ϙu/ A&V!a.L&4"K#-zg.C8@8p P!FqU ]jZsA % 4( &qv vEB;Y32"\&@aABd\ L'd`L&dJ!<œ33;AVБV8P]} ̔A1pL*o;_tKGëKg2, &w'h; $Pn ?$f+ؖ'8;JaĉÒ0Wo_}?V֟Ukޟ_ޕSjY#Su_e: yd$y|{f2if N3bjRl6uG3>F'Qd!EH#Pt, a ClOH?B.3A?p`2 B (* a<. 6Hk0zhë́L0B]pş 0j|"& &H Y!B4 (\<xLAB҄ب0SMB DyE cEۤkۻPi$\b5dT2T v|j<᧎!a4t0d#ޚ xEzV2%aϑNdXnETw"Ix^untB[~հ٠&Kj0׺NPM MNxAj_ ۭ]k7CUo}j]J׽/˅߭zK_޶VZ־߾[]A{#zv\%kCW}~[__ߵW5iz?_}<⿿nh*_ﵼBW$\/: __\DWI߮@_׫&#,`e~'M_]!־~{}xDZ_kK"Q"OA;o۴mߥk_}?_T_uMT ~eZO߯*ޖ+*}n? ]־_o/~{F}k yg0[]{_ц}uNs]^I^i_]CZo_}-nW'nMߺK-pUz;#]w` $կvc-m+K_R}2$-JԸӻ Giǰ׫H%lAh'0{^ li. cV+BG-m&KŰl%kLR1Q#bvն -܉v/bDz 5aZ*ql]ƺh5UkڦEDUWj Cӆ k@0 ؤtBN0[L 4j CPA ( @ j*dG H&6 x mzAv)ia a!1#N6 i 9ȃA膍]; WiL0PÛid'A5j K 5l-` AawvXKiMA'\& RÚ & gL,wae@">Вy* "B""#&y!漢#!E00D.{YMqh<t2D|W ЩNN ;th@q4ʰHD ˄H@+КaHgNb""""""""""zЇDDDDDDDDDq"hDDDDz׬%^,ixV! aNa,JB2; GjRɰv٨+#ϓuzi֘&V &`  ̖ ~&zE"ov.4z qKWǃr|]G+ouu_^W; Di"5aeFNHDDDe^KbP5f]@yDE4_#3cIp#3|!2D"h\b {,?BӞ@f,u43S:a"5GQhtE>AĢ"##DDDDDqADEDDDDDku K֒KUKMԄq0`<aml % !KB#LRvS[L &aLɚGO""1-pQuVA96+ݝ;S²ѐv&dE@ZkaS[̼iŨP((PA_inpڐG\l8h_piVxEq\Cuo8wZ׾_$Kz[kkzW^v#SV|Yʆ.=t8NJ$"'ESFyΨhF:22#y3!8tyAd!ȇa0@8  #dh[$S:2 6Pd y<@DIQ τ Nd)ac0#c΂Ft,SB8=0A ! ʁ@8ЇZ`%NF= MBAy {Ix(L# ` j3!H`qAS gA,4AO /za 004 kpx4ld'BT]Zh{Ij4$87t^! tA0[O4HvUӍ,"CD{v^a"yj%;M"} MȯEmZ10vhham}SGADC /(.G!2c 'mv>l2+pI6҆[_I?'IWi6Ho K%Oᤘ$h&m]'݂a]u/ڶХ}[Uv ɟ~m'_{m&=䨝~Im< }/}5O?'tK?]}uVU}}ko_wu_]Sཾ{Ez~[" ~C꽮#ֻTw oj_N=K8ԅuݭ:noH` r~ X?@H߿Kr9 ie 'WoO~; tXD!NLoz_l?{_ ./~ISDQ$zoI߭"o4utgz l/ ! K >a]}7 wh[ [i^VHm K/(?$n+c w.)۶v a_'$nH^y#ڭo['amH/JDц]m-]_Vy*Vj{Zv^x4톿w~uu_C_]; rw/_] 7n%]{ JX:ͭ[]0V }li0Eh?ciW HH!0c}}ǭݵӑWd{j+ 0Hi;+kD$}5a[1qզ $}xa-h(>jqǰT$XbGn bi>h1^´ iMHAAGT0dASM&iMN T ؤ jMC &8\Ai0<70[k2#"=A50Zj0kZal&L&(BMA1aL(j vDt 4N)0h5[I"[#vXamh0ݦ Aa `M0B#a33DAw PE0Imrt 9WN<6kk废32p c݂ (^X LsP)C\CP0A DD3 *aOhq$Cb"""1`DDDA"6""""""6"B DDDDDDDDGN"ti*(4 $qrX2ⰘTWH6 PaQ2`c mM|b""?G}^QC+ J㵈ȣ( JPD.'$ᦝb `Z$ds)p"`n n/% 0K4w4S ] 輇jpdh9:.'eue=5[$wp}Q k_^t{ۮ*>j_I%ݵp\:&G!rlE_}J;KƧ!%>F0$E"C0*!h]L 6GQq>dtͲvuDf٣$fHILg3LgXO65 6&( f82@)3‚j `!9,ȮDzcNM 0Av("&JLF't4 g 3a0 8 v(0 (L!`wj >  ̓v(T-UCM=Ph[V88D0`H61D4B„50VwN~KL' 0@a}Z "wxDt\4O?Ɖa.@+DHi{R<tG}}'^2+. |̛n/}MOO{ n pХ^kӤz;k Vۧzu>KWkUtNvWdpPO}]VIv?J]uriVX\w^[ %Zo??޿~?~+޾+[,{虱J#rKU[`''i:Cҿ.WPÿB?z^]!߫B?:"oo^-Ni_]pD_aM[Uo_o{ӿI~/ I|m?]zSo,?_(߮dKZnCu_MT_}[۵}?_nA}߿ތ3W_k]]-{{]]v鰽k^W}{e/.;uUuowjp:m[o>a/Ӯ[W Gwj  ڏ /Kc?VմU}Ӫb+WiZu %oa, vbMZaI#vBuUN%BFuI_Ixa4 x.tƬAZ* %0]66)ڐⓆ0AA0TqI D-` im0ib)5:dG` Va4a:A h0AH`&D{6PӴA鴭4 46!HA4"(0L ЅH4hoӴ @VvE &]ZML&Sof0MX`@zɎ,pK '4~j]j' &pA H|%][Ulig&5ObeY(0Z0*DAuC3(1e " !>!"" 0!TH0S+>QR'DD0Ba"""""""""#DDDDDDDDDDEBת +\X@O)\c-d̅Sh3"y.̪+Gv8(N![AddFzv PA"_%qݣ$q UoU=[/U 8d 9)6e̾}l1 gS:|Eǔf`<W_Wwpam&kId6 =8a Ny.M['i&ZMtkZ\.~~¿{kUzv_J?QAV֟uGTUƾ 1=pzaׅ'9sLrp_H/c60~L&匤"ö/Vo_H{}W"owaa#[oN޿nz_o>޺ o߯mUl?@mW_ҿA~ pH說Kw?o_dd& ]~PK9?_pn|OK׼ 7Oޞn\=?ߪ3oV/O^K߷nz} C( i{uK^k}r a$OKV?KWu1\W>R={EMM8wWTv{J.>_q$&Rt0 .]0mA'pa+ [ /mf58~9΢ji:  ঌ 0A\#d|GHC =PD1pِ Dِ 0D)l!.-SA!"y_D6YAa,͘DRg Bh3M;L j L& ?A"Cow 0k 0" l.?*aau ,Ń%1vM0v>̴."%N4a-.!֯/W'R^-Ik!&/"pwj;^'뾡l"QPD߆sհޗ4RmcK"y aizo|O^Hhд|6k>߃h﯄ǒ?ޯ]ڒ<__^?oۥW5S/S0K7mY/*c͠Ѵ꾶]u=Oޯ[Om_o-OMiU:UVֻvkkm~ֿIukskz};a[1*uޮUK]\_ ~a'Z_1_l0[ ZxZ~!!i0Ҋ۫؋JR_{e\bR=uukfN‘Zt{}?ؿcY)c?l%l4 XV#>0V#ՆlGi_uX؆Մ بhpMa:ؠL &v){4bu'M $80AOb0z T<&:ip 4omXM4$i4a4"X{AG @ 8":i"ňM2,ՆG;ݦ .a 4; &i &Ι`3 hL(&%&2Lg\DD| hi Led0tN `i 2(RV4L(rB0C;jL{;t 0&0 0D !hCB"B""""""14B""hXB"""""""!`a "#*!?6+T̹;rrw Vd'3C+5P 0Y p aN@^֥ƨt}ʝ\, MCTad$ |o]G}%k-D3ȔU2ZȟD^&"0—D2Fx"|#0s',#H ">! 7&*-sL՚ȌgDsȺZf%x.Gd8#"ZNB.C͙O383l> L&PІkff`PaSAٱBa8B a2   D`4C҈q!}{(F3xhI 80D< Bp82pa@ L&AT& &j @0P I0S7! 8*0aBjiad@^>0!a &|/^!-Mڢak & c֋8 ѧE'_87xD4]'l d-e D2C' 'l'N\`A&X2x,"xyDD7xݠ҇D7dzM82$-D۸2-ߠȶDE\5 A7MH2H: nAIH:<)6] 6:}62$1:O mjs_z ӽU<'v}m]^&tr8\$J#ZZ֕z߄+ݪ0L'W^ U ]ojKJ N4ӥuګݾO_Nzz(-]åzO_I+q}ڡ֟=huNjiWOnC;oץP~ߊ PEuoTBDX(=җeg ͥ%_&1,`m\vgWK[/Bk}taAXa{Kau^֗Z>Gwt(@Av`[?}W-~v[] 7U7do+$oY#~X|{ڱH%7i1#OW$&+tFo Q=kֵI۳oOԢc7xu]붞%k}UW]ۭ;}umjv+_~wa+:"5W]7گ_&kWJ l%YUK]_ª 46m[J i{MwᅾnKa{n+?Tw]\ Za;  /LVQ"ݯWV~4i[AL+IT6}ww֓OcL&XXoV?jwQ ,nb ᫮4gMzlRkP݄l%޶6)4 i&M0A  0a&Nl(Dx 1@ jqA0@ 㐏M4ȃ u1T Bb`A AnӵA4,&a _j - vSL H`C"ƤXCiT%]\@AIpD|Kjqe2PC@VxaM0 K&tQ2E0D9ʆ)oihAaa0Du`L#Z`B =HDb"2*B/0LBDD3!""""""""""""""";qpH-Xl(Pa !Rl%fe)P@ [ڇa4QD|"B}U*z#h'GԊB #x9' hfC  G h@0D\Za;0aBfMnBhaXD8m4(h!ŵiLp&cn v} S|Ѿ̾ ^^Rm&aOPߠ2-WK $/H>Ou'VJ[O_Mxaz~}b;ܘtaA`1ݩu z"*xV_Wl0{{GvZG 0޿,<߽1_#1 n: }}?}նn?Nz_jsfu~ˍ $R"#+n/* j´[mX-qp+k!`G t0j)Am& ":a?_m"qWz_ 5AM2_?"B #1'=@E-P""""4U M )~?iaL'E:3G3YKH7#c ah3g6".$E27>d ^;/aѶ]# c5t62HGJB$(0QjB"$x!.$= q"""EC! BM UA(0@X0 #0A KDh7` +D8$E"`{'K%ȽApvH:֪_3AXzrw6~\=m+wOᮒ}w_I݅wꞟo~W ִ}{}޿'w~Wgק0vZ^[iO_}E?^~UwuF_ wm>uՇv{++cozpMިU(a׿PGK'_h}n}E?{ _~ȯp {' _CǺe}_t?q}׿~z֟]Z]!oz,uI+!톿_멈m 'ZKﾻOoo- oگޕTW{oPkzw_ޠV Z\AqHKl*mpD1cah. ch xDqH@$6@A؂(B;հ0+=y aa; ,?\atɹ0[7;p`BH*ϰ3Rq9BrTjo56YqdS""#NQ>/1Ι>*\)a˙xeDo929Ƒ|#s33`ܸd,4?TsEsȶw0sw#rCud 0`No0>YU N} œ* Rr8S#WPPg ۙw*rVqMAQJ?M([%7F#\́s\h!/7zw{յn~}+_kV"W~կ[׃J6 %匿KPyj5ME'aVG ͂lU޶We*Aqկ!;U±ml|8;*4ھ;6lUPQLU ب@⢩A<;: BM#ڠMڃj*H1A n!2,&M DL P&¤-IlmAj+h2CU $L  &M gШAp@>#B3A3 : 3280AL g *2l7""""4"""""""""DDDDDDFDDGWtikJ[Ae /^+UlU Zڰ& &デjo.__o$vtCʼ}>eifYFh$D5ԁgN6uE3%yDhSd%n/!ܗA"$"#c'h@蝄 9x2`>-3286Z'Џ2< %&LBq #>)'@a` &3 'p P]+ ̬&OPL!Ncp}a ª !iL! +za4!1aA?C}:.b!੨TLva.*qij&80j}bzn c&U4Mڪ'N'} CFi"ᓜI_t-^RoMm__\RWVmC־}ktֺ_kǷ}~~}pƺKBc!}:NK߾A+Rv B뿿~HG8ɊVtLY}!/W9b-_-?`Bw.="O 5UJ7_]o{ _O_a//]Om6.~;>XׯGOp|o_~s DW6QVX_ȍ7^u׿-8ZOW{Uii綠^֗d_Ku__k z[_pa..KHVaZ]ui7Zﴶ[o`_u/ vK^ 7*14JJ i^HGdzMwæ+鴛O؊!5tl ??Yxa ;& Ӄ%g2A2`` 3:f38|q0,f iD"2r|08DP <Z4H/xІDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE!؈QmU}uר_;Y N /]ӨL4*`1ɰY; ̱2[D]$`DMDXL.o 6 &EJ7%Xs4mzտi,=W[]}tZNrf@\"# dL#DB1<5@D3S"yt34SNrl"4!FA ϑ~x a0 "!@lل"ٳ>3  ̈́80`La "a r$B33y Tah^ ;04TLr킄͊'駢nL"o 0(_M6DcD =|N(h4h G1;hXA;.`z,{%Jj$qiڻ#o֗%MkkKa5{_uz߽+͈^j/_o㶣k7ïz㱦w1Q ߑT4cb "$0ӐL[,gà8kX|=w"cFz&C޽-[}k0Ç%m{l%^j`Axpu^57h-د}$-{}zAGW$um^>%h ñׯλ[_Tק~K}~wm/~/ݯow(tnqװ·c_c/3߬~Z#@Xi|/B;Unm+u #GviWc؃ $qi:cxAI4H AQOAa6i&i@ QQ0!hEv &׆kM \* ؤ ؠA0 P0#p"Ii l8PҴˢ4H':6P2LΜfL k Ѓ(pL{'^\Dur"gB !W$""DGxab"""""""""""""8ƚUH,}-%a0?4hDvIh 2PFJyx @BSbx#v\2*\?i4AāN S\įw4qd,]`Y&MÒ6L7hB; )~!N& iș 'j{z\' BzwީvOׅ}v_mu_qzW?_ .׮v RdyKXO;!F&T]xOq!PUN!`C\fƹا<ل I>)¯pP^0}#~!"r$< z$hcfC "PB, B}CC ӧ/ 40AC`t}5 oB Tlz]>/hh0ީv7p]شJ^;(on#G"8nR#I;:Ȑ Ez%yz#i+dIVǸDAR}&a[%뺼wKu}um!㺼_z}}t :_O[n^ AUmm}܉zuD'iCu¯׶vtoV[M}wkDp5_ca_ȶgWȏw ߥV. IҮu/$5K >܋WIkq_~_Nnv&뭺o~IׅԎ:M-Oy[H,+|#_Do [TN1_a&}uWu~WKƌOu̍֒%߿~PkV}UZ1%ݭ}擄OjE'm'/ot_]]鴗 _MWz{dz?_݃ Ij4_LWWU ]>ػoU+b v)j0˨^i/M چ!7 7a=aCނA4 @4r bL'm a a& p[ 6QT& µaRhCh uHA &װr-Va4ӄ8a3MBG/u,se9 Յ,up 8jgO䍝@{A0LL 2b h0#R":D@! !3Y ! DDDDDDDDDDDDDCDDDG#\ K3D :9Qϑ|堑ɏ+1t>)iт0!k13$t]:>f %|Fg dp0 &X2q".)Eto1./F3y|BDgEٰᰎ bK@Pj@ Na[&\{=ɹNq90悜mC*ʡ,*@2[ Iυ9 AYE'Ssܧ*sTq.rc;\"@ceHsC\VYPTeq9 G1AÑ8&r$һΎ<@D1I DQ͑ '" A!9a3!ɁB腴pΣ*ȸGA0B&BD YN# )`Ca U D*jBY@S΂ & L&ziL AA0T5w i l&0M?BS 65_0PjCrC u7b1a!N!h=x7aiP/բ&lJզE;qqh '"NyD7L&w'8xE!NڤBvrnLCE@ݸwAEAFm"cVd_vNFA'rwV ?NW| wG& I pd\M,.KM:N u`﹑i?#MWs ?G FI+_~ըf2.RmCM~֓~յk~OꝦUhvihBIwa7Zu֥>]kk2oW+G /ǿt!wW_j\ӯ?/]hG]qդ⿥+?_]^ &9+ ].H/\-2pD/^Xκ}:9豰ד}DS ,ac/~i~"[`]V_8i~ƪvNҭa/i~zAM W_ oP+ `ޟ~CU:d_$a ?">{o3REomq}QZ~0ׯVz/kizw }ݭzֿnUUTnV4ik ӯtK}'u]~i_JvޖU$UԺȷl0+Jvӊd8$z[ӧkiZL$ nPAiWK{kmۊXJջcq6>6luqKl|/tȖըk!h(th&=$pi&;mZI;i4ZxM7Rc@0) aL PVQ[QLS@A#!PPAAȰ!H   lRiXA!4Ȱ-M i4V_ aoi Գ 5iL Ȯ r: ^ZjL8a2 2@^ & Ʌ=s APd`N;&"!M= zjg!:rxPBSЫLa0R x)[8YXDD00Z@!2|HDb""""8""#B"""""""*"""5I]kzTW ilUzjt! ,0,a|BMT Gl%>-e\W_]/] yl%ok) endstream endobj 26 0 obj << /Length 2076 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im27 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F28 11.24 Tf 83.28 691.92 TD (likely benefit.) Tj /F28 10.31 Tf 196.80 1.44 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F28 11.55 Tf -4.32 -54.96 TD (Those documents and information may reveal) Tj /F28 11.72 Tf -192.72 -26.64 TD (information that is highly relevant to Complaint Counsel's case. ~ addition, Dr. Vellturo would) Tj /F28 11.70 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (have diffculty arguing an undue burden, as a seasoned and very experienced testifyng expert) Tj /F28 11.63 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (that has been through the litigation process time and again. Moreover, we would agree to take) Tj /F28 11.65 Tf 0.00 -26.40 TD (no more than four hours of his time. Second, Dr. Vellturo argued in his motion to quash that the) Tj /F28 11.86 Tf 0.00 -26.40 TD (subpoenas infrnge on hs proprietar interests. That is incorrect.) Tj /F28 10.26 Tf 199.20 -54.24 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F28 11.66 Tf 228.48 -51.60 TD (That) Tj /F28 11.59 Tf -428.16 -26.88 TD (is what this case is about, and Dr. Vellturo is a witness to the competition that would be lost as a) Tj /F28 11.73 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (result ofthis merger. Just because he was a witness for money, does not immunize him from) Tj /F28 11.49 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (being a witness in this case.) Tj /F29 11.94 Tf 124.80 -26.40 TD (II. ARGUMENTS AND AUTHORITIES) Tj /F28 10.31 Tf 75.84 -52.56 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F28 11.84 Tf -87.12 -27.12 TD (They fuher argue that responding to the subpoenas issued by) Tj /F28 11.68 Tf -114.00 -26.88 TD (Complaint Counsel would be burdensome and would infrnge on Dr. Vellturo's proprietary) Tj /F30 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (interests. None of ) Tj /F28 11.48 Tf 87.60 0.00 TD (these arguments withstands scrutiny.) Tj /F30 9.37 Tf -53.52 -26.88 TD (A. Respondents And Dr. VeJlturo Have Failed To Carry Tbeir Burden.) Tj /F28 11.80 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (As the subpoenaed pary, Dr. Velltuo and Respondent bear the "burden of showing that) Tj /F28 10.56 Tf 188.40 -25.68 TD (4) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000104871 00000 n 0000104930 00000 n 24 7 0000105021 00000 n 0000105185 00000 n 0000133307 00000 n 0000105713 00000 n 0000105332 00000 n 0000105461 00000 n 0000105588 00000 n trailer << /Size 31 /Prev 104545 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 135449 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000186051>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R ] /Count 5 >> endobj 31 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 32 0 R /Contents 33 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 32 0 obj << /XObject << /Im34 34 0 R>> /Font << /F35 35 0 R /F36 36 0 R /F37 37 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 35 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F35 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 36 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F36 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 37 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F37 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 34 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im34 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 45690 >> stream -Q ɲ̍"9qX"&B%Y?(&2MNeR/Dv$P…AHv4gb9-Nda2f5Q9D|Ì;Ԍr q3幠.DVN*al9 (ipm&h0 .""@B.8CB ?jnӾ;,A NE |yNM<Mx "pmvH:#=,B## F i p7_}z@7nnhwul[I__m{ۤVZMN~_oW%֯A^~J#/2*y")ZT&_}&m*o}A3G#fCd4_K_;^aDnL*gfbe8͊i" ) R>3pb:ՂR2<ÿ뱱{iJ ipy8vp&k^&;`A4P cNa?2l MO@\8gQtI_ƿ(ӷ,@pvEaM pUNEHvNCpL &Z D){]}Sfۭ?M^TZn_VAE#l 987}"kqai_K tMInȮ0i]\$%&bV20:% xpdKn_~ N_+HxM_O%DK0lz0'Tt5ckniuu{>߮~nҫޒ} > ֻx8Kެ?ab!k_XWOpzcVD~M8wJzO~__C䎯a_^MGQj,>K\Ԝ1ߨtz Sv?LWW&=~}u^Ln o\zV;'a?$KvFw /u uJta^4x_~+xDпO=ߥ}j?^O붩%z_nHV ,nK߲ޒ$Sy ߶[mmwH[u޶UҤu 5vjҾ[C_ﺵw]S~I/3&}ئ8`޺_c_i}֗뤭]z}*HBt ֒.+a;4^#;_58ޥ㶻HgjVKv I/ aEj+aoAzL m-~`h$p‘$NJI?#ނpaNAS `[hMA#V֝鴛 Xk;c݆D6V]/maSK]U҈:l) j T ¦aCM T@6":0؄ צ0oIaXUJ8NH -Q`= 0&25kAɆil4釤 Z&(1^T$"DDpqXB:x_lDDDDDDDDDDDYIsV e  0v20ùh4xzX aJGDDDDDDDD DD$3O`H<3B:`s /B"#hDDDDFD}MDk &.)G$ rBHIwI"9#8r85/5EI2Qkxˆط]]Ȉe_‚! &,dA@Z?xPa0Hl̅:#UffA#Fv;+tl{&6 %| ؘgDqP쪺M/pFCC]v7%ytx@#._!]+^}*ZߺKJvph; #/AjzOI_tv!+AŇ[_w:Cuvo3c:-mZUp}}tv[ozj}W )d:5@󩚑Wٛ3C$O1<_TiJZ ga :h0ف ULH-xA!03 6f(3QLjg $P<83H\C`υD `>hSzKP-a18[>O]d\0p蝵M 0 D L"CCTMw 0[ZaD _WNi6pgia!6|:MAޛEEmF|~ؙ?A] D$L$N^;k7Qxn i0zzm[ dy 7VGKWק6:=pW`EI`(+zKzj5ޟ}ޒo[Kpi]z_ZV_m.ڿmwU{]Z_ {~ ~munlk v5uuֆ~u#O{ȐԸ& p׿zN,?uUN*__Um8C_Wzo°Ņ*}6RV_;UW^}$=VW¿%,Ru^0үM~xDÿ"o/ꖡwt?\ ߠ޿ߏhO%.OO]WQV_> W[_LDkfp^nsga֮S. K_}Akdk a~U ޟtV#$c=7([ % Һ' 8%W }z^i?UN֭w#+]NV^{ 6+Br-u0jծ׽zڮ?վҴs0H6?mC V׵5"+V׫VՊ# W& k $Y>n h=AAciqƇդ5[+#6؇pwR<WcVl%ZHIq5!56I0PK"54n M'=L!6v*(1ZimjLlGË#xkM1wDE8@ROzNۧixa50+ih4-;P AA, L l8 `"q ]>atAӴ h@oDDGÈHiBt,aOh25 0M0`4ܘM0G ilH7 ([A i\iS""""""""%:0DCB"%DI DGaO8i҈aI!$>ghJս/DDDqDDDDTO5IRT𕳴a ~a^I+h L.ua.44DZA(h JZƴI"DDJb1-b dm+ȒJ;;RdֳK(L- 2󺌳rl(H [` ̬G:+dK\k8hG9bF0V_9F,Fn%ݠ \/\0SPD!Z" 8xD0.nȑ;§-FUvP4„ 6u${4';!h8a"񓉦_42Cȣ) @h0DGUah6MމapI\:!`䃴ɢA>KMyWzxJ7noz}uޭ_m/K;y5#ČfK[ozjS C &a8ME"$#!H(K׻ ߯ե h? [`OA„ǒQ" 3S:Pe:0}:?O;B{[kXa/}:/."p [ MC.`|0Bў0 ".(CN 2x"G5;% at6"BtW4v -l2EB'L.#&؎ OA!Ñ| A8#A 27<2{uۯKQkf&ޒl;ȑW{(&z'm i Cm E]T0Z=-Z.l oDK@a4 zi'dLm"pH ۤC!wi_9^ aoCz"۬4ᒴq#M[=o{x ^#AoH붭pZ[{[tҵI[qj_d}+-k}/'u񾿼EG:_z:^]? =꿢um^[k`[.O>ǿj'uۥ~kh/78n6}4x% [V>]C?Xi:>*|?/ Kpl?"a=!p}֍o a &?믿h&&ֱ&z-+ 5.)AzI{KIчwxa֮]c^ҷA:[[vQU]7{PI񥴺"ooڷN_e}%LW zzw_k[gedN{NHg*K&_5,ե~+V+t*w߿KMmww?'#[h*c0l%k#SY_ҪMM5xZxO vGAEq0Kڠ_.-m5_{unäWIUC!SA;~66mZױVbv 6 H'~0a  ph aȏCAR 7cU@8kb$]A7=oKKջYJg-AvTa4 0톃 A Dp*`` AM'SM&)wl-XK-PMI;l%fcL zP҈"&3<2vVLᦘM;kM mH 6@iv{$("`vGؠBaiKb!%+9|5\/ a3 &TkT.p`jm/hARHDDDDDDDE!a0e@L@+ <4 0 u"3ܡ%L,r+p"""""#"""u4DDDb"""'$ix%GvDr.A28!Hٴ\Cx#̾c#x8Bxfx<|DvXDXDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDZIE]%ԃHr㑎sQSʡdsA7;9Lr$Z9F3F|(VReP-au& gc춄B/rR8m\ga̷ U krS"!a $gAqH2QEڢ;'v%繆h*A/R*0L aAU MPdTs.x a&zTD{aQ;p S"rV P i}5wnNh m;H6ꕠ)_Ұnڴ&Y D8a_I1u\[I޽7"kY4Q~Nzv<D7oI:u 5WIwAQ}@aޖ05C39?ֵ Hvk@"N oH"4jd]d O_k_;`ɌS=S_KM &:! t A Mꖕ%o\'ZK 5]ux ߥE RwH~i~ _G'h_\_4t0KEuomu~~KMO CJ㊻ +A&whcw>>wdA ا7t*xA0aB"BAW#i[oP _uC __NiӅA@0 a`TpziGncqܽ!G i0_i^J—׾E*Cj+a]f&`bvA0W7 qTPTWUa 0լA؆Kl4?3hD\ gʈit 0LT#pMv40ƒ !HG#>)PtLa $Ȏ +` $A4^Iiȁe$WWPB+Ftp;t>|)v[A& Pj.r`4ɽdX mȎd0@b!H h?B4)1"faa V)er'r,0Dt, S5ˋј ;5MB"#""#(app`9@B""" eQ e2%/DDDDp uIM* -!T_ᠻb 6b!VN^2+iAO`qjaR,sʪ;2Ҳl/t }+eYH|J((-gc1dFIؓQ$ K%"2*5dȔVCD {ppHA`0 -́@ޜSmP+M'0wnI'__o&yhgS:f2C)ȑxKZ꾫ɰT (@P`r "3L3R8։v4SD!|0Ch3@Ɓ>H0{28C)@ΙC"JO_hq 7iꚧ|i kL a532A!A88GW!|͐85Bٚ苞ß|5Ƭ'SS:JCd9粟BA |*EH:.0Zhw.d9p (*,CA'$ L d t "7vThL`gAaCA`x9L`I[$>xA'wt_4E!މ΋DyD"yED!P}_XB`/A* &|j a4UAӄt;C>`;ql;\tᤝ_ ttAtMZ/9h(wǤ<~98krnQnSE ib†$MwA Ut^ܙ{uM%ԃ6 gmԋt2(W^tlQ}ABXlNh ܇{%y|ސL??Jzo}ڸNam%sz۾W^7oջ_w_,`u֐HGK{(o vw;Koa~8OO]vk_2G[$/po$CO_7zO]>|uW~e^ j[${Oc#v3z.[^vmE?toD^Z?KKcY=[^._ooAoz믅M]R׷~ oKl6j=yN_~MW^JKU U[_o `@;h nAJ5㽫};UG[Xa}+$T _m6tV dpi6?ha:Am&E1I_a'bᅆi@RGa ݊v^î톷M -z]TDuFphPL^\6m´aE:q!EE5 a;AB ~؅ka$Ն]GN"4."""" a4wN ,0Lg&&a5 ai  ΁B!y n4 `]h0bL1I|R֝A\DDhDDDDDDDDքL]Ed* )G"AgV0RCkip/M}2,(aAASV{A iGN_DDDDDDDa"B FSTA a4aL&P;0–>L{Aa4UFOK !B#a&/i$$^AW&fGK\FBtFSkj?M)S"%^&Jn CgkDwGq((%&T2'PK֏-^>W%OɰSAP3̠'c:ʝd-|RPlAA 62FN6fG3C͙DPg"!$L{EAVMpD,ZzphQ@C8iZ'm #,'&F: * !u< &{yvia蝵ӥjlWJ8nh|2.joI߼&ҽJi[avB?z O[z~^6꟯ԏ^a_p_\DW2l=^N=]WK_p7-t6M?Y_kVolS]}޷mzoխV5Qh5 buXdq¥8bU_xؐ5Ek0؅&Du vf0zfp u@Ȯ&@>"""!""""SLLd5,0 DDDDDDDDR` @'O,XZ~4fU} %*8 dX2A]I 8d#d- l:99 9VPje ,ٙG4GGFJQ_5戾uW M;vvYӴ"иgn ȠhBJmЌSA'o U"NAa"Cn(nu-1 퐴 7P0ú}뫥NԄT{ֽ?§z]]zWn뭭}Sꭅ{ mj? F33N:4# !LNE={uzAڂCaPA]m\q 3  W5#/@$\):ߤ W =ADd1 P9qA302 "h.$ ȧ2Fc8cAp$Hi"V ;cvƩ]¸WL;l q~jh x"xi,ioBd$Ud@}!] Dn{h ![ֽ[Aour{+ӭ"$3%oڠzNȟDvmTp;DQ%pȎ օWju m}c[I]HG!/ӥlm$J{$5t_vz*ב#_":ֿ֟oiGCקmUȷ>_﮽zZ׭zDk]҅OۯZ#.}{8_Tz=]}"_u^7 K}Ern__߬=_D޿"6]zGyTj6Ѽo-޻zzoZ{#g~_~ItWտ݇W߷L%tcu„\>{_i}z_n架Ю®~ڱ{A{>u_?nե'+㽴IpDۊjҿ_X`k^[w &צ[ XMlTgPtJQM[.q[iva+ki4"/z4M6qL%h pڦ!&Ah=2?YtV)l/շV=+ڋb]҈B@Ld*WLAڠյ  ѬB6;M^h06 @ +E1IlTDDDDDGR "r&F8Aa\] Dt82B /WAA ; +o TC"DDDDDDDDDDDA2&&m0׆ {Ť #ݣhǑX""""""""""""""""""""""BHrr1Hld$o9Ftqˢta/gpp>]"H#o87|##7eo8a"x.t] X) DDDDDDDDDDDDx{6#/D|Gv]!̎)ȏ ^#x\ˌ4zQvh)0EG$,~ ȘC'era ܠCs3';)FeTVհ`w "oB>?i}}]~u׾>|AzޤHBM?~\qzkb'#r¯^~,? }DH}:1 ([u-/D{kr0.f_DwD_Kwww'{{gOy:]u_{~k{~}WT7~^/7a}_ϮW7ifn湿X\m\:ju/}/Unگzl%^ Xtm[q[UaN^_~ud`JL4l%AT}A0L+@iXbbՊ>+cQ($qi7M M(iC C 醁"hT&}'a)Nam(Տs02'&:CΉaC !^-O`Ci6dAb!H nhU) #G2> k)zӵ &)NaIC + \ZtMFMlDDDDDDDDDJaU,4&Y#e <"إ̸f^#3G]ٚ#Yv#HDDDDDDDDDDFDDDDDDDDDDDHG#Es@Ts9?70AJ V """""""""$ rCsh#rnT9w8|<Y0A 񜳙qT<.VB(LlDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDH Es[9SfsIH,9͛F3y]t\\ˁ̎f#fy2vn9#.GlDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDU34aFy|a;7EȸdvDDDDDDDmԉ)# c. xg2qF{9|c1ˢ#.GdvG\GtG\"""""""""""""""""""""""""1,f@|4̂E\;+aBCAYP Ml Hڅd*(*bﳈ.O?ApI&`UYR6Tzl eP㠡;&wtO4B 0¯Zq;Gjd 4@,ۺ j WݿW}z@BxΥx<ԇʇ>oz)ׅZ^a050  8G@NPv膎## \k}wpTA-B`ia0]i 4B*!OWmHAǼE˶ Qq"q C}ж {!)ග`΃CL!i|onWTbG8h;A,|OdKxz 0Z^4O(‹E]MB-܃LH8x$#޸dyU:M5MV-]7N.j.Bj|N)ɿa~~J_wMVܑKꆛ'mA$|@;%ki~r;}m鮕|1Zm/]o_mW?Eud!?&3!w}-/c]izj`oT}~X7=t Mz_ߏ]ˏ~z&2̧_v ~IWK_/aM/ԴoMΊ5_ǫxoZ ޵~z~^zۯӮe^Bwh-XoUoAk׻n_{~O~ka4n-Z7K{W# m_[~.._jќ7w5Ku6;[I.ҰRl^+].GUX4i[^Kotki_[lViwX BAaBv 0a6,* a7qQ; 4ujXa$={f!e W•9 k[-0Ain^ 4l&Tҧb0@߫D]28o fA* X0p_ )7kkaK^s Ћ+Bi(;a)I@.UVB:u B K*,cABaqGwRo%+aKh0DM;Oªiy,a2]@jd\[eJaNaޒvf@ANi!,Rv* _~I A?"H̒smF׫"N#_]}uW4#2B%~ B!CA  R RK !fn ب0 M4`a |Lp^@a`C1sH3e>N"|KtdD^Qp'`n-S n hh4 MŅBA*$ B#A@֞A6۸d ge :<|7 5PKjiBa|` S A aheDBC 0B тaAz.Fd䁟2>2q3!"t %I`6pP۠"IñL`q%C[CCDiyOᡢpAЋ PM0T`L* ~O:}¿}nj2vBCe=&ؘvEvB}Y;m"a"vl.B==W8և _-}>ի׭/_T(u j 62G vJ 84X274f\ސwd% d;B8M^^`ȷ؏_]^Q{_t?WJI IL0MCwF:_80M]UU_zjڧoz5[Wzڧ^ɧ @J,uC#DWw]w~m7KVwV-W+z`Z /]k19|c(JGQ?zG䏯 k_ס_oVHZ}a/޺_뵺 :'~N?8x"O63k]d- {w 6}~[K__~_~]nG?j4ߧ0_ﯶu]|>iZ+iX%ia}^p_o]Uz }})Zb_ĉcbV՗j";  G 6jZ& ik i4ak 0Imxw"VH.מ=K]z[ajzN~vaL& ! 64  &0A6( 0 0j Ұ]I__5awejUj[RH & 0Plw#Va&Am;">(1Aa0OHi1JFXM7W{~!Ƭ4[KҾ"""""""""""" ! )StωAŐfgx3:kat 2(PPIZÇEDxA,&  >B8(a6MAˆVa>dqDDDDDDDDDDDDDDYA Mi}݄8Rc3*`[P_i6 SqFñAqDDDDAA"2{RFby i]~ˠ&v[ 8"""""""!`De 38L!5B"""""?U/P; 0Ai?AMGsNM* gdL̄wIL(ib C@D =45 +iԸ0vK<'d>kiTh V +;r﫹;)iBL: 6wZH7pL/]l"^AL9, P_^APmNMWZY/dd/ܖ'S!n E8\u;Ta4QŪJҷZZo]UWۤk]^]n^Udp\)V>ё#鮗h&&!C4~tqB̑! 2! {>]+ꖫp-D4Hvx(MiV6 i C&P'$f̆D0F'l7d|T}Wi?`N>HB.4=}wHL'zAjaB`8x,64B2vNHYPeALQ# rJ&F@*֓27i7A鴃9a.4O`݄(,5Av`A, D' < v0 [# 2% \CCY+ ~H29Fl`7^tG?OӸOQ=kT1N1.vuI9oM7i4:}=\& LwS0*V/JZklåwjH:w?@'mF(2s' 1(4"p0h)D #D=/ ~!P^?Wuɟ#]RO"2.Rp&ޕiDGrЄq3*b1dlpz;~~-C`NiCnim+oI\R|'IAi8`??`c# {pKt}ju_: DQ9UZ=c_֯p /tk}2?-_ak~ciuf @ ]w hz o%"Q~U_zmGڤ3JA?Km߯$D￯ZWޖH]uuMUtK[V_﫿ϣ2r)G[!_AUm~E{U%f(ab4*W_/~?}իF5_߰ibDqQ  f}n_Kuͦ V4붖?]V]}azm1 ;I %k8`qM{<ƛ{4Ml0Aap_":jK ЅCJyubr,U|0SV_H[ᄛaf6aR~~0(,4_M5w : RA] 6h6BkA*tj)06{⯍ب bNr^dz""""$eoIPt }dLAkUk"KIA SAqb4^~X+4 DDDDgjpk Ekpk Ai ڠL x'h:jY纴EDDDD'vax `AVL+݅[M/MZaT 0 oDDDDD4""8a<ʈ2PftGXYZaxik0THDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDGJJ%tTRljIE!:h!Kkl D0m]l28esj"&JkM2^" ګzPŹvAB2KgdH4"kjLTkNa%u`|4;ʴT[ʯ$ڦ896hK='ȮBoIߤSkJ^ &TD@ΑP~#䈨GќgA$M" $A9eFdc5UB@ fl!њRD⪚pECP@M0D<4 a0CF0BhpaB  aC$t$D32]L\e<@ȦDiU/"w$ \&Lvza *j#T$=APgL0\B #ŨB舀"# aXd6A ZP2Du3CAT 0X@B WI`wAښ(@X4ۋTl'M^&HhE4 'h A0DB&L  MB4QA 3͌=:$RTz3nh8A:[A.I 7IaJh; `Mtm#}4҃v$r ƉD "w jޚ 4T& xP=B‚E/ROш KTVl2XA:A EzA wt|:__Ryy B'x|h` ;\4MEz.ކȣp1MZ't)*^֗ +KJu/qW)^}+| kh nt2;KZZz~I*ZzKCw~ ~J}-_Ka?/nNݦVi}1A*KT'KHt_Wu൷ׯ||Fբ#u~~B_IT]BU_rΫ/xkzZ";WWm?*I/$*dqU%]7}Lsh烸">Ѕ5^CUjT ZK[[|DGH-/ūO7_'WtU|% z/O_x_Dڄo^Yx_}NeoK_ K_'V߮__nz,oK׮-WA(UJu޻/T^{uIozꞴg+WzQ ~kK_A뿿}a/]4z[Kֹ=^G,mv{}{_E[ݒ6~# _CVc%/#u깍$+=pi?i%~_K]Â]U~ImՄ><%H1]a. a.oU\_uK }kv |TL:TPTETvV>6UmwbD^ ֠vmm? }i}ڶw=XH5ME+h;MS j&QLUSh)tŦ 0M^40qU ,]lUqR :d00 uz^\[6 &`aNU !Ba4B 0 h5VCh &H` r+lBL n->njUb/C]"""""" (E  `W ¦Ga54M(h&Aa4$Ӧ `liÊb];[DZQMxkB$`@œy N6A: nZa5a2,{ \4l  h Ӱ0@ L(Aմ;RhƐg ` iHMTœp@¦a5BXVM-AK!DDA"B 8Dfîc i `R""""8h̒+ _^%]tu`XVV50gfDDCV?媣hG,#*Ȼ`0I &P]5 2dv5ҩcXL Ƀ& Mq"2gbJJz" 8[K f`A q;pm'I S}_AK"^Ɗjzd|T9U]wZZC*2Ajlz%KWvE&h3a0B pa4R (0RD :#94tUS 0PT8&`0@&HXD$@ 2""(G325G"ud< 3c/71…t4H440A 8L&":Hfń_Gp ߄]vhb?vOA&#*}mywoka6JӆD'Ka H6dƋƅ"xDv<`Ɉ%1c}+tD{ٱ?o; ' :4Zܑum822_H2-Ipm&au8b㽦DKӿ_Vn`u~bLr*}KÖ9c7X;z"qޖG(}u~~nߡ~XD医!>R-sBWD{{ZR}^k ?_Xj}㣾WQX(j.oWvݻ\W﯏"i:NF:޿/;ӽX&F #^?z{HT ݯzK+[/(7WB~{][{[z2~HtKVҾ½zگ_ں^owu~H$<}kKmW0K*{iff.[Kip{ {n}o[kMG]޻~QKMiZQ==if=X>%V֗گZkjw2>E1QM1IWmXMAbalAձZM{|/e\0K݆ dvJҾ 0p@ G6(7 A4 4" 'Šbw ip& Z6cx~_`-}[IGⱾ_ɭ0Y9OPax0 z 2+5aEa<&hlB ln'Zx@$&'88L5]zc""""""g  вr@!a;LjiP0ڤ6( { 75cVڭ"""""")a&9 “{8t$MӸi{ imD A#M h4:A ´T#B""""""""" ^T'T„¤AKqC NԌA7AxKDDDGIu,^a8U~&zɰudvF K`cq&v+BUSBpCPPL&L$S%C@H)7C;̉uxA Ba0Dsh8ppe=u^!j+M&Aّ&D:tjDZ4ogVS8_t_@AlN™L)=4DA2qu2pNe$Hfd33?=2! 6"ij lP'a<h0\"c8*aa Ќ GL(A`> DiфCsE}-zصbXqQwCua0M=mUL iM0,&! #36gx'dDytRd{9& d\ X=6w"n^cDX2g5Æz/n,*iа 4B"(fB !"̉&p#CF`EFs(3YA2)[:ńun: pڷڸ~|^QqDT4a=ML&a͊D0mBZ 0  ÙC{]_I[JzM-d\kt2/WH=7z/Çhh4NaQavD$o_mw INMw+ o1+?!a"I"|; dX8Nɗ'1hӸ:'dJ z}uuh6{ZN鿺uia}鴛wzSoȶmi;Vm>R;t+ Unxcǻ]՗/^OU]]Z:NWK+a&9ZOwKb8cx~߿޵~]ZnaL|t>-zp}ɧiU j>y =kp +}ɧoX5W]z;k_',?ߒs^/#5oK]Aa{v,kB?cudO_߮k{K{%F?z]__~ٯ Z~{H$%T_'^}\߮z=?,?k6V_ڮ_iWmk_5/xc OK(\i6}Vx#`°_ީ}vֿi:U۷kki6zW_^ O_{kka&D au AX4؎ %Wa6;ҵLz@om[Ioᅿ]UUiw1A!&qQ AGA0Ah+cG]`҄5b/E0a&Oiԍ~i_ I |8S 5AIMUEa6SQ脶S7i v8`4vү^C(4cYح k %}PDDDDDDDQ; F]4A#(\ Y¦EpL,0Jr$}M1M5VNXMMc\jv8b<#uئ˅ !elKOPA4" BA B >( ^0;_Nbl+\EDG2 mS`A< a5״HT \UڡuAp@U;wa,{PM5Ն#5L&"/Јы"""-ӵ*|4t9""#K^~ @.a~)c0<+ b#AĮi\GlN%"4[@LȲ'gi#4V-/jL3!7vT iD3Q-īJ믦 x@stc.ڔvXq;CnWwp(*zD;;‚wL4Ztr!8w &^_Ҹp0P&bColSiU^M &u3у43)? ghگkޗf44 h0bE()0|gV`ω x)"8AP‘tIk_ /1X7 T"NBpfM`K?UA= @aB!fCPEA 0.dPA:K VO2T0C8hdCdܸhaŢpcM"pкpaRa W Tψf0|#LՔT^P;(S(8dyt"k } aK`&ՂABCHi l ;LA*0Qh|: 0*im4""y33AA J|3|K L)8C6 6Gzoކ6ZX4ն: 'a?J" Dq-0At MxD& `8‚L *if4f[]{l/}wJ]MnIA7 :W:NdE|A~- %oV8m 8%w0: jmhlC.մ}߯BxM>mPk =7iV' _|WMn/޴#6_K!wMWi[N%dz+w}[~wX_c WB8cOzKO=__ja Onm__WK&mBK_lA&7J߼]G?Z-/_ +886aUW#s<_u_RC ֗]kR }R7_u?1/rܼ DWu/{ :o%|/a~d/Dj5/u^{O}j^C[enHl?n$֗tY8of0oAzlo;VT߯}ى y>QGQ}B>O_R8պ{m%l/ak뾯}?_Μï I7{N؋G{\VU#;/aVJ_V=?X`vb i  WPm&[$oqm.Pk{e~S K_4UUki,&aA 6a rL t0h0ON 80ŴKcajKM۽:zM~g[i8\fo gxkg}°uPkJLᰚ U&Hq#AM1ljlU.W{/DDDDDDDDD!tDC>`ζ)P5atx& @TA0m1Xdt\6#U#M S ­ӴPŠLh6<4D%&DA @AOb\/Ј&6L *r&ॺ0 \^i,$„h6E05]DDGDD0DFV3fjK NL0~+ 2ZGP֌d"$ GG3hh9荬DBО xSlG—NEpi!p`UrД #|fyc/y/ˢ;.<Hb.F&B""""""""""""""1L5Ml$3M,\&vZj╡2"!yfD՗ Gf3"@RfZ%44 hԈT4@hD\DD2@:fs8|9 0Fp3v'a45@T?!6U`k" I#}6iiwD~>&U۾7zҦTdVopKa%qkTu]џa7*b~ M>-G_$uz^չ7Z֛uoSJ$MO}R_5߭}[=]-_^i}ׯz]R~]vZKm/aO wI'K[u[Wvkia{H_xxAW .Ia{v>T2%`X~Ni:Zp}Ӥ roA a7ccAv aaXdq - 4fc05ՇW r"֓. a-8a{ `KOe8SiX`#SPB3fXa&L\vvwޒp`IՔdO4„u `bNЃb##lS[NM(E)4$aC8W)0LaܛPM 2@Ն" )p2&`WMtڂ !W&=fq_1#8f "."݂h0jDDDDDDDDqhDA^4>AUTr+ rxEtA]$"""""eXA Ui%lBWJ0F*i+70ڝKEDFHN)΢W` A0;f ;I$S;KPd6x"q",!֤`hDj ęߣA\p(xL HH3|zv?AA ;J[%& oKdar\4K!}~i'I&YÆި:AM W_[lShZO}+K]+[K:O?7#qRK}=u^wH:MOAA:BaD >"B=?!|A| 3\|j_a%}-./P_N͍4SP& &0v*;DC4HF:qJ@O@N`T] 6FcOzS a0L! @~,d8|o3g6iJ wOu:P''NRmbgAOjA(PP YChDk ڠL-j)`&iCM-1LW0  0A4Hp@4TiL0TF\b""F:a +0& """"2S 'C tX:?D*$geQPR;*2Ad)~ ~ ŨtPUlʶvS%,ZW2@a aL3nBao;dF#Dmzk?~L Z,åӝt&jvKw.]o`ɲ:#ѝ. `A=0t Ò q-' su5F%(DQ5k m3XMa L" `C"'"#^E .EW/ hQ .}oxE2t'-a% 0P&a4[A$!h`& a6D1BKP>HDgR]{"I k /:.9]H6Tˀ0zB F@ȃ0[#$ !5A<FAA:G8ѓr4 dNzIpdH$0 ӠPD Dv ńMŧ7 @ `"L`4/0)(L i h84 C`6Rް:_j{&'tn޺NBn#6:`mi?oJ8dnoH6>0L :MӫCMm]V ~it /U-&ݦ-G%z&֖?e^p[ů&!(1 z]^p$?wkսݡս/|0 >= j `rcrAoLpq]RuWGvӽ =$:o ЈHDbZO6+⿍1J}Ka0wH(~1@Oa_ߒsZA-"*_wدܐkz}`} \+K :8}UhFi^L/Oާo55o^AҫK3"q`\"o]&M]uo7~*+sݒ4/_6xI'}a'K{VaW'zZ^?@ULZ6 }^oi iUwwm0ݓQ J(^>mkA0+kvG[n|0Mi /W~ޟYtդbN{ ;/ %olTv{pӇD%iQ/\4m-kݿȯ G@D&駂a8a44M1UvcNccCa&._al%Oi¦Z i0Pa]Pj  6i"QA>:M8{L~G^]zL{[LwYPTֵizQ$&Z@B3BФN?Dx3X&f0 ^VMS 2#OuH?lS]1׫XhyV.V^o" "s`,; .҄ dWA0 NA0 AO +iQjK ca"""""@c Ta;idXAL ձH:L G &adW (tTDDDDDDCD0P{pL` A0O`kdv &Pٵ4, W" g)eg*`PgĂ"""""""""""""? Zʣ43p&e>ae̯W)>!3$Ȗ2KA2xÇǢ<T.0r5~jw\'_5ONot\9 I(9؎88JW_]dA@: 3c:_"j3!H^}iaAaL&, 8)8"# H7Y9D4}i|"p5W ?]7v34M 32@ "8hdc&t?J5zw ۍ4N' "hpp8Hha& `o A!t|D0sj &F\+S#"=)FDdשNm,O}^A7Ozäa&#=Qah;$"` pT,`V . "$@x@!qxApDR!!~6!df`HѠ`s(3A3fn,MM"IldH~ ' mD au;Br'p@u/U\ La i@P?O $]{Tƛ8I wp7Ӹd0tO,&&'}P` aBc\IWzעTkmWwl2?~_/iKAu Z_pv]K ?D?_/~;A/i/iz{DK!ׯ@OD~_KھHI??/׽}V{t~nG7$+ͣ3?_I}}o3;^kzoWk&ޘnl''o}mKA6 $VZWwW8/KW?0B9Q~ڗ?-;ai?}+߶Oþmx~aaڊrAba=0J/ZkwGL*VE anSjzcp .m)cn)u舯 %.}z &a;ZE )Aȑi0 `GH4بax`jի l]{/_v]"""me ѥLa5MLÄ4 L,|Aɠk~IVj)]`h4ոߑ!VpAmipcn*""8E`4¨L E4h48l'aAiMp Qw &]4PA gtʜT2&az[vTiZp ŵ a 0i t|DDDDEEEgK&Xa`O ^WmITT8FM͹5e>ʙ]<M3 :w vIS@za%}=\0 $+qSc|ھ?YRfF̅ A32-`Euf@YnuF O$S> e{gi3Jv ADXfS8iC"Ј4]|r[>&&dK(N˨ inGABH'v]5q&haҧH$Ds  &*nI6}u}능\&ܛf!ȌR/2|.]kIݯWC gpp`!f iʹB(E O]Fq Fy/& EFh!$|yyH^R<'su^0CiN./vؑ(A ,`దDSyYA3xND3Cg9#9H/~(I7 zj IMH'Al2,vqE Lm 'mvx4O🂂 &ph?m, `;B 3LM4Mv3վRzW=_I4ON+R>>do+WzD>q~Ċ?dAa\p¦_蛰d,\*v`Qi'oo_ۭƫ %vd=:M"݄a"G~4Z/h[2SDSǻ걈a Zr-Wo^>p;da=wdG#.5l>DWN Bw_ic/I/^quN{ڿ/o}uNWݯNnvF]ԝ`~d K;K \޸~4_zj{m_~>m҃u[__}?aZ/j4/}Rt˥կz;a7^| ?{קZ+UߩP0oi' ~y1=k_VpGOnm߲BAkh%_zމ:_߮B~^dd')~II%Kït/n'GkWc =j=E߮}oK$^ ?{b+-cV_ݴֺu/_O\.}׵{{a5}:{N[?]6___~u_쑯ueV~ccAN%?(`Q{}A5}5^ү<ۮ,G[}kK_[^lJQ 6(ƼFՍ؄ـk"8i\0\~)?D/ݯm}/_/AdGU!R &x qm/E}RVGtNUT[Nu׿kޮ_-+h0NDuIh;uA2 5ㆼ0A|CR[ i~ao6_4ML g0AC'" PE:u;4 &톙 'aqa]m "AvxA7ؤQ?KXa]:e'ii~DDDDA#8!a`020SSA )cXUT([ A 647$Ivmr#uDhD\DDDDDDDDDFMP)8e8NBi6G Y A &0asqaȱ.h4"@χ֕8`|葬)Xih0DuPV4ɏjGiL$<0KHDFOcv<t,LG0LS gt@FuȚc֒V""""""""""""#GW)apXHVZ(5P߄4ڏACX ŅiDp{|4 )A #D41[Q @ezgӖDO#C)j&a;gb.ʐX!v([ L&W~pB0vɺuA'Api(\B'2NIºAp,lBzKPBLL/IirYO ܆^Vv#DUWT{WCAi}V%qW 9U_IߓaGL1Jvs#B$Fy̗Y T -?/UXL"!_- "!#43p@L@' tgpA03!2FC1*PI }&M}0L(*35.U@iB e!"ěrd{6F#qp`"y Ő\rIɼG N"!ƃƶ~{%KJ."_Ҵ Ejowtl rDޅOM7pBH~~ WS_)i__ .27IV; ]g/! EU "cD* 4 M Mvp^S.o &EndXt'pò>;8j wɛ=l?ިVE_^Z[ !uOi?OMV)S R$~Gu}!aGT'A['Y5VDGO{qCii 6[&v{_ZIv6i[KK_+! ]u])}ziˤw}ޞN5 DW,k7Qn҈_jKoKkKXx{i >MȣKo+>_O岹+#//]ؤ~{ߺ/^ﺽԻ5Sž?!Kn%kޯK <kyH^ٯzs}w[߭D䍯K}mB Aհ?]o_k_U_[ڵ^[jGM}5_׵ni^~W}װU}tWl>DMMv4DLUޟf;1Zt{np_0]jU}㊭??[V4Z`L3$ SQtCI خBCuج'5aK6m__sE DxMPb%`p:L'v0& #DV[Z߯ {N64'i@t56 o">f(.~/첹ŵ跡ռشڴ9{1?<ս_<aRY4X CL/M>YV0 PA6Rq"l|4 8`Ոpwp$Hjam&@L1Y{"""""""""""!`gr hxiN4a4 p`:A[a6!HAPawӪb[+I!R *a  T$: T &0AP<頃 ȃ( \DDDDEBaL$Ag  3L/ L*`#sG  """"""" """#GF"""""""ODbDDD~4"=$iW4+6BŠKPpJ ɰTw D%;(GaT2f.[b/&& 3"S2+@ơBL*H3!_2h'\.2EW+6FÇtAl33#GT%bbgK^pv`BB {9BE0jB"q"?AF/H-zO87B>zk5ko,SjW t$ I 3#d`<32:2|BчҗD&$uJҵ_I連Ba~ !AdpBQtH\Gc$$ l D >tS+zXc?DcAXpi0*Yp¦ߦA BpΣ>a (B a?d ;Ou#zGpA<;Hm"}oa'_Y˷xEv-t[\'pM>, 2A : $Cd ׃?<H_m.0Aꝷ ~=It: t_8$%Dݣd8t0P`  " 3@F4h? S0C`e yHhqC_7ޗz_$Ҥ=]%VdLxpdK Cvhhr"pN\OxT=mRO_AպkڷzFW@I mmAIAO %N .۵Qz&-iQW!oi5?m5\[[]na7Ыk6 '2>uKA [Ӥ֗w~Etr8}־ x{>7}o}~t#һPY>jpҐ zZ1ÏtkwK_սhk;/m:Ic=l ߵצGa:~v}U>~~wk~ ݏR{j/x_~[[mo߽kz}kݑSs:q_\AV^c aڻ{6޾_෭A3PM,_r|?[^H^}EQ ?_8oU D߭Nk~{Qg7ho-{AuMwo?kum._K}pmWAk~a+-xkWt~kUK$/krҊrGu ֛("U8kU]o_jVwӯo_67Mz`u8Kcr;ae'[0_~t}~~_^F{e= &cq?eak4AZQLx lVzoM}Zճ]pG UL* :a ah8Dw$[Ih6+/KkV\VaaպxgL'` 08h0O5`Pa*m^ DtiDtD$=4u±7XjvZ[zI:I҈""&!fBf+u #^Qg &d„I70N": 4lPA؋V864$cb 0 f\DDDDDDDDDDD * 54CcLaL@ZmZr#@"ȃ:<iwA`&a\@&+""""!BD4""$GL3: Դ @@ʠMdTC jdM;O5`0B /b""""""""!"B"28DJ a, '@ 80 "#}*vaM(G&1gu䵑XάYRl*<; @AlhD wAam Bģ;QP}jhlO^pmA߮rIֵ^l y@Fye9hyyR K <4„@f ad=te& a<˲^C \ sLh>fW~~ XM4\=1x` BxPTN`;Xa0L&&adtHaKG!Z//q;|ATD'dN-d^PNdHr+ [¦ 0/B 3񱗈Ghˢ.)SV·װAjt] ܅A B\H8dH^4]RD8.kN40iCpiݪtnKWIw}-VaòaDAmtJ*E3ioa7_O#&KMDjAѹ4&CuV߻_WJBj:JW pd[`[׿=kCVim@zk/ۥudn%꜍5ڂ_!a;KU'ok/A]x/.4o~C{Q߱nzZ o~18B[սq_i{\/hA/΁-&E߆X?{DcwFv+O_|/o(~Y!>W׿^?Ey w?T=}GJ+elR |?_5WZVo}yWW?^H^6ˍS 1[M ~5KoKKw]^ƬEa!iKح.եaHLpZ_AU_~v1aM ni] +؋cb֬UW#_vG_ۮdXAPA>630i b4Gdqzh'q 4*biv j)^-(¦(@"4 8a "h8Am1["A}h,UZac0qFB%>! gO3׼ Lp84 'eFL' a0a6 8u_ XICa+8b`D4uBFBA4ZEXJ:$Q6!1ȎM|DDDDDEDADID"e9C3 PMS],DDGDDDD 눏ZKLIpuA"(A# (J;l)l,ifl~<=n iK`,XVlb1 endstream endobj 33 0 obj << /Length 3059 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im34 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F35 11.61 Tf 84.24 693.12 TD (the request\(s\) \(are\) unreasonable." In re Rambus. Inc., No 9302, 2002 FTC LEXIS 90, at *9) Tj /F35 11.43 Tf 0.24 -29.04 TD (\(Nov. 18, 2002\) \(denying motions to quash a subpoena in an FTC adj udicative proceeding\).) Tj /F36 10.70 Tf -.24 -24.48 TD (Moreover, that burden is "heavy." In re Flowers Industries. Inc., No. 9148, 1982 FTC LEXIS) Tj /F35 11.61 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (96, at *15 \(March 19, 1982\) \(denying motions to quash third-pary subpoenas in FTC anti-) Tj /F35 11.62 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (merger action.\). For the reasons discussed below, neither Dr. Vellturo nor Respondents have) Tj /F35 11.45 Tf 0.00 -26.40 TD (satisfied this heavy burden.) Tj /F37 9.30 Tf 34.08 -26.64 TD (B. Dr. Vellturo's Expert Report And The Information He Relied Upon To) Tj /F35 12.40 Tf 35.04 -13.20 TD (Prepare It Are Relevant To The Antitrust Case Before This Court.) Tj /F35 11.68 Tf -35.52 -26.40 TD (Respondents and Dr. Velltuo argue in their motions that Dr. Vellturo's expert report, and) Tj /F35 11.65 Tf -34.56 -26.40 TD (the documents and information he relied upon in its preparation, are irrelevant. Commission) Tj /F35 11.42 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (Rule of Practice 3.31 \(c \)\(1\) states that, "Parties may obtain discovery to the extent that it may) Tj /F35 11.57 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (be reasonably expected to yield information relevant to the allegations of the complaint, to the) Tj /F37 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (proposed relief, or to the defenses of any respondent." Moreover, "\(t\)he practice of ) Tj /F35 11.39 Tf 389.04 -1.20 TD (the) Tj /F35 11.64 Tf -388.80 -25.68 TD (Commission has been to uphold subpoenas duces tecum upon a showing. . . that the requested) Tj /F35 11.61 Tf -.48 -26.40 TD (information is generally relevant to the issues raised by the pleadings." In re Kaiser Alum. &) Tj /F35 11.52 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (Chern. Com., No. 9080, 1976 FTC LEXIS 68, at *4 \(Nov. 12, 1976\).) Tj /F35 11.58 Tf 33.84 -26.40 TD (Dr. Vellturo was retained by CCC in connection with a 2006 patent dispute between CCC) Tj /F37 7.62 Tf -34.32 -26.40 TD (and MitchelL. At issue in the case was a feature that allowed a user of the estimatics softare to) Tj /F37 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (automatically calculate and compare the costs of ) Tj /F35 11.74 Tf 227.28 -.72 TD (repairing a vehicle with pars from different) Tj /F35 11.56 Tf -227.52 -26.16 TD (sources, such as recycled parts, aftermarket parts, or Original Equipment Manufacturer \("OEM"\)) Tj /F35 11.64 Tf -.72 -26.88 TD (parts. CCC was the first to introduce this feature to the market, through its Pathways product.) Tj /F35 11.66 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (The dispute was over Mitchell's subsequent introduction and sale ofUltraMate, which CCC) Tj /F35 11.53 Tf 0.00 -26.64 TD (claimed violated one of its patents covering the Pathways product.) Tj /F35 9.12 Tf 223.20 -39.84 TD (5) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000135776 00000 n 0000135835 00000 n 31 7 0000135933 00000 n 0000136097 00000 n 0000182648 00000 n 0000136625 00000 n 0000136244 00000 n 0000136373 00000 n 0000136500 00000 n trailer << /Size 38 /Prev 135449 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 185773 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000191428>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R ] /Count 6 >> endobj 38 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 39 0 R /Contents 40 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 39 0 obj << /XObject << /Im41 41 0 R>> /Font << /F42 42 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 42 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F42 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 41 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im41 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 3667 >> stream QBldM( q${0#ˁg!f.D_!|=rW2Ã,4ipfiߠ3/x5W(_)_X W묰wK-Ӱ{^Pl0|Yk Ȏ0B3 N3g~; """"#~QaQx%Q ?W0[fJ?ɺIG2QRmdDs#993170^.̾]ġdp@f9IτxLrrrCq.:Dt3DgtPgQфaEќc0""""""""""?d-\ZuQOa0U3,8q"7h;j(,D#az:$B!@K%&L OMP $];i.mAÓv)P6HOI\/t߭맂dw zNm-WoIn NmJ]Vu28f5#^u'r>%2p_`M D6At֕zI ~T֣VI޻Ӥ{m ( ݭ~_?wA(AC oޒo#$dӆF{FkR!u_^w+;i7 2=uji}?C=wSZ- 4;-ʯ3i?Ɂw ?[[7zL?Vuʲ޷b}]}'zZ߶J?k}+__I֒?o޽W/kmu_Lmn #vҵODVد]oDS ԄlQN !-E1@Ρ4BSR`]7j_0Mi & L^,.B,2  Soe*i5DDDDDDDDYIzU.T*G`yEȔ\; '#PC@`SPBhޡ i6"748ѭvӇh4 3E% +O׫ۻWI]^\:IZN%j׭:iեt괶IZ~=]^u/ tfhOZR._W-t?CD~3F`R@Rs.o X~ A&> $CVE.E~֛w[_~oJޗ9#B}[i/׽Ww_Zm.nׯJR#v[GoVH(K-⮬/ۧ4^/݋I6)ƝESI]aԈMdLHlB  D$Ɓ\#`&ႂ m?h0* MDDDDDDDd"9WO@`&b#]z],:ƶX#[0@\;W;\b`bW FtFvBB @CA!H k0|Y%6jMڦHxa0v'4@᧢ymAr~_ 7Vմlk WmuyhK`v_zҫw~TI׾E_uaR_Kդj/ FdS#F{ <^봛kqȶEt!gQatҥWZ1pੂ  i]KvIWpt7Av$nCO.%C4 I9 vk^&{0W 7ſ׭%]pˈOmb?ۦ*LU!_ ,v~+‰mB0 _K{ӯvW{o~oWB!zH^__U_ ꟠_i/Z5M%iVdAup u83o'J6[ +wi4.ᄭ¶a;t*%#8:La APi„ IAPan„MUiAIDXB,L"2n"i{=#2`M ""4#.la-,% TRzYlo^(Z  endstream endobj 40 0 obj << /Length 446 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im41 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F42 11.50 Tf 115.92 186.24 TD (5 Vellturo Report, PX0837-019.) Tj /F42 11.52 Tf -.48 -25.20 TD (6 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003.) Tj 0.00 -24.96 TD (7 Vellturo Report, PX0837-015.) Tj /F42 11.50 Tf 0.00 -24.96 TD (8 Vellturo Report, PX0837-016.) Tj /F42 10.22 Tf 166.08 519.84 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F42 10.08 Tf 21.84 -549.36 TD (6) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000186100 00000 n 0000186159 00000 n 38 5 0000186264 00000 n 0000186428 00000 n 0000190679 00000 n 0000186680 00000 n 0000186551 00000 n trailer << /Size 43 /Prev 185773 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 191190 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000205220>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R ] /Count 7 >> endobj 43 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 44 0 R /Contents 45 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 44 0 obj << /XObject << /Im46 46 0 R>> /Font << /F47 47 0 R /F48 48 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 47 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F47 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 48 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F48 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 46 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im46 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 11321 >> stream ڌ&KjM["JZ@(8 C&l _A?nZ$D8͙4KLә6 ~ú A]{ljϯ_;QOMi7.;ov6^NHKp!(r/`` +  CoI<1]]B<4!8`F"""#-8@L4KX(J`9eh䙒e:gsF]TB_#"?j !Sw6< @@U_G P![h>SGi@4EPI7= Bi86_{{^O^WK]׎oGE>S_*S8a3#BlC'xgBl52@BA ˈqBNaN-b:I<3HB#6H >;#|' oW7Y7650 AށVޤQa  Mkl80 2%W=i; zO;7oº[][}\]_> O7 [z]K1?޽ӿoLjޭ/NtտiU[Z[u{wC~j7WW?7&}_o$Qvjc1[KJ+uW8p[Z70`ԨD͊AɁ7>GOh[ O}p9'(swPB<+~[Kz]i?".B!}_NaDP0M{\=ZK_a}~/{0xDowWk~Tm6 6{[߾p̋.uynQ o$u6*O} zX{$i6jnP;(ߤvx;! #b%VH4VQ7]?K߫K{ M_kW|_=Jڿtҷ>wKkImo^m'}wu/뵿뾛Hw߶Uo_[*NJ׻xaO=ݽl%`{u ,0Vf7kl]_aHf=%o 160Gkkdz6qvj+Zb!{iDu9[p)>6a+-a&҈5b鈨a{Zݤ &6L0t mHgSX4N*»QÈT%O7Ӧ* 2 %tkA 6 ?pu Hq5)0 t2 1 [*MK :a"j a 4;Ȱ!@b0A"4 m1LS#0N)i4m;  5@v 0 0apOAA5,tZ Mմ[v0K 4SM{ XpfCG a:)1 uCk:DDD0D 21eB""!@ &JCt """"""""""#Q\E!D2 Q/#U Ԯ0I U; 0"?1y]N" &HGdgf"l6`؛)l̂?>B3ZPP,3 vN2v„AB[P*a?P 踵i## 7_魣3 xAÄ:8@fv"_lÙ(È{ו|}oN}RkK[]T[KzU:O}Z[nU_#՜z/]-/}ŮUQYyu(#C"E Kh#ԗT0Crl( K3Pq5<`ZL  axPAA t ' h@Sh3L G .&" 4gh<,X vh3b&L*xP0M0M5CAL'$ i%qIXD04PA^ 0'aGH  ;qhw^X0MދXEhh$ x;K'  _6B:Aw oj: @ۻ$!7RNHk6 Xv DŽ\;h AwHFޔ _{}tX!.`p§GdcN%}>2?<:mzIO{A\>Ӥuupzv : m\2,-aoOtuIzMЯ\*z֮:i]=_t)7wjmutZVWzT_oݻmnm?µWtn~MoI~q]Nuq|{U}uסubtZյ?#ڎ+^Q]x^?K_ǿ\i~D F[A!ʅ&pzS(pcX}$?pU7^B"a ߿3u#_j޻im_=$=o/(M=$nOK}Jt/? =_a% +ޮ߻_߱5#G}~k]e}yEd̫^>Q>8ܣr#6_~i]Hk}u }~߭ެ.K[I}pz}{_UKjݥ/PZ]]k[V޿^pj|0莯J.M{{e<~)kbcm7ئ)Ұih{c zqV+Jw\)}HJ_MF؋qqj&] _k.0jpڊ鰂\]l&06DC`ڤaR)i la66 Mb2 ]8A 4' `{ *) 0ix h` 4 uA A0Pa4~)jEt0am04M bHG Bm8APmN!tA5APL ia[O G*&UaO` a )jXY- 5Namh0/e2? P 5a-AgAveDmm0A|LD >"""""""!I DDDDDAV3!ee !Q=lDDqA+i> KP`*L㪆 !fȒqBc6A%] &2 bc!u3c<2g>"UEANi @ f(XBg!˫4wU< 80NAq L&AMAW`T<(L&8 U& 1P  21 w0iNp97gXJ:a8 kL"ww./D\cJ ˡq ; 5A6;q]%ƋƮ:MtoxHگ{?A & A;&A6t t $PO(&ZE!`JA iݤtdAO}l4tjNx'O2V |:+n nG ][d?K~6 StZ;O:_W]~/ {J.ߦoZw_owi{i{qU_2+{׿~ ;6uo^^#k4#Z,%J(1$[JCQ_}Wኯ?޺_UȮhBlMw< .^L"  ,/[ +,e0fּ-X˯-G"!/_/WU࿫Xw}kx?]oZAwN?azDoﯵzU^-}KVx?t/mL6%AV~CZZoA55b?;[NK_;CiuM1ATSAli 0D-P tt0@aNEEqN H頚8"0`8+ )7A M5MPh']8o"Յ8> 'zi,h 5h["\5L*&H&pҴ5a#G2vr`P.NisM4g@hL>X0AMat xL#̫a9<fr:&0Lt3*YapA0L0DFLhDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE"JB%*KXN0!dF[؞v}?)^7ݫtW][}zO]!_}~ n?kޢﴛoI~b*(/}>(Xc+pׯw&]?__׊[^կzLHO}B* f/ʰɁ5K^{_1,e/&Nk}_ 0KMIz&na'%]8(?"Q #/hN~m_/KbkAX{J_k o&rLOI}lw_맭eA߽ Hm*]N}Y!wd"(;(zȪ^_}sɾ_T:a~tw0V]~Wi/ѓޮׯjҾ[^oZWuVkWuu }k߽5 "6u{ھpzi?OIn/][H MV^WUnא`a &*Ҧ¦V}D(תּa/ v m0Ay]p@*Bh}B*bc~Ն }:j.<0i8llZb*=C 'lp0~W}tqpK:v)SAa!E1HPmHG&`ETS6( !H6)A+v ';LBAN!iuX th0 aA' 0AlqX@@$A[a*XAm05+NmBi6 ],& a44a' j.i4 ڒ5Wl /a5e@SĝٮMi;fS1@-8D"""Q3M!g)a0@BAT .gT"""%D0g% g ))3<4eGRCF)ە""""""8"""""""2{ֿҿ֩--RZj Ь3$MC8ZLU_b.B 醠t gZC 1;%{4K+e,DtCE\P|ԲR ؘ.Fb3FFxgABf)"C:6β `J2V͑fpfbF SPMNM0AiDL-x*a?0PᡄMP&0"wj"ᆂiBEC'dž&44a Ť L}uH6+Eݠz  {L&) l2iA`چŠ Ci `C 5چLڬU=L:0&\0KQ!`nG~[8X Ӥ #&\ZQlH A`́`\;5k2:qC0D(Vҫt"аM0D(MÅ.(BBV273Bv0CaUkY 7?h]I#e D1x_IDno21' 섆l~K}V y$tҽ%U/WOXM  vʊ[)?%N)\Fc_Xg Tji{O&TS""#'/Dc?@ i?E*YGbMRLj/#<4SX0`uD% C0§`Rn7iaW F9݆Kv ]w4[;SmMyH+z'^>izJmzZ׭?aշ|O GfhjgaJVZ@C0`Z< H hE?A|4z^`zIiҤM'ϪB< {_n#L?WX`97">a_ k޻k_![SvIjz긅ҸHo7d`K/\ X'o`6I#-?;V(Y׭?[B> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im46 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F47 10.17 Tf 282.00 627.36 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F48 5.00 Tf -165.36 -200.64 TD (These issues go to the very hear of ) Tj /F47 11.68 Tf 166.08 -.24 TD (Complaint Counsel's case. As noted above, this case) Tj /F47 11.67 Tf -200.40 -26.40 TD (is about a merger between CCC and Mitchell. There is only one other significant competitor -) Tj /F47 11.59 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (Audatex - in the estimatics and TL V markets. This 3-to-2 merger would create a duopoly,) Tj /F48 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.64 TD (leading to coordination, as well as a company with huge market shares, reflective of ) Tj /F47 11.48 Tf 391.44 0.24 TD (monopoly) Tj /F47 11.46 Tf -391.68 -26.64 TD (or near-monopoly market power.) Tj /F47 10.22 Tf 201.60 -60.72 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F47 11.58 Tf -168.00 -124.08 TD (9 Vellturo Report, PX0837-017.) Tj /F47 11.39 Tf 0.72 -24.96 TD (10 Vellturo Reiport, PX0837-014.) Tj /F47 10.08 Tf 187.44 -29.28 TD (7) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000191477 00000 n 0000191536 00000 n 43 6 0000191648 00000 n 0000191812 00000 n 0000203855 00000 n 0000192201 00000 n 0000191947 00000 n 0000192076 00000 n trailer << /Size 49 /Prev 191190 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 204962 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000241863>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R ] /Count 8 >> endobj 49 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 50 0 R /Contents 51 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 50 0 obj << /XObject << /Im52 52 0 R>> /Font << /F53 53 0 R /F54 54 0 R /F55 55 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 53 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F53 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 54 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F54 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 55 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F55 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 52 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im52 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 32716 >> stream Qj?Knv̀ܶJb*-ϦJYDڳ;%8Q(S&['+UPj#9 v'` k*J+MB ?2y+%RI{w_2Z 488pp@2xw١^Kr샷_]_E,}}u_K[ORIRUKf@ʶuV) 2xsaHDhRD~Ij5TrO2QC̛gzy/1CGe@4 B` h'8`G$@Hh6!H h3pbѳg#!3AQ ņFvH@<:"2 eX98L#DI4 ' A ƁZa5Aiql~_60aiaQИ'b!(MN5 `4aP0(L h00PiŢGM55O#bÆ7IAi0A'b! 'j}HZh.A~@MaoC ɻ/ OpdlD!#6,?Q` ooxD78_7 yE-ؽ }HNihq`\su nq

~H60E#G^!˾67i~n޶{V_~UiZh2=_ݹI{k߶JM]j·߮ "eՆA"v#H'X^a.c&bK#m-c `V>r$?B^lP^)j mP4v 'q҈v&ڏ`p>tQlj_lqQ1wZB PL `( ia^A `q ݍ#tӦLSax h8i@ؤnMl'b p:P8ZiaZa4ڪZL a &]5 5PA6A,4ȰVUMmS[A0N 'i 8M0% +IQvUaUHI8e9OhE S< aL aPa0ɸ@00MPi0aN6u\DDDC^կKP1^°Be1 Y$edB#eiq[#D&l=3fQQih J`M0M4aB As/&NI(MT('&tk&ƸCP OzIh?g v9QV6a l8L$8pxI4h9ئs|^ߺvwbU^W}5RX_Z/U_NNxZI;uU|!0ιf2AP3JjFh%—JBgk(_;/eTPlΤID>dЄB0D\ ; 4g xg6!@R|`2Fphfd_:`!3ʉݣMӃ#NpŐIp_oOM``{#=`;#|+o {:߭nzoԺ.&vpz}~:&AޒAᮿׄ#k6WiS{^U؏:_n[N%~Dpz f/CЏM]^Wccq>Ӻ{]Z]z ][7_WU{ݵ҆}^<N5OFwWW__^m"yc8&i׾tc?D)py:]]BOa'Ճ^z_E"q}[_NָaaDk}>DFI-\?_t߆ +!M p_G~&߇MKW^~H[ G__!B{_iE]_W[$y0Xm]V /97~s]Uꫭ{տA}}v_=_I?_{{mW׻V鵯vkiik}i+JIKJKNm[U֡]+X0Vmlj}`Zi~Dž#PɄ_6?akk#l]a~)m(D-um]~=ۯ?q$v$%V )7MWI3e V,6CaM+XJMkX a[U t#i}մlB6x HADxjS0P@ 6  ! ~`+@0igEMb0A&`NtjC EPjk 'x0,4¥TM:MB L,&[maXAҠ&AEp0jj,WPg@ϡ L;@FL`DD`N YPeX"?-Ѯ &fhF0@>*0S )M3?i !Al¦G װMPaW`.8m %!DDh8H"""#""""""{9`!R_b@[ R)Z4,ǡMqYFyd QJDT xk ~E'{ 5/KRaVk"$d o TP<v|ˊL*h[L50-5MT&ڢ򈿦0ɀҶa#.C"CÃ"ۭ:Bv;Wժz~WU[Q? ?_/Z/Q7Wua]-Mxiv _ l0]5݄ h0Ath4 a*wXdvل3e9ALςaLhM4ˆq,IL$s`A9́Oh{ÖhE B5 /gރ;Avi:Ov~z_zuuuY^=_[煈M=nQ{}ko+~7}^=^UΝ oi/a߄L+"8͆M0dpC0 {JP }DDDAl(S#Ȕ̽G/*#aѝ` ,j@AvG؈<3V3`!d!d$ a2 ydTR ZehIB- B׈a4 + Z3 !GDOnL{ T܃q@9"1 vE禮h0@ CC%A NkM_~ҷ5[]%x?{J]kRk_w^0]~vvk~$#hy?~C2Mfl$0#zD.•(U3:FF]76f4j8!M}A&x@Гr$=b d2^HbDG!0fr@C03A rr:*$O+_nGi6"+~6H?h"PdkC\GBD DGa뼉$/z +r$6GF"Ez"wukJ܏:mߐqK֗ۥu!7I]HHT .;{Ka}Ȉ/k]Bz뮿׾Jn7Om. w+}ڿt1_[#ooJJZVc.פQBս.K-_#W8m;*|+^pȼ /EGtm)uΰ??^'{o}m >?7?z?ʰ[۲Y߿/k.A L'^!a+.&(ƛ@ bmRia\}$[Aګ zh' n9'  d a&\50N˚ox0/A,**G* )'!; 2vaAv5 ]&0T\jg)s=eDDDDhDDDDDDDDDAdDDN0B!H]0!R BdĊCDDDDDDDDGɰ*QkE?f% ftmFyo6yo$d|n7f#^/# n7dqKtlh[0g.G"/.ex_.\dt\e/\Bs#|es#>ˢ칗2;#Ⱦ#ٳٰ/<_.e;63m"7F2g:$e&3/g3S]wB""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""10F99ͩNw)09s7q~#37|b/2|o/g#`GqHˁqH>#G#9DJBADDDDDDDpDDDS嘝mDGfmKBS0"0"0,Ѻ5D o io>G ma$Fg, Ф а@T a`PO`00M<*`4?OT @!~@8*  32@A!|".( (Ya5OL AkD.rp82ɹql:C_+&`8l?[ߺ]x`aPD%#/]W7'} _߶;[k0 8zK {k_.jޗ$#7w} kzUWzok7t__Ҧ(_%]~Q 7; T:OZ.?6o_߭~>sFmZ߿~Vm'zgm~O/o[պtWl ~ Ւ~^V[4uU6׫J+WW^pSڪTj?-=˥X0Il0_zi}!eV?>Z5[ڻ&KlAp҈78N-E 4xոZ_}[aa]l0 D 0al%QAXLGS  @\aCM?IU.Ҋ ᤁ$ :bDX h ☦E@‚ #PӶGam $ia K'nȱA6B@Dxi:0@&AANlPA  &(1@ adXH4 aM2pA ( “sDDeW5`" e1HSX(0`+:vJ0)=tx`&^u5!} h<Fg;t an ҆܅p`]p &L0B""i#HDDDDDDDDDDD0B""" 8'$!eW""D";""""#E\DDDDGzkL%#,,&Ip@)@F TaDG5d|rnȃSC+"B2Ge#"H#"(EB>A=.kxP ޡ4T`h0M0AB 4DJt98A0D(B.ب\"PD3H;6gQNI*L 0? Ӧߡhp״ v͢p0ذjbv!lS i MP`EpGi݂#žfxdd8A5 3g - cdAJw){A„ `%!ixa4 AAȰ0I27}dD":g0Ue)ʋ rVC0WfD\ ›_"0NPAc'T"""""#DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDdډAAM(Lj;'̍і2d"iK*0@2-̢ȴDLɄf|mbA2)[W . .)ؘSzB" 4\@`иCZ*,Y:%  ]46<*"q Ià8z Bkǂ#r!L Dviɾ4pzrDx$ $]$\GjD;Tt½zb/N ZI n~\RNwW:q z;SH3VgH/I~\_<:Vу4.h'u߿_ki6I.}Uo[NJ$M~Ҋ8iw0ECau@VZ:6DuH3yG|eŭ_^qU_Bxf|)!O"q6 @fu : 2:?CM3̨G4GN3g2Ft @g:٢yӭ[JWKzA!Ӧ "܅h3]y~hTC pa0A|0 { 4 'a:u*&*v vGWM,Vޛu먍7nw_AMoz_k{n= O~ݥ_R_ m&G??IoIgP0xDb ^[]~+E[m}/c3\yKnw;M煿k ҡ}?[v+ mv}wGDu0/-?ekw~a8Km}{kXDׯ/uh2*׏)yp?cOUV'oa;ZU~߽rG%|z~HWJZyZM^x}d䎿r#?wW*{ҵ}WSU>^ajOaݽ.ճ]ӽ[zQWZ/o{޾ߥwk].^-5+Zz(k_K[z4۠[//u!z $i >ïa%nom{ϳ7u󭠗i']Z¬HHJ!ӵpNi۫#׭u'WK Rl0Vh5OlD%zm aa0}ijL0_W0J6`4H$T.`> P(6lL5[Ip~a&a@ӂ n A < `_Gb> F)jCA+ I+: @| "A#]Ј0"` )O`K$6$z[2Vaa[.j᠂| Kˌ HTHh/`"' T8""""",@00Bv L(P *|DDDDDDDCDDDFADDDIxDDDRIH|0eфam3mqfl!vn# p˲828SpP`|/5|QI;jv!\p6PK. BItj+#VueG#0ͣt_0"]>Ge|e8ˢ^#x\dx\ˁjDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDHPb &,F@RjZ dgjO*&fBG):/;y)neH(Fv6  a 4-; iLBXDA੮j.v.(.pPL) l/ />$֫%@m"pZAek"HvW!Aܔ黄[E"VwZM/ w;_Iz 5U_֫_u{_KmbҼt_ºRnC"xg_YS5ap"%M>&ұ3"<3HK3 |"@ `@@/Hq ' | @(dc292N7JtQFf2Dl!˓L0!ft@Iջ]W/޻WIDD/L quz||m+ݥFK _u[ީ.&n_^(_ODӆ' }ttHsBnWU _0?/S׷In=jp]Cb4#_{d*+ uwֶ_=ީzK=A(_Uz%>_A?`H/_;/WA8o .?~}/KW$a ɐE>M޶K_]zJ__K(iVR:d7>ykK׾?~_w$wG_sץH^K߶P TMqO_?},ct߿}Q RIjӿ $]akZۯZ.ttLA-p]i&zu^V_sk~ cCL5wy)ia[}v`IyKPM_LqG*I%7V5.>cc&=?p|:7 u@i*qب8Zvap'ְ qO *6 i4"h4l't6))ڵPaMGM6lP@taLMdXMR{[ZL)IǢJXa0#aBjՑL+M0"0 0ȎI "lL hCA1 !L:d# 8ai `SZvS`( C;XT88"!rV@lo x8wAiM3a0}Zi 60G&0E2e:DDDDDDG")8"" """""""""""""H"#Zpg-*D#iDhD~IkI*KVR jҶI$JBb& B,SatA[D(nT%Tid#2|B+me$ErO+!&a0TvS KH;PZ `L5\&'I~&S}v}Rpw0hCfn!5Gt@OhF>M'U_]WT|SUU!OeZ% 6 ' !K\E9vKR=2%g\) . gdֺj@<9#ƫ6y:"- "ѱ( wf  ͊)fAꁄ C0T h^͗ `d r$  sKRZ Qͅ>΂l\ٝFN2s:[:g0i>~!2>gG@y 2DBqB"u 0a=;\[Tл tBDk`4L(*`P `=j $N " ' A4GL CL!4BiƋ' vO' 4^4B/\a lPNL&1 B'XMEkN(NLpRjN LxuZ'FE;ڢI"dLGL=uav D5s}b A- ˷[{4Q3AL=  "5\xd _'E&Wr]82.VW^ozzX2IVUS&8)p^ cOOm#@F{Wt["oK+zB:#k_Pu}^\&m߃z/'[_D7o z_Z{Kg־_Dޗ֟.ͦt\ "KbFjA D_yFeko?]tPڶj0޻Z~z_Zէa׵bYmץ_m/ﺽ5'[j[Oaj)ׯԺk}Ұ5_ޖo_W^Jڻ'دl uwh6*Vҿ {B ]p֥6>|0K 4d}/vH 0 cGV OcG AA ( 1 h6) 0}C75P؃트Db>:U=7OVc4L6AG 2,Uઃ4@7 aEEmG pAuAZpM"t?.&oAQL銊iB ȮX&" v]uL& #nEn(VDt>5jj:dA@ ж&Nڭjb&KAM:;(!&`ϖ|A0A' wAA8M4;D3 L?Y3EV q|Øx0ZӰPU&=L,ȈqDDpq * aЈ4"-H"8OKz^{I.-~v.v;g**)9h૵pp6t:BHk2b"#@a"h*4OB+K*dM2U+ƙaSLp¦L"L&I%LSX]WS\-_JFP((.:@ӃM?s"dCdc Е88;Di9H;@~5K-7믪_WK굠_ZbqyFjfc(3SʈF $kU]?[ԁђ9#t PpɱPAicC@B`)͙x"ND' `3AO8( d2qI 8!৆F p)\٠x"Tl43Tl j ̐apT0 T pBMU4]8xi,hh ¦a< B4_ N&„ 0A'XAƞ(Mqa=SMAh4"wQpi|ߗ}IpuD" 5%O(W 8m[-qT- !M+T+ŽF'h 蛰d2}:/4BGH q<7 2-dnҺt}=-'H>vDq4=Tl7BEi'}@Ea:' mBd+AtVܝf3OM+a'ME% a0z hW_Izj_anߥ%$ۥ R;zIN !;@}|0Mu:}VutӰ[Vt4Tڽ쏦^վ+ vLOTtM?>Sկ릗V~8c PwK㱆>[ݯӮ^L𺷤ՊmDH_/ +J*7#x{ڈ't*Ö9/4C/__޵m܃k uU}zA=' Gx&~umҬ&],g-Q0_^.a޷$>m^'Ee@մݺD]z(Z~~/!!xb\.W }_7U%>F7;w0ۯ_Y!u~H]iy#b]o{I=^{[z?{KcrGv~ LU_[k/ױLoUN jnuOjn7Z[_mU/[~SuIuދoi_iaxdqqVq?[T[u׻Rnmsu^2?4~ +&!Ӯl* (0"X4D̃ ^c0c/uJ/[)ma-64ia_w6 4 * ; l&8Ah;cݫ k FZӫAA lSLPA8L0 i5WڄȃdXڭUL TlwpL6Dt h&2#v 0NMj) `A6E ZL+"a& k0U&xrnܨA#=`&(2o}Va i^N?Th5Ps ՅdXTV`{Otea3:8DMer|0#ш`DA2!hA S4 HtSL&0E alS pϱ3""#l+GXDDDDDDDDDDDDDFDDYD";I_**5 k0d dOJ B[u &S m \p Q !aG>U7z2+-u6 wgj#|{Syij1LfU J" N/Pq0@Іs s;(8 Dx"Iqtyv~Y qcM6 pҥ\*aAr&4 c5$P6HzHt 2Jh`$pM.;anp1T7B A 'ĨvD@Q]5a L aN  dDJ$dfLrK^QBNۤ7Jl"l&**3DΙ B$g$gUr޿K㿺^jE5EY y/&j還LT A#g3*| gQn3mf g][Am"$za|iݢ *j=S 0}CN(Ɠ &t{%3^.mװv4ꅄH: 2}ECx1}:+4k{JZˏUhH n[)y) 7nXt-ZptD`ȗoJ ' %q|Z'n=/"pخծ+VA/N-l2P &Dǵȷ,;;zw[GҿB+a:Btid#ս{)u_v۠`_+ zIa7&{?nۍ[Ztק]v?p ˀ Ii`Z lltTC ri?zqK{ׂa7l4L~_ {EjڸDl<(A:>߸ K4MW /}t}6&}{C^zwAN]}]~_M~[u}/>'KUQwZ[I{I~_ߥzOwU?I={դtﴵnzw_-տ} +{e;\4]oں_tﶖI6A/=-{D+,W_ J~Ƿzjkam~)+P<=T~$^.}NviFo`Mt $a4i" N!4,5bg  A]4V &һ%^ X&i0dpplRAm(@=ȃ}U865ND AQMTH)} Q LS܉ aWO"8M4Xidnj xa3D0!ۢ?a{ VZi B i07b _MQDŽlP!e8aD`e 0æ&gPA hDDDDDDDDD"""""g "> ><3`]za5iAp &g03;OypS@@8`4""t""1$aJXFOq2.@"f&0Ka\F"8""""""4`xr8G p0`d9\izHDDDH5@Ar NClrnDAk*PA Ia6RJ$$g Ѹ{7|c.#GE8vGˢ^#29p4BaDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDJL5f_3g7F>c>#4h#`)_/!"#-t rl-O&[AgpVS!xSHBjV )PmS a MBܛ+H?ԙIv+F Ƶq8>'j÷W~4h"?]߾Btr54dn"#)2*t "i7 )A. q`ghD$,d5c$&L$ۄMhńjT'lT,7TC D lgl08D[/mnGO__h#Ňdi~AW $F9Ǿ i; IR ᐎ tӃMi7˚uG5鴭Gtߪ~ W{WV=6Ы>|Wx:~kվ0O0oޔ/_K/o߮:mpǵ . |I[wu.z0w UwS@$9濢Rqz'k﫯]{D׾#=B?U_W_WD}-BoۥAa_iz۹׿"  j{'h%鋶!z޻ }XKlG /׆Gi LvJZ tȮTU a4!A\( `("RxMæ8@dGPM w;@Am3D9)a<Bere9LIegROh4(N0{Pj M?P v"„߈DDDDD\DDDDGV0DDC0! &PB*Q!! !e=aKp@ͨD3O3Xk8؈"#__I_hNB!de%uS*Gee}Qĵ b gn!&Q⸤vYd:'h&vRA?zGc W;A/  wa >ȳzNE pmiki0a9Ghrhu^~4vYU{פֿW󢣦RzgsGu\_qHq2`DB CY9W(_'tfӤKO%xSA4AGt lDJ 0 A!8PP!`Bȿ6D5tTe(e#j~ 0@ `Ba4 B FBz4; 8aABt0==^TC d ѦQ3C F#438(B 0DSBsBҽk Ѡ0bN^tǤ17x"N BMSAL( 4B )U5T?+=N(UNtOxy_xI8! 8d[=/.DƋ.*iwމ8: " ɻՎD8pȷIհt "X"V;O/v>j[HH:/4B'^ ɜ8'\8P:A@覆_ǤçA6 ݄O OJWNO~pd:mtA(AA%Z7t#?RWi?]}^^nn_vsK]%\xN{t-w-_]}c{b_֗Tkվ28jzQ;}c ~~C AO⫪I IX֒^+?__s@L葸׭&1iwi TA6jn]d4 U z￯ a+Z0/JI+ }G_V{o_$?a÷"oIj B]_}SKo ߬7]zOA7_ A:{M ?د$/}0z*7!k_b!;e?yjOHJQ%ꪼ8?_x~2фou[ߒFk^{coҶl/]uvkUNUZ~[~tָjrVzh'' βzӇю,ҥ#._tҤa//[[Ծ4Iԃbal04X𴖓Uam.uu3)l _dLm 5o[oj ui4͠vi;(JI86MJT2㰂H4SvȗK Zoj kIS+B4 w hur$B M2#V8Ii0 DTTULBbi8j8{$!}0`Ȏ ؄ 8LA{kXPaSԛ5 ]A  j1 )AEt*a0QTUZ״p.:wM6'&8vL:3 ixe )΁0 """"  `E>B PAajM TMM&L&EpL)AA!4G0A:5D""""""" Ј&pel!EhA)Za -dLDDDDDDDDR_҇+0&!Pv,*i Z31"MeQl(Rli& 2,LGB$q 42-N-wN;I8pppDI Zi@O݆n߯_m\h}Z_Y6,?3DWtSD2[Wɰ0`E/D8_6D%fs"A, 2>P)NY9ND ;.a*GX4rfyQ#R w晹qmEȇ7'P47aa駂v0jDu2|CC# 2i{$}?+i^dpi>+I:ps|?#XIpt'FQi~Mu~z5ӫm{I[_ݺ}^T1xkZ~iW_]~W~7k_b t{ժ_PoQ_ju]~ձUK'[W'W&{^/'zxخt_wZ_}7 `/z_u /?  ݺUKc˯߮VN/~AWza]8]`??}۠߮U)xwo N=/_Q_A_^rFcz}__Z8KK޷ۿnp]6e GU][ߧm}]_k[_rzկwk__[Ozk_v׻_o]ko{?*=j}[lmX/}e8kjȎmuR>OZT6xa/v-{Ka[~vN}>B@ثI+KmCl-W]G߻oa-.֕])Ktc]w +c!&!ǻQ^D 6&¦v[ [ mqMlAq; lHH"C WDL.il~MM"Aa5r-AdW+ACm;a&۠ 5!C h uabŽTz߷׭7$W.{y!'޿m-W,z_}練vkza{i_%W[w}_ՊՂ*!4/ 鴿Cw_mRo𿶗vi[@A<0V#^An *k /}[ᄗJ :lP  AM&bkiU-Ҵ\ -i /zLVWuƝ*v O"M i#H@ n#I ? Zkja)JM 0a$ᒀ@ 0#?eq 0atdW4M ت A:* ;"6 a00Mb76:x0BB`X"|3',h* RMo 5j""""""2{P  5A`GDЉ '!{*rhA A7&|MRn!aDDGvTK^ M!6 太Wq؅j8,Mr(6CC0FA" ׸{xC2Xpe͝ED/˜a8z A]_uu?o?_W_^Yc o7/߾޽_k-sJaD J`I\lJRˆ$^2d=˲_3`"!r"""#-jf 0BtЃ mAO` &o0?r A DDDDDF"#B"""""""""""""""""8.UPO?Sȿ5lCKlk32]dOfv!2C TBy,4 O%-N nNPBC<' NIݤkkҴ;i.i;aZ&x;5IP; ā`L6%.wzuƖt?ׯZo]&$)9ѤHG쁼Z-z[D ! aA L :##D')DlϏ6Ψ2r߄$3PC!q"0a#f͊lSl (ɚ#Bh)#lyF|Cl@.B0ha L&A62E˰"ñz88dH ȱV:a¦T?_{W/nӯIlF֯]64NZ^֓k\ FBw\n[M.>OW]]oַ_nۭս__e_ص[aUb zT'&_~! p ^&z_B֩ةv?+h%bw_9j=wUwU_gr^z5ÒH~VK װ }zQ1N0{ho._oz_A|K={`z]9!{WwazuOm}}/W#D׼7Q_jD鷣t[o ߧ8uG{4=tTxKw}V}iuk۶{k~}h#/%_a^{%m-][_X{{ﯤ7ummo0Mv{pئULa_MmV_5t~zJltDv_+yub+#ئP֢8umڼE\R~7}iZͦ)}RVWi6k~{mZVB7b  &iXj> 1LAt z\kv:J A7­2(MV5XL&E: 0CNlW"=Li;4M44# 0IlS!hoT[ Ȃ`9wL0g&2/ AJ'PXTh4҄ᴃi6 aH kؠipaB`¯i"#4cY^C:aDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDQк uANa28AWSALiIgx#(BDDDDDiDDDDDDDDDDDDDDemLFB#A.%%V*m ?Y^uKjoH7ثPaG  endstream endobj 51 0 obj << /Length 2331 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im52 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F53 11.55 Tf 123.12 692.40 TD (Thus, it would be a "reasonable" expectation that the documents and information sought) Tj /F54 5.00 Tf -40.08 -26.64 TD (by Complaint Counsel's subpoena's would "yield information relevant to the allegations of ) Tj /F53 11.20 Tf 424.32 0.48 TD (the) Tj /F53 11.65 Tf -424.08 -27.12 TD (complaint.") Tj /F53 10.22 Tf 199.44 -58.32 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F54 9.50 Tf -165.12 -74.40 TD (C. Respondents And Dr. Velluro Have Failed To Support Their Claim Of) Tj /F53 12.37 Tf 34.80 -13.20 TD (Undue Burden.) Tj /F53 11.56 Tf -35.04 -26.40 TD (Respondents and Dr. Vellturo argue in their motions that Complaint Counsel's subpoena) Tj /F53 11.51 Tf -35.04 -26.40 TD (would cause an undue hardshp to Dr. Vellturo and would impose a burden that would far) Tj /F55 10.89 Tf 0.24 -26.64 TD (outweigh any likely benefit. In re General Motors Coi:., No 9077, i 977 FTC LEXIS 18, at * i) Tj /F53 11.66 Tf -.24 -28.80 TD (\(Nov. 25, 1977\), states that, "seeking relevant data wil not be quashed on the grounds that the) Tj /F53 11.73 Tf -.48 -24.24 TD (burden is imposed on a third pary, especially where the pary initiating the subpoena has) Tj /F53 11.64 Tf 0.24 -26.64 TD (expressed a wilingness to mitigate whatever burden may exist by negotiation and compromise.") Tj /F53 11.55 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (In addition, In re Kaiser Alum. & Chem. Corp., No 9080, 1976 FTC LEXIS 68, at *18, states) Tj /F55 10.40 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (that "a general, unsupported claim \( of burden\) is not persuasive.") Tj /F53 11.67 Tf 34.80 -26.64 TD (Complaint Counsel's subpoena duces tecum issued to Dr. Velltuo contains one, single) Tj /F53 11.65 Tf -35.28 -26.40 TD (request. That request is for a copy of all documents and data cited by Dr. Vellturo, and all) Tj /F53 11.67 Tf 0.00 -26.88 TD (documents and data relied upon by Dr. Velluro, in his expert report.) Tj /F53 10.26 Tf 21.36 -43.92 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F53 11.57 Tf 158.88 -9.84 TD (Respondent does not submit any detailed evidence on the) Tj /F53 11.61 Tf -180.72 -26.40 TD (cost and burden of searching for those documents listed in Exhibit 2, but rather, makes a) Tj /F53 9.12 Tf 223.68 -39.60 TD (8) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000205269 00000 n 0000205328 00000 n 49 7 0000205447 00000 n 0000205611 00000 n 0000239188 00000 n 0000206139 00000 n 0000205758 00000 n 0000205887 00000 n 0000206012 00000 n trailer << /Size 56 /Prev 204962 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 241585 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000266040>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R ] /Count 9 >> endobj 56 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 57 0 R /Contents 58 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 57 0 obj << /XObject << /Im59 59 0 R>> /Font << /F60 60 0 R /F61 61 0 R /F62 62 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 60 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F60 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 61 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F61 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 62 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F62 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 59 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im59 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 20888 >> stream d[FJ?NL-FZ96#)ŸJ %$tB/vLԙ7-"He 2B~aB E>GgDHhfA˃ — _%bP&A{"85vtQC(./ A$I+"q}=W B#dG2KTI58l d `B/P'>O ɞNTҺT~i<,8H>ºtWޤ3K.;IaGNE+ۧ޷؏ ^T~ik%]mK?ߪ]ZNX-ZM j8gQFAS#Yg#OgLٝE!!hGc:TwJ8Wny2\1PA#L g paD$80TfcC@.a7A%syH k&ﴨ /°5aB3iB=ڬDzO<-A`AL# W 00$MZ{":M4N°a| P0`I4q[L' (ZA R:3DDE\jgeHvA`t&当5 ^' .*UttDDk؍""""""""""""F DDE8\DDkJ~UrhNh4e&GG3R6.6dB3ℵ"""""""""""$>BIX I% !AHFMF7,y]hDᒏ`DXB"34v7DjFvAb&i))ؠ:a8gv)2vUeV]FeV *d"<! .apP]4 XU >eAu¯Xip @@a{^o 2pq(yBԲ(3Od1 ADr'lċ T Fz3"shٝ a0L& )EO<0L &@0Tτ̈́3!EЋ9Ƒt$DQ)4(HD#ff!%Ժ3,)Sqq1"f„C̈<0gTh]}N¨(P & ڗ. AB$L `! "AxM B &4Bd"&Bka5P* (DuolF߰dQxqE^b'ni-mb n8*a`Pi'T(*"1ɜ (h~D%+p섿 zvB8hkFFBj/kh4^8LL4Nz N&]v}Dݢq vx@M2$8ޙCȮu^ ~pna{' dWI^+چArt&nppȹ 13i 2eM IWHo! Mm7NN A| w_l'_ꮛa['\-ZP [oiW`P Mi;`'Poy }齯^/|]'^J^otDG)Uљ7__~Xš}MkZVVQx\ ^#vׯ{9| kZ}}kE[/߿?a}_Oz2u׷CX̘9t,r~ۥk\91Ȯ\? fOno?ޘ8!G~ KvX_ {io~n_[kKa>=_Up޴Aհ%-a?UiN\/?x0ik~MWVH_k!_+WVS O>{o(A$._$֭ ?}Z"ۯk'` ` +OrKai}jim^Om~oA+حp*zK ơ=hLS ,0R֥{tk)|_ mN ӽ6M1v 󟴴ǫR<„~þ.I^.S' m/AK(' A9 M /-V_+Z֭FnWOG_]n /&Ա`#࿿Ö90࿵ܷ<:n"?"Caj ?WI~1?E|/%VM'kۮݰ׿%߿7װm~U`¿Mm'_^a/AuO]~m`"Qm{p_rF 뿒?ӊBK;_z~o{_)P./Y#_ /x> t$_jÿ u]=z2ww7޿ݔ_HaaE}Qx6w4&n{a^ }S߿i> WnKn߆#_."nkJJ?Vi_Kuku~k.C`Nc-aCJOalR{ V<^!aݗҏ5/Hz ol$麰X4w턳AqTmG`ii5cV>ڎaa8t,ְ>8piE9tEa~#&UL 6$IGITo $k_j8= 5Ml%װVL\SGƽ1LTPAoAVDuJڄpA qڂ 4MiM4@<: ">*"AM40@$B*a0>40M51kK`$}0FM0B0=00L0^aO A֛"MAP5ԾaBSL DQOkV ih0@ "`Fg=tišЈ&p0  3@ω &x`5H(&A!eL8gB`' f 2@ g4'  B#5AeQ _v;u0TTaS DZj"Nb?6-,vZGf2 L& vfEddY\k.viiĩłL+L aBS`aN [魧 ]PZ @bTI->Mphv$zn% 88Z޿}@@ڧr|B_z[}Vۭޚӷ_?]ZK]}mHPL5'2x " "D% gC m"Ld( ahMB 50ma{ 7B%n.NEE*hqh8 ExB!vMa͊*&;tXh=u@P*h0h4*haעQ iA or,:" 2% M  1adHl lQ慇0:6 m'Iޖ<'݄5'zO z %#{ F>\`ȹA4ȸޑ_0ȸ7#M?NvT:k}uZn]+WT߿k+K{io&ޕ-'ں]i=j ^WimZ>?ҐbнDһk_Z^}յ}f$'_: J"[kkt{סtwK~W~Fp]IKu}Kǧ҈?_ۺ׺~Y~ }ra?'_jDnx) PWG_í.eZu [B#k}WZ:ּɍy`_]7T_HvzjN}u` kzޭuT]ZAwED{{m_ki}}~-_#OB(W]il}%ֿ_I{tUu^tEN6HAw5PHB꽺zߴn8_׮=X>{;z{KKv__m$m^__~mV~kֶӣk at_ (VaI6KoVUW߭Zi«}V|4* P}bWxJ|0J7&o_rJ4 %}?KOG⟇AݠzAuv0;Ӻ_J!Ą~q+ƞ|SXa;4؍ TZlxNa0btmhiA8 WJ6 +V:TXZm4zq7a{L6vȏh5 ha dn`UdvdQ:kL$L @|lVLm40dQD0AA0i4AZ kj&7YaAB" "DB,L@U=3p ii,r(Owiv [ dvAh4NFvL%L0L iYU8Zgt""""""""TLA* a284g#4 & aT5e 1fՈЈ"(u {a S8xMFWd&Abeѐ&vi%*qd K A0O>ɽj°N00ŵ/n>A*ӭܯֽܳﱫ%½ׯ6ȉ0܂E'}wEhX2s|7C LK~o| }m.?W9f3K"7ү=Ds ޿Ht{m`_a~kWzU]^]v߽_/7[[ҥL ~P;] ,]{{{kkakWW{w8% '~+X})HG}}cO~XLA0 ;dq lSAa0ccc^h uV-aIڵ+#^+8Z=w a>m(@AGMU4Iq#1 &4AdGSS O“pS Y7^6L 4ҵ{ P°xT28KaMPjA馛 4&V2;TMDDDDDDDDDPD3քDDCB D C0sqd9Q>2AAOPGAE&L{-d &pD3isB(niDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDhk. XjK GQ*Q,$a jl =vtE'2Cr5 49Cfq׆ߺOO_gX#_(_W/5_!wb׷z^_o]a~ |0dG0h4e__Wi[ """"?)8lFWdaDK3 ]dawYZC. VR0PP"?פN{/d; V-1$cWAD5 jMi/n]w~. %xYھ̧ˣDFCDDDI>"HDDDD0B,DF""?? ?n è&eڶd d;',WC&j+0F PD0pPpjCCKUQJI݃=<"G4{'NpyQA? W~Ӥ /~ ڧ&32]^ou][BfbBMH{'A8#*(>f١HaRe qֈ2%R:yk oi` t `(L"0CD  h P@ծ ":ng`D_"͐dnZhRJZhx-0ނ ,"W޼2Cqrޗ-ƔY-a> ] d nJH#u# vsa-pdyE IxFgW>_0Vߥ׾M ݄xGF"""" i0 FY[&a :l 8!""" DDDDDD~#ZK\KaZhUDR, !9!0;AAݡ6HѶfu">$36|[Plm+H?WK\~[^?뺿>8 iB޽]wIoYd;=V.kl_ Җ0$ 7806)8` Պ /캏MRJ6v*rU PAT)؛NTv<>pw]4/ڱ촡?磱Ҋ!$2Gh y:0C BC  Ao 馩\:µwPEvEpٲGV5d/X d#*v>HFѡ3&G aD͙(@< TDv," B`‚ &pat& p  0OL $D>BX@DH3L!l9;tpC:7X jDŽ{I 14a4L$âqFi˷*!;;=xK>ݫ z}H&majv/+_}޴vҿMoKI+IUWU /K5w{_mf[Xf?K_V6_xW¯_x|Bz1ЊtCu,ki W]#$z/Ðs9T0__\|)'Duۯ M.w9e* 5-.D] q}c__-omxoaI׷8D_ 5 ­޼^wamk[I/u}i-¿^H~i'wcz쐽_}?sDIlj6!NHQIw|^H^t~knFwA^!YEYBu=]ҿ]k/UjNZvnpҶ_iU[kUuJ7_{nKk{~ï۫m{{j{~]^w___":b/_zY _`U_{ZV wk}l:/fzZُ^[(k/`{uwQÃqnK bV8݇j0W BT_{0뗡>ˈGV^t6w^D^űO 08@66:064 'jcA &J!ii4ȏx5ڶ @) i; B1TM b !GL 4M28 ȶLa A!!l' a&Dy(N(0q@AȐ0AAptB 4 S"98jR,*VDuVaMP 8&jE <eVpDܧDtXYD"HBI04" +; )L: ˜t鳎V8L as<څL AV&Na5=aVwm4 (s:ge)3݄SM459Aa D3eb:f g.22 3:AuA8BٝVpB"""QCHb"""""""""#"""""""4"">o^I%RU nqBUAG Nj0knMxx3̳;UeZ&#e0!0Yf؆v1p r&Q뗓;UpA/@"h5;*" A$ ]ݡ*Be*ZT# \LR8W{yaȀn 4mĊ shJ35RNapy#y;OO蠃jІܒۆ۫UUŶI^UAR_J__:gdֺzڂ AhȃpA2xD>(96ف9’C09ELE,<-c"3I ΨOa2C&"5^iOP7FmC"L A xN @0Aa <40 @~N) P"W\3<4G9Ճ 64CĨq 8a s] wH9 !m:A L5D݂YaaUSL*x'aS L A00N a01?B0P (L(U05v5u>4EB.=q;a-O(Ń'dHKv;axDݤvn֨7't[ЋD MtLpiQyC %8uD  VÆE ߃#OᐏTI ˺'tir{|}' ;D/E'A̾?MT Ial m}zuն|d}7v[&pjtJ($tbPJpdxltp½/p:Ot5_׾u]=ކMv`*ӯ צ~ߺ}nWo_^îoƗUut׭OQS|V1KDc1އӻi7׽!Ou#MmVas]!?~BP#ǧצ|n"d?a*_lAX9kIÒ<+Ks^,`?D}I{e_KۯkV6qU{_NՇ]Whֿ턺0'ҽ_׺imoaaKu :oߴ{um~Az/p䊨==P_k$}^׿]{D+Qd%K(^p0߷E^t_Me>km__W]Noo{O[R_ju{ץuM!t`Kv{} oikoaޥ-,/۰׿~mO}ui^M\4֝]H|Kb5DIbQ\=?3"^A(b(a ئ_1lMr4>Ui}a{LD/0A4p h=66 q+ظ0'fŮ"ZK]CNiuaJ $.9 ~҃ b@0a"B LB(&:dWBh0md!"6 8@P@ ᠐a>6  aG@PAMXAECMj^ Aean(MB 5M4 8&W\4'aN6] =5 "($v5 i0\f@DDi] O B Ls agR 0c$>!F3@A0L铰A=$KUPDDJ4 DG qHL"#-Iim/W_/p  t 6*:@Èd{ڗ+;vRRlQ&v"`gb&Kح `AN(*X]U\. ]';OokiI"?^)B4D ʋ)фgEHԧ7>S 1 " gN0D>AlPprD#|S \a e &!f3·d#12>R>:< œ&@*  ւi0Aύ B:XDޮzt:A:o~Es8^ }qƿ`zZ\>WL ˂p'|?}/-/_U##U~$ >X5iܳǷV<ׯK/~G?(^_}S_]m*^]&z.ק]uﴫߴݯ~_5aᆖG_l&֪LW6gݫU IcظՄ6᤼4a*݊AGH `lP"0Anȃ݊ f1 m[ _ c_ v0T0P[4jD iXavx4t6 &S2A4jFe (L`2 =\L&P0XamAȣDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDIDDA` aG՟<(fLԶEޞIث"u]BT)l*! G[Q endstream endobj 58 0 obj << /Length 1686 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im59 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F60 5.00 Tf 83.52 692.40 TD ("general, unsupported claim \(of ) Tj /F61 10.97 Tf 149.28 -.24 TD (burden\)." Kaiser Alum., 1976 FTC LEXIS, 68, at *18.) Tj /F62 11.55 Tf -149.28 -26.64 TD (Complaint Counsel is merely seeking to obtain a copy of those documents listed in Exhibit 2,) Tj /F62 11.63 Tf -.48 -26.40 TD (which were used by Dr. Vellturo in December 2006, only 26 months ago. In addition,) Tj /F60 5.00 Tf -.24 -26.88 TD (Respondents argue that the benefit and usefulness of ) Tj /F62 11.62 Tf 246.24 -.24 TD (those documents are "too slight to justify) Tj /F62 11.59 Tf -246.24 -26.40 TD (the burden and expense" on Dr. Vellturo, and that any evidence he could provide "would have) Tj /F62 11.59 Tf -.24 -26.40 TD (nothing to do with the facts and issues in this antitrust case.") Tj /F62 10.31 Tf 23.76 -43.44 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F62 11.59 Tf 183.36 -9.60 TD (This case is about the loss of competition that would) Tj /F62 11.53 Tf -207.36 -26.40 TD (result from a 3-to-2 merger between CCC and Mitchell.) Tj /F62 10.26 Tf 199.44 -125.76 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F62 11.63 Tf 114.48 -166.56 TD (These issues, and thus, the) Tj /F62 11.72 Tf -316.08 -26.64 TD (documents and data Complaint Counsel seeks, are not only relevant, but rather, go to the hear of) Tj /F60 8.08 Tf 0.00 -26.88 TD (Complaint Counsel's antitrst case. Based on the foregoing, Respondents and Dr. Vellturo's) Tj /F60 5.00 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (claims of ) Tj /F62 11.51 Tf 46.08 0.00 TD (undue burden should be rejected.) Tj /F62 10.56 Tf 177.84 -26.16 TD (9) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000241912 00000 n 0000241971 00000 n 56 7 0000242097 00000 n 0000242261 00000 n 0000264010 00000 n 0000242789 00000 n 0000242408 00000 n 0000242533 00000 n 0000242660 00000 n trailer << /Size 63 /Prev 241585 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 265762 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000288119>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R 63 0 R ] /Count 10 >> endobj 63 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 64 0 R /Contents 65 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 64 0 obj << /XObject << /Im66 66 0 R>> /Font << /F67 67 0 R /F68 68 0 R /F69 69 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 67 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F67 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 68 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F68 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 69 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F69 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 66 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im66 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 18950 >> stream T,h$Q)n? .O zlQw6d q^ ae91Z/t=Gg6U VEh8d( bZB4͈uRZv pwAN%!ND.3b# a'\ ڻ /o{pޛ"S%dLp`!2FӽY XE;[ȸhxN ^ iޘVzUq_WΨ,.}k~4& [%(#y RrsqsV~{cDBH5@ q&аD8by'^"ѳ5>_$gs=g$y+GY0 ْ2qS0`W &Ŧӻ5@tZ S|da4&'n\oa Z" +"!~^Hh6NDCAXNAT4.jq-b Ɖ{ș 7YI> _DWݎwb&؇Nv  %"«OX`EoH(D{ȑ¨8d_O##DL"GdpBw~W[[GPDVV]OL}[Z߽JȮr%npƽPW %Z}5CD^*uho_>Wi/ O|]}?K.׏=«:#9;w~?ҒeRaׇMxD_DK?WotŽNw/K=i{goⷅK7}}/o]K߳z;?煮K}'vGAUMߘu{?ׄB)n]}bG?]'_Jo^'_Y ( \ 5v?h.q__V zui~dB RalPpvVPV دU |m~.)4.#-@S F鄛"&Z"h  4IMqMH8L'`.v"r PDDDq ea^S# 2)*`0{RcCAX2Pdn`4 SL&Op¢[4d٠DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD3T!!it!aUlE˂V{B"" x;x)њ0tbOhJDFZ 0yh'DDDHd8<<&AVw(sh* r,sg3rܨ;9} v]<2ˁᵈ!q^x#9rc #)9PQY5ş-9쥣A\{+qPl; Y9pl;yyyg)Ù9˃7&9#ȣrc"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&Iqc#ь?3|]2s.#1G]\#7g>Dȓ&BvgB"""""""""""""""""""" !-Dg%2S&B"@;(#.K2.MPaB"$iD19ؐdG!"hCDǦ>&4}0W?``HӃ*_~nB[ u4Js{kﯿBu~e?I{ݥpkǽIu;.]N0""*3}/pEpd0:@ %>&9U8*כ<G'C8gF_q6rN, jil60A$Ou0[΂.#m&h4{TDh!H ͊D,2g.4AJdH%@еD+8 DnTma]Mwinĉ:xO >aoȸPY$}>IPN*ajկ ?k":nDtMm,Y*.-DK~a}t޲$%mDHMW"F7[o_ct=4_=zI^ՇBo }WT]_K'{wQko܃Kv O6YV]Wo_[E_Bӥ{;#7~Hb$JI_B-Ka=W_!w['E7^tG[߿_Z}p῭}Oثz}{}/kMxo}KP]뚕kn_~f}]dDmz 3J3]V}>+wJxgӭշ'AM+~/M}UW^ /b;ۥmW'jץ +݄|zzA~ΘfL{ǺWN^m)b8t |v Hta&5LO@ӈaiUi4wa&*TiQU&'`o&؋c d úFpDti %n01Aa G ӴL%j#b""" Ј0h3""!,=e8Sa 38S0a MN4C2pA! 0B""8aЈDq2rA#x/F tGˣao(FyaA9pArcw8q9qɹ8g#Ɏ[9=FK9#d\ /2#7y~4q͊G|DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE<#\CN"'x!2EM!#G|^0Tc%tjgFRgz#|_.dxl7F#x\.ea1;%S3x+&BJȔ+R* P&SUB""""#"""""""#`*hb? (9b!zYdYGwp&v+EHHED'̋sؚ2b.KrqDv ,/t PNBd1F2dr(0Tds Bk#% m@v AױoIAwnd7d*7;CEѤl:[iz^weot}%ե.!P\Ⱥ#t'fB$ u3Zs$$D&EiwNU àC0PL"1R!$-sdB&|SA_!@!qgQd9.FdC!d0DO^iN cvA_q2xhT7Q&.$8bBB 0l4 nD{ 8h^2@G02v  &h5 aL") a (Bs !B _;VY-Qx.h4p/!A0l:&[(QhaQh0 40T- (E `~B41__FU $jdHFnABnE c@iqb Њ.T"!q㎁wECDNA} [o&0K 3oN\ uI7 DXlN&7!n ȷNds`A "[k7 =[ift֗Zu=N=m6um'[Ph[Ҷ4a7L/ׯ}տi?vNtz~kuMoc[c_o~?_׫ukyvuuů֔_߮R OKo) L?.>~<uo__uu_ܲL0X.`to{u!G*5aoWtrh+w/zU~_D}_Du Q_o:7z^} Kz7Kk$~u3/>Cj __ޗv_ F W 7M~H^֛pGڧgT]_dW^ Y"oڿZWok߷z^_\ѫkJzJ%i~^v~outX:߸kZ^i:>ޙ|]&0A}VG_MJ?+uHݗ+k|AtVn}'A %iW *aN-ȃ l0vÄPawç؏bbD,*kWQ_܆&68VD Xkk>h 4MDtqM8M4aY4Aö{j $a&8 Ol&$PE!AA:DOpq f ga2 i & ;Æ!40@¶KOdvb r#S" B Sa <0L`  i W 6""""""""""$NeZe { AFl j{?вgv )3<a4PA{ ~a0AӰUL "6"""""" """"""""""""""J@dDDDE3F財Sz#B""""":_KPTi0K~g,-jZ  G+QJT~&gx+@'YT22FB̉#Y2R3# v&v7VM4iS p7Gi t\?ivfHfzISjmk2ZІ*ҍR]m{̇]G;dK%L¨Z]u0r)Q#(D?|< ::&g gpPЈ4,fl" 2% BsA,Hӗ 2$iu5"al?" TV4P((N`|a428!'<)@lA*0p.# CE i'f30M"Xy|aŽļ#TӔgcC8dy:>pΙq0 _?!^2^dpJHVX!xD݂.QA҄0LPr4>F4Gd7i'"|68O A Aa]-4]CD=aBD !jav~0A5-<&"L 0[ u iC OOOC$Wl*82P֟ҵlabm?m4~ ؜|n` ma'Z&'Lr ]Ɖ}x'a lh^UN:áiipµopdtOM_a#}=+h6I;!NjG  "E;<  m NԎHD2x SĈRFZF@f͆0ʘ&<4C3M<92(@dC62@0NA*g A!`gĆ03OM:MvDݵNMAE"Ƅq4*'gHva &4j&pT  ; ‚䁅& &D?L(_ a6ޖnadnzmxA8rHH^7uE-/.h踡nDq Wh 4"qDޅႌ'"̼h"vMjշuo=߫С鵅ӫG&|:=ZV|:Anwd$0H7nth Hj : !a]ioۧ*{k_NOZ:GW ҿv w_dy7Ni82>i>'Ka D0njҿwVڿ}ki'^niwOk[W~޶֪jcwZQP҆鄆_oMe.-{vBKuk~B:z8-J-?I./JGvǯw ~[_!Gvm%a{KtȚ~LrPa!oVɹ DᆿX"^BSɊ°k8^=kݤu noO^_aKߵI]k}kҍ-쑇~_[n7"qngXAtWƓu <䏧m_ZUWnI='T[^[׵:_G7Azޟc_$}w]ն޽T߿tl'u^S);wkǵm_齽iMu{j{~޿W}zkՈl0 {X`0j ++[V^[W{յ޷i^PAil~}+(zcl$鴛 Zl/M]zoְ^p`թ~߰Jia0z V ^>چSTT4X㺿o[aZpҧ]ҐC"@-h+kNڥGvO@!U aTmP@M4t kjaboK/tcui:b"W* 2@ 0c E a&  VATA:dA5!oӲ#@D-;"8AABDA ""'D"#*h&9pMX0@80@3V,t) PaSMBUa4iBՄ& -ɿP"""""""""""$"iKpA0AaO0Edµ5"ɞ>C ;Aza4!E:"""""""""""""""""#_YhyN_KBkJZ G~UiҨ5;rnˆ6 cdS`Mn FK" 0]8DDŽSp)ZA\5q$X~!(]WKj8Σ$f! /:y:8 P0 PA xf8dx2Rk SvPqٲP4i&=#<"!@DF : iM0L.jP4 0 ~hv'  Mpmi'dc\08I2ez/(ytOZN%@nuoxxO޵o_WI_XSm"OV޿t݌v+5 OVD qaޮBybX9i-=um+_꟯vP}ֿz Ǻ_=6޿miMߗ]]u?׽m[w_L0wI׆J-Wu ޟ}5S@4q $;aºi0Ҽ'iC `.+[鰓dWA TS P" XL0A1LlSWhIruy aPp"DDd a0̜ g #ADDDDDDDDFN{A@?e-T9GMBy@P t"Al p?un Ȓ"gYg3Ng fC_ӫ39t={[Q__Ǿ+OM[~ob_Gohwn7ޕoN_ [lN̈́ G'1r1eVس]-lREiC& W) DDDDDG GaQ-ʤSo 4}vip EApa -Dv:aȚ""HFVC;a=>O ?_}Ξhfk"p`fS&A#H '/Dvi"d1N:00LB&fa4B  = Z~?Vuݻkդ '!8Aha< lWJ{w֓[wWVe}]GI\0M [[# U  l( 7"=6)8`A0IJ)i,jD]1K&:4EBT!h׆9O&a2;^h0@T& i@8) d3)e3 㦧AܧKM3t * 1'WuL'""#R{2 ɸ 5 @= 0AP"-]:_Hb}-_ C$_Wi:0,*qLpl(@\b@{)?岐r A "vEqpeHqhF`晧32737~ [:ק3M>;(c)+7|;5B7~no7oݳ_ . R Ȱ3a 0lQ8` ]~ Q"1fk[2k~"  H`B4D8fშCPB@Hd- A`H#H0ADaxAI6ADs`Iw 7wnW'þoЭzC 1wտ}]um\=v_+Afi]t]oz߿r kouoݰZnmCa-V7 =ni+i0Ҷ`]AAx ب`=`JVA B6lqAd#VUt^UDHfa@M 0 A)(2A Qc"""Nedp#x#G2>Be !$A9g1jDDDDDDDI5EU//| 28Rf8tNh3#H˲"""""# Vv"&DvTvWJʲ5l(O+{M33+p`vvK;fB&2$s!G .DW$ bAڢI;A5  ).27 T`̵@EY+fA[ oK}Pֿ_o__\>ʴ@^nxDP˃jA"qPL B= eЕD#?agNjVӯT_-*! !qP " 0PP.[0!ND # 9cd|y#0Q]^_FHu7a L"NB-j`0!M `"aTQd|Hd[_ HxtO^Aݡ ی"vC>a`/‚w &@yIOF( a͌3 0{""! q <CS:#8LמFE A8[#Ir_+k\1l dvy{^|/';ZX[1vD?/zo=uZ1wKǯc_^߷.|M{kLAy7!֗_u}v&?u&Ի[J_n\~^ aE߇lWb,/uIxam_]uo8kÂnAy#K ֟t?{?}Wwׯڭu7_o^_eӥN[jW ܧ9Fc d y#0 xײq"am6mnv^zn_k]{~qK{a+j6HX`~Aim~m'?vu0 thba%M`;M C_GGֻ쏂$֓a*{l1kka]j҇ "!ib5M; z % &!xb+ulǸOZc@w0MbwiYpaLK OdXT;A4'6Da LB &mib~<[PҎi55kjïbZlwQ!f cS`PNa{RCl*A\6)`i 97 Ԅ{!\V6a(h&HmC E q4"VLa5P &Ϝt PaS v5N} j l pQQH=4_"#DDDAg#^AC `&L&w*e#jpP0MRN OfM;+1 *J@Ј""""""""#'@B"QuUK"Zׯ㐎U ̃ 72]0O# p ODz%yB+MA vJ G (*"!cdb6Ն׭\0Ph!K @]C;ZgbE0 7 B&d ;UH@3%Hfː&B 7h89>tg.aPDAo^DW;+a8pȶMo+R.zxIx ܼ%zN?vֵoKۦuzT_K֕+_i//_҇MV]YM8{yN&ER]L>aHkJ%״ (@ &C |".GĄCX@!&rC%ˌ͐6"}u뤅jncC }p@& vX!D;s9y!dc:g8- X A|"rap7\ 5wL&n=A ` FQOUP2ȃ(3*BE:kou-*pˌXkM6X* j y2:AY.FO4pbp` a 4aF hE&}tfFy ?5;^G 2PznH'd%A==Qx74I'j0Afئ =հ 7NhWU Ӷ ȷҪvN`"8҄_BcZƿo^T,%PKFLL;Fz-*iz[ZN#=w&_-So^]_!IBU/IVյmzh.sƩUDDZWV>_M%W]*]%TֶZ^_]Vxq*5o/_n|(#$:I6*V!OM:JKK%It_VYkU_|V{ZKOꁿ*,~ERZJKc7_aw^UA& /KF?ZHMJIk!|~d ?.ToPT-xDAZU}O"0_~Xo^W*IA^%0WV_u{~kvl^҂u@ \U}R__k6]]k6U?KAj"AJIU*ZR? e`z~t'_ᄮ{[UנIi/'}*VkXv!jd|ؾ/AkޤLµl%im{҆uh䅔iOk_}Z%Ua!qiMpdr#V-m+0Qï;UKZ#&$kUva/-Y_ֵZRudX +AT@= BبZ 1M Ob 5vAi0<ImեouR?KWJ[ڑ[rO _=zgúg; l3e\6L& _L 1[!T0@ dpA4J6*v`0Q_4 VFaKZFq&1"ϱ3a f&aG0j!a#M$0A(Sbb $iT؝qiE!KV* 'uiDDDDDDDDDD4! D3a3qgE v *T0aUkN2 L&a !ULST]R\DDDDDDDH; e+?A0L-Tza2Vl9c,4]2;^UL&p """"""'LA <&3 X" !f)Ze j0PL&B"""""6ָoUAKA[UE qZPZ%MX"b&N \A9 Vb1|"(a0dN _L&3baCŢNDU@'^ftd}IkuR쏂}>## C_w_LǓOuׯ"5}WV}mzᮽX+!7{' Ck6@ 7A5 A.T s DDDDDDGd$, ?|"-A?TSk*?- Ö!u*@7-CJ߯uom/m`!vkK%U@ endstream endobj 65 0 obj << /Length 1516 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im66 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F67 9.27 Tf 118.56 692.16 TD (D. Respondents Fail To Meet Their Burden In Establishin2 That The) Tj /F68 12.40 Tf 34.80 -13.68 TD (Subpoena's Infrin~e On Dr. VeIlturo's Proprietary Interests.) Tj /F68 11.62 Tf -35.04 -26.64 TD (In Dr. Vellturo's motion, counsel argues that the subpoenas infrnge on Dr. Vellturo's) Tj /F68 11.55 Tf -34.80 -26.40 TD (proprietary interests, and argue that he is an unretained expert whose "opinion and information) Tj /F68 11.52 Tf 0.24 -26.64 TD (do not in any way describe the specific occurences in dispute and who was not retained by any) Tj /F67 5.00 Tf -.48 -26.40 TD (party for puiposes of ) Tj /F68 11.67 Tf 99.60 -.48 TD (this case.") Tj /F68 10.26 Tf 65.04 -36.72 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F68 11.51 Tf 118.08 -16.80 TD (Second, Complaint Counsel accepts) Tj /F67 5.00 Tf -283.20 -25.44 TD (that Dr. Vellturo was not retained by any pary for purposes of ) Tj /F68 11.20 Tf 291.36 -.72 TD (this case.) Tj /F68 10.22 Tf -90.96 -71.76 TD (REDACTED) Tj /F68 12.27 Tf -23.52 -60.72 TD (III. CONCLUSION) Tj /F68 11.55 Tf -143.52 -26.16 TD (For the foregoing reasons, Complaint Counsel respectfully requests that Respondents') Tj /F68 11.50 Tf -34.56 -26.40 TD (and Dr. V elltuo' s Motion to Quash the Subpoena Duces Tecum and Supoena Ad Testifcandum) Tj /F69 9.87 Tf -.48 -26.64 TD (be denied.) Tj /F68 10.08 Tf 220.56 -200.16 TD (10) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000266089 00000 n 0000266148 00000 n 63 7 0000266284 00000 n 0000266448 00000 n 0000286259 00000 n 0000266976 00000 n 0000266595 00000 n 0000266720 00000 n 0000266849 00000 n trailer << /Size 70 /Prev 265762 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 287841 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000291370>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R 63 0 R 70 0 R ] /Count 11 >> endobj 70 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 71 0 R /Contents 72 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 71 0 obj << /XObject << /Im73 73 0 R>> /Font << /F74 74 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 74 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F74 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 73 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im73 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 1804 >> stream (W;$F3;S?KRԫ_G*jkۖQQɲ?e"?mGuNͣh/~""$dL x02N3Q">GfY9DhHCw*ʳ=G6&v5X LXn{< 96wXjdpuB""""" "'YplM2v!)۴`38mȐl/u 7&SACh/m aHt 5umìD2a}wa/aXp}ۻO ~W]itpn{Iuoӧ}ZwK~m]{ Wگ;];iK:ëGw!wկ[mצi;moh%[-M/oI>۷CNOawVI>oi}]K{w $֛~]{u)I='_åL?n_^-O߷KҮ>T+*AP+u~֯iwVIVt׷$IXzJ^߷_ou7߫T] |#--p:ޟM'kuoo^to{uoMԂ Ctޟo~4u k߇[u޽Zo 9\x9m{Ј{}UtCë7oz[n zt{: snSoI""""!]+_~'~[j!]t۷6o{}}܇rc0Gom!3&zI:oo_oi6t;ui_;J]5_լaW]]t} 7o}o邏+UIzOW_%tV֡[K車znk>߭&պ_{IBM]=uT[k~ Oa*WMSNp@i邂L5nieh6v,ŀ 2זb7)z![Oha29 eJ+ 'DFw(& चi'#NR`@¬D.7+ޝ 24DDE2Aܖ#/"G٨S"""#BHXxh8Yh"%..x3Dv$!0DY"F^/ G(Y~#&K@HmV?׏@O^? 4QG ,kkE endstream endobj 72 0 obj << /Length 145 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im73 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F74 57.88 Tf 180.96 449.76 TD (ANNEX A) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000288168 00000 n 0000288227 00000 n 70 5 0000288370 00000 n 0000288534 00000 n 0000290922 00000 n 0000288786 00000 n 0000288657 00000 n trailer << /Size 75 /Prev 287841 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 291132 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000300583>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R 63 0 R 70 0 R 75 0 R ] /Count 12 >> endobj 75 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 76 0 R /Contents 77 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 76 0 obj << /XObject << /Im78 78 0 R>> /Font << /F79 79 0 R /F80 80 0 R /F81 81 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 79 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F79 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 80 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F80 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 81 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F81 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 78 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im78 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 6696 >> stream 35(TQ  /rM1@Rdq)DI#d'}b8Y4*_QS-%X^Sikj\f `4Hl 6vީ!((5ORuBL0l4ԓd+E!x!,CGd|@1Q4$\,%Zm; P aE`'pGEDXɎEv⁵$unW]nmAAD){7{kv']tkZ^﵏OIվ~qj_oR\%CbV^{m:u`  ~+Q _ ~I$@~wWu߯w޾zUտI_GtK~^u޻ HZbxLШauEvu4Ga @&L!HBY^l\:Jv!tT˲ILAhP&8a0 vl$DE$mHs gH8);Ԙc8LSmDDDD&M0˹V(4S. a GJ":{&gD]m2pI 2 ">qF_$󧇠8d7.NPl%>CF|CFo*8l8D}Jܷ";!v8A`Ј o48|dzp l4 a"I 6ظa 6}za5AdqD qه h"7DӰo^ޒb9E;@ AWz:_tzW{Ղ$o_b8*ژ[ovCUwXIK>|k ݇*_}1ZO#lֿm}7o} Ԍuԍtmگ9}~atIjZm-0*$/K9o^K [_mn{7aiuZU}&b 0L!A%vma%m/֗z5^kRq-Ј#@pjixOM{wJJ- ЈLo0Nw@IIgA] 1A nӆ""""""""" )2 àa(0p\B"#9lFAFGDDx8ͅ6d3!Dpqn>O"3R6>Lppqq"5Dh 9@G؃08e5Gl0L 0 H 6צ}o菛mk7V?::xշ{_MM_Mzn|hök[^={_[k ~難^G+ ?1C9}]{ǃ"m-iQ^obuixz޿Cm'Nw[~ i*kpzKz  !AX{%]AȗyTx!nP&x  J—~t1'DDDEA^X)e Dc;Gr80!20~1!X!"VVHSm Z92O ”sq^P2ܓ R+LDDC<!x)95pA;*Fp@) b"$h"3q`"""""# uNZ<a5L&Vr &)\ #r!iAe̮I5D l 1'AP _RUtUZA_QLq5n'?^\[`"4<& b8fqLOk1rcSBMM /^ ]d$1-,zTe!i~J?L =H1!7P'~ ]ܕzuPނ ]Px_xxO_/Em`_,0o}KalUn_joK_{"u_we}iZ6UJ!0ˌ&¶NKa%n1( Wihll[ lS )e^ʌ叅N)t֒>ZDDDXM'a23˜u,|à0P"ЈhDDZaP iMkXOڏZ]=ff׍GiiH̓"Df ""3d.AûTYa"*S8_m?OI,!WL jC-},"wak ^k_XZD ׿_,^4NOM  ҷK-;BH<&gS.B? t\}Z#Z>:{4GTTPD0E2!΢FfD. 4;ݤM,pRcҦpT݄m)gR7ۚںA$E:AJ=[_K <-zZ ڠk[tDiuõZ*<_m]R n' _WP~xztϏҽi}7m+h5}mOմXbȎw_Tڰ^׏hawl=~س^J/_a}{_UhnRc6aޗXNWH- G.JK $(6HmI t*ؠIM@Pb(l! $aL3P2x4sP^w& B4' rAim7l&G8uV]wl'nEú[p~wWA8dqJu{߶j[^ikKZ$EiUB}[/]O_~_WmZ״_qK_ .?tG xB a5[bȯax a._o鄭*. (IO B 3DErRSA+#""""" [TqQ?q] A%긏MȽ<_ji\SC޿i%/9ƁW\0Ma-C֞VN f B=M8! xXI!Xl4E`"ᓏdo ׵.{kxlyd/^ְ֯D~wwjӟ8MگZyLpث=>A4p>B[{SD3wdf i"""""""a"kn_WRPGy#w5x09(r @9d3|g. CP–""""""$"Ta(yeQ3G_#a̎\B˜ A7Jd(9pB8G8D0G Ո>Ѱ)𒫬Z噞r?-?YE9#ȹͼb-<܃;'Y$C&"|Vظ!㆙Ų f kʼԉ"D4@ۈ""!08lBF02KB6d#vz1#DIV Dp!0nCA!Ddq`N3Ԉb2(d聣܇hי1wry l"/0ddH{(Ȏ"$ ؃ CAz4,4A(\"i V.`!P%}/m pnv '0ј6h!OjD44,ߴ {k"ci'[l2#0n|S&T vvDphnm~W8I} C <"Xa ]zcr/}nkбO^[K{W[kc֯_MMI*ion}kKJ!귭O_]$kk{֝_?ۯ8꾷U_x}_T>T*@W}WV?~_"H>[ zJL'ip+uuK"GE־+n*8.ݬos"XnԎ>W-58g}ȵ!(X~V/]8Vu}UW„(8TK}};OJW4kM20v{Mj%}aOt~+_аhaꃆi-_K޿ K3\H#0 lb0BA3Zju}au-"""",2Y8j_"r %@#\P eN' o{ &m-?`E0a) Pkn@MA~`0H&m҈>!a0d73=waqkoWb"""""- $}aBtΑGܡ+)DDDDDDDDDDNpt" DD~ZE? ;?R-QmBBr&g-0P͆s A.l3.`S0x(H$@ eA@ {|5A~oaGmeHNFP vis8A)iΌ a#BD"w4>zAaooo?om_}]w^mk#;x^?^UJ?I?\~_~} `,Gp+_b)}o(waS oMc|?h^n[7#]S~_owO/v wk]¯L(;"D,b\l"\w' YDȐ3(vE 5^ww!a v""""""""""""#-`,m(b[~?G姧 ()58`8nIt k =4i&zi)+h(4ehm &Me mnKWVҧ*}׻X_m~K#J_U/𾯷iQ'^+ /,20Za  ɉ>Oz[7`߭_oMtMmյJVkڶm Lئ)iZkL' &`*1$q endstream endobj 77 0 obj << /Length 892 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im78 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F79 9.31 Tf 230.88 624.48 TD (UNITED STATE DISTRICT COURT) Tj /F79 9.70 Tf -1.92 -10.56 TD (NORTHERN DISTCT OF ILLINOIS) Tj /F80 8.19 Tf 31.44 -10.08 TD (.EASTERN DIVISION) Tj /F81 8.29 Tf -122.88 -30.00 TD (CCC Infonnation Serices Inc.,) Tj /F79 9.15 Tf 77.28 -20.40 TD (Plaintiff) Tj /F79 8.32 Tf -52.32 -19.68 TD (v.) Tj /F79 8.43 Tf 155.04 -.72 TD (Case No. 03 C 2695) Tj /F81 7.95 Tf -180.96 -19.44 TD (MitcheIJ International, Inc.,) Tj /F79 8.59 Tf 77.28 -20.16 TD (Defendants.) Tj /F79 5.00 Tf -43.92 -73.68 TD (EXPERT ) Tj 42.00 -.24 TD (REPORT ) Tj 43.92 -.48 TD (OF ) Tj /F79 10.54 Tf 15.36 0.24 TD (DR. CHRlSTOPHERA. VELLTURO) Tj /F80 11.49 Tf -44.88 -148.08 TD (REDACTED ENTIRE REPORT) Tj /F79 11.46 Tf 241.44 -237.36 TD (PX0837 -001) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000291419 00000 n 0000291478 00000 n 75 7 0000291628 00000 n 0000291792 00000 n 0000299348 00000 n 0000292320 00000 n 0000291939 00000 n 0000292068 00000 n 0000292193 00000 n trailer << /Size 82 /Prev 291132 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 300305 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000310714>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R 63 0 R 70 0 R 75 0 R 82 0 R ] /Count 13 >> endobj 82 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 83 0 R /Contents 84 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 83 0 obj << /XObject << /Im85 85 0 R>> /Font << /F86 86 0 R /F87 87 0 R /F88 88 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 86 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F86 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 87 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F87 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 88 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F88 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 85 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im85 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 7713 >> stream [U4H#8tvi#t?Qɹ<ȄZ" S;5б&ndȯե;$$W_ڰTiճʴoմ\/@!G8dHN\%kn[]T'Tl-CJͯON%h;HHj6vvZM [Ibvv5\SLSnI-[I$a (i;QIÆu|NAiLW a0Th'"B6 SAQQPM  ➘L d ! L&0%53œa=0Ae8R i7ue8L)t= 0L'8)a?ZIW҄d2XCM@[Q)9L1 0th9L'IAC+Ae0@:#X* [fLҸr% *P{Xk p@TlS#,+BC`䜠amA&@#Z]9)IU"WXD;(VM?*2ivwzW֒8v>3﮷[(꒿[TUUK-H% 'O'+"gKdҥ# #DBB .2.IX@$LzjDQ n,&f$R||%;H4jq##Aݲoέ-$EqOY7V !>@} '{;VMAKW8Po JKZ`+BI͂E&o{#zMAG?Jť}i!!7CVx>ﵨ黮i:ҷ$AJoVJoo T__Im/{x.6PKk"wN?o_ooj+ׇUI~J1Zg8ST,߯PQi"qַ& ?KwL&Ul0G[$?B8#< }BkP/b~)~%B~=R~LzA_ɏ#+_[0Րkھ &_Z$^o`kڷd"Zi%? q$KI /]A?v:Dk ~"roB_lOҴWK t@]+JշtC` lW W}CXPOzWaA., 4Cŵm(IZW~ Wa&M6*Az0[ a1[MJ(4uL3p@Чa&}ڊl% 1ASU qc0(]=SCiH67xm[~?_wK$/X_73A6/ro }4}WuWKa¯^ k%] '/!GfQn0/!|> ƾJS|25FܓߒoG?{׿ߴ߽ڳǰ7moǴʸ﷥~;߾ۯγ޿ڏ۳/m.-<ۭum+߷kKio=ZJ I6 6om-6 $0Be6M$!!h80b C `ؠH l0a&nPa ^=T hDB"""kDt""""#ښ*;(d i,)0 T58D^d%o}w~֗qus#\בL!y d AL 0aAAP& 1T*[4M邦U0WRtWzi}|?}/\?Wny匿D}%_K}{dwoUO[Kt鴯a,.)tm 7_Cُm/ 0,pvD] ZKk &**4Eai0@ئH p´ ؄aA5 Zj bӓBjZ0PS0L 2 ` ! DDDDDDGO<[E8.]uVV_VUMեmZwaij,Wa2?p!mIj44c 5wS 7dGA6DtMZoU [ *ݦ QӃ IDDB" /qKAJdcJcZlo&ϒ[A5 R ̪Pe8B BitCbA pD80@ D_ ?@AuuIһbR6 3{}iZNv۫~Zw_Z{HYYv1Qsc!@Σ9_AX& DxAOu^iw$^4鄂.:D/?Ih=D=(ݫӓiK` ~iֻu/tCKۯ/շAXkOokjߤ][ե֯b-~? z]'i 'ZV׽^x *]i:/-S{&Hm .wImS +iZL5m.!ja4)AiE1 Uh4 z!XJ&h5iM&n jw025e30DDDDDEH+ҮTHlU)N?FF\ȃ%[Pd ̍cA⚅(ȐI0 A &$M4M/MaN_0Ay~K-&MaIm'MHj/h t_4@i_zAzIڷ[ii:}.o_/ZJM[Uo:q碜hSt4<aB 0u]O Bz km/ıDh=-v!i&& N za7 lYW7}KaR]Su޾,$/Һ?WZ3U=,_[i.`V/Ҿ'z ޟW^_/K. vC]{vCZItuv!>#}?iv_i: nTKZڞ]izI[׭[ii{kzQZMtՊXnbIZAJMiSjڰpISkum A&Il$I B lP@ )&)b Rcᄻ 0 * "5` `"80C2Ab#DEVn %޶#[^?[j!KB"D2F ᖦa8` (  z$;;A 7h z 4m0ڦIM&mv&+_6 @}ҧWn*u}}k$K*gzUm~U{(4\S7:W%5T־. $HaRKBRp/u؄$}ZՄȃt{kK 7M~umO>,v_q߯t$gh JҺA~Sinl:Ix'&I'WBB3Ukץ -o-=/KI]_sK/z^M7HD?ޗKֿ&ۤ-i%I_{ ]+iE)O$!O^4մ@IjAW=l$a`¶.j_⽄V&+SxGnw3@2xI Z ".b""""8[m+ +i[JQU ,Q1 o;3o;ZZJ/E=ATh H R|U&OZO{T}Rd5 ёfjD{]"ٝ ?tB`4a E3* "LvxTOv|S8{&A n&L.ИxdP p3l0A섷 ն6 pa?Oko[׿wokcv5zk 9`K۾7d?u^=e=~^wfi60a]ڗ_OVE-6M[lF 0LL=;i8b B< 6SA a-P0Se x!ܱ1G,?U?[~q5O_Q:Eb „Bu 8߯^l8l( $h endstream endobj 84 0 obj << /Length 786 >> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im85 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F86 11.92 Tf 70.80 701.28 TD (Dated: March 6, 2009) Tj /F87 8.19 Tf 251.76 0.00 TD (Respectfully submitted,) Tj /F86 59.62 Tf 0.48 -55.44 TD (By:3~~) Tj /F87 12.77 Tf -.24 -27.84 TD (J. ROBERT ROBERTSON Dfj,) Tj /F86 11.99 Tf 0.24 -13.68 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F86 11.97 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (Bureau of Competition) Tj /F86 11.97 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW) Tj /F86 11.96 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (Washington, DC 20580) Tj /F88 10.83 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (Telephone: \(202\) 326-2008) Tj /F86 11.92 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (Fax: \(202\) 326-2884) Tj /F86 11.92 Tf 0.24 -41.28 TD (Complaint Counsel) Tj /F86 9.60 Tf -22.08 -426.96 TD (11) Tj ET Q endstream endobj xref 1 2 0000300632 00000 n 0000300691 00000 n 82 7 0000300848 00000 n 0000301012 00000 n 0000309585 00000 n 0000301540 00000 n 0000301159 00000 n 0000301288 00000 n 0000301413 00000 n trailer << /Size 89 /Prev 300305 /Root 1 0 R >> startxref 310436 %%EOF % Page Description << /EndOffset 0000331379>> 1 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 2 0 R >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [3 0 R 10 0 R 17 0 R 24 0 R 31 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 49 0 R 56 0 R 63 0 R 70 0 R 75 0 R 82 0 R 89 0 R ] /Count 14 >> endobj 89 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 2 0 R /Resources 90 0 R /Contents 91 0 R /Rotate 0 /eCpyResolution 300 /MediaBox [0 0 612.00 792.00 ] >> endobj 90 0 obj << /XObject << /Im92 92 0 R>> /Font << /F93 93 0 R /F94 94 0 R /F95 95 0 R>> /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC ] >> endobj 93 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F93 /BaseFont /Times-Roman /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 94 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F94 /BaseFont /Courier /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 95 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Name /F95 /BaseFont /Helvetica /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding >> endobj 92 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Name /Im92 /Width 2550 /Height 3300 /eCpyDPIX 300 /eCpyDPIY 300 /ImageMask true /Filter /CCITTFaxDecode /BitsPerComponent 1 /DecodeParms << /K -1 /Columns 2550 /Rows 3300>> /eCpyColor [0 0 0 ] /Decode [0 1 ] /Length 17085 >> stream l)?VZ:"e9d$3:jDY.H3K0S8#p\dh9٨3*ӄED[aH Ѕ Ӏ \:p͠!&!}A_+\Eפa AK<T  :8d?C!8 h KvzIށm8h4 0DIIַn}_oMoTK_o}~uz]~?Tk׺ר85^_F0cեX:=_?ҵ`KK Z_ -o/Hz"_ȏ*~AVav#0%N?Szҽ}-_"" D630D ChÔ&j5&gO A$0g% 4C!H5Hdtַ%D᪢nEDݡ# p4M  @A5_B zX87;AXoI6 .sC 4 AXB|Jt`"S#8( a!F ! SN6GAH0g R j!|]h}2.CpD6 ҰI<&$(>BoKI g& Fa t a# F xA BaB` Az ׽ ]=CtV >W tnqitO h!O*n8񄂧.-;x*vSDUD턴^4,t.}oV7OO#tm'[h MƂ ӤN'z/ em +MnnBPAU+O_NڥM#N`=dn `~+m._Mni=U֯/v+IkWI,FXRܷ8_׶.UZz~_~_uw~_/]_/[IoD+ZIxD`upa\/Bۖ"bnz&A~C׿Yk^_ ?k_-?wc_KVKak_]aw^"d߯zI[\ []~J~{ %_wm.$^^*kzk_zD=뤲3kVHא/Kܑa\KIiXKm_kF-{ji-׵_#/-VilSG1_]5IHm'ҿҫk_^Ydp *ibN6#$$X4=&I^KnIMik߰뭴LSAA0dGM$0H9 =6m+I]A\0!5u!am.Mٵ_ DD&T0FP ;M{_MSi`Vl$ aH7b +a%)7Tة&ON@ حOnӊ ob"#B""" Tt; lP N)c6 m iGia$M0!GA6H0h DDDDDDDD'`;A\JH6(&mMB 'TMAL M4 PkIRqq& 2=0L w8a߆aaL,/pMi?U0S iHDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDkNI$^K]uUZKZqڦ `Q`XMCPem$D A3er0P[+:..L(QyD<8f"Ld>S?t(AmO AD?iASDXD4੣D f 0Й'A6 H:']$m@m& 7+oa?Jݭm?Z];mmu_vK'ث?׿zls H׽;_k_ֽI}__i]7YIAm,'L0IVa zi bqõb)4خ 0m*A ^M?MAwյ` "|"P"""4^JZ@M8-5S+̥Sc.)dx 閭h 4I> I[_Q ӿ_O͙6tA5!;0dp8D;egD=& ¡q=gi_D[&AxB"I&n* 8IZl(ڶ ?['Ҷ?䇡]:zCX_޿o$~|&_?m-}+A{Ka/ҼbH&ON*յ[])0 Ah   _Wl$lBN"""- yn=ڈҹih`; H AFԁSwPsVo9Ffv kD)E0@äJA݄L''*zhInnJ BLGR=i%pa'( aBK ɝK00AL&! lN)a&<Yi _! PZ{ 4A0C0@"""' 2zDǰ@L/kOB""""" ϰUQUGjr@MbadPaAihhIK=ѹ4uu}zum_o{Kڿ(p'2ڗ]k4M[_ T(6BApjbw M[Mj:ڈ0@,&?^X / "Т"""""""" -;wI`j њ!/%TDFhA%e8ɁqNDa` m aA5060@D@$NTMNZ[T 6O$&ѻ"]ʊH*ޓ뽺t]$'ߥ_zKWE_I1s6]6fү{4-bނ!Q<]뷦iB$;p LDOUe98ApBM蛆 Ņ 0C!$H[bq :4 hNFŰp8 WPwW3"KIna6Omtq>0it+W5W:XiNa׷KKu zۅ'jw[TUzlV,GaVV[~^{R=_zI+_W"m+[޽u])}a _p{amk/ZTK[^{u`V{mt0$9-&Zp6^ m a.#w +[ mz|Sa%} Aq@6!AVT 6i2Ј^EY\x0LpD~F=b0h4ڄ 4"""! DDDDD&NEF|wS>QS|i3hK""""$QHrnt9 q1* Tsw;9r1 w(F/#<_/|r.p<B"""""""""""#` !) Ζv(L;-h(KEnVX v4kb)x>334v)LPJ,i>v30CB SBLX:"C ւZtXn @4RAG| /HiA8A&pZ&VIZO}re-k A4F}SuN]k*+-u$_%ZWKFIj"΅E:g\槔*K֒MUT=0 Ղ `ȼKRC0IyO)B?OQ!-}F=g❐*..J7a &/& `BO" (ᚋٛ8| `>(AL f +oI^KA9_&A8u'ii$;IB$9eT$BBjTX㰉t/KtZM-%4ai8iɈKmPN:6}[INJA@MA`/WZHЪҤKA>4h"ނ]('hr.U)n𒮗*K҅i-+֒҄k_KZO /ת^-*]-IzK_Ҥ*I*I%k.*IqJҥ[ti*ZҖZ}iRjqJZZZIWUJT -tV_[B$ƾI%A-}}Zү_׮}|uIWZkIT~%Bu^A,BzZZI}}ZZW_B _"U$hRkTR^u֩**%-S-j$HJ_/ӥj#%UnT?SKK_^WTZ:_Ɍ]֕VZJ߯ץ^&VZiR>~V_#Z/J>]o3]Ui%֓&IR'WJ~uu0Ǧuz]wT~*M*]Aa-*U u'^I+TaUZ)yW1OTa*\?RK]-gXa'J8J R[.JWKJ鰓h'K-.jZkүKJpv* &!EvF!p%l#8I ]-+IiRZڥ_'_T$UI%_Vzp T*BbBa$.a `$l"TUE0}ZkK[).+D% |0AXL!<MPaT UMSUU1 b@J**i8i8 kQRՄAU5""""80B!X`&a0L& BqMu T]$ˆPU}qdHD&3  nUZ *a0L XM/R@Ͻ҈AqDkT,tvWK.$KJ{6 &qN#QG->4jdb!CChX0;AӴ ]0yخZD>UUVjI=οD;0AGDw]4PMJK&#G3+KK* \%IUTKtH"PIUuZAUR뺈/TTWX.k/ҭ~zzI}V1T-ftycZRAIiC i*ZZVZOLB B* kl @ B  T!: Ɍa2hDF*TGZeQggӀΘ) {#X.A\z!Epl>ј2 zvϋ ῿'/:8gR:"L &`TψHp!8q@v *_0T ᠃Ƌ蝰U#K[Zn> /~ :JB &]`'K΀_vtrNiup.k^:?__N=n _-7y#΋j￥_o.j}gmXKhaK iSb4a6 mXخ0!P rxAA;aVȮ0N &ADDDDL&TEaq-:#b#HZdBpf#A E;Y90u0@ @蝰x[lk*-Ge#tvצ.z]7V]O\׽KJa^!#4>)a #  xg(?߄M BmS`?i~M>Z7jnq40 Bko4 8׿N 'H i?տ|&i$2PuOOzkO 2}/}E_ߺQ|7*޷Z~aX*mwoW[woWǺWGd?߮1d(A7_Kڸg^IZa/ߦK =X6"}oױAh6 ئ$a.KAM ӈ /H0A% qDE aAL9DDDi%\yZJ?ZUa5R)  j NAЇP.> It6(I: tKlAhE Qm‹mKo޺^*/[ZݪtHEzÿF80@B!Nd]Au~ya?}$`Han|;Pnյ zAnLZ]o&SK]a/׳屷߳곢̨/Z//-8o濦zُk!.3 `_o 5 m;`?Q/ۺ3-hPA=oqMN '_AK_M#~ׯul1Kni[~K+}7ݍ,0_KZ [ۮKo߶IKد ?s{_ua"4WVUUץNHji7`~Yi!Ojkb;J=9=j|# $ڷ_D|0 (0I M6i]j!zzmxA!+a&J""i8a>&(1Q !̈́"wB  F9?}!haB+ z&i&HphC3 @>'{FXAXݪU> lA%J_M17\ A{z%x֮l*mN4wioZ5^=0:p}ROUKtWZOV~9<*}R[H9O_Qޒ蛿{T]_aW֯< wUyݦKU׆"n{(޷^oݥ4۾vJw *JM[Vmm/80ADA 0aG)iZ~MX=vܷ'a=Sa* $Ap e}{)ʀ0 V )4؈`a3O""""2Ӵ}фapDDD@k9!G0Øsw;sÙrTsSeV"""""""""""""@l+NB9!"B8Q9F2kjK]/߉՝R_K;_K gf  C5 [Zi.-VKDᮩZP>(O. pSuCvxD(NjC2:,"*4~sUa;z~7DݨL(CMRB`3 + B 83f#lόi~*iZm4h'hg ?.AB]-R﮴֩.UP'IT$#=+/J\U^zC*T4WJgIVKn%ΫKKѝ+RKXItb.(RI*~U=%^7UH$KIz\WKit}/_7ZU$8/ZmTuA-BUZ]/_ZU=b]RI%V?]ik ZTT_RUR^סִD*BJ-k^ZUAnIUUp_]*^R//HRWzۅZ|uz}U-t[iGJUZKIRZk4WVVZoU^JiUyU_ikZ^tǩ­/K_ֺFK>I/rBoKֽԞzYG?TcԿ_W­/_R 'I}*_IR~IRH%aUuqZ_TItcI-uS~1_R* VTR]6m/&]JW[ִ#\.-ujTzԹ8b*Xl%H3bD*` qXJ)u]%tҴwRZZTa.Kzpb5UMlR!5KLU1UQ qHV\TRg1TqQRqL0g׆HX)V a=5 Z kaA@ZbHa!"""#B"),& Aa5ªb$]SPaUUT*B_z"""""" `  ! %`B`x D'T- T""#B"""""?Җd̖.+bJ &j#? ӭm~ʼGbNSEiJA~_Mou&}Us(rc{R5-Cq ֪}zO]sOh?ӭS*WRK7_v&iDl_@]:O# {׫'nATO{UVW4>oVUt=Gޛ]5ڦ]Zz[ /ZO'Vkvuuo}%tOXKO}6iki?~[ % %i=1]+V.nl/M^?U^a]'V,z}¶j Pj_D޺W{"a =w{iu} S b0_0 C;&$% [_DM?1IޯPaIڲn_ p`&Q[I/(`OLSgJv44 a|S ;.b $hL4jU`/auA;Gea`+B|HC)pl_\XOԨƥGpr8R^!BzDDDD[RNtP:.##"T5ްSi^Pt lo Mv]4:]Ck_# ^A!ֿ %OՊ~>@0M:AƛM8M pA$ AAh!_V>?H㲚[\`p2f2)7…)-HX.wkvH88y>%tE]A;KoA; N#HGFSQJ~ `L&x%`ψ_W k}mT־_Ǭ_]{ui?Rt_,1哗O刂߂:"c_ At_Z ^6"EOWuF}͠omoS3Mߺ׵׽ :M6%ڑﰥՠp°tm/bؤ=Sb- &%i*~}ҶkM46B< at 000;J  }ȎdZ4ȎYa1Viq!2]0B& 0@" 9T+#eu&dt)L""""""""""""""?-j[@Ƞ[PH a2 Cs29NVAA# aE* mmh4JF{}-IqO[ӇޕÿFw[|3x<3q/%PgL sCM--mAzT TT,0P<4E8>u鰘O4kAM& =]輻MhqnaK 4|gaâEntBnAH7?.^N[oIjI{~G>o_߿K|~}&Iou܃`Xrt>1aVm[{}ý)Oޑ z^uwݮd>r~\VC솷k>{~zvwXjiw׶GIaշmS6i:Wn5]U/LVj0D0pA]E4vNA'vuZb7a44SZ &H0@ow0La{)80?^}""""""88a%)MUu(`lMt!T̵ `S2u[P*0@ ,0A > "vv'mn=2>h:i6t^@:/6i6ޖ$ ozt+z:mzmozC,ٝr5SKAA„"y {_t]]MD' ?ƿ$Ar0MxDDC030G]W^-Xa(X (0Qk[\e L̗2 ]# QlT ` 0@ B(u $&& _8:A4m6L PERoIpDHtu6ۄ66$'I-uִҦKk:Ψ֏Z꾒ￂ `SLb=cڍ%ZBL &Ux]մ.ދQx¦u $҆A7l Otnj-$!1]_Wk`Ӻka MV_X'R>a?wKZ{]:im:o] Tl*l pzXt6c刾/E_/Ku#i*A?t/7WIz^?D]6}I/eBoWt"$^H}ta/sDD?Tz.}JRK m׵G5DWh$I崌^ j)7i*N]"ݭ5Gֈ?Zg|x"#`v@B`L `a38!tА,(D,BdYiJr]vBM~n!QCpv鷒ss t Bv.~jM7ui%+t]uk_j{K__;O}J]um{U%꿷_l%_үVWmbL1O[_鶚בZuݲFۮ'jj;WHvͯ?65a4Jn6Os|UqGO`AZ 6EEl%V ؠA[)VAQ3L (sØx2A 'l5DDDDDDDDDDDDDE@m`dpG 0i!3VB huM 62dAQ 3A b5 dm= @` p&Dxi&m&oȟE[I~H'o]*uov?U}_^hii_zpd dQߒ$F tpMPhkXA@Hm&> stream q q 612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm 0.00 0.00 0.00 rg /Im92 Do Q Q q BT 3 Tr /F93 12.84 Tf 227.04 702.48 TD (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) Tj /F93 12.00 Tf -118.56 -27.12 TD (I hereby certify that on March 6,2009, I served the foregoing via electronic mail on the) Tj /F94 8.18 Tf -36.00 -13.92 TD (following counsel:) Tj /F93 11.99 Tf 143.52 -28.08 TD (John A. Herfort) Tj /F93 11.93 Tf 0.24 -13.92 TD (Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP) Tj /F93 11.96 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (200 Park Avenue) Tj /F93 11.92 Tf -.24 -13.92 TD (New York, NY 10166-0193) Tj /F95 10.79 Tf -.24 -13.92 TD (Jherfort\(g gibsondunn.com) Tj /F93 11.88 Tf 0.72 -27.60 TD (Counsel for Defendant CCC Holdings, Inc. And Christopher A.) Tj /F93 10.72 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (Vellturo, . PhD.) Tj /F95 10.92 Tf -.96 -27.60 TD (Richard G. Parker) Tj /F93 11.87 Tf 0.24 -13.68 TD (O'Melveny & Myers LLP) Tj /F93 11.87 Tf 0.96 -13.92 TD (1625 Eye Street, NW) Tj /F93 12.01 Tf -1.20 -13.68 TD (Washington, DC 20006) Tj /F93 12.15 Tf 0.24 -13.68 TD (Rparker\(gomm.com) Tj /F93 12.06 Tf 0.48 -27.84 TD (Counsel for Defendant Aurora Equity Partners III L.P.) Tj /F93 11.13 Tf 71.52 -55.20 TD (By:) Tj /F93 8.63 Tf 85.68 22.32 TD (.) Tj /F93 68.13 Tf -55.20 -23.76 TD (~~V\\) Tj /F93 12.63 Tf 5.76 -12.48 TD (Terri Marin) Tj /F93 11.97 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (鶹ý Trade Commission) Tj /F93 11.96 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (601 New Jersey Avenue, N.W) Tj /F93 11.89 Tf -.24 -13.68 TD (Washington, D.C. 20001) Tj /F95 11.09 Tf 0.00 -13.68 TD (Telephone: \(202\) 326-3488) Tj /F93 5.00 Tf 0.00 -13.92 TD (tmaitin ) Tj 36.00 0.00 TD (\(gftc. ) Tj 25.92 0.00 TD (gov ) Tj /F93 11.95 Tf -314.64 -26.64 TD (Dated: March 6, 2009) Tj /F93 10.56 Tf 229.68 -193.68 TD (12) Tj ET Q endstream endobj 96 0 obj << /Title (CPY Document) >> endobj xref 1 2 0000310763 00000 n 0000310822 00000 n 89 8 0000310986 00000 n 0000311150 00000 n 0000329096 00000 n 0000311678 00000 n 0000311297 00000 n 0000311426 00000 n 0000311551 00000 n 0000330963 00000 n trailer << /Size 97 /Prev 310436 /Root 1 0 R /Info 96 0 R /ID [(243144275144011390) (315192303265684381) ] >> startxref 331015 %%EOF 1 0 obj <>/ViewerPreferences<>/Metadata 1100 0 R/Pages 2 0 R/StructTreeRoot 869 0 R/Type/Catalog/Lang(EN-US)>> endobj 3 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 10 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 17 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 24 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 31 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 38 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 43 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 49 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 56 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 63 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 70 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 75 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 82 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 89 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]>>/Type/Page>> endobj 97 0 obj <> endobj 98 0 obj <> endobj 99 0 obj <> endobj 100 0 obj <> endobj 101 0 obj <> endobj 102 0 obj <> endobj 103 0 obj <> endobj 104 0 obj <> endobj 105 0 obj <> endobj 106 0 obj <> endobj 107 0 obj <> endobj 108 0 obj <> endobj 109 0 obj <> endobj 110 0 obj <> endobj 111 0 obj <> endobj 116 0 obj <> endobj 117 0 obj <> endobj 118 0 obj <> endobj 119 0 obj <> endobj 120 0 obj <> endobj 121 0 obj <> endobj 122 0 obj <> endobj 123 0 obj <> endobj 124 0 obj <> endobj 125 0 obj <> endobj 126 0 obj <> endobj 127 0 obj <> endobj 128 0 obj <> endobj 129 0 obj <> endobj 130 0 obj <> endobj 131 0 obj <> endobj 132 0 obj <> endobj 135 0 obj <> endobj 136 0 obj [1/space] endobj 161 0 obj <> endobj 162 0 obj [871 0 R 872 0 R 873 0 R 876 0 R 877 0 R 878 0 R 880 0 R 881 0 R 884 0 R 885 0 R 886 0 R 888 0 R 889 0 R 893 0 R 895 0 R 896 0 R 897 0 R 897 0 R 898 0 R 899 0 R 900 0 R 901 0 R 902 0 R 903 0 R 904 0 R 905 0 R] endobj 204 0 obj <>/CM11<>/CM12<>/CM13<>/CM14<>/CM15<>/CM16<>/CM17<>/CM18<>/CM19<>/CM20<>/CM21<>/CM22<>/CM23<>/CM1<>/CM2<>/CM3<>/CM4<>/CM5<>/CM6<>/CM7<>/CM8<>/CM9<>>> endobj 205 0 obj <> endobj 207 0 obj <> endobj 211 0 obj <> endobj 212 0 obj [1/space] endobj 225 0 obj <> endobj 226 0 obj [1/space] endobj 231 0 obj [906 0 R 907 0 R 908 0 R 909 0 R 910 0 R 911 0 R 912 0 R 913 0 R 914 0 R 915 0 R 916 0 R 917 0 R 918 0 R 919 0 R] endobj 247 0 obj <> endobj 248 0 obj <> endobj 253 0 obj <> endobj 254 0 obj [1/space] endobj 262 0 obj <> endobj 264 0 obj <> endobj 265 0 obj [1/space] endobj 271 0 obj [920 0 R 921 0 R 922 0 R 923 0 R 924 0 R 925 0 R 926 0 R 927 0 R 928 0 R 929 0 R 930 0 R 931 0 R 932 0 R] endobj 286 0 obj <> endobj 287 0 obj <> endobj 288 0 obj <> endobj 291 0 obj <> endobj 296 0 obj <> endobj 297 0 obj [1/space] endobj 303 0 obj <> endobj 304 0 obj [1/space] endobj 309 0 obj [933 0 R 934 0 R 935 0 R 936 0 R 937 0 R 937 0 R 938 0 R 939 0 R 940 0 R 941 0 R 941 0 R 942 0 R 943 0 R] endobj 326 0 obj <> endobj 327 0 obj <> endobj 328 0 obj <> endobj 336 0 obj <> endobj 337 0 obj [1/space] endobj 353 0 obj [944 0 R 945 0 R 946 0 R 947 0 R 948 0 R 949 0 R 950 0 R 950 0 R 951 0 R 952 0 R 953 0 R 954 0 R 955 0 R 956 0 R 957 0 R 958 0 R 959 0 R 960 0 R 961 0 R] endobj 375 0 obj <> endobj 376 0 obj <> endobj 377 0 obj <> endobj 379 0 obj <> endobj 380 0 obj [1/space] endobj 387 0 obj [962 0 R 963 0 R 964 0 R] endobj 392 0 obj <> endobj 394 0 obj <> endobj 395 0 obj [1/space] endobj 398 0 obj <> endobj 399 0 obj [1/space] endobj 402 0 obj <> endobj 403 0 obj <> endobj 404 0 obj <> endobj 410 0 obj [965 0 R 966 0 R 967 0 R 968 0 R 969 0 R 970 0 R 971 0 R 972 0 R] endobj 420 0 obj <> endobj 421 0 obj <> endobj 422 0 obj <> endobj 428 0 obj <> endobj 429 0 obj [1/space] endobj 441 0 obj [973 0 R 974 0 R 975 0 R 976 0 R 977 0 R 977 0 R 978 0 R 979 0 R 980 0 R 981 0 R 982 0 R 983 0 R 984 0 R 985 0 R] endobj 458 0 obj <> endobj 459 0 obj <> endobj 460 0 obj <> endobj 462 0 obj <> endobj 463 0 obj [1/space] endobj 466 0 obj <> endobj 470 0 obj <> endobj 471 0 obj <> endobj 472 0 obj [1/space] endobj 476 0 obj <> endobj 480 0 obj [986 0 R 987 0 R 988 0 R 989 0 R 990 0 R 991 0 R 992 0 R 993 0 R 994 0 R 995 0 R] endobj 492 0 obj <> endobj 493 0 obj <> endobj 494 0 obj <> endobj 496 0 obj <> endobj 497 0 obj [1/space] endobj 504 0 obj <> endobj 508 0 obj <> endobj 509 0 obj <> endobj 510 0 obj [1/space] endobj 516 0 obj [996 0 R 996 0 R 997 0 R 998 0 R 999 0 R 1000 0 R 1001 0 R 1002 0 R 1003 0 R 1003 0 R 1004 0 R 1005 0 R 1006 0 R] endobj 533 0 obj <> endobj 534 0 obj [1/space] endobj 539 0 obj [1008 0 R] endobj 543 0 obj <> endobj 544 0 obj <> endobj 545 0 obj [1/space] endobj 547 0 obj <> endobj 552 0 obj <> endobj 554 0 obj <> endobj 555 0 obj <> endobj 556 0 obj <> endobj 557 0 obj [1/space] endobj 562 0 obj [1009 0 R 1010 0 R 1011 0 R 1013 0 R 1014 0 R 1014 0 R 1015 0 R 1016 0 R 1017 0 R 1018 0 R 1019 0 R 1020 0 R] endobj 579 0 obj <> endobj 580 0 obj [1/space] endobj 583 0 obj <> endobj 584 0 obj [1/space] endobj 586 0 obj <> endobj 587 0 obj <> endobj 588 0 obj [1/space] endobj 594 0 obj [1021 0 R 1023 0 R 1024 0 R 1024 0 R 1025 0 R 1026 0 R 1027 0 R 1028 0 R null] endobj 609 0 obj <> endobj 610 0 obj [1/space] endobj 613 0 obj <> endobj 622 0 obj <> endobj 626 0 obj <> endobj 627 0 obj [1/space] endobj 632 0 obj [1029 0 R 1030 0 R 1031 0 R 1032 0 R 1033 0 R 1034 0 R 1036 0 R 1037 0 R 1038 0 R 1040 0 R 1041 0 R 1043 0 R 1044 0 R 1045 0 R 1046 0 R 1047 0 R null] endobj 823 0 obj <> endobj 824 0 obj <> endobj 825 0 obj <> endobj 826 0 obj <> endobj 827 0 obj <> endobj 828 0 obj <> endobj 829 0 obj <> endobj 830 0 obj <> endobj 831 0 obj <> endobj 832 0 obj <> endobj 833 0 obj <> endobj 834 0 obj <> endobj 835 0 obj <> endobj 836 0 obj <> endobj 837 0 obj <> endobj 838 0 obj <> endobj 839 0 obj <> endobj 840 0 obj <> endobj 841 0 obj <> endobj 842 0 obj <> endobj 843 0 obj <> endobj 844 0 obj <> endobj 845 0 obj <> endobj 846 0 obj <> endobj 847 0 obj <> endobj 848 0 obj <> endobj 849 0 obj <> endobj 850 0 obj <> endobj 851 0 obj <> endobj 852 0 obj <> endobj 853 0 obj <> endobj 854 0 obj <> endobj 855 0 obj <> endobj 856 0 obj <> endobj 857 0 obj <> endobj 858 0 obj <> endobj 859 0 obj <> endobj 860 0 obj <> endobj 861 0 obj <> endobj 862 0 obj <> endobj 863 0 obj <> endobj 864 0 obj <> endobj 865 0 obj <> endobj 866 0 obj <> endobj 869 0 obj <> endobj 870 0 obj <> endobj 871 0 obj <> endobj 872 0 obj <> endobj 873 0 obj <> endobj 874 0 obj <> endobj 875 0 obj <> endobj 876 0 obj <> endobj 877 0 obj <> endobj 878 0 obj <> endobj 879 0 obj <> endobj 880 0 obj <> endobj 881 0 obj <> endobj 882 0 obj <> endobj 883 0 obj <> endobj 884 0 obj <> endobj 885 0 obj <> endobj 886 0 obj <> endobj 887 0 obj <> endobj 888 0 obj <> endobj 889 0 obj <> endobj 890 0 obj <> endobj 891 0 obj <> endobj 892 0 obj <> endobj 893 0 obj <> endobj 894 0 obj <> endobj 895 0 obj <> endobj 896 0 obj <> endobj 897 0 obj <> endobj 898 0 obj <> endobj 899 0 obj <> endobj 900 0 obj <> endobj 901 0 obj <> endobj 902 0 obj <> endobj 903 0 obj <> endobj 904 0 obj <> endobj 905 0 obj <> endobj 906 0 obj <> endobj 907 0 obj <> endobj 908 0 obj <> endobj 909 0 obj <> endobj 910 0 obj <> endobj 911 0 obj <> endobj 912 0 obj <> endobj 913 0 obj <> endobj 914 0 obj <> endobj 915 0 obj <> endobj 916 0 obj <> endobj 917 0 obj <> endobj 918 0 obj <> endobj 919 0 obj <> endobj 920 0 obj <> endobj 921 0 obj <> endobj 922 0 obj <> endobj 923 0 obj <> endobj 924 0 obj <> endobj 925 0 obj <> endobj 926 0 obj <> endobj 927 0 obj <> endobj 928 0 obj <> endobj 929 0 obj <> endobj 930 0 obj <> endobj 931 0 obj <> endobj 932 0 obj <> endobj 933 0 obj <> endobj 934 0 obj <> endobj 935 0 obj <> endobj 936 0 obj <> endobj 937 0 obj <> endobj 938 0 obj <> endobj 939 0 obj <> endobj 940 0 obj <> endobj 941 0 obj <> endobj 942 0 obj <> endobj 943 0 obj <> endobj 944 0 obj <> endobj 945 0 obj <> endobj 946 0 obj <> endobj 947 0 obj <> endobj 948 0 obj <> endobj 949 0 obj <> endobj 950 0 obj <> endobj 951 0 obj <> endobj 952 0 obj <> endobj 953 0 obj <> endobj 954 0 obj <> endobj 955 0 obj <> endobj 956 0 obj <> endobj 957 0 obj <> endobj 958 0 obj <> endobj 959 0 obj <> endobj 960 0 obj <> endobj 961 0 obj <> endobj 962 0 obj <> endobj 963 0 obj <> endobj 964 0 obj <> endobj 965 0 obj <> endobj 966 0 obj <> endobj 967 0 obj <> endobj 968 0 obj <> endobj 969 0 obj <> endobj 970 0 obj <> endobj 971 0 obj <> endobj 972 0 obj <> endobj 973 0 obj <> endobj 974 0 obj <> endobj 975 0 obj <> endobj 976 0 obj <> endobj 977 0 obj <> endobj 978 0 obj <> endobj 979 0 obj <> endobj 980 0 obj <> endobj 981 0 obj <> endobj 982 0 obj <> endobj 983 0 obj <> endobj 984 0 obj <> endobj 985 0 obj <> endobj 986 0 obj <> endobj 987 0 obj <> endobj 988 0 obj <> endobj 989 0 obj <> endobj 990 0 obj <> endobj 991 0 obj <> endobj 992 0 obj <> endobj 993 0 obj <> endobj 994 0 obj <> endobj 995 0 obj <> endobj 996 0 obj <> endobj 997 0 obj <> endobj 998 0 obj <> endobj 999 0 obj <> endobj 1000 0 obj <> endobj 1001 0 obj <> endobj 1002 0 obj <> endobj 1003 0 obj <> endobj 1004 0 obj <> endobj 1005 0 obj <> endobj 1006 0 obj <> endobj 1007 0 obj <> endobj 1008 0 obj <> endobj 1009 0 obj <> endobj 1010 0 obj <> endobj 1011 0 obj <> endobj 1012 0 obj <> endobj 1013 0 obj <> endobj 1014 0 obj <> endobj 1015 0 obj <> endobj 1016 0 obj <> endobj 1017 0 obj <> endobj 1018 0 obj <> endobj 1019 0 obj <> endobj 1020 0 obj <> endobj 1021 0 obj <> endobj 1022 0 obj <> endobj 1023 0 obj <> endobj 1024 0 obj <> endobj 1025 0 obj <> endobj 1026 0 obj <> endobj 1027 0 obj <> endobj 1028 0 obj <> endobj 1029 0 obj <> endobj 1030 0 obj <> endobj 1031 0 obj <> endobj 1032 0 obj <> endobj 1033 0 obj <> endobj 1034 0 obj <> endobj 1035 0 obj <> endobj 1036 0 obj <> endobj 1037 0 obj <> endobj 1038 0 obj <> endobj 1039 0 obj <> endobj 1040 0 obj <> endobj 1041 0 obj <> endobj 1042 0 obj <> endobj 1043 0 obj <> endobj 1044 0 obj <> endobj 1045 0 obj <> endobj 1046 0 obj <> endobj 1047 0 obj <> endobj 1048 0 obj <>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 1049 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1050 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1051 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1052 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1053 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1054 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1055 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1056 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1057 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1058 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1059 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1060 0 obj <>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 1061 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1062 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1063 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1064 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1065 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1066 0 obj <>stream H\͎0 gn&mĘż}}.dzEg|n||1bnhxsݐ M24,Ie~5t}}zzh?&Ymn ״6xOa1V.<uMϻd coS\טUMն,k[\Zy;6@S`GSI=^AP$(^VBpQ FHh ڿTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTQE!lzΪ:@ց$;(Kt(KʒH;"eIw(,V{t#a]t#NvЍAHn$,rx\%, (ټT={mI~+GA^a9K˯9^[9Qg/W<{{HWQ_?=s<& 'ۈ yNLƤ .Nnot'2e0tez endstream endobj 1067 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1068 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1069 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1070 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1071 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1072 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1073 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1074 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1075 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1076 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1077 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1078 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1079 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1080 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1081 0 obj <>stream H\0E/gE|@b .bڪ7" ! }}_ ±+_}7x41]/1&sL/Li&a(|~y߷ϼxw5ISghIcן/~]6 oX!ݼoL$K`J4:ПRvgm+Rf6̱՛mgvV <<)&X+!(PT +G *4 $@K ( ; ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (**fs(s!l%qAY΂$,,#PD~džjGM7EA7ήdHXlЍD Fb-\¢kU߳ _,r˯sGʀ\#%0a/{%{K9y){yUγ_Ѻg/ x>98\8>Tc_2"elqJu}e)?E.c endstream endobj 1082 0 obj <>stream H\0E @zmfӸ$=MRI.;7Iؘ<*/MuNGu~,Ȩ-􃛋2[c7)ʗn˫zeQP!vEm q[Z2w)ͤm/nꆨŋJ~?ōX4Z麶coMk'7]h ;88*jZ `pN+UA  >*H რ >*H რ >*H რ >*H0PQ6"$Pc@cdqMKՐšH;"dqw v{pápaw H;,ph:=qu4TG浨oj5\,z٣8rv/H >^#es9@/AE/Kˊrl.8]%3&cr``(_4xL”6Ii)>Ed endstream endobj 1083 0 obj <>stream H\0E/"fHb V>8T(W؎|c&1 gv}3pB4x 4]oZYosv0]Lyz7/.N_g6˿OMb^~7^c?+d_F?# `Fxlgvžo̹՛mONlx%xU`KU (( J*JO jgAP!hQ@P>@@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>@P>UͦlWrQYC:PceI8 *ʒ𲃲$ҎH@YeUxn$ n$(ЍD Fb+\¢+U߳ _V,roKGJR#%a/{%{k9y){yUγ_Ѻg/xz%3'crpp=SOS^2ehqJu}|NqyʤO}`1\b/ endstream endobj 1084 0 obj <>stream H\0E3_gX.ŴUΞ!MRi2}"WF'˟_}74cMm ќ38ta^IK=fy:||rvY3-^<|o܅}4Mlĩ~xǷxl~Yx~o%\Ir04:!Nuڽٵ>}ߚ)6˙S7'f#p l6 <<)%*P A' ' (4 D@K ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (*Jfs+(s T!l(K⾃$MN$,,#PDzGA@YUޣ  g7n$, t#vx=F~u6(bJll׶y[uR.`/k{I8,G˯@^~-GɞZN^^^rK"^^G ̉r.~*ܦ)/28>~LqyʤO}+7dL endstream endobj 1085 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 12.84 0 0 12.84 227.04 702.48 Tm (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 12 0 0 12 108.48 675.36 Tm (I hereby certify that on March 6,2009, I served the foregoing via electr\ onic mail on the )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 8.18 0 0 8.18 72.48 661.44 Tm (following counsel:\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 216 633.36 Tm (John A. Herfort )Tj 11.93 0 0 11.93 216.24 619.44 Tm (Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 216.24 605.76 Tm (200 Park Avenue )Tj 11.92 0 0 11.92 216 591.84 Tm (New York, NY 10166-0193 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.79 0 0 10.79 215.76 577.92 Tm (Jherfort\(g gibsondunn.com )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.88 0 0 11.88 216.48 550.32 Tm (Counsel for Defendant CCC Holdings, Inc. And Christopher A. )Tj 10.72 0 0 10.72 216.48 536.64 Tm (Vellturo, . PhD. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.92 0 0 10.92 215.52 509.04 Tm (Richard G. Parker )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.87 0 0 11.87 215.76 495.36 Tm (O'Melveny & Myers LLP )Tj 0.081 -1.173 Td (1625 Eye Street, NW )Tj 12.01 0 0 12.01 215.52 467.76 Tm (Washington, DC 20006 )Tj 12.15 0 0 12.15 215.76 454.08 Tm (Rparker\(gomm.com )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 12.06 0 0 12.06 216.24 426.24 Tm (Counsel for Defendant Aurora Equity Partners III L.P. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 8.63 0 0 8.63 373.44 393.36 Tm (.)Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.13 0 0 11.13 287.76 371.04 Tm (By: )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 68.13 0 0 68.13 318.24 369.6 Tm (~~V\\ )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 12.63 0 0 12.63 324 357.12 Tm (Terri Marin )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 324 343.44 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 324 329.52 Tm (601 New Jersey Avenue, N.W )Tj 11.89 0 0 11.89 323.76 315.84 Tm (Washington, D.C. 20001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 11.09 0 0 11.09 323.76 302.16 Tm (Telephone: \(202\) 326-3488 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 323.76 288.24 Tm [(tmaitin )-4116(\(gftc. )-2796(gov )]TJ EMC /P <>BDC 11.95 0 0 11.95 71.04 261.6 Tm (Dated: March 6, 2009 )Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 10.56 0 0 10.56 300.72 67.92 Tm (12\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1086 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 11.92 0 0 11.92 70.8 701.28 Tm (Dated: March 6, 2009 )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 8.19 0 0 8.19 322.56 701.28 Tm (Respectfully submitted, )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 59.62 0 0 59.62 323.04 645.84 Tm (By:3~~\001 )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 12.77 0 0 12.77 322.8 618 Tm (J.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( ROBERT ROBERTSON Dfj,\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.99 0 0 11.99 323.04 604.32 Tm (鶹ý Trade Commission\001 )Tj 11.97 0 0 11.97 323.04 590.64 Tm (Bureau of Competition\001 )Tj 0 -1.163 TD (600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW\001 )Tj 11.96 0 0 11.96 323.04 562.8 Tm (Washington, DC 20580\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.83 0 0 10.83 323.04 549.12 Tm (Telephone: \(202\) 326-2008\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.92 0 0 11.92 323.04 535.2 Tm (Fax: \(202\) 326-2884\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 0.02 -3.463 Td (Complaint Counsel )Tj EMC /Artifact <>BDC 9.6 0 0 9.6 301.2 66.96 Tm (11\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1087 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 9.31 0 0 9.31 230.88 624.48 Tm (UNITED STATE DISTRICT COURT )Tj 9.7 0 0 9.7 228.96 613.92 Tm (NORTHERN DISTCT OF ILLINOIS )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 8.19 0 0 8.19 260.4 603.84 Tm (.EASTERN DIVISION\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 8.29 0 0 8.29 137.52 573.84 Tm (CCC Infonnation Serices Inc., )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 9.15 0 0 9.15 214.8 553.44 Tm (Plaintiff )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 8.32 0 0 8.32 162.48 533.76 Tm (v. )Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC 8.43 0 0 8.43 317.52 533.04 Tm (Case No. 03 C 2695 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 7.95 0 0 7.95 136.56 513.6 Tm (MitcheIJ International, Inc., )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 8.59 0 0 8.59 213.84 493.44 Tm (Defendants. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 5 0 0 5 169.92 419.76 Tm (EXPERT )Tj 8.4 -0.048 Td (REPORT )Tj 8.784 -0.096 Td (OF )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.54 0 0 10.54 271.2 419.28 Tm (DR. CHRlSTOPHERA. VELLTURO )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 11.49 0 0 11.49 226.32 271.2 Tm (REDACTED ENTIRE REPORT\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.46 0 0 11.46 467.76 33.84 Tm (PX0837 -001\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1088 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 57.88 0 0 57.88 180.96 449.76 Tm (ANNEX A\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1089 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 9.27 0 0 9.27 118.56 692.16 Tm (D.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( Respondents Fail To Meet Their Burden In Establishin2 That The\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 12.4 0 0 12.4 153.36 678.48 Tm (Subpoena's Infrin~e On Dr. VeIlturo's Proprietary Interests. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.62 0 0 11.62 118.32 651.84 Tm (In Dr. Vellturo's motion, counsel argues that the subpoenas infrnge on D\ r. Vellturo's )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 83.52 625.44 Tm (proprietary interests, and argue that he is an unretained expert whose "\ opinion and information )Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 83.76 598.8 Tm (do not in any way describe the specific occurences in dispute and who wa\ s not retained by any )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 83.28 572.4 Tm (party for puiposes of )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.67 0 0 11.67 182.88 571.92 Tm (this case." )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.26 0 0 10.26 247.92 535.2 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.51 0 0 11.51 366 518.4 Tm (Second, Complaint Counsel accepts )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 82.8 492.96 Tm (that Dr. Vellturo was not retained by any pary for purposes of )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 11.2 0 0 11.2 374.16 492.24 Tm (this case. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.22 0 0 10.22 283.2 420.48 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC 12.27 0 0 12.27 259.68 359.76 Tm (III.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( CONCLUSION )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.55 0 0 11.55 116.16 333.6 Tm (For the foregoing reasons, Complaint Counsel respectfully requests that \ Respondents' )Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 81.6 307.2 Tm (and Dr. V elltuo' s Motion to Quash the Subpoena Duces Tecum and Supoena\ Ad Testifcandum )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 9.87 0 0 9.87 81.12 280.56 Tm (be denied. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.08 0 0 10.08 301.68 80.4 Tm (10\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1090 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 5 0 0 5 83.52 692.4 Tm ("general, unsupported claim \(of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.97 0 0 10.97 232.8 692.16 Tm (burden\)." Kaiser Alum., 1976 FTC LEXIS, 68, at *18. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 83.52 665.52 Tm (Complaint Counsel is merely seeking to obtain a copy of those documents \ listed in Exhibit 2, )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 83.04 639.12 Tm (which were used by Dr. Vellturo in December 2006, only 26 months ago. In\ addition, )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 82.8 612.24 Tm (Respondents argue that the benefit and usefulness of )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 11.62 0 0 11.62 329.04 612 Tm (those documents are "too slight to justify )Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 82.8 585.6 Tm (the burden and expense" on Dr. Vellturo, and that any evidence he could \ provide "would have )Tj -0.021 -2.278 Td (nothing to do with the facts and issues in this antitrust case." )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.31 0 0 10.31 106.32 515.76 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.59 0 0 11.59 289.68 506.16 Tm (This case is about the loss of competition that would )Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 82.32 479.76 Tm (result from a 3-to-2 merger between CCC and Mitchell. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.26 0 0 10.26 281.76 354 Tm (REDACTED\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.63 0 0 11.63 396.24 187.44 Tm (These issues, and thus, the )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 80.16 160.8 Tm (documents and data Complaint Counsel seeks, are not only relevant, but r\ ather, go to the hear of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 8.08 0 0 8.08 80.16 133.92 Tm (Complaint Counsel's antitrst case. Based on the foregoing, Respondents a\ nd Dr. Vellturo's )Tj 5 0 0 5 79.68 107.28 Tm (claims of )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 11.51 0 0 11.51 125.76 107.28 Tm (undue burden should be rejected. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.56 0 0 10.56 303.6 81.12 Tm (9\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1091 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 11.55 0 0 11.55 123.12 692.4 Tm (Thus, it would be a "reasonable" expectation that the documents and info\ rmation sought )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 83.04 665.76 Tm (by Complaint Counsel's subpoena's would "yield information relevant to t\ he allegations of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.2 0 0 11.2 507.36 666.24 Tm (the )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.65 0 0 11.65 83.28 639.12 Tm (complaint." )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.22 0 0 10.22 282.72 580.8 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 117.6 506.4 Tm (C.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( Respondents And Dr. Velluro Have Failed To Support Their Claim Of\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 12.37 0 0 12.37 152.4 493.2 Tm (Undue Burden. )Tj 11.56 0 0 11.56 117.36 466.8 Tm (Respondents and Dr. Vellturo argue in their motions that Complaint Couns\ el's subpoena )Tj 11.51 0 0 11.51 82.32 440.4 Tm (would cause an undue hardsh\355p to Dr. Vellturo and would impose a burd\ en that would far )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.89 0 0 10.89 82.56 413.76 Tm (outweigh any likely benefit. In re General Motors Coi:., No 9077, i 977 \ FTC LEXIS 18, at * i )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.66 0 0 11.66 82.32 384.96 Tm (\(Nov. 25, 1977\), states that, "seeking relevant data wil not be quashe\ d on the grounds that the )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 81.84 360.72 Tm (burden is imposed on a third pary, especially where the pary initiating \ the subpoena has )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 82.08 334.08 Tm (expressed a wilingness to mitigate whatever burden may exist by negotiat\ ion and compromise." )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 81.6 307.44 Tm (In addition, In re Kaiser Alum. & Chem. Corp., No 9080, 1976 FTC LEXIS 6\ 8, at *18, states )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.4 0 0 10.4 81.36 281.04 Tm (that "a general, unsupported claim \( of burden\) is not persuasive." )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.67 0 0 11.67 116.16 254.4 Tm (Complaint Counsel's subpoena duces tecum issued to Dr. Velltuo contains \ one, single )Tj 11.65 0 0 11.65 80.88 228 Tm (request. That request is for a copy of all documents and data cited by D\ r. Vellturo, and all )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 80.88 201.12 Tm (documents and data relied upon by Dr. Velluro, in his expert report. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.26 0 0 10.26 102.24 157.2 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.57 0 0 11.57 261.12 147.36 Tm (Respondent does not submit any detailed evidence on the )Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 80.4 120.96 Tm (cost and burden of searching for those documents listed in Exhibit 2, bu\ t rather, makes a )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 9.12 0 0 9.12 304.08 81.36 Tm (8 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1092 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 10.17 0 0 10.17 282 627.36 Tm (REDACTED\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 116.64 426.72 Tm (These issues go to the very hear of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.68 0 0 11.68 282.72 426.48 Tm (Complaint Counsel's case. As noted above, this case )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 82.32 400.08 Tm (is about a merger between CCC and Mitchell. There is only one other sign\ ificant competitor -)Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 81.84 373.44 Tm (Audatex - in the estimatics and TL V markets. This 3-to-2 merger would c\ reate a duopoly, )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.48 0 0 11.48 473.04 347.04 Tm (monopoly )Tj 11.46 0 0 11.46 81.36 320.4 Tm (or near-monopoly market power. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 81.6 346.8 Tm (leading to coordination, as well as a company with huge market shares, r\ eflective of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 10.22 0 0 10.22 282.96 259.68 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.58 0 0 11.58 114.96 135.6 Tm (9 Vellturo Report, PX0837-017. )Tj 11.39 0 0 11.39 115.68 110.64 Tm (10 Vellturo Reiport, PX0837-014. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.08 0 0 10.08 303.12 81.36 Tm (7\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1093 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 10.22 0 0 10.22 281.52 630.96 Tm (REDACTED\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.5 0 0 11.5 115.92 186.24 Tm (5 Vellturo Report, PX0837-019. )Tj 11.52 0 0 11.52 115.44 161.04 Tm (6 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003. )Tj 0 -2.167 TD (7 Vellturo Report, PX0837-015. )Tj 11.5 0 0 11.5 115.44 111.12 Tm (8 Vellturo Report, PX0837-016. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.08 0 0 10.08 303.36 81.6 Tm (6\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1094 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 11.61 0 0 11.61 84.24 693.12 Tm (the request\(s\) \(are\) unreasonable." In re Rambus. Inc., No 9302, 200\ 2 FTC LEXIS 90, at *9 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.43 0 0 11.43 84.48 664.08 Tm (\(Nov. 18, 2002\) \(denying motions to quash a subpoena in an FTC adj ud\ icative proceeding\). )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.7 0 0 10.7 84.24 639.6 Tm (Moreover, that burden is "heavy." In re Flowers Industries. Inc., No. 91\ 48, 1982 FTC LEXIS )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.61 0 0 11.61 84.24 612.96 Tm (96, at *15 \(March 19, 1982\) \(denying motions to quash third-pary subp\ oenas in FTC anti-)Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.62 0 0 11.62 83.76 586.32 Tm (merger action.\). For the reasons discussed below, neither Dr. Vellturo \ nor Respondents have )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.45 0 0 11.45 83.76 559.92 Tm (satisfied this heavy burden. )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 9.3 0 0 9.3 117.84 533.28 Tm (B.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( Dr. Vellturo's Expert Report And The Information He Relied Upon To\001 \ )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 12.4 0 0 12.4 152.88 520.08 Tm (Prepare It Are Relevant To The Antitrust Case Before This Court. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.68 0 0 11.68 117.36 493.68 Tm (Respondents and Dr. Velltuo argue in their motions that Dr. Vellturo's e\ xpert report, and )Tj 11.65 0 0 11.65 82.8 467.28 Tm (the documents and information he relied upon in its preparation, are irr\ elevant. Commission )Tj 11.42 0 0 11.42 82.56 440.88 Tm (Rule of Practice \247 3.31 \(c \)\(1\) states that, "Parties may obtain \ discovery to the extent that it may )Tj 11.57 0 0 11.57 82.56 414.24 Tm (be reasonably expected to yield information relevant to the allegations \ of the complaint, to the )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 82.32 387.84 Tm (proposed relief, or to the defenses of any respondent." Moreover, "\(t\)\ he practice of )Tj /T1_0 1 Tf 11.39 0 0 11.39 471.36 386.64 Tm (the )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.64 0 0 11.64 82.56 360.96 Tm (Commission has been to uphold subpoenas duces tecum upon a showing. . . \ that the requested )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.61 0 0 11.61 82.08 334.56 Tm (information is generally relevant to the issues raised by the pleadings.\ " In re Kaiser Alum. & )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.52 0 0 11.52 81.84 307.92 Tm (Chern. Com., No. 9080, 1976 FTC LEXIS 68, at *4 \(Nov. 12, 1976\). )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.58 0 0 11.58 115.68 281.52 Tm (Dr. Vellturo was retained by CCC in connection with a 2006 patent disput\ e between CCC )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 7.62 0 0 7.62 81.36 255.12 Tm (and MitchelL. At issue in the case was a feature that allowed a user of \ the estimatics softare to\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 5 0 0 5 81.12 228.48 Tm (automatically calculate and compare the costs of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 308.4 227.76 Tm (repairing a vehicle with pars from different )Tj 11.56 0 0 11.56 80.88 201.6 Tm (sources, such as recycled parts, aftermarket parts, or Original Equipmen\ t Manufacturer \("OEM"\) )Tj 11.64 0 0 11.64 80.16 174.72 Tm (parts. CCC was the first to introduce this feature to the market, throug\ h its Pathways product. )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 80.16 148.08 Tm (The dispute was over Mitchell's subsequent introduction and sale ofUltra\ Mate, which CCC )Tj 11.53 0 0 11.53 80.16 121.44 Tm (claimed violated one of its patents covering the Pathways product. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 9.12 0 0 9.12 303.36 81.6 Tm (5 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1095 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 11.24 0 0 11.24 83.28 691.92 Tm (likely benefit. )Tj 10.31 0 0 10.31 280.08 693.36 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.55 0 0 11.55 275.76 638.4 Tm (Those documents and information may reveal )Tj 11.72 0 0 11.72 83.04 611.76 Tm (information that is highly relevant to Complaint Counsel's case. ~ addit\ ion, Dr. Vellturo would )Tj 11.7 0 0 11.7 82.8 585.12 Tm (have diffculty arguing an undue burden, as a seasoned and very experienc\ ed testifyng expert )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 82.56 558.72 Tm (that has been through the litigation process time and again. Moreover, w\ e would agree to take )Tj 11.65 0 0 11.65 82.56 532.32 Tm (no more than four hours of his time. Second, Dr. Vellturo argued in his \ motion to quash that the )Tj 11.86 0 0 11.86 82.56 505.92 Tm (subpoenas infrnge on h\355s proprietar interests. That is incorrect. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.26 0 0 10.26 281.76 451.68 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.66 0 0 11.66 510.24 400.08 Tm (That )Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 82.08 373.2 Tm (is what this case is about, and Dr. Vellturo is a witness to the competi\ tion that would be lost as a )Tj 11.73 0 0 11.73 81.6 346.56 Tm (result ofthis merger. Just because he was a witness for money, does not \ immunize him from )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 81.36 319.92 Tm (being a witness in this case. )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 11.94 0 0 11.94 206.16 293.52 Tm (II.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( ARGUMENTS AND AUTHORITIES )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 10.31 0 0 10.31 282 240.96 Tm (REDACTED )Tj 11.84 0 0 11.84 194.88 213.84 Tm (They fuher argue that responding to the subpoenas issued by )Tj 11.68 0 0 11.68 80.88 186.96 Tm (Complaint Counsel would be burdensome and would infrnge on Dr. Vellturo'\ s proprietary )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 80.64 160.32 Tm (interests. None of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.48 0 0 11.48 168.24 160.32 Tm (these arguments withstands scrutiny. )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 9.37 0 0 9.37 114.72 133.44 Tm (A.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( Respondents And Dr. VeJlturo Have Failed To Carry Tbeir Burden.\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.8 0 0 11.8 114.72 106.8 Tm (As the subpoenaed pary, Dr. Velltuo and Respondent bear the "burden of s\ howing that )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.56 0 0 10.56 303.12 81.12 Tm (4\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1096 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 10.26 0 0 10.26 282 689.04 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.62 0 0 11.62 132 638.88 Tm (Second, Respondents argued that the discovery sought from Dr. Velltuo is\ irrelevant. )Tj 11.56 0 0 11.56 84 612.72 Tm (In its subpoena duces tecum, Complaint Counsel asks for "a copy of all d\ ocuments and/or data )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.94 0 0 10.94 84 586.08 Tm (cited in Dr. Chrstopher Vellturo's Expert Report. . . or otherwise relie\ d on by Dr. Vellturo in )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 83.76 559.44 Tm (the preparation and drafting of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 228.24 558.96 Tm (the aforementioned report." )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.26 0 0 10.26 281.76 527.04 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.74 0 0 10.74 397.44 505.68 Tm (These tyes of documents )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.71 0 0 11.71 83.28 480 Tm (are exactly the tyes of documents that are used to investigate, prosecut\ e, and defend an antitrust )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 83.04 453.6 Tm (case, especially \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.63 0 0 11.63 157.68 453.36 Tm (one in which the parties referenced in the documents are merging. Third,\ )Tj 11.49 0 0 11.49 82.8 427.2 Tm (Respondents argued that complying with the subpoenas would cause an undu\ e hardsh\355p to Dr. )Tj 11.67 0 0 11.67 82.56 400.8 Tm (Vellturo. Respondents fail to meet their burden with respect to that iss\ ue as well. In Exh\355bit 2 to )Tj 11.6 0 0 11.6 82.32 373.92 Tm (his report, Dr. Vellturo identifies documents and information that he re\ lied upon in preparation )Tj 11.66 0 0 11.66 82.08 347.28 Tm (of the report. Thus, Respondents already have a list of the documents so\ ught by the subpoena )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 81.6 320.88 Tm (duces tecum. In addition, Complaint Counsel is requesting to depose Dr. \ Velltuo, which is )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 81.36 294.24 Tm (hardly unduly burdensome, especially for an expert who represented that \ he had testified over 25 )Tj 11.71 0 0 11.71 81.12 267.84 Tm (times from 2002 to 2006 on his currculum vita submitted as Exhibit 1 to \ the expert report at )Tj 10.74 0 0 10.74 81.12 241.2 Tm (issue.4 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.69 0 0 11.69 115.68 214.56 Tm (Dr. Velltuo also filed a motion to quash, and made two separate, but rel\ ated arguments. )Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 80.4 187.92 Tm (First, Dr. Vellturo argued that the subpoenas impose a burden and expens\ e that far outweigh any )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.62 0 0 11.62 115.2 136.08 Tm (3 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003.\001 )Tj 11.61 0 0 11.61 114.72 111.12 Tm (4 Vellturo Report, PX 0837-053.\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 9.12 0 0 9.12 303.36 80.64 Tm (3 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1097 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 11.54 0 0 11.54 84.24 692.64 Tm (markets, thus creating a duopoly in each market, leading to coordinated \ interaction among the )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.64 0 0 11.64 84.24 666 Tm (remaining competitors. Moreover, the $1.4 billion transaction would crea\ te a company with )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 84 639.36 Tm (huge market shares, reflective of \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.69 0 0 10.69 238.08 638.88 Tm (monopoly or near-monopoly market power. The Commission )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.75 0 0 11.75 84 612.72 Tm (issued an adminstrative complaint challenging this merger on November 25\ ,2008, and a )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 10.55 0 0 10.55 83.76 586.08 Tm (hearng on the merits before th\355s Court is scheduled to begin on March\ 31, 2009. Par and parcel )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.74 0 0 11.74 83.52 559.44 Tm (to the case before this Cour is the head-to-head competition between CCC\ and Mitchell that wil )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 83.28 533.04 Tm (be lost if the transaction is consummated. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.22 0 0 10.22 276.24 488.16 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.64 0 0 11.64 118.08 427.2 Tm (Respondents, in their motion, made three separate arguments. First, Resp\ ondents argued )Tj 11.56 0 0 11.56 82.56 400.56 Tm (that Dr. Vellturo's expert report is irrelevant. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.22 0 0 10.22 281.28 367.92 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.6 0 0 11.6 197.04 320.64 Tm (These facts are admissions in this case that can be verified by )Tj 11.76 0 0 11.76 81.36 294.48 Tm (Dr. Velltuo, who was a witness to these statements. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.22 0 0 10.22 282.48 248.64 Tm (REDACTED )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.54 0 0 11.54 115.68 111.12 Tm (2 Vellturo Report, PX0837-003. )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 10.08 0 0 10.08 303.84 81.12 Tm (2\001 )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1098 0 obj <>stream /Artifact <>BDC q 0 0 0 rg 612 0 0 792 0 0 cm /Im0 Do Q EMC BT /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 3 Tr 19.18 0 0 19.18 256.8 747.36 Tm (ORIGfNAL )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 12.08 0 0 12.08 226.08 696 Tm (UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 11.85 0 0 11.85 221.28 682.8 Tm (FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.54 0 0 11.54 85.2 617.52 Tm (In the Matter of )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 9.37 0 0 9.37 328.8 627.12 Tm (\) )Tj 8.65 0 0 8.65 328.8 613.68 Tm (\) )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 11.43 0 0 11.43 356.16 608.16 Tm (PUBLIC VERSION )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.42 0 0 11.42 84.96 590.64 Tm (CCC HOLDINGS INC., )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 8.65 0 0 8.65 328.56 600.24 Tm (\) )Tj 9.37 0 0 9.37 328.32 587.04 Tm (\) )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 11.31 0 0 11.31 116.16 564.24 Tm (and )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 9.37 0 0 9.37 328.08 573.6 Tm (\) )Tj -0.026 -1.383 Td (\) )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 11.48 0 0 11.48 361.92 562.08 Tm (Docket No. 9334 )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 12.14 0 0 12.14 84 537.84 Tm (AURORA EQUIY PARTNERS II L.P., )Tj 11.37 0 0 11.37 118.32 524.4 Tm (Respondents. )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC 9.37 0 0 9.37 327.6 547.2 Tm (\) )Tj 0 -1.409 TD (\) )Tj -0.026 -1.409 Td (\) )Tj EMC /TD <>BDC -0.026 -1.409 Td (\) )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 12.08 0 0 12.08 125.04 457.92 Tm (COMPLAINT COUNSEL'S RESPONSE TO RESPONDENTS' AND DR. )Tj 12.04 0 0 12.04 126.24 444.96 Tm (CHRISTOPHER VELL TURO'S MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA AD )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 11.56 0 0 11.56 135.6 431.52 Tm (TESTIFICANDUM AND SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM ISSUED TO )Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 219.84 417.6 Tm (DR. CHRISTOPHER VELL TURO )Tj EMC /LI_Label <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 12.28 0 0 12.28 256.08 390.48 Tm (I.)Tj EMC /LI_Title <>BDC ( INTRODUCTION )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.62 0 0 11.62 116.16 365.28 Tm (On February 23,2009, Respondents and Dr. Christopher Vellturo filed two \ separate )Tj 11.63 0 0 11.63 80.88 338.88 Tm (motions to quash the subpoena ad testifcandum and subpoena duces tecum i\ ssued by the )Tj /T1_1 1 Tf 10.9 0 0 10.9 80.4 312.48 Tm (Secretar of the Commission on Januar 29,2009 and served on Dr. Vellturo \ on Februar 6, )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 8.04 0 0 8.04 79.92 285.84 Tm (2009. As discussed more fully below, Respondents and Dr. Vellturo have f\ ailed to car their\001 )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 6.05 0 0 6.05 435.6 261.12 Tm (i)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_2 1 Tf 5 0 0 5 79.68 259.2 Tm (substantial burden on these motions, and thus, the motions should be den\ ied. \001)Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.55 0 0 11.55 113.76 232.32 Tm (This case is about a merger between two competitors, CCC Information Ser\ vices )Tj EMC /P <>BDC 11.65 0 0 11.65 78.96 204 Tm (\("CCC"\) and Aurora Equity Partners II L.P., the parent of Mitchell Int\ ernational \("Mitchell"\). )Tj 11.55 0 0 11.55 78 179.04 Tm (The proposed merger between the parents of CCC and Mitchell would leave \ only two providers )Tj 11.59 0 0 11.59 77.76 152.16 Tm (of U.S. partial loss estimation systems \("estimatics"\) and U.S. total \ loss valuation systems )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_1 1 Tf 10.81 0 0 10.81 77.52 123.6 Tm (\("TL V systems"\). There is only one other significant competitor - Aud\ atex - in these two )Tj EMC /P <>BDC /T1_0 1 Tf 11.69 0 0 11.69 112.08 90.24 Tm (i Dr. Vellturo's Report is attached as Annex A. )Tj EMC ET endstream endobj 1099 0 obj <> endobj 1100 0 obj <>stream application/pdf D-9334 Complaint Counsel's Response to Respondents' and Dr. Christopher Vellturo's Motion to Quash Subpoena Ad Testificandum and Subpoena Duces Tecum Issued to Dr. Christopher Vellturo - Public FTC 2009-03-09T11:25:42-04:00 2009-03-09T11:25:42-04:00 2009-03-09T11:25:42-04:00 uuid:fb7cdf58-c9ea-4fce-813d-138445751a7b uuid:b185c02d-4bf8-48f4-8bf2-fec4c01fa1b8 endstream endobj xref 0 2 0000000629 65535 f 0000331381 00000 n 3 1 0000331547 00000 n 10 1 0000331792 00000 n 17 1 0000332042 00000 n 24 1 0000332292 00000 n 31 1 0000332542 00000 n 38 1 0000332792 00000 n 43 1 0000333016 00000 n 49 1 0000333254 00000 n 56 1 0000333505 00000 n 63 1 0000333756 00000 n 70 1 0000334007 00000 n 75 1 0000334232 00000 n 82 1 0000334483 00000 n 89 1 0000334734 00000 n 97 15 0000334985 00000 n 0000335095 00000 n 0000335203 00000 n 0000336358 00000 n 0000337515 00000 n 0000338671 00000 n 0000338780 00000 n 0000339937 00000 n 0000340046 00000 n 0000341202 00000 n 0000342359 00000 n 0000342468 00000 n 0000343624 00000 n 0000343735 00000 n 0000343844 00000 n 113 24 0000000158 00001 f 0000000113 00001 f 0000000114 00001 f 0000345000 00000 n 0000345091 00000 n 0000345183 00000 n 0000345273 00000 n 0000345366 00000 n 0000345460 00000 n 0000345535 00000 n 0000345628 00000 n 0000345722 00000 n 0000345814 00000 n 0000345906 00000 n 0000345999 00000 n 0000346073 00000 n 0000346147 00000 n 0000346240 00000 n 0000346314 00000 n 0000346419 00000 n 0000000115 00001 f 0000000133 00001 f 0000346464 00000 n 0000346549 00000 n 138 5 0000000134 00001 f 0000000138 00001 f 0000000139 00001 f 0000000140 00001 f 0000000141 00001 f 144 1 0000000000 00001 f 146 13 0000000144 00001 f 0000000146 00001 f 0000000147 00001 f 0000000148 00001 f 0000000149 00001 f 0000000150 00001 f 0000000151 00001 f 0000000152 00001 f 0000000153 00001 f 0000000154 00001 f 0000000155 00001 f 0000000156 00001 f 0000000157 00001 f 161 2 0000346576 00000 n 0000346752 00000 n 204 2 0000346979 00000 n 0000347862 00000 n 207 1 0000347912 00000 n 209 4 0000000142 00001 f 0000000209 00001 f 0000349069 00000 n 0000349154 00000 n 214 13 0000000210 00001 f 0000000214 00001 f 0000000215 00001 f 0000000216 00001 f 0000000217 00001 f 0000000218 00001 f 0000000219 00001 f 0000000220 00001 f 0000000221 00001 f 0000000222 00001 f 0000000223 00001 f 0000349181 00000 n 0000349266 00000 n 228 1 0000000224 00001 f 231 1 0000349293 00000 n 247 2 0000349424 00000 n 0000350581 00000 n 250 5 0000000228 00001 f 0000000250 00001 f 0000000251 00001 f 0000351737 00000 n 0000351822 00000 n 256 10 0000000252 00001 f 0000000256 00001 f 0000000257 00001 f 0000000258 00001 f 0000000259 00001 f 0000000260 00001 f 0000351849 00000 n 0000000261 00001 f 0000351914 00000 n 0000351999 00000 n 267 2 0000000263 00001 f 0000000267 00001 f 271 1 0000352026 00000 n 286 3 0000352149 00000 n 0000352260 00000 n 0000353416 00000 n 290 8 0000000268 00001 f 0000353525 00000 n 0000000290 00001 f 0000000292 00001 f 0000000293 00001 f 0000000294 00001 f 0000353604 00000 n 0000353689 00000 n 299 6 0000000295 00001 f 0000000299 00001 f 0000000300 00001 f 0000000301 00001 f 0000353716 00000 n 0000353801 00000 n 306 1 0000000302 00001 f 309 1 0000353828 00000 n 326 3 0000353951 00000 n 0000355107 00000 n 0000355216 00000 n 330 8 0000000306 00001 f 0000000330 00001 f 0000000331 00001 f 0000000332 00001 f 0000000333 00001 f 0000000334 00001 f 0000356373 00000 n 0000356458 00000 n 339 12 0000000335 00001 f 0000000339 00001 f 0000000340 00001 f 0000000341 00001 f 0000000342 00001 f 0000000343 00001 f 0000000344 00001 f 0000000345 00001 f 0000000346 00001 f 0000000347 00001 f 0000000348 00001 f 0000000349 00001 f 353 1 0000356485 00000 n 375 3 0000356656 00000 n 0000357812 00000 n 0000358969 00000 n 379 2 0000359078 00000 n 0000359163 00000 n 382 3 0000000350 00001 f 0000000382 00001 f 0000000383 00001 f 387 1 0000359190 00000 n 392 1 0000359233 00000 n 394 2 0000360390 00000 n 0000360475 00000 n 397 3 0000000384 00001 f 0000360502 00000 n 0000360587 00000 n 401 7 0000000397 00001 f 0000360614 00000 n 0000360680 00000 n 0000360762 00000 n 0000000401 00001 f 0000000405 00001 f 0000000406 00001 f 410 1 0000360811 00000 n 420 3 0000360894 00000 n 0000362051 00000 n 0000363207 00000 n 424 6 0000000407 00001 f 0000000424 00001 f 0000000425 00001 f 0000000426 00001 f 0000363316 00000 n 0000363401 00000 n 431 8 0000000427 00001 f 0000000431 00001 f 0000000432 00001 f 0000000433 00001 f 0000000434 00001 f 0000000435 00001 f 0000000436 00001 f 0000000437 00001 f 441 1 0000363428 00000 n 458 3 0000363559 00000 n 0000364716 00000 n 0000365872 00000 n 462 2 0000367031 00000 n 0000367116 00000 n 465 8 0000000438 00001 f 0000367143 00000 n 0000000465 00001 f 0000000467 00001 f 0000000468 00001 f 0000367189 00000 n 0000367274 00000 n 0000367359 00000 n 474 4 0000000469 00001 f 0000000474 00001 f 0000367386 00000 n 0000000475 00001 f 480 1 0000367436 00000 n 492 3 0000367535 00000 n 0000368692 00000 n 0000369848 00000 n 496 2 0000369957 00000 n 0000370042 00000 n 499 12 0000000477 00001 f 0000000499 00001 f 0000000500 00001 f 0000000501 00001 f 0000000502 00001 f 0000370069 00000 n 0000000503 00001 f 0000000505 00001 f 0000000506 00001 f 0000370117 00000 n 0000370163 00000 n 0000370248 00000 n 512 1 0000000507 00001 f 516 1 0000370275 00000 n 533 2 0000370406 00000 n 0000370491 00000 n 536 1 0000000512 00001 f 539 1 0000370518 00000 n 543 3 0000370546 00000 n 0000370646 00000 n 0000370731 00000 n 547 11 0000370758 00000 n 0000000536 00001 f 0000000548 00001 f 0000000549 00001 f 0000000550 00001 f 0000370827 00000 n 0000000551 00001 f 0000370912 00000 n 0000370999 00000 n 0000371085 00000 n 0000371170 00000 n 559 1 0000000553 00001 f 562 1 0000371197 00000 n 578 3 0000000559 00001 f 0000371324 00000 n 0000371409 00000 n 582 3 0000000578 00001 f 0000371436 00000 n 0000371521 00000 n 586 3 0000371548 00000 n 0000371614 00000 n 0000371699 00000 n 590 2 0000000582 00001 f 0000000590 00001 f 594 1 0000371726 00000 n 607 4 0000000591 00001 f 0000000607 00001 f 0000371822 00000 n 0000371907 00000 n 612 16 0000000608 00001 f 0000371934 00000 n 0000000612 00001 f 0000000614 00001 f 0000000615 00001 f 0000000616 00001 f 0000000617 00001 f 0000000618 00001 f 0000000619 00001 f 0000000620 00001 f 0000371999 00000 n 0000000621 00001 f 0000000623 00001 f 0000000624 00001 f 0000372066 00000 n 0000372151 00000 n 629 1 0000000625 00001 f 632 1 0000372178 00000 n 823 44 0000372346 00000 n 0000372395 00000 n 0000372442 00000 n 0000372527 00000 n 0000372595 00000 n 0000372662 00000 n 0000372745 00000 n 0000372844 00000 n 0000372907 00000 n 0000372958 00000 n 0000373005 00000 n 0000373069 00000 n 0000373118 00000 n 0000373185 00000 n 0000373299 00000 n 0000373349 00000 n 0000373415 00000 n 0000373478 00000 n 0000373526 00000 n 0000373588 00000 n 0000373655 00000 n 0000373700 00000 n 0000373813 00000 n 0000373862 00000 n 0000373929 00000 n 0000373994 00000 n 0000374078 00000 n 0000374126 00000 n 0000374176 00000 n 0000374243 00000 n 0000374293 00000 n 0000374344 00000 n 0000374425 00000 n 0000374510 00000 n 0000374601 00000 n 0000374669 00000 n 0000374737 00000 n 0000374828 00000 n 0000374912 00000 n 0000375003 00000 n 0000375087 00000 n 0000375138 00000 n 0000375184 00000 n 0000375275 00000 n 869 232 0000375325 00000 n 0000375469 00000 n 0000376446 00000 n 0000376512 00000 n 0000376567 00000 n 0000376632 00000 n 0000376725 00000 n 0000376789 00000 n 0000376849 00000 n 0000376909 00000 n 0000376969 00000 n 0000377033 00000 n 0000377093 00000 n 0000377153 00000 n 0000377200 00000 n 0000377264 00000 n 0000377324 00000 n 0000377384 00000 n 0000377445 00000 n 0000377509 00000 n 0000377570 00000 n 0000377631 00000 n 0000377678 00000 n 0000377742 00000 n 0000377789 00000 n 0000377850 00000 n 0000377897 00000 n 0000377957 00000 n 0000378024 00000 n 0000378078 00000 n 0000378141 00000 n 0000378198 00000 n 0000378248 00000 n 0000378305 00000 n 0000378362 00000 n 0000378425 00000 n 0000378482 00000 n 0000378532 00000 n 0000378595 00000 n 0000378658 00000 n 0000378721 00000 n 0000378788 00000 n 0000378851 00000 n 0000378907 00000 n 0000378974 00000 n 0000379037 00000 n 0000379104 00000 n 0000379167 00000 n 0000379235 00000 n 0000379292 00000 n 0000379356 00000 n 0000379413 00000 n 0000379476 00000 n 0000379543 00000 n 0000379606 00000 n 0000379669 00000 n 0000379736 00000 n 0000379799 00000 n 0000379866 00000 n 0000379929 00000 n 0000379992 00000 n 0000380052 00000 n 0000380116 00000 n 0000380184 00000 n 0000380241 00000 n 0000380304 00000 n 0000380364 00000 n 0000380431 00000 n 0000380498 00000 n 0000380564 00000 n 0000380631 00000 n 0000380688 00000 n 0000380755 00000 n 0000380822 00000 n 0000380886 00000 n 0000380943 00000 n 0000381006 00000 n 0000381069 00000 n 0000381132 00000 n 0000381195 00000 n 0000381258 00000 n 0000381321 00000 n 0000381380 00000 n 0000381436 00000 n 0000381499 00000 n 0000381557 00000 n 0000381621 00000 n 0000381679 00000 n 0000381737 00000 n 0000381801 00000 n 0000381859 00000 n 0000381917 00000 n 0000381985 00000 n 0000382042 00000 n 0000382098 00000 n 0000382165 00000 n 0000382221 00000 n 0000382284 00000 n 0000382351 00000 n 0000382411 00000 n 0000382471 00000 n 0000382531 00000 n 0000382587 00000 n 0000382654 00000 n 0000382710 00000 n 0000382773 00000 n 0000382829 00000 n 0000382896 00000 n 0000382962 00000 n 0000383028 00000 n 0000383095 00000 n 0000383152 00000 n 0000383215 00000 n 0000383265 00000 n 0000383329 00000 n 0000383397 00000 n 0000383465 00000 n 0000383522 00000 n 0000383579 00000 n 0000383639 00000 n 0000383706 00000 n 0000383773 00000 n 0000383840 00000 n 0000383900 00000 n 0000383966 00000 n 0000384033 00000 n 0000384093 00000 n 0000384149 00000 n 0000384208 00000 n 0000384264 00000 n 0000384327 00000 n 0000384394 00000 n 0000384462 00000 n 0000384523 00000 n 0000384587 00000 n 0000384647 00000 n 0000384716 00000 n 0000384778 00000 n 0000384836 00000 n 0000385095 00000 n 0000385154 00000 n 0000385216 00000 n 0000385278 00000 n 0000385343 00000 n 0000385405 00000 n 0000385474 00000 n 0000385546 00000 n 0000385611 00000 n 0000385673 00000 n 0000385742 00000 n 0000385804 00000 n 0000385867 00000 n 0000385926 00000 n 0000385985 00000 n 0000386093 00000 n 0000386152 00000 n 0000386207 00000 n 0000386269 00000 n 0000386321 00000 n 0000386380 00000 n 0000386432 00000 n 0000386497 00000 n 0000386562 00000 n 0000386621 00000 n 0000386683 00000 n 0000386749 00000 n 0000386818 00000 n 0000386880 00000 n 0000386939 00000 n 0000387008 00000 n 0000387074 00000 n 0000387146 00000 n 0000387215 00000 n 0000387284 00000 n 0000387372 00000 n 0000387436 00000 n 0000387499 00000 n 0000387566 00000 n 0000387633 00000 n 0000387686 00000 n 0000388318 00000 n 0000388949 00000 n 0000389580 00000 n 0000390216 00000 n 0000390847 00000 n 0000391478 00000 n 0000392114 00000 n 0000392745 00000 n 0000393376 00000 n 0000394012 00000 n 0000394643 00000 n 0000395274 00000 n 0000395906 00000 n 0000396537 00000 n 0000397168 00000 n 0000397804 00000 n 0000398440 00000 n 0000399071 00000 n 0000399703 00000 n 0000400334 00000 n 0000400965 00000 n 0000401596 00000 n 0000402227 00000 n 0000402863 00000 n 0000403494 00000 n 0000404130 00000 n 0000404761 00000 n 0000405397 00000 n 0000406033 00000 n 0000406664 00000 n 0000407295 00000 n 0000407931 00000 n 0000408562 00000 n 0000409197 00000 n 0000409833 00000 n 0000410464 00000 n 0000411095 00000 n 0000413490 00000 n 0000414716 00000 n 0000416056 00000 n 0000416308 00000 n 0000418314 00000 n 0000420350 00000 n 0000423204 00000 n 0000424554 00000 n 0000425150 00000 n 0000428887 00000 n 0000431472 00000 n 0000434441 00000 n 0000436570 00000 n 0000440211 00000 n 0000440518 00000 n trailer <<1397E4027E62AE448DD616A3A5FA627C>]/Prev 331015 >> startxref 444166 %%EOF